Westworld's Jonathan Nolan and Lisa Joy Break Down Season 2, Episode 4 | Vanity Fair

[@c17rox]

vanity fair, you could've cut this down to your standard 10 minute video, but you didn't... and we really appreciate that

[@UnencumberedWords]

Love the way Jonah looks at Lisa while she explains the scene. The ultimate power couple right here.

[@rubaidaallen2764]

UnencumberedWords Love how he's so proud of her and how they compliment each other. This is what a marriage should look like.

[@sz5876]

"ultimate power bottoms" Jason Manzoukas - Comedy Bang Bang 2018

[@ElizaHamilton1780]

UnencumberedWords I bet it’s more like she puts a leash on her husband when he needs to go out for walkies.

[@xplosionslite6439]

@Alexander Supertramp It kinda is actually. I know this is kinda big brain, but hear me out: Theresa's being the female equivalent of a simp by saying what she thinks men would like to hear, which is that Lisa is the controlling wife.

[@AZANlA]

i want what they have

[@Rock_Lee_Yess]

Other movies and shows: 5 or 10min Westworld : 34min

[@RHICfct]

for one episode, its great!

[@nganjieming]

Alexander Supertramp ladida. Someone’s gonna get laid in college

[@alejandrogiorlando1886]

and thank god it is! this is great!

[@igotlove4theballers]

Lol and it still felt rushed! 😂

[@tangchuho123]

oh my god that part about inserting ed harris's lines in jimmi simpson's lines, totally mind blown

[@lyrilljackson]

no it's been obvious since kid ford and distorted line, also obvious since bernard wife turned out to be ford

[@umanuu]

L Y R I L L r/iamverysmart

[@bashful_michael]

This video was just a masterclass in filmmaking! These two are just so knowledgeable. They're just so meticulous and it makes you appreciate the show even more. I love how supportive they are of one another as Husband and Wife and creative partners. Lisa really did such a great job directing this episode and I hope she does more in the future.

[@lyrilljackson]

nonon o it's just watched too much kubrik, also watched too much got and td, but being on hbo, there's really no surprise. same themes, also vikings, knightfall and alienist, and couterpart are all of the same subject, duality, which i've been a maestro of since decades ago, it's literally in my name

[@maxjackson.7533]

L Y R I L L Vikings, knightfall have nothing on westworld. Counterpart is good but it’s kinda about good versus evil with hbo camera’s, set design and other hbo type things

[@maxjackson.7533]

L Y R I L L alienist doesn’t even seem but I’ll give it a shot

[@missve7]

Word!

[@RNDY1970]

As for directing for the first time, She is giving a Masterclass in Cinematography! Hope she''ll direct more in the next season! And OMG, thank you for this season!

[@Ryuk45]

I was amazed when I found out this was her first time behind the camera, it's the best episode of the entire series

[@butaleo]

@@Ryuk45 I absolutely agree

[@suzyrottencrotch5132]

Can you believe it’s now racist what you said ? “Master” class . So full of hate you are

[@arianrahman5886]

Their children are gonna be insanely good looking AND crazy intelligent

[@miasinclair1770]

William, m'boy.

[@GhostFan-ev4di]

Good to see you again jim.

[@kael7953]

Doesn't look like anything to me.

[@TheBreezus]

What door?

[@drgero2]

LOGAN!!? …LOGAN!

[@soufian2733]

OMG 35 MINUTES ??!!!!! THANK YOU VANITY FAIR THANK YOU SO MUCH

[@RNCHFND]

Soufian 27 right??? Thanks for not cutting it into 2 minutes

[@rubaidaallen2764]

Soufian 27 Very happy about that too!! 35 whole minutes of these two. Yay!!

[@kumar4848]

The part about the vocal performance and how they went to the lengths of taking each syllable of Jimmys and putting it into Ed Harris overtime...thats insane.

[@AStarr5]

I'm surprised that they didn't have any commentary on the symbolic significance of the record, because to me it was by far the most crucial object in this episode. Both for its continuation of the circular motif and its looping/rotating action, but also for its explicit symbolism of the season's theme of fidelity. Records are copies, recordings, that attempt to capture a moment in time using sound and trap it within a physical medium, but can never be perfect renditions of reality, merely representations of it.

[@suzyrottencrotch5132]

Basic concepts clearly need not be explained

[@redxoctober2822]

Wow, I never thought of that! That's a great observation!

[@abdeldorado]

I’ve stated it many times, but episodes 4 and 8 are the best, episodes in terms of quality put in the history of series and by far. You don’t even see this level of details in every area (photography, music, actors, etc...) in 99% of movies. Amazing job for you both, you make TV a grand art !

[@mariromero2413]

Episode 8 is the best episode of the entire serie hands down

[@ninelr222]

Abdellah Ibrahim Yes, 4 and 8 were two best episodes!

[@abdeldorado]

Ninel R glad we share the same opinion :). Don’t you feel like the finale in terms of directing was quite I’d say, a bit confused no? I feel like they should have a done a two episodes one or something.

[@ninelr222]

Exactly. I had a feel this episode had a great potential to contain more interesting details, but it did not because of the time constraint. Should be 2 episodes. For example, I was hoping that Clementine, while riding to the Valley, would dig into her memory and by the time she reached the Valley... surprise!.. Clementine would have her own agenda in mind. So it could be more interesting than just riding thru and being shot. And a few other things like that. Akecheta story could have some more development. Feel sorry for the guy who now, being awake, will have to spend the eternity with 20 other non-awake robots walking along the endless green fields and hills :) Maybe Teddy, who seemed to woke up just before shooting himself, would keep Akecheta company, and they will play chess in the evenings while bunch of robots will walk around searching for their loops :)

[@deloaded]

Couldn't agree more! 4 and 8 are some of the best moments in television history.

[@cadewarrencns]

So glad she wound up directing this, as it might be my favorite episode of the season, especially cinematography- and pacing-wise. Love it.

[@Kuhreenuh]

That water reflection / God and the Devil thing that Nolan mentioned connects to Logan’s last meeting w his father when he remembers how he has sunk all the way to the “bottom” of the pool, or of consciousness. Then he asks his father “do you wanna see what I see” which is the exact same thing Delos says to Elsie and Bernard. In his descent into insanity/truth Delos finally understands his son.

[@rachael6823]

'i'm your best boy' 'you are my best boy!' lol that was cute

[@madamegorgonzola]

find someone who looks at you, the way Jonah looks at Lisa

[@beeztrapp1612]

The way they look at each other is so loving and proud.

[@lois1677]

This only never happens to most of us.

[@charisma-hornum-fries]

Afterwards. Don’t freaking let go!

[@rmgdmv2786]

Notice how Jonathan lets Lisa shine silently as she works within her element. #manhood #secure

[@blacksmith8594]

He didn't "let her" and at the same time he wasn't "mansplaining". They're both working together very well and a great couple.

[@rmgdmv2786]

The Spastic Tiger not many couples have this chemistry. Live a little and you'll reconsider your norm.

[@chedderburg]

Let me splainmen this. I believe Tony’s intention was, “Notice how Jonathan didn’t act like the stereotypical man and talk over Lisa which allowed her to shine in a situation where a jerk would have interrupted her.” I believe we need to look more at intent. It’s seems clear that Tony believes in promoting women. Let’s not attack people for saying the wrong thing with the right intention. Have a great day everyone, and take a second put down the phone take a deep breath and appreciate life :)

[@chedderburg]

Sorry but couldn’t help mansplaining splainmening, it’s when you explain men, and if your a man doing it I guess it is mansplainmening :) Ok now I’m done ✅

[@rmgdmv2786]

chet corey Tony approves this message. Sorry I used "let" everyone.

[@Welkerlan]

Oh man i love these two, cute couple and obviously they are great at their jobs. That episode was a fantastic directing debut for Lisa, the amount of thought she put on all of those details is mind-blowing. She deserves a Emmy nomination for this.

[@dannabats]

Having been someone who has has a mental break.... Thank you as producers for projecting this uncertain feeling so well. Having been there I immediately caught the feel of the episode. No one that hasn't been there can understand

[@manunited62]

One of the best episodes of Westworld for me. Peter Mullan's acting is superb!

[@alv_alv_alv]

Lisa Hoy should direct more episodes.

[@andr4203]

Alvaro Martinez joy

[@xyoxus]

* Lisa Joy

[@nicdennis]

31:44 Woah! This water reflection imagery is in the title sequence of Season 3 now!

[@mandumetheking]

Lisa Joy is a joy to watch. So much detail in one scene. So much knowledge of their craft. And they complement each other very well. 18:40 - So funny, so beautiful. And yes, Westworld for me, is the best TV show ever created. Writing, Directing, Acting, Visuals, Scenery and Wardrobe... Just perfect. I hope they give us as many seasons as they can.

[@thelastpepsi9369]

Get Jimmi Simpson to recap this season again

[@janedoe1787]

Yes!

[@annikaj2770]

I miss jimmi too :(

[@GhostFan-ev4di]

Ignatius Ryandika elsie gets killed

[@soufian2733]

I want Ben Barnes or Jeffrey Wright

[@xoloveebuggxo]

*SPOILER ALERT*

[@andr4203]

this video just saved my life? the riddle of the sphinx is a truly masterpiece LISA JOY DESERVES AN EMMY FOR THAT! and they are so cute together 💗😭😔

[@wwaxwork]

This was excellent. I learnt so much, it's great to see just how much thought goes into each scene.

[@dapeach06]

She definitely deserves an Emmy for this. This is a level of direction that easily is on par with Oscar winning movies

[@drlee2]

I totally agree and was disappointed she didn't get a directing nod for this episode.

[@madamegorgonzola]

when I grow up I wanna be both of them and his brother

[@amidseyed4323]

who is his brother?

[@soufian2733]

AgentOfChaos 93 Christopher Nolan

[@aznthy]

You want to be 3 people? Ok, psycho...

[@honzagomela5800]

AgentOfChaos 93 some unknown movie director, you probably never heard of him.

[@GhostFan-ev4di]

Maryam Lea freak .......

[@backpackingislife]

Loved the buildup in the first scene, with the single shot around the room, and not showing the face right away...Absolutely spectacular!!

[@josephlyons4698]

“But don’t play with me, cause you’re playing with fire”. Probably the perfect song choice on a lot of different levels. Great episode, one of my favorites.

[@MyManD]

Still feels weird listening to Jonathan's American accent after listening to Christopher Nolan's strong British accent. These two grew up together and they have different accents!

[@xyoxus]

Kevin Sang As someone (a few comments further up) already said Jonathan decided only to speak with his american accent to better fit into America.

[@chelseaclo3180]

They remind me so much of SHIELD's writer/producers (Jed & Maurissa) in a sense that they're both amazing couples that produce great television experiences because of their genius in writing, directing, and overall storytelling. Their genius is often times underrated. Also I guess it's just coincidental that both guy's brothers are major film directors as well, and both women are just absolutely amazing at what they do.

[@kylepn5223]

This was my all time favorite episode in the Westworld series, really sums up the whole philosophical underpinning of the show, brilliantly acted and directed. This break down and seeing the amount of thought put into it is just incredible.

[@1RobHunter1]

William my boy..... Ed Harris breaking him down was spot on.

[@rubaidaallen2764]

Love this!! The anatomy of a scene 101. This episode was so f'n epic. The Delos' story line, wow. Lisa Joy and Jonathan Nolan are so f'n awesome. Love Westworld!!! Amazing, super smart and intelligent show. I also just love how Mr. Nolan is letting his better half have her moment. True gentleman.

[@DNotzz]

Part of the reason this show is such a great show and a haven for creativity is because of these two. Love em.

[@layunirocha7111]

She’s great at directing. I hope she gets more episodes next season.

[@mastaaceexclusive]

This scene was one of the highlights of season 2. Incredible thought and skill and detaill. Lisa joy. U a real one

[@YouFightLikeACow]

This and the finale are my favorite episodes!

[@Boxman-GG]

She is a true visionary a poetic beautiful soul and how romantic.

[@iamthebatman6557]

This is the greatest episode of the season, it feels like a mini movie, it tells a story of its own while taking place in the major story of season 2 especially now that we think William is one of these special hosts.

[@failogy]

So many memorable quotes in Westworld. They're the best writers imo.

[@TheBlckWitch]

they’re both so beautiful, you can tell how much they love each other just by how they look at each other.

[@vhampyre01]

More of these Westworld videos. So interesting!

[@ChandlerLawsonPlays]

God, I hope they do this with the season 2 finale.

[@silkthyme]

they're both hot wtf

[@Welkerlan]

I know right it's not fair

[@tonym2744]

Because they're are robots.

[@woody_you_want]

Anyone know why Johnathan Nolan has an American accent but Christopher has a British one? They don't seem far apart in age.

[@fatim0nster]

Eric Woodard Jonathan picked up american accent on purpose because apparently british accent wasn't popular in Chicago.

[@Welkerlan]

Eric Woodard Jonathan grew up in the US

[@thatbigkahuna6655]

I love how after Jonathan’s Nolan’s extensive filming and movie career, he is still trying to learn how to use three cameras, still trying to learn.

[@DMCEagles05]

Such a masterpeace. I love this explanation. GOD I WISH I WENT TO FILM SCHOOL.

[@HerMajestyFromHell]

I think she never went to film school

[@xyoxus]

*masterpiece. Peace is the opposite of war.

[@nicoavetikian8908]

You don’t need to go to film school. Sure it helps but i think it mostly has to do with being creative and having an intent in everything that is put on screen, wether it’s dialogue, cinematography, set design or other.

[@danceonyourtoes]

yeah she went to law school. honestly you just need to know philosophy, history, be smart and creative

[@ianvjones]

Wow! I just went to film school! So good!!

[@jawjagrrl]

This was one of the best produced scenes of the entire season for me.

[@levisnafu]

This is a great series but man, this episode I ALWAYS come back to it. Can't believe this is Lisa Joy's directorial debut, it's my favourite episode fo the series and this video is PURE masterclass on directing, it may be Westworld - but there's nothing flashy about this episode. It's essentially two characters talking to each other in one room. Those kinds of scenes show what a director is really worth. AMAZINGGG

[@zembryoz]

Have you ever witnessed such splendor?

[@snilrach]

love this. please do more long ones like this.

[@FuzzyTrekkie]

This breakdown of this scene reminds me why I love time loop episodes in scifi shows.

[@theKonfusion]

What an awesome serie you two have made (and all the writers and staff of course) and you guys seems to genuinly enjoy yourself and be down to earth. So cute and adorable! Keep doing more and keep this fire within you !

[@misterpillows2800]

One of my favorite episodes, thanks Lisa

[@almiram8094]

Peter Mullan's performance was incredible!! Such a great actor!

[@juliebarber9069]

i love how Jonathan looks at her with pride

[@hassaanlodhi238]

THE DETAIL, SO MUCH DETAIL!

[@Bamgeutcutiepie]

Jimmi is so handsome! he HAS TO be in season 3!

[@Welkerlan]

I'm so glad Lisa is gonna direct and write her first movie soon, i'm sure it's gonna be fantastic.

[@raghu7174]

Jonah : I'm your best boy Lisa : He is my best boy!

[@shawnbrown2064]

10 points to team Nolan for referencing the panopticon!

[@Shalalacls]

I think it's the longest video of this series so far... Totally worth it. I could listen to these two for hours.

[@simoling]

A loving and supporting partner is EVERYTHING. Brilliant direction.

[@lisavalentine8877]

I assumed that Kurt the goldfish in his bowl was meant to represent the room that Delos is living in... really, no place to hide or be truly private as the observers check on his fidelity.

[@Dzumeister]

so thankful that such smart people are working on this show

[@allenyu4054]

Such an incredible actor! Jeffery

[@rajsrivastav6940]

wow .......what Jonathan said in the end about insanity and consciousness.........wow ! brilliant man !

[@testpattern23]

I now realize...we are so freaking stupid compared to these creators

[@oscar857]

thank you both for this amazing mindblowing show!!!!!

[@knaguar]

Favorite episode this season!!!!!

[@mrsyno1179]

31:09 "Great Joys" that pun was totally intended haha

[@randomyoutubeuser6171]

They’re so cute 😍

[@Sab_MJsMama]

Eric Carey relationship goals!!!

[@jarin4847]

they should do this for every ep

[@DanielS2001]

31:57 - The moment you realize this is the exact image used in the opening credits in Season 3.

[@SETHthegodofchaos]

Kurt the goldfish lmao

[@ghosted7450]

how are there NO interviews with the Nolan brothers together 🤯

[@CasparLoesche]

The opening Shot felt like the introduction of Desmond in Lost.

[@internisus]

One of the only episodes this season that I really liked. Definitely glad that Lisa did direct it after all. Her approach is so thoughtful, and I loved hearing her describe her process here.

[@S1leNtRIP]

Lisa Joy directed the best episode of the season. Jonathan is indeed, best boy.

[@FrankSkornia]

32:12 is when Nolan gets the idea of an underwater reflection that we see in the Season 3 opening :-)

[@Fahamut]

Great video, this was my favourite Westworld episode period.

[@navigill2707]

*MA BOI*

[@theengineer9910]

Navi Gill WILLIAM

[@xeraph02]

D'awwwww.... Why are all the people behind Westworld always so cute? lol

[@MagnumDB]

2:58 - (Lost spoiler alert!) This opening reminded me very much of the season to opening of Lost. It’s the first time we see inside the bunker, and it’s shot very much like this, although not in one continuous steady cam shot. And last, we also don’t know where we are, it’s a new space we’ve never seen before, there is old music playing, we only see parts of a figure, they’re also going through a mourning routine, they also are on an exercise bike...

[@kickballjedi]

I am really surprised this plot wasn't expanded more. I finally got what the whole Delos Program was working toward with this episode. More information about trying to duplicate thoughts, save a lifelong amount of data, build a lifelike robot to insert this data, it's all so fascinating. It makes you wonder- If you had a hard drive hooked into your brain, then that hard drive was installed into a robot body, would you continue to exist? Or would it be a digital copy of an analog soul?

[@jfassettx123]

Idk what it is about the Nolans working on projects with their wives but I like it.

[@el22osvi]

This was an incredible experience. Subscribed.

[@Legeon1080]

Episode 8 would be great to see their process for.

[@nwc628]

Reminded me a little of Desmond's intro in Lost with the exercise bike and record player. "Make your own kind of music"

[@samdeane6683]

lisa just became my favorite director

[@bedeliagraham2846]

I really love and appreciate you and your show. Best so far. Perfect team.

[@Totorus]

Great explanations of how was directed, really enjoyed it.

[@69Muki69]

in my opinion westworld is much better than game of thrones when it comes to directing. my only pet peeve with ww is how they play with the time. I mean it was okey in the first season but, i didnt like it that much in season 2, i hope they wont do that again for another plot twist in season 3. I mean there are better ways to create a plot twist imo.

[@crewzta]

My favorite WW ep sonfar.! Watched it 4 times now. Thanks for the behind the scenes explanation. Thanks you both!

[@missve7]

In love with them! They’re phenomenal.

[@eobard1328]

Lisa and Jonah are such a power couple. Love them.

[@AgentMcQueen]

This is *LOVE.*

[@Murmurrr]

This opening scene reminded me of the first scene in Lost with despond