What do Chinese think of Islam? 【 Interview】

[@hussainmujahid-e6n]

i m pleased to seeen how chiness and other ppl think about Islam. well i m Pakistani Karachian Muslim. in my view that guy who visited Pakistan he told truth. we have large amount of ppl who learned Quran but they dont know the deep meainings of Quran words. we divided to our fiqh but we forgot we are Muslims. here ppl have not religious freedom we just follow what our ulma said and we have different fiqah ulma. Muslims should have one ulma one fiqah but sorry to say we are salves of them. i am glad to seen only obey to Almight Allah said we should perform what Quran and Hadees said to us. Jazak Allah Kheir.

[@luthfisidik001]

Assalamu'alaikum According to data from the World Population Review for 2021, Indonesia is the country with the largest Muslim population in the world. In total there are around 231 million people in Indonesia who embrace Islam. That is my county Indonesia 🇮🇩

[@fizz2005.]

MasaAllah one of my fev country

[@luthfisidik001]

@@fizz2005. Alhamdu lillah, what country are you from?

[@oldwatchma]

wa alaikum salam~

[@fizz2005.]

@@luthfisidik001 from India

[@catboy9360]

waalaikumsalam

[@razinamarjan1110]

7:19 this brother, even tho he is not muslim, he is aware of islam and why we have certain rules, and he respects that, he observes his peers and educates himself in our history and our book better than other do 😊😊

[@nanashi9145]

But he said that islam invade egypt and this is not true ...i am egyptian btw

[@DroidRomixGamer]

The chinese guy who lived in Pakistan is absolutely right if a muslim cannot understand the deeper meaning of quran then there is no point understanding the core meaning of quran is that which make the difference people of other religions also memorize their books

[@alHayyu.alQayyum]

You start and agree to the basic meaning and then move on to the deeper understanding (hikmah حكمة) of the Quran

[@DroidRomixGamer]

@@alHayyu.alQayyum i am not talking about me its about the scholars of majority of the countries of the muslim world

[@alHayyu.alQayyum]

@@DroidRomixGamer my point being how can you move on to the deeper meaning of any thing without understanding it's basics !! 🤷‍♂️ and trust me a lot people aren't even aware even of the core concepts in islam

[@unifieddynasty]

The bond between Pakistani and Chinese people is so pure. It must be protected from the opportunistic individuals who seek to immorally profit from it.

[@dbh-o8m]

So pure that Pakistanis will turn a blind eye to what China is doing to Uyghurs across the border

[@unifieddynasty]

@@dbh-o8m Tell us, what exactly is China "doing to Uyghurs"? And ask yourself, are you getting your allegations from the same groups who have colonized and genocided the Middle East and most of the world for centuries?

[@dbh-o8m]

@@unifieddynasty i'm getting my information from Uyghur Muslim friends who have relatives imprisoned in the concentration camps, as well as from Muslim relatives who have studied in China and have friends from there. Where are you getting your information from?

[@unifieddynasty]

@@dbh-o8m I am getting my information from my Uyghur and Hui and Kazakh and Tajik muslim friends and family with generations of ancestry living in Xinjiang and Gansu and working to improve the region, in addition to the millions of upon millions of social media posts every single day coming from the region. If some of your Uyghur muslim friends' relatives are in prison in "concentration camps", then perhaps they are. And perhaps they were sent there unjustly. But if you do not have evidence and only have anecdote, then you cannot speak for the entire country of China and how they are allegedly treating the entirety of the Uyghurs and muslims in China. So do you have evidence? Tell us, what exactly is China "doing to Uyghurs"? And ask yourself, are you getting your allegations from the same groups who have colonized and genocided the Middle East and most of the world for centuries?

[@shanwang7677]

我觉得这种关于宗教信仰的视频很有意义并且很真实，真的反应了我们国家宗教信仰的状态。不管哪个宗教，确实都是需要去深入理解自己宗教的教义，只有深入理解才能获得启示或者真正心灵上的共通。不管是什么宗教，宗教之间相互尊重和平共处❤

[@r18453]

I fond you channel today and I find your videos are very eye opening about China Keep up the good work !

[@THEKHULNAIYA]

*1:10 she is soo sweet MASHAALLAH.Love from Kbulna Bangladesh 🇧🇩🖤🇨🇳*

[@lingsongjin1003]

我是生活在海外的国人，感谢你把我们真实的样子发给全世界，加油。

[@oldwatchma]

谢谢☺️

[@dionydonny]

8:53 this man is sooooo warm. when he mentioned pork, he used the word 大肉(big meat) insdead of pork. and for those who don't know chinese, almost none of the interviewees mentioned "pork" directly, and they were very careful not to offend their muslim friends with their words.

[@oldwatchma]

Yes, he even paused before saying "big meat", maybe he meant to say "pork", actually I never cared about that, but the respect he showed warmed my heart

[@astranger8569]

This man believe in communism 💀

[@CHINABEATBOX]

@@astranger8569 So？

[@astranger8569]

@@CHINABEATBOX I don't like communism

[@suzyEvermore]

yes, the solar galaxy involves around you. Everything is about you.@@astranger8569

[@ahmedbehbehani911]

Nice bro 👍 We hope one day that the majority of Chinese people will understand Islam positively & accept it with their hearts InshaAllah ..

[@yongzhu8454]

Isn't atheism bad? Why must we be bound by religion? If religion must be accepted, why cannot it be Christianity, why cannot it be Buddhism, and why cannot it be Hinduism?

[@ahmedbehbehani911]

@@yongzhu8454 Yes atheism is bad , And we muslims believe that Islam is the one true religion witch leads to salvation & Paradise in the after life & this atheists can't understand .. Everyone believes that their religion is the true one ether if they are christians , hindus , buddhists , jews or any one else ...

[@tinaz1818able]

Chinese accept all the civilizations yet nobody should think about converting Chinese into other religions. all those Christian , Islamic missionaries and Buddhist monks tried for hundreds of year but failed. Chinese believe in Confucianism that is why Chinese are so peaceful and tolerant.

[@Raihan__4535]

Muslims are also tolerant.you don't see that because you hate them that's why.​@@tinaz1818able

[@Raihan__4535]

​@@yongzhu8454it's Thier choice they will search every religion and find the truth

[@zaphrode4110]

really good video, the convo with the man drinking tea should be cropped into a short. Especially the part about education.

[@oldwatchma]

Thanks for the suggestion, I will be doing it! ~

[@mrsdin3739]

4:38 this is I AGREE THE MOST Sir you earned my respect.

[@Yamimdewan-e4x]

Love for all muslims❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@inception6657]

Troll. Fake Chinese. Noob

[@alHayyu.alQayyum]

Guy's you are the ambassadors of islam in a majority non Muslim (agnostic/atheist) country with the largest population in the world. Always try and convey the core message of islam to people you come in contact with. تبارك الله فيكما

[@Liv-ie4xl]

They seem to be more respectful than the westerners (and i live in the west). Welp, the saying goes never judge and form an opinion with your own eyes not through the media/ camera lens.

[@jattdreamrider]

Love and respect for sharing such nice video ❤

[@beinghumananity]

Yes

[@BlueSea-cj6rx]

Love❤ from Bangladesh 🇧🇩

[@raihanhamid7997]

You're great bro love from Bangladesh 🇧🇩 ❤ 🇨🇳

[@Madleen7l]

mashallah this is good...I hope you do for us translations ❤💗

[@oldwatchma]

I have made it just now~~~

[@TinkerPaw]

The scene at 5:45 was so funny. Definitely the book for a knowledgeable person like him to read. I even wonder if this whole interview was prepared in advance.

[@Gamer-jw5wb]

Assalam alaikum brother (Love from India)

[@oldwatchma]

wa alaikum salam~bro

[@Abigoria1]

About taoïsm and islam, read "Insights into Islamic Esoterism and Taoism" by Rene Guenon and "Sufism and Taoism: A Comparative Study of Key Philosophical Concepts" by Toshihiko Izutsu. And also the books of these authors : Seyyed Hossein Nasr, Martin Lings, Reza-Shah Kazemi, Frithjof Schuon, Titus Burckhardt, William Stoddart, Huston Smith,

[@fizz2005.]

Love from India❤

[@soibrat5586]

Thank you so much for this video It was intresting to see . If I understood that mean there is two largest muslim ethnic group in China (Hui and uyghurs) ?

[@wsmithe2209]

There are about 30 to 35 million muslims in China.

[@alice_wuz]

In China, there are a total of 10 ethnic groups who believe in Islam, including the Hui, Uyghur, Kazakh, Uzbek, Tajik, Tatar, Kirgiz, Salar, Dongxiang, and Bao'an ethnic groups.

[@wsmithe2209]

@@樂熙-f7d - You mean 150 million muslims in China? Not sure that's correct. Hui is around 12 million in population and Uygur population is around 20 million. Not all Uygur are muslims.

[@oldwatchma]

In fact, there are about ten ethnic minorities in China who believe in Islam.

[@benjaminbenbenben1702]

You are right, there are other ethnicities like Tajik and Uzbek but Hui and Ug are the two biggest ones

[@马征-m6f]

I am a subscriber from Gansu, China.

[@oldwatchma]

谢谢~

[@马征-m6f]

⁠不客气 😂原来你是 中国人

[@oldwatchma]

@@马征-m6f 哈哈哈🤣对啊，土生土长的那种

[@ahmadmuhdi190]

Is it just me or Chinese mainland in general has more positive view on Islam than the other east asians countries? Is it because their contact with Hui and Uighur people?

[@oldwatchma]

Perhaps because almost all of the people I interviewed were students from better universities or well-educated people, they would not be so one-sided in their view of the issue.

[@ahmadmuhdi190]

@@oldwatchma ahhh Thanks...

[@MdIbrahim-bk3vy]

​@@ahmadmuhdi190there was a Muslim rule in half of China for a period. Silk road Central Asia and China used to have trade between them

[@TaiwanSausage]

China had contacts with islam since the birth of islam in 7th century. one of the oldest mosques in the world was built in port city of guangzhou south china in AD 620s. back then, there was extensive trades between china and islamic world via silk road and vis indian ocean trade routes. other east asian and southeast asian countries never had contacts with islam world that early like china did. not to mention, mongols brought in many arabic and persian merchants into china during mongol domination period. since then, many arabic and persian settled in china. they were slowly assimilated into general chinese population. but they kept islamic faith and customs....i believe there was how Hui minority formed in china.

[@aanamkhan8352]

Salaam brother from Pakistan 🇵🇰

[@apadia8447]

our prophet muhammad already mention “Seek knowledge even if you have to go as far as China, for seeking knowledge is a duty on every Muslim,”. - he already travel to china and what i understand china are brilliant until end of day. That's why today you can see china also successful country and what he prediction are never wrong.

[@yaok248]

No Muslim would say islam is strict. We know how strict judaism is. We compare to stricter not less strict.

[@mohdamirhafiz2910]

Interesting ❤️ from Malaysia

[@muhammadkhokhar7899]

Subhanallah

[@SK-nc6mn]

Very well said by the brother wearing glasses. Spot on. ❤ from 🇵🇰

[@ashrafkarakkad9202]

Hello brother, I am very happy to see your channel and videos. I was studying about the situations of Muslim community of China for a month. Here I got your channel. I think that I can make your channel as a reference for my study and I also hope your help for my study.🤝🤝🤝

[@oldwatchma]

hello~bro~Glad my video can help you~

[@ashrafkarakkad9202]

Yaa sure It's very helpful for me. I have more doubts in this topic. If you don't mind Can I contact with you for clearing my doubts through this medium. Otherwise can you give me any other contact number or anything else to contact with you.....

[@ashrafkarakkad9202]

​@@oldwatchmaBrother I'm student from India. I'm studying about the culture and traditions of Muslim communities in China and how do they face the civil laws of China as a Muslim. If you don't mind Can I ask you my doubts about the topic through here or any other platform if you have.

[@ashrafkarakkad9202]

​@@oldwatchmaBrother, Can you please connect me with any Islamic scholar of China or any Imams of the mosque from there. I want to know more about the practical Islam of China including their experience in this field.

[@oldwatchma]

sure bro,do you have wechat?my id:412960343@@ashrafkarakkad9202

[@maryamfiazmaliam-t9v]

Love from PAKISTAN to CHINA❤

[@illyrian3057]

What abput Israel then?

[@Wizard06]

​@@illyrian3057idk

[@Yamimdewan-e4x]

Love from Bangladesh❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@おうねい]

我家是辽宁的，在我老家很多人都“信仰”自己的祖先，和普通的祭拜不一样，每次祭祖都有一套很复杂的流程，严格的每个月初一十五都要祭祖，要杀公鸡，做贡品，祈求祖先保佑，虽然这算不上是宗教，但一定是信仰。

[@薛氏-z5s]

祖先崇拜也是道教信仰科儀

[@oldwatchma]

是的~这虽然是一种不成体系的“宗教性”行为，但也是你们的信仰~

[@dionydonny]

绝大多数宗教都有功利性的说法，比方说信了就如何，不信就如何。与之相较，中华民族或者说中国道教的祖先崇拜，其实是具有先进性的。它不直接告诉你信或不信会怎么样，但在一次又一次祭祖中，人会潜移默化地意识到，我有我的祖先，我也会是我的后代的祖先；我如此祭拜先祖，我的后代会不会如此祭拜我呢？这就形成了一种无关乎神，只关乎人的传承。有这个信仰，人也会自然而然约束自己的行为，使自己的行为符合公认的道德标准，并且尝试在有生之年做更多对后代、对社会、对人类有意义的事。

[@hoohoo0574]

这个是民间信仰，或者叫民俗信仰吧

[@榕树下-h6v]

@@dionydonny 实用主义 儒的思想道的习俗还融合了些佛理

[@aishazafar3485]

A lot of love❤ from Pakistan 🇵🇰

[@prhasn]

Amazing. Thanks for the insight.

[@KZ-mo2rz]

Alhamdullillah..i am happy now for muslim people in China and all i see is positivity in China after bad propaganda from western USA Israel and other Western country

[@catboy9360]

assalammualaikum. is it true that the news that happened in xinjiang about the mosque that will be destroyed right ??

[@薛氏-z5s]

di Yunnan Najiaying Mosque Unrest in China as authorities try to demolish a mosque kzbin.info/www/bejne/kGjRh3-rhLJkepo

[@oldwatchma]

wa alaikum salam~Although I am very opposed to this matter, but I don't want to lie. Actually, the dome will remove and replace with a traditional Chinese architectural roof，make it like the mosques in beijing. how do you think about this?

[@catboy9360]

@@oldwatchma In my opinion, it is better for a mosque dome that has been installed like that to be replaced again, let it be like that. if you want to build a new mosque with traditional Chinese style. I hope the Chinese Muslim brothers are under the protection of Allah. Aamiin🤲

[@yushofi-ss8uu]

​@@oldwatchma It is a shame that its historical value has diminished.Alhamdulillah in Indonesia We are allowed to build mosques in Chinese architectural style.

[@oldwatchma]

@@yushofi-ss8uu wow，really？do you like it?

[@wiwinhandayani5020]

assalamu'alaikum im moslim from indonesia.and indonesia is the big population muslim in the world.and we are very tolerance each and other.

[@子国-t8q]

as Chinese,i don't think so.

[@extraordinaryartandcraft]

Love from Pakistan 😊

[@muhammadkhokhar7899]

Mashallah

[@Innocent-Human-Soul]

Ma'sha'Allah 💐💐💐

[@user_onehundredtwentyfivef7856]

brother can u put chinese subtitles too ?? because i have a Chinese friend who wants to watch ur videos but doesn't speak English well . and thank u brother

[@ashrafkarakkad9202]

Hi brother can I contact with your friend who knows Chinese language.......

[@oldwatchma]

hi bro~We speak Chinese in the video, it can understand without subtitles

[@user_onehundredtwentyfivef7856]

@@oldwatchma thank u ^^

[@Alifahusna_97]

What dialect does your friend speak?

[@ashrafkarakkad9202]

Hello brother can I contact with your friend who knows Chinese language.......

[@create-new-handle-first]

Tauheed, the concept of one God, Allah, is the exceptional beauty and the biggest attraction of Islam, spread this beauty. Everything else is regional rituals, how to spend lifetime keeping in mind the presence of Allah !

[@Strangerstranger-z7o]

IDK why but i want to hear more and more from the man in purple shirt, he have a deep knowledge i feel .....

[@salimaali3507]

Assalamualaikum warahmatullah wabarkatahu.very very interesting video.

[@oldwatchma]

wa alaikum salam~~~

[@mohammedsheriff4211]

Whether It doesn't matter that world peoples are accepting or not Islam, but one truth' is we are all aadam عليهِسَّلام 's sons and daughters.. there is no doubt, peoples who are disbelieves, & most of the peoples who doesn't accepting they will see the truth after they died.. and they will say, that "please let me go again in that earth." So that I will can worship you even I don't blink .. I promise you that I even don't blink my eye in the middle of the prayer... Things like this they will say in the last day of the earth... Allahu

[@yongzhu8454]

🤣What if you see the Christian God after death?

[@JannatulFerdusMim-yx7ry]

There's no Christian god , there is only one god. Who send Quran to his last and final prophet.

[@mohammedsheriff4211]

First you go & see after your death & confirm , you will go into the hell for not believing in islam 😏😎🔥... We are just doing our job ( called dawah) Allah said to us : whomever mock the people who are not believing & belive in various gods that are blindly follow their own created gods ... . And we are not mock any religion ! WE ARE JUST DOING OUR JOB AND NOTHING ELSE‼️ 💢💢😡🤬‼️‼️‼️

[@hereabran]

MasyaAllah, they know Islam

[@hermioneera]

ofc they know, a lot of native chinese are muslims for more than decades. china is the country in east asia that have huge muslim population compared to japan, korea, mongolia, etc

[@arminalert4795]

Act christian do have restrictions in food term ( based on Old Testament) they cannot eat pork for example

[@yaok248]

Now many Muslims study sciences. Millions on millions.

[@inaminam4895]

واعلیکم السلام ورحمتہ اللہ وبرکاتہ ویلکم

[@shakeelasghar2362]

I love China ❤

[@jeremyz653]

宗教和民族问题，至少在中国，我觉得最重要的一点是国家要确保任何人不能把自己的宗教和民族身份置于中国人这个身份认同之上。要打造统一的中国人身份认同，成为所有人的第一身份认同。在此基础上，民族和宗教身份认同可以对其进行补充和丰富。一个中国穆斯林或者中国佛教徒的第一身份也可以包括其民族宗教身份，但是不能高于中国人身份认同。就是，你可以有两个第一身份，比如既是中国人又是穆斯林，或者即使中国人又是佛教徒，但你的穆斯林身份认同或者佛教徒身份认同不能高于你的中国人身份认同。否则就是身份认同极端主义。这种身份认同的统一才是中国式“大一统”的核心和灵魂。也就是“中”与“华”之间的关系。

[@oldwatchma]

说实话，做这个频道一年了，收到了来自各个国家的评论，90%以上友好，10%是持着各种不同的意见相互攻击的。让我最大的感受就是世界上的不同民族不同信仰的大多数人也不过是些普普通通的老百姓，这时常让我有种世界将会走向“大一统”的想法。 但也总是会收到一些“共产党怎么糟糕”“伊斯兰是恐怖主义”“西方社会如何虚伪”“某个国家又怎么怎么差劲”甚至说“我们中国人像蟑螂一样到处都是”等等的负面评论，有时候我在想，这些可怜的老百姓，他们被灌输了太多所谓的”知识“，以致于他们无法平和地去看待每一种民族，或是政权与国家。 说认真的，在做这个之前，我以为我们中国人是最民族主义的，但在这一年里，体验到各式各样的割裂，慢慢体会到为何我们要不断地强调”中华民族“这一概念。也慢慢认识到中国人其实已经是一个通过包容不同的民族加以融合后的产物了，而西方很多的移民国家才正在开始进行”融合“的这一过程。

[@jeremyz653]

@@oldwatchma 是的。西方社会，在种族、民族这方面，其本质是一个虚构的“熔炉”：自称为“熔炉”但其实永远也不会真正融合。中国应该追求的应该是两个方面：一方面在世界上追求各个文明的平等与互相尊重；另一方面在中华文明内部追求我刚才说的超越民族、宗教、地域的统一的“中国人”身份认同。这两个方面是相辅相成、相互配合的。

[@muhammadkhokhar7899]

Very nice

[@ДилараБайрамова-ф7у]

Can you tell me which is the best city in china for muslim? And are there any universities where u can wear hijab??

[@oldwatchma]

No matter which university will limit your hijab if you are a foreigner

[@yasminea7149]

​@@oldwatchmaAre you saying you're not allowed to wear a scarf at university in China? What do Chinese women do?

[@handaxia1251]

@@oldwatchma are you sure about that? i have seen foreign students from Malaysia and Indonesia in China's Unis wearing hijab..

[@oldwatchma]

yeah，before maybe 10years ago,you can do it.but now, no@@yasminea7149

[@oldwatchma]

I think it's because they don't want to wear it? Or is it the school's rules?@@handaxia1251

[@GNF-b2z]

Why don’t you make more such video, bro?

[@oldwatchma]

bro，Interviewing strangers makes me a little shy

[@mono9196]

Salaam from singapore. Im a native singaporean and not a chinese singaporean. This video is insightful. I am always curious about the general concept of God/religion the chinese have. Because mostly the chinese here especially from Buddhist and Taoist faith backgrounds seem to asscociate religion with culture/tradition/ethnicity. Most of them are unable to distinguish the difference between faith/religion and race/ethicity. Just like some people in this video. They only know islam because of some minority ethnic race. And this video affirms that many Chinese think religion = ethnic tradition. And why do they do this? What in history made them like this? Cos God is the God of everyone and everything. Not just for a race. And i always wonder from what angle can i engage with them about the topic of God of the universe and not just merely of God of a ethnic race. So im wondering what if you could ask them maybe in the next video, what is their idea of God. Do they believe in a Creator? If so, what kind of impression do they have about the Creator of the universe? E.g all powerful, all knowing etc of Allah's 99 names? What would their response be. Would be lovely to see you do one video on this topic.

[@sajjadpre]

People of us know more about Islam that south asian people. Thats 100% true.

[@fathimasifana9781]

As salaam alaikum v.v how are you brother?....Thanks for the video...😍

[@oldwatchma]

wa alaikum salam~~~I am good~how are you?

[@fathimasifana9781]

@@oldwatchma Alhamdhulillah i am good....thankyou

[@syedfarrukh6077]

那个老师太成熟，她解释了巴基斯坦人们的问题很清楚，尊重这种的人。还有他的采访的时候我们可以懂了他理解了很深的伊斯兰教。I am student in jiangsu , do you put your videos in xiao hong shu or other platforms would love to know and also welcome anytime to my city . 我请客你们哈哈。

[@oldwatchma]

有ins账号～ 谢谢关注，有机会找你玩吖😊

[@ssportslivetvstreaming]

which Camera

[@axiaaaaa7524]

I'm very sad, when he say Islam( Pakistan )don't care about education. What a narrow mind they have😏.This because they don't know real Islam. Our prophet already said.. Muslim must learn until he died. And parents who neglected their children (girl/ boy)education will be judged on judgement day. Education is important and Allah ask too.

[@shaziashimu2326]

Assalamualaikum. How are you? What about your village?

[@oldwatchma]

wa alaikum salam~~It‘s ok sis~

[@noriepanda3098]

Alaykumis Salam!

[@GR_Mplo]

plz more videos like this

[@abdurrazzakabdurrazzak2925]

10:33 damn,aunty got some serious moves.Probably she's gonna apply it on her son.😂

[@alice_wuz]

That's Tai Chi

[@oldwatchma]

hahaha，she is doing Tai Chi

[@yasriacali2527]

Can I ask , if Hui , uyghur , kasazk is a group of muslim people in china but different culture??

[@HanChinesemuslim]

totally different

[@oldwatchma]

yeah，totally different

[@tilegensana]

i am kazakh, not from chiba tho😅 kazakh and chinese cultures are totally different but still share little things! well, we were neighbours😂 the most famous is i guess manty🇰🇿-mandu🇨🇳

[@deanjackson2102]

people forget that the Indonesian's Singapore Malaysia Philippines all this area = the Muslim's use to class these people as Chinese but i think they was mixed with Indian/Muslim due to the mixing that happened = it was America/west that started to separate all these little islands away from china and India = for there own gain

[@Meoffff]

I mean most of them ok being whoever you want , but when you say Muslim at least they know no pork no alcohol 😊

[@salmansomali]

Hello bro i've seen some video that police trying to demolute mosques? Any information

[@oldwatchma]

hello bro，not demolute, But they want to replace the dome with a Chinese style, they don't want the mosque to be Arabised. I don't quite understand, is the dome from Arabic?Because I have seen many Christian churches in foreign countries also have domes

[@dionydonny]

@@oldwatchma before the 90s, there were almost no domes in chinese mosques, and most of them were built in the traditional chinese style. after the 90s, suddenly some new mosques were built with domes, and some old mosques were renovated or expanded with domes. the videos we can see online of the dome buildings being removed are either of old mosques being rebuilt to what they were like or illegal structures being removed. we can check the top ten oldest mosques in china, how many of them originally had dome buildings?

[@oldwatchma]

@@dionydonny You are right maybe, but this is not politically correct in Hui muslim circles, just like a Chinese can’t say in Chinese circles that “it doesn’t matter if Taiwan is China’s or not”, similarly in the US they have their political correctness, maybe is it LGBT or something，so i dont really want to talk about this

[@oldwatchma]

@中美争霸兩個墙:美国的谷歌脸书KZbin等 中共的百度阿里腾讯等 不会，其实没有人会在意这个...真正在意的是这件事实在劳民伤财，而且部分人表现得有些挑衅的意味

[@榕树下-h6v]

@@oldwatchma 既然是政治正确那当然以国家为主，就如华人不为当地社会做出改变 便有被排挤的理由，中国清真寺院建筑自唐代以来在融入传统文化上做出过许多改变

[@farooqshah3104]

Can you interview people and ask them about Pakistan? 🇵🇰 Love from Pakistan 🇵🇰

[@commie5211]

Mostly positive since Chinese media only reports positive news about Pakistan. But if you asked the ones really knows about the region, they will tell you Pakistan is facing lots of challenges. power struggle between regional and central government, ethics groups, political families and the military, and much more... It is so divided and it hindered its development. China sees Pakistan as its closet ally, and wound want to see it develop.

[@川普大帝2024]

我们对巴基斯坦兄弟抱有一种朦胧的美感，大多数中国人只知道中国和巴基斯坦是友好国家，但有非常多的中国人会把巴基斯坦和巴勒斯坦搞混

[@SoufianeBella]

🐪🌴💚🌍☀️

[@陳式-p1o]

非常客观的采访

[@oldwatchma]

谢谢~

[@shahabuddeen4522]

❤❤❤❤

[@kkpola]

Dad is a wise man. But pakistan needed scholars who have the Quran memorized cover to cover. So the 1400 year old claim can be proved that it was a mouth to mouth tradition then it was written on document. Beautiful video.

[@zizancat5995]

Bro, NEXT .. REVIEW chinnese muslim district or old MOSQUE there..

[@luthfisidik001]

strongly agree

[@oldwatchma]

ok~~~

[@dotamaze]

7:19 This guy is quite intelligent and provides some interesting conversation.

[@SoufianeBella]

Islam is the middle way between Capitalism et communism sys.💚🌍☀️

[@Shallow-o1o]

May Allah guide you oldwatch and viona ! Your way of asking triggering questions like what deen would you choose ?! This question could result a person to make redah and believe in Kufr ! May Allah guide you all

[@treeinafield5022]

very interesting

[@Nancy_Momolands]

what is issue of 13th century mosque najiaying mosque why CCP party want to demolish this Can you explain this issue???

[@oldwatchma]

Although I don't like this, but to be precise, it is to transform the dome into a traditional Chinese style, not demolish

[@SmokeMamba-pi5xk]

Hello brother i wanted to ask something. Do Chinese muslims drink wine? Do hui and uyghurs drink? I'm curious that's why I'm asking,i hope you will reply

[@oldwatchma]

wow,bro,of course no drink~

[@shehryar_ali]

It is Haram

[@kaiyuzheng7663]

It depends on whether you are a 'good' Muslim or 'bad' Muslim. Similar comparison exists, such as a 'good' catholic girl or a 'bad' catholic girl, a 'good' Buddhist monk or a 'bad' Buddhist monk.

[@raditcs]

7:13 bro is smart think

[@thomasdong3882]

Ccp is a religion in China?

[@clother2745]

其实跟儒家差不多，算不算宗教看人怎么看吧。

[@oldwatchma]

To be honest, I don't know if

[@shziabzisbzh]

不是🥹

[@jamilhussain5421]

Egyptian religion wasn't the Ancient Egyptian religion when Muslim arrived in the 7th century, it was mostly Christianity, the old Ancient religion was mostly finished not long after Christianity appeared

[@Rendyariawindana]

how about our brother muslim in uighur?

[@oldwatchma]

yeah

[@banglayn3231]

❤❤❤❤

[@berdigylychrejepbayev7503]

the interesting part many know about halal food but they don't know (or didn't mention) about One God and His Messenger. I mean this makes Islam special not halal food or some strict regulations. It seems to me that many Chinese have very very little knowledge about Islam. Even though I can understand their situation, this makes me feel sad bout them. i mean if they know the essence of Islam, its core concept then they would love it, at least some will do.

[@tenlee4744]

Greed is the cause of all problems. Greed will destroy the greedy. Everything is do not know blind believe in deference authority is the greatest enemy of truth. Because do to lack of knowledge. deep inside too much stress too much worry fear like that. ✍

[@jifiza1828]

Nice

[@ozgetheozzie]

❤

[@arbidacrow]

in past China more have spirituality...

[@josephsaleh7433]

Checkout isa Mai he is Chinese and a scholar in islam

[@Akasahamir]

Do you know that the true follower of Islam came from China, that's what professor Naoki Yamamoto said after his surveyed around the world, Salam

[@adanphu4325]

I have muslim friends. I never had anything wrong about Islam until a muslim harassed all the innocent chinese by saying "they are living for their own interests." Still I try to not accuse and judge all the muslims. I still think there are innocent muslims out there. Before that, I saw the whole world very nice and innocent until the muslim harassed

[@oldwatchma]

I'm sorry. What you're talking about is like when I was studying abroad, some Chinese people did bad things. For example, a Chinese student wore a mask and ran into a foreign girls' dormitory in the middle night，ddid strange things in front of girls. This incident brought shame to all Chinese students, and people from other countries mocked us as perverts. So once you're in a group, it's inevitable that someone's behavior will bias the entire group, right? Like what country are you from? Which nation? Are all your people perfect?

[@adanphu4325]

​@@oldwatchmaI'm from the US and I am a Christian. What is your definition of perfection. Yeah, not smart people harm innocent ones because of what others did.

[@lifequestions5546]

Just an opinion that may differ from others. You are entitled to your opinion and so am I, right? I think most religions in the world are Human's Centric that is the focus is human. What I mean is to achieve Heaven or a better place after life, one needs to struggle to obtain it with one's strength. There is no guarantee only hopefully you can get to heaven when you die. And I heard Christianity is the opposite. Their belief says Christianity is God's Centric that promotes no one can go to Heaven based on their strength or effort to do good deeds or to follow religious laws. They believe God intervened in Human History by sending His Son to die on the CROSS to redeem us the sinners. Once one is truly believe and repent from the sins, they will be saved. Guarantee 100%. What do you think?

[@turaes2134]

8:44 "i believe in the CCP more" This dude's social credits: ↑↑↑