What Do Comic Book Dealers Think Of Current CGC Comics? 9.9's? Lawsuits? WonderCon 2024 Discussion

[@bradschubert775]

I am a long time reader/collector or comics. I will not ever buy a slabbed comic. I have zero trust for graded books. I feel that any of the grading services have damaged the hobby. I really liked thus video and getting the perspective from the dealers.

[@peterparkercomix729]

👍🤘

[@wolviempq171]

This is one of my favorite videos. As individual collectors, it's easy to get lost in the weeds. So it's especially insightful to get the comic dealer's perspective on the bigger picture. I enjoy hearing all of the different viewpoints on the current state of the hobby from those in the know. Thank you for creating & sharing this valuable content with the comic community!

[@CollectorAuctions]

Well done interviews. You didn't make the mistake of asking a question and then spend 5 minutes explaining why you are asking that question. Great content.

[@B-T619]

I love these dealer interviews... Christian is always my favorite. Would love to see him in one of your shows as a guest.

[@darthjarwood7943]

dude i have sent in hundreds of books to CGC and have never got a 9.9 ...2 weeks ago i sent a 25 book submission and got five 9.9s in one submission

[@jeffschmitt6977]

In the end meaning that 9.8s are now dropping fast. People just dont know it yet. What a scam this 9.9 stuff is.

[@govatos]

If that’s true, it’s good info. You should make a short video proving it.

[@jEdi_bUddhA_YOGi]

The difference 'twixt the 2 are ridiculous. It's all marketing. This is how they get people to resubmit 9.8s to try & get 9.9s. It works; rakes in the dolo. Sadly. Not an issue for me however. Raw all day. I prefer to look in my books, & see the other 95% of the book, not just the cover & back; they're not hocKEY cards, they're key books with beautiful art pages, & fun literature by fantastic writers. Profiteers & their avariciousness always ruin hobbies.

[@darthjarwood7943]

@@jEdi_bUddhA_YOGi people have different reasons for getting books graded...the books ive had since i was a kid in the 90s hold a special place for me and most of the books i get now are for the cover art ALONE...they put shitty artists on the inside alot of times and the stories are unreadable so yeah i dont feel no bad way for slabbin these modern "cover art for the carry" books

[@WadeNslade]

Well Cgc is drumming up business

[@versewonderstrikes5353]

17:22 Wu Tang ODB reference!! We’re definitely allowing that!

[@jEdi_bUddhA_YOGi]

"Allowin'?" Ain't no one stoppin' tha Dirt - shimmy shimmy ya! Furthermore, I'm w/ dawgie; only raw from now on! R.i.P. to tha god *Osirus*

[@Erik-gs7ef]

These are my favorite type of videos. Keep up the good work. These are the type of videos I can watch over and over again.

[@a3marketing991]

The 9.9 grading is a joke. It's just a money grab by CGC and everybody knows it.

[@TheChadTI]

A new (potentially massive) revenue stream for CGC . A glass eye up a ducks ass could see that.

[@benellison5668]

The Raiders guy should have a podcast of his own

[@andrejplatoniactor]

Guess who's comic book I picked up at King Con 5 over the weekend? Which by the way was one of the greatest shows ever. I met Klaus Janson and had a long conversation with him. What a great guy. When I got home I looked at my free comic book I got at the door and it was yours! Which I am so excited to read. My Saturday night might be reading your book and listening to 80's music. How cool is that? Btw I love your channel and think it's the best when it comes to comic book KZbinrs.

[@tensixtythreecomics]

So much to say!: This for me is one of your best videos. I really enjoyed how you asked the same direct questions in the same order to each person. All the dealers answered directly and it was refreshing to hear! I also liked the variety of answers especially around cbcs. It always surprised me when people would send a book to cgc to get “marked in ink” instead of cbcs. There was so much great opinions in this interview! This is one of those videos I will likely watch again. Personally I have very little confidence in cgc right now and this whole 9.9 thing is a game changer. The siggy thing is almost signs of desperation on cgc’s part. Like one of the people said “why now”??? Thanks for this

[@Bar-Lord]

I’m a CBCS guy purely because my LCS swears by them and I really like their slab better than CGC’s. I’ll still be using them after all of this just for the fact that, for me, CGC has to start over. Their 9.9 Giant Sized X-men throws the existing scale away and starts new. I’m a case, though, where I collect and don’t flip and only grade books I buy from my LCS.

[@brianoneal2547]

Where do you buy

[@JohnSmith-ib8qr]

Brad from FVF Comics knows his $hit, his answers to your questions/topics are more practical and sensible. He's been around awhile and most likely seen it all. His knowledge and wisdom is far beyond the younger dealers in todays marketplace, I'd feel safe doing business with Brad! The best part of the hobby was haggling and dissecting a comic to complete a fair, agreeable deal on a purchase price. Today you put your faith in a newly hired grader, deciding if your comic is a 9.8 or a 9.0 costing the owner perhaps $1000's, rarer comics $10,000's -$100,000's! Enjoyed the interviews!

[@Mr.Digit115]

thats a big issue you dont see talked about enough is that as graders come and go over the years,...grading can change as well, yesterdays F is now a VF- and so on,...can ai be used to grade books yet? hmmm. ive never slabbed a book, have had to buy a few, ....so ill watch with minor interest....

[@KarensPages]

I always look forward to this video. Great job, Swagglehaus! 👍

[@AlextheComicHoarder]

I would totally agree with the guy that said @cbcs has had every opportunity to take advantage and gain market share. They don’t seem interested.

[@tensixtythreecomics]

Wonder what their move is now?

[@AlextheComicHoarder]

@@tensixtythreecomics nothing. They seem to like to watch from the sideline as CGC gives them opportunities after opportunity.

[@TheDjk300ComicGuy]

Perfect timing to see Cgc grade a 9.9 GSX1 to over see the mists of scandal etc.... it's a business. Plain and simple. Great video with the dealers

[@PaulDavidCooper]

All the dealers' comments were insightful. Thank you, Swagglehaus, for asking good questions and then letting the dealers talk and formulate their points without interrupting them. I especially Mr. Sloan's analysis of 9.9 and 10 graded books.

[@Paulies-Hideout]

I'm a little grouchy purchasing my Batman Adventures #12 in a 9.8. With so many of them on the market, I know at least several of them will be 'upgraded' to a 9.9

[@DanSchawbel]

I just sold mine last week because of this exact thought. Dump now before it’s too late.

[@Paulies-Hideout]

@@DanSchawbel Appreciate the advice. I was literally wondering if I should do just that.

[@DanSchawbel]

@@Paulies-Hideout Do what's best for you. I love that comic and HQ and batman the animated series, but I know that the value will shatter when 9.8's get re-graded 9.9's. I can buy back for $500 in a few years if I want.

[@Dev003x]

My main issue besides the scandal stuff is, I can;t see anything that warrants the price jump between 2 books 1/10th of a point difference. I mean serious jumps.

[@jonr269]

The last guy from FVF comics i actually liked listening to him talk. out of all the guys talking, you can tell he is very passionate about comics and while it is a business to him. He still enjoys it as a hobby as a whole and is more in it to enjoy it. While also making sure his clients are into it to enjoy it as much as him. Sadly vendors like him are few and far between at these kind of cons. Just like he said about not selling books above a 9.0 raw and how he views signature books as a whole about it use to be free getting stuffed signed back in the 90's. Hes actually a vendor who i could do business with when looking at what he has for sale and be able to work out a good deal when buying books from compared to many vendors at these kind of cons that are more focused on the money aspect of this once great hobby instead of what it use to be and that is the enjoyment and fun of owning awesome books.

[@Mr.Digit115]

dont feel bad,down here cons are dominated by wrestlers, cosplay, voice actors and a smattering of old comic dealers,....those things are cool, but for comic collectors like myself, it just runs up the price of tickets for something i could care less about, but still have to help pay for,.....

[@jchanh]

Great work Swaggy!!! This is what comic books youtube should be about!

[@twindiezel1965]

Swaggle and the Defects are the best!! Another awesome video!! The questions were on point

[@consumetheliving]

I love the one dealer repeats "it's CBCS's" fault for not gaining market share but in the same breath says I got all these sigs I can send to CGC now? You mean as a dealer it was your choice to not send books into CBCS further perpetuating the CBCS is less than notion. All the while CGC just had reholder gate, internal switch switch gate, soft 9.8's on heritage, and finally 9.9 pre-screen into Giant Size 9.8 moonlighting as a 9.9. What can CBCS do when everyone has blind featly to CGC no matter what they do?

[@robotzvsfolks1559]

This!! Most accurate summation of this 'debate'.

[@crowrevell2082]

Exactly. CGC has a stranglehold on the market and people don't want to admit they are willing to look the other way versus risk their own collection of CGC books lose value. Unless CBC was to offer free grading on all CGC books, those who have sunk thousands perhaps 10s of thousands of dollars into CGC will never budge.

[@revoltpuppy]

CBCS's only big differentiator was signature authentication, so yeah, they haven’t done much of anything to gain market share, and that's on them. Meanwhile their books go for less, so as a dealer, you're going to hold onto your investment until you can get maximum value out of it (CGC's more valuable signature verification).

[@revoltpuppy]

@@crowrevell2082 People readily admit that they're going for maximum value.

[@consumetheliving]

@@revoltpuppy I completely get the business aspect of CBCS selling for less than CGC but that has nothing to do with CBCS. There is nothing that CBCS can do to make their slabs in grade sell for the same price. This is my only point of contention, saying its CBC's fault for not grabbing more market share but no dealer is willing to slab in mass with CBCS and take the "financial" hit. CBCS could tape $100 dollar bills to each slab and Heritge still would send anything them.

[@300baud]

I love your videos like this when you get a good gauge of how the dealers feel about the market. A lot of different and yet very reasonable insights.

[@Narynan1]

These videos are fire. THESE videos are the reason I showed up the very first time.

[@charliehobbs7968]

Wow! Thank you this was very informative. It was nice meeting you at this last Near Mint Sunday event. Keep up the good work.

[@AlextheComicHoarder]

Love Blue Chip Nico’s integrity. I need to do some business with them.

[@brute_nm]

I love these - thanks for doing them for us!!

[@Swagglehaus]

You bet!

[@sadvillainee]

What a great video! Thank you Swagglehaus for the consistently great content! Great questions and answers, very informative.

[@Supertomscustoms]

It’s silly to think that authenticating a signature is “only as good as the authenticator” but grading can be done by any one of the dozens of “professionals” and we’re supposed to assumed it’s the definitive grade.

[@allisknu11]

I love these interviews. Would love to watch and listen to more people that are living the comic book life.

[@bobbyandelena]

Thanks for posting the video. Lots to learn here. Just wanted to say I’ve been collecting for over 20 years and my experience is if one collects for the love none of the other nonsense matters. I started collecting as a young boy to escape a bad childhood. I continue to collect to nurture that same young boy.❤

[@davecironelibrarykid]

“No, we don’t eant to sell you fries and bacon” - best line of the video! - Great interviews, Swagglehaus.

[@best9642]

Great show, I love the interviews, you did an awesome job, bro, your guests were amazing.

[@peterthornton8814]

These were great interviews, thanks a lot Swag!

[@thecomickeeper5127]

This reminds me of the housing crisis of 2007-2008 where everyone from the mortgage companies, investment banks, insurance companies, ratings agencies and everyone else was making a lot money off of fees and could care less about the health of the market. CGC only cares about fees , not the market or collectors. Once they squeeze all the juice out they'll liquidate their assets and move on. These are hedge fund ppl, they are the worst of the worst.

[@leeniren3706]

One of the things that could resolve this problem and help people see what is a true 99 versus a 98 is having CGC put greater notes on every single book and explain why the grade the book received is there. Can you imagine if a 99 explained why it wasn’t a 10? It would blow the market apart.

[@larrysmith7301]

Love the dealer interviews, thanks for the effort.

[@versewonderstrikes5353]

I submitted an ASM 194 during that time period it came back a 9.8! It was my book tho. I checked the number. 🥵

[@Bradimus1981]

ODB! Oh baby I like it raw! Oh baby I like it raw! Oh baby I like it raw! lol That remark in the video at around 17:20 was priceless.

[@jabezcreed]

Blue Chip has good advice for those people looking at 9.9s like gold prospectors. Be smart, don't gamble.

[@DiewithZero62]

Great content. Super informative and helpful. Question - Mark Jewellers was mentioned by Elveen. Segue of sorts - any comments or thought on Canadian Price Variants. Not as rare as MJ, but still tough to get keys in high grade. Cheers.

[@mojennith6427]

So if we resubmit....will they still back the original score?

[@concettodamico3916]

Great insight from the dealer interviews 👊thanks Swaggle..

[@DukeCityExplorer]

That 1st dealer you interviewed summed it up quite well. I will add that CGC finds interesting ways to extort money out of us collectors...

[@rayatl217]

These interviews are some of the most interesting stuff from Swag👍

[@jessepearson557]

Great video thanks for sharing this commentary from professional dealers, great insights! 😎👍

[@eddinsssx2667]

My favorite videos you make. nice work

[@BigMoneyGripMCV]

great questions and great interviewees

[@jeffschmitt6977]

Great channel and good content. Just a word, When you hear a dealer comment in the video "Whats the difference between 9.9 and 9.8s NOTHING! It does not provide confidence in buying either at this point simply because if 9.9 is a ridiculous grade and 9.8s are now going to go down in worth, Then why bother collecting them at this point? For me, on graded books, they only way for me to get around this is to buy raw or if slabbed, lower priced 9.6s and 9.4s after waiting for them to take a domino drop for 6 months after this 9.9 baloney cycles thru.

[@jEdi_bUddhA_YOGi]

Lil' skeletons in the capsule. Not sure how anyone can trust CGC now. I wouldn't of bought that AC#1 for $6 million unless they cracked it open in front of me, & I was able to count the pages, then I would of had a professional (not a novice player like CGC) encapsulate it for me in real glass. Are you kidding me...? A $6,000,000 piece of art in a cheap plastic capsule by a company known for not being authentic. I'm done with encapsulated books. Buying all my keys raw from now on.

[@thecomickeeper5127]

This comment is on point .

[@peterparkercomix729]

👏👏👏

[@flipdoubt23]

"Get your Swaggle on!' 😂 Great video.

[@frognanana4646]

The "taking to dealers at cons" are my favorite types of videos you do.

[@Thrawn.]

Will there be a value difference between a CC Signature series or a verified signature at CGC? There won't really be a difference in value until tje 1st scandal occurs on verified signatures. Then CC signatures will be worth more!

[@Mr.Digit115]

thanks, mickey, i cant imagine, living in the rural area i do, the traffic you must deal with every day there,... that said, i like these type of videos the best of most you do, hang in there,...

[@michaelmarcuri1506]

Brad is the best! I agree with everything he says. I've got comics from him for years. Great dude! Raw is the best. Always will be.

[@captain_uk]

Brad should have his own show, he talks so much sense, old school like myself.

[@JimChurchSr-lu2pq]

Super job Mickey - thanks for doing this video

[@jdc4483]

The only influence CGC - and other like grading services have - is what the market collectively gives them. Without that group-think-market-confidence, these grading services have little influence. In other words, they have credibility, only because they have credibility, just as the Kardashians are celebrities, because they’re celebrities.

[@robbiebateman7245]

Hey Swagg - love your channel and you actually inspired me to do a 1-100 Avengers run as well. Just curious if you have ever been to Heroescon and if you plan to go this year? It is in my opinion, the best true "comic" con.

[@brychology]

Heroes Con is AWESOME! It’s a comic focused show, tons of great books in the room and lots of dealers.

[@sidneyrivera3578]

Thanks for the video Swag. This is my favorite segment of content you put out. Keep up the great work.✌️

[@doctorshawn3461]

These are the best videos!

[@prettyflyforafilipin]

Great interviews and great point about the masses being whatever about cgc. Even so, it’s up to the diligent minority to keep these companies in check.

[@rickylima7798]

Appreciate your work & Content ! 📚🔨

[@verified893]

These are the best. Thank you.

[@ScarecrOmega]

I like that last guy from FVF, and agree with several of his points.

[@GoldGauntletComix]

Great! Great video brother as always, but what I would like to know is what do the owners of cgc fingerless I'm referring to Blackstone that is a company I used to work for and I know that they can get real funny about stuff like this. I don't mean funny as humorous. I'm wondering if they care or if they're ready to dump cgc how much is this costing them? Just wondering

[@nickm138]

I love reading comics and enjoying the artwork.. I don't own a single "slab"... Keep your comics free from enclosure to enjoy!!!

[@walkthataisle]

Yeah so your grubby hands can ruin the value.

[@nickm138]

@@walkthataisle 🤣 Yep! The comics value to me is the enjoyment I get from them! 😃

[@walkthataisle]

That's why God invented tradepaperbacks.

[@BoostersGoldComics]

@@nickm138does the rest of the world need to mimic you beliefs. I really hate musicals. I dont find videos of musicals and tell them how much i hate musicals. Do you know why? Cause no one gives a shit what I think.

[@RobbyRobDu929]

​@@nickm138then when you are done reading them give them away for free...stay consistent.

[@popsequentialism7213]

Christian at Elveen is definitely a "pitch" man. And that's not necessarily a pejorative. That said... I don't think anyone who expects a 9.8 is happy with a 9.6. I also don't think very many people actually care about Mark Jewelers books, and so there was a fair amount of satisfaction among a certain collector demographic in seeing people who paid a fortune for an advertisement insert get burned. But if you are heavily leveraged in selling those MJs and 9.6s then you are going to be bullish on them. He and others in this video are rightly concerned but dancing around the impact of 9.9s, which is that a collector deeply invested in 9.8s is going to leave the hobby. A max exodus kills value across the board and a LOT of people were 9.8 collectors.

[@justiceforcomics32]

The CGC 9.9 is crazy. Is there a discernible difference between a 9.8 and a 9.9? Seems like a scam to me.

[@Sasquashy_1]

These are my favorite videos of your swag

[@STASHdadtv]

32:22 my boy @thenandoknight my hair in the background 😅

[@davidsamuelson2089]

You think about why dealers sell overgraded raws priced at a graded book at a minimum?

[@br7693t]

I have a Batgirl comic with a blank cover that Babs Tarr drew a picture on for me at a local meet and greet. I had it graded and slabbed afterwards. Grade is irrelevant. Over time the platic warped and has bent up a book that i treasure. Never going for their scam again.

[@dcal7406]

I have a bunch of 9.9 thst I haven’t sent in yet. I ll get around to it

[@chrisjoyce6610]

Let me know when you are done. Out of respect, I will hold my 10s until you are done.

[@murrayc9615]

I like what Brad (from VFV Comics) said about embossing the well itself with the serial number. The ONLY thing wrong with that idea is that you just KNOW CGC will screw that up too. Someone will mistake an "8" for a "0", and then people will really freak out when the serial numbers between the well and label don't match up thinking the slab was swapped out [again].

[@Skievy]

it's easy to tell if 9.8's will drop if a 9.9 came out bc it's already happened, i don't have an account for GPA to check but did new mutants 98 9.8's drop in price once a 9.9 hit the market beyond normal market flux & movie hype? if it did then they have a valid point, if it didn't then it's all scare tactics

[@JGSoCal-e2n]

Elveens has the best, most real, most subjective, answer to the holders issues.

[@DavidM.P]

Great job!

[@chrisbullock6477]

Wow I was just looking for something interesting about comic books but this whole conversation and part of the industry can totally zap any of the fun out of the medium

[@jgracie22]

Christian is the Man!🎉

[@RobRVA]

Enjoyed this. Christian is a character.

[@stevebradley4885]

Great vid...thanks

[@CosmicTrekker]

I sense there were quite a few cuts/retakes/stoppages during that Elveen commentary. He sounds like he drinks an aquarium of espresso every day. lol. Seems like a nice dude, though. I agree with him on Swag being the kindest dude. When I walked up to him at the last Collectors Summit and started talking to him, he talked to me like he knew me for years. Anyway, I like these "ask the dealer" interviews. One thing I think should be in all these interviews is the question "what are some trends you're seeing in the market whether they be price, subject matter, publishers, general fan interest that you're seeing increasing or declining?" Or just ask them about anything they're noticing about the market like "Are Silver and Bronze still tanking in price?" or "Is Golden Age gaining interest?", etc. And I'll repeat what I've said in the past - this 9.9gate seems pathetic for what CGC is doing. It seems like a manipulation of the market for profits at the expense of others while CGC rakes in money.

[@pulp420]

Bob is the man!

[@RAG718]

i always like these type of vids when u talk to the dealers ......... couple of them on this episode almost made me go to sleep though ,,, words out they mouth just over my head i guess ,, no way 9.9-10 sales makiing 9.8 values go down ,, smh

[@davidsamuelson2089]

Quite surprised that if you’re looking to “invest” in comics with big price tags 1) you’d roll the dice in dealer raws with all the probable issues and 2) why wouldn’t you be knowledgeable about the scams and issues with CGC recently?

[@mr.woolleys]

I don’t hate graded books but if you send in a book to said company and receive a 9.8 because it’s the highest other than a 10 and then if they re-adjust the scale, you should get a free resubmission to see if your book qualifies for a free upgrade since it’s not fair to have to pay for a resubmission.

[@thegardenstatepicker]

CGC uses JSA for autograph authentication. I’ve had numerous issues with JSA along with others who had lawsuits and won, and somehow they still have a high reputation of grading autos. So although I agree with the sentiment of his point…. It takes way more than 1 mishap to ruin a reputation. Grading in general across all platforms is only as good as the 1 guy grading. Autos or not. Video games to comics to cards to vhs and everything between. CBCS uses Beckett (their owner) that I trust a little more but is not issue free. Still highly respected in reputation. ACOA and PSA is overall the best to grade cards and autographs in my opinion and PSA has a reputation for mistreating cards and grading high before the mistreatment, so you could have a damaged 10 lol. They all pull shady crap and all are still successful. CGC had to get into unwitnessed graphs because CBCS is stealing that market share, along with a better looking slab boosting sales. I also agree, graded books are still a large part of the market, it’s healthy and it’s not going anywhere… even if niche.

[@ryanstafford9484]

Brad is the best!

[@mrtorrance1263]

Bragadocius is back!

[@anthonybrown3363]

The fact that it just doesn’t go from 10.0 to 9.5 is stupid.

[@Rhett-Christopher]

I enjoy Swag's content but my favorite is when Swag interviews others (dealers) in the community and i get to hear more of a broad spectrum of anslysis and thought.

[@justiceforcomics32]

The highest chance for errors and issues will always be graded books. Grading is very subjective and always has been. I mainly collect high grade raw comics and I don't need a perfect book to be happy. Everyone has their own idea of how to collect. Just be happy with how you collect.

[@rickinquest]

It was always said by many that the difference between a CGC 9.6 and a 9.8 is whether or not the person grading was having a good day or a bad day as the subjective difference of that 0.2 differential. It's that very reason why it's smarter to buy 9.6's over 9.8's if the price is right and value spread is wide. It was always rumored that the difference between a CGC 9.8 and getting a CGC 9.9 or 10.0 was if you were a whale client or name was J. Scott Campbell or Jim Lee submitting exclusives. The term "gift grading" was always thrown around. Grading is great, but take it with a grain of salt, it's a subjective professional opinion and evaluation. Crack and Resubmit 100 modern 9.6 and 9.8 books and I'd wager a lot of 'em will come back with interchangeable different grades. I'm a fan of CGC grading for the presentation (beautiful picture frame type presentation), archival storage (the slabs/encapsulation), the authentication (yeah, despite trimming and other scandals, I still think they are high odds good for detecting restoration) and the grading (as a general opinion).

[@AlextheComicHoarder]

Elveen is always legit.

[@dcal7406]

Blackstone is a big part owner on cgc now. They will look for anyway no matter how small to increase profit

[@marthinusellis6564]

I'm a collector in South Agrica been collecting for more than 40 years.. i will never slab my books and make others rich in putting my comic in a casing and put a grade on it and render it useless only to be used as a large trading card.....

[@mizaeldiaz8325]

I have one thing to say about CGC… Fuck them. I sent out a Marvel Comics Present 72 in near mint between 9.6 and 9.8 and it came back a 7.5. With the comments slight tear on the back page. That book DID NOT have a tear. But I got screwed because I didn’t have a before and after picture. I am 100 percent someone at CGC switched it out. I used to be a big believer I had probably close to 50+ books graded and never had an issue. I was trying them out then that happened. I have not sent out anything else to them. I have over 4,000 books great collection and now I will only deal in raw copies.

[@randysmith4318]

NO LIES!!! NO JUDGEMENT!!! HONESTY OPINIONS MATTER AS LONG AS THEY DONT OFFEEND. SPIRITED DEBATE WHER BOTH SIDES OR MORE HAVE EQUAL SHARE