What Does Islam Say about Protests and Demonstrations? - Q&A - Sh. Khalid Yasin

[@pabloikonyero]

This message was relevant 12 years ago and it’s still relevant in 2023… This is Islam, relevant 1400 years ago and still relevant today

[@kysotope]

Please make dua for my country Pakistan which is currently intoxicated with the idea of rebelling against rulers openly via protests and marches. It only leads to Fitna, but the people currently are too emotionally invested to hear otherwise. May Allah (SWT) protect the entire Muslim Ummah. Ameen.

[@bigjallday110]

Muslims in 2020 need to see this.

[@bintkhan2827]

🙌🏼🙌🏼🙌🏼

[@Goat_edit25]

Seeing this in 2022

[@Salman_Tre]

2024

[@Moon_2024]

I hope people around the world hear this and understand it.

[@ITBari]

May Allah Grant. Ameen

[@medicalstudybuddy2964]

Subhanallah 12 years ago, and this is the best and most wise message regarding this topic that I have heard

[@user-ow3qs5ef7c]

Sunnah is sunnah. You are being tested with what you can’t accept. He’s not saying leave the matter completely. He’s saying follow sunnah and not protesting which is adopted from non islamic ways. Modern day protests will always some point lead to violence. So spread voice online spread voice in community.

[@CosmicIceBerry]

"And the servants of the Most Merciful are those who walk upon the earth easily, and when the ignorant assure them (harshly), they say (words of) peace." Al-Furqan (25:63)

[@ctrlaltdelete321]

If 5 million Iranians did not go to the streets to protest in 1979, would there have been an Islamic government?

[@Salman_Tre]

That street protests brought Shia republic into power not the Islamic republic. As a result, 50,000 mosques are closed down in Iran due to lack of religipusity as per Senior cleric.

[@ctrlaltdelete321]

@@Salman_Tre I don't think you're understanding the point of my argument, that protests can drive change...in Iran's case it is majority shia and brought a shia government, why can't us sunnis do the same? Because of our palace clerics spreading madkhali b.s from the saudi zi**nst rulers

[@ctrlaltdelete321]

@Salman_Tre if the cowards on this channel stop deleting my comments and allow discussion, I will respond. Literal cowards have deleted my comments, follow the money I'm sure you will find the satanic house of suad Bank rolling them

[@danishsheikh8082]

Would this also apply in the current climate what's happening to our brothers and sisters today? I would be grateful if someone can awnser my question.

[@danishsheikh8082]

Would be it better to have a jammah where we all pray in congregation and seek the mercy of Allah.

[@talhaucme8527]

Same if the protests for Palestinians are wrong then sadly most Muslims are on the wrong.

[@adam6543]

@@danishsheikh8082 no that would be worse, that's another bidah. You can't just make your own salah up and your own way of worship

[@danishsheikh8082]

@@adam6543 I dont mean making up a salah. I agree. I meant to say was if everyone woke up to pray fajr in jammah in the masjid. That would be powerful and would probably scare the Zionists.

[@mailman8042]

Yes this still applies in the current climate most peaceful protests still end up turning into Violence you should instead try to raise Mel awareness through social media

[@ModouLaminFofana-l3i]

Love you Shiekh

[@hasinaakter2903]

SubhanAllah mind blowing what we see today so true

[@inayah4518]

How about for the Palestinians, what else can we do besides protest?

[@talhaucme8527]

No its still not allowed. Check assimalhakeem lecture on it. He said online protests are okay as long as we aren't hating on Muslims. Second, its best to donate things or do jihad.

[@sarimhasan2073]

This vid is is very wrong. It is only haram to protest if it is a violent protest

[@talhaucme8527]

@@sarimhasan2073 nope Assimalhakeem said it's haram anyway.

[@salmanmussa6866]

Look these protest are haram because of mixing of men and women…..music being played…and nationalistic flags being held while saying La ilaha illallah….. now can someone bring me a Quran and sunnah that says all that is halal. As the brother above said….only two things can be done is jihad physically or by your words or by given money to a halal charity.

[@aazibibnzuhair6588]

@@sarimhasan2073 is it OK if it involves free mixing for no reason at all..their is high chance of the protests become violent ..better be safe than risk it

[@Amasika2]

Can anyone help me with the verse in Quran or Hadith that speaks against demonstration or protest

[@musaabdullahi1660]

You can find that in the Sunnah

[@ibnamanot]

May Allah bless the Sheikh.

[@blueq4324]

Can someone explain- isn't changing with your voice basically another way of saying "peaceful protest"?

[@saaniyahsajed1932]

Yes exactly! It's just a mix of words but the purpose behind it is to demand a change from authority. It can be called a movement of justice for any sake and the reasons for such will be the same as a "protest"

[@blueq4324]

@@saaniyahsajed1932 I don't understand the sheikh's position in this case

[@saaniyahsajed1932]

@@blueq4324 perhaps he is saying this so that we do not imitate the ruckus and non peaceful way of protest that is in our society. He might be alluding to the idea that peaceful protest is basically appointing a leader to speak on behalf of the public.

[@Whichofthefavors]

He is saying that you can make a stand against injustice without doing it the way the non muslims tell you to do it. You don't have to imitate them to make change. Go to your leaders, they need to be speaking up for the Muslim communities.

[@moefinesse9878]

There's a difference between shouting and marching out on the streets and to speak with an opposition. The prophet commanded us that protesting by yelling and screaming on the streets is not permissible in islam

[@tahaazeem90]

BROTHER WHERE I WILL FIND THE COMPLETE LECTURE............

[@ZakuZuko]

I've never been more confused ever. I thought speaking against injustice in your society what we as muslim commanded to do? I don't get it. How is that not a protest?

[@nabilyasin2088]

I’ll give you one point, can there ever be a 1 gender protest as in all men or all women? Free mixing is haram and so as you see these protests are created by free mixing

[@ayyahayoub3375]

Nabil Yasin using that logic public school should be haram as well, intention should be the focus, there are muslims in china being killed & put in concentration camps currently. should we stand by and allow it to happen?

[@ayyahayoub3375]

we should be speaking out against injustice, islam encourages us to stand with the oppressed. he says use your voice doesn’t mean to protest, but that’s what a protest is, using your voice to be heard

[@nabilyasin2088]

Ayyah Ayoub girls are encouraged to study at home but some students of knowledge say that education is best achieved through attending school so it shouldn’t be that you can free mix when you like. Same as going to the market isn’t haram but that doesn’t make protesting halal. Protesting isn’t something we created rather took it from the west and so regardless of the case we shouldn’t resort to protesting as there are other means to attaining the goal. It would make more sense for all the women to cover themselves in a way that doesn’t attract attention of men but that’s not what’s happening now is it. So it’s not just a case of “everyone should focus on the goal” because that’s not realistic and individuals are bound to be affected which is exactly why unnecessary free mixing is haram . I hope I’ve answered accordingly

[@ayyahayoub3375]

Nabil Yasin as you said knowledge is best achieved through attending school, women shouldn’t be given any less of a chance, or opportunity. if you believe in no free mixing then neither men nor women should be attending public school, you can’t disadvantage someone based on their gender. it’s not choosing to free mix when you want, you can’t deny women the right to go out. and yes people should focus on the goal of the protests, that is 100% achievable, men are definitely capable of protesting for equality without harassing women, if you don’t believe you or the people you know are capable of that, it isn’t women protesting that you should be worried about, that’s not the women’s fault. even when people go to the masjid for prayer there is both men & women, you can’t pick and chose what is free mixing. saying that fighting against injustice isn’t necessary isn’t true, people are being killed, it is a necessity, as we would stand if it was our muslim brothers and sisters being killed, we should do the same now.

[@ayyahayoub3375]

speak can mean protesting, it means using your voice to spread awareness. when people are being killed, you can’t sit and wait for change to happen. a good analogy is if you are applying for a job, you are going to make duaa to get the job, but you aren’t going to stop there, you’re going to work towards meeting it’s requirements. Allah does provide, but you can’t expect to be handed everything

[@Whichofthefavors]

So, what to do you advise we do as Muslims?

[@AhmedQuthb]

He's talking about the Mass Protests which Involves Free Mixing. Also there's particular Jurisdictions for that hadith. Fiqh needs to be implemented. Don't be Ignorant fall for the Deception Shaytans do. Actually only these kinda Perspectives are gonna save our Muslim Ummah from doing shirk. Literally the entire System governing the Globe is haraam.(ie, Secularism, Democracy, Monarchy, Feminism, Liberalism, Radicalism, Conservatism, Education System, Monetary System, Paper Currency etc) It is because for all these Allah subahanu watala'a has given us Perfect Halal Alternatives. Its just the Khilafat is not here for it to Implement. But as you know its all part of Allah Azzawajjal's plan. He's Testing us to be honest. Then why ekse do you think Allah Azzawajjal gave us the story of the People of Cave in Surah Al Kahf? Why did Muhammad ﷺ told us to recite Surah Al Kahf every Friday? Why is Friday day of My congregation for us? Now that is our Protest. Just take a moment back and reflect upon the Qur'aan, you'll see the broader view. If Muslims and Disbelievers have the same System then how do we differ from them? We can come in certain common terms with Some Jews & Christians only. No need just imagine it like this; When Isa alaihisalam & Imam Mahdi comes will we Muslims do the same? No we'll do Bai'yah and follow our Leader. Khilafat will only be restored then. Until there's much have got to do. There isn't going to be Eternal Peace in this Dunya! Only for few decades when Isa Ibn Mariyam Alaihisalam Rules the World there will be Justice & Harmony in the Worls. Now that's just before the End of the World. Amidst this confusion & chaos many of us are forgetting our True Purpose, Obligations, Meaning of Life. Allah will not change our Condition until we chabge Ourselves. Read, Reflect and Ponder upon the Qur'aan my beloved. It is the only source of True Guidance and Inner Peace. Listen to the Beautiful Qirat of the Qur'aan Al Kareem. Follow the Sunnah maximum, Stay Humble, Be Grateful everything Allah has blessed you with. Now that's how we Protest. Instead of hiding & confining our Deen and Akhkaq show it, live it. Attaing Paradise is True Success not the Enjoyment in this Deluded Life. May Allah subahanu watala'a Forgive and have Mercy on my Ummah. Aameen:)

[@arnoldinho7217]

If the ignorant people just held their tongue their wouldn't be so much fitnah. I hope you know that the tongue will be the reason for many a people to be thrown upon their faces into the Hell fire. Be mindful of what you call to.

[@rshikanga]

Who else clicked on this video after George Floyd protests

[@حمزةقشلان]

Me

[@salimhayman8948]

Every Muslim should protest against Happy new year event all through the world .

[@dahliademyan8207]

Sorry how is it weak? Protesting for Palestine actually changed a lot of people’s minds and politicians in my country actually are trying to make bills to stop support for Israel which they never did before until now. All the protest have changed people’s minds and even Israelis came to ours.

[@mailman8042]

Protesting was a western ideology Muslims just adopted it Most peaceful protest can turn into violent protests and lots of free mixing goes on in these protests You can instead use social media to raise awareness for Palestine.

[@truth4004]

Sorry but people would have no rights if they didn't PEACEFULLY protest. It's not enough for just one person to do. Why should we be afraid to die if fighting oppression? The right to assemble peacefully is part of the constitution of America. one voice is great but it has to have lots of people backing it.

[@yasinfazley8313]

the prophet was terrorised by the people of Makkah not once did he do a protest against them and Allah granted him victory

[@shuaibanas1880]

After Umar bn khattab converted to Islam command Muslims to protest against the makka leaders?

[@Callingoutdeceivers]

Bring the evidence. Islam isn’t based on your opinion.

[@bintkhan2827]

Jazakallahu Khairan for this👍🏼 shares some valuable information ✨

[@saaniyahsajed1932]

Assalamualaikum, I actually watched sh Yasir Qadhi's talk on protests. He really emphasized to take advice from the local shaikh in your area, because each person and even scholars are a product of the culture they were brought up in. Sh Qadhi doesn't disown this shaikhs views on protests being Haram, but instead he emphasizes the history of the results of protesting, such as civil rights, women's suffrage, etc. Protesting in itself is a way to show authority that there is something wrong and to give reason for change, given the numerous amounts of people that show up at rallies. Thus it is charged to say that protests are Haram , but Allah swt knows best. Please do not attack me, I am also learning.

[@thamoza88]

that's true syakh...

[@tejasKadam-ut3jz]

So protesting haram or halal?

[@lazna2423]

Assalamu Alaykum! It's not very Islamic to protest because it brings more fitna and nothing good ever comes out of it so it is categorised as haram by scholars i think. It was also never done by the prophet SAW, the sahabas RA or the taabi iin and they were the ones who faced the most injustice. And Allah knows best. I also think you should also do own research on it if you want. May Allah guide us to the right path.

[@mwanjatmugambe3015]

I really don't understand what this sheikh is saying 🙄🙄now what is to protest? And what did Rasool mean in removing it with your hands? I don't even know what to say but am not satisfied with this lecture

[@arnoldinho7217]

Removing something with your hand is for the one in authority. E.g. a husband and father is obliged to remove the munkar and haram things brought in his house by his wife and children or other family members. Stopping people from selling alcohol in the shops in a Muslim land is obviously for the muslim leader who has authority to handle such an issue and not for the vigilante to go and break the bottles in the shop. Such an action might get him beaten or even killed. And as for speaking up against evil, it follows the above mentioned principles. Only those in a position of authority, depending on the situation, should speak out.

[@semirla]

Protesters spoke with their Activist/leaders and politicians heard their message ... So protest/marching is not looting, looting is not allowed by the law or religion. It is a big subject but generalizing protest/marching and giving Fatwa with mostly opinionated explanation is not acceptable. You scholars shouldn't rush to give answers before giving a lot of religious though on a subject matter ... just my opinion too.. Allah knows best

[@arnoldinho7217]

Keep your opinion in the garbage bin. When we talk about the deen we return to the real scholars and Khalid Yaseen is far from being a scholar. Go learn the language of the Quran.

[@falaahblackwell1535]

2023The Muslims walking to the White House protesting against whats happening to Muslims in Ghaza by the Israeli army, supported by United States

[@loveeaddictt]

@LaDyErOtICaa What kind of username u hav please change your username or don't comment on Islamic videos

[@Blueli0nesss]

But in his recent video, he is saying something else.

[@rafsanjanidenisaputraprata9062]

Share the link akhy

[@Whichofthefavors]

What is he saying? I seen the latest video and he is not saying the opposite of what he is saying here 🙄.

[@mbarakjabry7634]

You are translating hadith on your own way

[@mbarakjabry7634]

So r u telling us we shouldn't protest just because police will catch us?

[@ragenFOX]

@ctrlaltdelete321 if they were the #1 backer of palestine, why did they deny the Palestinian state?

[@johnwaynepresley]

if only the capital rioters saw this. lol. pictures of iris. SO TRUE!

[@cima5878]

This was 9 yrs ago or so...What are Khalid views on the issue now! Bc I have heard him change his town somewhat on certain issues...Anyway his explanation on speaking out, saying the Prophet meant choosing a representative, that is only his interpretation, the Prophet's words show no such thing....This was obviously the najdi understanding he was propagating at the time, I would be interested if he unquestionably follow their opinions today.

[@lucidniprogramer589]

By najdi, surely you mean the understanding of the salaf.

[@ibrahimabdullahi2910]

The secret service all true

[@ctrlaltdelete321]

@thamoza88 its still 1000 better than the monarchists that go clubbing and gambling. Give Iran credit for at least trying while the arabs were sleeping

[@cheapache9778]

Credit for what, for cursing the Sahabiyun, for praying to the graves, to giving their Imams qualities which belongs to Allah alone, for spreading shiism, to support Bashar for killing muslims, to make muta, to lie about our Prophet, to curse his beloved wife,...

[@محمدأبوبكر-ج4ف]

@@cheapache9778 Barak allah fik you said it all may allah curse be upon the rawafid

[@randomjoy8411]

Disappointing analysis.

[@minasid95]

People are marching for Palestinians right now. These are peaceful protests. People are also turning towards Islam. Is this not okay? All leaders are turning their back towards the Palestinians and our Muslim brothers. What should these people do instead to remove the people in power? Please do let me know. @IslamNetVideo

[@60yearoldcyclist17]

I disagree

[@berikbolsadybay9294]

👎👎👎