Is it Haram To Participate in Protests? | Ask Shaykh YQ #23

[@shamni]

Being an Indian, We can't allow CAA and NRC done... It's the matter of Nationality. Its our responsibility to protest against their decision to make them rethink about their act. If we stay calm at our homes things gonna be wrong. So pls pray for us to succeed in our efforts. May Allah help us all. Ameen

[@salmanhusainjabri]

Absolutely

[@rohanysaed7551]

As’Salaamu alaykum Dr. Yasir, I love your lectures. I benefited so much from you. I pray asking allah swt to protect you from all the jealousy and evils people. May you continue to success.

[@AndroidAndPCChannel]

Protest are haram

[@ziasmailbox]

@Hamid Hussein There are shuyookh who are ihkwani, deobandi, khariji, and hizbi in arab too... I m not talking about them. When I mean shuyookh i only mean the ones who are full of wisdom (and not all).. for example.. shaikh ibn baz has massive book of fatwa on protest (I have read the brief of it).. and Wallahi it underlines step by step mishaps that can happen while protest.. and from among them all of which i witnessed in the indian protest step by step happening one after other.. I was taken aback That ibn Baaz rahimahullah had such an insight about protests.

[@ziasmailbox]

@Hamid Hussein just as you said they pretend to be salafis.. .that is how they also pretend to be madkhali...(make a group).. but among the scholars whose names are taken for groupism there is no difference between them.for us salafis we are Wahab,i madhkhali, bukhari maliki, hanbali, albaniyan, fawzaani .. and all of the strands which comes from salafi scholars... and no scholar is protected from minor mistakes... and all of the scholars who have sanad to Rasulullah sallahualaihiwasallam and upon whom senior scholars have witnessed good are our scholars.. and hibiyaah is the thing against which salafi scholars have spoken a lot.. the SPUBS case is a fine example.. scholars don't approve of them

[@ziasmailbox]

@Hamid Hussein I will see the link.. JazakAllah khair

[@ushna.shahab]

Ameen

[@athrai]

FANTASTIC, time to time Rulers used religious leaders for their own sake , current time is is no different so how a layman will practice الأمر بالمعروف والنهي عن المنكر

[@AbdulKarim-fu5er]

Very true, in today's Indian situation, I don't know any other thing having an impact other than peaceful protest.

[@whitefriday2585]

Jihad, maybe?

[@khamzibchimagomedov7240]

Well explained ya shaykh. Jazaka Allahu khayran

[@nom211]

What is Fatwa, I am confused. I thought Fatwa is legal ruling which should be agreed by number of scholars backed by some evidence. I listened to Sheikh Asim on matter of protest, and I think it is just an opinion

[@aimanroslan7734]

Does anyone have any reference regarding the protest by Muslims in Baghdad upon Jerusalem being conquered by the Crusaders?

[@stevenv6463]

It was fifth or later crusade I think. The ruler literally gave the crusaders Jerusalem and people were very upset. Though the agreement gave the crusaders such limited power that they lost it after their agreement ended.

[@nusrathjahanjameel350]

Brother, Jazak'Allahukhairan kaseera! For playing a great role in helping kashmiris!

[@thundafundamentalist]

Kashmir is free now due to the efforts of the Shaykh. Yes? www.ikhwanis.com

[@salahg6106]

@@thundafundamentalist, are you a murjiyah?

[@RIPer-rg2cz]

Leave it to the Salafis to make anything haram as long as making it haram makes the religion difficult

[@in0711]

Jazakallahu khairan Shaykh. This series is so beneficial for us. Please also do the topic "wiping over the socks" regarding usual over the ankle cotton socks one wears in the western countries.

[@athrai]

I like to hear speech on Battle of Camel and Battle of siffin , this two events are very important and catastrophic.

[@j_gh812]

What makes this events very important to u?can u be specific n clarify your self?I already know who u are and where you are heading...come to the table now pls...

[@cerealman4842]

Protesting to support Palestine is not haram

[@adnanbipu5610]

It his been narrated through a different chain of transmitters, on the authority of Hudhaifa b. al-Yaman who said: Messenger of Allah, no doubt, we had an evil time (i. e. the days of Jahiliyya or ignorance) and God brought us a good time (i. e. Islamic period) through which we are now living Will there be a bad time after this good time? He (the Holy Prophet) said: Yes. I said: Will there be a good time after this bad time? He said: Yes. I said: Will there be a bad time after good time? He said: Yes. I said: How? Whereupon he said: There will be leaders who will not be led by my guidance and who will not adopt my ways? There will be among them men who will have the hearts of devils in the bodies of human beings. I said: What should I do. Messenger of Allah, if I (happen) to live in that time? He replied: You will listen to the Amir and carry out his orders; even if your back is flogged and your wealth is snatched, you should listen and obey. وَحَدَّثَنِي مُحَمَّدُ بْنُ سَهْلِ بْنِ عَسْكَرٍ التَّمِيمِيُّ، حَدَّثَنَا يَحْيَى بْنُ حَسَّانَ، ح وَحَدَّثَنَا عَبْدُ اللَّهِ بْنُ عَبْدِ الرَّحْمَنِ الدَّارِمِيُّ، أَخْبَرَنَا يَحْيَى، - وَهُوَ ابْنُ حَسَّانَ - حَدَّثَنَا مُعَاوِيَةُ، - يَعْنِي ابْنَ سَلاَّمٍ - حَدَّثَنَا زَيْدُ بْنُ سَلاَّمٍ، عَنْ أَبِي سَلاَّمٍ، قَالَ قَالَ حُذَيْفَةُ بْنُ الْيَمَانِ قُلْتُ يَا رَسُولَ اللَّهِ إِنَّا كُنَّا بِشَرٍّ فَجَاءَ اللَّهُ بِخَيْرٍ فَنَحْنُ فِيهِ فَهَلْ مِنْ وَرَاءِ هَذَا الْخَيْرِ شَرٌّ قَالَ نَعَمْ ‏.‏ قُلْتُ هَلْ وَرَاءَ ذَلِكَ الشَّرِّ خَيْرٌ قَالَ ‏"‏ نَعَمْ ‏"‏ ‏.‏ قُلْتُ فَهَلْ وَرَاءَ ذَلِكَ الْخَيْرِ شَرٌّ قَالَ ‏"‏ نَعَمْ ‏"‏ ‏.‏ قُلْتُ كَيْفَ قَالَ ‏"‏ يَكُونُ بَعْدِي أَئِمَّةٌ لاَ يَهْتَدُونَ بِهُدَاىَ وَلاَ يَسْتَنُّونَ بِسُنَّتِي وَسَيَقُومُ فِيهِمْ رِجَالٌ قُلُوبُهُمْ قُلُوبُ الشَّيَاطِينِ فِي جُثْمَانِ إِنْسٍ ‏"‏ ‏.‏ قَالَ قُلْتُ كَيْفَ أَصْنَعُ يَا رَسُولَ اللَّهِ إِنْ أَدْرَكْتُ ذَلِكَ قَالَ ‏"‏ تَسْمَعُ وَتُطِيعُ لِلأَمِيرِ وَإِنْ ضُرِبَ ظَهْرُكَ وَأُخِذَ مَالُكَ فَاسْمَعْ وَأَطِعْ ‏"‏ ‏.‏

[@user-pe1fz8cf1b]

who’s the reciter that’s the beginning

[@recitationtohear]

Hazza balushi

[@salmanM34]

Link is in the description.

[@SimbaLSG]

I feel like he wants to say things but is fearful of saying them because of the consequences. Say it as it is MBS and Saudia! We all know but we’re all playing ignorant and living in the clouds. This ummah is one body and this body today is weak and ill. Not saying what needs to be said and being silent is wrong. When your silent against the oppressors it is unjustifiable to the oppressed.

[@j_gh812]

Brother Yasir qadhi...I'm a Sunni..Ahlisunna waljamaa...but u mentioned an example of protest in the bettle of Jamal.....a very wrong and in wise example....what was the out come of battle of Jamal?this is exactly what sheikh Asim was trying to tell us...... protest ends up in cheos like the exampla u gave of battle of Jamal....just because sheikh Asim is a wahbi or salafi....we don't have always to argue and be different...this is y we Muslims are split.....I would rather advice u all our sheikhs..when u have a difference of opinion....contact each other n sort issues out instead of coming out publicly and criticize each other and create more rifts among Muslims...sheikh Asim gave many example and hadiths in his speech....u did non of that.. when will u our sheikhs realise we need unity? subhanallah...may Allah guide u all.........another example is battle of siffin....the outcome was hurendous.... horrific.....as we all know....the issue of karbalaa,..the same out come...so by facts and evidences.... protests have always had a negative impact n so being it called Haram...I think it's just openly very right......and our current evidence of Syria...Yemen.. libya.etc...proves even more that protest are unlowful and has bad outcome.......in the event of hudaibiya...Allah prohibited the army of mighty Muslims to enter Makkah..just because their were a few hidden Muslims in Makkah that would be harmed...another proof that killing of inocent is Haram even when u are at right and in power....may Allah guide us all and unite us bi idhnillah

[@serkankoldere]

Not all protests end in chaos and war. What about the peaceful protests?

[@anasahmad6749]

I agree that protests may end up in chaos. But HARAAM. Sir that is a big word.-And obviously the companions were far more conscious of this than us. And obviously you get what I am trying to say. Is it right to see injustice being done to you and your people? Does Islam allow us to think only about ourselves only and Not the Ummah, the oppressed. I think you got it wrong somewhere. Chaos is Not haraam man... Please correct if I am wrong

[@nusrathjahanjameel350]

Assalamualaikum wa rahmatullah wa barakatuh Masha'Allah brother, I love your answer, a perfect answer!

[@wasiuadekoya4127]

Ma sha Allah! Very cerebral response. May Allah preserve you on good. Barakallahu fiikum shaykuna

[@Gog3453]

Commanding the right and forbidding the wrong 😑 is to protest

[@ibrahimkb8684]

Are the runes haram

[@sologamer8287]

What’s that

[@Saad4k]

JazakAllah khair!

[@e.k874]

So Malcolm X and Muhammad ALi are sinful for protesting for civil rights ... Man some of these Imams / Sheikhs have small brains

[@is-haq4637]

No, you have small brain to think Muhammad Ali and Malcolm X have more knowledge than these edicated sheikhs.

[@e.k874]

@@is-haq4637 Malcolm and Muhammad Ali had 10x a bigger impact on muslims in North America. if it weren't for there hard work us muslims in north America things would be a lot different

[@e.k874]

@@is-haq4637 So tell me what should the palestinan and Kashmiris do not protest just give up and die?

[@kokksesos2699]

wake up, we follow the Quran and the sunnah, not Malcom X and Muhammad Ali

[@e.k874]

@@kokksesos2699 no matter what u say Malcom X and Muhammad Ali are amongst the most important muslim in recent history Do you actually believe protests are sinful ?

[@usamamuta-ali9905]

There are no scholars that live in North America. So who do we go to for our Fatwas..?

[@jeremyh9213]

I’m not sure why he wants to protest so bad...btw Modi is still in power...the rape of Kashmir still happened...that protest was a waste of time...so how does all this fit in to the current situation with riots and looting? It’s better to avoid protests all together and effect change through other means. The non-muslim Americans are not our teachers. We’re better off giving dawah to them. And Allah knows best.

[@tahir9591]

I don't know how you arrived at that conclusion in your first sentence. Nothing in this video indicated that he wants to protest so bad.

[@jeremyh9213]

Mostly based on history, videos, and other writings all together...

[@AbuYacob]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/bWPSmIRpp5eLsM0

[@katipati2847]

Wallahi I agree with all what the scholar said who you are complaining about!

[@adnanbipu5610]

I respect YQ's Opinion. But problem is if we start to take fatwas on the basis of different regions, then the fitna will increase most likely. Another thing is, he said, no explicit mention about the prohibition of protest in holy Quran but didn’t talk about any sahih hadiths. That's really surprising. I hope he'll discuss about the hadith of sahih muslim, book 33, hadith, 82

[@drifterak288]

Ok than come to india and sit down side of modi and obey his teaching against your religious.

[@drifterak288]

And if any other Muslim ask you why you are doing it show them this sahih hadiths .. because you are the only knowledgeable of this man kind hood right now. And the mufti's of india are dumbs. Follow the saudi law

[@adnanbipu5610]

@@drifterak288 well, explain what the hadith said If you're a muslim.

[@muntasifsusmit]

@@adnanbipu5610 even with that hadith that apply to muslim khalifas not bedouin oppressive zionist regimes

[@bennoah5499]

The hadith has unauthentic additional phrase according to many scholars of hadith. That is the phrase "even if your back is flogged and your wealth is snatched". Without it, when addition to other hadith saying "Don't be Oppressed and Do not Oppress"

[@thatmuslimguy6495]

He is speaking of ibn uthaymeen right?

[@yosuf815]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/qnm5n3toat-Eppo

[@Demlab11]

The example you brought in the beginning of the video about the drunkered does not change the fact that Alcohol is Haram.

[@yusufadedokun3193]

Yes that's true, but he did not say it is allowed. He just brought the scenario to teach a way to correct people

[@yeasiraman2474]

I came to seek knowledge but i saw a woman and heard music through the ads. Now tell me who is sinful?

[@taymiyya1399]

No Fatwa is a fatwa unless there is an opinion of the Shaykh al Islam Taqiudeen ibn Taymiyya

[@ImortalFlow]

So many people have died doing these protests.

[@ayyahayoub3375]

many have died fighting for islam as well, if you are on the right side and fighting for the good of humanity is that wrong?

[@tanveersheikh9860]

@@ayyahayoub3375 in case of India the last year protests have resulted in a real chaos ;muslims houses burnt, property charred, innocent muslims butchered while protesters including even pregnant muslim women have been thrown in jails !

[@ayyahayoub3375]

tanveer sheikh yes and hundreds of muslims are being killed in india, their lives shouldn’t be forgotten, but you have to understand that those protests were to help protect the muslims in india.you also need to remember not all protests lead to violence

[@ayyahayoub3375]

tanveer sheikh this was already happening prior to the protests, not as a result of them

[@aldeen9190]

@@ayyahayoub3375 Did u just compare democracy with islam?

[@Gog3453]

Only if it is in accordance to the minhaj (Islam Iman and Ihsan) of the Salaf

[@katipati2847]

Respected Sheikh, why do Muslims should not listen to scholars in far lands? Be honest; it’s the first time I hear such a fatwa. And if you are advocating a notion, it may not be sound unless until you back up your advocacy by sunnah and sharia!

[@muneebalman6777]

Can women involve in protests

[@shaheerbinshafiq7549]

No

[@purple1985purple1985]

Yes. Dressed appropriately..

[@abdulmalik_al-habeshi]

I think I know who sheikh so and so is

[@rockz7772]

Yes assem al Hakeem. Why don’t you go and watch his video on husbands cheating on their wives? He said that wives should become skinnier to prevent their husbands from cheating on them, essentially justifying husbands committing adultery. I am not making this up. Some of his opinions are very interesting to say the least.

[@melekmhiri5588]

@@rockz7772 kzbin.info/www/bejne/h3nSe4Wlf7N-f5I Please watch the whole video and concentrate on his wording, he gave many options depending the situation, which the first is the divorce. And he clearly says that absolutely nothing justifies husbands cheating. In another video he said if a woman has clear evidence that her husband is cheating on her, she has all the right to abstain from sleeping with him.

[@rockz7772]

@@melekmhiri5588 I’ve seen the video akhi don’t do your mental gymnastics to defend him. And it is legit to rebel against the ruler if the ruler is unjust. Husain RA did this and he became a martyr as a result. There is nothing wrong with standing against oppression. In fact it is part of our religion. Assim Al Hakeem wants to keep his job and doesn’t want Saudi to throw him in jail.

[@rockz7772]

@@melekmhiri5588 oh and the woman has the right to divorce him too, not just abstain from sleeping with him

[@siamshikdar]

@@rockz7772 Your knowledge on fiqh is questionable. Do you have any degree on it to justify that your word has impact?

[@xxscar24epicgames21]

sheikh I am new to hearing your lesson, you mention a lot about IT (Ibn Tammiyah); are you yourself wahabi?

[@JaefarSABNW]

Protest sin and even crime, but not losing elections.

[@truthseekerBVC]

Hahahaha that's so on point! 🤣🤣

[@Anwaribnabdulla]

4:35 Does that mean that drinking Alcohol is Halal? You are far away from truth. Islam is based on Quran and Hadith. It is complete.

[@AbuYusha1425]

That’s not at all what he said. Ibn Taymiyyah essentially made an exception for these Mongols who declared themselves to be Muslims saying that there is more benefit of these Mongols are drunk and lying around than if they are sober, killing and raping the innocents of the towns. Additionally, you’re right, Islam is based on Qur’ān and Hadith there is wisdom in the application of it. That’s the point of the Madhabs and scholars. The classical scholars understood and applied Islam better than anyone alive today could.

[@serkankoldere]

You completely misinterpreted what he said.

[@anonymous2150]

You understand nothing what he said. He said if you are a Killer and your drunkness spare thousand peoples life then people should let you drink. It's not halal or haram.if it's haram you will get punished for ur action. But people’s life will be saved.

[@RAMESHKOTIKALAPUDI]

Who decides what’s local? Is the Houston, TX Sheik non-local for Sacramento, CA? Is the Sheik in Mexico local for Hondurus? The random political boundaries set up are valid? Is Sheik in Muscat, Oman is non-local for Abu Dhabi? What if some Sheik comes along in San Francisco and says any meat is okay or gays are okay or khimar is optional and says Sheik in New York is not qualified to criticize him because he does not know the situation on ground in San Francisco? Isn’t the whole point of Islam is to have one set of rules for all?

[@aimz4178]

It's not the same as other fiqh issues that are clear cut in quran and sunnah, for example salah or alcohol. So that's why you will not get a different view about those things because they are fixed. No ulema can change that based on any reasons. But those things that arent clear cut mentioned, like protests, will be treated case by case, as YQ said, on the knowledge of the Ulema, depending on the situation, time and region. Its that simple.

[@RAMESHKOTIKALAPUDI]

@@aimz4178 It may look very clear cut to you. But you’ll be surprised. You can hear differences of opinion on issues as high and supposedly clear as interest (riba). Not that long ago there seems to have been unanimous consensus in ulema on anything to do with riba is haram. You hear sheiks in non-muslim countries nowadays, you can clearly see this issue is treated as “local” by them. Interestingly any sheik that faithfully follows the older opinion is slowly falling out of favor of their own community.

[@Sam-ng3of]

Link in bio to into reciter doesn;t work

[@mustafamistry4966]

I'm so glad that you have come up and speak about this issue becouse I was listening to the sheikh and my husband was just coming from work and he aske me to put my head phone on becouse he did want to listen to what sheikh was saying, but Alhamdulillah now i kow my husband was right.

[@j_gh812]

Your husband is just one of those who take sects..so as soon as he knows the speech is from another sect..then it's just wrong...we Muslims look on evidence not who is the speaker...apart from shias of course......I'm a Sunni..but I agree with sheikh Asim from evidence he gave and what we see currently in our own current world...

[@abdelhakyac7285]

THANK YOU A LOT JAZAKA ALLAH

[@AuraBreezeOfficial]

Is the protest haram

[@pursueexcellence7737]

Keyword: Peaceful

[@manwithironfist267]

When you speak sir yasir qadhi please take a pause after comma and full stop Reduce your speed

[@saaniyahsajed1932]

You can change playback speed of the video

[@aminelmessaoudi1107]

Salam alaykum. The video ended and I'm still waiting for a hadith or ayah to be mentioned. The only "substantial" thing I heart is the "protest" that was made to make justice for Uthman radiya Allah 3anhu and what a bad example, that ended up in war. One of the dangers of protesting is having enemies such as the khawarij infiltrating and easily starting a violent conflict.

[@chemashud4948]

Asalamu alaykum warhmatullah wabarakatuh, Yasir Qadhi Isn't a scholar he is a Hizbi ! I advice you to listen and read what the great scholars of our time said about protests ! The scholar Ali Ferkous even wrote a book about it with evidence of the quran and sunnah that it is forbidden You can also find some answers of the scholars like Sheikh al albani, Sheikh al fawzaan, Sheikh al sheikh, etc

[@salahg6106]

@@chemashud4948, so what is the solution??? you ppl are just helping the oppressors by giving such fatwas, By the way, your "fatwas" didn’t work for last 100 years, Just seat in your home & making dua didn’t do anything good, need to be activists...

[@chemashud4948]

@@salahg6106 Akhy do you think you know better than allah and his rasoel ? You know better than the sahabas ? When Allah decide something you fellow it and dont try to use your logic ! And if you talk about history look at what protesting did the last 100 years ! It destroyed cities ... people died Muslim blood was dropped ! Allah said in the quran:"If you don't know ask the people of knowledge(scholars)" They gave all the same fatwa even the salafs .. protesting and demostration are forbidden

[@salahg6106]

@@chemashud4948, I asked you what good your dua & "fatwas" did for this Ummah for last 100 years??? Bcz of ppl like you the oppressors got more power & justification to do whatever they want, & they think it's legal to oppress ppl bcz of your "fatwas", & don't always try to pretend like a follower of Salaf, I'm a follower of Salaf & I asked you to show me one hadith that said protesting is haram...

[@salahg6106]

@@chemashud4948, are you serious!!?, ppl protested bcz of bloodshed against them. Rasul(pbuh) said speaking truth in front of oppressors is the best Jihad. your sheikhs don't know that hadith???

[@Islam-q9n]

MashaAllah.

[@FarhodiOktam]

mashallah

[@t96zafar]

❤ 🇮🇳

[@farrukhabidi2764]

This person is not a scholar. He cut short his beard and prophet sallallaho alaihi wasallam prohibited to cut beard, such person who shorten his beard less than one fist is considered faasiq. Talk ill about scholars. The person who can not even make his face like the face of prophet sallallaho alaihi wasallam is not deserved to be called scholar at all, listening and following such person will take to mess up your eiman. Don't try to learn Islam from this person, learn Islam only and only by qualified and pious scholars

[@gingerbread7778]

If you’re brainwashed just say that

[@farrukhabidi2764]

@@gingerbread7778 And for you? Do you get revelation from Allah about who is a scholar and who is not?

[@RIPer-rg2cz]

@@farrukhabidi2764 don't bother. He's a salafi. For context, they ignore everyone from the actual salafs to Ibn Abdul Wahab while trying to nitpick knowledge from Ibn Taymiya and Ibn Bin Bas and another scholar I can't remember. They believe anyone who follows other opinions than their own (including the opinion of the four great imams) are deviants, misguided and even kafirs in some cases. These people are arrogant, blind and ignorant most of the times and love to call people who follow other opinions in very arrogant and disgusting ways. Arguing with these people is like trying to debate against a stubborn manchild with autism.

[@franklopez861]

HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA. How many people have converted on your hands? Masha Allah this sheikh has brought us all closer to Islem except for you because you're a ghasheeeeeemmmmm!

[@farrukhabidi2764]

Do you need revelation from Allah to know if the person is scholar or not?

[@tamannanaima2076]

Very lame explanation.