What Have We Learned? w/ Mouin Rabbani

[@charliedw100]

Mouin is brilliant. I never pass up a chance to hear him speak.

[@dalvinderbasi3495]

I agree, he is quite exceptional.

[@sarahweaver8879]

YES!!!!!

[@rozalialuks6583]

I AGREE!

[@feralLove]

Me too!! I love how calm, cool and collected he is, and the super smart part to!!

[@Ded_Silu]

Here, here!

[@patriciagroleau3398]

I love Dr Mouin for his intellect and integrity…a great speaker of facts.

[@Peaceandjustice6896]

Mouin Rabbani speaks the truth with such clarity.

[@Marius_vanderLubbe]

So glad Mouin said what he did about the dog wagging the tail. There is continued debate about this online. I agree with him.

[@cedcol356]

Not really a "debate". Just opportunists giving their "analysis". Like Lowkey and John Mearsheimer who push the Israel lobby nonsense

[@erick.liebler6470]

I don't think I'll see this on CNN.

[@MrElOuargui83]

Thank you for a great interview. Long live Palestine 🇵🇸✌️

[@robertkelly5658]

🌬🇵🇸✊🇵🇸✌🇵🇸✊🇵🇸✌💞🕊🕊

[@ruthokelley5833]

I have come to the same conclusion that Israel, ‘has gone off the deep end.’ A person cannot follow this war closely for a year and conclude otherwise. The horror of that knowing is watching thousands of people being destroyed and those left standing, living in tents and starving in concrete rubble. Watching with heartache from afar.

[@nathanperkins5353]

I like Mouin's style.

[@kathleentrinity7367]

Today's discussion was excellent. I'm glad Mouin addressed the issue of some blaming Gaza for all the excesses of this war. I'm also glad he stated Israel's exclusivity that is at the heart of the expulsions of Palestinians from their homes. A number of people keep saying the Palestinians want to destroy Israel and take all of Palestine. I think this might be true of a relatve few, but that most want the right of return or to just be left alone and not conized any further.

[@AcaveAtiger]

Mouin Rabbaniji, Great Soul. You have made another Great Soul smile from his eternal and blessed grave. May the peace and love of your God go with you. ❤❤❤

[@rozalialuks6583]

#LONGLIVERESISTANCE EXCELENT. Thank you both!

[@peacenow6618]

Thank you so much for this video. It was very beneficial. Keep up the Great Work! Much appreciated!

[@annchendoherty9558]

Thanks for sharing this insightful, thorough analysis from Mouin!

[@roisinmalone3015]

From Ireland Thanks

[@melektaylan7696]

Thanks a lot to both of you: Best talk ever!

[@carolcoutinho8777]

VP candidate Waltz stated "Israel’s expansion in the middle east is of utmost importance to the US" during the VP debate. He said the quiet part out loud.

[@pacoshuman7642]

Thank you.

[@dabay200]

Rabbani is absolutely correct - excellent analysis

[@ZeroGods4595]

I'm so sorry for the actions of my country, the US😢😢😢

[@newdawn5212]

Thank you Mouin for your intelligent circumspection, no small feat in our world at present.

[@gyaldo9417]

MOUIN YOU ARE A TREASURE TO THE WORLD! GOD BLESS YOU AND YOUR WORK!

[@AnishaDarsot-lr1wx]

Thank you, Mr. Rabbani for stating the facts without overt emotionalism. You are entirely correct about South Africa. I am sure you are aware of the close ties that existed between apartheid S.A and Israel, to the extent that the two "states" financed each other at the time, albeit more from S.A/ Africa. Research as to the continuation of this "financial" relationship as it CURRENTLY stands, needs to be done.

[@r-Justice1421]

Thank you

[@NV_Out-of-Place]

Thank you very much for sharing this enlightening conversation and accurate analysis. This is a brilliant series, thanks Bassan.

[@peterandjoycevanbreemen600]

Thank you!

[@lulusp1023]

Excellent ❤

[@nksarwath]

❤

[@neha_94]

❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@johnnyandersen-w2m]

🇵🇸✌️❤️

[@deva8347]

👍🏻

[@mozartsbumbumsrus7750]

This talk demonstrates why we must ALL vote against genocide. A vote for Jill Stein is a vote against genocide. The Trump/Harris duopoly that supports Wall Street and forever war. WAKE UP ! Vote for Jill Stein!

[@PaoloRiveraPinelli]

Every one with interest and conscience around the world knows you are right but unfortunately we don't vote in us

[@ruthokelley5833]

My vote was to go to her…but the horror of a Trump Presidency, sent me other wise. But, I will work toward getting another party like the Green Party, more say and a place in our government. Americans must be tired of being held hostage to TWO choices (that may not stand independent of each other because of lobbyists.) This can’t be accomplished at the last minute. I was left with my anger…in having to use my vote by force.

[@thewordsmithsdaughter]

I do appreciate Mouin’s opinion but I disagree with who is controlling whom. Israel and the US share a symbiotic relationship, and while the US is the superpower, Israel manipulate that to their full advantage. You don’t need to be a superpower when you’ve infiltrated one to do all your heavy lifting.

[@afrusali1412]

So anything after that date will give a voice of confidence.because the 1st Nakba was 1948

[@rodneydunn1419]

My heart goes out to the Palestinians,but where was this outrage when this was happening to black Americans??? We’ve been through hell also 🤔

[@leylamohamed7950]

I completely understand how you feel, and I'm so sorry.

[@rodneydunn1419]

@@leylamohamed7950 thanks👊🏾

[@afrusali1412]

So this means a real life modern warfare game was played on Palestinian children.😮

[@afrusali1412]

So what does. ICJ ICC OR ANYONE WHO CAN UNDERSTAND THIS THINKING NOW?

[@afrusali1412]

Doctors have said that they whiteness there were no Hamas militants there through their time there.and it’s been a year?😮

[@llukyman5588]

Soon west international law will be gay for everyone as they wanted Africa leaders to accept gay in Africa, what shame

[@WeiShihong]

What does someone being gay change in your life?

[@afrusali1412]

Feels like ZIONISM is a new word they are hiding behind.for another chapter.just like HOLLYWOOD 😮

[@ABCXYZ-jk8me]

BIBLE

[@ronstasYoutube]

Quit jinxing it jfc...

[@ia1530]

Facts about postwar Europe do not agree with your argument that “There would not have been peace if particular regimes had not been dismantled…”. What regimes are you referring to? Are you familiar with the cases of Spain, Italy, Portugal, Greece, to name a few? Or perhaps, you mean peace at any expense. People in those countries disagree with you. You bought into the metanarrative, the fabricated Cold War. V

[@Jean-rg4sp]

4:16 I do not know what Mouin Rabbani means by this remark. Really, there was only one regime that needed to be dismantled for there to be peace in Europe after WWII. This was the Third Reich which was changed into two states with the biggest part in the south and west morphing into the capitalist Bundesrepublik Deutschland, pardoning almost all Nazis and continuing its hostility toward the Soviet Union, handing over the judiciary to the former Nazi judges and lawyers, putting former Gestapo officers in charge of the new security forces and changing the military into an American style look and discipline led by former Nazi officers. Then there was the smaller eastern Deutsche Demokratische Republik which was socialist but completely renewing the judiciary and no Nazis were permitted to have any social leadership roles, retaining the true German military Prussian discipline but anti-fascist in its leadership. Apart from Germany, no other regime needed to be dismantled once the Third Reich was gone.

[@ia1530]

@@Jean-rg4sp Points well taken and I agree with some of your remarks on Germany and the accommodation of the former Nazis in the postwar order. However, you left out unaddressed the critical point of my initial comments I singled out Spain, Portugal, Greece, and Italy. You do not include them in your comments. Any reason? Include them and try to rethink the Cold War in that framework. After all, these were the countries that housed the key military bases throughout the Cold War.

[@Jean-rg4sp]

@@ia1530 My comment was already more than twice as long as yours and this is KZbin. I could have written much more but I am cognisant of the need to be brief. You went on to mention several countries and the Cold War and I thought this expansion of the topic was unnecessary to question Mouin's odd remark which we both picked up on regarding his claim that it was necessary to have dismantled several European "regimes". He did not mention which countries he had in mind. For this reason I did not speculate about which countries he meant. Your mention of Spain and Portugal does not fit Mouin's comment as these were not dismantled and Spain went on to have the longest and most successful fascist dictatorship in all of Europe, functioning well into Franco's old age and natural death. Spain was not dismantled until it came to apply for membership of the European Economic Community (EEC) in 1986. Both Spain and Portugal applied for membership of the EEC earlier and both were rejected because they were under dictatorships. When Franco died and Portugal gave up its corporatist dictatorship they became eligible to join the EEC, now the European Union. The dismantlement of the Spanish and Portuguese dictatorships came as a result of the desire to join the EEC and was unrelated to the Cold War which you had mentioned. This development also had nothing to do with Mouin's comment whatever was going on in his head.

[@enciam9791]

That remark jumped out to me too. My first impression is that he must be referring to the Axis countries. I.e. the governments of Germany and Austria, German occupied Hungary, France and Poland etc. It only really makes sense as a comparison if you separate anything even tangentially 'communist' or cold war related though as clearly there were numerous conflicts across the continent straight after WW2, admittedly on a regional basis rather than the scale of WW2. To be as charitable as possible, I take his argument to be "without dismantling the Third Reich and the governments they installed and supported, it would not have been possible to de-escalate the conflicts in Europe from WW2 to the post-war order", and his comparison with Israel is "without dismantling the Israeli regime, it won't be possible to de-escalate the conflict from the current situation to a more stable peace". I think that mostly makes sense, although it's stating the obvious and I don't think it's a particularly useful comparison given how easy it is to misinterpret. If his underlying point is that the current structure of Israeli society and political life means that pursuing peace will be virtually impossible because they seem intent on pursuing a regional war of aggression, then I would unfortunately agree.

[@kafiruddinmulhiddeen2386]

lol. What about Islamic values demonstrated on October 7? Do some introspection.