What If Ahsoka went to Mustafar BEFORE Obi Wan?

In this Star Wars What If video, let’s see what would have happened if Ahsoka Tano had gone to Mustfar before Obi Wan Kenobi? How would that change things? Lets find out…
Music Used -- • When life ends, anothe...
Wanna support the channel on Patreon?
/ starwarsquill
Here are the Benefits;
• Early access to FanFictions
• Very early access to Star Wars Lore videos that won’t be uploaded to the main channel for AT LEAST a month :)
• Shoutout in every video I make :)
• As for Pricing, it’s set the minimum amount Patreon allows and all tiers have the same benefits :)
#starwarswhatif

[@OverHeed]

What if Palpatine WAS A GENUINELY NICE POLITICALLY MOTIVATED *NON CORRUPT* Man?

[@starwarsquill]

Then he’d be a Sith similar to Darth Vectivus I suppose haha

[@OverHeed]

True, but maybe you could have plaguis do more?@@starwarsquill

[@starwarsquill]

Yea, I’ll probably make that eventually:) Thanks :)

[@kristiansmuzikants24]

Now THAT is something never seen befpre xD

[@heartwork86]

To play off this..... WHAT IF YODA WAS THE SITH LORD. PRIOR TO THE CLONE WARS, YODA FOUND DARTH PLAGEUIS, AND PLAGY CORRUPTED YODA, WHO THEN TRIED TO MAKE IT LOOK LIKE PAPA PALPS WAS THE SITH

[@SlimGod2662]

Aheoka told Maul to not betray her after giving him a lightsaber but immediately betrays and restrains him

[@joshjohnson2753]

And then he disappears from the story completely lol

[@kpmh2001]

I really like how you managed to somehow go an hour and twenty one minutes of complex planning, detailed explanations, and overall great storytelling before just going full-on unhinged at the end of the video there, that was funny.

[@kasonsmith408]

And this whole time mater yoda just chillin 😒

[@DarthWinterMadness]

That was amazing! The emotions I went through with this feature length video rocked me from tension, sadness, hope then fear and bittersweetness... Those Prequel era What Ifs are my favorite. I can't get enough of them. Cheers from France! 🍻

[@DemonKingRegalia]

Felt so bad for Maul here lol.

[@destinysoblivion3268]

For someone who hasn't been making this type of content for long, youre pretty damn good. Among wll of the "What if?" type channels, you're one of the best. Well detailed with resonsble outcomes and decently lengthy. I am pleased.

[@ericlondon2663]

Loved your take on this "What If". We both know there are a few "their canonical abilities and backstory knowledge fail them so this plot works" moments. In the end my only major complaint is you give Mas Ameda too much credit. The character only had power BECAUSE of Palps, without him he was nothing but a coward.

[@tritonefreeze4058]

Wow. That was one of the most captivating what-if’s I’ve ever heard. God bless you.

[@ericcanup4994]

While good, i will point out one flaw, if they kill sidious, they don't have to worry about much

[@steel58836]

Its a story, best left untold

[@starwarsquill]

Probably lol

[@nopeace3689]

the Jedi did commit treason by asking Anakin to spy on him and killing him without trial.

[@itbeme_bobbybsopinion9637]

Good job man!!!

[@starwarsquill]

Thanks, man :)

[@itbeme_bobbybsopinion9637]

Keep them coming!!!

[@hammygaming8075]

What if anakin had died during the clone wars

[@starwarsquill]

Sidious would be really disappointed :(

[@Dynamiet_gek]

@@starwarsquillthat is unlucky anakin gone that sucks get a new one that sucks more shmi skywalker dead

[@benjaminparker671]

What If Kit Fisto and Mace Windu survived in Revenge Of The Sith

[@starwarsquill]

Thanks for the suggestion, man :)

[@evanlopez4891]

When she left that's when hi fell but is she doesn't leave after she gets framed maybe things turn out different padme was going to die anyways at child birth asoka and anikin where ment for each other it was destiny

[@Senate917]

Ngl you had me on the edge of my seat worried for Padmes safety lol

[@dylanh7600]

Its good but is abit convulted and padme dying was unsessery

[@thetrisdamian]

yea how did the blaster get turned completely around to where it would hit her in the neck?

[@seanprice6049]

What if Qui-Gon-Jin never died?

[@leomichael8068]

I am not sure why or how you would keep Yoda on the sideline!! Kinda ruined this for me

[@starwarsquill]

Well, I wanted to put him in there but since Anakin left Mustafar much earlier here, I figured by the time Yoda arrived to confront Sidious, he’d already be dead. But now that you mention it, I could’ve had Yoda go after Anakin after Sidious died I suppose :/

[@leomichael8068]

@@starwarsquill I do not mean to arm chair QB but I just cannot see any reality that would have him on the sideline the whole time. Even if he was in your Padme angle. I meant no disrespect but I kept thinking…then so and so hears/senses something behind them and hears “f’ed up you have”. To powerful not to be involved. Again not being rude or a jerk

[@Fatherofheroesandheroines]

Looking at this ive often wondered. What if the Jedi tricked Palpatine? Anakin is a double agent and Windu fakes his death. After Anakin is sent to Mustafar he warns a still alive Windu who blocks all communications in and out of Coruscant. Anakin instead of killing the Separatist leaders arrests them and goes back to Coruscant. Palpatine realizes hes been tricked but he cant get off Coruscant. Not sure where it goes from here but thats just the baseline.

[@targaryenbatman5728]

Was kind of hoping organa got to padme’s body and somehow got the twins out

[@Catman580]

This was amazing!

[@starwarsquill]

Glad you enjoyed it :)

[@shadowfast541]

What if anakin dies in the episode jedi crash and at the end of the war ahsoka becomes the emperor's apprentice?

[@starwarsquill]

Thanks for the suggestion, man :)

[@DarthRequis]

This channel is underrated

[@starwarsquill]

I’m glad you liked the video, man :)

[@heyhayhi1]

I wanna know the story of Darth Jar Jar......there is too much potential there for whacky Sith hijinks 😅

[@philliplahm6264]

What if Count dooku stayed on the light side

[@starwarsquill]

That would’ve complicated things for Sidious…I might make a video on that :)

[@Omnipulsar]

What if padme never existed

[@starwarsquill]

That’s an interesting one! Thanks :)

[@alexanderyoutubeplanmyseco2974]

What is the Internets obsession with Darth Jar Jar

[@megawarrior_101]

So Yoda does absolutely nothing?

[@thetrisdamian]

for real 😭😭

[@ZackarySchejbalCODBO2RGM2]

Went to do some death sticks

[@DD99654]

The clones at 53:44 “that’s fkin obi wan Kenobi”

[@enclaveofficerz3245]

take a shot everytime he says mas ameda.

[@johngaines1720]

What if Darth Vader captured Asokah to find a way to make him and palpatine the Father and son as the mortis Gods

[@noah-os5ev]

What if every order 66 survivor survived the reign of the empire like K’Kruhk.

[@RodBlanc]

Ya but the twins. A shot in the neck would most likely still leave the twins alive

[@kierangilchrist5645]

Part 2

[@johngoudie-qz8jh]

Gms haven't learned their lesson

[@Spyro757]

What if Rex did death sticks lol

[@rickyg9200]

Bravo

[@gurnoorgrewal7853]

Where’s Yoda ??????

[@teddyj5187]

What if darth bane was in plagueis then transferred to sidious. Then anakin kills sidious and he takes over anakin.

[@dravenbladesong1]

They coulda saved the twins.

[@michaellindsay22]

From a certain point of view

[@AuoraWolf5911]

If plot holes were fixed

[@phontex]

OK it's time for some serious constructive criticism here. This story started out fairly decent but the back and forth scene cutting was long, drawn out, exhausting, somewhat hard to follow and was enough to give people mental whiplash. I definitely do not recommend doing this again in future stories.

[@AaronDW]

Good story but you give too much details

[@nyaalilith]

No. It's good with the details. Some things don't make any sense to me (Grandmaster Yoda,where is?; Padme Amidala, capable with a gun in her own right, dying like that; etc. But the level of details in the narration can help greatly with immersion and with following the story.

[@Baelfyre]

Details are literally what make good stories.

[@cecilarthurton3795]

what if anakin was born female and what if anakin killed plpatine instead of doku and what if yoda reform the jedi order after the death of gui gon jin

[@evanlopez4891]

Plus with the power of the sharigan all things are possible anikin become the sage of 6 paths pocessing the powers the uchia and senju thats bad asf

[@lordofpain3476]

One little problem with this. The jedi high council DID betray the republic and planned on seizing control of the Senate . The only jedi that didn't commit treason that night was Anakin.

[@spartanxdarth201]

🙄

[@lordofpain3476]

@spartanxdarth201 . Question : Did Windu and the other three have the consent of the Senate to go to the legitimate leader of the Republic's with the intent to assassinate him ? Answer : NO Question : in " Return of the Sith " did Yoda , Obi-Wan and Windu discuss taking control of the Senate ? Answer : yes Question : do those two facts make the jedi traitors to the Republic ? Answer : yes Question : did Anakin obey and follow the orders of the legitimate leader of the Republic ? Answer : yes Therefore everything in my above statement is factually true and correct.

[@ZackarySchejbalCODBO2RGM2]

@@lordofpain3476 But Palpatine did orchestrate the Clone Wars.

[@evanlopez4891]

She only needs to not leave the order

[@Jarikraider]

How would she go to Mustafar if she wasn't canon yet? smh.

[@jediofswtor5738]

Because this is a "what if?" 🤦‍♂️

[@Hunterkiller-wz6yr]

1 good story. 2 Ahsoka doesn't remember the events on mortis or the father because the father had erased her memory and Anakin memory and Obi-Wan's memory before they went back to the regular galaxy. 3 Ahsoka would have never been able to turn Anakin back to the light he would most likely see flashes of memories for him and it would throw him towards the light side a little bit just barely but he would overcome it and embrace the darkness again because that's Anakin's Destiny to always embrace the darkness

[@starwarsquill]

I added the Mortis parts because in Season 6 of the Clone Wars, Yoda asks Anakin about how Obi Wan saw Qui Gon on Mortis and Anakin tells Yoda that Obi Wan believes it to have been a manifestation of Obi Wan’s memories of Qui Gon. So, because of that exchange between Yoda and Anakin I assumed they held their memories of Mortis when they returned :) Edit: Found the video; if you have the time look up the video “Anakin Talks To Yoda About Qui Gon” That’s where Yoda and Anakin talk about Mortis. I could be wrong in my interpretation tho :/ Thanks for pointing it out :)

[@Hunterkiller-wz6yr]

Oh you're good dude don't worry about that this is fine either way this was such a great story I enjoyed it all the way I just thought that I would throw that out there cuz I know there's people that are going to see this and be confused by mortis

[@starwarsquill]

Thanks, man :)

[@surfaceintensity6835]

I disagree with the story of this mainly due to the fact that Ahsoka isn't powerful enough in Anakin's life to actually convince him out of the darkside. I believe that beyond a shadow of a doubt he would kill her before talking this much.

[@Baelfyre]

He wouldn't though. Even when he was fully submerged as Darth Vader in the show Rebels, he still hesitated to attack Ahsoka, and she managed to bring him back for a moment, before he succumbed to the Dark Side again.