What If Anakin Skywalker Actually Killed Obi Wan (Rako Hardeen) In The Clone Wars

[@johnhorton4436]

I cannot Imagine Anakin Getting over something like this if he did

[@MrMasterDebate]

He would blame the Jedi council

[@DragonGoddess18]

​@@MrMasterDebate Well,they did lie to Anakin

[@tailsprowerfan2729]

@@MrMasterDebateeither that or off himself

[@cadeshanley218]

@@tailsprowerfan2729 He still has Padmé.

[@tailsprowerfan2729]

@@cadeshanley218 true but I think him haveing nightmares would make him go even more crazy

[@arcanaido6415]

God I really would just love to see the smile on Palpatine's face when he was told about Anakin trying to kill the entire council, I imagine that the entire senate would just be confused hearing the loudest evil laugh ever.

[@ErtuğrulBeySon]

Same.

[@SWDude2710]

That youngling twist during Order 66 was really unexpected yet surprisingly wholesome for once.

[@captaintitus4637]

Welp palpatine is gonna have a field day isn't he?

[@joekauffman9690]

The Jedi in this would make the sith look like the good guys

[@KingSlayer_.]

If Mace Windu had told him that Obi-wan was still alive and hadn't kept the secret from him, he wouldn't have cut off his hand later on. Windu had every chance to put some trust and respect into Anakin and get him on his side, but his hubris and jealousy got in the way every single time.

[@dikastederook6380]

@@KingSlayer_. Yeah, Anakin isn't blameless but Mace has never been really that great with him and didn't make anything easier or more positive.

[@coisasm3029]

​@@dikastederook6380no anakin is blameless

[@HeLeavesThe99ForYou]

What if Rako Hardeen shot Anakin Skywalker instead of Obi-Wan? What if Anakin was framed for the Jedi temple bombing? What if Obi-Wan stayed with Anakin instead of fighting Grievous?

[@samchanda]

the last one aged well

[@noahsibahi-jackson8757]

Interestingly enough the Jedi are technically bad guys in this senario… had Obiwan actually been killed by Anakin being confused it would have been down to them being ignorant and stupid which is their fault. This is a perfect example of why the Jedi and sith are in a way both bad

[@Demonoicgamer666]

Mace and yoda made the situation like 1,000,000x worse than it could’ve been. Mace lied to him for years yet he has the nerve to blame Anakin.

[@tankenginefanaticstudios]

This is why I hate Mace Windu.

[@megaman37456]

@@tankenginefanaticstudios I hate Mace because he's a hypocritical asshole. The only reason people like his character is because he's played by Samuel L Jackson, not because he's a good person, he isn't. He's the closest thing to a Sith on the Jedi Council as one can get.

[@Zminator1986]

Would like a part two of this. Maybe Ahsoka's perspective.

[@americansyndicalist7602]

Part 2 please. This was awesome!

[@lowlypooch4186]

Darth Vader Any% speedrun

[@thelumious6980]

The one thing I don't like about these sorts of What Ifs is that they never really take into account Padmé and how influential she could have been on Anakin remaining in the Light or seeping into the dark, like in this, Anakin could have thought whilst he listened to Palpatine spew his nonsense "Would Padmé agree with this" because the one thing he never wanted to lose was her.

[@Fridaey13txhOktober]

If Palpatine can influence Anakin, he can certainly influence Padmé albeit subtly.

[@onion4620]

@@Fridaey13txhOktober Anakin acted out of emotion. Padme is a more logical person. It would be hard to manipulate her.

[@satinekenobi4ver855]

@@onion4620 nope Padme is easy to manipulate like Anakin is as palpatine was already manipulating both Padme and Anakin into having a relationship with each and to lie about it and neither padme or Anakin knew it until it was too late.

[@ShinigamiSamaH]

The whole point of the Dark Side is how insidious it is, how difficult it is to remove once it got hold of you. And really, Palpatine just needed to spin the story of how the Jedi prolonging the war by influencing the Senate, and in turn Padme. Anakin would be livid, and all Palpatine need next is make him think "this is what best for Padme" and let the Dark Side do the rest.

[@Nate31891]

What if Anakin killed Sidious and Padme joined him in ruling a new Empire?

[@johnhorton4436]

When his Father Figure is the Highest Ranked Individual in all the Galaxy and its Society and Military he can Give Anakin Practically Anything He Wants Especially in this Scenario where the Council Just Ostracized Anakin for his Relatively Justified Desire to Attack Mace windu

[@MrCadeRay]

Bruh for real He basically said"Ya Anakin you killed Obi Wan, now hurry up and take a seat so we can go over more important things" like wtf

[@tonystank3091]

Not bad for Anakin. He got to have his cake and eat it too this time.

[@simonkendrick3212]

Really enjoyed this one. It’s one what if I’ve always thought of after watching the episode. Good work

[@eidoneverchoosen1171]

A brilliant move by sideous to take advantage of this incident.

[@benjamincoats8301]

It was a great story but I don't think Anakin would just forget about ahsoka I think he would ask palpatine to keep her alive and he would knowing that she would never Go along with all of it and if she did she would be another sith added to their ranks

[@Zeke313_Editz]

This needs a part two *possibly* This was a good one as well. As soon as Anakin gave into his hatred and anger I said: *This is where the fun begins*

[@aarohalme1020]

I like this as a one parter, showing the jedi making an almost hilariously bad blunder basically handing the galaxy to Palpatine on a silver platter, with Padme even trusting Anakin.

[@sebastianwicks1565]

Bro thought Yoda would push Anakin like that Anakin's rage would have been immeasurable and his already faint connection to the dark side would have amplified 100fold therefore temporarily unlocking most if not all his potential in the dark side which would be twice that of yodas and sidious, he would’ve handwaved everyone except yoda and mace while choking mace to death and engaging a duel with Yoda which yoda would be vastly overpowered by the strength and speed of anakins body as skywalker would channel in a huge push back nocking yoda cold stone out

[@cadeshanley218]

That would probably turn him to the Dark Side much sooner. No thanks to the Jedi Council.

[@Intrepid_A]

What if Commander Thorn survived? What if the Coruscant guard had a civil war? When Anakin became a youngling he had no friends, was bullied for his upbringing and spent more time with droids so what if Anakin had a friend, a young nautolan youngling growing up in the temple? We can go down two paths regarding order 66, path 1 Anakin fights and kills his friend in the temple or path 2 Anakin spares him telling him to leave and either ordering the clones to let him go or ensuring that the clones don’t come across the nautolan’s path as he navigates his escape from the temple.

[@shorstka5264]

It was such a powerful story! I haven't seen something like this for a long time. I watched a lot of videos on this channel. All theories are good. Thank you for your efforts!

[@johnhorton4436]

Though I'd imagine He'd probably go to Padme Sometime after he Bursts in on The Jedi Council That is

[@ninjago0o9]

13:30 I love the Revenge of The Sith book reference

[@micahallard426]

The whole things using the book it’s amazing

[@Godzilla00X]

Palpatine using the power of social media! Always enjoy your what ifs

[@korhol2065]

The funny thing that I like about this scenario is that it’s the only one where padme not only lives, but also is willing to go with an empire plan when her thoughts on a Jedi were completely shattered

[@lamaahruloma4270]

This one is the best, please, can you continue or make a longer, newer version? It's fantastic! A next episode or something similar would be great! Greetings from Prague

[@webby8950]

This felt like a happy ending, I love uncle Palps here

[@joshw0805]

Only time I've ever truly thought Anakin was right

[@maxmcintyre5068]

I always thought it was interesting how close the Jedi especially windu was to Darth Sidious without knowing it in these particular episodes

[@no_respect_k_y_s]

lmfao bro would go mad at the jedi for doing such a plan and would go on a killing spree 💀💀💀💀

[@megaman37456]

I like to imagine that if this actually happened, Anakin would've killed the Jedi without so much as a thought, at least the council. Anakin would've said to Palpatine "A greater damage to the Jedi would be to turn future younglings into sith apprentices, why waste potential?" I also like to think Anakin willingly joining Palpatine with minor manipulation in this scenario would make Palpatine mellow out just enough so that he's not mad with power. Palpatine would have all the power he wants. Anakin and Dooku would never want to overthrow him because they got exactly what was promised. Dooku got a new Republic (Empire) where corruption was seemingly gone, and Anakin got to be his own person. I like to think if things went smoothly, Anakin joined willingly, the Jedi completely wiped out under justifiable cause, and Palpatine not getting deformed, he'd actually go from power mad tyrant to "Why did I want this job again?" over the course of like a decade.

[@ENDERDARK0]

È uno dei migliori What If che ho mai visto

[@tysondennis1016]

Anakin: What have I done?!

[@mauricetoyer1844]

Damn, this was a very dark ending. Unfortunately, the jedi were the cause of their own destruction with not telling Anakin the truth. Too bad I just found this video 10 months later😅😅

[@nobbyfirefly57]

0:53 why didn't Palpatine just use that Nanotech after Revenge of the Sith?

[@Godzilla00X]

8:11 Grand Inquisitor?

[@DRAMAGLASSS]

PALPS FINALLY SURVIVED LETS GO

[@ThesonofAJR_edits]

Can you please do What If Anakin Skywalker was King of Naboo and Padme Amidala was a slave on Tatooine aka The Chosen One What if Anakin Skywalker drank from the mystical Well of Urd giving his arm as a sacrifice

[@darthvapor4209]

What if boba suceeded killing windu when anakin and windu were trapped in the bridge of the Venator

[@corylair3947]

This is surprisingly well for the Sith, and you know what’s better someone actually pointed it out and you’ve probably heard this too. If the Sith could actually learn to control themselves and learn to few things, the Jedi taught the Sith would be unstoppable. Yeah, there’s a rule of one rule to, but again, imagine a galaxy where are the Jedi are still Jedi but they’re the threat Mrs. an unknown but dead religion who’ve done a few tuneups the Sith would be unstoppable

[@dianesinger9729]

So sad Anakin killed Obi-Wan like he did. Never did like Anakin being kept in the dark.

[@Itachi_Uchiha7283]

It was stupid on the councils part they know how anakin would have reacted and should have told him after he brought obi wan as raco Hardin into prison explaining that obi wan was alive and they needed anakins reaction to be real anakin likely would be upset but after being told he would calm down and understand and likely add to the plan to seem like anakin was trying to hunt down the bounty hunters and seem like he was still in a rage state the Jedi risked the entire plan they knew how anakin would react but they are so arrogant it made them absolutely stupid

[@JacobHunsickerbailbonds]

what if anakin saw the light side and dark side as both out of balance the dark having power two only 2 not spread out as it was and the light side blind by the light and too condensed and not spread out enough this is what allowed slavery and force the jedi to scatter and opened up a sith academy and trained new dark side users to balance out the dark side and light side

[@jamesstarbuck7262]

My favorite vid you made yet DANG

[@nobbyfirefly57]

You made me cry. Good job.

[@jxdvidz9914]

You should continue this version with what if Asoka reached out to Anakin

[@johnhorton4436]

He can give anakin anything Any Technology He wants to Tinker with to his Liking

[@sn1524]

Atleast Padme wasnt brutally murdered, so this is technically a happy ending for Anakin

[@fkai1]

Let's face it, the Republic and the Jedi order deserves to fall. Rotten to the core

[@MRGaines12YT]

Part 2 please with Ashoka

[@socialaccount0000]

What if Rako Hardeen *actually* killed Obi Wan? Anakin finds Rako in the tavern, arrests him, then what?

[@fulcrumsee5968]

This is like the best case scenario for Anakin. LONG LIVE THE SITH EMPIIIIIIRE!

[@john_1986]

6:40 I don't know if this was intentional, but this part really seems stolen from Star Wars Theory's video "What if Anakin Didn't Take a Seat?" from a couple years back, where Anakin says the exact same thing after being told to take a seat.

[@danielharman572]

Ohhh mannn. I really want to see part 2 if and when you decide to make it and maybe find out if there's potential for a alternative part 2. Like a dark side part 2 & a light side part 2. Anyhow I enjoyed your story very much and I'm giving it a like. So keep up the good work. Kind regards from Daniel Harman.

[@onion4620]

What if Ahsoka leaves the order stumbles on a meeting with Palpatine and Duku and asked to join them?

[@Chlxe16]

What if All of the 501st Clones and 212th Clones died during the battle of Umbara? What if Ashoka died when she got captured? What if Anakin stayed as the chosen one?

[@glacier1253]

A part two would be KILLER! (Hah) Also reiterating my suggestion of: What if Denal killed Cad Bane on Devaron?

[@justsayori3046]

Part 2 Idea: Ahsoka joins the Sith Empire, mirroring the living Force with Palpatine as the Father, Anakin as the Son, and Ahsoka as the Daughter

[@soularprimestudios5930]

Yess....Palpatine would not only have dark power but light too...that's OP

[@wambutu7679]

A part two focused on Ahsoka would be fascinating. Does she try to rebuild the jedi order from the shadows? Essentially a jedi rule of two. Or does she team up with Anikan to take out Sidious? Or something else entirely? Maybe she ends up with the night sisters and fuses their teachings with her jedi background to create something new in the force? Just a thought.

[@benmccoy6417]

This is the desirable end imo

[@ericcrabtree7075]

What if Obi Wan told Anakin he was going undercover as Rakto Hardeen

[@The-Gaming-Chaps]

Love your vids ❤

[@hazat8123]

We need a part 2

[@lightweaver1839]

The thing is Anakin always acks on his emotion and that just should of been anticipated.

[@bigwsly]

Can you do what if anakin turend to the dark side and joined either Dooku or palpatine after he found out obi wan and the council lied to him Also at 2:09 I don’t think he was kicked in the stomach in that scene…

[@CoolThebro]

what if obi wan and qui gon died to maul on naboo

[@catpin]

Can you do What if Darth Tenebrous killed Darth Plagueis?

[@ghostface9171]

What if qui gon was saved by either dooku or palpatine from dying on naboo, presumed dead, but is alive and joined the dark side

[@omacher]

What if Luke fall in love with Qira

[@YayoHernandez-b1j]

happy thanksgiving the Star Wars Galaxy hey a question when you make and release what if Anakin Skywalker was trained by the force itself on that what if he would be a force wielder not a Jedi or sith but something even much more wielding purple and white lightsaber colors which you know the canon in meaning trust me you won't be disappointed besides on that what if he would reach his full potential early quick faster save his mother be with Padme and the rest I we leave it to you ;):)

[@DarthTerminus-wy3gp]

Great story idea and worthy of it's own TV show on Disney plus

[@saveritas731]

Order 66 speedrun.

[@DarthnightKing]

Great work I like it

[@Tea-ke4yv]

Part 2 would be awesome

[@brothers_of_nod]

I felt it would end with a Sith victory, that kind of turmoil in Anakin was sure to be used by Palpatine

[@VersatileElement]

The happier ending of the Empire

[@johnhorton4436]

Is this a Part one

[@victorherman6851]

What if Palatine was a light side Sith?

[@commanderclown8620]

Not a thing.

[@DrSnak3]

@@commanderclown8620 they exist in Legends

[@soren2386]

That was a good story, I liked it

[@iowaredneck9416]

Part 2: Ashoka finds the truth and connects with Padme. Part 3: Luke, Leia, and their master Ashoka defeat Vader. Then Anakin defeats Palpatine and the Republic is restored

[@Achuidian179]

To be fair: Obi Wan was killed by Vader, so it was only bound to happen that in a WHAT IF Anakin Skywalker Walker killed Obi Wan. Feels like there should be a part 2 with Ahsoka and Anakin’s children rebuilding the Jedi Order. Day 19 What if; Anakin never gave into his feelings for Padme, Aayla Secura was the chosen one and became Darth Talon, Shme Skywalker was adopted by the Tusken Raiders, Boba Fett saved his Tusken family, Count Dooku was a regular count for the CIS, Jabba the Hutt supported the Jedi at the Start of the Clone Wars, and finally, what if Sabine and Ezra fell in love?

[@dantheman7t804]

what if Satine survived and went into exile with obi-wan on Tatooine?

[@Jediguardian]

Can we get a part 2 please

[@Jb02a4]

Part two Ashoka trains new jedi

[@zombieslasher134]

What if the council told Anakin of obi wans undercover mission as a sign of trust

[@okidoki444]

What is the music playing in background?

[@shadowkion.]

What if Luke and Leia weren't Force-sensitive?

[@WalterBorges-lz4qi]

Maybe a Part 2

[@onion4620]

What if right before they blow up Alduron princess Leia says father don’t let them…and Darth Vader feels her in the force

[@Dar_ishere]

What if Padme was a Jedi please?

[@TheLostAstronaut98]

Part 2 please!

[@irBribe]

Early squad

[@onion4620]

Freaking awesome

[@Arasael23]

Needs part 2

[@blacklighthologram5339]

When Mace spoke and said Anakin killed Obi Wan it reminded me why I hate him with a passion, Mace was everything wrong with the Jedi he embodied the hypocrisy, pride, militarism and zealotry of the corrupted order.

[@edisonlaw934]

Part when? Ahsoka leading the rebellion against Palpatine's empire

[@kylescanlon9167]

My question is where is Ahsoka

[@philipptodorovski8586]

He would have felt him through the force no?

[@atharvkadiwal2156]

Pleaso dont tell me even fives exexuted order 66 😢

[@padmeSkywalker]

What if the Jedi had rescued Anakins mother from slavery?