What If Anakin Skywalker NEVER Had Nightmares Of Padme Dying

[@MRGaines12YT]

What if anakin became Vader on his own during the clone wars and taught himself the dark side of the force

[@barcabocalda2583]

Yes !!!

[@Jabes_1163]

Got your own idea on how that'd work out for Anakin?

[@TheRebornExpert]

So basically Palpatine wins by doing nothing? Lol. 😅

[@adriandiazrivera8096]

How tho bc anakin isent a master and dosent have dark side holocrons and scrolls to teach himself,maybe be teached by maul or dooku or asajj

[@dhgintercept3622]

@@adriandiazrivera8096 Morris could be involved, rather than him becoming like the father he inherits the sadness from the brother

[@darkbooger]

What if Anakin and Obi Wan secretly ran a ramen shop on the lower levels of Coruscant?

[@NimNenLP]

This is fucking hilarious i am all for itXD

[@iainballas]

this would absolutely make a good april 1st episode

[@leiratno820]

I adore silly ideas like that. "What if Palpatine did death sticks" was amazing and I'm sure this would be too.

[@paulmann8570]

Right across the street from Palpatine's Death Stick Cafe?

[@darkbooger]

@@paulmann8570 At the very least there would be another branch shop there

[@edwardnowakowski5990]

*fight between the strongest force users is happening in front of him* Anakin: “lemme take this call”

[@whitnip7868]

obi-wan: “i’m just worried about you, anakin.” “… what’s that sound?” anakin:”oh just the chancellor and mace and fisto dueling” “they’re WHAT”

[@ScyllaIo]

Just what I was thinking. The placement of this scene just makes no sense. It should have happened after he talks to Sidious and before the Jedi come in.

[@radioactiveassassin5218]

Palpie: Have the jedi told you about your father? Anakin: They told me enough! They told me that I was created by force and have no father! Palpie: No. I am your father! Anakin: What? How can this be? This is outrageous. It's unfair! How can you be my father and not wield the force? That's impossible! NNNNOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! *jumps out the window *

[@whiterabbit3050]

Palpie:oh shit anakin jump off the window💀💀💀

[@littlefoot5013]

This is very well written. While Palpatine used the "The Jedi are planning to take over" and "All who gain power are afraid to lose it". in canon, the Padme route was his main means of getting Anakin. I like here how he's using the Darth Bane story instead. I wonder, though, if in the end, Palaptine's strategy will backfire on him and Anakin will realize that Palpatine is the REAL power-hungry one.

[@Achuidian179]

I absolutely love how you told the tale of Darth Bane instead of Darth Plaguise story!!! Making this story my favorite of your channel from now on (as I love Bane’s story and looking forward to The Acolyte show). Day 63 of my list. What if; Anakin never gave into his feelings for Padme (Pentre Patrol did his version), Aayla Secura was the chosen one and became Darth Talon, Shme Skywalker was adopted by the Tusken Raiders, Boba Fett saved his Tusken family, Count Dooku was a regular count for the CIS, Jabba the Hutt supported the Jedi at the Start of the Clone Wars, and finally, what if Sabine and Ezra fell in love?

[@edwxx20001]

is that last one a what if? it feels like they ARE in love in the Ashoka show, but are both emotionally stunted adults who cant express their feelings.

[@Thaumh]

I like how in this one, Palpy's attempt to win Ani by reveling the Truth "from a certain point of view"™ sealed his own doom.

[@Matt_JJz]

What if events played out as they did but Dooku survived the clone wars, still betrayed by sidious but unable to warn the republic of who sidious was and lived to see the empire rise.

[@dianesinger9729]

He was so close but I am glad Obi-Wan pulled him back

[@Darkdealer651]

little did Anakin know that Palpatine was lying about creating him, and that it was actually Plagueis who inadvertently caused the Force to conceive the Chosen One (at least in Legends)

[@KepaniGrayson]

Love that Anakin chose a better world for his true family.

[@drewhutchison3115]

What if Anakin had nightmares about Order 66 instead of Padme dying?

[@avatarenthusiast2289]

He already did that one.

[@KoRaL-GT]

@@avatarenthusiast2289he already did that one

[@nursestoyland]

I thought this said “what if Anakin had the high ground?”

[@zackcross7190]

Obi-Wan: Oh, think the high ground is your ally? You merely adopted the high ground.

[@supervegito2277]

I remember a fanfic with this premise, but hell, i wanna see your version. What if Vader crashed on Yavin 4 (after the death star battle) and lost 20 years of memory AKA: Clone Wars Anakin wakes up on Yavin 4 in the body, and ship, of Vader.

[@Integrous_Melodies]

Damn, fic link?

[@supervegito2277]

@@Integrous_Melodies I dont remember that one sadly...

[@tobyplays2748]

What If Luke Skywalker traveled back in time to save Padmé Amidala?

[@nursestoyland]

I’d want to know what happens!

[@eereree]

“No, Anakin… I AM your father…”

[@goldenlion1155]

What if Anakin focused on the force instead of being a warrior. So he has a green lightsaber

[@destructiveraider]

I love your spin on this one, thanks for yet another great story.

[@npittswarof2]

The fact that palpatine thought that anakin would save him thinking that anakin saw him as his pops, only for anakin to be thinking about padme is hilarious.

[@ClaudevonRiegan_]

What if Jango Fett was force sensitive

[@alexandernorton693]

What if palpatine used his second saber against windu after losing his first?

[@Metica777]

I cannot watch this right now I will watch on my lunch break but while I enjoy pretty much everything you make some of the times I see the title of some and am like now that is a good one and this one is sounds like a good one.

[@brokenbridge6316]

I get the feeling that had the nightmares not gone through Darth Sidious might've drastically altered his plans at the last minute and tried to get Anakin another way. But still this video was nice to listen too.

[@LivingInTheLifeOfChrist]

God bless you❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@shadowmane43]

What if as the nightmares of Padmes death begins, Anakin start to look for force healing techniques in the archives and finds both force healing techniques in both sides of the force. And by learning light and dark force healing techniques he learns how to heal any living being as long as there is life.

[@wolfspider2034]

What if Anakin turned to the dark side a but earlier like when Palps revealed himself and instead of executing order 66 immediately he used Anakin as an inside guy for a reason..... that I'm sure you can think of

[@floppyinc2968]

Good writing I loved this one!!!

[@thespikedpenguin]

What if Echo never went for the shuttle and escaped the citadel. What if in jedi history there was a jedi on the council who wasn’t a master, and the Jedi used this as a counterpoint to anakins frustration.

[@toddkurzbard]

Ol' Sheev would have succeeded if he had only told Anakin about The Tragedy Of Darth Plageuis The Wise.

[@brynstarkiller7419]

Anakin should never have been told he was the chosen one. He should have been trained and treated like all Padawan’s and Knights. He deserved the rank of master especially considering he had a padawan. He should never have had to bear the weight of that prophecy. If he had stayed in the light he could have reformed the zjefi. Allowing marriage , Jedi parents to live in quarters with their children while they’re trained as Padawans (if force sensitive). Anakin was treated really badly , especially consider his tactical prowess in battles, his leadership and compassion . The guy absolutely ruined separatists in negotiations and battle. The Jedi would have become real protectors. Also a Jedi task force should have gone to Tatooine, arrested all the slavers, freed the slaves and left republic troops and maybe A master and Padawan. They could look out for Shmi and let Anakin know she was ok .

[@zackcross7190]

What if Dooku killed Palpatine while waiting for Anakin and Obi-Wan in the Invisible Hand?

[@sitrukpc1]

What if Anakin used both the light side and dark side of the force to protect the innocent during the war? That could result in him bringing true balance to the force.

[@KRIT_101]

What If Anakin and Obi Wan were still dueling when Palpatine arrived on Mustafar

[@joekauffman9690]

You never disappoint me, this would had prevented Anakin from turning to the dark side of the Jedi kept the nightmares out of Anakins dream, could you also do what if Anakin had quit the Jedi order after not been granted the rank of master, no one has done a video about that and maybe do what if Anakin had turned to the darkside by himself and he taught himself the dark side of the force during the clone wars

[@reckszkingzactivitiesrkat.4134]

Another great story, keep them up 🔥

[@raww_dogg_1876]

Another 🔥 story as usual 😊 I'd really love to see more what ifs involving Plo Koon and Kit Fisto and Ayla Secura and Shak Ti 🙏 😊

[@ElizabethSchmidt-nw9di]

This is a very good question. I agree that Anakin should’ve destroyed this Sith and, yes again, because he made the right choice in this to keep Padme from dying in order to get rid of Palpatine. Whereas in the movie it did not save her which was why he was lured to the dark side and Padme died in child birth.

[@Texascowboy68]

My head cannon is that it was palpy boy who was giving Anakin those nightmares by manipulating the force. But honestly that’s seems like kind of a stretch actually now that I think about it but I wouldn’t put it past him.

[@19TheFallen]

Well, considering that the whole reason he decided to turn to the Dark Side of the Force, join the Sith and become Sidious's lapdog was because he was having those nightmares....Nightmares that were similar to those he was having about his mother before she died in his arms, which *greatly* enhanced his fears that his nightmares about Padme dying would come to pass, because if the ones about his mother proved true, what's to stop them from coming into fruition? Then, he meets with Palpatine, who tells him the Sith knew of a way to stop people from dying, which peaked his interest, he decided to betray the Jedi and the rest went downhill from there......No nightmares, no direct, strong compulsion to betray the Jedi because he doesn't NEED that knowledge, meaning that Palpatine can't weaponize it to draw him in.....Not yet, at least.....So, Palpatine, as Sidious, would need to find an alternative way to pull him down, and a different way to make him move against the Jedi......It wouldn't surprise me if the guy simply had Padme assassinated, and made it look like the Jedi had done it!

[@Tmhjr_Baskar]

More I think on a certain thing, the more often this idea pops into my head. Alas, no long winded, drawn out idea today....yay for those that don't like long messages :-) If Anakin is truly the chosen one, created by the Force, then it's the force that failed him. How's about this? Qui-Gon does NOT discover Anakin. Instead, the Wills hide Anakin's presence (to an extent). Qui-Gon feels something, but he can't pinpoint it...and because of this, even though they're close to meeting one another, they still miss one another. Anakin is being led by the wills to go on his own path, but is still permitted (due to Anakin's strong will/desire to free his mother) to race, but due to the powers that be, there is no intervention by Qui-Gon whatsoever. After the race, the Wills began to visit Anakin in is dreams and set him on a path in the light. As to what this journey entails, that's for you and your team. I just think that for a while the Wills would take responsibility in instilling lessons and traits into him. Maybe even guide him to a Jedi who left the Order and follows a more balanced route. Could discover the Jedi Prophecy is a lie, could change things completely. Would like it to be a good ending, even if there's no Padme due to his upbringing or surroundings. Maybe bring balance for ALL force users...light, dark, sisters, sage's... Just a few ideas.

[@maxmcintyre5068]

Interesting how anakins lightsaber is blue and purple

[@thunderrobots1980s]

ok now you got me interested in a jedi civil war, what if Palpatine was right that half of the jedi did want to take over, and darth plagus was hiding inside the jedi order and was quietly turning jedi to the dark side, an palpatine knew this but didn't know who plagus was and what jedi hadn't been turned , which is why he converts anakin

[@ghostzombie6397]

What if sidious taught Darth Vader everything who knew?

[@ClaudevonRiegan_]

What if Satine embraced the mandalorians warrior ways (Death watch would never break off because satine rules as a warrior) What if Crosshair didn’t want to join the empire, and stayed with the bad batch What if Bode never betrayed Cal

[@ericcrabtree7075]

What if during revenge of the sith Revan spoke to Anakin while waiting in the council chambers

[@marcusisgod2592]

What if yoda decided to swap the masters of ferus olin and anakin. So anakin with siri. Obi with ferus.

[@inductivegrunt94]

What if Anakin humbly declined the offer of being on the Jedi Council? He would believe that only a master should be on the council, and by not being a master Anakin shouldn't be on the council. So Anakin politely refuses with respect to the Jedi traditions.

[@64man100]

What if Anakin Skywalker was raised by Starweirds

[@brianvernon249]

How about a Battle of Malachor story. The mass shadow generator used by the Jedi killed them too, or converted them.

[@Aerrocuda]

What if Dexter Jettster didn’t know about Kamino?

[@mrbeebs44]

Think you could do one about a duo between Kyle Katarn and Dash Rendar?

[@Bwillis2099]

What if Luke Skywalker married palpatine’s secret daughter?

[@tahideeley-king]

No no no anakin was created when plegues and sidious messed up a sith alchemy spell trying to become force diodes ending up to shmi Skywalker

[@chrisbutler170]

What if anakin gets trained by revan

[@klcsdc1]

Honestly, If He Didn't Have Nightmares Of Padme Dying Then It Would Be A Little More Difficult For Sidious To Make Anakin Into Vader

[@cameronclophus7998]

What if Revan returned during The Phantom Menace? What if Satele returned during the Phantom Menace and trained Anakin? What if Satele returned during The Empire Strikes Back and trained Luke? What if Plo Koon was sent to fight Grievous? What if Plo trained Cal?

[@brennanschroeder3010]

I mean, this seems like a forgone conclusion at this point, but: What if Palpatine WAS Anakins father?

[@alixc7575]

What if the Jedi and Sith's roles were reversed in the galaxy? With the sith being more numerous than the Jedi? It'd be interesting if, in this case, the story would be about Palpatine convincing Anakin to come to the light.

[@MichaelDeLaRosa]

Ok Now we need what if palpatine was pregnant ? And birth Darth Hidieous

[@jessesmith5501]

He would have never turned to the darkside because he wouldn’t have wanted the secrets Palps promised to show him ! Palps would have either found a new apprentice or he an Dooku would have continued to try and run the clone wars !

[@Thehang-hm4mm]

What if Anakin Skywalker was raised by general grievous

[@talktothebarrel9333]

I'll throw it up again, What if Padme had give birth and survived before Anakin found out that Sidious was the sith lord and order 66?

[@burp6889]

What if Tup had killed Anakin Skywalker instead of Tiplar when his chip was activated ?

[@DarkWolf9889]

What if darth nihilus took over the galactic empire

[@davidrodrick2109]

What if Anakin jumped in front of Mace, protecting him from Sidious’s first wave of force lightning

[@markstark1007]

*NEW IDEAS:* 1. What If Qui-Gon Jinn found Dagan Gera? 2. What If Padmé Amidala was a Sith Lord?(PART TWO, please do it!) 3. What If Ahsoka killed Rex during Order 66? 4 What If Padmé Amidala went to World Between Worlds?(to met her children or to save Anakin Skywalker) 5. What If Cal Kestis found Yoda on Dagobah?/What If Cal Kestis found Obi-Wan Kenobi on Tatooine? 6. What If Thrawn discovered Luke Skywalker? 7. What If Cal Kestis went back to the time of the High Republic? 8. What If Darth Siduous captured Ezra Bridger & Ahsoka Tano in the World Between Worlds?(In your performance) 9. What If the Galactic Empire had destroyed Courscant instead of Alderaan?

[@nursestoyland]

Why would the empire destroy Coruscant? Do u mean the people rebelling against the empire on Coruscant?

[@markstark1007]

​@@nursestoylandfor example, yes.

[@nursestoyland]

@@markstark1007oh, I thought you meant the empire using the Death Star on Coruscant

[@markstark1007]

@@nursestoyland They could use the Death Star, at least it would explode spectacularly. XD

[@oliverhendrix8176]

I think if Death Star was used to destroy Courscant it would treated as a false flag attack by the Rebels or Separatists. While in reality the attack would have been carried out by the Empire or Vader.

[@snakeplissken2018]

Why is it that one branch of the jedi family tree seem to have all the game changers in it, Yoda, Dukoo,Qui lGon, Obi-Wan. Luke Anikan, Asoka, There are 10s of thousands of jedi but this one branch master apprentice master apprentice seem to be the ones that make the biggest impact good or bad

[@qalexandria]

What if Yoda and Obi-Wan Trained Luke and Leia at Birth

[@zombies4555]

I love what ifs

[@chasetopsecret2018]

What if padme asked anikan to leave the order after killing doku and before the dream

[@burningchihuahua9159]

What if Anakin had the children earlier in the clone wars and Sidious took one of them?

[@lightdragonslayer9630]

What if Anakin never killed the Tusken Raiders after the death of his mother?

[@SeverusSnipe20mm]

What is Anakin was born of the light side instead of Darth Plagious. I think that's why he has so much darkness within him, ye being a slave didn't help him any but I think the main reason for his darkness is being a product of the dark side through Darth Plagious

[@beckywilson1550]

What if the droids rebelled against the cis

[@cronag4172]

What if Anakin lost his sight, instead of his arm?

[@CPUReddragon24]

what if anakin told mace about what happened on tatooine and mace decided to help him

[@jiltedensign7479]

Is the audio broken for anyohe else? EDIT: Nevermind

[@marcusisgod2592]

What if darth vader went to darthomir to learn. New suit or perhaps more unique powers. Resurrect talzin maybe. what if Vokara Che became a mentor to anakin as anakin was being treated for bullying and trauma from being a slave. What if anakin fell in love with luminara unduli, serra keto or bultar swan. What if anakin was taught by agen kolar or sasee tin or adi gallia.

[@JekutusGD]

Wsg bro

[@dragonplayhd2047]

What If R2 didn't stay with the ship on Mustafar?

[@marcusisgod2592]

What if anakin was piloting before attack of the clones and sensed ventress fall to the darkside as her master died and took his ship to the planet to investigate. Perhaps starting a romance as they are very similar in their stories. Also what if ahsoka taught ben skywalker as she saw him as history repeating itself. What if anakin was a jedi watchmen or wayfinder. What if anakin went with kenobi to face maul and savage instead of adi gallia. What if anakin fell in love with luminara or your own version of aayla secura romance. What if oppo rancis trained anakin. What if anakin met and fell in love with ventress just before the clone wars just after her masters death. What if anakin became a jedi sentinel like a watchmen or one of those who find younglings. What if evan piel became a mentor or second master to anakin. Or anakin became a healer either before or after his mother death could be related to his friendship with offee or alternatively what if he was trained by tra sa who taught windu and actually did not forbid attachment as shown by her relationship with tholme , they could become like a pseudo parents to anakin and train him away from the temple in azati martial arts and from trasa the living force as she is a plant lady so imagine anakin controlling plant life.

[@Foreman-pig]

What if Anakin was smart?

[@chasetauscher9544]

What if Anakin Skywalker received his injuries on Mustafar during the beginning of the Clone Wars?

[@XxJxX_1]

where's the sound?

[@rayswiatek5948]

What is yoda had 5 fingers instead of 3?

[@reeceemms1643]

Here are my ideas day 21 of asking: What if Cal and Merrin had a Daughter (Jedi Nightsister hybrid)? What if Padme was enslaved during the clone wars? What if during the rescue of Han Solo Leia failed to kill Jabba and was left behind remaining as a slave? What if Din Djarain and Bo-Katan fell in love during the events of Mando season 3? What if Luke and Leia found out they were siblings earlier (like before Empire strikes back?)? Similar to the previous one, what if Luke and Leia were not separated at brith and were both raised by Owen and Baru? What if Jyn Erso survived and went on to meet and fall in love with Luke Skywalker? What if Ahsoka found Shin Hatie before Baylon Skoll? What if the Aldani Heist went fully according to plan aka the whole payroll was stolen from under the Imperial noses?

[@bigjoem9808]

Ok hear me out. 1. what if obi-wan had nightmares of Satine’s death 2. What if Palpatine accidentally gave the nightmares of Padmé's death to Obi wan or Yoda and not Anakin

[@CCZZ.B]

This story seems all good however, the one thing I would change is that. I don’t believe Seth was ever Anakin’s father I believe if a Sith was to create medical Orion seduce, so I think it would’ve been plague his master because I don’t think would believe that’s worth doing I think he would just believe it’s beneath him

[@karinaromero8612]

day 6 of asking what if anakin faked the execution of order 66

[@DeanSue-see]

What if you did one of these without a happy ending?

[@rodey6416]

What If Darth Bane killed Darth Zannah?

[@JeremiahBinkleBottom]

What if R2D2 didnt stay with the ship and went to Anakin on Mustafar. Would R2D2's history with Anakin be enough to break Anakin from the dark? Or would the events go down the same?

[@ClaudevonRiegan_]

R2 just zaps him when he tries to force choke padme

[@CABOOSEBOB]

What if the Zillo beast killed palpatine?

[@lv-420]

What if palpatine was a horrible Sith Lord Or what if he had a low midichlorian count

[@davidrodrick2109]

What if Palpatine changed his mind in episode 3, began targeting Obi Wan to turn him to the dark side instead

[@phantomphan873]

THIS

[@sharapurplereignlowecharat921]

Star Wars what if Anakin turn to the dark side during the clone wars

[@FTWDKSSB]

Romans 10:9 That if thou shalt confess with thy mouth the Lord Jesus, and shalt believe in thine heart that God hath raised him from the dead, thou shalt be saved.

[@Mauscmkwk]

First😊

[@howtogoogle8031]

what if yoda ttraijnjed dooku griveous rasied adopted adlso allowed them to have emotions nut sent them to mortis mother tsara the mother of darth mau padme padme shodul know that there needs to be balcne betwrrrn good and evil adn what if they rwee rasied by gods and the force hmmmmmm