What If Anakin Skywalker NEVER Turned to the Dark Side

What would've happened had Anakin Skywalker never betrayed the Jedi and never turned to the dark side?
#skywalker #StarWars #AnakinSkywalker #anakin #starwarsedit #theclonewars #maytheforcebewithyou #obiwankenobi #macewindu #shorts #short
Community Discord: / discord
Support the Channel: / ppsw
Twitch Account: / pentepatrol
GIVEAWAY: docs.google.com/document/d/1a...
THUMBNAIL BY: Tilian_Creative: www.picuki.com/profile/tilian...
Pente Patrol Team:
Voice Actors:
Concordia Jedi: / @concordiajedi
James: / jamesmck345
Jordan: / @spectrum_country1028
Silver Bullet:
Bly: / @jackogeography3950
Cole: / connerthehonker
Editors PPT:
Jakub: / jakeup
Nnaemeka: nwosennaemeka.artstation.com
Saito: teambellaro...
ATLAXS: / @atlaxs
Writers:
Cameron Hall: linktr.ee/spproductions
Support My Other Channels!
PPR: / @pentepatrolreacts
PPMP: / @pentepatrolmusicprodu...
Support This Video's Musicians!
The Way of Water - • 🎥 Epic & Trailer (Free...
In Search of Solitude - • 🌳 Classical & Cinemati...
Permafrost - • 💭 Meditation (Free Mus...
Fire & Thunder - • ⚡ Free Epic Music (No ...
Unexplored Moon - • 🌙 Copyright Free Orche...
Eight Mountains - • Eight Mountains by Savfk
The Epic Hero - • 💪 Orchestral Trailer P...
Dunes - • ⏳ Soundtrack (Free Mus...
Refusing the Ultimatum - • 😟 Tense & Orchestral (...
Passage of Time - • ⏱️ Cinematic & Backgro...
Love - • ❤️‍🔥 Romantic & Piano ...
Resolutions - • 👼 Hopeful & Angelic (F...
What Happens When We Die - • Sad Soundtrack (Free M...
The Preparation - • 🔭 Soundtrack (Free Mus...
Eglair - • 🚤 Epic & Cinematic (Fr...
Instructions for Living Life - • 🎹 Piano Instrumental (...
Terminus - • 🎖️ Free Epic Heroic Mu...
Still A Long Way To Go - • 📽️ Free Film Orchestra...
Magic - • 🍬 Free Classical Fanta...
Pirates of the Quarantine - • ☠️ Free Pirate Music -...
Long Way to Go - • ⛓️ Sad & Beautiful Orc...
Age of Wonder - • 🌁 Cinematic & Epic (Fr...

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

Subscribe and Share

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

@johnpope I'm saving that for when BB season 2 comes out

[@CAPTAIN-REX]

@johnpope then I shall recommend you Nicolas damani what if movie

[@josiahpurtee1156]

What if Ashoka was in the Siege of Mandalore with Obi-Wan and Anakin?

[@josiahpurtee1156]

What if Bo-Katan Kryze was a stronger and better fighter than Maul and Pre Vizsla combined, thus defeating Maul and/or Sabine Wren in combat for leadership of Mandalore and/or the Darksaber?

[@wyattbrown2122]

Hello Pente, pretty soon, your intros will end with a Star Wars story. 😂 I can’t wait to see how they evolve

[@82dorrin]

To think the Jedi Order was wiped out and the Galaxy doomed to Sith rule because Anakin couldn't sit still for thirty minutes...

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

Haha

[@Luchux177]

Well, I read a fic where Anakin sat still for 30 minutes but everything still went to hell because Palpatine decided to cut his loses and enact Order 66

[@jsaplays33]

I know right

[@paigestubbs9718]

@@Luchux177Where can we find it?????

[@Matt-nw2te]

The ULTIMATE ADHD! Lol 🤣🤣🤣💀💀💀

[@Jifty]

The one on right was Luke, the one on the left was Leia. Obi-wan looked down at the two of them and smiled. "Hello there."

[@Teon5072]

Luke looked up and said "General Kenobi!"

[@The_Approaching_Storm320]

@@Teon5072 Leia added : "You're a bold one"

[@belamcmillan4337]

I just spit milk out of my nose 💀💀💀

[@chargeminecraft]

Anakin Skywalker was like: “These are their first words, how cute.”

[@lukemarriott306]

​@@Teon5072 two more arms pop out from his back with lightsaber

[@tomjensen1]

Great idea using Shaak-Ti as the calming influence Anakin needed in the moment. If Anakin and Padme were this happy and content they may have had another child. What could have been.

[@CharlieHepp]

The Secret rise up solo

[@christianpimenta6332]

Wasn’t she dead though by grevious?

[@logandelaharpe6362]

Shaak ti has died like 5 times but canonically she died to Anakin in his raid on the temple

[@JohnGeorgeBauerBuis]

@@petercaballero8059yeah, it’s kind of a meme at this point.

[@amachinethatgoesding1629]

@@logandelaharpe6362I thought her death from grievous was canon as in clone wars before anakin and Ashoka part ways obi wan tells anakin that Shaak-Ti went radio silent or smthn and that’s just before the start of rots

[@boko1564]

As anakin (an elderly man) nears his life’s end, he revealed that he had a family and that it is possible for Jedi to have attachments and still follow the path of the light. Proving the old ways to be wrong and that change is needed. (This is my version of anakin s ending)

[@seanbraley2772]

the no family rule isnt about attachments its because when the jedi where basically taking in any force sensitive they could to fight in the multiple sith wars they took in jedi who were married their kids like Luke and Lia were strong in the force they would train and marry other jedi creating family lines those jedi were usually stronger then first gen ones if one of the parents had a rare ability like shatter point or Absorb then the child usaly did to leading to the stronger multi gen jedi slowly starting to rule the order it lead to a civil war

[@georgethefriend29]

Idea for Christmas next year: What if Palpatine was visited by 3 ghosts, and learned to change his ways, as well as the meaning of Life Day?

[@xuruiyu]

Goddamnit xD

[@jsb6975.ah.crapbaskets]

Now I'm wondering what three ghosts would be sent his way.

[@donnamiller3463]

Darth Plaguis for Christmas past Yoda for Christmas Present Revan for Christmas Future I am assuming Yoda for the second spirit as he capable of Astral projection while living (i.e. Rebels and Dagobh). Revan for the third as he was on both sides of the force and played major roles in the outcomes.

[@georgethefriend29]

@@donnamiller3463 Yoda: "Know me better, and come in, hmm?"

[@donnamiller3463]

@@georgethefriend29 I can imagine him saying that

[@CesarACastillo]

Has anyone ever done one with Anakin still falling to the Dark Side but the pain he felt from killing his Jedi siblings was what saved him? You can clearly see him crying in agony in Revenge of the Sith. I can definitely see him regretting his actions and after putting things right go into self imposed exile as penance for his actions before his pain saved him.

[@adamking5215]

yes.

[@CesarACastillo]

@@adamking5215 u know who did? I’d like to watch it

[@TheAlpha38]

@@CesarACastillo I seem to remember Star Wars Theory doing such a story a couple years back. Something along the lines of "what if anakin had turned back on mustafar?"

[@trainknut]

The way I always understood it is that the pain from killing the Jedi is what further pushed him into the darkness and fully completed his fall to the dark side.

[@CesarACastillo]

@@trainknut this is definitely the case but it could go ether way when you think about it

[@Bucktopus37]

Not gonna lie, the moment of instant serenity that washes over Anakin when Palpatine, the shadow that's been looming over not just himself but the entire order for so long was finally snuffed out... absolutely beautiful.

[@seanking8427]

I would love to see a alternate universe where this happened

[@TheGuardianofAzarath]

There are a couple of else-worlds novels where Anakin does leave the order during the events of AoTC, the main difference in the story is when Padme goes with Anikin to rescue Shmi, and subsequently stops him from killing the Tuskens.

[@herooflight7931]

@@TheGuardianofAzarath what are they called?

[@TheGuardianofAzarath]

@@herooflight7931 Star Wars Altered Universe Episode 2 and 3 by Scott Ferguson on Apple Books. Might also be on kindle

[@herooflight7931]

@@TheGuardianofAzarath thank you

[@adammartinez8061]

@@TheGuardianofAzarath well because there are infinite realities….so….yes this does happen.

[@rafsilva20]

Hearing this story, I understand why Anakin hate himself so much, and how deep he dive into the dark side, knowing what he loses, the only way to survive is kill your old self and be the darkest one you could be. I wish nobody need to feel that way. I wish all the good vibes to everyone

[@seanbraley2772]

the kill your old self thing is a Disney star wars thing when Lucas was in charge vadar was a monster because he believed him self one i killed children to save my wife i then kill my wife and child all im good at is killing im a monster

[@js3599]

I enjoyed this story overall. and I honestly believe that Shaak Ti could have aided Anakin to make the right decision had she been there, even if it was only through nudges in the right direction... BUT... I do question the decision to give Luke and Leia the name Skywalker instead of Amidala and still expect to keep the secret, ESPECIALLY with Luke and Leia both growing up to become public figures. Other than that minor catch, great story.

[@ddieter603]

Or Naberrie, wasn't that Padme's name before she was elected queen?

[@js3599]

@@ddieter603 Yes, that was her family name, but, as you mentioned, she changed it to Amidala for political reasons. Also yes, they could have given them that name as well, but they likely would have changed it to Amidala themselves upon going into politics... Anything to avoid the name Skywalker, unless/until they go public about it, whether by choice or circumstance.

[@AdrianGarcia-wz7kd]

Leia was given the Organa last name. Can't say the same for Luke. He was adopted by his stepuncle, and they didn't bother to change it. Maybe because they thought Tatooine and was at the outer rim that the empire wouldn't reach them (like really?)

[@Creatxr9530]

@@AdrianGarcia-wz7kd Leia was given the last name Organa because that's who she was adopted by, in this story Leia was never adopted so therefore her name would never be Organa

[@Luc42]

I honestly don't think Anakin would care at that point

[@maxhaly1612]

People say Shaak Ti is "Useless" in Disney's Canon because we never see her doing anything noteworthy in the 2008 CW series. If this actually happened in ROTS, where Shaak Ti convinced Anakin to stay true to the Light side, I'm certain those people who called her useless before would start respecting her more as a character. (I know in Legends she played a much more important role in the lore than she did in current canon, and was actually a fairly good fighter, as she was capable of holding her own against a small army of Grievous' Magnaguards during the Separatist Invasion of Coruscant in the 2003 CW series)

[@TheAusar]

You mean if the character that did nothing, did something instead, she would no longer be called useless. What insight...

[@theseekerofancienttruth3873]

She was also on par with Starkiller, who only beat her by using Force Lightning. It was still a Very Near Thing for him.

[@t74guard78]

The greatest Star Wars story ever told. I loved every second of it. Should have been how the story went. Thanks so much.

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

I'm so glad you enjoyed!

[@triberedeyetv5971]

TOTALLY agree

[@jokekopter2509]

@@PentePatrolStarWars you could do what if confederacy won Clone war?

[@Lyoko012345]

Yeah but 4,5 and 6 were made first so the ending was already written.

[@Creatxr9530]

@@Lyoko012345 How different Star Wars would be if the prequels were made first

[@alanpickett3802]

Dude brought a tear to my eye. I'd love to see a clone wars type animated movie about this. Great what if story. Loved it.

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

I'm so glad you enjoyed!

[@CharlieHepp]

@@PentePatrolStarWars The Secret rise up solo

[@TheChris1122]

@@PentePatrolStarWars Disney should do something like this like they did Marvel What If

[@neonbatteries4389]

What if the public was informed about the clones being requested by dooku? It would be crazy.

[@skyrunnerblake1481]

Yeah hard to imagine what would have happened to public trust toward the republic. Also, I'd imagine without the empire/order 66 the clones would have been still around, whether they all remained in military service or were able to become free citizens of the republic, they'd all have to deal with the consequences of the war, public trust in them would decline, and I'd think they'd probably be treated poorly by many after hearing Dooku and Palpatine controlled so many aspects of the army and it's creation.

[@nealsmall9316]

@@skyrunnerblake1481 Do you think it would be cool if a director makes a Star Wars reboot and it will show what it would be like if Anakin stayed to the light side

[@skyrunnerblake1481]

I would watch it probably. There's something satisfying about seeing a version where everything works out for everyone, right?

[@TheUncivilizedNation]

The Kaminoans would spill everything about the Sith once the Republic threatens to not pay for the Clones

[@GRasputin91]

So it turns out, Anakin's hyperactive excitement over his family indeed would be canonical. "I HAVE A FAMILY!!"

[@lilithhecataniangoddessesm187]

I can imagine Padme and Leia doing their speech together. Luke’s energy has the potential to help his dad out whenever he’s having some mental and emotional problems, I see that in Luke, he’s going to make the best therapy for his dad.

[@georgethefriend29]

Ah, yes. A timeline where everything turned out well. Truly a Life Day miracle.

[@treylol4110]

I just wish Anakin can finally have peace

[@kennethturner7124]

If Vadar had to exist, then let him be a separate person. And can you imagine Yoda, Anakin, Mace, Obi-Wan, and Ahsoka against any Sith as a team? Awesome thought.

[@dakotaharp883]

Literally any Sith Lord in history would look at this team and just be like: Well Shit. 😅

[@samuraijackson241]

Yoda, Anakin, mace, obi-wan, ahsoka appears. Sith: why am I hearing boss music?

[@Kooldood0874]

I've watched plenty of what ifs about if Anakin never joined the dark side. But this is by far the BEST one I've seen!!

[@vitovitale8325]

cheers bravo my sentiment exactly 🙏🙂🖖V3

[@venator-yv1gw]

Anakin,being an engineer from childhood. “Yo. You know what happens if you overcharge a battery?”

[@AliceGiggins-rc2cn]

Such a beautiful story, it’s was what I always wanted for him.

[@bricknard]

Talk about a Christmas miracle, Anakin gets a happy ending! I’m glad he trusted Obi wan and Ashoka to be apart of Luke and Leias life it shows the life he has for his master and student. Also attempt 66 for what if Anakin Skywalker and Galen Marek were rivals and trained together.

[@blackgamingdk3232]

Love to see Anakin having a happy ending. Great video as always :D

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

I'm glad you enjoyed!

[@nealsmall9316]

@@PentePatrolStarWars How come Darth Vader never talked to R2 D2 and C 3 Po

[@Maik_Privat]

What if Obi left the Jedi after Qui Gons death?

[@georgevanhoose6333]

That was beautiful. Especially the part about touching on what happened to the clones in a postwar republic.

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

I'm glad you enjoyed!

[@Kubinda12345]

I've some ideas for What If: - What if Plagueis or Sidious turned to the light? - What if Anakin and Shmi were Mandalorians? - What if Palpatine wasn't elected the chancellor of the Republic in Phantom Menace? - What if it was Saw and not Steela who died on Onderon? - What if Tarkin died in the Citadel meaning there would be no Tarkin Doctrine for the Empire? - What if Qi'ra joined the Galactic Empire with Han perhaps becoming an ISB agent?

[@catvanbrian9470]

Sidious has a psychopathic disorder, he was within the darkness the moment he was born.

[@evertonporter7887]

What if both Cassian Andor and Jyn Erso survived and became Jedi.

[@kelvinth117]

- What if Anakin and Shmi were Mandalorians? this one sounds like a really good story

[@jenniferbrewer5370]

What if Cody joined up with Rex, Wolffe and Gregor on Seelos, and was therefore part of Star Wars: Rebels?

[@AnthonyPalmisano007]

your wish for that mandalorian one came true

[@sgtbudahgaming3122]

Can you just imagine a movie based on this story in the Clone Wars Animation? It would be so awesome, but great job. Also, should've added Rex into it as he knew about the relationship too!

[@residentevil1.5nerd]

You should do a part 2 to this where Anakin Skywalker also Trained not just Luke and Leia. But also Gelen Merek (StarKiller).

[@alexander.tahtadjian]

This was beautiful. I always love these types of videos because they always add a sense of awe and wonder with these types of "what if" scenarios; and this was by far my favourite types of what If's...Ahsoka would make an awesome aunt for Luke and Leia. I may have gotten to watching this today, but this was definitely a wonderful Christmas present. I hope you had a Merry Christmas and Happy Holidays and enjoyed some wonderful time with your loved ones.

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

I'm so glad you enjoyed!

[@CharlieHepp]

@@PentePatrolStarWars The Secret rise up solo

[@sailorbychoice1]

17:00 I always assumed that as talented cloners as the Kaminoan's were purported to be they could make the growth cycle of the clone accelerate to maturity, then slow either to normal rates or slow the aging process considerably to extend their viability as soldiers. So a twelve year old clone could look like a twenty five year old man, but a forty year old clone may only appear to be thirty to thirty five with perhaps a fifty year shelf-life, then perhaps a rapid acceleration of aging to minimize caring for a "retired" aging clone.

[@SithxRaverxLuis]

Imagine this is was he dreams about then we he awakens he looks in the mirror and sees that he’s vader…silently crying

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

I've done that in another video... and it was evil.. it hurted

[@cedratte7438]

I love how you include Jedi such as Shaak ti she is super underrated and awesome good job!

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

You'll love today's video in that case :)

[@lottieparish1715]

What if ahsoka got the Powers of the daughter please

[@samrit8298]

Please

[@FeuerflockenTv]

Dude you slowly turnig into a meme 🤣🤣🤣

[@lottieparish1715]

I don’t know if I should had you are like you???

[@blacklighthologram5339]

And Maul got the powers of the son and Anakin got the powers of the father, let's do the whole shebang.

[@lottieparish1715]

No

[@PizzaLover379]

I've always loved 'what if' stories and this was a great way of reimagining such a confusing time for Anakin. I was not expecting that ending. Thank you for the story!

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

I'm glad you enjoyed!

[@nathancruz9172]

Now, that’s what I call a good alternate ending.

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

I'm so glad you enjoyed!

[@jeremydale4548]

What you said about the clones. THAT is a FAR better way for the clones to be handles. OF COURSE some caution has to be taken, but with the war over they can finally have lives

[@Revan9821]

As a new father, I completely understand the feelings Anakin has for Luke and Leia.

[@raymondpratt3055]

Legit one of the most detailed fan fics I’ve seen. Well done.

[@ch62013]

What if Anakin Skywalker was raised by the Mandalorians? Also Merry Christmas!

[@rickyhutchins6897]

This was a great Christmas present thank you I always loved stories where anakin lived and told obi wan about him and Padme. The friendship between obi wan and anakin is my favourite part the clone wars show and the hole star wars series. Marry Christmas

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

Merry Christmas! I'm glad you enjoyed

[@tadhggoreyoneill13666]

What if C3PO never had his mind wiped at the end of Revenge of the Sith and told Luke and Leia about everything that their parents did from the start of the Phantom Menace to the end of Revenge of the Sith

[@Vulcar2500]

''My mom had a crush on a 10 year old boy?!?!?!?!''

[@broketoon7996]

​@Ohio Gaming i mean she was 14. Still weird tho.

[@sharksam8583]

Imagine if this was the case. And Vader tries to do the dramatic Luke. I am your father. Reveal. And Luke's just like, I already know. c3-po told me. And Vader is Just like. c3-po, you say I built that Droid when I was around 10 years old.

[@tadhggoreyoneill13666]

@@sharksam8583 if Luke and Leia grew up knowing everything about their parents. The good bits, the bad bits and everything in between their lives would have been very different

[@sharksam8583]

​@@tadhggoreyoneill13666 Very true but my earlier comment Was something I thought of that could be a comedic moment in the movies. If this scenario actually happened.

[@hiddendesire3076]

I’m just picturing the excited Anakin bit from How it Should’ve Ended as Anakin meets his kids.

[@DIYprojects66]

The greatest and happiest story I’ve ever heard

[@Only1199]

What if Anakin wasn't born on Tatooine? What if Anakin and Shmi were born and raised into a tusken tribe? What if Anakin was born on the wild space planet of Odessen? What if Palpatine was another form of Vitiate? What if Palpatine instead of erecting the Galactic Empire chose to form a new reconstituted Sith Empire, with a new dark council answerable and pledged their allegiance to him, Vader as his wrath, all the old spheres of influence, ministries and organizations that the old sith empire had and instead of using stormtrooper armor, they used vitiates imperial trooper armors? (Obviously none of the sith in the last what if are remotely powerful enough to overthrow Palpatine and Vader but still powerful to an extent in their own image.)

[@ZinXlX]

I found this vid not expecting anything but finished it with a satisfied smile. What a wonderful story.

[@greenleader2809]

Damn man. I visualized the whole thing. It was beautiful. Such a beautiful what-if. Wish I could see it become reality one day if they ever do an official what if

[@user-bp5eb4qz4g]

Honestly, somehow I'm thinking how this story in its ending would be a good dream for Vader to just wake up in grim reality he's in in the main story. And it's making me sad... Why can't I think of this as just separate story...

[@darrelleaster5381]

How I always think of it is that each what if I read is its own separate alternate universe. It might not have happened in the main timeline, but there is a timeline in which it did happen, and Anakin did at least get a happy ending somewhere. Although I’m glad he didn’t end this as a dream. The cruelty would be immense

[@courtneyfranks4851]

What if Padme and Sabe had been successful in their attempts to find and free Shmi Skywalker before Attack of the Clones? What if Padme survived and raised Leia on Naboo, while Obi-One took Luke to Tattooine to protect the children from the Empire? What if Count Dooku betrayed and killed Palpatine during the Clone Wars and became the new Sith Master with Ventris as his Apprentice? How would the Republic replace Palpatine? Would the Separatists win the war?

[@shaydowsith348]

A couple open ended questions from this story: 1. What would happen to the inhibitor chips that the clones had in their brains? 2. What about when the Vong showed up? Nice story.

[@madhippie6347]

Would be cool if maul somehow escaped and since he knew somewhat of palpetines plan, he winds up deciphering data from where palpetine used to meet dooku in secret and finds out the codes to execute order 66 while luke and laya were young children, plus it gives mail time to gain control of the sith holocron from rebels, maybe he turns someone to the dark side like Luke or laya.

[@jeremydale4548]

For your first question, I mean from what we've seen, the chips only had a major impact once Order 66 was issued. So, no Order 66, then the chips wouldn't activate.

[@Matt-yg8ub]

There are over 100 general orders. The chips are always active. order 66 legitimately existed in the event that the Jedi attempt to overthrow the republic…. Which technically is exactly what Mason Windu did, when he extra judiciously assassinated the chancellor of the republic without evidence of an actual crime.

[@bindair_dundat]

I believe that at the point this theory starts, it was already too late for the Light Side. Palpatine wasn't someone to let chance choices influence his plans. If he has had a sliver of doubt about Anakin, he would have had a plan B already in motion.

[@TheTwilightQueen_]

I think thats exactly why Shaak Ti was involved because otherwise he would likely have just given into impatience as he is well know for doing. I also was wondering if Palpatine was gonna use the same power he planned to use on Luke should Luke have struck him down. Likely taking over Windu's body or how ever it was intended to work. Palpatine's plan B was Anakin probably because Dooku kinda was planning to betray him. That's not to say that Palpatine didn't have a plan C for if Skywalker didn't turn. He probably planned to use order 66 and any other secret orders necessary to overpower the jedi which would have resulted in failure probably given Anakin kind of being his Ace in the hole. Assuming he did steal Windu's body or power he might have actually still won, BUT would have had to change plans quickly. My best guess on that plotline would be that Anakin would have had to been the one to take Windu/palpatine down. This is all also assuming Windu could handle Palpatine's darkside energy, could be argued either way given his training to drain darkside users of their own power for his fighting style but that seems like a long shot. If it did work out though Palpatine probably had his biggest plan of taking Anakin's body for his own, the ultimate vessel for the "ultimate" sith lord. Would have honestly been a way better plan to take Anakin's body instead of the other options but hey what can you do about adding more stuff to the canon right?

[@bindair_dundat]

@@TheTwilightQueen_ Considering Palpatine's confidence, I doubt even Padme could have prevented Anakin from going there himself.

[@sas6384]

@@TheTwilightQueen_ I think Palpatine's plan originally was to possess Anakin before Mustafar happened. This works perfectly if you take Palpatine being his father as canon, created the chosen one to be nothing but a vessel and weapon. Then he opted for Luke, same Chosen One blood (his own). Similar to irl possessions, Palpatine can't just take over somebody against their will, they must be properly corrupted/willing first. That's why he immediately sent Anakin on a killing spree, that's why he was baiting Luke to kill him and Vader.

[@sas6384]

@@N0Vanity999 Non-canon source!🤫

[@andy84denham]

Thank you for this story. Honestly it brought a tear to my eye with the kids and obi-won. Well done

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

I'm glad you enjoyed!

[@whitewolfcrowley6550]

I love how you gave Anakin the best possible outcome he could have, and in my opinion, SHOULD have had.. Everything you said, probably would have happened, had Anakin just stood still, though; I do doubt it would have been Shaak-Ti, her personality would have been the best case for Anakin, as reasons already stated.,

[@daninironen1505]

This story telling is executed in such a beautiful way... Thank you for bringing this to us

[@ocksahlnestreves6139]

That was the most wholesome story I've ever heard

[@theclickbaitmasster]

I love this video I feel like this would be an awesome conclusion to the show if Anakin didn’t turn to the Darkside in revenge of the Sith

[@locoarticwolf2181]

-What if Tenebre/Vitiate/Valkrion returned during the movies in the same vain of you Darth JarJar or Jedi Palpatine fics? -What if The Rule of Two was abolished after the Clone Wars? -What if the Sith Empire returned during the Galactic Civil War instead of the Clone Wars? -What if Vader lived at the end of RotJ, not redeemed and in charge of the Imperial Remnant? -What if Thrawn was a Republic General in the Clone Wars? -What if Thrawn was present during the Original Trilogy? -What if Anakin/Vader was a double agent and played the long game like your Rebel Thrawn fic? -What if Maul was found by the Jedi before Sidious? -What if Vader,Thrawn and Several Imperials started an Imperial Rebellion separate from the Rebels,which really took off around the DS1 destruction? -What if Vader never burned on Mustafar? -What if Grevious was a Republic General but still hated the Jedi? -What if Starkiller lived at the end of TFU1 and later trained the Skywalker Twins? -What if Lord Starkiller lived at the end of TFU1 dark side ending and ignoring the dlc, basically replacing Vader?

[@kimberlyruiz0716]

I loved every second of this.. thank you 🙏 i always wanted to hear anakin have his happy ending.

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

I'm so glad you enjoyed!

[@cadenroberts7984]

I love how much respect he has for Shaak Ti when he describes her actions and reasoning

[@Callisto_Arcas]

Beautiful! I was surprised by this, but it was the Ahsoka-Anakin moments that effected me the most. I even teared up a little during their first conversation after she returned from her Darth Maul mission. Great story! Really enjoyed this!

[@warreng440]

This is the fanfiction i didn't know that i needed 😁

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

[@briandaleske5139]

I can imagine in an alternate reality, a version of (ANAKIN SKYWALKER) never did turn to the Dark-Side, and I imagine that he quit trying to ask to become a Jedi-Master. In addition I imagine that he settled with just being a Jedi-Knight, and being with the woman he loves so much. Plus to add I imagine that (ANAKIN) had decided to leave the JEDI ORDER, to live the rest of his life with his wife, and be a good father to his two offsprings.

[@shaveyodamust8505]

What if Qui Gon Jinn fell in love with Shmi Skywalker.

[@devinreis5811]

He would've been a pretty awesome stepdad.

[@chadbrassard8329]

What a truly beautiful way to reimagine this story. For Anakin to finally have the family he wanted, not torn apart by his fears, and live his life serving the Jedi order. While I still don't like the Jedi or the teachings of them, I can still understand the happiness that he feels Several points in the epic retelling, I had indeed shed multiple tears, happy that the greatest of all Jedi got to have his happy ending, to be with his wife and kids, watching them grow and learn. This was the best "What if" story I've heard from this point of view To go back on my previous point about the Jedi, I personally relate to a Sith more. I like the idea of power. But without true goals, power becomes a tool for destruction. I don't think as a typical Sith but my point of view is complicated. Again I am happy for Anakin, that is all I mean to say, thanks for listening

[@profitprophet6418]

Gorgeous story telling. Really great character reveals to make us want to hear more. 🎉

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

I'm so glad you enjoyed!

[@firedogman2280]

Imagine Palpatine in this scenario, the dude had everything planned for the final fight only to be wreaked and have his plans completely destroyed

[@S60Rguy]

I really enjoyed this story. Would love to see it make it's way into live action, maybe in an alternate reality. Pay attention Disney!!! This is what happens when fans write stories and not people who say things like "I never watched Star Wars until I got this job".

[@matthewmann8969]

What if both Ahsoka And Obi Wan started pushing up daises on Mortis before Anakin could save them and then shortly after Padme And Yoda also passed?

[@Vulcar2500]

Anakin dies from cri

[@kennethturner7124]

Oh my God. This should be a movie! Your story was awesome. No order 66, and this is how Star Wars ought to be. I love it.❤

[@FeuerflockenTv]

Well this is where the fun begins

[@CAPTAIN-REX]

*this is what Anakin was thinking before killing the younglings*

[@chassan10]

Can you imagine him raising two rambunctious force sensitive twin toddlers? "Leia Shmi Skywalker, stop drawing on the ceiling with your markers! Yes, it is a pretty picture of Mommy, but it should be on paper or a datapad. Here, redraw it on this loose-leaf while I scrub the ceiling... Wait, where's your brother?" Chirping, beeping sounds of distress come from the next room over. "Oh, no. Luke Obi-Wan Skywalker, stop levitating R2! You know how much he hates that!"

[@tinkerbellrock]

This was an awesome tale thank you for the "What if Anakin didnt turn to the dark side"

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

I'm glad you enjoyed!

[@jacobcarman6431]

What I would give for the canon story to actually turn out like this

[@locoarticwolf2181]

This. This is the Universe that many of us want to see happen.

[@Granty707]

Great story. Nice for Anakin to have a happy ending at last

[@AM90715]

And without missing his limbs this time

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

I'm glad you enjoyed!

[@detectivenuthead7869]

I was expecting Obi-wan to say to Luke and Leia "Well hello there" lol

[@johnpittsii7524]

What if Anakin fell in love with Dutchess Satine or Bo katan. Also what if Anakin was trained by Bastillia Shan or Alayua Secura

[@barcabocalda2583]

What If The Father Transferred all his Powers and Abilities To Anakin Skywalker before he died ?

[@THEREALBLU13]

I want a “what if” show but for starwars it would be so awesome

[@nurulainrohaizat672]

Too much of how every possibilities for a happy ending, yet we all know how this will be a Drama instead of thrilling Sci Fi movie as it should be for the Star Wars Franchise.... One word can it be is a good book for us to feel there always a light behind every bleak struggles we facing in life. Good work in rearrange the story lines.... It does leave me in tears.

[@natha9412]

This is totally perfect. You're incredibly talented doing this.. this is really the story, everything just makes so much sense. Also I totally imagined every single part, with their faces and expretions, totally beautiful ❤️. But at the end at the final argument I would say that the acceptance of anakin's family would be the beginning of a new era and world, worthy of a new total series of Star wars, following this path (i even have material for the sequels look at that 😉 haha), developing the family argument. That would be the opportunity to extend the family idea to the Jedi, so they can understand that it doesn't prevent you from having a good judgment or understanding. That actually it was the key that they were missing. That all of us need a family, that's how humanity and all species developed, and how all form of life was created. And that strong families will bring balance to every individual, to their cities, to the galaxy and their future generations. This change would be the fulfillment of all, and the most profound and precious understanding of the jedi, knowing that they can have a family. That affection doesn't corrupt you... totally the opposite, love saves us all and what preserves us. That would be the ultimate lesson and argument for all of the star wars history.

[@nxblelxrdjova7147]

1) What if Maul was the chosen one? 2) What if Palpatine loved and cared about Maul like a son? 3) What if Qui Gon turned Maul to the light before what would’ve been their final duel?

[@noahvanderwyst1232]

Feels really good watching Anakin finally get some wins

[@electricofff]

Bro this story is so wholesome 😭😭😭

[@jennsheelar2753]

Have always enjoyed the stories here. This one espically warmed my heart this year. Have had alot of heartbreaking things happen this year, but this made me feel good. Thank you, and Happy Holidays to you.

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

I'm glad you enjoyed!

[@Azrael81996]

What if Ahsoka was the chosen one?

[@Maik_Privat]

7 months ago

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/nH3KZIuEgdhgm5o

[@RichEDMixed]

Honestly if they did this as a film series as alternative timeline thing that would be cool

[@danielharman572]

What if the rebel alliance had access to multiple YT 1300's about 50-100 of them. Beings highly modular, easy to modify and upgrade this makes it very versatile and useful to the rebellion. Kind regards from Daniel Harman.

[@Grace-s]

usually with these stories i tend to like most of it but dislike a few aspects, but i loved every bit of this! it all makes sense and even brings up points that are self-indulgent for me, like obi-wan's bond with satine and shaak ti being an absolute queen. i surprised myself by how much i enjoyed this!

[@carsonrichards9902]

What a wholesome story for the Christmas season love you videos keep doing what you’re these are amazing

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

I'm so glad you enjoy!

[@guardspeedy]

OMG! I love this and I even shed a tear. Holy cow! this moved me so much.

[@DarkRaider-li3gk]

Bro the part when he said “if you want it take it” made me think of kung fu panda😂

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

Inspired by Po XD I love KFP

[@Maik_Privat]

What if Qui Gon asked Obi Wan to train Anakin One on One?

[@Rex-The-Wolf]

OHH I CAN'T WAIT TO WATCH THIS!!! also, watching starwars what if's on youtube became a december tradition to me In december, my parrents marriage anniversary takes place as does christmass and ends on old years day, and each year we went to the cinema, but we focused on the hobbit and on starwars, sadly we couldnt go this year, but thats fine, to continue the tradition of watching starwars in december, i got all the starwars i need in disney plus and on youtube, long live patreon! I can show proper gratitude with it 😃

[@christianhillman1050]

This is so touching it melts my heart

[@jesseokami7087]

This was honestly beautiful. I'm happy this was shown in my recommendations.

[@edgareliseev1773]

What if Grievous trained Anakin or joined the Republic and worked together with Douku and Sidious and later on Vader?

[@timothyschwartz5518]

What if Chewbacca is a Jedi? What if Rotta the hutt was force sensitive? What if Sabine Wren is force sensitive? What if Anakin was trained by Tarre Viszla? What if Anakin was trained by Bastillia Shan? What if Anakin trained Grogu after Ashoka left the order? What if Anakin fell in love with Ursa Wren? What if Luke was trained by Kanan Jarrus? What if Anakin and Padme adopted Hera Syndulla? What if Obi-Wan left the order after Qui gonna death? What if Maul killed both Obi-Wan and Qui gonn before he died on Naboo?

[@stevedash5339]

You have a real talent for story telling.....amazing! Love that you wove Shaak Ti into the story