What If Sidious ABANDONED Anakin on Mustafar (Star Wars What Ifs)

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

Subscribe and Share

[@topdog5252]

What if Pong Krell survived at some point on Umbara and went to try join Dooku, as he said he would?

[@josiahpurtee1156]

What if Ashoka was in the Siege of Mandalore with Obi-Wan and Anakin?

[@josiahpurtee1156]

What if Bo-Katan Kryze was a stronger and better fighter than Maul and Pre Vizsla combined, thus defeating Maul and/or Sabine Wren in combat for leadership of Mandalore and/or the Darksaber?

[@josiahpurtee1156]

@@topdog5252 As my friend, Charlie Quigg, would say "only time will tell".

[@CAPTAIN-REX]

that video was like a torture for Anakin

[@arcticwolf8313]

"Even if she was into it, it wasn't the proper time to find out." Dude, I'm dead 🤣

[@lukeslosthand]

Bro that caught me way off guard!

[@SuperGamefreak18]

honestly I'd believe she would have been into that honestly

[@jonathoncarroll4856]

omg i thought the same.

[@mastercheeks2]

Just like Padme in another universe

[@JTruong3rd]

I take it he saw that comic.

[@shadeslayervii9427]

"he knew he was out of line by chocking her, even if she was into it, it was not the time to find out" - Best line of all your videos hands down

[@linda-0587]

*choking

[@chessduncan1864]

🤣🤣 ikr

[@GeometricOne-hr5oz]

"chocking"

[@Abigdummy4life]

And when she was already in later stages of pregnancy, no less. XD

[@faari232]

Sidious: *sees burned Anakin* Also Sidious: loser hahahah

[@JasonAguirre]

'He regretted choking Padme. Even if she was into it, it wasn't the time to find out' 💀💀💀

[@johnnylee6122]

😂😂😂dead

[@marcuswilliams3758]

I was searching the comments just for a response to that!!!!🤣🤣🤣 I thought I heard it wrong the first time.

[@Daddyzigger]

@@johnnylee6122 literally

[@trainion9626]

"Yeah Ani choke me, choke me with those sturdy hands of yours mmmm yeah..."

[@Rodgerball]

Padme deserved what she got

[@KingCodd]

“even if she was into it” omg 😂 i do like that mace windu survived being thrown out of a windu

[@richardmoser7062]

I'm glad that even in this alternate ending, you still had Anakin fulfill the prophecy. It kind of goes to show thst no matter what happened that day, Anakin was still destined to bring balance to the force, and not just die there on Mustafar. Good story, man!

[@aftoncultistandsimp]

@blackshark2536No I assume him as The Chosen One would by some miracle survive

[@Glitchrat_YT]

Anakins last words to windu should be You should have just given me the rank of master

[@keironwaite]

Yessss😂

[@darkhorseofwis]

Take a seat.

[@blackcat940]

What if Anakin had visions of order 66 instead of padme dying of childbirth? What if Anakin went undercover instead of Obi-Wan? What if tup was taken to the jedi temple instead of getting the atomic brain scan? What if order 66 was issued when anakin was on the mission with the Bad Batch.

[@wargamesmaster]

What if the Disney trilogy was a vision of a much younger luke?

[@ClipsAndTracks]

@@wargamesmaster i genuinely wish that it was truly the case because thats the only way they can cover their bullshit

[@thebestoneforreal3491]

@@wargamesmaster lol

[@haydenfowle7576]

Palpatine wouldn't be a fool he wouldnt issue Order 66 until Dooku and Grevious's death and until he is sure he got Anakin to turn to The Dark Side

[@HPACE77]

@@haydenfowle7576 its a what if

[@kevinfox500]

PPSW. As a double amputee, recovering from a recent surgery, thank you. Had a bad week, and came across this, and it was the lift my spirirt needed. I found myself identifying with Anakin, more than I ever have, as he was struggling to deal with multiple limb loss, and adapting to his prosthetics. The small moments and details are similar to my own, getting used to life with my metal leg, and carbon fiber feet. Details most gloss over in fiction. Just wanted to let you know it's appreciated. Thank you, from the bottom of my heart, and keep making the excellent content you do. Can't wait fir the million subscriber giveaway, which I know will come. We'll be celebrating it with you.

[@Iepisto]

You could make a killer Jedi cosplay

[@kevinfox500]

​@@Iepistolol. Been thinking about that option. Also consodered a T 800/850/888 option for a future Halloween gathering. Kind of like what I do on the bike. Left foot is partially gone, ball forward, right leg is above knee. Took a pair of riding jeans, shredded the pant leg over the bottom 10 inches or so. Now it flaps aroind the shin bar. They pass me, everything lopks normal. I pass them, they see metal. Makes a good icebreaker at fuel stops. Also designing some artwork for the new leg. Old one has Yoda liftong the X Wing out of the swamp, with the well known phrase from Empire. One I live by. Do. Or do not. There is no try. Have the new socket down to 3 options. Something biomechanical/ T 800 inspired. Hot rod or lowrider inspired custom paint. Or a tribute to the military, as I have family in all 5 branches. Have to sit and look over a few sketches, and go from there. Finalize a design, then get the airbrushing supplies out.

[@manwhas]

real life darth vader cosplay

[@0BI-WAN.KENOBI]

Hope you are doing fine bro.

[@kevinfox500]

Thanks guys. Yep. Hanging in there, got the 2nd foot last week. Learning to walk again, start PT and OT in a week, checkup with the prosthetist the week after.

[@lucabestea6844]

32:44 really shows what skills he could've maintained, if he could get in his upgraded suit. Loved this, escpecially the confuntation with Windu.

[@spyrite1657]

"Even if she was into it, it wasn't the proper time to find out" Lost my shit at this line - 6:08

[@thealbinodino637]

*Pente patrol:* even if she was into it. It wasn't the proper time to find out. *Me half listening:* wait wha-

[@oliversherman2414]

"Even she was into it, it wasn't the right time to find out" What kind of kinky stuff were Anakin and Padmé into lol 😂

[@oliversherman2414]

@@rachelprighel4409 lol

[@The_Emperor823]

Somehow you made Anakin being left on mustafar into a 44 minute video, Props to you bro always making good videos

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

Thank you so much!

[@The_Emperor823]

@@PentePatrolStarWars No problem

[@_DaBirbBro]

@@PentePatrolStarWars 10/10 for this video

[@LTRX_]

Palpatine squirmed as Anakin walked towards him, wielding a pure blade. "Anakin, help me! Help me!" Palpatine pleaded, forgetting that this is not the same Anakin he last knew as his old age has been catching up to him.

[@logandelaharpe6362]

Anakin help me I told you the Anakin were trying to take over

[@miniman649]

alternatively: Palpatine squirmed as Anakin walked towards him, wielding a pure blade. "Dew it!"

[@aftoncultistandsimp]

Fr

[@lelouchvibritannia4028]

@@miniman649 Alternatively: Anakin: "Dew it!" Palpatine: "I shouldn't..."

[@TheBlackenedLegacy]

@@lelouchvibritannia4028 Anakin: "You're right, you shouldn't... but I should, and. I. Will." Palpatine: Nooooo, don't Dew it-" Anakin: Peace has been restored.

[@XenoTronusWeePoo850]

Imagine being burned alive after having your limbs cut off, and then you get electrocuted soon after. That's the definition of physical pain

[@ryanqueen9705]

The "hello" at the beginning is when I chuckle and know I'm on the right channel. 😊

[@malusofficial]

“Even if she was into it, it wasn’t the proper time to find out” MAN JUST CASUALLY PUT THAT IN THERE 😂

[@majorchimera2494]

Let make a drinking game every time "Anakin" is said take a drink.

[@talonsentinelrebelrider]

Achievement Unlocked: Acute cirrhosis, liver failure imminent...

[@yarokiduncan9788]

Lol I was not ready for that joke with Padme "He thought of choking Padme, even if she was into it, now was not the time to find out"

[@anelbegic2780]

That one made me burst out laughing, we know which meme he saw for sure.

[@dakotalange2858]

What if the rakatan empire came back in the clone wars? Like they were in stasis in the unknown regions and woke up, got their stuff and starting taking stuff in The unknown regions, saw the war going on and were like “hey it’s free real estate”

[@blueiron_yt]

W idea

[@Blazeyblazeyblaze]

Also maybe the separatists and Republic would team up to destroy the rakata

[@blueiron_yt]

@@Blazeyblazeyblaze I really like the idea however I just don't see that happening. The amount of hatred the Republic and Separatist held against eachother was rather high so the likely hood of them forming an alliance would be roughly at 4 to 1.

[@Blazeyblazeyblaze]

@@blueiron_yt fair enough but the reason I say this is because the rakata could become a threat to the sith and the jedi order I agree it would be unlikely but they would have a common enemy which logically Could turn out well for the jedi and sith however I think it would be unlikely

[@dakotalange2858]

They were the original bad guys in the Star Wars setting after all not the sith and having both “orders” try to overcome them would be interesting to me

[@bizmasterTheSlav]

Wow! That's a wholesome theory today. Anakin's redemption is something you can't watch about without strong emotions. It was bittersweet and I loved it! Especially the ending, it was really, really amazing and wholesome. Thank you very much for your work!

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

Thank you so much!

[@MannyDemaga]

I love this story. Gray Jedis are my favorite characters in all of Star Wars and Anakin becoming a gray jedi would’ve made a lot of sense. Anakin was destined to bring balance no matter what path he took; when he defeated Sidious in episode 3 he did just that, but him becoming a gray jedi which is the definition of balance makes a lot of sense.

[@worldofwarcraftman2]

Just looking at sidious's responds to Anakin coming back was gold. Especially with the purified lightsaber that must have been a shock to Palpatine.

[@thedj8955]

You mentioned Ahsoka and Maul. But why not have both of them go to save him? They both would be willing to have a truce if it meant taking down Sidious/saving Anakin. Having a prime example of the light and the dark around him would even him out in my opinion.

[@E_duckYT]

Maul even offered Ahsoka to join him right before order 66 so yeah

[@thedj8955]

@@E_duckYT that was more as a sith tho. She'd need to make him agree to work with her as "Jedi" and Sith

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

I'd certainly do another 1 or 2 versions of this with them, but in this, I felt like they would've taken away from Anakin achieving victory on his own. In a way almost paralleling what Sidious did by saving him in RotS

[@trekstarsam2494]

I would have had Ahsoka and anakin get together to raise luke and leia.

[@Rodgerball]

Darth Maul and Ahsoka, not expected 😮😮😮😮😮

[@erzmagus]

Anakin seems to have lesser injuries than canon, especially to torso and lungs. Arguably, crawling back would have failed then. But possibly like Grivous Vader had artificial asthma anyway. Gloomy meeting this former Jedi... thank you for this story.

[@SuperGamefreak18]

my guess is he was able to crawl out enough to not instantly catch on fire

[@beeftheif1544]

Probbaly one of my favorite AUs, really ever. Great job my friend, may the force be with you.

[@TheMrscf98]

This was such an amazing video, seeing anakin rebuild himself from the ground up, overcoming all obsticals and finally living the happy life he always dreamed off, even without padme. He really came through for himself😊

[@evernight1405]

What if Darth sidious died from a heart attack right before he started order 66 but right after Anakin and 501 went to the Jedi Temple?

[@breadstix-]

That would be fucking hilarious

[@pascal026]

Would love to see this haha

[@James-Nobles]

dew it

[@D4rkslider]

Mace windus force ghost: lmao Take The L

[@Reaper_Rapi]

@@D4rkslider bro Magine freaking notice for skills comes here in those take the L on him, I’m too lazy to write Yoda, I swear I hate auto correct

[@SuperStig92]

Qui-Gon said it best "keep your concentration here and now where it belongs"

[@bizmasterTheSlav]

I hope Anakin will still somehow survive.

[@CAPTAIN-REX]

we all do

[@00martoneniris86]

No he wil die

[@johncherfane9316]

Did you watch the whole video?

[@Bored_Kaga]

Somehow, Skywalker survived

[@Tyler_Persad]

Well he didnt burn so far as im watching

[@yitzhakbolnick1811]

What if instead of Anakin immediately seeking vengeance against Sidious, in this video, he goes into exile. I like the idea that he is dragging himself across the scorching rocks. Instead of being as burnt as he was at the end of episode 3, he is scarred due to dragging himself across the hot rocks and from Sidious' force lightning. Falling unconscious, he would wake in a bacta tank being tended to the local worker droids, who all have a sub routine to help injured biologicals. Though they do not have the skills or data capable of giving him new limbs. Anakin would have to guide the droids in the construction of his mechanical arm, built with the scrapped and damaged battle droids and local labor droids. Once he had his arm he would build his own legs. He would have a similar exile to that of Obi-wan, where he would cut himself off from the force. He would seek work as a scrapper/occasional mechanic. I am not sure that he would go to tatooine, if he truly doesn't like sand. I think he would go to one of the lesser known outer rim planets. He would want to go somewhere where no one would recognize him, and even tho he might not know anyone he would keep to himself. His nights would be plagued with images of younglings, Jedi knights and masters alike being cut down by his own lightsaber. He would dream of his duel with Obi-wan and seeing his old master walk away with his saber, his sith master abandoning him to die a slow horrible death, and padme. padme haunted his dreams the most. the dream might be nice at first but it always ended the same way, her grasping for air as he lifted her up into the air with the force. it wouldn't be years later, after the first death star had been destroyed, that he heard the name Skywalker again. He would overhear a hushed conversation between some spacers of how some guy named Luke Skywalker destroyed the death star and was quickly gaining prestige and rank within the rebel alliance. this would lead Anakin to go out and find this Luke Skywalker, but first there was someone he had to go see. cut to Anakin walking off of a public transport, heading toward padme's memorial grave. there he would weep and apologize and come to terms with what he did to her. it's there where he attempts to connect to the force. a violent wave of images come to him. all his nightmares one after another. it's to much to handle so he shuts himself off from the force again. clearly he is not ready to come to terms with ALL that he has done. but he is determined to find out if this Luke Skywalker is indeed his son... anyways I am sure y'all can imagine how everything goes after that. I just think that Anakin having a spiritual enlightenment as soon as he left by Sidious seemed rushed. Pente I love your stuff and I am excited to see what else you put out there and in no way am I trying to diss your story!

[@breathofthewildvids1658]

Calm down

[@tchalla7401]

Aw man can you keep going. I was getting so into it lol. What would happen as soon as Anakin begins his journey to find this Luke Skywalker. “His son”

[@yitzhakbolnick1811]

@@tchalla7401 lol it would probably be a long drawn out journey. Without the force to guide him, or funds to finance the journey he would be going from lead to lead. Picking up work on each planet to afford his next trip. This would be a long and arduous journey. Time and scars hid his identity from most, but Anakin still neglected from interacting with most. He still felt it necessary to self exile. More than once did he even question whether he should be making this journey. What would he even say to Luke? Would Luke reject him? Did Anakin deserve to even be a part of Luke's life after he murdered his mother? Occasionally Anakin would try and open up to the force again, in solitude, but the same result would occur. A flash of pain, anger, dread, and sadness would awash him. He had to rely on his skills as an investigator that he had picked up during the clone wars. Three years would pass on this fruitless journey. Always 10 steps forward and a hundred steps back. Chasing a lead only to find that Luke had long been gone from this new location. Only to see the destruction that the Empire had left in its wake. Only to see his actions against the guardians of the galaxy, the jedi, take fruit. Until one day, Anakin found himself on a public transport station docking at a imperial fueling station in the mid-rim. He decided that he needed to stock up on provisions before he made his way to Ord Mantel where his next lead was taking him. When he overheard stormtroopers complaining about having to quickly get ready for a quick jump to the Hoth system. Anakin felt a great pull on his heart. He pondered, "was this the force, was it reaching out to me...?" More than instinct rather than thought, Anakin found himself smuggling on to the Interdictor-class Star Destroyer that was bound for Hoth, that was bound for Luke Skywalker.

[@Geobat16]

“Execute like sixty six.”

[@shep9231]

This... is an excellent tale!

[@justamadmax3849]

That was beautiful and an even better redemption arc for Anakin.

[@jaymilo8425]

This kind of plot twist with Sideous abandoning Anakin would've made for a hell of a next few revenge movies

[@paetonlaur3655]

This alternate ending is awesome; thank you so much for an amazing video. I love alternate lore videos on Anakin Skywalker, especially this one.

[@OfficialTaylormade1]

Lmaooo glad to see I’m not the only one who spit out their juice at 6:16 😂

[@CG87343]

I damn near died when I heard that choking line. That was absolutely hilarious 😂.

[@thrawnedits5860]

What if Dooku and grievous permanently joined forces with maul?

[@hackman669]

Bad guy trio!!!

[@Zulu-RideOrDie]

I feel like the length of the video very appropriate and this is my favorite Anakin redemption story cause he did it himself without any outside influence. Bravo! Well Done.

[@dtz1000]

This was the first fan fiction story that got me emotional near the end. Great job.

[@GC0077]

This would be a killer "what if" film. Especially the part on Ilum.

[@jspeedstar1129]

This is a bruh moment for anakin

[@oesterreichischeeiche]

Well George Lucas stated that Anakin could have survived his injuries without an operation, however he would have not been able to do anything.

[@jspeedstar1129]

@@oesterreichischeeiche I mean before the operation he was very well alive, but I just wanted to do a joke

[@mako2king609]

Me: This is literally a bruh moment *BRUH*

[@darthnexus9570]

VERY MUCH SO!!!

[@fearziel8622]

That is so dumb yest so accurate

[@paulypauleypolly6417]

I just discovered your channel 3 days ago and my job allows me to listen but not watch videos all day and thankfully your videos don’t require visual contact the whole time so I’ve probably already consumed over 10 hours of your content and I think it’s great. The best Star Wars what if’s in my opinion. Thank you for the great free content

[@wyattbartlett3660]

"Even if she was into it it wasn't the time to find out" line had me wheezing

[@juanzapata6461]

You know I don't know if artwork has been done for it - but a good illustration of Obi-Wan and Anakin embracing with tears running down their faces as Anakin says he's sorry would make a lot of fans well up with tears I think. I hope if they ever make a What If animation, such a scene would be made too. Excellent job!

[@metallicdragon3614]

I really like these what ifs. It's interesting to imagine Anakin becoming a neutral Force welder. Or a Gray Jedi as most people would like to call them. It's also interesting to see how the Empire might maintain but resemble more the Republic rather than the Empire we recognize. I do genuinely believe that Palpatine maintained and grew the empire as it is in the films. So if he died shortly after forming the empire, it makes sense the Empire would not become an authoritarian regime.

[@TheJediKermity]

I loved this so much. Though, I feel it is a bit unrealisitc that Anakin would fall in love again. He loved Padme and would even think of her after everything was said and done.

[@megaman37456]

Honestly this is one of my favorite what ifs. Where Anakin loses to Obi-Wan but doesn't burn and even manages to make up for his mistakes.

[@Intrepid_A]

What if Darth Vader has his own HK Assassin droid?

[@finger3306]

M e a t b a g

[@hackman669]

Yeah and his own Padme fembot play thing!!!😁🙃

[@finger3306]

@@hackman669 no

[@jacksonconley5117]

I have to say this is the best video you’ve ever made.

[@jayiinmistaya]

This is probably one of my top three favorites of your fanfics. Well done.

[@soularprimestudios5930]

He would either die or let's just say Ahsoka some how senses his pain and her and Rex save him I always wondered what would happen in this scenario.

[@Gogito__]

They would of been to late because obi wan sensed sidious was coming and he had to leave.

[@ch62013]

I'm surprised that neither Ahsoka or Rex cross path with him in this story.

[@Masso-gy9yu]

Attempt Number 40: What if Anakin was trained by master Fay

[@00martoneniris86]

Its 40 40

[@pascal026]

@@00martoneniris86 it’s 01:10

[@MajorLeagueAwesome_]

"even if she was into it... Now wasn't the proper time to find out." Omg dude! 🤣 Video paused. Lmao. 😂😂 That was so well placed. Effing perfect.

[@YNR_Yung]

6:08 "Even if she was into it, it wasn't the time to find out" This man rlly said that 😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@WilliamMosicki-Nystrom]

LMFAO can you imagine if Padme was in to being force chocked. (next what if video) What if ideas: 1. What if Willhuf Tarkin became Emperor 2. What if Leia fell in love with Lando Calrissian 3. What if The Wookiees joined the CIS 4. What if Komari Vosa trained Anakin Skywalker 5. What if the Sith Empire conquered the galaxy

[@NormalChannel95]

0:00 Grand Inquisitor Jumpscare

[@RyanTheDark]

This went into a whole different direction to what I expected. I love ya, Pente. Lmao

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

:)

[@locoarticwolf2181]

-What if in SWTOR, Ochos of Oblivion didn’t happen and Vitiate/Valkrion return around the movies?(In the same vain of the Darth JarJar fic you did.) -What if The Rule of Two was abolished after the Clone Wars? -What if the Sith Empire returned during the Galactic Civil War instead of the Clone Wars? -What if Vader lived at the end of RotJ, not redeemed and in charge of the Imperial Remnant? -What if Anakin saved Mace Windu and stayed in the light during Order 66? -What if Thrawn was present during the Original Trilogy? -What if Anakin/Vader was a double agent and played the long game like your Rebel Thrawn fic? -What if Maul was found by the Jedi before Sidious? -What if Vader,Thrawn and Several Imperials started an Imperial Rebellion separate from the Rebels,which really took off around the DS1 destruction? -What if Vader never burned on Mustafar? -What if Grevious was a Republic General but still hated the Jedi? -What if Starkiller lived at the end of TFU1 and later trained the Skywalker Twins? -What if Lord Starkiller lived at the end of TFU1 dark side ending and ignoring the dlc, basically replacing Vader?

[@doomtitan1172]

A republic general grievous is way more interesting to me.

[@suggswithabox]

One for each movie! What if Jar Jar was killed by Darth Maul on Tatooine? What if Padme fell in love with Obi-Wan instead of Anakin because of his speech about sand? What if Anakin going to the Dark Side actually saved Padme? What if Han Solo never existed? What if Rogue One didn't bother stealing the Death Star plans and they all joined the Empire? What if Luke liked life on Tatooine so much he didn't want to leave? What if Leia sold out the rebels to the Empire? What if no one could be bothered to rescue Han Solo? What if Rey knew who her family were? What if Luke wasn't where the map said he would be? What if Chewie killed Kylo Ren?

[@adammartinez8061]

Han Solo not being rescued is kind of understandable, considering that They are dealing with A Hutt and his bounty hunters……Yup……Makes it almost impossible to rescue Han. Especially since Han was transferred to Jabba Palace…..PALACE……Yup…. Sneaking into Jabba’s Palace……Where The Hutt and his bounty hunter resides…..Yup, the plan will go very wrong.

[@silverblade357]

​@@adammartinez8061 What if Luke didn't send the droids, Lando, Leia, or Chewie into the palace and just blew the place up with his X-Wing? After all, Han would have been very well protected in his carbonized state.

[@bizmasterTheSlav]

6:15 - that's where I laughed my guts out

[@betterlatethannever4529]

Imagine if instead of taking back his children, Anakin lived under the guise as their uncle.

[@allanwhite5747]

This is one of your best stories I've ever heard, totally well written, and brilliant. I always hoped for a story like this, this was how ROTS should have ended.

[@soniasharma5187]

I agree the only thing is that the originals wouldn’t make sense then but I agree with you with everything else

[@jordanelza8806]

33:00 and 34:10 Anakin does actually achieve balance in the Force here. I love this hypothetical situation. Well done.

[@benjaminobienu5297]

Anakin being abandoned by Sidious on Mustafar is a wake-up call; Anakin to see the true face of Palpatine and able to redeem himself without becoming vengeful 2.0 Maul, and what I really love about this video is how Anakin can have limbs again and able to reconcile with Obi-Wan and able love again with Dawes as his new love interest which is very interesting. That includes Anakin being more of a grey Jedi and able to calm down and more reasonable with Mindu, the vengeful one. This is a great story, Mr. Pente Patrol; please keep up the fantastic work and no matter what happens, always follow your heart to your passion. May the force be with you!

[@matthewmann8969]

Well unlike Maul the darkside was not the only thing Anakin Or Dooku knew even Asajj knew more then the dark side yeah.

[@nicolasa.q3301]

“His chest was full of lightning marks and….it was very ugly”… 😂😂😂😂😂.Good one

[@wargamesmaster]

What if the story of the game Force Unleashed was the canon version of how the rebel alliance formed? What if the game Dark Force was the canon version of the mission to steal the Death Star plans? I think that's the right game, it's just that Kyle Katarn also has to deal with an admiral who created Dark Troopers supersoldiers. What if Luke Skywalker was the main character of the PC game Rebel Assault II (aka "Rookie One")? He was just a rookie when he joined the rebel alliance in Episode IV, after all. What if the events of the SWTOR operation "Chamber of Eternity" happened during the clone war? I think it would be interesting to see both the GAR & the CIS fight for the newly discovered Belsavis and ultimately causing the awakening of the "infernal one" Soa (who also created/led the pureblood Sith species until the rebellion of Sith king Adas).

[@claytonrosson4504]

Wonderful wonderful wonderful! Very well thought out and executed what if. This is the first video I have watched of yours and I am now instantly a fan!

[@thosko98]

At first I though that Anakin would just die on Mustafar, but him surviving anyway makes sense. He is the chosen one after all and he can't die until he has fulfilled the prophesy. Although you could argue he would still indirectly do that if Luke were to defeat Palpatine instead of what happened in the movies.

[@biggreeve5511]

Mustafar is actually closer to bespin, hoth, utapau, Naboo, dagobah, crait, Endor, and geonosis than it was to tattooine

[@therealnearwater]

I didn’t expect Mace Windu to have survived, very good twist

[@robertruse6552]

I really like this one I wish it was longer maybe it'll make the part 2 i don't know this one is good at telling Jordan story of lot keep up the good work and May the force be with you

[@LordMayorOfDairyBell]

I would love to see a video where you follow-up the events of Star Wars Infinities: What if Luke Didn't Destroy the Deathstar? In the comic, Leia is captured and then trained a sith, Luke believes Leia is dead and spends five years training with Yoda, Luke turns Leia and Vader back to the Light, Vader dies fighting Palpatine while Luke and Leia flee, and YODA HIJACKS THE DEATHSTAR AND CRASHES IT RIGHT ON TOP OF PALPATINE!

[@nathanbriggs4747]

I won't lie this is a great thought experiment. If Sidious threw Skywalker away then he could have possibly redeemed himself. And though never being a Jedi would be supportive and possibly helpful of the order. I so wish Quigon would have survived. Anakin would be a great dude without Obi-Wan. I find this story to be one of the best you have done.

[@edgaracajabon9522]

He would've become Darkman wearing a trenchcoat with a hat fill of gauze and living in an abandon laboratory.

[@dianesinger9729]

Well done, I really liked this story especially the twist of Anakin being left to fend for himself and he found peace in the force

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

Thank you so much!

[@MrBizkit1003]

Not bad not bad at all, I did enjoyed the alternate story timeline I guess you could call it cry little bit but was glad to see Anakin redeem himself. You obviously put a lot of thought and work into your story and I do appreciate all the hard work. Made me think how your story would have made a great what if storyline

[@anthonyogletree6660]

Only once we've lost everything can we become who we're truly capable of being. My favorite so far.

[@gabrielryan-leon832]

I love how realistic this story feels

[@ricardokojin7]

part of me finds it hard to believe Obi one would ever forgive anakin...but then I remember he is a jedi after all

[@creidy2018]

I know you did NOT just make a joke about Padme having a choking kink when talking about Vader force choking her 😂😭

[@hellopuppyarecool]

All that physical pain and suffering along with the news of Padme's death would make Anakin be extremely deep into the dark side, more than what he was as Darth Vader

[@Toumahitoedits]

This was an unexpected what if. Interesting to say the least...

[@suguhayuuka8160]

28:49 Imagine Mace windu insulting anakin while laughing and expecting anakin to get angry with insults like "Anakin Skysucker"

[@wyattpotter2103]

This was super great one of my favorites. I'm sad that you won't be uploaded quite as much as before but at the same time I think you definitely deserve a break. Watching your videos makes my day a little better.

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

Thank you so much!

[@marcusisgod2592]

This supports plagueis theory that losing flesh does not limit potential power in the force, you just have the will of spirit to persevere.

[@dylanbaptista1103]

I like that anakin became a grey jedi and didnt fully go back

[@darthvader78441]

Still your best video to date. The orchestral soundtrack(at the start) is haunting.

[@anewmystery]

It's interesting to see if Sidious stuck to his anger and let Anakin Die for his failure, Thanks PPSW

[@daverage4729]

That was a great one. Nice to see the villainous Windu get his comeuppance. Lol!

[@Yang_1230]

I can’t believe Palpatine would leave a non burned anakin it’s what he was hoping 😢

[@easternequinox9324]

Dude this was just plain beautiful. One of the few videos that I've watched from beginning to end. It's just that beautiful. More power to you man.

[@dillonpercy1058]

All except the Dawes thing, I don't believe he would have got another partner.

[@ascensiongenesis_sigma]

- What if Anakin achieved inner balance earlier - What if Obi-wan mastered Ataru after along with Soresu (honouring Qui-Gon) - What if Obi-wan Found an ancient jedi Library? - What if Padme had Darth Vectivus' holocron as an artifact?

[@jarmoliebrand2005]

Very interesting to see an Anakin story in which he truly achieves balance in the force despite losing everything.

[@timothydeose1639]

Wouldn’t the separatist base on Mustafar have some medical bay in it? Wouldn’t that medical bay have a medical droid and a Bacta tank inside that medical bay? Wouldn’t Anakin have spent some time in that Bacta tank stabilizing his wounds before leaving Mustafar?

[@wearywolfkins4755]

Shouldn't Padme have survived in this? Wasn't it canonised at some point that Sidiuos drained her life to keep Vader alive?

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

Yes technically, but I decided to keep her death for Anakin's motivation

[@silverblade357]

The Count: "Two. That's two idiots that can't secure the kill. Ah ha ha."

[@cherry-blossom8]

That’s cool one! My what if ideas? What if ani and Obi and ahsoka were all chosen ones? What if ani had dreams of Obi wan dying insead of padme dying? What if clones never born as human but born as a droid? What if Luke Time travelled to the clone wars? What if Luke and Leia were switched places? What if Leia Married Lando? What if Luke and Leia were born in corusant? What if Kanan Jarres was chosen one? What if ezra killed grand insquitor?

[@john98765333]

I was not expecting that bit with Windu to happen. Even less that Windu would be killed there. But, quite the interesting video! And quite good!