What if Darth Vader Went to War with Sauron and Middle Earth

[@youtubenutzer6620]

Yoda and Gandalf talking about Live would be so fun to hear. 😂

[@gono4806]

It’s funny that Sidious mentioned Dooku.

[@w1ndgeneral226]

What if General Grievous wore the Carnage Symbiote?

[@Fenris77]

4:10 Wow, Tie-fighters actually have a target feast for once...

[@ReconViper1]

I haven't finished the video yet, but I think Vader's going to be confused when he sees Saruman.

[@NormalChannel95]

I can imagine Darth Vader and Palpatine's interaction with Saruman

[@jimmideerichards9554]

😂😂😂 yeah….. you look familiar… have we meet? 😂😂😂

[@Jgcbjhff]

They’re talking about budgets and finances

[@mehranpritchard4314]

Saruman interaction with count dooku

[@803bucho]

I feel like this is easy? I mean Saruman and Gandalf could be a serious problem but it would just be them. No army in LOTR can even be perceived as a threat against the Empire 😂

[@ASNS117Zero]

There are things in Middle Earth that solo all of Star Wars. They just don't show up in Lord of the Rings.

[@w1ndgeneral226]

And DON'T underestimate Sauron, all of The Lord of The Rings and Hobbit movies were what Sauron could do WITHOUT the ring, if he got it, he would be ten times more powerful than what we've seen.

[@Htarogoehs]

⁠​⁠​⁠​⁠@@w1ndgeneral226right, vader may be the chosen one, but sauron is a godlike being, and with the ring hes easily the strongest in middel earth, now i now vader did kill the mortis gods, but the son and daugther’s power are based on what side of the force is leaning on, and the son was killed before he could leave mortis and empower the dark more, sauron does not have that kind of limit, the only limit he got is based on his skills, as his not a fighter, but a ringmaker with a silver tongue, im sure he could beat vader if all he need to do is break him mentally, as for the empire as ahole, depends on if they use star destroyers to bombard mordor, or overwelming numbers or the death star, but that does not seem fair tho.

[@francothebrazilian2764]

@@w1ndgeneral226no way does sword and arrows beat full auto blasters. Even magic wouldn’t defeat a planet destroying laser beam from space.

[@w1ndgeneral226]

@francothebrazilian2764 There are beings that can LITERALLY lift islands in middle earth, and do you have any idea how big dragons can get? And most of them are less than powerful than Sauron at his PEAK, Not to mention he is incredibly deceitful and manipulative, he managed to control Lumanor(I think that's how you spell it), an entire continent under his influence, it was so bad that the entire continent had to be SUNK by higher beings while Sauron was still on it, *but he survived and went straight back to conquering.*

[@toddkurzbard]

"...Vader takes a deep breath..." CAN he even?

[@mateuszslawinski1990]

Deep, hissing, asthmatic breath😛

[@sw-rs]

Did you forget to add the music on this one?

[@ethanharley1458]

What if Anakin was a Saiyan sent to Tatooine as a baby?

[@jasonarmstrong8070]

YESSSS!! ANAKIN DOING A KAMEHAMEHA WOULD BE MY DREAM

[@bobafett7613]

He would need to go to Roshi to learn that

[@IBelieveinJoehendryTNA]

vader be like to Saruman, count dooko what happend to you?

[@tmote-O76]

It was a nice story. Left me a little conflicted, but it was entertaining. What if Anakin was born a Hutt or a Da Shade? Both species are Force resistant but not nulls.

[@joeybavis]

good video, just one little thing, you show a photo of Vader's tie advanced instead of a tie bomber, when it is the latter thats mentioned

[@MichaelHarder-e6m]

Can you make please, what if Morgoth visit the Star-Wars Universe, after escaping the Door of Night?

[@Joshua-tb3dl]

What up Darth theorist would you make a video on what if Obi wan and Ashoka join anakin in revenge of the sith

[@traveller4583]

It's a great story. I just want to make a comment about the ring. The ring provides the wearer power based on the wearers spiritual energy. So for frodo, who's a hobbit and good at being sneaky, it made him invisible. However, for Gandalf for example, it would provide him with enhanced magic rather than make him invisible. So it would probably make Vader a stronger force user, rather than just making him invisible.

[@ASNS117Zero]

I can tell you exactly what would happen if Vader and co rocked up on Middle Earth. Let's say they show up in the Death Star. Eru: Lol. Lmao even. *Unmakes the Death Star, Vader, Palpatine, the Corusca Galaxy, and the Force itself.*

[@Rooikunbo]

What if Padme discovers she's force sensitive during the clone wars? What if Anikan trained Lop after Ashoka left?

[@christophdewarenne9309]

Sarumon is in Isengard, not Mordor. It's Sauron who is in Mordor.

[@TFAric]

Normally don't care much fro crossovers but this was a fun ride. Also idea. What if Grievous failed to kidnap Palpatine just before ep 3?

[@alexander.tahtadjian]

Why do I have the feeling that the mere idea of Vader going to war with Sauron and Middle-Earth would not only give the Sith a run for their money but is also a very bad thing for everyone involved…specifically their enemies. Plus its nice to see a Lord Of The Rings x Star Wars ‘what if’ story since these are two of the greatest franchises ever and for some reason Middle-Earth would fit perfectly well within the SW universe. Plus, who doesn’t love a good battle between light and dark with two of the greatest franchises ever. Plus Vader and Sauron teaming up was so badass. Also the voice acting for Vader, Gandalf, Aragorn, Saruman, Legolas, Treebeard, Sauron, Obi-Wan and Luke was just amazing. I do have a few ideas for some possible what if’s: 1) What if Rey was a Mandalorian…essentially what if Din Djarin found Rey and took her in as a Foundling. 2) What if Ezra was a Mandalorian…something like how both his parents were Mandalorians who left Mandalore and went to start their own lives (you could still keep most of Ezra’s backstory) and potentially make Ezra and Sabine a couple (since Disney won’t, we have too…#ezrabine4ever. 3) What if Jango Fett and/or Boba Fett Joined the Republic…I think something interesting could happen with this. 4) What if Rey, Finn and Poe went back in time to the Clone Wars…this would make the World Between Worlds even more of an important focal point and I could also see them get along well with Anakin, Ashoka, Rex and the rest of the 501st (it would be fun to see Rey, Finn and Poe join the 501st) I hope these are some amazing ideas for some potential What if’s

[@ATalesTruth-]

Can you do what is Sauron was in Star Wars during the phantom menace and tried to take over the galaxy

[@MichaelHarder-e6m]

True. After he learned about the technical news, I see in my eyes Star Destroyers with the Flaming Eye. This should be a great story!

[@mehranpritchard4314]

Saruman vs Count Dooku should been added to the group.👍

[@Sasuke81a]

Gollum will be crying 'My Precious!'

[@darthblanket2121]

Well, I think Palps would have done more to claim the ring. Empire would have won with low-diff

[@KeyMasterX]

Even in What If's, Sean Bean can't avoid death.

[@Umbrellacorporation1172]

They didn't have to do my boy Sean like that first game of thrones and Lord of the rings and now this bro can't catch a break.😂

[@barronstormblade4552]

@@Umbrellacorporation1172 He dies in everything he's in the only movie that, I know of where he doesn't die is national treasure.

[@leiratno820]

>burial of heroes via Mount Doom's lava Tolkien would spin so much in his grave that if he were connected to an electric turbine, he alone would power an entire city.

[@cunningsmile4166]

I think Middle Earth has had enough of being stuck betwen Sauron and the Sith.

[@johnhickman8391]

Wonder what Palpatine, Vader, etc would do if facing Smaug?

[@BlueBoxRevan]

Damn Theorist, you are on the roll lately!! 🍿

[@jerome96114]

Huh? Gandalf isn't even there in that instance. He is still dead/ being rebirthed. As well I kinda doubt the Valar & Eru would just stand by with an interstellar force attacking their planet.

[@mohammadhosseini6675]

To be fair Eru did kind of let Sauron get away with a lot of crap.

[@DelinquentChibi]

@@mohammadhosseini6675 And Melkor, don't forget everything happened because of Melkor.

[@mohammadhosseini6675]

What if L ( Death Note ) try to solve the Clone Wars mystery e.g Who is Sidous, What was the True Cause of the Clone Wars and so or whatever you need to put him in

[@fireinthesky3379]

ooo that's a very good one.

[@KingPlaymakerChampion]

Hay you should do a Star Wars crossover with Voltron Legendary Defender

[@toddkurzbard]

Vader is an immensely powerful Force user. Sauron is a MAIAR, a demigod. I'm putting my money on the Dark Lord... ...Of Mordor.

[@francothebrazilian2764]

I am putting my money on the laser beam from space

[@GothReaper616]

Not a bad story. BUT: i have to bring up a few points. Wouldnt Sauron had felt darth vader? And the gods? Could darth vaders presence maybe have freed melkor? And...why was gandalf with the fellowship at the river side? And aragorn did not have anduril at that point, so how did he proof his title to the undead? And saruman was at isengard, not mordor. Even after the empire destroyed mordor and the barad ur, saurons spirit would remain. The ring could have seduced and allured darth vader. But, in the end..it was amazing! I am a fan of both star wars and tolkiens work. And that is why i would love a multiple part series, going into more detail. Just imagine a version of Darth Vader, using the one ring, with sauron whisperin in his head...using his tormented, agonised mind against him...fueling the darkside with knowledge of millenia of evil.👍😈

[@ASNS117Zero]

The entire scenario doesn't make sense if you know LotR lore. The Valar would *instantly* get involved and unmake the invaders. If the Force contested to the point where the Valar aren't able, then Eru gets involved, and casually *unmakes the force* -- LotR's top tiers are so far above what Star Wars is capable of handling it's not even funny.

[@GothReaper616]

@ASNS117Zero true words

[@DelinquentChibi]

@@ASNS117Zero Assuming Eru Iluvatar would even care to get involved. He DID allow Melkor (and Ungoliant with the two trees) to wreak devastation with only the Valar to oppose them. It took a LOT for him to finally get involved. (Granted, I haven't finished the Silmarillion yet, so forgive me if I'm missing something: I'm not there yet lol)

[@vieuxreveur617]

Here’s my idea: What If, on September 11, 2001, it hadn’t been a plane but a Star Destroyer that crashed into the Twin Towers, imagine our world against the Empire.

[@mattdotsonrailfanproductio266]

Or what if the empire invaded earth during world war 2

[@vieuxreveur617]

@@mattdotsonrailfanproductio266 It could be nice, but it would be cool to see humanity with a much greater power. WWII is quite weak… why not the current era? Like 2025.

[@tragickai5856]

So as a lotr fanatic, Vader and the force pales in comparison to the power of the wizards of middle earth. The wizards were made in the image of the old gods basically the god kin elves were 2nd. Elves would prove difficult for imperial ground attacks. Sauron alone is a fallen lesser god he would have immense power even in the state of the watch tower. This would end up being a combined attack of immeasurable power not seen since the oldest wars on middle earth. The wizards conjuring calamities to destroy the forces of the empire.

[@charleswolfe8896]

Please the next crossover you do, please have it be what if Anakin Skywalker became doctor Manhattan?

[@Rooikunbo]

What if Coruscant was infected by a TF furry virus while Anikan was away?

[@johnn9977]

Wow super great job 👏

[@BitoyV3]

What if Vader and Thrawn went to war against Wakanda and the Avengers

[@TenkoBerry]

Quite Interesting 👌

[@Shia10101]

How dare Sean Bean die in a SW what if 😂

[@owenscott6159]

What if Tom hardy venom was in star war original trilogy

[@teamalagtic6141]

What if malcor fleed to the star wars univers after this happent.

[@28467Vanus]

What if Mace Windu left the Jedi Order instead of, or with, Count Dooku? What if Palpatine saved Shmi Skywalker as a way to bind Anakin even closer to him? What if Anakin was born a Sith Pureblood? What if Illum bestowed a naturally red kyber crystal on Anakin? How would the Jedi react? What if General Grevious was made of beskar and force sensative? He would be an absolute monster if given proper Sith training... What if Palpatine created the Imperial Knights as a light side counterbalance to the Inquisitors? What if Palpatine turned Ahsoka to the dark side as a way of turning Anakin to the dark side? What if Ahsoka was with Anakin and chose to join him when he pledged himself to Palpatine and became Darth Vader? What if Count Dooku ordered an unaltered clone of himself to be an apprentice and heir? What if the Republic lost the First Battle of Geonosis? What if the Clone Army was trained by contracted Mandalorians? What if Palpatine didn't kill Darth Plagueis, and they turned Anakin to the dark side together and trained him? What if Plo Koon fell to the dark side before or during the Clone Wars? Just a few what-if ideas...

[@malcolmhead6333]

What if count dooku fought Saruman

[@barronstormblade4552]

What if Anakin crash lands on middle earth and joins the fellowship.

[@Agandaur-fq8jy]

What happened to the army of the dead in the end and The Witch King and his Nazguls!?

[@TheDeviousBandit]

8:07 vader is actually much weaker than even third age sauron

[@LucioRodriguez-m2b]

What if Anakin was trained by Eru Illivitar

[@Godzilla00X]

Orbital bombardment, gg no re

[@ericj6636]

BDZ Base Delta Zero Bye bye Middle Earth

[@Followerofchrist221]

Wrong Sauron who is literally the devil in that universe has the one ring and can’t be killed unless you throw it into mount doom which by the way none of the Star Wars characters know that so they are absolutely fucked as anyone who try’s to use the ring will be corrupted by it so again they lose.

[@taransrinivasan4475]

@@Followerofchrist221can’t the Death Star just blow up the planet

[@ASNS117Zero]

The Valar would casually unmake whatever is attacking from orbit by singing if an extraterrestrial threat rocked up on the planet. I'm not kidding. There are deities in Tolkein's works that casually solo all of Star Wars. They just don't show up in LotR.

[@francothebrazilian2764]

@@ASNS117Zeronah laser beam from space still wins

[@newbornviking9721]

What if The headless horseman of sleepy hollow is in the star wars Universe ?

[@yourtruelordandsaviour]

What if Obi Wan had accepted the Death Sticks in AotC?

[@grizzlybarrows4390]

What if Palpatine had planet Vegeta destroyed during the Clone Wars and Gokus pod ended up at the Jedi temple

[@EarlTruitt]

He's not getting past Frieza

[@ASNS117Zero]

Genuinely... how? There are numerous individual fighters on that planet that can expy the Death Star as individual persons. Unless Palps does it covert with a bioweapon, this just isn't going to work.

[@mehranpritchard4314]

Perfect ❤

[@donnyjackson1309]

Timeline allowed for Sauruman and Tyranus to not be in the same room. 26:00 lol nevermind

[@maimonidesofcordoba1343]

Do these crossovers 1. Batman - what if Darth Sidious used Scarecrow to Turn Anakin to the Dark Side 2. A Christmas Carol- What if Yoda was visited by the Three Spirits of Christmas during the Clone Wars 3. Rayman- What if the Robot Pirates were allied to the Separatists and Rayman 2 took place in the Clone Wars 4. It- What if Vader fought Pennywise 5. The Boys- What if Homelander was a Sith Experiment created by Sidious 6. Harry Potter- What if Voldemort was a Sith Lord in the Star Wars Universe 7. Digimon- What if Myotismons spirit went into Anakin/ Vader instead of Yukio Oikawa

[@leonjenkins5741]

Good story But I wanted to see the bad guys win. The rebels and jedi intervene Seem too convenient , I would of like to see the Empires come and took the ring and leave middle earth in ruin and everyone just wondering what was that

[@jacobwalker3060]

What if the IMF was in Star Wars?

[@KingJim97]

What if deadpool was in the SW universe?

[@KeyMasterX]

He already did this What If.

[@KingJim97]

@KeyMasterX aight cool, thanks 😊

[@nicholaslisle7089]

Can the Empire win once?

[@IBelieveinJoehendryTNA]

your a wizard Vader

[@jermailpeterson8983]

What if Anakin switched minds with jar jar, and, Palpatine thought, how did they let this bumbling buffoon into The Jedi order🤣🤣🤣!!!

[@lemonke4209]

We NEED THIS 😂😂

[@davidbarry282]

Ten mins in and cheering on the empire

[@jakstorm3180]

The death star comes into orbit above middle earth Sauran and morgoth surrender

[@francothebrazilian2764]

4 star destroyers would do the job perfectly fine

[@ChrisMcElroy-k9n]

Not a vs Harry Potter theory?

[@djashovel]

I wonder how powerful darth sidious Would be if he got the one ring ( And I mean by a power multiplier like 10 20 or 30 More powerful than usual )

[@epiczk0n141]

I feel like he would just draw the attention of Sauron. The real question is could Sauron do anything to Palpatine without his physical form if he did take the ring.

[@tommyhedden]

At least Frodo died lol

[@Rick79LUFC]

The would be no contest lol like a Morden day army taking on a medieval army lol even with spells and magic middle earth would los2 10/10 times against the Galactic empire from star wars lol a silly match up ....but a fun one 😊

[@ChrisMcElroy-k9n]

I thought they were called oliphants

[@kieranhughes558]

aragorn, not aragon

[@Followerofchrist221]

Wrong Sauron who is literally the devil in that universe has the one ring and can’t be killed unless you throw it into mount doom which by the way none of the Star Wars characters know that so they are absolutely screwed as anyone who try’s to use the ring will be corrupted by it so again also the Maia are a thing which is like arch angels hell they even have their own version of God so yeah if we are going by lore Star Wars still gets utterly destroyed simply because of Sauron and they’re lack of knowledge regarding the way the rings work. Also Vader absolutely would fall to the ring eventually because I don’t want to deal with a Sauron juiced up with space Jesus which Vader is technically as the chosen one of his universe so yeah

[@Thunder-Ghost]

Exactly

[@MichaelHarder-e6m]

Please reboot this story. I love that story, but, a lore correct story is even better.

[@shadowfast541]

What if ahsoka was the one who betrays the clones on umbara?

[@dillonroberts9945]

That would hurt so much more! Good idea

[@reeceemms1643]

Star wars would win since they have superior technology.

[@IBelieveinJoehendryTNA]

middle earth would have no change

[@nicolechrista4190]

@@IBelieveinJoehendryTNA until the Valar and Eru show up

[@francothebrazilian2764]

@@nicolechrista4190they ain’t beating a laser beam from space

[@nicolechrista4190]

@@francothebrazilian2764I dont think you get the fact that Eru is Tolkiens version of God, an almighty creator of everything. The Valar are a Pantheon of Powerful God-Angels. Even if they destroy one of the Valars Physical Forms, they will just reform almost instantly. If the Star wars Galaxy is Ea, then Eru created it and the Valar shaped it, Eru will just unmake the Death Star and Vader and Sidious, because i think he would intervene if there is something threatening the existence of Arda. Yes, they would beat a laser beam from Space, easily

[@Rambam1776]

Okay, half of me is going This is the stupidest thing I've ever heard, who would waste their time with this? And the other half of me cannot wait to listen. Truly, the internet is a strange place.

[@chromxrobinandcorrinxcamil9031]

>:)

[@TheRealCHIMShady]

Based but insanely schizoid video