what if every girl group had only four members? (part 1)

[@shujinko2944]

BP, MAMAMOO and aespa would make great 4 member groups

[@kim_minju_]

IKR

[@Blanka767]

Please, make the most all rounded 4th gen group with members of multiple groups

[@arbuz510]

if we're following the concept of this video (4 members), I'd choose Soyeon, Haewon, Giselle, Hayoung otherwise add Lily, Hikaru, Yves and Jiwoo to them, I feel like that group would be unstoppable

[@User-ev6mz]

I'd choose soyeon,karina,yeji,jiwoo, Haewon.

[@ratuneta]

Group With 4 Member? All rounder? 1. Karina (Leader, Lead Dancer, Lead Rapper, Lead Vocalist, Visual, Center, Face of the group) 2. Yeji (Main Dancer, Sub Vocalist & Rapper) 3. Yunjin (Lead Vocalist & Lead Rapper) 4. Haewon (Main Vocalist, Maknae)

[@Blanka767]

@@ratuneta you can make with more members if you want

[@ratuneta]

@@Blanka767 add youngest like kyujin since that girl very well rounder

[@tybaker_x7565]

Lily and Haewon are honestly a must in NMIXX

[@ha._.bbangbby]

The 4 members chosen for Nmixx are literally just my bias line

[@Nameless_mixes]

It was a brave decision of you to remove Teddy from BP. They look like they’d have so much promise as a 4 member group! 🙌 (Just in case it’s not obvious, I’m joking. I know that BP is already a 4 member group lol)

[@RoyaleMusical]

chae + momo with 3MIX would be a good 5 member group

[@elfy2006]

Love how you adjust some og positions when they are wrong (like wendy lead dancer and not irene)

[@guigzs]

Yess!!! it was great that HF ​​adjusted the positions

[@lluuiizzff]

i would put momo with 3mix, she'd be the only member that couldnt sing, but she would make up for it with her her dancing and rapping skills!

[@annagurtner9606]

NMIXX IS SO DAMN TALENTED

[@_7normalboysfromKorea]

It must be so hard to choose only 4 members in nmixx they all are so talented 🦋😌

[@_7normalboysfromKorea]

@@Cryforme- ikrrrrrrr Nmixx is such a talented group 🫶

[@Verowinday777]

@@Cryforme-yeah but the ones in this video (lily,haewon,kyujin and jiwoo) are the most talented members so they are the best choice

[@baalz6391]

I love how there was no point in putting in the 4 membered groups but you did anyways-

[@beomgyuarmpithair]

90% of my predictions were correct that which members hopeflakes would choose in this video

[@Awes731]

adding red velvet was such a drag to Yeri LMFAOOO

[@chaesaura]

disagree

[@multifan6679]

Same goes to Itzy's Chaeryoung

[@yummyeon]

did they lied tho ....

[@PureHoneyBoo]

Ive would just not work without Wonyoung

[@eunchae_niki_maknae]

It would be really sad, if these groups had 4 members 😢(except for the ones that already have 4 members 😑)

[@abc_jv_xyz]

companies would prioritize visuals over dance, btw

[@arbuz510]

I love this idea, it's so creative! can't wait for the other parts I tried guessing which members you'd choose for each group, I got all of them right except twice, I was sure you'd pick Nayeon, Chae and Jihyo and I knew you'd pick either Momo or Jeongyeon but I went with JY 😭 also I love how you adjusted the positions for every group

[@user-yp5di6eg2d]

Mamamoo is such a well-rounded group😎 looks like they'll win this too😅

[@smilxey_]

Loved this video! I think it would be cool if you would also add Dreamcatcher in the next round and would maybe do a dance analysis for them? Cuz I’m very curious about it tbh, but don’t stress yourself with it^^

[@sohini2006]

The way these æspa's positions are already official except for the center 😮

[@bishuthepanda]

and the removal of winter's visual position

[@ratuneta]

​@@bishuthepandavisual just a credit by the SM Talent wise it's a same she a Lead Vocalist/Dance also Sub rapper okeish

[@revellia5121]

TY FOR INCLUDING YOUNGEUN! She was the one that caught my eye and I never see anyone talk about her. I think she’s talented I hope other people see it too!

[@diduii4507]

As a youngeun stan i feel you, she deserves more attention😭, she is so important for the group, and she is one of the best concept master i've ever seen

[@Anjan_-]

Nmixx without sullyoon would feel incomplete but the 4 here play a significant role in nmixx

[@KoALa_tOo_BAsIc]

Nmixx without all of them will feel incomplete

[@Anjan_-]

​@@Forda43yes

[@imbetter-jo7dh]

how js saying she doesnt do much for the group. her talent isnt outstanding compared to some of her bandmates, and she is so dry. like it seems like she has no humour tbh. like i cant remember any memorable moments form her if im being honest, yk?

[@imbetter-jo7dh]

but she is still very talented and amazing

[@kadotanoia]

i love that you added billlie in this!!! ❤️

[@damieon_]

QUEEN DAYEON SLAY

[@_7normalboysfromKorea]

“But Chaeryeong is an all rounder”

[@rose_x_me]

Lmao, not the "Chaeryeong is all rounder in Itzy and is the best dancer in 4th gen"

[@_7normalboysfromKorea]

@@rose_x_me lol

[@daniellegula7506]

Yeji is better in singing and dance, arguably in rap too VCL : Yeji E > Chaeryeong F+ DNC : Yeji LT5 > Chaeryeong HT7 RAP : both are T7 cuz ITZY's rap verse aren't good.. Ryujin is T4 because she have good rap verse in their covers..

[@_7normalboysfromKorea]

@@daniellegula7506 yes I agree but u know Chae Stans likes to be delusional and act like she’s all rounded when miss girl is weak in most categories. Yeji beats Chae in dance, ofc vocals, rap and stage presence. Btw Yeji is a tier 6 rapper

[@daniellegula7506]

@@_7normalboysfromKorea oh really? I didn't know that she's a T6 rapper.. what's her best rap so far? i really like her rap in Mafia even if most of the people think it's cringy 😅😅

[@jungwoniz]

imo IVE 1. Naoi Rei * Main Rapper * Sub Vocalist 2. Kim Jiwon (Liz) * Main Vocalist * Lead Dancer * Maknae 3. Ahn Yujin * Lead Vocalist * Rapper * Main Dancer * Leader 4. Jang Wonyoung * Sub Vocalist * Lead Dancer * Center * FOTG * Visual

[@LJPPKGGFS-C]

Agree with Chaehyun still in Kep1er though her dancing just isn't it, she's the only real vocalist of the group.

[@yummyeon]

her dancing is far better than bahorsie or yujin the '''idol''' since 6years lmao

[@LJPPKGGFS-C]

@@yummyeon Be respectful. Stop calling Bahiyyih names just beacuse of her looks or because her siblings debuted :// You have better things to pursue other than hate. Chaehyun is slightly better than Bahiyyih but Yujin can outdance them both, imo.

[@yummyeon]

@@LJPPKGGFS-C i have no respect for miss ponyville and will never have because she’s a cheater and a fraudulent idol that ruined a trainee life, hope she get even more hate next year yujin is a lame idol that doesn’t stand out in anything except being a petty immature «leader ». meanwhile chaehyun can outsing the whole group + is way more noticeable on stage than yujin despite her having a better energy, chaehyun is maybe not as good technically but on stage her mistakes and weakness are way less noticeable. and mind you yujin debuted in 2015, she had a decade to fix all of that

[@arbuz510]

[LONG COMMENT] thought a bit about it and decided to do few groups myself, boy groups included (it was hard 😭): fromis_9: - Hayoung - leader, main dancer, lead vocalist - Jiwon - main vocalist - Seoyeon - main rapper, lead dancer, sub vocalist - Chaeyoung - lead rapper, lead dancer, sub vocalist, maknae ATEEZ: - Seonghwa - leader, lead dancer, lead vocalist, lead rapper - San - main dancer, lead vocalist, center, FOTG - Mingi - main rapper, lead dancer, sub vocalist - Jongho - main vocalist, maknae LOONA: - Yves - leader, main dancer, main vocalist - Jinsoul - main rapper, sub vocalist, visual - Heejin - main dancer, lead vocalist, lead rapper, center, visual - Olivia Hye - main rapper, lead dancer, sub vocalist, maknae Stray Kids: - Lee Know - leader, main dancer, lead vocalist, sub rapper, visual - Changbin - main rapper, lead dancer, sub vocalist - Han - main rapper, main vocalist, lead dancer - Seungmin - main vocalist, maknae TXT - Soobin - leader, lead vocalist - Yeonjun - main rapper, main dancer, main vocalist, center, FOTG - Beomgyu - lead dancer, sub vocalist, rapper, visual - Taehyun - main vocalist, lead dancer, rapper, maknae NCT DREAM: - Mark - leader, main rapper, main dancer, lead vocalist, center - Renjun - lead vocalist, lead dancer - Haechan - main vocalist, lead dancer - Jisung - main dancer, lead rapper, sub vocalist, maknae Dreamcatcher: - SuA - main dancer, lead vocalist, lead rapper - Siyeon - main vocalist - Yoohyeon - main vocalist, lead dancer, visual - Dami - main rapper, lead dancer, sub vocalist, maknae Purple Kiss: - Goeun - main vocalist, lead dancer, center - Dosie - main dancer, lead vocalist, sub rapper - Yuki - main rapper, lead dancer, sub vocalist, visual - Chaein - main vocalist, lead dancer, lead rapper, maknae

[@shujinko2944]

Yeonjun MVP

[@WickedSua]

I think siyeon will be lead vocal with sua and yoohyeon will be main dancer with sua and dami lead dancer

[@arbuz510]

@@WickedSua dreamcatcher improved/showcased their vocals greatly in this era, they were re-evaluated and apparently 4 of them can support now, one is close and one is relaxed Yoohyeon is still the best vocalist but Siyeon showcased her abilities a lot, she's closer to Yoohyeon's level than SuA's (who has also improved a lot) so they're both main vocals imo (SuA and JiU should be both lead vocals in DC now, maybe also Handong if she improves a bit more) and about dancing, Yoohyeon is a great dancer, very underrated (I'd say she's sometimes even better than Dami) but she's not better than JiU, not to mention SuA so I disagree

[@WickedSua]

@@arbuz510 actually yoohyeon is better than sua in dance already based on open style but there is a chances the there re evaluations maybe make sua better

[@WickedSua]

@@arbuz510 well handong already has support but she is inconsistent otherwise she is high weak vocalist and afaik yoohyeon is low average,sua and siyeon are mid weak to average (but sua is still evaluating so there is some chances that sua is low average or high weak to average),jiu is low weak to average, handong high weak or mid weak ,and gahyeon is maybe underdevelopment to weak or ^underdeveloped

[@ratuneta]

So only aespa who's fix position with their talent? lol, i credit Winter & Ningning sub's rap since their had some minimally part rap like: Winter (Savege, Girls, NL) Ning (NL, Don't Blink, Wake up)

[@harveyism]

IVE without Wonyoung is a crime.

[@multifan6679]

This is mostly based on talent. And as much as I love Wonyoung, she doesn't really add much in that regard. She ads it factor and popularity (though Yujin also had plenty of that on their debut, do it would have gone well without Wonyoung as well). Talent wise and even visual wise (Leeseo, Yujin and blond Liz. Rei and Gaeul are also pretty as hell), the other members easily make up for it

[@elsak2202]

Yes, she is the one that brings the most fans and popularity in the group

[@hebapa2766]

​@@elsak2202ofc she is a slayy but the video creator put the most talented once

[@keepitlowkey1906]

Ngl that's a creative concept! I'm loving your channel even more day by day..💙

[@Sisaaaa15]

Ok I can say this is somehow accurate to me while I disagree with few... U should make these types of video in future and editing is excellent as per my point of view(>ω

[@guigzs]

do you intend to make a bg version, hopie?

[@hopeflakez]

maybe yes or maybe not

[@_7normalboysfromKorea]

@@hopeflakezu should

[@Anjan_-]

'Hopie'-guigzs

[@Anjan_-]

​@@Cryforme-ikrrr

[@iyyihcore]

A video idea: if every group had 4 members but this time based on popularity

[@Forever_2424]

Oh so that's why u were telling us to choose one i thought it was for ur pf 😅

[@yone_774]

BP ,Æspa, MMM be like : my time to shine✨✨

[@guigzs]

so basically, the groups would contain the most talented idols from their original groups (and the most "important" ones too!! like the main vocalists hehe)

[@_7normalboysfromKorea]

Your idea is so unique ✨ and btw I think this positions suits Jisoo more. Center Ningning would be so good 💅

[@books_ww]

Nayeon>Momo kbs

[@bangchanhusband]

visual ≠ kbs

[@ireneicals]

@@bangchanhusbandvisual = kbs, you can’t pick a groups visual cause u feel one is prettier, it depends on kbs.

[@Animeme7]

Does it matter?

[@bangchanhusband]

@@ireneicals the visual member is the one who pleases Korean opinion the most, regardless of kbs

[@ireneicals]

@@bangchanhusband exactly, the one who pleases korean opinion is literally the meaning of kbs.

[@appleberry713]

some more girl groups imo: lesserafim: sakura: lead rapper, lead dancer, vocalist, visual, fotg chaewon: leader, main dancer, lead vocalist, center yunjin: main vocalist, lead dancer, rapper kazuha: main rapper, vocalist (g)i-dle: miyeon: main vocalist, visual minnie: lead vocalist, rapper soyeon: leader, main rapper, main dancer, center yuqi: lead vocalist, lead rapper, lead dancer, fotg loona: yves: leader, main vocalist, main dancer, rapper jinsoul: main rapper, vocalist, visual kim lip: lead vocalist, lead dancer heejin: main dancer, lead vocalist, lead rapper, visual, center, fotg everglow: eu: leader, main rapper, lead dancer sihyeon: main vocalist, visual mia: main dancer, lead vocalist, rapper, center aisha: lead rapper, lead dancer, vocalist, fotg purple kiss: goeun: leader, main vocalist, lead dancer, center dosie: main dancer, vocalist, rapper yuki: main rapper, visual, fotg chaein: lead vocalist, lead rapper, lead dancer

[@Verowinday777]

Eunchae is more talented in Le sserafim's case, since Kazuha's experience and talents in rap are just poor and basic.

[@Verowinday777]

And also Onda instead of Aisha, since Onda is a great dancer while Aisha doesn’t really excel in anything and she won’t add anything to their rap line since she isn’t a good rapper to begin with.

[@pinkystar6469]

I SUPER AGREE WHEN U PUT NINGNING AS THE CENTER !

[@Forever_2424]

I will give lead vocalist position to rei too as she is also equally better to yujin in vocals i also have proof of her supporting G♯4

[@Forever_2424]

@@Cryforme- kzbin.info/www/bejne/oZqtapaarZqEg5Y at 0:35

[@soyeonvsveggies]

not my bias line leaving ive 😢

[@bangchanhusband]

can't imagine nmixx without yoona and bae 😿

[@rose_x_me]

Can you do 3 member groups next? Also, since when were u planning to post this video?

[@hopeflakez]

i think its been more than 2 months since i started editing this video lol, around a week after ive's comeback ig

[@rose_x_me]

@@hopeflakez 😭 I want to start doing longer videos too, but the price might take me the whole summer

[@_7normalboysfromKorea]

@@user-tw1zv8ki9qfor Itzy I would keep Yuna instead of Lia. Like I know she saves the Vocal line but Itzy is not a vocal based group anyways. Yuna would fit Itzy way more then Lia. I respect ur opinion tho 🦋

[@_7normalboysfromKorea]

@@user-tw1zv8ki9q yh

[@Anjan_-]

@Hopeflakez and all dancer please listen I am a dancer i am learning jaaz at my dance academy so yesterday i had to do a solo performance the teachers said my expressions footwork and dance was good my musicality is not good i can't dance on beat so how do i fix this its been going for a long time now any tips?

[@Anjan_-]

Yall answer

[@hopeflakez]

I think you should just sit down and listen to the song, & pay attention to the beats, maybe change your way of counting, use 'e' '&' 'a' counting methods to catch detail beats, and i think just practice and enjoy while you dance, groove to the rhythm and you'll get there eventually.

[@Anjan_-]

​​​​@@hopeflakeznks I already used to do this but forgot ty for the reminder I'll practice seriously ty for a & e how do you do it? Can you guide me tyy it'll be good help tyy once again

[@StayforOnce]

U literally picked up the members without whom the grps are incomplete

[@cosmirene]

About rv basically there were four members in the start and tho yeri isn't really the best in any of the category,she still adds a lot to rv😌

[@Anjan_-]

Off topic i love your editing

[@tinadoe4180]

It is really interesting for me idea for video. And i want to try make some groups with 4 members (not only gg). And i will not give positions like visual, center, fotg or leader. Dreamcatcher Sua - main dancer, lead vocalist, lead rapper Siyeon - lead vocalist Yoohyeon - main dancer, main vocalist Dami - main rapper, sub vocalist TxT Yeonjun - main vocalist, main rapper, main damcer Tahyun - main vocalist, lead dancer, sub rapper Beomgyu - lead dancer, lead rapper, sub vocalist Soobin/Hyuka (you can choose) - lead vocalist Stray kids Han - main vocalist, main rapper, lead dancer Chanbin - main rapper Lee know - main dancer (idk maybe) I.N - lead vocalist Le Sserafim Chaewon - lead vocalist, lead dancer, sub rapper Yunjin - main vocalist, lead dancer, lead rapper Sakura - lead rapper, main dancer Kazuha - main rapper, sub vocalist NewJeans Hanni - main vocalist, main dancer Haerin - lead vocalist, main dancer Danielle - lead vocalist, lead dancer, lead rapper Minji - sub vocalist, lead dancer, main rapper Babymonster Asa - main dander, main rapper, sub vocalist Ruka - main dancer, main rapper, sub vocalist Haram - main vocalist, lead dancer, sub rapper Ahyeon - lead vocalst, lead dancer, lead rapper Maybe i made some mistakes. Btw waiting for your new as great as always videos :)

[@ValentinaFlowers]

I love how you called Liz by her korean name lol

[@Hype-V-oy]

Omg i agree with all of these- Btw my biases that made the mineup are : -Youngeun -Gaeul -Jisoo -Ningning -Moonbyul And even jisoo is my ult bias i agree with her having no lead or main position tbh she doesn't have vocal support lack in rap (i wouldn't give her sub rapper position tbh) and is only low t7 dancer, i don't think she's gonna improve bcs she didn't showed any improvement in vocal since the debut of her career, but i'm happy that you gave her leader position ! She really suit that position a lot and should be the actual leader bcs she's the most carring member for her teamate and she's the oldest ! Anyway slayyed as always ♥️

[@ratuneta]

Red Velvet officially 4 Member but then something Yeri join but she still talented guys

[@_7normalboysfromKorea]

Yeri was in the final lineup she just joined late because she was young by the time they debuted

[@yummyeon]

she shouldn't have been added tbh

[@skaii-]

why did you choose groups that already are 4 members?

[@Anjan_-]

Did yall see yeri 's drama i Didn't expect her acting to be so good she did great

[@Anjan_-]

​@@Cryforme-ikr

[@Kfae-lz6bh]

wait what's the name of the drama ?

[@Anjan_-]

​@@Kfae-lz6bhbitch×rich

[@cosmirene]

She's a good actress fr

[@Anjan_-]

​@@cosmireneikr

[@pinkystar6469]

rosé should be the visual line, she own the korea & inter beauty standard .

[@matmic0326]

Chaeryoung insted of Yuna imo

[@MillPlayz]

No yuna has better vocals and rapping and visuals which overrides dancing (which is only a little difference anyway)

[@matmic0326]

@@MillPlayz Maybe she's better in rapping and she's a visual, but i can't agree that she is better in singing than Chaeryoung. But overall Yuna might be better in this group than Chae

[@jungwoniz]

imo Yuna: • rap • visuals • >= vocals Chaeryeong • dance •

[@sunnyjeon]

@@MillPlayzchaeryeong’s vocals are way better technically.

[@kadotanoia]

@@sunnyjeonno? yuna’s vocals are better in technicality

[@lovingeight]

were 5 and 4 member groups really necesaary?

[@Zendaya-es9nv]

They changed some positions or wanted to compare

[@supershyhaerin]

This video idea is so creative and nice :) !

[@kilbertsantos4915]

IVE sin wonyoung 😭💀

[@sznqrt]

I love this idea! ❤️ Can I ask why Rosé was given a lead dancer position? Not trying to be rude or anything, just genuinely curious

[@hopeflakez]

She genuinely does justice to most of bp choreos

[@sznqrt]

@@hopeflakez thank you for the reply! ❤️

[@shujinko2944]

@@sznqrtshe fulfills the role as a lead dancer far more than Jennie

[@sznqrt]

@@shujinko2944 well technically Jennie is way better

[@silverhammermax]

​@@sznqrtyou're right, but I'm guessing Jennie's inconsistency is a problem

[@eluneee00]

Iz*one: Eunbi - Leader, Main Dancer, Lead Vocalist Yuri - Main Vocalist Yena - Main Rapper, Lead Dancer, Lead Vocalist Minju - Lead Rapper, Sub- Vocalist, Visual, Center, FOG I.O.I Chungha - Leader, Main Dancer, Lead Vocalist, Sub Rapper Sejeong - Main Vocalist, Visual Yoojung - Main Rapper, Lead Dancer, Sub Vocalist Somi - Lead Dancer, Lead Vocalist, Lead Rapper, Center, FOG Le Sserafim Chaewon - Leader, Lead Vocalist, Lead Dancer, Sub Rapper Sakura - Main Dancer, Lead Rapper, Vocalist, Visual, Center Kazuha - Main Rapper, Lead Dancer, Sub - Vocalist Yunjin - Main Vocalist

[@eluneee00]

@@CrownPrinceEdvin you’re underestimating the power of a visual. Minju might be the less talented idol of the 4 but is a powerhouse visual. Visuals are the backbone of kpop. And given how crazy knetz are about visuals, minju is needed. She also proved time and time again that she can keep up with the members and also knows how to utilize her beauty. Eunbi and hyewon are beautiful but they don’t know how to utilize it. Sakura, wonyoung, and minju know how and only minju has enough talent to keep up with the already talented members. Chaeyeon can also be interchangeable to eunbi. But i prefer eunbi more.

[@Verowinday777]

@@eluneee00this video is not about visuals it is about making an all-rounded group

[@Verowinday777]

@@eluneee00and chaeyeon is actually a way better dancer than eunbi

[@Verowinday777]

And kazuha is a dozen she can’t really rap and her dance is weak (op),and ofc she doesn’t have a vocal support so eunchae is a better fit.

[@aericonicc]

​@@Verowinday777 Kazuha isn't a dozen, she has a pretty good stage presence

[@Swanniest]

6th.....😭

[@Swanniest]

@Roses___are___rosie should have given me the lily flower 🤧(don't think that exist but anyways)

[@julianogueiragaldino2303]

Imo Twice Nayeon lead vocal, lead dancer, sub rapper, fotg and visual Momo main dancer, lead rapper and sub vocal Jihyo leader, main vocal, main dancer and center Chaeyoung Main rapper, sub vocal and maknae Nmixx Lily main vocal and fotg Haewon lead vocal and visual Jiwon center, main dancer, main rapper and sub vocal Kyujin lead dancer, lead rapper, sub vocal and maknae Kep1er Chaehyun main vocal, fotg and visual Dayeon center, main dancer, main rapper and sub vocal Hikaru main dancer, main rapper and sub vocal Yeungeun lead vocal, lead dancer, lead rapper Red Velvet Wendy main vocal and lead dancer Seulgi center, main dancer, lead vocal and fotg Joy lead rapper and sub vocal Yeri Main rapper, sub vocal and maknae Itzy Yeji lead vocal, main dancer, sub rapper and center Lia main vocal and sub rapper Ryujin fotg, lead dancer and lead rapper Yuna visual, main rapper, sub vocal and maknae

[@Forever_2424]

I was waiting for everglow , g idle 😢😢

[@WickedSua]

My predictions Ever glow Shiyeon:main vocal,main visual Mia:lead dancer,lead vocal,lead rapper, centre, fotg Eu:main rapper,leader Onda:main dancer For gidle Soyeon:leader,main rapper, main dancer,centre Yuqi:lead rapper, lead dancer,lead vocal,fotg Miyeon:main vocal,visual Minnie:lead vocal,visual

[@KoALa_tOo_BAsIc]

@@WickedSua Mia should be main dancer too

[@KoALa_tOo_BAsIc]

@@WickedSua and I would say Minnie is sub vocal

[@WickedSua]

@@KoALa_tOo_BAsIc actually mia is mid high tier 6 and onda high 6 and yea we can make both mian dancer but then shiyeon and eu are very weak to be lead dancer so i maded mia lead dancer

[@KoALa_tOo_BAsIc]

@@WickedSua Aisha can be lead dancer since she's mid to high T7

[@aainibbbbbb]

is it just me but does anyone else not like ahyeons voice

[@vvenuskook4170]

I find it annoying tbh

[@Anjan_-]

​@@vvenuskook4170me too kinda annoying

[@KoALa_tOo_BAsIc]

Me too tbh

[@KoALa_tOo_BAsIc]

​​@@Forda43not racist but ignorant

[@green360z]

I love it. Powerful vocals are my jam!!!!

[@cosmirene]

Ok but the video idea is really unique ! Loved it

[@Lizardlarry2000]

The way you took out all the stan attractors lol

[@Roba_0]

Your editing slay ✨

[@ragsleramen]

imo ITZY- YEJI: Leader, Main Dancer, Lead Vocalist, FOTG LIA: Main Vocalist, Visual RYUJIN: Main Rapper, Sub-Vocalist, Center, Lead Dancer CHAERYEONG: Main Dancer, Lead Vocalist, Makane (My reasoning: (NO HATE) Visuals aren’t a reason that makes one person better than another, thought yuna is really pretty, i don’t think it’s as beneficial than chaeryeong’s talent, not to mention chaeryeong is also beautiful. Chaeryeong is a strong dancer, while yuna may be energetic, chaeryeong has technicality, and has stage presence nowadays. chaeryeong is a better singer than yuna in general. she’s more stable, her voice is airy, in comparison to yuna’s voice which has become more shrill and nasal. chaeryeong also hits more notes than yuna. she has a more soothing voice which can be perfect for a pre chorus in any song. yuna’s main strong suit is rapping, which imo she’s better than ryujin. she has a better flow, attitude, and she’s faster. but the reason i didn’t add her in for rapping is because ryujin has a addictive voice which again imo ryujin is a better singer than yuna recently, she is also a better dancer than her. though yuna is a very talented and necessary member in itzy, if it unfortunately had to be narrowed down to four members yuna might be better suited somewhere else.) just so yknow i’m not a chaeryeong stan or smth, bias ryujin, bias wrecker chaeryeong

[@ashlvsgyu]

actually yuna is apparently better at vocals (can be interchanged w chaeryeong) rap, & stage presence so if itzy was four members, i think they’d keep yuna bc not only that, she’s also a visual. (saying this as a ryujin biased midzy)

[@jebepilled]

yuna isn't that far behind ryujin in terms of rapping and even beats ryujin in some specific qualities of rap. yena has better stage presence than chaer. yuna isn't as good as a dancer as chaer but she's a lead dancer and a good one too, not too mention itzy has a bunch of great dancers. so it's not just visuals tbh.

[@shujinko2944]

Nah, Yuna needs to stay. She’s the best performer in ITZY.

[@_7normalboysfromKorea]

U didn’t not put Chae but not Yuna 💀 like I know it’s your opinion but Yuna beats Chae in every category except dance 🙊

[@pinkystar6469]

@@ashlvsgyuFRRRRR I WOULD CHANGE CHAER WITH YUNA

[@soyeonvsveggies]

cool video idea!

[@guigzs]

wow this style of video is so fun and creative!! You should do it more often hehe

[@owaowarats]

For LE SSERAFIM: Imo- Member 1: Yunjin: Main Vocalist, Lead dancer, Center. Member 2: Chaewon: Leader, lead Dancer, lead vocalist. Member 3: Sakura: Sub- Vocalist, Lead-rapper, Main- dancer, FOTG, Visual. Member 4: Kazuha: Main Rapper, sub Vocalist. :)

[@tinadoe4180]

Agree

[@negaras1898]

I disagree with sakura. Sakura is high tier 7 dancer but she cant sing nor rap. Chaewon as a high tier 7 dancer, should be main dancer and eunchae also as a high tier 7 dancer makes both dance line and vocal line stronger than sakura.

[@_7normalboysfromKorea]

I would rather have Eunchae who have an actual vocal support even if it’s shallow then Sakura tbh

[@Verowinday777]

@@negaras1898kazuha is the one who shouldn’t be included

[@_7normalboysfromKorea]

@@akedyy4299 she have shallow support

[@monikajha7892]

I want to ask you one thing . Now both jenlisa are interchangeable in rap then why you didn't give Lisa main rapper position.

[@hopeflakez]

i dont think there can be two main rappers, it would seem so off

[@monikajha7892]

@@hopeflakez okay. Thank you for replying me

[@feonix813]

@@hopeflakezi think it’d be fine tbh. We have two main vocalists for NMIXX, so two main rappers should be fine for BP, no?

[@WickedSua]

​@@feonix813but then jisoo and rosè who are non rapper will be lead rapper which will be weird

[@mariaat1]

I think it's because one thing Lisa already has a main position. Second jisoo or rose are not much good to be a lead rapper.

[@feonix813]

slayy

[@Doli702]

3rd 💜💜

[@Doli702]

@Roses___are___rosie slayyy

[@sriyagnajupalli]

First one❤❤

[@eluneee00]

Kepler should be: Dayeon Youngeon Chaehyun Xiaoting Ive: Wonyoung Yujin Liz Gaeul

[@Kpopsta_n]

You’re literally losing so much talent if you remove Hikaru. Best dancer, best performer, and best rapper in the group.

[@eluneee00]

@@Kpopsta_n in every four member girl group, there has to be atleast 3 good singers. Hikaru may beat dayeon in dancing and rapping, but she can’t beat her in vocals. Youngeun is needed in order to be the lead vocalist of the group. Chaehyun is needed to be the main vocalist of the group. Xiaoting is there because of not only her visuals but also her distinct charisma and stage presence. Xiaoting knows well how to attract the camera making her the perfect center of the group. If the rules was 5 members then hikaru would be the perfect cherry on top.

[@Seowonie12]

​@@eluneee00Hikaru is their best dancer, best rapper, best performer, best SP, popular, versatile, she's also a center material. It will be a big loss if she isn't included. This is only a 4 member group so main vocalist and lead vocalist are already enough. Dayeon, Hikaru and Xiaoting all cant support so vocals doesn't really matter. Also Hikaru, Dayeon and Youngeun complement each other. Hikaru and Dayeon will make a great dance duo. They are both rappers too. +Youngeun. They are like Ryujin, Yeji, Chaeryeong. Chaehyun's vocal skills is much needed in the group so she is added. Hikaru, Dayeon, Youngeun and Chaehyun can be center. They are a complete group.

[@eluneee00]

@@Seowonie12 chaehyun literally has no stage presence lol. Do you think she will do well as center in a group filled with beast dancers? Dayeon and Youngeun can’t support but their raw skills in singing is enough to support chaehyun. Did you see a successful 4 girl group who only has 2 members who can sing well? No you haven’t. There’s a reason why xiaoting is always the center despite her rank in kepler. Her stage presence is unlike any other. The problem with you people is that you always equate stage presence with facial expression or how much power they project to their dance. Stage presence is how will you utilize your visuals and skills when performing. Just because hikaru is more expressive doesn’t make her better than xiaoting in sp. did you see xiaoting in snake? She absolutely owned that stage.

[@Kpopsta_n]

@@eluneee00 Xiaoting also can’t sing, so why would you choose her over Hikaru when Hikaru outslams her in every aspect except vocals?

[@ireneicals]

the itzy one is a bit funny so let me fix it! :3 ryujin - main rapper, lead dancer Yeji - main dancer, lead vocalist, leader, fotg chaeryeong - main dancer, sub vocalist yuna - lead rapper, lead vocalist, visual, maknae OR ryujin - main rapper, lead dancer Yeji - main dancer, lead vocalist, leader, fotg chaeryeong - main dancer, sub vocalist lia - main vocalist dance line will never be gone‼️

[@Verowinday777]

Lmao they need someone who could fulfill too positions' demands, and sadly Chaeryoung can only be the main dancer ; not to mention that she only excels in commercial/idol dance style only, and we already have another main dancer that is at the same time the lead vocalist, but Ig you might be choosing her out of pity.

[@ireneicals]

@@Verowinday777 it’s kinda funny honestly, looking back at this, ryujin should have been out instead of yuna or lia or worst of all, chaeryeong. Ryujin can only handle rap, her dance is in the middle and her vocals are weakest. Chaeryeong is main dancer, and a side rapper. Lia carries them in vocals, Yuna is their visual, maknae and will most likely make up for ryujin’s rap absence. For yeji, do I need to explain? She’s an ace, no need to get her out. Just Ryujin,

[@soyeonvsveggies]

or we get rid of yeji and we have a visual, a vocalist, and a good dance line

[@ireneicals]

@@soyeonvsveggies yeji is part of dance, visual and vocal line. ryujin is the better fit.

[@Verowinday777]

@@ireneicals Disagreed esp after listening to their Bet On Me live stages, Yuna sounds like she's just mumbling some random stuff here and there when it comes to rap, so maybe Yuna is the one who gotta be left out.

[@yummyeon]

that's why visuals should be taken into consideration bc these lineup doesn't eat. wonyoung was mandatory to debut. yeri can stay in vacations. nmixx sullyoon should be in it instead of either jiwoo or kyujin. kep1er without bahorsie = instant eatery. but these 4 don't have a cohesive image at all and aren't well balanced. yeseo should be there instead of either dayeon or hikaru. there was no point to add the group with already 4 members, what would have been interesting is to add more group with 5 members = gidle -> bye shuhua, le sserafim -> bye dozeunchae new jeans -> tough one bc they don't have any special habitilites, they should keep hanni and fire the one with the nasal voice whoever that is

[@soyeonvsveggies]

sullyoon? that girl contributes almost nothing to the group and u wanna get rid of one of the all rounders for her? kyujin is already the prettiest nmixx member along with bae so your visual argument still doesnt mean anything

[@yummyeon]

@@soyeonvsveggies she got the koreans tuned in it and kyujin is pretty but she have bad proportions and jiwoo isn't skinny. bae have a mid visual. no hate

[@martacastillo6272]

​@@soyeonvsveggies"contributes almost nothing" wow harsh for a girl that can consistently belt out songs live and keep up with the choreo

[@martacastillo6272]

​​@@yummyeon disgusting comment, Bae's eyes, nose and lips are gorgeous, her side profile is incredibly elegant. And she looks incredible both with short and long hair.

[@soyeonvsveggies]

@@martacastillo6272 “keeping up with the choreo” is like the bare minimum lmao, and all of nmixx can sing

[@kilbertsantos4915]

Cuando vi que Lia era la #1 en ITZY dije todo mal 💀😭

[@Tyyry.tut678]

Without lia itzy vocals would be done

[@pinkystar6469]

nmixx i would say haewon - leader , main vocal , lead dancer , visual line sullyoon - center , lead vocal , sub rapper , visual & fotg jiwoo - main rapper , main dancer , sub vocal kyujin - main dancer , lead vocal , lead rapper , center

[@しかすたか]

i think its Lily cause it really makes the vocal line stronger, while Jiwoo and Kyujin enhances the dance line

[@edu.8552]

​@@しかすたかTechnically, HaeLy ain't that different.

[@しかすたか]

@@edu.8552 Yea, except Haewon is a better dancer, but the group would still be all rounded with either

[@imbetter-jo7dh]

bro what lily is better than sullyoon in all categories

[@しかすたか]

Lily is not better than Sullyoon in "all" categories.@@imbetter-jo7dh

[@elsak2202]

Bahiyyih and Wonyoung should be here. They are the reason why there group are famous

[@aeriellaa]

they are talking abt talent

[@iloveyouiwantyouseokmattchu]

@@aeriellaa Yeah but to be fair, stan attractors are needed to be part of a group's success. Hiyyih is carrying Kep1er on her back and as sad as it is, the general public wouldn't care about their talents unless someone got them into the group.

[@aeriellaa]

@@iloveyouiwantyouseokmattchu guess so but it wasn’t what the vid was abt

[@yummyeon]

bahorsie make kep1er flop they should go as 8 without her nepoass

[@cherimming]

bahiyyih isn't as popular in korea tho chaehyun xiaoting are

[@NingKook_]

Sullyoon instead of Haewon aespa center go to Karina The rest i agree

[@hopeflakez]

Haewon > sully in every category so she seemed like a better option to make the group more all-rounded

[@NingKook_]

​@@hopeflakez i agree with you but i directly think to sullyoon first

[@sarangnambiar8367]

I don't like how visuals are compared with all rounders

[@welovenaevis]

itzy imo lia- main vocalist, sub rapper ryujin- leader, main dancer, main rapper, lead/sub vocalist chaeryeong- main dancer, lead/sub vocalist, sub rapper yuna- lead dancer, lead rapper, lead/sub vocalist, visual, maknae

[@RYUJIN.SLAY._.2205]

AGREE

[@aainibbbbbb]

NO YEJI??

[@welovenaevis]

@@aainibbbbbb nah

[@RYUJIN.SLAY._.2205]

@Meowmeow-jf9eh she's a great rapper and dancer

[@welovenaevis]

@Meowmeow-jf9eh and yeji isnt even a visual shes just that one bald girl

[@husky7444]

Jisoo would be lead vocalist with jennie

[@KoALa_tOo_BAsIc]

Definitely not

[@husky7444]

@@KoALa_tOo_BAsIc bro instead of support jisoo is better than jennie in every aspect of vocals

[@Anjan_-]

​@@husky7444oh really?

[@bishuthepanda]

@@husky7444 this makes no sense actually cuz support is directly proportional to it

[@KoALa_tOo_BAsIc]

@@husky7444 name them