What If: Fire Oasis had Earth Instead of Water

[@JakeTheDrake]

If you're wondering why Hoola is here as well as Spurrit, Hoola is on Air Island as well as Earth because of Pango and PomPom being on both, Pango and PomPom are also in this island now so it only makes sense EDIT: i accidently put Repatillo there instead of Ziggurab so pretend Repatillo is Ziggurab please

[@Artoym]

col

[@wubbtasic]

Ok

[@FeliMSM]

Lol i just noticed that repatillo isn't supposed to be here Edit: ok so i'm pretending that repatillo is ziggurab...uhm....ziggurab my beloved

[@mumbofuze]

I was wondering what repatillo was doing there. I don’t remember you adding plant.

[@spiritblox1]

errrrm jake you forgot to pin thi

[@dotalbo8279]

I love oasis normally but damn floogull always makes the songs better, just like in the bone island “what if” video.

[@ScuttleBugReal]

Yeah floogull should be on way more islands

[@justanormalrobloxchannel]

I swear god he does

[@charcoaleater343]

Bone island floogull slaps, such a great what if

[@TAKTlmao]

He could've also been on faerie island

[@hoglin7]

Floogul is in my opinion the best fire monster Glad to see I'm not the only one who likes him😄

[@Ramenationss]

Three. Seasonals.

[@toad7829]

You absolutely annihilated it with pompom and hoola

[@booposreal]

Three?

[@NoahPhillips31]

Gobbleygourd, Hoola, and Spurrit

[@Pizza_Party_Time]

​@@booposreal yes

[@Lucas-sl1dw]

@@NoahPhillips31 oh

[@pawer_themaw]

didn't expect Repatilo and Stogg to literally CARRY the 2nd part of the beginning verse. I mean they're my fire favs...

[@zenochara7522]

You mean Ziggarub and Stogg

[@imati7319]

@@zenochara7522 well yeah lol

[@TheClackbillula]

If I had a nickel for every time Jake accidently mixed up two monsters in a what if where he replaces one element on an island with another element, I'd have two nickels, which isn't a lot but its weird that it happened twice.

[@SealiusIII]

Drumpler on light island moment

[@cycoMSM]

Love the reference

[@flameflareonog]

First Fwog on light now this

[@rydersother]

@@SealiusIII Fwog*

[@GummyPikminProductions]

-Dr Heinz Doofenshmirtz

[@Camphreneas]

Floogull’s addition to the song made fire oasis 10x better than before! And the trio of PomPom, Hoola, and Kayna sounds epic!

[@Pun_TheConsumer]

That's why floogull is my favorite monster Simple yet nice design and plays one of my favorite instruments

[@kingghidorah8106]

floogull is always a W

[@iPacing]

Goes in symphony with whaddle

[@iPacing]

And you may have forgotten wynqs part

[@SodasGumball]

@@iPacing they did it better tho

[@Splotch-015]

Anyone ever tell you you have a great Spurrit impression, Jake?

[@Mr_Accurate]

His Spurrit in his Seasonal Shanty vid wasn’t great, but he’s definitely been practicing because this is leaps better

[@goblinandslimefromTH.]

Fun fact: this can be used as an insult

[@RealAshleyChill]

@@Mr_Accurate in past updates of the shanty cover I do believe Spurrit was more like the one in this, he changed it in the last update for... Some reason?

[@MiiRailgunner]

@@goblinandslimefromTH. This is so sad. Alexa, play Fire Oasis but Earth replaces Water

[@XorbityXorbGlowbe]

@@MiiRailgunner ALEXA PLAY GOBBELY ASMR

[@thecrispyacorn]

What if he replaced natural island monsters with magical island monsters? like "Cold Island with Bone Island Monsters" or "Plant Island with Psychic Island Monsters"

[@DaKingKayden]

Because we dont know what something like psychic air water would be bro

[@thecrispyacorn]

@@DaKingKayden no we would replace all monsters with the Psychic monsters, so Psychic, Fire, Plant, Water would replace the Plant, Water, Cold, Earth elements

[@thisisntdababy]

@@thecrispyacorn wouldn't it just be plant island with bone island's rhythm

[@Sylveon386]

Air with faerie too

[@schizopenguin]

​@@thecrispyacorn plant* cold*

[@fredprince8256]

So I’d like a what if… What if Ethereal Island was a Fire Island? - Tweedle - Ghazt Kayna - Grumpyre Noggin - Reebro Toe Jammer - Jeeode Phangler - Humbug Flum Ox - Whisp Cybop - Jellibilly Stogg - Arackulele Scups - Boodoo Floogull - Sox Whaddle - Nebulob Fwog - Bellowfish Quibble - Fung Pray Glowl - Dragong Thrumble - Kazilleon

[@echossaisse]

This is basically just replacing each of the ethereals with a fire monster

[@Mr.HippoFromFnafUCN]

I'm trying to localize the one that asked for your opinion, cuz i dont think this is the video you need to comment for.

[@Helentar]

@@Mr.HippoFromFnafUCNI’m trying to localize your brain

[@Mr.HippoFromFnafUCN]

​@@HelentarDid you find it?

[@moopymeebloopy456]

Why would tweedle be ghazt and not quibble

[@GalacticPenguin2.0]

This is close to a thing I always wanted to see: Fire Oasis switches elements with Fire Haven, like Noggin replaces Congle’s role on Fire Oasis and on the other side Pango replaces Repatillo’s role on Fire Haven (examples) That would be interesting but I also like this a lot!

[@MoopyMSM]

its really funny that you say that because i'm working on just that right now and might release soon idk

[@ninni9050]

This is awesome fire oasis really needed some more percussion! The stogg woolabee is insanely good and jake cybop is always the best

[@Artoym]

floogull is masterpiece because i love floogull

[@Naitikus]

Imagine if BBB hired some of the msm content creator and then they made a lot of beautiful islands

[@IanMCgaming]

Yeah like Jake, Raw Zebra, and more the creator of dark island and magical ruin

[@bsemz5836]

@@IanMCgaming ghostpympa too he not that good at designing but he amazing at composing

[@Veehead1]

@@bsemz5836 his animation is also wacky, so he deserves composer or producer

[@IanMCgaming]

@@bsemz5836 yeah

[@Uranium----...---23592]

@@bsemz5836 His designs are improving I'd say, epic ethereal wubbox is pretty good compared to some of his other epic wubboxes.

[@goosley6977]

Ok but that Stogg Repatillo duo is the best thing I’ve ever seen from this game fanmade or real it’s SO GOOD

[@bprocrast]

You made one of my favourite islands into an absolute MASTERPIECE.

[@muensterwasnttaken]

Pompom is terrible wym

[@CatteryAcid]

@@muensterwasnttaken ik but she doesn’t play until after kayna’s part, and plus she only plays for around 10 seconds

[@ComposingKing]

Oh my God. Krillby island 😍 Sounds so good! Great job! (again)

[@bsemz5836]

Fun facts: farie Island was supposed to be fire park and has krillby as the quad

[@Tiagoo90]

At first I thought it was a Fire Oasis Cover 🥺

[@JakeTheDrake]

not yet

[@olga68906]

not yet

[@omaramo19]

Crazy how one element switch added so many percussionists to this song.

[@nasutchi3080]

I really like how PomPom and Hoola sang after Kanya, though I kinda expected to sing with her, other then that, PomPom and Hoola sound amazing when they duet on any island they’re on! And their duet is giving the same energy when two sisters singing together, one is older and one is younger, anyways, this “what if” is great 👍

[@diddper9513]

Yes

[@kaidayuri5526]

Kayna + wynq

[@MrHerlinanurdiana]

kayna*

[@Aarontheman-5567]

Stogg, noggin and drumpler sound legit in this what if

[@LowQualityCarbink]

Fire oasis struggled with the lack or percussionists due to the water element, this really would have helped if it was the official

[@erendrunkyaeger4793]

No one is going to talk about how Zigurabb just turned into Repatillo?

[@GlowingEraser]

Whaaaat? Zigurubb is evolving!

[@DaKingKayden]

Repatillo is better ziggurabb fight me

[@BabyBillIsCool]

Jake made a mistake

[@swiflte]

LMAO I just noticed 💀

[@fischyfisch420]

@@DaKingKayden fr

[@7h2ubfn9h35]

Finally, like fire oasis should've been.

[@wubbtasic]

True

[@amral-abdulsalam1193]

but oasis is in relation to water

[@7h2ubfn9h35]

@@amral-abdulsalam1193 I meant song-wise.

[@RedLemonCola]

You should’ve never existed on fire oasis.

[@TheJayWay101]

@@7h2ubfn9h35 But how would that be possible if earth isn't on fire oasis?

[@lainedsyelwah]

i'm in love !! cybop's track kinda reminds me of "last christmas" but thats still an amazing song, and so is this 😁 awesome job jake

[@glowyogurt]

Stogg and ziggurab make the beginning part so good

[@adifferentone426]

why did it take me until just now to notice drumpler had a tail

[@Mannerisms-wg8le]

An absolute masterpiece. This should’ve been the main fire oasis

[@RealAshleyChill]

Bill did the funny before me- Nonetheless absolutely stellar cover, the redone Cherubble is very nice, Floogull goes extremely hard as always and all the vocals vere awesome!

[@TheCodaCrew]

Dang, Fire Oasis just got a whole lot more upbeat

[@ChugMSM]

this really added the extra pop to the song that it needed. great job as always

[@musicaman8683]

Floogull sounds SO GOOD!!! You managed to make this sound even better than normal fire oasis

[@Bluewatersonic]

Rip maw fire oasis gone but not forgotten 💔

[@DemiroseCrab]

Repatillo and stogg change the whole vibe of any island they're on.

[@NeverEverWatchThis]

Rep a-t-il Lo? Zig-u-rab!

[@moopymeebloopy456]

Jake always makes floogull awesome

[@donnapauls1562]

Bro I loved the first part with noggin, mammot, floogull, stogg, krilby, and reptalio that was the best ever!!!

[@Gameguy5289]

Man part of me wants this mashed up with the normal island music. I hope someone does this eventually but its still a damn good banger by itself.

[@Madisongs]

I’ve been wondering what it would sound like with Jake’s fanmade tracks mashed up with the original island. Might make a compilation of that soon.

[@KaijuEdits875]

This is so so good! Everything is perfect But THIS IS AMAZING Like MSM is so underrated, we need more attention

[@cuboembaralhado8294]

5:10 Smoothiest transition I have ever seen

[@kesqae]

the krillby fits amazingly well

[@ExclaimInc]

sounds incredible omg

[@liamfletcher7757]

I’m so glad woolabee was still there

[@naturescorruptedinfactorie8062]

Loving these different elements on islands concept videos

[@GhostelFaceMan]

Bro really went and predicated spurrit like that

[@dinothebetatt6733]

I only just start watching, and I'm in love with Noggin's sounds

[@backgroundcharacter8972]

Congle had water element so Noggin had to take his place

[@boblguyy]

"i found a guy who really likes cybop"

[@Cutletz]

Ziggurab got stuck in amber

[@imati7319]

Oh wow cybop sounds (along with every other monster) goddamn amazing.

[@odayakaanimations7938]

LETS GO ANOTHER ONE OF THESE VIDEOS!

[@ambush8830]

“HAZAAAAAAAAAH” 💀

[@Warios_Warehouse]

Honestly if you’d release the full song separate I’d love that. Also this amazing! Wario approved for sure!

[@RealAshleyChill]

You can actually loop specific chapters of the video! Its what I've been doing to listen to this on repeat, alternatively you could ask Jake for the full song's audio file on his Discord server

[@DaKingKayden]

Wah

[@YLNpart2]

Stogg, Floogul, Repatillo/Ziggurab, and Krillby make the island so much better

[@ObjectGuy]

This is super cool and what if Earth island had Fire instead of earth

[@hux0rd]

YESS

[@pinguimcomquiboa9589]

Awesome music as aways jake

[@Juanbot_007]

Sounds beautiful keep the good work!👌❤️

[@Chrispratt18]

Noggin: sound like congle (Kinda) Pompom & Hoola:Obvious Floogull:whaddle Drumpler:sound like tympa

[@BierBart12]

Cybop and floogull are perfect! Actually, all of them are

[@phuditanfield2385]

Bro predicted Spurrit on fire oasis

[@LoarvicLoarvic]

Although less variative, Spurrit here is placed better than in the original.

[@Da_FB]

Disagree but ok

[@mranima748]

@@Da_FB it works as a transition, which with how boring spurrit’s sound is, is what it should be

[@Da_FB]

@@mranima748 the original makes it part of the song, this is like a clamble

[@bexonYTx]

One gripe I might have with this is congle isn't here so the mythical should have changed, and I guess that goes for spurring too, but really freaking fire with them so eh

[@zwodderk]

This is an actual masterpiece

[@tomato-c9l]

Pompom and hoola is everything 😍

[@nielvincentpaolopantalla3022]

Damn (am allow to dsay thi in this channel) the floogull whaddle is fire

[@purplexed9music]

This sounds awesome! Now get GHOSTYMPA to animate them lol

[@bsemz5836]

Or raw

[@amelonnamedkate1400]

Heard that beginning riff with Noggin and was half expecting “COME ON LETS GO” from tribal

[@lootex]

It sounds so much better than the real fire oasis

[@DaKingKayden]

This just shows why earth is the most powerful element in music (krillby, floogull, repatillo/ziggurab, and stogg carry this I swear)

[@athos9293]

Fire Oasis normally sounds bad tbh

[@richardholmes9264]

I disagree. Fire oasis is my favorite island

[@ForwardFacingTeimo]

@@athos9293 bruh it's good

[@FletcherRosas]

@@DaKingKayden because of stogg 🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥

[@Liam-da-weirdo]

I didn’t think that there was a way to make me actually like this song

[@WOE-ComposingGod]

Just leave it to Jake and he will make a masterpiece out of any island

[@tarecogames7377]

Krillby sounds like a pokemon song

[@Pazinfinity94]

3 seasonals, pretty epic

[@-Chaos_Potato-]

I love how Stogg sounds like Faerie island in the second track, but slightly sped up

[@whistleosc]

No wonder it’s called FIRE oasis

[@braidonsaelens5174]

As much as I love this nothing can save an island from Gobbleygourd. You did everything you could though and it ended up sounding great besides that

[@Keepup715]

Ah yes repatillo

[@GoofyAhhSonic]

Fire Mountain

[@taylorvanhorn5594]

Could you release another one where you add back water, plus the resulting Quad? Maybe you could also later add the plant elements, with the other 3 Quads and Candelavra?

[@spunchbob.]

You should make a what if with the natural island, so Plant Island would have fire instead of plant, etc.

[@Guicarvalho190]

I really love these kinda random projects

[@eliasstenbak5689]

Unexpected but I love it all the same

[@professoraristotlemeans8860]

The trio of Kayna, Hoola and Pompom is so damn beautiful

[@user-ut5fp6gp2p]

I LOVE noggin

[@chinarules666]

4:58 on this part the percussion went hard. Gobbleygourd sounded superior with them

[@quasar42069]

Scratches the brain. Mostly because Mammot has percussion in its part and I've been WANTING that.

[@Jellyfishs]

I started laughing the second time Spurrit started in the middle of the song and I don’t know why, love it though!

[@CloutmasterPhluphyy]

I have a crippling, burning, passionate hatred for spurrit, but i gotta admit that he actually sounds good here

[@LoarvicLoarvic]

Cool story bro HUZZAAAAH

[@user-fc1fo8yk6f]

THE ZAA ☝️🍃🍃

[@hopeflower3106]

Omg the floogull!!!!! He sounds amazing! Same with repatillo/ziggurab

[@jackr9445]

Can we take a moment to realize Spurrit has more tracks than an freaking icon of the game (mammott)

[@Zimathezim]

i love how stogg and repatillo sounds together

[@Kristan_Phillips_Bacon_The_2st]

How do you always manage to make every island better

[@Charlie-ck6fc]

100 times better, sounds amazing!

[@vapolemon]

It sounds like disco music, especially the parts where only stogg and percussion monsters play, i love

[@kingpremolky]

One thing I wanna say, jake the drake is absolutely awesome and amazing

[@treerex-id2yo]

I love cypop so much y’all make him sound so cooool

[@Chrispratt18]

4:57 god gobbleygourd carries

[@Reurovision]

Fire Desert. It has no water.

[@strangecolouredbird]

Good on Krilby for becoming a quad element on somwhere that isn't Amber island!

[@DiZiStiTch]

Yo this actually sounds super official?? Love Cybop's part, though you can never really go wrong with cybop

[@TheDumbTwin]

I take back what I said on the bone island what if on the floogull

[@Rizzymuth1843]

My favourite monster is floogull so I’m really glad you did this I LOVE floogull

[@Q_Nova]

Stogg and Ziggurab sound really good!!!! Probably my favorite