What If Obi Wan RAISED Luke Skywalker On Mandalore Instead Of Tatooine

Thoughts on todays video? I hope you enjoy, and have a great day!💚💙
Become a member: / @thestarwarsgalaxy
#starwars #ahsoka #anakin #anakinskywalker #clonewars #darthvader #georgelucas #revengeofthesith #whatif

[@rjhprofessionalemail7520]

Obi-Wan can never catch a break in these What Ifs. XD

[@seankately4411]

Least he got to impregnate Lady Kattan

[@iainballas]

Yeah, he's not a huge Obi-Wan fan XD Loves killing him as a 'sacrifice to make there be some pain' for the story.

[@Donkula23]

This was the worst one so far in terms of how badly written the sacrifice was lol

[@matthewlaflamme9019]

It's a Canon event 😅

[@lanesmith1465]

He gives him the Spider-Man treatment.

[@Fenris77]

A Force adept trained as a Mandalorian super commando would be a true powerhouse! Luke becomes a Mandalorian Knight.

[@valjamin8456]

Part of the reason for that is because The Way of the Mandalore, by necessity, overrules incompatible parts of the Jedi Code. Firstly, the "no attachments" rule is as Din Djarin states, the opposite of the Mandalorian creed. Secondly, as part of a warrior culture, Mandalorian Knights by definition do not hold the same pacifist ideals that the Jedi do. The result of this lack of many of the Jedi Code's flaws is an order of Mandalorian Knights that's far more balanced in the Force than the Jedi or Sith could ever be. Perhaps they would even be balanced enough to bring a permanent end to the endless cycle of war between the two sides of the force!

[@Fenris77]

@@valjamin8456 Indeed. During the Mandalorian Wars Around 4000 BBY (Revan's time) there was a number of Jedi that defected to the Mandalorian side. But a proper Mandalorian Order of Firce adherents could have worked. Like the Zeison Sha and Jal Shey that were Force Orders that was not part of the Jedi. THAT and they had the best armours in the Kotor 2 game.

[@thespikedpenguin]

What if Echo never went for the shuttle and escaped the citadel.

[@ClaudevonRiegan_]

That’s a good one!

[@Austrianhedgehog-mg6iz]

Good thought, hed probably help fives with the inhibitor chips

[@thedeadlydevils9130]

@@Austrianhedgehog-mg6izmost liky

[@wlm1697]

Horrible idea

[@unclebozo9845]

Now THIS is a great idea! Having Echo around when Fives discovered the chips has a ton of potential!

[@kalebdee790]

I appreciate that Luke's plan at the end amounted to bum rush the emperor 😂😂😂

[@valjamin8456]

I imagine part of the reason it worked is because the curse of the Darksaber worked to Luke and the Rebel Alliance's advantage in that war. Luke properly won the blade by winning a duel against Darth Vader, (By the way, you don't have to kill the previous owner to win the Darksaber like Luke did, just defeat them in battle.) and the blade likely easily attuned itself to him because he started leading a crusade to bring down a galaxy-spanning empire! (This blade is temperamental and resonates the most with someone who goes on such a crusade, whether they be conquerors or liberators.)

[@Jimusmc]

it's a very anakin thing to do.. just rush in

[@MrMrPWN]

Someone needs to tell Yoda he can come out of hiding 😂

[@markhanover2973]

That would be part of the sequel.

[@sillybob9689]

Nah, let him enjoy his "retirement" on nice, beautiful, wholesome swampy planet. It's time for new generation to fight for their future, not old generation.

[@dianesinger9729]

Well done, I loved that Luke was raised by Obi-Wan and Bo

[@timothyleggett7444]

🤣

[@jjmotion3498]

Same here.😅

[@MegadeathAdams]

What if Obi-Wan accidentally got a clone named Obi-Tew?

[@JohnGeorgeBauerBuis]

That would be funny.

[@chaplaingilgamesh2964]

"This is getting out of hand. Now there are two of them!"

[@NickMead04]

Yeah but the grandson could be obi trice

[@attackboss6]

Xvdksbsj STOP

[@legodoc1853]

This is treading on really old school theory territory XD

[@johnsullivan9064]

Mado Jedis sounds too badass to be true. Such is the beauty of what-ifs.

[@ArianaariasPrieto]

Vader- I can’t stab through you and can’t force choke you obi wan .obi- my turn force cracks anakins neck and says I should have did earlier

[@MatthewN8OHU]

Well, the Darksaber was created by a force-sensitive Mandalorian that trained with the Jedi Order, so it's not that far-fetched.

[@johnsullivan9064]

@@MatthewN8OHU but a whole order of Mando-Jedi? Nah, the Jedi wouldn't tolerate that.

[@MatthewN8OHU]

@@johnsullivan9064 At full strength, you're probably right, but don't forget the Jedi Order was pretty much non-existent at the time this story was set, so they wouldn't matter.

[@johnsullivan9064]

@@MatthewN8OHU fair enough

[@echocraft5741]

Obi wan really followed oogways teachings and went for the sister

[@megaman37456]

Yeah two things about this that are hard to believe: 1) Vader having the Dark Saber, like that shit was DEEP in Dathomir, a planet even Palpatine knows better than to fuck with. 2) Vader dual wielding. We know because of his cybernetics he can't move even a fraction of how fast he used to be able to before mustufar, so I doubt Vader would be able to successfully dual wield in a duel with a beskar wearing, well practiced, obi-wan. Like, nothing short of Vader dropping a tie fighter or star Destroyer would help him at that point.

[@GAJake]

I love the idea of Luke meeting Sabine at the academy before she makes the duchess.

[@darkvortex2410]

Thank you for everything you do. These What If's are a highlight of my day. I got some interesting What if's that could be fun. • What If Luke and Leia were switch - Luke goes to Alderaan and Leia goes to Tatooine. • What If Luke stayed on Dagobah • What If Anakin Skywalker and Padme Amidala assassinated Palpatine. - Anakin could become suspicious of Palpatine and does some detective work and discovers he's a sith so he and Padme kill him in secret. • What If Rey was Kylo Ren's sister. • What If Anakin Skywalker was made Battlemaster during the clone wars. - Cyin Drelic(can't remember how to spell his name) could die and the council votes for Anakin to replace him. • What if Kylo Ren was Luke Skywalker's son instead of Han and Leia • What If Anakin Skywalker had a younger sister. - she could also be force sensitive and trained as a jedi. How would this effect Anakin's fall. • What If Count Dooku was made Grandmaster of the Jedi order - this would happen before his turn but could be interesting. • What if Anakin Skywalker was sent to Malacore during the clone wars. - Palpatine could send him their to turn him. Maybe he makes a cross-guard lightsaber. • What If Anakin Skywalker created the Knights of Ren. • What If Anakin Skywalker and Obi-Wan Kenobi were Half Brothers. - Shmi could have been married and had Obi-Wan but they separated then Anakin was born as normal. Over the course of the story they discover the truth. Be cute to see Obi-Wan refer to Padme as his sister in law. • What If Palpatine and Sidious were two separate people. - Palpatine could be a caring Chancellor who sees Anakin like a grandson. Sidious is someone else trying to manipulate Anakin. I could see Anakin having an "I told you so" moment to the council. Maybe Palpatine retires after everything and helps raise Luke and Leia as a great-grandfather. May the force be with you.

[@thestarwarsgalaxy]

Woah! I’ll have to come back to this! Much appreciated

[@nightfuryman1209]

@@thestarwarsgalaxyI have a what if scenario that takes place on earth if it’s in the Star Wars universe if you’d wanna hear it

[@kobig982]

Those ideas will be awesome to see!! May the force be with you

[@adapperdragon8822]

@@thestarwarsgalaxyif you’re open to more ideas, what if General Grievous discovered that his memories were altered (the ones villanising the Jedi, happening somewhere before he is sent to “kidnap” palpatine)?

[@Achuidian179]

Gives me the impression of what Satine’s and Obi-wan’s life would had been like if he saved her from Maul. Day 56 of my list. What if; Anakin never gave into his feelings for Padme, Aayla Secura was the chosen one and became Darth Talon, Shme Skywalker was adopted by the Tusken Raiders, Boba Fett saved his Tusken family, Count Dooku was a regular count for the CIS, Jabba the Hutt supported the Jedi at the Start of the Clone Wars, and finally, what if Sabine and Ezra fell in love?

[@heatheroutre]

I'd love to see Aayla Secura as the chosen one

[@Achuidian179]

@@heatheroutre a popular choice for people

[@Thaumh]

Luke sees Ben and Vader, and the words of Yondu come to mind.

[@ldungey6972]

Fun fan fiction. Not entirely reliant on the foundation of canon for the fan fiction, while taking generous liberties while not getting too greedy. Good job.

[@connoreverright6592]

Whatch those wrist rockets!

[@benrossiter8605]

Can I just say why didn’t George retcon Episode 6 in the Death Star… why didn’t Luke tell Vader “ I have the high ground” when he jumped up to the cat walk

[@nerdwatch1017]

Man this idea is cool. I mean imagine how more capable Luke would be growing up being trained in the force by Ben right alongside training to be a strong Mandalorian fighter using all tech built to even the odds against a force user. But now in the hands of a very powerful Jedi!!! Sounds awesome!!

[@brokenbridge6316]

Nicely done video. And Obi-Wan and Bo-Katan together was interesting to see.

[@aaditchaudhary5067]

You should have included Din Djarin as Luke's best friend in this What If. It could have been awesome.

[@triskcyt5484]

Bo-biwan

[@thekaiser3815]

There is legend of the Mandalorian knights. Jedi who became Mandalorian. It was in interesting story in the Mandalorian wars

[@Isaac644]

This was so wholesome for obi wan and Bo they lost so much sister lover a planet a order a student so much sadness and in Bo case forgivence that her sister will never hear from her

[@beanzandcheese]

Maybe we could have an evil twist on on maybe “what if sidious killed yoda in their duel”

[@paulmodderman]

After killing the Emperor thisway, I don't think there would be any big battles left to win as any remaining war lords would more than likely try to keep from being found and put on trial for war crimes and more.

[@guts60]

There was a period where Obi-Wan met Satine, stole her heart, and nearly left the order for her. What would have happened if he did leave? Who would train Anakin, defeat Grevious, and eventually watch over and (briefly) train Luke?

[@valjamin8456]

There's already a what-if from Pente Patrol, Star Wars that covers this exact scenario. The short version is Qui Gon doesn't die to Darth Maul thanks to Count Dooku being by his side instead of Kenobi. The ripple effects of Master Qui Gon's continued presence eventually kill Palpatine's plans in their cradle before the Clone Wars can even begin.

[@robertdrexel2043]

There is also a fanfiction series with that premise called "She Said the Word" which has Obi-Wan and Satine married soon after Obi-Wan left the order. From there they end having two kids and later adopt Anakin after the Jedi refuse to train him. I do love how the whole story goes along and at the end its Obi-Wan along with his family, and their followers who end up putting Palptine into the ground before the Empire could even be formed.

[@brenersilva7361]

You dont know how this make me happy man love your videos

[@thestarwarsgalaxy]

Thank you!!! I hope you enjoy

[@Hammerchucker]

I said I had the high ground. Pouty face kitty emoji.

[@RolenCliffjumper295]

Watch those wrist rockets!

[@arcticfox3243]

This was a great story. I like how obi becomes the father figure luke needs. Also love bring in the arc generator story. The bo and obi twist was good as well. Nice job my friend keep up the great work.

[@thestarwarsgalaxy]

Thanks a ton!!

[@KingCodd]

what if sidious told the republic he was a sith when he was elected it isnt illegal to be a sith and i think it would be very interesting

[@juliangates4218]

This is amazing man. O my goodness, a duel saber battle between father and son is crazyyyy

[@ChrisPBacon-js1ch]

If I tried writing a more fleshed out story without contradicting anything you’ve already written in this story, would you be okay with it? I’ve been a big fan of the what if’s from your channel, PPSW and a few others, and this is legitimately one of the best what if stories I’ve heard and I’d love to see it expound upon.

[@nathanialwashere2404]

if u didn't publish it and or u give credit I think you will be fine.

[@seanbuckner2970]

Dude we need a part 2. That was pretty good 👍

[@draonoyxeta6795]

What if, hear me out. . . Palpatine never executed Order 66. . .?

[@valjamin8456]

Aren't there already lots of other what-if scenarios covered that result in Palpatine being unable to execute that order by the end?

[@Happysecret180]

What about if he executed someone named order 66

[@alexandernorton693]

What if palpatine used his second saber against windu after he lost his first?

[@jgamer516]

he would still lose

[@alexandernorton693]

@@jgamer516 windu just sees a lightsaber suddenly fly into his hand and be like what the heck? Windu would be off guard. Also it allows Anakin to see them fight so that would be interesting

[@jgamer516]

well yeah palpatine for sure would put up a fight but still mace was amped up but good point man@@alexandernorton693

[@Thaumh]

This is honestly one of your most intriguing ideas ever, and very well told.

[@arieshellstormm9487]

Man, Thank You for this, I truly love how this story has played out, You did a magnificent job in my opinion here, Please keep going with stories of this caliber, I will even play this tonight for My wife when she gets back from the eye surgeon, she loves anything to do with Mandalorian Culture and this story will make her so happy to listen too.

[@dennydanschin2001]

What if Anakin joined the Jedi Order however barely anyone (of course Qui Gon even though he still dies, Obiwan, Sidious/The Sith are the ones that do believe) actually believe he's "the chosen one" So I guess the title would "What if barely anyone thought Anakin was the chosen one"

[@nathanialwashere2404]

or what if only Obi-Wan and Qui Gon Knew he was the chosen one

[@memeboyr6177]

I have a few ones involving the clones What if Echo escaped the citadel? What if Tup's chip never malfunctioned? What if Crosshair never joined the empire? What if Wrecker killed the bad batch and Captain Rex when his chip activated? What if Captain Vaughn survived?

[@garrettwalter7293]

I love how almost any change suddenly gives every one. At least some measure of happiness.

[@StarWarsElement]

The Luke-alorian

[@scottmarshall5031]

Bro Disney need to hire you to right these, like the marvel what if series!!

[@chrisrisner3165]

This was a very interesting story line a bit different but at the same time very good. Great job with this

[@Kane-qf8dn]

These make my day always thank you!

[@thestarwarsgalaxy]

Hope you enjoy!!

[@lilynanswort5090]

I would love have more Obi-Wan adopting Luke, or having a child, it's so cute !!

[@chefmatthewlafferty]

I would LOVE to see a Part 2 for this story.

[@cylesteasunrise3199]

Would love a part 2

[@theguybehindyou4762]

I forgot Luke was even in this franchise! 😵‍💫

[@justingrillon]

Man, if thrawn and Vader died I feel like the emperor would know that immediately. And wouldn't be caught off guard

[@PSchafer29]

I think a part two of the order being formed and doing is part to weed out the imperial remnants throughout the galaxy would be awesome. There’s essentially become an order like the order of Revan following the will of the force

[@Elyseon]

Revan would be proud.

[@DarthTerminus-wy3gp]

I liked the way you included Sabine wren

[@majesticmsfc]

Bo and Kenobi together is one of the greatest things I've seen in a post ROTS timeline.

[@KepaniGrayson]

Amazing job. Luke couldn't have asked for better adopted parents.

[@NotceDragon]

Really love this atory and can't wait for a part 2

[@stuart00knight]

Great story. Very well thought out, and good conceptual alternative history.

[@user-tf8mb6cp5w]

This is too good. Bravo

[@masterwolf408]

What if Thrawn seeked the Mandalorians for aid and became a Mandalorian himself.

[@brightlord-ov7cm]

What if Clone Troopers were outfitted with Crysis Nanosuits and all of the upgrades?

[@LoliFoxQueen]

WATCH THOSE WRIST ROCKETS!

[@tobyplays2748]

What If Luke Skywalker traveled back in time to save Padmé Amidala?

[@the.unhappy.mechanic]

Fantastic story. There definitely needs to be a part 2 to this, it was over to quickly. 😊

[@markhanover2973]

Really this would make a great actual different SWUniverse to explore. Great idea!

[@DoomsdayOps]

Interesting alternative. I wouldn't have been upset if this was how the story went.

[@darthyetgon]

This is very cool would be great to see what you would do with a part 2 for this one 😊

[@spikethedragon341]

I literally spat my coffee when hearing Obi Wan and Bo's daughter's name is Cersei... And then I rewind a bit and turned on captions. Good Job making me facepalming on myself lol

[@troymathis9930]

Love the idea of a blending of Mandalorian and Jedi philosophy. True warriors of honor defending the Light of the Galaxy! Would basically be a Order of paladins dedicated to "The Way" and based on the "Jedi Philosophy"! Great combination in my opinion!

[@velder22]

These are really good

[@grandmasterbob1040]

Awesome video it was perfect

[@user-yc9vv9xb8s]

the Star Wars Galaxy what do you think of making what if anakin Skywalker was a jedi/mandalorian like tarr vizla what if Anakin Skywalker was trained by the force itself and what if Anakin Skywalker was reborn with all his memories powers and abilities also great what if

[@RJ-cf8jq]

I really like this "what if"

[@Stuingtion]

It would be boss to see Vader wielding the Vizsla Darksaber. Or even Luke Skywalker doing so.

[@danielharman572]

Man that's so cool. I genuinely enjoyed it alot. Hope you have a good idea for part 2 in mind because part 1 was awesome. Therefore part 2 must be equally as awesome. They say it isn't work if you love what you do. So enjoy your self and come up with something great. Kind regards from Daniel Harman.

[@Hiipower23]

This was a really good one

[@jonbonda1917]

Bo could had ejected before her ship crashed to take out Thrawn's ship. Palpatine could had used Force lightning in orbit but that would had distracted him and the Mandalorians could had bombarded his position from the flank after someone keeps him occupied with sniper shots.

[@devanmitchell1188]

Man this story would be so great

[@Iansco1]

Can we all mind cannon here that Luke also realized before 60 thst the Jedi needed to show a Stone Cold Steve Austin salute to NR?

[@mynkir-sol2150]

Nice story! It inspired me to expand a small family of Mandos i started making for my TTRPG SW campaign! Though i'm still debating making them Pantoran or Mirialan Mandos...

[@reeceemms1643]

Here are my ideas day 16 of asking: What if Cal and Merrin had a Daughter (Jedi Nightsister hybrid)? What if Padme was enslaved during the clone wars? What if during the rescue of Han Solo Leia failed to kill Jabba and was left behind remaining as a slave? What if Din Djarain and Bo-Katan fell in love during the events of Mando season 3? What if Luke and Leia found out they were siblings earlier (like before Empire strikes back?)? Similar to the previous one, what if Luke and Leia were not separated at brith and were both raised by Owen and Baru? What if Jyn Erso survived and went on to meet and fall in love with Luke Skywalker? What if Ahsoka found Shin Hatie before Baylon Skoll? What if the Aldani Heist went fully according to plan aka the whole payroll was stolen from under the Imperial noses?

[@robertorestrepo2335]

GREAT WHAT IF! THANKS!

[@rubenssilva6902]

What if the gonk droid became a jedi, lets say the force gave life to its metal

[@haroldchase4120]

Nice love the story !

[@immortalkombat6632]

"what if obi wan raised luke on manadalore" meanwhile less than four minutes in they leave mandalore

[@ttlghosty]

An amazing video as always! What if Admiral Yularen defected to the Rebellion after the destruction of Alderaan?

[@thestarwarsgalaxy]

Thank you! And interesting idea

[@ttlghosty]

@thestarwarsgalaxy Thank you! Would be cool for him to meet Luke, reminisce about Anakin! Rex and Yularen meeting again would be awesome!

[@Reighnfyre]

Part 2 & 3!!! DOOOOOOOOOOOOOO IT!!!! Have the Mandalorians claim the Clones in as Foundlings!!!!!

[@marcusisgod2592]

What if darth vader went to darthomir to learn. New suit or perhaps more unique powers. Resurrect talzin maybe. what if Vokara Che became a mentor to anakin as anakin was being treated for bullying and trauma from being a slave. What if anakin fell in love with luminara unduli, serra keto or bultar swan. What if anakin was taught by agen kolar or sasee tin or adi gallia.

[@TheRedHerring01]

While fighting count Dooku in revenge of the sith, what if all force sensitive beings lost the force.

[@onion4620]

I loved it part two please it’ll be great if they knew about Leah as their sister

[@madfingers72]

Well done.

[@martincorrigan8240]

Why do people forget about yoda no body tells him its free to come out now😂

[@SebRhade]

I want to see this as a movie!

[@hazemturjman]

hey swg i've been wondering about this question for a while. What if 10 year old leia never got caught.

[@chrislazcano1868]

In this AU, Luke haled as Mandalore the Liberator

[@wedgeantillies66]

Great alternate story and having Luke as a mandelorian Jedi and eventual leader of the mandelorian resistance would be a change for the difference and give the rebellion, greater military strength and experience in respect of its alliance early one and allow it to take on the empire in cannon, but sooner than in cannon.

[@DarthnightKing]

Great work I really like it

[@thestarwarsgalaxy]

Much appreciated!

[@scottwestleysmith3196]

I love this one.

[@timotheussimonatlas1431]

I’m so delighted this satisfies my headcanon of Obi-WanxBo-Katan. I’m of the belief that Kenobi is very exclusively Kryze-s3xual

[@marcusisgod2592]

What if anakin was piloting before attack of the clones and sensed ventress fall to the darkside as her master died and took his ship to the planet to investigate. Perhaps starting a romance as they are very similar in their stories. Also what if ahsoka taught ben skywalker as she saw him as history repeating itself. What if anakin was a jedi watchmen or wayfinder. What if anakin went with kenobi to face maul and savage instead of adi gallia. What if anakin fell in love with luminara or your own version of aayla secura romance. What if oppo rancis trained anakin. What if anakin met and fell in love with ventress just before the clone wars just after her masters death. What if anakin became a jedi sentinel like a watchmen or one of those who find younglings. What if evan piel became a mentor or second master to anakin. Or anakin became a healer either before or after his mother death could be related to his friendship with offee or alternatively what if he was trained by tra sa who taught windu and actually did not forbid attachment as shown by her relationship with tholme , they could become like a pseudo parents to anakin and train him away from the temple in azati martial arts and from trasa the living force as she is a plant lady so imagine anakin controlling plant life.

[@sampsjt]

11:48 Why would Obi Wan and Bo Katan's daughter be named skywalker