What If Obi-Wan REFUSED To Fight General Grievous Without Anakin Skywalker

[@benjaminparker671]

What If Yoda went with Obi-Wan and Anakin to rescue Chancellor Palpatine above Coruscant and Mace Windu went to Mandalore with Ahsoka to fight Maul

[@grandmasterbob1040]

Awesome idea this must happen

[@baby_toster59]

Agreeed

[@TonyMontana-bo8ne]

❤

[@WorldWalker128]

That's an interesting flip.

[@heisenberg1681]

Dooku would be dead within minutes easily

[@RyanTheDark]

Without plot armor, this most likely would have happened tbh. Obi-Wan was protective over Anakin throughout the Clone Wars more than he likes to act like.

[@skyesmith5683]

I still don’t know why obi wan never fought for him to be made a master he might have said it once or twice every once in a while but not nearly as much as he should

[@british35]

@@skyesmith5683If the war wasn’t at it’s climax, he probably would have

[@8vantor8]

@@skyesmith5683 well, the actual reason is that it was a prequel, thus it had to end badly, and the characters could not be written to 100% be themselves or it would not be a prequel for a in universe reason, i guess he was a little drunk

[@histguy101]

​@@skyesmith5683Why should Anakin be made a master? Obi Wan was the youngest mast ever and he had to wait until he was like 38 yrs old. The only reason Anakin even wanted the rank was so he could access the Sith holocrons locked away in the Jedi library. Definitely not master material

[@gabrielharris4361]

“I see your sense of humor survived the landing” “At least you’re a master… at getting caught” “Very funny” 😅😂

[@jamesplunkett8912]

Anakin jokingly to Obi-Wan: Next time try not to lose it. This weapon is your life, Obi-Wan. Obi-Wan tries hard not to smile chuckling: Very funny 😁.

[@nooneinparticular1491]

I realize that the plot of Revenge of the Sith was greatly streamlined by not sending Anakin with Obi-Wan, but it never really made sense. As far as the Jedi Council knew, that mission was the one that could end the war, yet they weren't going to include one of their best battlefield commanders, who also happened to be one of their two most formidable combat pilots?

[@chrisbo5288]

I think normally they would have send both but due to Palpatines manipulations they were annoyed with him intervening in jedi business and so only Obiwan was send instead. They did not trust Palpatine and to an extent Anakin as well.

[@eduardofarias6810]

They didn´t trust Anakin at all, especially when Anakin joined the council through Palpatine. To be honest, with the excession of a few masters like Secura and Obiwan, the entire order didn´t like Anakin at all. He always recieved a special treatment as the choosen one and was a genius (geniuses always piss of everyone). Besides that, he was never a younglin, so he didn´t had any childhood friend in the order.

[@Skyline_r3496]

They had Anakin spy on the chancellor

[@tronovonflidder775]

Anakin had to spy on Palpatine. Personally I don't get why Mace Windu never went himself, as slaying Grievous was really important.

[@eugenelau3927]

@@eduardofarias6810 Anakin's fellow Younglings got under his skin by saying the "slave" word and nearly had themselves killed!!! Don't blame him for that, no-one scolded those bullies!!!

[@434444334]

This is a dark history there is no HELLO there

[@thestarwarsgalaxy]

How could I forget 🤦‍♂️

[@bedsidekhair3667]

Anakin: hello there Grievous: GENERAL ANAKIN

[@RMV1560]

@@thestarwarsgalaxyhello there separatists

[@Skorpion_B]

@@bedsidekhair3667wouldnt it be general skywalker

[@scareditymays6yearsago477]

What if Anakin and the entire 501st lead the Rebellion?

[@lilithsellie8976]

HERO WITH NO FEAR REBELLION ANAKIN... THE ANAKIN WE DIDNT KNOW WE NEEDED

[@HurstonEstep]

This needs to be done.

[@randomiser2267]

It would have been a short empire.

[@jearlblah5169]

Yeah like maybe the 501st doesn’t turn on Ahsoka because technically she wasn’t a Jedi, so they don’t end up crashing

[@mtroy5761]

Yeesssss

[@devingendron2287]

24:11, Honestly I like the idea of these fics, or at least the ones based around obi wan's actions and choices, being his nightmares while in exile, that he is haunted by all the things he could have done differently to save his friend, his brother, by the choices he made guided by the code which proved ultimately disastrous. It lends well to his statement "I have failed you Anakin. I have failed you."

[@Dragoninja26]

Yeah it'd be evil to spring that twist on us in the end, but it also feels like it makes sense and I do respect the idea

[@billybubbabill2253]

What if Ahsoka was convicted of the bombings and sentenced to death because the evidence to prove her innocence didn't fall into Anakin's lap , and Obi-Wan decides to go rescue her believing her to be innocent and knowing that the council will be watching Anakin too closely for him to do it himself.

[@watrebel9595]

This is awesome

[@JM00237]

Good what if scenario I hope he does it. Hope he decides to give it a good ending too if he does

[@metalanarchy5186]

That is a really good one another that I think would be a good is what if qui gon Dookoo Anankin and obi wan left the order together to start something new I guess you could throw Ashoka in there to cause they all have been know to go aganist the norms of the order

[@kevinhudson4552]

Thank you for a story that doesn’t kill Obi-Wan. 🙂

[@Shadoweagle7]

The only crime here was the removal of the "Hello there" meme. Awesome take on this What If!

[@seansmith8758]

This was a great What If, very well written and narrated. Keep up the tales of the Star Wars multiverse.

[@noratheweeb9387]

I honestly doubt Mace Windu would not have sensed the attack coming, let alone not reacted to Palatine flying at him, just because he didn't know he was the sith lord.

[@ebonaparte3853]

Windy was barely prepared for the ferocity of Palpatine’s attack when he knew he was a Sith Lord. If he didn’t know, he wouldn’t be prepared at all for it.

[@noratheweeb9387]

@@ebonaparte3853a fair enough point, but the thing is: no matter what, they were going there to demand Palpatine give up his power or be arrested. Whether they expected him to be a sith lord or not, they would have been on guard for some kind of response if he said no. And had he started attacking them, whether or not they knew he was a Sith Lord, Windu, of all people, would react. He's literally one of the few Jedi capable of defeating Palpatine in a one-on-one fight. It's unlikely he wouldn't react, even if he failed to counter the strike.

[@aarohalme1020]

​@@noratheweeb9387He was expecting that Palpatine was just a Chancellor, and there were no guards in the room either. Given these 2 circumstances, him dying to a surprise attack seems likely. Maybe he could have taken a severe injury and fought back a bit instead, with Palpatine winning due to Windu being weakened to show Windu's power a bit more though as the master of the jedi order.

[@Matt-yg8ub]

I doubt Palpatine wouldn’t have just placed a claymore mine under the carpet to deal with unwelcome guests.

[@glennbriggs6490]

Technically, this outcome was mostly the same as many others, so I'm glad you told us about the idea of it all being in obi-wans head. That sort of provided an alternative ending to this story. Loving the details for these stories dude. Nice work ☺️

[@kyledavid9415]

Sidious' plan is so insanely convoluted that the smallest change of events would make the galaxy a better place in the end. He's just like Madara

[@imisstheoldyoutube9845]

Its almost like you can write whatever outcome you want 🤯

[@peete9582]

Yeah I doubt that Sidious would kill Mace Windu immediately here are some outcomes either Sidious flee before the Jedi even get to him or even during the confrontation he could have jumped out of the window and hijack someone's flying car or he found out that General Grievous's dead and he's aware that he needs to give up emergency powers so he would have called his loyalists so that he could use it as an escape route

[@Fridaey13txhOktober]

"Soap dropped, Mace!"

[@Jarikraider]

Back when the animated Clone Wars movie was canon, it actually makes almost no sense to send Obi-wan alone since Grievous was such a large threat that managed to best multiple Jedi in combat.

[@youngmerk88]

This ending was way better than the original. An alt timeline where 66 never happened would’ve been cool. Or full body ANI killing palps, and having the empire to himself, or leave with Padme, and start his own order.

[@fosterfied9007]

If you ask me they should’ve done that at least, Obi and Ani should’ve gone together to take down Grevious. Especially since they didn’t trust Ani they might as well make him hang out with Obi instead of being closer to Palpatine. But instead of course, they decide to be assholes to Ani instead.

[@lukewilliams6648]

This was pretty good apart from Mace Windu dying instantly, he canonically won the fight in Revenge of the sith. I find it very hard to believe that he couldn’t draw his lightsaber in time and the battle would end the same.

[@thestarwarsgalaxy]

I get it. But he has no idea Sidious was Palpatine. And Sidious attacked him first because he’s the biggest threat. Also I needed this to happen for my story lol

[@TheHighborn]

Yeah, but fuck Windu. Everybody wants him clapped

[@nikolaarandjelovic1930]

What if obi wan saved anakin from the Jedi council I know this is kind of that but what if he saw the councils corruption from the start

[@soularprimestudios5930]

What if after Maul died by Obi Wan he was given a second chance with his soul brought back in the past the moment he was taken by Sideous as a child with all his knowledge power and memories still intact?

[@theseekerofancienttruth3873]

This sounds Amazing.

[@mitchellpennell]

Do it!

[@valentinlageot4101]

He was already brought back

[@soularprimestudios5930]

​@@valentinlageot4101I'm afraid my what if is more complex than that my friend...He is not coming back he starts over entirely....from the very start......birth...a child....

[@valentinlageot4101]

@@soularprimestudios5930 okay but that will never happen in star wars, that's simply breaking the lore that is already quite fragile (the world between world could be a explanation of your what if but I really don't like to consider it cannon at all cause it basically gave us more questions than it answer.

[@agentmjl7]

What if Bail wasn’t on Alderaan when it was destroyed? I know this might not have many places to go, but maybe he could have told Luke and Leia who they were and go from there 🤷🏽‍♀️ either way your stories are amazing and I love them!

[@vnep5743]

In these scenarios where Anakin faces off against Sidious, what if at the last second the sith lord said "now strike me down, and complete your journey to the dark side." which Anakin replies with something about how that will never happen. To which Sidious replies "so you believe." And cackles away as Anakin finishes him.

[@theplatinumdragon1744]

I don’t think the temple would fall if Anakin wasn’t there because anakin killed almost every single Jedi in that temple the clones by themselves wouldn’t stand a chance at taking the temple by themselves maybe they’d kill a good few Jedi but I do believe the Jedi would eliminate the clones regardless of how many fell

[@ballisticautistic5398]

What if Ventress and the Nightsisters killed Dooku on Sereno during the Clone Wars?

[@isaaccarter5650]

You do a great anakin and Palpatine impression!! Love your videos I stumbled across them maybe 2 weeks ago and listen to them while I drive to my jobs at work. Keep up the great work!

[@thestarwarsgalaxy]

Welcome aboard! Thanks for the support

[@WolfBlade84-]

"Hit every button in your vicinity" *Nukeler bomb operter has entered the chat*

[@patrickd2853]

One question, how did Anakin and Obi wan defeat Sidious when Mace and the others couldn’t. Mace already suspected Palpatine was Sidious , he would’ve probably been prepared or get more Jedi to join him because there wasn’t an immediate threat.

[@oliversherman2414]

You always come up with the best scenarios

[@rangopistacho6928]

I like this ending, it isnt a perfect ending where everyone ends up surviving, but it still leaves the galaxy mostly intact

[@havesomeculture]

Lord DARTH MAULUS, Lord DARTH VAEDER - bubbly bubbly nose

[@dianesinger9729]

Now that ending would have been fun Obi-Wan waking up in the desert. But this was a good ending thanks

[@Hei_Darkfire]

This one was pretty good. I didn't even think about the fact that, in this scenario, there was no talk with Palpatine about the power Anakin needed to save Padme, so Anakin had no reason to side with Palpatine.

[@disneyknightspadilla1406]

Truthfully I always believe grievous was meant to be anakin Skywalker nemesis because they’re both flesh and machine. But never had because they’re always facing the same running gag over and over again.

[@matthewaven3802]

If Obiwan was fighting the 2003 Grievous, he would have definitely needed Anakin’s help.

[@shadowslayer9196]

Gracious would still lose its just animation n nostalgia clowding ur judgement

[@ttcannonii857]

​@@shadowslayer9196no, 2003 Grievous was way stronger than 2005 Grievous.

[@blow4804]

ive watched like 30 videos. best youtuber to watch when there is nothing to watch (which is almost always)

[@Randomthew]

Who else read "I need him!" In Anakin's voice when he said that about Palpatine

[@ericcrabtree7075]

Anakin - Hello There General Grievous - General Skywalker *ignites lightsabers* 8:37

[@austinzizzi1142]

This is what it should have been it’s so weird they sent obi wan by himself while they had always been together before

[@reckszkingzactivitiesrkat.4134]

Great stories man keep them going they are really good 🔥

[@troykanotz626]

What if the separatists disabled the droid shut down command?

[@OtawoOnlineGaming]

Don’t hit any buttons unless they’re red and labeled, “Don’t Touch.”

[@Forge_Spark7567]

Just want to say that I really like your content. You put a lot of effort into your videos. Also, What if Anakin was happy to get a seat on the council instead of being angry that he didn’t get the rank of master.

[@kappakiev9672]

All these clone war era whats are good but I’d like there to be more during the dark times, OT, and post-endor eras

[@TheForcesWrath]

Not bad man, good work. I await the next one with great anticipation. Hopefully its about the Sith growing in power but not as overly evil but as a rival to the Jedi in solving the galaxies problems in such a way that the Jedi become jealous (as expected by the Sith) in doing so giving more supprt for many to become Sith citizens. Just like The Old Republic days where the Sith and Jedi split up the galaxy equally.

[@johnonyango3166]

Wow. This was really good.

[@RayAkuma]

The Star Wars Galaxy: ,,click every button in your vicinity." The president, when watching this: ☢️👀

[@cipeam8090]

what a happy landing

[@rickybartlett7210]

Great story. It's hard to buy that Palpatine caught Mace off guard. Mace already didn't trust him, and if he wasn't expecting something he wouldn't have gone with 3 other masters. But still, it was a great story

[@DarrielOni]

What if General Grievous remained his 2003 cartoon version, without having his chest crushed by Windu?

[@havesomeculture]

Even before that event, he had coughing problems.

[@Noah1985HA]

Enjoyed this i always wondered about this exact topic

[@MrJejonez]

What if they revived Greivous but re programmes his base synapses. Made him a good robot.

[@willess1310]

"press the like button. press every button in your vicinity." The President: "well, since you asked..." (presses the nuke button)

[@devingendron2287]

18:29 I like that Anakin immediately assumes he's the "much younger and far more powerful" apprentice lol. I mean, its a reasonable assumption, the only Jedi more powerful than dooku were yoda, windu, and anakin I'm pretty sure and Anakin is the only one of them that is young, and the one most likely to fall.

[@haydengames9271]

What if grievous learned the truth of how he was made and joined the Jedi?

[@callumreynolds2812]

What if obi wan captured Maul in the phantom menace

[@Teardehawkee]

What if Lando had force abilities and trained by the Jedi.

this was wholesome, the first part

[@Coleskywalker]

Padme is smarter than palpatine in this nice

[@SecureInMyHead]

The more I watch this, the more I realize that almost everything is actually Mace Windu’s fault.

[@GAJake]

What if dooku told qui-gon palpatine was siduis before they went back to naboo realizing palpatine was had used this to become chancellor and killed plaguis? Lets say they intercepted his transmissions to nute gunray. Would the republic have sent judicials? would the jedi have sent more masters to help naboo and defeat maul?

[@ICallShotgun13]

The thumbnail made me think it was about Obi-Wan somehow taking Grievous as a new apprentice on Utapau.

[@joekauffman9690]

This was a brilliant talk, Obi Wan would of been there for Anakin, could you do what if Anakin quit being a jedi and left the Jedi council after he was not granted by the rank of master

[@gameslayerdragon1049]

Know if you said that at the end that would be a twist of awesomeness

[@Dragoninja26]

You would be so evil if you twisted it like that at the end lol

[@h24manu]

"Somehow Palpatine was a Sith Lord"

[@scottbraun2457]

"WHAT IF"... it was ANNAKIN..alone after Grevous, on Utapou, and Obiwon..impatiently waiting in the counsel chamber..then running in to see Windu, ready to finnish off Sidious. But, instead of stopping him the way it was done originally..Obi-Wan..sees through the force a creature in Windu's arm.. With a FORCE-PULL, he yanks him in away from the window..but still severs the arm while catching the FORCELIGHTNING attack of Sidious, sending it back at the same time as saberslicing him in half. For a moment, only the Jedis' heavy breathing, and wind through now open window could be heard. Just the instant Windu was about to demand an explanation..while looking across at his severed arm..a serpentine creature emerged from the disembodied limb. He had already all the explanation he needed, and thanks Obi-Wan for his life... I trust you can wrap up the story the rest of the way..with ANNAKIN..triumphantly returning.. with a Grevious head trophy in one hand, and the Sepritist Counsel in the other....

[@InfernosReaper]

It's always weird to me how in *all* of these What-ifs when they don't know he's a Sith, the Jedi *never* expect Palpatine to just break out a blaster and start shooting.

[@Cantersoft]

Why would Palpatine be upset about Anakin going to fight Grievous if he's the one who made the suggestion in the first place? This doesn't make sense.

[@jamescrowley5668]

bc he wanted Anakin to get angry that he was declined the mission and lose more trust in the jedi

[@eereree]

Big brother Obi-Waaaan

[@spacedragon1175]

12:20 Obi-Wan you dropped something...

[@Dag8791]

You demon you just broke my soul

[@MegaRogash]

Bail Organa would make much more sense as an interim chancellor.

[@haydenfowle7576]

It would make sense Anakin and Obi Wan had been a effective team since before the war started they fought in the shittiest battles together and it would only make sense to send Anakin too

[@davidmauriciogutierrezespi5244]

Obi-Wan should really have gone for the throat with _More experience in combat than Anakin, Master Windu?_ And if they bring up any objection about Anakin not being a master he could just say _Remeber the invasion on Naboo? You sent a master with a padawan against a sith lord. Anakin is far better equip now than I was when I saw Qui Gon die_

[@cdoconn]

I love your little own Star Wars Infinites

[@RobertWWD]

Mace Windu was once terrified of General Grievous because of how quickly General Grievous adapted to Vaapad. I’m not sure how the process worked but General Grievous is force sensitive kind of because of what Count Dooku did to Sifo-Dyas.

[@PhiloLogos777]

This was a great one

[@benjamincoats8301]

Thank you for the happy ending ☺️

[@simon19981]

And Dadbeh woke up seeing an orderly placing his medication into an intravenous drip, and seeing one of the doctors looking in, the only thought on his mind, why does he look like Palputine?

[@jewlbunny]

What if Anakin and Vader were a split personality like Harvey Dent and Two-Face? What is Qui-Gon was taken seriously in The Phantom Menace? What if Vader was Venomized?

[@spoon-q1g]

so obi-wan never said HELLO THERE??

[@darkmonger6244]

Y’know, this is probably the best ending in terms of bringing balance to the force

[@chasetauscher9544]

What if General Grevious was the Chosen One? What if Mace Windu was the Grandmaster and Yoda was the Master of the Order? What if the Lost Tribe of the Sith landed on Exegol?

[@patrickd2853]

With the lost tribe do you mean the grey Jedi or a different faction.

[@chasetauscher9544]

@@patrickd2853 I mean the ship that carried members of Naga Sadow’s Sith Order.

[@patrickd2853]

Thanks.

[@vencislavdimitrov9304]

Not just Obi-Wan, we all wished that was real 😢

[@isyx9935]

This was one of my fav ones the very good happy ending with the brothers surviving and not obi wan or anakin turn to the dark side bc of their death (wich im pretty happy you didnt kill them this time) and the clones being normal again and probaly most of the favorite jedis being still alive. 👏👏👏👏

[@tylerbunner4353]

Fisto only died because of skywalker and they had their suspicions on palps

[@Dajurassicaustralovenator]

What if when they arrived they both said to grievous hello there

[@deaddevilking]

I love your fan. Fics

[@YamamotoKazuo]

Anakin did the right thing slashing Mace's hand off. Mace is evil, look what he did to Asoka

[@irruption4770]

what if Anakin stayed in the Dark side after the tusken incident

[@conork9060]

what if Tatooine was in the republic?

[@brothers_of_nod]

A fine video.

[@dorukvolkankaynak9116]

I love this stories

[@djdjdijon]

The windu confrontation just wouldn’t happen without Anakin being their they’d actually be committing treason with no evidence

[@RetroGamerBB]

Strange the jedi didnt want to capture grevious

[@andrewweber9930]

Bad ass brother

[@CharlesLaBuhn]

I understand, that WOULD have been a great ending lol. This was one of your best, emotional and filled with power. Please do not let the Mando that Disney hired get to you, that would be a real shame. I would have to find another Apprentice, I mean Creator.

[@MackHeath-ns7ly]

now that would have been Awesome grant you it would have changed Episodes 4 thru 6 but at least it would have ended on a better note than what it did so keep up the good work a CGI Story line with live action might have been good but hey that was just a idea I have had in the past