What if Planets Were The Moons of Jupiter? - Universe Sandbox²

Hello and welcome to What Da Math!
In this video, we will talk about a hypothetical scenario of all of the planets becoming the moons of Jupiter.
Patreon page:
www.patreon.com/user?u=231819...
Enjoy and please subscribe.
Other videos here: • Universe Sandbox 2
Twitter: / whatdamath
Facebook: / whatdamath
Twitch: / whatdamath

[@Sam-oz8pn]

I asked this before, and you declined because you said you weren't creative, but could you create a solar system of your own? You can take user suggestions for names, and maybe what kind of orbit/planet to use, etc. No need for creativity, it would be mostly fan-made. You could go through a lot of the topics you did videos on previously too. It could be a mini series.

[@AlexEvett55]

I did that once in US2, and the planets and stuff had random names.

[@garrettlarrivee8997]

Ηι βγε I belive he should do all this stuff u are suggesting I completely agree with u

[@Sam-oz8pn]

I have done one of these, but I bet it wouldn't be as cool as a community created one. I named some of the bodies. Would you like to compare our systems?

[@kilos5958]

Ηι βγε.

[@waynejackson207]

ßįę?

[@kodiak4594]

7:11 "we might have actually created a stable system" as mercury slingshots even higher outsystem. I am laughing so hard. I love these videos

[@saturn2950]

If Jupiter got all the planets then i will be the largest moon of jupiter

[@lvpgaming9187]

saturn ok

[@rocketnerd7763]

Yup

[@suntheyellowstar9976]

true but what about me

[@aratakiitto4568]

Lol

[@aratakiitto4568]

It's a binary system

[@cratfin2474]

as mercury flies into the orbits of other planets "we may have made a stable orbit here"

[@watersheepsson1722]

Cratfin247 Name It was Venus that was flying

[@tomvorat4173]

I love how jupiter slingshotted neptune into saturn

[@tls559]

Pew

[@MarshalArnold]

Always find myself saying "hello wonderful person" everytime I start one of your vids Haha! Great work man, really enjoy your channel. Just subbed a few weeks ago.

[@JoaKimzen]

Jupiter is really nice planet yes :)

[@watersheepsson1722]

JoaKimzen What bout earth ya jerk

[@moustachio05]

@@watersheepsson1722 just do it sub to pewdiepie

[@videoinformer]

*Suggestion:* If the program allows, try setting the initial position and velocity of the planets smaller than Saturn so they start in a circular orbit around the *center of mass* between the co-orbiting Jupiter-Saturn binary planetary system. It seems to me the reason the orbits of planets quickly degrade in the way they do is because you are telling your program to set the position and velocity of the small planets as though they are in orbit around Jupiter. But, they are *never* really in orbit around Jupiter, but always and only the center of mass of the system. As a result, your initial placement/velocity puts the small planets into a radically elliptical orbit with one of the two foci being the center of mass of the system. This brings them crashing into Jupiter, around which they were *never* in orbit, according to " *da math* ". (BTW, this was really fun to watch. I feel like a little kid playing with toy soldiers again.)

[@Barnardrab]

This is one of my favorite speculations. I've always wondered what it would be like to stand on the surface of the Earth and see Jupiter sitting there in the sky.

[@dezraq1984]

Your videos are awesome and satisfy so much of my curiosity. I had no idea that a program like Universe Sandbox existed. Thank you for enlightening me to this fact and the intriguing theories you bring to life in your videos.

[@zappadow6538]

you put Saturn too close to Jupiter's Roche limit

[@xmalin1]

I hope you can make a part 2 of this. I watched this so much.

[@yorgle]

I've been going through a lot of your videos recently, really enjoying them. It still both hurts my brain and is totally fascinating that huge masses, in the middle of the nothingness of space are attracted to each other...

[@SuperMano-me5vl]

2:22 "Oh, no! We're headed straight for it! NNNNNNNNNNNNN...PHEW! Thank God we barely made it...OH CRAAAAAAAAAAAAP!" *feed cuts*

[@annieyu4490]

The shape you're talking about is called a trochoid, all of those shapes are prolate trochoids.

[@czarpeppers6250]

You should do a video on that exo-moon candidate of a Neptune sized moon around a Jupiter sized planet.

[@eggaweb]

Oops, I just destroyed Neptune.

[@27bluntman]

Jyuranus

[@autistickid8905]

eggaweb how

[@suntheyellowstar9976]

@@kittycats17 that joke is becoming older

[@shakattack1163]

this is actually quite fascinating

[@Hydrogenblonde]

Hi Anton, have Jupiter and Saturn orbiting a common center of gravity and then have the other planets also orbit the common center of gravity as well rather than orbiting Jupiter. Also make the other planets orbit a much greater distance, ie: more than 1AU.

[@charachoppel3116]

This was just awesome!! So fun to watch! LoL !!!

[@TheJedimaster6788]

wow! this is fascinating!

[@Bdan-ez6jv]

Maybe do a video seeing if the planets in our solar system were in the Trappist system. Also love the vids!

[@qualifiedidiots2165]

Jupiter lighting up isn’t a bug. Because daddy Sol isn’t home, and has Technically put big brother Jupiter in charge. Big J thinks he’s allowed to push his siblings around, sometimes even hurting them by being too rough, and raiding the liquor until he’s all woozy and ends up with a burning headache. Sol: what the hell happened? J: I learned it by watching You!!

[@KerbalLauncher]

Anyone else notice the orbital resonance between Mercury, Venus, Earth, and Mars before he placed Saturn? (it was 1:3:5:9 I think) Unless he planned this out by calculating the semi-major axes beforehand, it's really cool that the bodies entered a state of orbital resonance all by themselves. It was also really cool that before he placed any of the other gas giants, the planets entered a 1:2:4:8 resonance.

[@Pluto-sl9fl]

Hey, that was only eight planets! Is there something I should know?

[@justgetdanked3589]

Pluto Hey.

[@CalebOfKartin]

uh oh should we tell him?

[@somusonuroy]

I like how you crash things in space at the end.. ha ha ha !!

[@TiagoTiagoT]

I think this might be doable if you put the bigger planets much more far apart.

[@HDdeadchannel]

Before I watch the video, I know that the planets orbiting Jupiter will have an effect on its orbit because of how large they are, especial Saturn and the two ice giants. I do not think Mercury will have an effect on the planet, because it is smaller than the largest moon in our solar system, Ganymede, which orbits Jupiter.

[@larrylentini5688]

If you got Jupiter and Saturn orbiting each other and put everything else much further away I think it could have been stable, but it's difficult with such large planets.

[@AlexEvett55]

I think ganymede is less massive than mercury, but i'm not sure.

[@TheInterstellarStorm]

Harry Evett Ganymede is a bit larger than Mercury

[@AlexEvett55]

i know but i think its less dense so it has less mass

[@TheInterstellarStorm]

may be true

[@ClasherofWorlds]

Harry Evett Ganymede is bigger

[@wormysquirmy9214]

Yeah

[@sethsammyrosevlogs9307]

I loved this

[@kinorai]

4:41 "If things go wrong, they go wrong". Did you plan 2020 with your game "universe sandbox"???

[@husseinmokdad2006]

You my freind are a legend no dislikes

[@thepigdot]

Create a stable Jupiter - saturn binary system and have the remaining planets orbit the further out? If Binary star systems exist, you can do it with planets

[@richardvalvona1159]

Actually there was something I saw in Google News about a Jupiters-sized exoplanet with a Neptune-sized exomoon orbiting it the other day. In fact, it was the first exomoon ever discovered.

[@veggiet2009]

You say there's a bug in the game where "the tidal forces seem to affect the planet that objects are orbiting around and not the other way around" I'm curious if you understand what tidal forces are, or are having trouble expressing what you mean. Because the phrase "tidal force" comes from our "tides" that are caused by the moon, in other words the tidal forces affect the earth that the moon is orbiting around. If this is the function in the game then it is working accurately. Now we know that the tidal forces work both ways, but the amount of the effect differs based on factors that I can't remember right now.

[@ShwappaJ]

The planets were all too close to each other, that's why most of them got murked by Jupiter and Saturn.

[@CursorIsHere]

You should attempt this again but like how multi star systems orbit each other

[@toby1248]

You need to put Saturn as close as possible to Jupiter (much closer than your first two attempts) and have the rest of the planets much further out in circumbinary orbits. There should be plenty of stable configurations in that scenario

[@Andominicus]

You have the same 1st name as my little brother, he also watches your videos, he says his fav is when you created earth using eris, lol

[@andreferreira4159]

I like the way you say Uranus

[@craig291086]

Create a solar system with 100 binary stars, and it has to work. They all have to be the biggest of stars and spinning in opposite directions but rotating the same direction.

[@AmaroqStarwind]

Man, Saturn's an asshole! Universe Sandbox needs a "kill-feed" / Event Console, so that you can see a written log of all the events which occur, such as "Earth has collided with Mars" or "Venus was ripped apart by Neptune's tidal forces". I have an idea for a future video: Use black holes to create an interstellar railgun to send planets from one star system to another.

[@pavasambashta3103]

Sir, nice video..By the way what software do you use??

[@moviemasters5415]

you should do something like this but with all bodies of the solar system except the sun

[@enkiimuto1041]

Should probably have made Saturn and Jupiter binary systems, make Uranus and Neptune orbit it from very far away with a resonance and make the smaller planets moons of the ice giants or just stuck in Lagrange points.

[@SkinnerNoah]

Put Saturn orbiting closest to Jupiter. Then put the Rocky planets further out, and the ice Giants after them. Saturn and Jupiter will almost orbit in a binary fashion, and their combined center of gravity might help stabilize each other and the other planets

[@tonk9246]

you can create a stable system with Saturn and even other Jupiter by change the Jupiter's size to 1 sun

[@Onychoprion27]

I like that Earth and Venus seemed to fall into a 2:1 resonance all on their own. Maybe if the gas giants' orbits werent so eccentric Mars and Mercury would've done so, too.

[@Spingerex]

the Sun is a huge troll,it gives sunlight and warmth but also gives cancer XD

[@SgtAbramovich]

Saturn is the reason we can't have nice things.

[@nightruler666]

It think its special cause it got rings

[@kingfaz07]

Vampirerockstar nearly every planet has rings in our solar system juipter does Saturn does Uranus does Neptune does

[@psyber649]

By the way Uranus kicked out Mercury

[@senbonzakuraonne9643]

John Abramo ，

[@eova]

...And all this time I thought it was Uranus...

[@ophadamia2579]

If you got Ophadamia the moons will swirl each other even worse because of its strong gravity.

[@Drkipernick]

Do a video where you create your own solar system from scratch. Not matching our current solar system, it should be simulation style. Would be interesting.

[@Ilovepointlessstorys]

you should do a video what would happen if Neptune was the third planet

[@doritospacecatoldaccount1557]

Evelyn Mason wich planet goes first? I would think earth is the second planet? If not then earth would either *burn* or *freeze*

[@MaruonYoutube]

that bug just gave us from the tital effect...*A hot Jupiter*

[@knowingfps]

jupiter finally can be what he wanted to be, a star

[@garrettamerson99]

ANTON!!! I WAS PLAYING UNIVERSE SANDBOX 2 AND I HAVE A PLANETS WITH LIGHTS!!!

[@garrettamerson99]

THEY ARE LIKE GLOWING DOTS!!!!

[@garrettamerson99]

HERE IS THE LINK TO THE PIC IN MY STEAM ACCOUNT!!!! steamcommunity.com/profiles/76561198206261723/screenshots/

[@garrettamerson99]

it is the latest pic

[@MrMoney-no8ry]

How did you do that?

[@betsythepretzel335]

Thanks for the name of the site

[@Ian07_]

in this video we will talk about

[@AlexEvett55]

Double upload?

[@voyagereternal11]

Harry Evett hey what's up guys it's scarce here

[@AlexEvett55]

what is a scarce

[@mediocre_skewber]

Bruh

[@michael120.]

.-.

[@cukik6325]

Probably last reply

[@TCBYEAHCUZ]

Could make a binary system of Saturn and Jupiter and then have the rest of the planets orbiting the common center of mass.

[@NXS1FY]

What would happen if Jupiter and Saturn swapped positions? Or Venus or Mercury were where Mars is now? How would that effect Earth or the orbits of the system? What if Pluto was Earth's moon?

[@kkamiyasatorukamiya8154]

This is interesting and amazing. Does your computer calculate their orbits instantly? Message from Japan. 20th/Oct/2019

[@elipark2038]

Jupiter and Saturn close together with the other planets at a distance would probably be more stable.

[@evinliang9814]

You can create a stable system by putting Saturn too close to Jupiter and wait until Saturn gets destroyed by Roche Limit

[@jmm1233]

tried it , found if put saturn and the other gas giants 6 AU away from jupiter it stays stable

[@maxpheby7287]

Needed the Sun to make it stable maybe?

[@dialgadialga3357]

What is the app you use to do this?

[@kvkman555]

I'm pretty sure tidal forces induce heat in all bodies involved, but I'm not certain. If true, could one assume the smaller body would get hotter than the larger?

[@kennithbrown4036]

What app you use

[@alaskagyal]

Kennith Brown Universe Sandbox 2

[@ginetteireland]

what app or website do you use for these videos???

[@shaygray6226]

Do a Jupiter system. The solar system will be full of jupiters

[@movedchannels965]

Every inner planet being kick out by Earth

[@Sagitarria]

Why do you put them so close- wouldn't a more realistic distance be much much much further from jupiter?

[@jeremyalmquist27]

Would'nt you need a "sun" to stabilize Jupiter like our own Solar System? I believe that would greatly effect the success of this experiment.

[@craig291086]

Can you create a solar system where all the planets orbit pluto, with the sun taking pluto's old spot.

[@thorium9190]

Maybe put Jupiter and Saturn very close as binaries then put the terrestrial planets in orbit and far beyond put the ice giants in binary around the jupiter

[@wedmunds]

Those are superior epitrochoids.

[@AdrianSchray]

# Branchistochrone/Cycloid

[@wedmunds]

Cycloid is exclusively when the radius of trace is equal to the radius of rotation. You're thinking of a trochoid.

[@mig-stallion1359]

Adrian, Janik Schray . Thank you

[@justgetdanked3589]

Then the sun would be lonely. And me too. ;(

[@luisvelez1952]

If Jupiter wants to have bigger moons it must be way more massive and it is today

[@sabrinanascimento5248]

Would it work? With the gravitational pull? Would it pull them all in?

[@MrChaoElite]

Could you try this again while having the jupiter system orbit our sun?

[@wetbadger2174]

I believe the mathematical name of the shape is 'whirlygig'

[@ericshute3975]

Could you have made a more stable system by putting Uranus and Neptune near each other and putting Saturn the same distance away on the other side of Jupiter? Would the two masses of Uranus and Neptune balance out the mass of Saturn?

[@luv4chaewon]

Oooo i will try that

[@NIsForNick67]

10:42 and then we have earth, venus, umm (was expecting mars) mercury, and of course A FRAGMENT!

[@BaconhairChadYt]

Oooooooooooooooooooo cool Jupiter's big so earth will collide two Jupiter

[@arandomelie8578]

Who else screams WHAT DA MAAAAAAAAATH until the song is over or is it just me.

[@Steven-td1wz]

hey Anton try to combine all the dwarf planets and there moons to see if it's big enough to be a planet

[@AgentTasmania]

Size is irrelevant to the difference between Dwarf and Major planet.

[@MedK001]

AgentTasmania It kinda is, since to clean your orbit you need high gravity, and it's kinda hard when you have a small planet.

[@lucasxxl4692]

No it isn't. If you have a planet with a mass a lot bigger then the radius you'll have a very high gravity

[@christmassnow3465]

Can you place a smaller moon around another moon?

[@klausgartenstiel4586]

pluto has the last laugh.

[@RoryRose_]

You should try to make Galiphray (however you spell it, sorry, I'm not into Doctor Who) from Doctor Who, (planet the Doctor is from).

[@dannyarmstrong2013]

Dazzle with brilliance, don't baffle with bullshit...

[@dododimitrov9657]

Is Saturn the reason why Jupiter didn't move closer to the Sun? It kind of kept is out in its orbit saving Mars Earth Venus and Mercury.

[@thorium9190]

Place Jupiter and Saturn very close but beyond the Roche limit to make a more stable binary

[@RebelJew777]

This wouldn't work in real life, in a game maybe yes, but in real life no. The planets would either be destroyed or tossed out. This is for many reasons. But do you think a gas giant could ever become a star, like a brown dwarf or something?

[@ladyren1575]

No one gets their hands on Saturn's Dixie boy.

[@dinogrcic4177]

if you think about it all of the planets are the moons of our sun

[@toesdoeswhoknows704]

Dino Grčić No, because, our sun is a star, not a planet.

[@apollyon2365]

I know that it exist a gas giant who has a earth like moon but it has an orbit that makes writers very cold and Summers very hot

[@bgrowsmars3918]

tidal forces would work both ways heating Jupiter the most I would think