What If Sidious Fought Qui Gon & Obi Wan on Naboo with Maul

[@TheWarmachine375]

If Sidious got involved, then Qui-Gon Jinn and Obi-Wan Kenobi would experience how Maul and Savage felt when they try to fight him.

[@larahblox1414]

Worse… None of them will survive😂

[@RosieBreakwell]

But it would be over in less than 60 secs

[@toddkurzbard]

"...Rival Sith Lord Jar-Jar Binks." You, Sir, just earned your upvote.

[@SuperDuper-CoolGuy]

So unrealistic though Jar Jar would never die

[@sillybob9689]

Impossible, Darth Jar Jar is too wise to die like that. He would've been right behind Sidious, spanking him for daring to make attempt on his life in cowardly manner. Darth Jar Jar is immortal yo.

[@Trailbreaker3966]

Never expected a light side ended to any of these stories to happen after the deaths of Qui gon Obi wan R2-D2 Padme Anakin (It’s easy to assume Padme was killed after being impeached, and R2-D2 if not killed after the Naboo capture remained with Anakin and was killed with him)

[@Ice_theurgist]

So, in this timeline, Asajj was not taken in by Dooku, which means she probably died like her Jedi instructor before Dooku stepped in. Without Asajj involvement, that means Savage Opress nor the other brother never learned of Maul, and he never became a Sith Acolyte. Without Savage's presence in the Clone Wars, three things occurred: 1) Dutchess Satine never died and Mandalore never collapsed 2) Without him and Asajj involvement, Dathomir never faced Genocide, meaning Talzin is still out and about 3) no unification of any sort regarding any of the crime lords

[@KingCodd]

these are the complications of changing one thing many people who write these overlook

[@KingCodd]

but also maul would never need to be found and would probably be like 10x more powerful cus no way he’s losing his legs with sidious here

[@ballisticautistic5398]

What if Sidious killed Maul on Mandalore, took Savage Opress prisoner, and made him the Grand Inquisitor?

[@soularprimestudios5930]

Well Sideous needed one Maul to lure out Talzin which worked. Unless he can use Savage perhaps to lure her....Mabye...

[@JLoC.2479]

What if Cal kestis and Merrin were taught by Quinlan Vos & Asajj Ventress? Two nightsisters and two Jedi w psycometry learning how to mix Jedi and nightsister magiks

[@IsaiahWayne2104]

A dying Obi-Wan to Qui-Gon: Master. I'm not like you. I never was...

[@predadorchannels596]

Where is that quote from?

[@predadorchannels596]

?

[@alexander.tahtadjian]

This was amazing. I’ve been a fan of your videos for a while and it’s always fun to see your interesting SW what if’s. It was also fun to see Sidious fighting Qui-Gon and Obi-Wan on Naboo with Maul getting shown some love. This is definitely an interesting scenario and it should definitely get shown some more love. Plus I think we can all agree that this is probably one of the most interesting/unique scenarios in SW…but it’s a welcome one. Also if Sidious did join Maul in fighting Qui-Gon and Obi-Wan…then it would definitely be an interesting opportunity to show another side of his character and make it even more interesting. It was also nice to see Sidious show his strength getting shown some love, since he usually never gets the chance to do crazy stunts like this (at least no more than usual) like this that much and it was a nice change of pace to see him take the initiative and definitely made us all impressed. Plus it was nice to see the Dark Lord of the Sith get that opportunity to have a larger role in help shaping and making a major impact in the galaxy…afterall it was nice to see him have a solid plan, afterall this was probably the smartest course of action they could take, so it was nice to see him come up with this plan to shift the power balance of the galaxy, since he knows that there’s still opportunity and strength in the galaxy. Also it’s always nice to see just how determined Sidious truly is…also this was definitely something Sidious would do. Also I think that Sidious is on of the best characters of SW lore so it was nice that you were showing this amazing manipulative character the love and respect he deserves. Plus it was nice to see this unique Sith Lord show just how power and cunning he is in one fantastic story. Also I’ll love any story that involves Sidious having a “fine…I’ll do it myself” moment…those are always so much fun. Great job as always and I can’t wait to see what you do next. I do have a few ideas for some possible what if’s: 1) What if Rey was a Mandalorian…essentially what if Din Djarin found Rey and took her in as a Foundling. 2) What if Ezra was a Mandalorian…something like how both his parents were Mandalorians who left Mandalore and went to start their own lives (you could still keep most of Ezra’s backstory) and potentially make Ezra and Sabine a couple (since Disney won’t, we have too…#ezrabine4ever. 3) What if Jango Fett and/or Boba Fett Joined the Republic…I think something interesting could happen with this. 4) What if Rey, Finn and Poe went back in time to the Clone Wars…this would make the World Between Worlds even more of an important focal point and I could also see them get along well with Anakin, Ashoka, Rex and the rest of the 501st (it would be fun to see Rey, Finn and Poe join the 501st) I hope these are some amazing ideas for some potential What if’s

[@texasrick7327]

Great story! You never miss with these 😊

[@redhighlander3062]

"What if the CIS reserve fleet was used during operation Cinder?" This way Palpatine can make it look like when the Rebels "defeated" the empire, making them retreat into the unknown regions, it left the people defenseless without their emperor. Ruining the trust of the rebellion and turning the people against them. He can come back to "liberate" his people

[@arizona-hunter6684]

That makes a lot of sense and does make me curious why Palps didn’t do that.

[@Clarence23rd]

This is a Amazing suggestion

[@Ty_Colis]

What an amazing story man! In the beggining I was like “well there goes everyone lmao” also the final fight had so much diversity

[@vieuxreveur617]

What if Schmi was a retired sith lord , secretly survive and saved Anakin during the Order 66

[@SvenJensen-d5i]

What if Dexter Jetster was secretly a super powerful balanced force user like Bendu

[@josephprendergast771]

What if Jaro Tapal survived Order 66? What if Ahsoka Tano trained Gungi in SW Rebels or after returning as a knight in the Season 5 finale? What if Cal Kestis met Gungi in the Shadowlands during Jedi Fallen Order?

[@leiratno820]

Nah, the Chosen One being defeated by a sith in circumstances like that is a pure bullsh*t.

[@kroskerkronger5402]

no it isnt. anakin had a gigantic potential but he wasnt able to realise it. maul was much older and able to embrace his power much better. people thinking "the chosen one" is invincible are just stupid

[@Eliazos]

Yet another excellent Star Wars What If. I have a potential idea that could be hard but I think you could do it: What if instead of Anakin Skywalker being groomed by Palpatine, what if it was Obi-Wan being groomed.

[@SunStreaker-wc]

Yaddle losing is a major stretch she has lived WAY longer than maul so she is wayyyy more experienced

[@noahsibahi-jackson8757]

That doesn’t mean her potential is the same magnitude as Maul’s nor does it mean that she would have continued to improve past a certain period within her lifetime as a Jedi

[@frostnova8300]

8:57 Did you really just slip Darth Jar Jar into it? 👀

[@itstaylor2137]

this was really good, maybe a part 2 showcasing the Yuuzhan Vong and how the empire and Jedi react

[@claudiostudios9002]

What if Ezra saved and brought into canon Galen Marek (Starkiller) in the world between worlds?

[@RayAkuma]

Goodbye There, General Kenobi.

[@I-amthe-new-hokn-ucks]

NEW MEME WAHT IF: WAHT IF OBI WAN AND GENERAL GRIEVOUS FELL IN LOVE 1!11!!11

[@Megabreath74]

Refreshing to hear a story without Anakin or Obi-wan being the focus! FYI Pente - your list of Patreons has the word "Text" before "Benjamin Wells".

[@AvidloreReader57]

Never a fan of Obi Wan or Qui Con dying, but an interesting turn of events, none the less. What if Obi Wan and Luminara fell in love? What if Obi Wan was elected Grandmaster of the order or Supreme Chancellor? What if Ahsoka and Lux had a daughter during the Dark Times, who would join the Phoenix Cell/Ghost Crew? What if Count Dooku was Obi Wan's father? What if Barriss freed Luminara from the Spire? What if Ventress found Merrin after the Massacre? What if Ahsoka met her parents during the Kadavo arc? What if Ahsoka found Ezra after his parents were taken?

[@TenkoBerry]

A Random Thought of a What if? : Palpatine had a Twin Brother Sidious one of light and one of Dark a Force diad but Palpatine would hide his force powers not being taken by the Jedi

[@TenkoBerry]

Just a Random thought I had randomly due to being reminded of old book

[@Reid-x5f]

I like the idea sounds interesting I think a easier way to say it would be what if palpating and sidious were different people

[@TenkoBerry]

@ Yeah quite True though I’ve seen people take that way in many directions like Jekyll and Hide style sometimes IOoOI👌

[@Reid-x5f]

@ I found one that was done by Star Wars kingdom that is really good

[@TenkoBerry]

@Reid-x5f yeah quite interesting 👌

[@julesstephenson8935]

I have an idea for an interesting video. What if Quinlan joined Obi-Wan and Qui Gon on Naboo for the fight?

[@y.n.tryone4683]

18:06 you are fckn trippin , maul would best dooku , espicllyy at this stage where he’s reached his potential not even close . Also maul is no acolyte and he would dust kenobi

[@Kidapawan_45]

This is a Correct Alternate Story of Star Wars in Episode 1 Darth Sidious Should Help Darth Maul fighting The Two Jedi in Naboo Against Qui Qui-Gon Jinn and Obi Wan Kenobi to Defend the Trade Federation and Captured Padme Amidala Because Darth Maul is Lack of Fighting Skills and Fighting Techniques as a Sith to Fight A Two Jedi in Episode 2 Master Yaddle will trained Anakin Skywalker and Help to Free Shmi Skywalker in Tatooine the mother of Anakin Skywalker and The Sith will Defeated The Jedi Because Darth Maul will killed Master Yaddle and Anakin Skywalker The Clone War will be Horrible in Episode 3 After The Death of Count Dooku and The Jedi will Discover that Chancellor Palpatine is a Sith Lord Even Order 66 is Actived The Jedi will Survived .

[@RomanVasquez-lf4tb]

Feel like this leaves a perfect chance for the rise of Darth krayt in a part 2 and invasion of the Vong

[@isaiahjackson803]

Holy mismatch

[@TenkoBerry]

a What If? I Thought Would Be Funny What if Samuel L Jackson Got Transported into Star Wars as Basically a Older Version of Windu haha That is Brought Before The Jedi Council in ROTS Where They Interrogate him as a Clone but at first he just thinks there some kind of Actors Surprising him and all with there Cool Cosplays at first and talking about the movies Before Everything is Revealed as Real and Him Trying to Learn Basic Force Abilities with Windu as his Teacher. another version Samuel L Jackson is Windu's Father and Windu Was Abducted By Accident By Purrgils who Flew Outside Earth's Space Hotel when They We Having Some Father son Bonding Time Flying in Space But i Took So Long Before The Purrgils Came Back Before He Was Able to Track His Son Down Mace Windu and Samuel L Jackson is Brought Before The Council without Windu Then Brought Him In To Reveal his Father and Then His Father Goes Wondering around Coruscant Underbelly with His Son as a Guard Getting a Burger and telling Stories then Sidious Finds Out About Windu Father and Tries to Use Him to Turn Windu to The Dark Side in the Empty Senate Chambers and is Like Kill This MF Son! Getting Injured Saying That.

[@Python085]

How BLEAK!

[@Exaris79]

Just realized that there's nomadic Jedi that was a part time member of the last iteration of the Jedi Order. A good example is Master Fay. I'm assuming that there are long lived Jedi that are hermits too who had gone into isolation trying to recover from their dip into the dark side like Yoda hiding too. So while the majority of the current Jedi Order were wiped out, there's got to be thousands more that's not part of the Republic. When Vader wiped out the Jedi, it was from the Old Republic Jedi Temple's database. There would be more that's not been trained in the current Jedi Order and just not actually hiding from the empire but more of just not living in the galactic civilization as they could be in some backwater planet with not much hyperspace travel to it. There's a multiple tribe of force sensitive in Ossus that survived the supernova and had been living there. So there's got to be one of them that had access to the holocrons that was left behind in the massive ruins on the planet.

[@ballisticautistic5398]

What if Savage Opress stayed loyal to Dooku, killed Ventress, and remained Dooku’s sith apprentice?

[@TamraH-i5x]

I feel bad that their about to die tho rip in the chat

[@Blue-Blazes]

Can I ask everone a question. Can Jedi or Sith not just sense eachother through the force. But identifying eachother through the force with never lnowing anything about eachother.

[@codename618]

Not gonna lie, with the way the story was going, I was hoping the Sith would win for once. RIP.

[@justingrillon]

What if Obi-Wan and Satine's marriage was a treaty between the mandalorians and the jedi?

[@y.n.tryone4683]

29:03 huh why have u nerfed maul so much , u do know in TPM he could beat those masters , yaddle was more powerful than them 😂

[@TheCrayon0034]

What if Palpatine appointed a successor(Thrawn perhaps) before the battle of Endor?

[@corleyroberson4575]

Before starting video reaction: "Things are not looking good for our heroes" No seriously I don't care how much teen angst Obi Wan gains after P Sidi double penetrates Qui Gon, he is not passing go and he is not collecting 200 Credits.

[@Ollyatlas]

What if dooku and the seperatists rose up In the old republic era (post great war and dooku is a dark or grey jedi pissed over the republic and jedis corruption and failures during and post the great war)

[@johnpittsii7524]

What if Anakin was trained by Bastillia Shan. Also what if Anakin was sent to kayshaxx instead of Yoda. Also what if Anakin trained Sabine wren. Also what if Anakin fell in love with mon montha

[@TamraH-i5x]

First comment. Love the contact brother.

[@MiyamotoMusashi456]

What if Luke died when he jumped off instead of joining his father which would cause a spark and the redemption in Vader to destroy the empire and himself with it

[@kevinhuber3886]

Wicked!

[@kevns2148]

Might just be the darkest one yet. An we've delved into some darkness on this channel.

[@Allmightyimortal]

What if pong krell didn't betray the clones and the order on umbara and stayed in the light?

[@blaisefontenot798]

8:57-9:00 Darth Jar Jar confirmed.

[@JST138]

What if full potential Darth Plagueis had to fight Batman with prep time?

[@VictorBodholt-y8z]

RIVAL SITH LORD JAR JAR BINKS??

[@derrickmabry5803]

Awww the sith died welp at least they made it that far

[@fduranthesee]

what if Rey was Padme's sister?

[@CJSanta]

I know rival sith lord jar jar was a joke, but please. Do a what if Jar Jar Binks was Darth Plagueis's secret second apprentice. 🙏

[@Tmhjr_Baskar]

If Gunray confirmed to Sidious that the boy and his fighter were captured, how can Yaddle train Anakin?

[@xenencross1717]

What If The Black Arms from Shadow the Hedgehog were in Star Wars and made their move during the Clone Wars as a Third-party?

[@TenkoBerry]

This be pretty Sick I^o^I👍

[@The-Gaming-Shark-i7k]

What if Palpatine was telling the truth to Anakin and was secretly a grey Jedi while the council were slowly being corrupted by the dark side basically what if the roles were reversed? Palpatine is good and the Jedi are evil

[@TomHorn-r2k]

Wait…How could Anakin be trained if he was captured…did I miss something?

[@Josiah-o2h]

They made sidious look so young like around padmè,s age but deep down you know that's not the case and he's much older

[@OrangedinoTrexBundle]

Crossover idea what if Ahsoka,obi wan and anakin Skywalker Joined team Avatar?

[@derg470]

Yaddle and Anakin killed off in one go, as a side note no less. 0/10

[@JLoC.2479]

Maul doesn't use a "pyke" 2 kinds of pykes hinged double bladed saberstaff w short gold blades or a lightsaber blade atop a pole like shadow guards from force Unleashed, Maul has a crimson double bladed saberstaff

[@Finance_Guy02]

No way Maul could touch Anakin, he is the choosen one.

[@christopherclark8035]

What if master tapal survived order 66 with his apprentice

[@christopherclark8035]

Pls

[@andrewalsup9930]

What if Padme was secretly a gray Jedi?

[@marcusappelberg369]

A good one!

[@corsargaming5196]

what if darth vader secreatly started his own rebel cell

[@theomnipotent3574]

What if anakin gained the powers of sandman

[@shadowfast541]

What if ahsoka was the one who betrays the clones on umbara?

[@nabarisealey7366]

If luke became darth vader after killing vader on cloud city

[@halefamily7553]

Darth maul had a staff hilt not a pike

[@hendrickrolled]

What if Ahsoka was captured by General Grievous instead of facing the Jed Trial

[@jaxonworldwrestlingfederat8031]

Once again maul loses to plot armor😂

[@ltmad1284]

It's s Saber Staff not a pike

[@edrgil]

hi I posted this suggestion in the last video but i think it was lost in the comments : , i have an idea i have been trying to work out for a while now and i would like to know what you think of it. what if bariss framed Anakin for the bombing. here's how it could be played out: first bariss's motive for pinning it on Anakin: it would be easier for the blame to go to Anakin because he is known for acting rash second how would the jedi act: two things would happen 1. the jedi would have an easier time believing that Anakin would act that way and 2. they would be more resistant on letting go of the chosen one. third how the senet and the public would act: i feel Tarkin would be himself the public would be split and maybe in temporary turmoil due to the fact that it is their hero being accused Palpatine would see this as a great opportunity to turn Anakin (i will get to how shortly) Ashoka would try to help her master but i doubt would go as far as Anakin did in the show. forth how would the trial go part 1 (option 1): i feel things would start off well for Anakin being the war hero but at some point Tarkin will bring up the LONG list of war crimes he has done lending credence to him committing this act. but like the show have Ashoka bring Bariss in. even though Anakin is not guilty for the bombing he is now on trial for the war crimes that were brought to light. how would the trial go part1 (option 2): like option 1 you would tarkin bring out the list of war crimes, but make it to NO ONE helps him, making him feel even more abandoned. how would the trial go part 2: for either option i think Palpatine would see this as the PERFECT spot to gain Anakin's trust and help turn him to the dark side. tarkin would most likely want the death penalty but Palpatine (not wanting to lose his prized student) would veto that option or better yet use his influence to throw out the trial under the reason of "he did it for the republic, to keep all of you safe." this would in turn make Anakin trust Palpatine and hate the jedi for seemingly abandoning him. what would happen after the trial: i doubt Anakin would go back to the jedi, his trust in them would be non existent. he would most likely go with Padme for a while. after the public talk about the event had settled down i believe Palpatine would ask Anakin to come back to the 501st. he could have the separatist hit back very hard during his absence and play it off like they need him at the helm if they are going to win. this would play into his ego and give him a chance to be back with his men. plus it would mean that he didn't have to play by the jedi code book because he was now acting as palatines main general. while seeing Anakin back would get mixed reactions i think once Anakin starts winning battles that Palpatine Definitely didn't rig, public opinion would sway heavily in his favor and against the senators and jedi who cast him out (because Palpatine was the one who brought him back and stood up for him during the trial he wouldn't be under public fire). i feel at points during the war Obi wan, Ahsoka, or some of the high council will try to bring Anakin back or the council will be it self and talk down to Anakin (I'm looking at you Windu) now that he wasn't following the jedi code in the war. with Anakin ego at an all time hi, him being happy with his men and his trust in the jedi 100% gone he wouldn't go back to the jedi. to get Anakin to want to get rid of the jedi once and for all Palpatine would need to find a way to make Anakin HATE them not just distrust them. to me the most likely thing he would do is the same thing he did the general grievous. he would have the ship has a critical failure killing all of his men (making sure Anakin was alright) and framing it as the jedi did it. he could play this out that the jedi became jealous of him or that they though he was giving the jedi a bad name by how he was going about the war. Anakin would believe Palpatine here because why would the person who saved him and gave him a happy life lie. with what all that has happened i think the public would instantly turn on the jedi and maybe even Padme might start to believe the jedi have it out for Anakin. with Anakin fully despising the jedi and the full public support, i feel Palpatine would pull the trigger and ask Anakin to get rid of the jedi due to treason (that treason being sabotaging Anakin's ship). once the jedi are gone Palpatine could have Anakin be the grand admiral of the imperial fleet, while slowly integrating him as an apprentice. the story has a dark side ending with Palpatine as the emperor and Anakin as the grand admiral, a father to his family, and as a apprentice to Palpatine. to be honest that ending doesn't sound like a dark ending for Anakin but i guess it counts as a dark ending because the dark side won please let me know what you think of my idea and if you have anything that you think would make it better (i would prefer a dark side ending if all possible) thank you

[@Reid-x5f]

What if during tales of the empire Vader killed barris in anger for framing Ashoka

[@sidious187]

20:07 How do you exponentially double profits

[@DawsonRobinson-bw6eb]

What if Luke skywalker was sent to go live with Pademe family

[@brenersilva7361]

What if obiwan killed Anakin on mustafar and after joined sidious

[@beaumcnally6358]

What if darth vitiate return that the beginning of the clone wars

[@shawnmoun9849]

Rip obi wan and qui qon

[@andrewflores3327]

What if anakin was trained the same way as star killer?

[@Drax_DBZ]

Why didn't Yaddle use her signature ability Morichro on Darth Maul? They would have easily won if she did that... I'm a huge fan of your stories, but it makes the video so much worse when you do something that isn't realistic at all.

[@Templewindle9741]

What if the covenant from halo was in the Star Wars universe?

[@andersonblock1211]

They’d be cooked

[@jasonmcguire358]

nice @ fresh

[@seanwilliams823]

I refuse to believe that Jar Jar Binks is a Sith Lord. I firmly believe that Jat Jar Binks was a mind controlled Sith Puppet.

[@PloKoon-f7b]

Did Plo Koon survive

[@28467Vanus]

What if Anakin Skywalker and Ahsoka Tano were a force dyad? What if Illum bestowed a naturally red kyber crystal on Anakin? How would the Jedi react? What if Shaak Ti found Anakin Skywalker on Tatooine and trained him? What if Shaak Ti was trained by Mace Windu? Just a few what-if ideas...

[@aratakasuga4095]

Qui-gon no diffs Palpatine.

[@marikam2998]

1. What If Avar Kriss Trained Natabre? 2. What If Avar Kriss Trained Zala? 3. What If Rey Was Reincarnation Of Abeloth? 4. What If Shimi Skywalker Was Reincarnation Of Abeloth? 5. What If Yoda Was Reincarnation Of The Father From The Mortis?

[@Perrolol88]

Attempt 3 What will happen if anakin finds emerl (from sonic battle) instead of C3PO?

[@saltyjosh]

Alot of stretching in this one buddy. Not a fan. This one sukt

[@y.n.tryone4683]

22:12 disgrace to George Lucas legacy

[@y.n.tryone4683]

U need to work and study on ur lore

[@mistermerchant7870]

What if Boba Fett forgave Mace Windu for killing his father from the first battle of geonosis?

[@ballisticautistic5398]

What if Darth Jar Jar trained Anakin Skywalker?

[@cecilarthurton3795]

what if anakin skywalker was born female

[@y.n.tryone4683]

Wtf don’t use bullshit Disney acolyte , he’s more of a sith than dooku 😂

[@rastagaming2116]

The term ‘Acolyte’ has been around long before the Disney show you total spoon. Really showing you’ve no idea at all here.

[@theptrit9758]

2nd comment