What If the Republic Used Stormtroopers During the Clone Wars

[@gabidz-u2s]

What if the rescue party sent to the separatist Jedi prison ended up crashing and found during the Imperial times about 20 years later? Specifically, imagine if during the mission to rescue a Jedi holding vital hyperspace lane codes, the shuttle transporting Obi-Wan, Anakin, Ahsoka, and the 501st troopers who are in carbonite crashed , resulting in R2-D2 being destroyed. Later they were unexpectedly discovered and saved by rebels.

[@Alex-yy5wo]

I like this.

[@DrTrip-pm2wx]

Now thats podracing

[@ElliotRobson-r8m]

Good just make r2 survive

[@gabidz-u2s]

@@ElliotRobson-r8m yeah but if he survived he could contact for help and that would not work. i think they should be found during the time of the empire like about 10 to 20bby

[@Thatonedoorguy]

Yes

[@ovni2295]

I like that the stormtroopers were able to resist Order 66. It makes sense to me - They have something the Clones didn't have, and that's a sense of self forged over decades. The Clones were tough, but they were Clones, raised as Clones, and they were so young their sense of self wasn't fully developed.

[@themysteriousspeeddemon]

I Honestly thought the inhibitor chips were some sort of hypnotizing devices that fully controlled the clones, I guess I didn't take to account the chips were only meant to enhance their obedience.

[@TheLuconic]

Remember Rex? You can tell he developed just enough to give Ahsoka hints, just before turning zombie.

[@yumallah]

It's really ironic that the clones in cacnon seem to be so much more fleshed out and 'human' than the stormtroopers, simply by virtue of them being the 'good guys' at one point and having an entire show dedicated to them. If the stormtroopers were given their own show from a pro-Empire or at least neutral perspective, I guarantee you that fans would love them the same way they love clones. Because most stormtroopers are recruits who have real names, families, and histories before joining the Empire, there would be so much potential to be explored, the motivations behind becoming a stormtrooper and all that. We already got a glimpse of that in the Bad Batch when Crosshair was given his own special battalion made up of regular human recruits. That one guy said: "the Empire has given me a roof over my head and a paycheck, what more do I need?", I'm paraphrasing a bit but the meaning is the same. If the stormtroopers were fleshed out like that they would be absolute fan favorites, even more so than the clones probably.

[@eidoneverchoosen1171]

@@yumallah They should also question why are they required to kill and hurt innocent people or why a ruling grand more is allowed to abuse his authority.

[@valjamin8456]

@@TheLuconic Rex was strong enough to fight the chip's control just long enough for Ahsoka to get out of the direct line of fire, but 22+ years of experience is still worth more than 12 in terms of developing a strong sense of self, regardless of the quality of those years regarding this. That's why most TK troopers were able to overwhelm and silence the control chip's influence during each one's battle in the center of the mind, while most clones were easily bent to it's will. Rex just held out the longest, and so Ahsoka escaped the initial attack, and eventually survived the entire Order 66 in canon. The more life experience you have, the stronger your sense of self, and the more capable you are of resisting not just control chips, but also force techniques like Jedi mind tricks!

[@themysteriousspeeddemon]

So basically If there was republic troopers, Palpatine's plan would be flushed down the toilet, just like his Master.

[@yuyaplays9311]

I can imagine some people would be talking to their family members on the front line asking questions about videos they had seen on the net. And then their family members who were serving in the war getting mad at them for believing that separatist propaganda. And telling them stories about how their Jedi generals were right there on the front lines with them and saving lives more often than not.

[@cr90captain89]

@@yuyaplays9311 except the problem is Jedi were terrible military leaders that got a lot of their soldiers & military forces killed. Windu & the Jedi were hated because they wasted lives, the clone commandos who are specialized in spec ops/ infiltration & army as a whole were used as frontline infantry against a numerically superior force in open fields with no cover & poor sightlines when a dust storm was kicked up on geonosis. the Jedi were saving lives, from the mess the jedi made in the first place. generals like sky walker, kenobi, secura & plo koon are the exception not the norm. the norm was how pong krel treated the 501rst & other clone units on umbara. disposable, emotionless, obedient cannon fodder/ meat shields to throw at the enemy in wave style attacks. the Jedi had become alienated to the republic for years before the clone wars, with their reputation, respect, & tolerance for their existence being completely destroyed by an attempted assassination on a democratically elected official. order 66 was soo easy to pull off because: 1. the army hated them (overwhelming numbers of unnecessary casualties) 2. the navy hated them (jedi favoring tactics that would resolve in the loss of naval vessels or would prolong the conflict, meaning the admiralty at large despised them) 3. the public hated them (it was common knowledge a jedi that started the separatist movement, & it was the Jedi order that started the clone wars with their invasion of geonosis, a war of galaxy wide destruction that left hundreds of unknowable worlds in ruin) 4. the Jedi's attempt on the chancellor's life was the straw that broke the camels back, shifting public sentiment of we'll leave them alone to COWABUNGA IT IS.

[@Commander_Viper]

I mean he still had trillions of cheap droids

[@tianoc-g4811]

"Begun, The Droid Wars have!" History repeats itself as the soldiers at the republic from across the galaxy unite with the jedi against the common threat; Just like what happened during the Mandalorian Wars, The Jedi Civil War, and the Sith Wars.

[@pauloj1983]

Palpatine: Execute Order 66. Slay the Jedi! TK Stormtrooper: instructions unclear, laying the Jedi. Finding Jedi General Aayla Secura.

[@joaovictordemelomazza3049]

The Jedi are fucked 😂

[@williamkraut5849]

@@joaovictordemelomazza3049 not fucked in the way Palps wanted though lmao

[@joaovictordemelomazza3049]

@@williamkraut5849 true 😂😂😂

[@hunterbg6651]

Exsecute order 69

[@DS_1065]

@@hunterbg6651 yes my lord

[@calebvaldecanas8867]

Man I wish the comments would actually talk about the video. He puts out some really great stuff and I go to the comments hoping to see people talk about it, only to be met with waves of requests and nothing about the story

[@Alex-yy5wo]

Man that’s so true

[@kinglukethe7th524]

That's because we live in a world of consumers. Creators are far more rare. These people have nothing to contribute. They just want more videos.

[@metal_pipe9764]

Personally I don't suggest ideas, because Stapy being a sith lord is not something he'd do, especially since he doesn't do crossovers

[@blindvision4703]

And those of us sitting on the edge of our seats, dreading what might happen looking for spoilers. Lol! I feel you in that way.

[@blindvision4703]

@@kinglukethe7th524 hate to admit it, because I’ve done that, or at least try to, and my earliest Star Wars fan fixed (at least the ones on my channel featuring myself. We’re absolutely cringe! But what you’re saying is true. At least two agree.

[@meancrank9039]

I really like the human element of this one. You can see how the clones were an integral part to the plan, even outside of order 66 - the separation between the people and the jedi, the uniformity of clones making them harder to connect with individually, and more. You really have a knack for the worldbuilding within the scenarios themselves.

[@brothers_of_nod]

“Wise my wrinkled butt! I knew I should have just gone with my gut on the clones.” -Palpatine in the afterlife to Plagueius.

[@eidoneverchoosen1171]

Lol!

[@blarg987665]

I liked how the stormtroopers were the good guys in this one. What if anakin focused on space battle rather than ground battle and became a legit admiral.

[@slatedragon9358]

This was probably my favorite what if you have done

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

I'm glad you enjoyed!!

[@brocktonbishop5874]

But now I want to see a video about “What if the Republic used the Clone Army and Stormtroopers during the Clone Wars?”.

[@novaterra973]

"What If the Bad Batch KILLED Palpatine Before Order 66" video has that. The TK troopers are used as expendable shields for more valuable clone troopers.

[@S3rp3nte]

What if both sides used clones?

[@WolfTrooperRex]

I mean- mass producing B1s and B2s would be considered cloning a bit

[@novaterra973]

@@S3rp3nte Depends. Do both sides use Kamino clones, or does one side is forced to use inferior Spaarti clones instead? In Legends, the CIS had its own clone army called Morgukai Shadow Army, but it was completed too late and didn't see many actions.

[@ColonelBragg]

That is basically what happened in the EU/legends the bulk of the Republics military was made up of volunteers while the clones made up the elite formations

[@demolition3612]

Very good, I like how the troops changed the jedi more than the clones did. It changes a lot of how the jedi handle the war.

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

I'm glad you enjoyed!

[@eidoneverchoosen1171]

I can see last stands of TK troopers iften out numbered taking on the droids while shouting the battle cry. "For the Republic!"

[@rafaelibarra6416]

Ah, a man of culture I see.

[@dianesinger9729]

I liked the idea of TK troopers over Clones, especially when it came to the chips and how they were able to overcome the orders. Liked Anakin's romance that didn't involve Padme. Love Opo Squeezing Palpatine to help end him.

[@Fordo007]

Palpatine failed to learn from Rome when armies are loyal to their generals.

[@eidoneverchoosen1171]

Indeed.

[@matthewbarabas3052]

...there wasnt a Rome in star wars.

[@austinestep8461]

@@matthewbarabas3052I mean there was just not in their galaxy

[@alexanderchristopher6237]

Palpatine forgot why countries turned away from relying solely to a professional class of warriors or professional mercenaries and instead chose the citizen army.

[@matthewbarabas3052]

@@alexanderchristopher6237 to be fair, the last time that happened had to have been in the far, far, distant past; well over 100,000 years ago.

[@LeviMartin-o2y]

What if PPSW and the Star Wars Galaxy do another collab.

[@FrejthKing]

what if Palpatine slept through the end of the clone war

[@nobbyfirefly57]

@@FrejthKingah shit I forgot my alarm! This would be great to suggest to The Broken Galaxy. They do comedy what ifs. They even did one where Palpatine got cancelled.

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

W

[@FinnishKrieger]

I don't know how to explain how good this makes me feel. Even though the clones weren't there it was such a touching story.

[@hmk5123]

I would imagine a Stormtrooper corp with a Clonetrooper corp would have boosted morale by a little, as the citizens would be proud to see the Republic take a step towards returning to its glory days where citizens took a direct role in defending their homes, instead of letting the Jedi and artificially bred clones do all the fighting for them.

[@nfinity1421]

Thank you for the story! It was a very fresh approach to the Order 66 failing premise, one that made sense given the differences of growing up with the chip and having it implanted later in life. Also I loved how you stressed the relationships between Jedi and Trooper and not just romantically, but how it brought back some of the "magic" of a Knight that I felt had been lost for many years, once more raising the Jedi into heroes to look up to and not just people with powers fighting beside. On another note, you had me with the inclusion of Oppo, thank you very, very much. Nice use of his tail, btw. I also loved how the "old timers" won the duel and how you stressed they had been dueling longing than Palpatine had been alive. Getting up there in years myself, its nice to sometimes see that its not always the young folk who win the day. This was a fine combination of both, the Jedi elders and the troopers, Jedi in the field and a young (brilliantly while pleasantly surprisingly added) Thrawn. It was a nice touch how Yularen was a balance as the elder to Skywalker, Thrawn and (sorry, I'm unfamiliar with with her) troop commander. The explanation at the end solved the one problem I kept having through the story and that was droid vs TK trooper numbers. I kept thinking the droids should have buried the troopers with plot armor and Sith manipulations only doing so much to compensate due to numbers, but yours explained that. Thank you again for another fine story. Be well!

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

I'm glad you enjoyed! That was such a fun element to add to the story, with the heightening of the Jedi imagery. Using TK troopers allowed for such a unique approach to the clone wars era! Also it was so fun using the oldies for the fight with Sidious. Oppo doesn't get enough love! Lol Anakin's fleet was so stacked with Yularen, Thrawn, & Idun. Be well, as well!

[@torik9300]

PPSW this was one of your best! I see the effort and thorough work you did in this story and it turned out wonderfully. Glad to see the Jedi and the Republic strengthen rather than wither from Palpatine's efforts to crown himself Emperor.

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

I'm glad you enjoyed!!

[@jasperlongwell6317]

I got a cute idea, what if Ahsoka Was Anakin Childhood friend inside jedi order

[@jonathansayah9506]

This was very good. To be honest, when you announced this, I kinda thought you meant they'd do "Project: Warmantle" a little early, and include stormtroopers with the clones they had before. You remember those episodes where the Republic was going to deregulate the bank in order to get more clones? I was thinking that someone like Tarkin, to everyone's surprise, would agree with Padme and her friends. They could keep the cloning program at its then current rate but then start recruiting more people who are not clones.

[@eidoneverchoosen1171]

That would give the Republic eventual Empire a head start on hiring troops for half the cost of the clones but with veteran training.

[@jonathansayah9506]

@@eidoneverchoosen1171 That’s why I thought this is where he was going with this. Obviously, most of the recruits would mostly be doing the easier, casualty minimal jobs and leave the dangerous and important shit (especially the ones that involve Jedi) to the clones.

[@erikakerblom2900]

Noice as always Pente! Day: 124: What if Talzin raised Maul? Day: 55: What if Darth Plagueis trained Maul?

[@metal_pipe9764]

What if maul trained maul?

[@austinestep8461]

@@metal_pipe9764Everyone trains Maul

[@JosephVargas-dj7ul]

What if Anakin trained maul

[@metal_pipe9764]

What if Luke trained Maul

[@austinestep8461]

@@JosephVargas-dj7ul he’d be a bit young to train Maul, Maul was 22 during the phantom menace when Anakin was 9. In order for Anakin to train Maul, Anakin would have to be a knight, he became a knight when he was I think 19. So earliest he could have taken Maul as an apprentice would be when Maul was 32. That’s much more then pushing it for the Jedi Order to accept anyone into there ranks, let alone a Sith. That being said I like the concept.

[@Bwillis2099]

What if the empire used upgraded battle droids alongside stormtroopers? What if Luke and Leia were a force dyad ? What if Leia was sent to live with Padme’s family on Naboo while Luke was sent to Tattooine to live with Owen and Beru? What if Anakin’s force ghost appeared to ahsoka and made her promise to help rebuild the Jedi order? What if padme gave birth to triplets at the end of revenge of the Sith? What if Luke Skywalker had a secret son in the sequel trilogy? What if the force reincarnated Anakin Skywalker during the sequel trilogy? What if Anakin Skywalker encountered a separate Jedi order that allowed attachments and familial/romantic relationships during the clone wars?

[@yesno8473]

My second attempt: I'm not sure if this would work, but I think it would could be interesting if you did a 'what if' between a character you've created from a 'what if episode' and a pre existing StarWars character in a new context. For example: What if Ahsoka had a sister who fell in love with her master, Anakin Skywalker? (referencing Odina here who was only a year younger than Anakin). Obviously this would change the context of the previous story you did about what if Ahsoka had a sister but it could just be a seperate thing. Anyways, love your videos and am wishing you well on making it to 200k subs!

[@Aahmpower]

This was definitely one of my favorite What If Episodes, I can see that this Grand Army-Jedi relationship would have led to a more positive Republic, since the interactions between your average militia men and Jedi Commander would keep the structure together and move the people to be more sympathetic to the cause Can't wait for more of these alternate GA vs CIS what ifs

[@nobbyfirefly57]

Imagine if the chips could wipe PTSD from war

[@Ol-T1864]

One of your best. Your content is getting better. I think you found new great angles.

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

I'm glad you're enjoying!

[@stevencisneros9306]

Great what-if fanfic, I love the idea of many people who sided the Republic & the Jedi Order, heck they even resisted order 66, cuz of their strong relationship with the Jedi, they fought alongside with, great stuff there!!! Also these are my what-if ideas: What if Rakghoul Plague was unleashed during the Clone Wars What if Asajj Ventress was a Jedi *What if Padme became a nexu* What if Republic made their droid army to fight the Separatists And much more!!

[@jiltedensign7479]

Another banger of a What If. I think the only detail I might have missed was how the inhibitor chips were implemented. Were they implanted in the brains of the stormtroopers, like they were with the clones? Or were they merely implanted in the armor of the units? Because, with the clones, the activation caused a sort of hypnotic effect on the clones, and yet, the stormtroopers (noted from Anakin and Yoda's commanders) quite easily brushed Order 66 off like it was nothing. Otherwise, I'm glad the outcome went as well as it did. And hey, major W for Yoda and Oppo. Keep up the great work, Pente!

[@austinestep8461]

I think they were still imo,anted in the brain. The difference is unlike the clones the stormtroopers have a lifetime of existing and being people that couldn’t be as easily overwritten as the clones with their shorter training on Kamino.

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

I'm glad you enjoyed! I def could've explained it better but, it was brain implants like the clones & similar to what Austine said, they had a lifetime without the chips which made them ineffective. More or less the difference between clones & TK troopers is the clones were bred with the chips & the TKs only had them for the duration of the war

[@jiltedensign7479]

@@PentePatrolStarWars Gotcha! Thanks for responding. I'm looking forward to more!

[@AIYFProductions]

Seeing that Stormtroopers are still my absolute favorite and they got this kind of justice done to them? Absolute perfection~!

[@percyjackson386]

Day twelve 2) what if Luke and Mara, post union comics, traved back to the clone wars. 3) what if The Pius Dea returned 4) what if ahsoka raised mara 5) what if the Republic Outland Regions Security Force formed the base of the republic army 6) what if Etain Tur-Mukan survived 7) what if Siri Tachi survived and her and Obi-Wan Kenobi fell in love 8) what if the yousong vong attacked during the clone wars 9) whist if Meetra Surik, Jedi Exile, trained anakian.

[@locoarticwolf2181]

Really love this scenario and how it ended up working out because these are people in the end who have lives and already developed personalities. Made it easier to empathize and relate. Not only that be it was closer to the older wars that the Republic fought. Overall great story!

[@LucioRodriguez-m2b]

What if Palpatine was unable to deactivate the droid army

[@dannylopez5976]

Would there even had been anyone left to lead the army?

[@gabenewell3955]

Super tactical droids could have gotten it done ​@@dannylopez5976

[@Aeronwen86753]

​@@dannylopez5976 considering that there where still many holdouts and generals yeah there would.

[@zfilms4858]

@@Aeronwen86753 *Palpatine at this moment:* kzbin.info/www/bejne/eZDUe4pog9CepsUsi=fRWgqnQtGgTogNi5&t=138

[@LeviMartin-o2y]

What if Yaddle was a Sith Lord. What if Tyvokka trained Anakin. What if Padme was a Jedi trained by Plo Koon or Yaddle. What if Yaddle was Grandmaster.

[@metal_pipe9764]

What if the sarlac pit was a sith lord?

[@S.R.S_Nuke]

What if Yaddle had wings

[@duelgundam]

Oh, hey. My idea got accepted. Or maybe one of the patreon members suggested the same idea? Small world.

[@johnpittsii7524]

What if Anakin was trained by Bastillia Shan or Pong Krell. Also what if Anakin was sent to kayshaxx instead of Yoda. Also what if Anakin looked after Bobba Fett after genosis. Also what if Anakin saved the nightsisters from dooku

[@mandaloretheangry9043]

wow a pro Stormtroopers what if, nice

[@kieronfoster940]

fantastic video my friend I love watching your what if Videos especially the Clone wars relate ones and i love hearing all the What if as it helps me relax and enjoy it and i can not wait to see what you do next I do hope we can see a what if Zombie video like with the geonosis zombie bugs witch some how effect the clone or some short of zombie out brake or even time travel video and i can not wait to see season 3 of Sith empire in the clone wars

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

I'm so glad you enjoy the stories!!

[@nathanwhite2689]

I've been looking for a what if about this for a long time "what if the republic conscripted soldiers instead of clones" no one made one until this video you made thank you.

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

[@christopherwyatt9754]

A surprise but a welcome one.

[@alexander.tahtadjian]

This was amazing. I’ve been a fan of your videos for a while and it’s always fun to see your interesting SW what if’s. It was also fun to see the Stormtroopers getting shown some love in a new way. This was an amazing video to watch on my birthday today. Great job as always and I can’t wait to see what you do next. I do have a few ideas for some possible what if’s: 1) What if Rey was a Mandalorian…essentially what if Din Djarin found Rey and took her in as a Foundling. 2) What if Ezra was a Mandalorian…something like how both his parents were Mandalorians who left Mandalore and went to start their own lives (you could still keep most of Ezra’s backstory) and potentially make Ezra and Sabine a couple (since Disney won’t, we have too…#ezrabine4ever. 3) What if Jango Fett and/or Boba Fett Joined the Republic…I think something interesting could happen with this. 4) What if Rey, Finn and Poe went back in time to the Clone Wars…this would make the World Between Worlds even more of an important focal point and I could also see them get along well with Anakin, Ashoka, Rex and the rest of the 501st (it would be fun to see Rey, Finn and Poe join the 501st) I hope these are some amazing ideas for some potential What if’s

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

Happy (belated?) Birthday! Hope it was a wonderful one! I'm also glad you enjoyed!! Also some dope ideas!

[@alexander.tahtadjian]

@@PentePatrolStarWars thank you very much. I’m glad you like some of my ideas for some potential what if’s.

[@i-Mukkz-i]

This man never misses

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

[@marcusisgod2592]

As we know darth vader was a natural engineer and could use technoguru or whatever so what if he used skill to create nanobots to repair his lungs and burns while also making limbs that could conduct the force to make lightning. This could relate to inquisitor baris as she used nanobots in the bomb and he may remember nanobots and their uses. He could could also conduct experiments diguised as torture to fool sidious, learning to heal wounds, make force sensitive droids/limbs and using nano bots to manipulate mididclorians to strip or enhance the force in individuals.

[@PhoenixSellen-jo2cm]

As a little kid the stormtroopers seemed really eerie to me, and actually scared me. It was the way their helmets were made, they never removed nor have seen their faces and barely even spoke. Their masks looked like there was nothing behind it, no mercy or morals

[@burningeagle1298]

What if the rebels found the star forge

[@nerino_chan]

The military aspects of this story are really accurate, i remember the last time you mentioned army numbers it was in the low millions, have you been playing any space games lately?

[@marcusisgod2592]

What if anakin was piloting before attack of the clones and sensed ventress fall to the darkside as her master died and took his ship to the planet to investigate. Perhaps starting a romance as they are very similar in their stories. Also what if ahsoka taught ben skywalker as she saw him as history repeating itself. What if anakin was a jedi watchmen or wayfinder. What if anakin went with kenobi to face maul and savage instead of adi gallia. What if anakin fell in love with luminara or your own version of aayla secura romance. What if oppo rancis trained anakin. What if anakin met and fell in love with ventress just before the clone wars just after her masters death. What if anakin became a jedi sentinel like a watchmen or one of those who find younglings. What if evan piel became a mentor or second master to anakin. Or anakin became a healer either before or after his mother death could be related to his friendship with offee or alternatively what if he was trained by tra sa who taught windu and actually did not forbid attachment as shown by her relationship with tholme , they could become like a pseudo parents to anakin and train him away from the temple in azati martial arts and from trasa the living force as she is a plant lady so imagine anakin controlling plant life.

[@Maiyosu23]

*What if the Clone War was Clone vs TK Troopers* (Galactic Empire enforced by Storm Droids)

[@Thurden_mixd]

24:23 slip up!!

[@Sorain1]

This demonstrates just how big a deal the clone army and it's mentality was in Palpatine's plan. Side note, it also touches on how unhealthy Anakin being surrounded by nothing but Jedi and Clones was for his understanding of the world. The break down of the isolation of the Jedi from the people, especially the GAR undermines everything Sidius was trying to do to get rid of them... but I am willing to bet the civilian population and former GAR population really clashed over their views of the Jedi, likely for decades to come after the war. I like the swift Republic reclamation of the Outer Rim here, with a huge push from citizens to resolve things the way they handled the CIS, the various warlords and criminals would have zero chance to keep their power openly. (But the wise ones will slink into the shadows and wait it out.)

[@The_Watchful_Scribe]

Ooooo I have an idea! As a fanfic writer myself I always wondered if a super Tactical droid say General Kalani became for a lack of a better word “self-aware” and just left the war all together I wonder how that would turn out?

[@roflchiefmcjoflchief1791]

I don't think Palpatine would have ever done this instead of clones, but I could see him increasing the war in scale and adding the TK corps as a supplementary force

[@kevintran5901]

What if Sifo-Dyas and Rohm Kota secretly revive the Republic Troopers from the Old Republic Era before the creation of the Clone Troopers and before the Clone Wars.

[@alexanderchristopher6237]

I don’t see how much difference there is between those Old Republic troopers and any non-Clone forces in the Republic and Empire. They’re the same thing with the troops being recruited from the general populace of the galaxy. Maybe better experienced to handle Force users since there used to be a whole lot more Sith they had to battle (but even that seems negligible).

[@sheevhernandez3869]

Man if Napoleon was in this what if, he would have been in love with the army. Damn I wish we do get a what if on Napoleon and then when that video comes out, this and that video on if Napoleon was born in star wars should be combined. The Republic or separatist would have a good general 👀

[@nathantinkler8250]

Thank you for using my idea I ask this question in the last video it not how I think it who plays out, but I like your story anyway

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

[@danielchavez919]

I was asked the same question about a year ago, the difference is that it didn't end on a happy note.

[@CullenRick]

What if the Bendu decided they'd had enough of the Bogan/Ashla nonsense, entered the war to bang Jedi and Sith heads together, got them talking and reformed the Je'Daii Order.

[@marcusisgod2592]

What if darth vader went to darthomir to learn. New suit or perhaps more unique powers. Resurrect talzin maybe. what if Vokara Che became a mentor to anakin as anakin was being treated for bullying and trauma from being a slave. What if anakin fell in love with luminara unduli, serra keto or bultar swan. What if anakin was taught by agen kolar or sasee tin or adi gallia.

[@CIS-m8s]

The fact that almost all other scenarios if palps made ONE mistake he would have been obiliaterd which to me simply amplifies just how masterfully he scammed the galaxy

[@oliversherman2414]

Doesn't matter how much you change the stormtroopers, they'll still never be as good as the clones

[@AleksKieca]

That’s true but it would be nice to see a version of The Clone Wars with them, most likely it would be remained The Separatist Revolution.

[@oliversherman2414]

@@AleksKieca yeah

[@saj2392]

@oliversherman2414 Of course. Just as no Clone will beat a Mandalorian. Those who live lives as warriors will always beat those who work as soldiers. For warriors, war is life. For soldiers, war is work.

[@oscar-xterminator7781]

@@saj2392 In single combat? Probably. Excluding the fact that war is literally a clones life, clone troopers would most likely perform a lot better as a squad than a mandalorian squad.

[@bwc-chvd]

@@saj2392501st clones were beating up mandalorians in one on one combat in season 7 what are you talking about

[@Maik_Privat]

What if Anakin and Obi Wans Venator was taken away by Purrgil after Ahsoka and Bo Landed?

[@peterpidrak9501]

I want to avoid spoilers. Point about chips made below. Keep in mind that the inhibitor chips would also probably have failed, because even the genetic deviations within the bad batch meant that only one of them worked, I believe. None of them worked 100% or immediately either. How much worse would it be with everyone in the army being genetically individual.

[@Trailbreaker3966]

Yoda and Tarken loving one another… Welp that was an unexpected twist 25:00 Also sounds like a relationship that didn’t last very long 30:18

[@Blaiseingfire]

Thrawn's appearence was a welcomed surprise.

[@b.goedgedrad7457]

Man I love you’re videos

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

I'm glad you enjoy!

[@worldwanderer91]

What if Jango and Boba Fett survived the First Battle of Geonosis and fought on the side of the Republic as one of the leaders of the GAR?

[@JoeSmith-os7zn]

A crossover idea. What if Earth from the Game Horizon Zero Dawn(pre Faro Plague) was discovered by the Star Wars galaxy. It would be interesting, maybe either during the clone wars, where Faro Automated Solutions would sell his Chariot Line Bots to both sides of the war, and how they might interest palpatine. Or. Maybe during the age of the empire, where they are sold to the rebellion. All they would need is one Horus to create an army of bots.

[@Roge_Tebnelok]

What if Mina Bonter survived the assassination attempt, maybe instead of Lux?

[@randallrona9618]

Why do I hear a Sabaton song? Strike at zero hour With overwhelming firepower They're fueled by the fear in their enemies eyes It's a shock troop infiltration A fast and violent escalation Out of the trenches the Stormtroopers rise!

[@Sonic57053]

I'd like to imagine how order 66 would be like with *STORMTROOPERS* . It would ABSOLUTELY fail 100% because of their aim! Imagine Ki-Adi Mundi & Aayla Secura, they begin to shoot only to MISS

[@WolfTrooperRex]

*order 66 gets executed* TK Trooper: *misses entirely Jedi: …seriously?!

[@JediMasterZim]

What if after Anakin killed all the Tuskens of that tribe, Anakin took the Barash Vow out of of shame and seeking repentance?

[@nobbyfirefly57]

What if Jango used a clone to fake his death?

[@rednovastrum2475]

considering the amount of clones that dual wield pistols that can be a thing

[@zshah3107]

What if Dave Filoni never Condradicted the Legends via the Clone Wars era!

[@colinmack93]

what if anakin was Chancellor

[@skepticalmagos_101]

Oh No.... 😂

[@Bencrackers]

Man U going up so fast it was like yesterday when you had 25k

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

[@KYRRUM]

What if Anakin was the Dark Lord of the Sith from the beginning?! Kind imagined that his mother participated in a ritual (satanic style but instead it's the sith) and that the little anakin is the new envelope of a sith, such as Darth Vititate, Bane or Plagueis. 😱😈💀

[@Melkor8249]

Or a reincarnation of nhiluius

[@KYRRUM]

Also Nihilus. 🤘

[@Melkor8249]

Thx

[@Trollge398]

And to make it more fun the jedi find anakin

[@Firefocus-fz2we]

This was a fun one 😃 Thank You.

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

I'm glad you enjoyed!!

[@ProcyonDei]

Reading the title, I thought that the Republic would mix regular citizens with the ranks of the clones: But this was amazing...

[@ZeroSeeker-mu2er]

what if the third systems (lead by Cody and kenobie, also includes 501 and plokoons legion) army was deployed to kill general grivus?

[@dakotalange2858]

Pente your were mentioned in *the prequel memes archives: order 66 edition* for the Oogway video!

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

Wooo, awesome!!

[@Kiron737]

Very well done.

[@sirwolfsalot01]

I feel like this video would be the same as ‘What if the Republic never disbanded its military?’

[@Komrad_Cybersyn]

10'45 : unorthodox tactics.... As in "war crimes" ?^^

[@karithomas5064]

I loved how the most Jedi like jedi of all the jedi (aka Yoda) was put with probably the most jedi hating captains of all the jedi hating captains (aka Tarkin ( is that how you his name??))!!!😂 Also can you please do one of my ideas I have suggested in the past? Btw this was a great video! Thank you! God Bless!!!

[@lamchakhimernestg8t-13]

Yoda and Tarkin leading together

[@sheridan1229]

I wish you make this a bit longer, i want to know more of the details

[@merafirewing6591]

*Wilhelm scream intensifies*

[@timrobinson513]

What if the jedi won the war much faster than Palpatine intended?

[@vrcommandoata5403]

So the Republic recreated the Old Republic GAR...cool, but why is there no Havoc Squad equivalent? What if all clone troopers were augmented like Bad Batch?

[@teamfmreborn7045]

How about: What if the domino squad killed Grevious on the Rishi Outpost Say Rex tricked the droid general into thinking a Jedi (like Kenobi) was in the base Only in this timeline they are able to sync the detonator and LT bombs so that Hevy doesn't have to stay behind with Grevious in the base

[@sillybob9689]

Genuinely happy about TK troopers being good guys and with strong bond witih Jedi! 1) What if the Force vaguely warned Sidious about Jar Jar being extremely dangerous and Sidious didn't want to take a chance so he hired Jango Fett to take Jar Jar out and Jango got blood on him and when Sifo/Dooku hired him to be clone donor but being smart and wary dude (like ain't no way he'll give his true warrior blood to shady old men), Jango tricked them with Jar Jar's blood and so Kaminoans ended up creating an army of Jar Jar clones (also because Sifo died and Dooku was too busy with something else)? 2) What if Jar Jar irritated Sidious so much that he blew his cover in front of the Senators and Jedi? 3) What if Dex had brain fart and couldn't answer the orgin of poison dart that would lead Obi-Wan to hunt for Kamino and as a result, the Kaminoans got tired of waiting with unused clones and decided to exterminate them to reduce expense on housing and feeding them and later, the CIS showed up to wage war on the Republic?

[@mikesmnell414]

Why is everyone just requesting for more videos? This is an interesting concept and no one wants to talk about it?

[@kinglukethe7th524]

I have some really creative and unique ideas that are so good you have to use them. Okay here i go. What if battle droids all had 3 arms? What if the Republic was only one planet? What if Count Dooku had a birth defect that gave him the title of special needs? What if baby yoda travelled back in time to kill master yoda? And finally the one i am most proud of. What if.. what if hear me out... What if... Padme had force powers but she used them to create a simulation where the republic was good.

[@warpstarrogue3554]

I honestly have zero clue what Palpatine was thinking in this timeline. If there's no way to forcibly control your method for killing your enemies, then you shouldn't use it.

[@classedupraven3991]

I genuinely loved this what if it was an amazing story

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

I'm glad you enjoyed!

[@timjr260]

What if Rex killed Ventress instead of hitting the droid in the temple on teth? What if Barris left Luminara for leaving her under the droid factory and becomes a second apprentice to Anikin, being a Lieutenant Commander in the 501st? What if Anikin turned to the darkside on Tatooene and Its "Vader" who goes to Genosis to rescue Obi-Wan? What if Jango wasn't the only Mandalorian fighting with dooku and a squad of them come up behind windu instead of b2 battle droids? What if Ashoka was convicted and Anikin and the 501st freed her by force?

[@matheusdemello2323]

What if Jango Fett freed Shmi Skywalker instead of Cliegg Lars?

[@hunterv9983]

That would be kinda cute. Boba would have a momma.

[@shaynemhopkins]

Clieg was never a slave.

[@matheusdemello2323]

@@shaynemhopkins You misunderstand the question, in canon it was Cliegg Lars that freed and married Shmi Skywalker. I’m asking what if it was Jango Fett that freed Shmi instead of being Cliegg that freed Shmi.

[@DarthnightKing]

Great work I really like it

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

I'm glad you enjoyed!!

[@korhol2065]

No wonder the clones were a must, it was this or risk a scenario like this

[@CenkHebeuy]

l would like you to get these video ideas please: 1. What if Padme saved Anakin from Count Dooku?(I mean when he was traded for General Grievous.) 2. What if Palpatine received the list of force-sensitive children? 3. What if Padme won the vote against Palpatine and became chancellor? 4. What if Padme Amidala was a Sith Descendant? (However, she will not defend Sith and will be force sensitive.) 5. What if Padme Amidala had been discovered and trained by Anakin to be force sensitive during the Clone Wars? 6.What if Darth Momin killed Darth Vader? 7. What if Anakin had not gone to save Palpatine but Palpatine had killed Mace Windu? 8.What if there was Tom and Jerry(Cartoon Characters) in the Star Wars universe? 9.What if Padme Amidala started thinking just like Anakin as a result of the clone wars (good things about the Empire). 10.What if Bugs Bunny and other cute heroes were in the Star Wars universe?

[@JosephVargas-dj7ul]

Jerry: you where my brother Tom I always loved you Tom: I HATE YOU!!!