What If We Lived in a Globular Cluster?

[@aniketnandy3124]

Sun is still a teenager *well that explains the solar flares*

[@Tranquility._]

Lol

[@timstephens5893]

Must be a woman. All those hot flashes lol.

[@blissxlove5048]

Wtf

[@JayJay-kp8ub]

I find this so wrong tbh 😂

[@kyletatoy5481]

Lmao

[@innocent8981]

What If rain never stopped ..make a video

[@skylorsguardian6550]

Great idea i second this

[@innocent8981]

@@skylorsguardian6550 I have told him not once not twice but three times 🙁

[@skylorsguardian6550]

Looks like we gatta get the masses to like your comment. Come on ppl this would be interesting

[@Superman820_]

There would be floods. The whole planet would eventually get covered up in water. Every city, state, and country we know would be completely under water. We would all drown to death unless we are on a boat or in a ship. Basically Noah's Ark all over again.

[@prisilal9380]

Life noggin has a video about that

[@saijeyaprakash8117]

What if we lived in a globular cluster? short answer: we die long answer: we will definitely die

[@Mi-Nasuno]

Technically the truth

[@lakshyabanga7637]

Very short: nope

[@gabgab1176]

nice

[@dailymotivtion]

*YES*

[@SirzSirzWasTaken]

sai siddharth even longer of an answer: We would definitely absolutely no matter what anybody EVER EVER EVER EVER EVER EVER say, we’d die

[@hulk7402]

What if we didn't die in a What If video? 🤔

[@4mb3rj43]

We die

[@aishathathikanafiu487]

We definitely die.

[@mansibuddin4108]

We will definitely die

[@aishathathikanafiu487]

@@seba2304 beyond the bounds of possibility *

[@gt_8106]

That would create a black hole sucking everybody in eventually leading to the mass extinction of all life forms on Earth!

[@tomassbaldins9850]

*Community-* But did we die this time? *What If?-* Yes,but no!

[@dat1pengu1n]

Yesn't

[@jessbragg1]

WHAT IF the sun set in the EAST and rose in the west? my kid was curious

[@shajithat3676]

Flood of religious comments incoming.

[@somebody3074]

Wouldn’t that just mean the earth’s rotation would be reversed? I remember if from an episode of futurama.

[@prvkr]

Nothing rocket science the Earth would has to rotate anti clockwise..

[@Wanderingwalker-ke6mg]

I see all the comments going religious.. I was thinking game of thrones.. poor drogo 😅

[@TheKennethfilm]

@@Wanderingwalker-ke6mg me too.

[@divyanshkumar8978]

What if someone actually succeeded in making a galaxy by following your recipe...

[@PerplexiaX]

That is the recipe, go for it! Oh, and good luck! LOL

[@chanchan12215]

But that's a story for another WHAT IF

[@PerplexiaX]

@@chanchan12215 LOL :-)

[@chanchan12215]

@@PerplexiaX thanks man! my first reply, I'm euphoric 😎😎😎

[@PerplexiaX]

@@chanchan12215 lol You're very welcome, but wow... that was a week ago! Just curious, are you one of these people who have like 20-50 KZbin sites, and check on them once a week, or are you just a busy bee!? lol I have a few other sites, one of which is shared by my musical partner... that would be our skit/sketch site, Comic Corn Comedy Channel, just some stupid idiotic skits and stuff, but there are people out there that apparently live on KZbin, Pizza, and Hot Pockets... they'll have 20, 30, 50, 100 channels... How they don't go insane is beyond me! Amazing! LOL ...oh, and hey, I hope you have a great weekend! :-)

[@ishanvarshney9054]

What if we discovered a worm hole...😱🤔

[@Saigonas]

:O

[@ArdePier]

:O

[@jahahataitin2220]

I assume we gonna die

[@zsanett01snowgirl31]

Wtf...how on Earth did you get this idea???????

[@divat10]

@@zsanett01snowgirl31 i think he / she saw a theory video Sorry if i made any grammar or english mistakes

[@gre3nishsinx0Rgold4]

I'd like to see if theres any intelligent lifeforms out there but I'd also settle in us finding ruins and abandoned technology on alien planets so then maybe we can create new tech out of those tech.

[@dream8870]

That would be nice if the tech is advance enough it'll possibly move the human race years into the future

[@zacherypritchett5546]

This just reminded me about the Mass effect games.

[@alberttopor6560]

Some of the alien ruins are the living organisms on earth

[@christianheichel]

Stargate rocks!!! Just an FYI

[@spartan16.]

there is many forces out there that are intelligent

[@arungowda]

Thanks for the galaxy recipe! Will try out in the weekend😂😂

[@snazzler]

Took me solid 20 seconds to read the statement

[@ivekofficial]

@@snazzler indians..

[@WhatIfScienceShow]

Make sure you share the results with us! :)

[@snazzler]

@@ivekofficial wdym

[@xxxzzz9654]

@@ivekofficial fam you're not even English speaking fam idk what ur in about judging by your video titles.

[@Tranquility._]

Moral of the video Don't (go) make ( raid )a globular( Area ) cluster( 51 ) just don't

[@restartedyesterday]

Lol I get it

[@restartedyesterday]

XD

[@stephluva9588]

What if an asteroid crashed into the Yosemite super volcano???? I'm gonna keep asking... 😅

[@charlescannell4064]

What if It hit the San Andreas fault, everyone wins, at least not on that side of the country.

[@phaztheaussiebastard]

You mean Yellowstone?

[@innoscent21]

It’s Yellowstone not Yosemite. But yeah that be a good what if

[@WhatIfScienceShow]

That's a very interesting idea. We are looking into it!

[@Wanderingwalker-ke6mg]

It is interesting, I’m no volcano-ologist but generally it’s activity from beneath that causes eruptions.. could a volcano be triggered from the top? I’m genuinely happy to find this comment 👍🏻 feel free to back an forth with possibilities people. Brain food 😂

[@rolltide4325]

These videos... omg Thank you for making them so darn entertaining even if we have no idea what the topic of discussion even is.

[@stxrry_lit3501]

I just love what if!♡ Endless possibilities,that's what I've ever dreamt of! Edit:Thanks for the likes!

[@nisa202]

This channel answers questions I didnt even know I had.

[@ijayjayi8584]

Nobody: My recommendation page: what if we sent our garbage to space me: well were about to find out *click*

[@neerajabhat249]

I got this idea too

[@shreyaslengade8830]

1: What if we stop using plastic completely 2: what if the vegetation gets mutated

[@Plextum]

we will die

[@lysithea6919]

we die

[@lalic2374]

D

[@Human_01]

What if we had Sword Art Online (VR)? What if we had Augmented Reality? What if Humans, Cyborgs, and Androids lived side by side, and even married? What if other Humans (cavemen) existed today? What if Mars is already inhabited?

[@WhatIfScienceShow]

Thanks for the ideas. You can watch one of those here kzbin.info/www/bejne/eYTKnJivprepf7s

[@Human_01]

@@WhatIfScienceShow Anytime, and thanks for the link! ^^b

[@mrEofPlanetEarth]

Apparently you didnt know but YEAH! There are still uncontacted tribes out there. Basically prehistoric people, alive, today. They're out there. Look into it. Read.

[@Genesongx]

WE DIE

[@astrophel12]

There is a tribe in india named sentinels

[@pharnstv4818]

You didnt explain why theres no metal on a planet in a cluster..

[@nefbee1743]

Cesar Malubay I think there wouldn’t be enough of it because it has to spread across so many stars and planets I’m not sure lol

[@Shevaron]

If you don’t have guitars There can be no metal🤘

[@christianheichel]

The prevailing theory is older stars go supernova forming heavy metals which then get incorporated into newer stars and solar systems so the older systems wouldn't have metal or at least not a lot

[@kevinv.5961]

Because heavy materials would still be trapped inside those stars.

[@christianheichel]

@@kevinv.5961 thank god they blow up cause we get heavy metal🤘

[@jumpsuid4863]

basically we die on every video of What If

[@saakshigadade4432]

Me : wow oh mi god so amazing What if : but your going to live without your phones Me : thank you, next

[@GeorgeStar]

What if you knew the difference between your and you're?

[@Final_Certainty]

Man, I always love your vids, especially for Space stuff. Great Video!!

[@WhatIfScienceShow]

Thanks for the support!

[@mikeconrad1183]

@@WhatIfScienceShow same

[@alexandermumma5635]

Speaking of using rocks to create rockets.. I wonder, "what if" we used a condensed dust explosion as a method of propulsion to leave the atmosphere. Most of the dust would be disintegrated in the explosion so it wouldnt leave much in the atmosphere. And we could bring extra "rocks" as fuel with a method on board for crushing them and igniting it repeatedly. Just a thought tho

[@saigonpunkid]

Maybe the Star Wars universe happened in a Globular cluster. That's why interstellar travel was so easy.

[@SocksWithSandals]

Being so close to the Milky Way, these globular clusters must have absorbed some of its metallic dust every time their orbits crossed the galactic plane. Plus very old stars will be more stable.

[@HandleDeleted]

Great Channel, great information, all around awesome

[@pinkisharma7675]

What if we can communicate to animals

[@gold1205]

We die, but that’s a story for another ...... what if

[@bhagwan7656]

I just love this channel :)

[@josephzumot1732]

Will we die? What if: We’ll yes but actually no.

[@Dark_Force_Of_Wishes]

It's Called The AfterLife.

[@shivaprasadhiremath-1073]

I'm a huge fan of your channel keep posting interesting facts.

[@sanskritijariwala8294]

What if the earth shrunk?

[@gt_8106]

I bet it would be smaller!

[@lawrenceh2522]

1. Earths gravity would weaken. 2. Massive flooding would occur. 3. Super Earthquake worldwide. Continents would move closer to each other causing massive tectonic plates collision. A lot more but in the end we all die.

[@EJayyDreadHead]

@@lawrenceh2522 facts we all decompose

[@lawrenceh2522]

@Sar. N If earths mass stayed the same. The gravity would stay the same. Does not really matter. We'd still die anyway. 😂

[@lawrenceh2522]

@Sar. N Prove whatever you want. Just saying we'd all still die at the end.

[@stussymishka]

this vid is awesome and really deep.

[@xxx-jq4ex]

and whatabout radiation hitting us in such cluster...

[@hubertwalters4300]

We would be toast

[@Flakester]

Life in a dense star cluster wouldn't be life at all. It would be a giant radiation bath.

[@mjdelantar9542]

*bright side left the chat*

[@evilboy3521]

Living in a Globular cluster would mean extreme, erratic "seasons" with lethal properties. Imagine the life likely to arise under such conditions. Ages of intense radiation giving way to brief days of lull. It'd be living hell.

[@ij465]

What if earth orbit and Mars orbit changed place ? Will we all die ? What happened to our climate ? Will global warming stop ? Will Mars be habitable zone ? How long does it took to complete an full orbit around the sun ? Will the weather be the same ? Does global earth temperature back to 0c° until -1c° ? What happened to moon ? What happened to earth gravitational force ? (+28 more questions) oMaGaH I had so many questions to ask 😅💫

[@glennnile7918]

It's very refreshing to hear someone say multi star systems are less stable and are less likely to evolve intelligent civilizations. You have my respect.

[@lovelylovingston4006]

Hey make a video that is about rain that never stops

[@arunrana7497]

Good work man keep it up keep making video about cosmology

[@jonathiccp.5010]

Steve Jobs would of still come up with an idea for iPhones even if we live in a globular cluster.

[@Bingblaze]

One question what is globular cluster

[@seanhyde5257]

What if everyone had there own unique special power?

[@tapodeepbhattacharya12c42]

Boku no hero academia

[@brucea9871]

His statement that a globular star cluster is only 3.2 light years across is a vast understatement. Globular clusters are typically 100 to 150 light years across. Moreover his claim that our galaxy has 150 star clusters is only the number of globular clusters. There are thousands of open star clusters which have a lot fewer stars (a dozen or so to hundreds), are not as tightly packed, have irregular shapes and are not as large. Globulars do tend to have less metal as he noted since they are older and not much metal had been forged in stars before the globulars were born. He noted the possibility of another star colliding with our sun if we were in a globular cluster which is a possibility since the stars are closer together. But a star would not have to collide with our sun to wreak havoc; if it got close enough to our solar system it could gravitationally alter Earth’s orbit, either sending us closer to the sun and frying us or farther away and freezing us.

[@chillmushroom6016]

Video: Uploaded 1 minutes ago People in the comments: comment 4 minutes ago *KZbin is drunk*

[@Saigonas]

And you're dumb

[@ussakira7294]

That was a really fascinating video

[@isthatasupra3228]

What if there was a planet in our planet?

[@seanceknowles2911]

0:09 I grew up with skies like this of course not in a globular cluster). In the small country villages and a little outside the main city in Mexico, Obregon. When I moved to California, U.S. honestly I was very confused and sadden. It's such a shame that I no longer get to look out my bedroom window and see a sky filled with shiny stars, or camp out, maybe sit in a hamic at night and see them all.

[@ayushdwivedi9240]

*What if we cover all the roads with solar panels*

[@calmingnature360]

I love your vids!

[@duke7052]

Just out of curiosity, wouldn't the radiation be too extreme for life since so many stars are so close together?

[@MapsaiLiv]

What is the soundtrack used? At least in the beginning in the video?

[@itza3991]

What if it rained all over the world at the same time?

[@expertgaming]

We die

[@Sam-gb7bu]

Who else suddenly felt kinda *'saddish'* due to the music change in 1:56.

[@whysoclever]

What If you stayed for 24 hours on beach without suncream?

[@hubertwalters4300]

Bad sunburn

[@vkobevk]

fine if your beach is antartica 😊

[@despacitospider4850]

Youre videos are awesome I like to watch many of these

[@tanushri18]

For the 1% of you who are reading my comment. Have a great week ahead ✌🎆🎇🎉💞💓💕

[@menumlor9432]

Rude

[@phoenixspirit6014]

RUDE

[@BlackIce777-b6h]

Rude

[@sidkarabc5878]

POLITE

[@tanushri18]

@@sidkarabc5878 Thank you broo!! Lysm💕💓

[@Archy112]

"Assuming there are no metals left" thats quite a bold statement. Regarding cosmic debree like asteroids and comets. Not to mention what we see mainly in the nightsky might nolonger exsist or have already changed, Due to time difference of light travel.

[@janericdaniel3192]

What if all humans had a gravitational force of Earth?

[@joelcrandell700]

Can you do what if you live in an open cluster

[@shwetadhabalia9705]

Dude I have some ideas . What if we had another planet with us revolving the sun in our orbit? . What if sun never became a red supergiant? . What if we stopped reproducing?

[@hubertwalters4300]

The shakers did not reproduce,it was a violation of their religious beliefs,the result of that was that the shakers stopped shaking,when the last one died their was no more shakers left to shake.

[@saraaziri8508]

ITS MY BIRTHDAY 🎂 🎁

[@kiantailor2612]

Daartgirl 07 happy bday

[@tooglem1468]

Why on social media? Go Celebrate!

[@doeverything4177]

Happy Eid Mubarak hope you are enjoying your birthday 🎂

[@187_-_ViRus]

Happy b day

[@saraaziri8508]

Edgy Kid I always celebrate it in midnight or something like that 😂

[@Payal2509som]

Make a video on what if moon got closer

[@_Clipper_]

WHAT IF all the nuclear power plants exploded at the same time?

[@zerkalt190]

We die...easy

[@kiruthikantrinco7689]

I searched for this content in wikipedia. It says that globular clusters have a volume of few million parsec. 1parsec = 3.3 light years. But this video says its 3.2 light years across. Lets say a globular cluster has a volume of 1 million parsec (according to wikipedia). Then its diameter will be 124 parsec across. That is 409 light years across. I don't believe in 3.2 light years because its physically impossible to have that amount of stars in such a small volume. Please correct this.

[@callmejm3073]

What if didn't Exist What if!? We never wouldn't Wonder.. 😒😑

[@AbrahamLincoln4]

What if I never died? But that's a story for another *What if*

[@upsick]

What If Every CLOUD Fell From The Air!! PLEASE LIKE SO HE CAN SEE THIS!!!

[@WhatIfScienceShow]

Noted ;)

[@upsick]

What If let’s gooo 🔥💙

[@expertgaming]

Damn he replied

[@christianheichel]

It's called fog

[@topsecret1837]

0:42 by handful of gravity you meant stars and planets chained to a black hole or a very strong center of gravity, right? 1:01 for the record, almost all globular clusters are about 100ly across, Not a snowball’s chance in the sun is that accurate. If they were that close together they’d blow each over apart from massive bouts of turbulent stellar wind, if not create a massive cloud of their components (likely to be pure hydrogen and helium if they’re not population II or I, but so far we know globular clusters to be population II, or metal poor.) from stellar collisions happening within a few years of being created. The three body problem is one issue but a million? The universe largely wouldn’t allow it, not with any stability anyway. 2:43 “an alien star would collide with our sun one day” that’s the last thing you’d have to worry about. If any planets existed around them, they’d be thrown about between star to star as gravitation perturbations result in planets being flung about like a juggling act. Although with more adult humor you could say gravitational attraction is more open in one. 3:00 I would completely disregard this argument. If we didn’t have a planet to stand on to become a civilization in the first place, we couldn’t become a Kardeshev type I anyway. If the planet can recreate humanity in its current form, not denying any shortcuts to where we are; that means they should have every element in their bodies we have. Therefore they will be able to achieve the same technological goals if the elements that they are made up of have to be at least a significant fraction as abundant on their planet as they are for us.

[@INTERESTINGTHINGSJCB]

If you see this message i wish you a great day and a blessed year❤ A What if fan❤ A small youtube trying to grow

[@sxperbia]

Same here I only 1 more subscriber to get 100 subscribers. So if u subscribe to my channel then I will subscribe to your channel

[@INTERESTINGTHINGSJCB]

@@sxperbia of course Buddy!! Deal doen!!

[@radhikanarayana2286]

Omg !!!! This channel is so good informational and educational...I juts love this channel ! ♥️😊

[@WhatIfScienceShow]

Thank you!

[@malikthoughts7011]

What if sun become larger than Milky way galaxy?🌞🌞

[@hubertwalters4300]

Not enough mass for that to happen.

[@malikthoughts7011]

@@hubertwalters4300 I said if.

[@christianheichel]

It would either become a black whole if mass increased with size or become a very thin nebula if the mass of the sun was spread out over an area the size of a galaxy

[@malikthoughts7011]

@@christianheichel The sun can only become black hole if sun runout of all energy of burning.Then it become redjoint and then black hole after a bang.

[@vkobevk]

@@malikthoughts7011 we call that black hole 😊

[@mbsports3686]

You deserve 20 mil subs not 1.8

[@ajithan6407]

What if if our oceans size is our land mass and land mass size is our ocean

[@franchiseunit2537]

just started 1000000 $ubs no videos

[@Idekanymore107]

They already did that. Check it out : reversing the topography of the earth

[@WujekFu]

What if "The Thing" from 1982 movie left Antarctica and reached civilized areas?

[@JessicaGarcia-xf9wr]

WujekFu that would be a good movie if they did or a comic book! How fast it would spread

[@aartimehra6414]

Why they termed it globular....I mean in which sense...??

[@Scarlxrd_fan]

Beginning of video showing the electric lit up, new York with a nice night sky full of stars Narrator: Its a nice sky but you would have to live without electricity

[@sushisushikun3577]

Who is the first viewer of this ? Where planet are you ? How fast is your connection haha lol

[@rarewifi9303]

He lives in a *black hole* Time in there is very different

[@jjadame7925]

What if the earth spins in the opposite direction?

[@tiny6694]

what if the earth got blown up by a creeper

[@vexx3969]

*Aww mann*

[@brianda2753]

What if the unevers was a planet please make a video I really want to know what it will be like

[@sangamthapa019]

What if poles of earth interchange their position

[@heidifirmalan5064]

Sangam Thapa they already made a video about that 😊

[@sangamthapa019]

@@heidifirmalan5064 thanks..

[@sharmanveraj3281]

What if every on Earth jumped at the same time? I really hope you guys would do this!😀😀

[@hahaa3341]

What if the channel beat vsauce?

[@Arcsecant]

What if the video mentioned how far away the next star would be in the globular cluster?

[@gandhi646]

What if we all died at the same time ?🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔

[@sindrieiriksson4223]

What if water was lighter then air ... Please make a video about it

[@jooniedundance2074]

Let's see.. *How many of them LOVE and ADORE What If?*

[@ivanpavko1352]

What if those stars are just headlights coming towards you all at once

[@sieras383]

what if we could breathe in space

[@Bruhman_16]

I still love it how he says are sun not are star

[@metroyd5152]

What if we never heard about deez?

[@homelackin2234]

I'll be that guy. "Deez" what?

[@surabhi_kumari]

I don't have all the ingredients to make it.

[@choomp2636]

I can't imagine living without rockets😭😭😭😭😭

[@heshpandemic7359]

Then imagine the 1900s

[@lottieantram9179]

What If:We would never have our tech My mum overhearing: Yes No More Damn Phone

[@aakashsatyavada721]

What if we didn't feel pain

[@maryamkhan2421]

then ur life is going to be boring

[@Marcianoverde1]

Marvelous video, but it's a bit short. There many key factors that should be included and others could be more developed. I strongly recommend it would last 10 minutes in order to show more interesting facts Thanks and bye

[@michaelonthedot]

Hi (sorry for my bad English)

[@kraladam2546]

You missed a perfect opportunity to say "without What If"

[@gamerdeck3510]

What if a time war occur