What if Yoda Went To Mustafar Instead of Obi-Wan?

[@gobberz3228]

Anakin I believe was too imbalanced to be able to defeat Yoda. True, his speed and power could defeat Yoda particularly as his experience and knowledge of Yoda would make him think. That being said, Yoda I think, is powerful enough and experienced enough to be one of the few to defeat him

[@hubertsmith2039]

true, however, I think Anakin only lost to Obi-Wan, due to his sheer hatred for him at the time. It was a personal loathing that made him reckless enough to attempt to attack him on the high ground. There would be less of a desire for personal revenge in the fight between Yoda and Anakin and, at that point, I believe Anakin was more than capable of defeating Yoda. After all, Anakin says that he is "more powerful than the Chancellor" to Padme, and Palpatine defeated Yoda

[@gobberz3228]

@hubertsmith2039 Depend how you view the fight between Palps and Yoda. Yoda had been I think, weakened by all that he had felt through the force as the Jedi fell. He clearly beat Palpatine in lightsaber combat. I think, he was close in regards to the force battle but this is where Palpatine has fhe edge. That being said, Yoda was certainly powerful enough and experienced enough ro defeat him and, I would think is one of the few who wouldn't underestimate Anakin but unlike Kenobi, would likely kill him. Then again, it's also possible he could have defeated him

[@hubertsmith2039]

@@gobberz3228 Yes I see your point, it all depends on how powerful one views anakin at the time of rots, however he was very new to the way of the dark side so I agree with you

[@JayVicky007]

Just because Anakin thought he was more powerful than Yoda and Palatine doesn't mean he actually was. After, Anakin was also know for overestimating his strength. Just like he did in his first encounter with Dooku.

[@thewarner2139]

@@hubertsmith2039 Anakin says a lot things, but they're nothing more than his personal opinion that is fueled by ego and overconfidence. The actual canon lore confirms he wasn't anywhere close to being a match for Yoda, Mace or Palps in RotS. He and Kenobi are stated to be perfect equals, and Yoda already confirmed Obi-Wan wasn't strong enough to defeat Palps. Anakin could definitely put up a fight, but he would ultimately fall to Yoda.

[@BiserAngelov1]

I have a soft spot, for a What If stories, where Anikin's faith is not tragic!

[@danielsee1]

Faith really is tragic.

[@christinacollins-gj1le]

Anakin is the Peter Parker of Star Wars. 😂

[@gjhorn6598]

Yah he gets a happish ending. Is one of my favorite out comes ive thought up.prehappes. When Anakin burst in on the Emperor and Windu.seeing and sencing the blood lust in the two...He Force pushes Windu.And Is able too hold the weekend Emperor in submition.After all zipping around jedi Masters and fighting one ..has to take a toll.Anyway Working together under a calmer Anakin's lead .Windu lends the aid needed too keep there foe in check.Until help arrives. As reward the Republic over looks any crimes Anakin may have commited to that point.And reward him. Declaring him Gaurdion of the Republic..and a Grand Master of the Force. To Avoid conflict he is supplied with what he needs too Start and operate His own Jedi school.Teaching a less rigit form of force control.Although a smaller order is mantained due to his exprenss the temptation to the dark side is lesser with his students...Luke and Leia becoming his prized puples of course. And after another 50 or 60 yrs ,The one who brought and taught balance in the force too a new order of Jedi ..Is called home and fades like Yoda into the Force...its greatest champion final rest."When 90 yrs old you reach look as good you will not?_ " Are his last words as spoken by his grand kids.

[@aranha6285]

@@christinacollins-gj1leNah cuz Peter doesn’t deserve it. Anakin deserves it cuz he’s a doucheback

[@darthnater9731]

Yoda would’ve killed Anakin and palpatine would’ve killed obi wan

[@thomasm9384]

Again. Obi-Wan didn't go 1v1.

[@historyking9984]

Yoda would easily win especially with Anakin mentality . Palpatine himsel said that Anakin would surpass the both of them eventually. So he with his full understanding of Anakins power at that moment believed that Yoda was still superior

[@justinklinck6575]

Idk. Yoda was crippled, out of his prime, and had to use the force just to stalemate against Dooku. Anakin beat Dooku rather easily in Ep. 3... Obi-Wan also had to learn a forgotten style to match Anakins' skill, a style Yoda likely didn't know himself. Yoda was more interested in the force than he was in Saber dueling, Anakin was pretty much the opposite. However, Anakin still had strong force powers. IDK, I feel like Yoda wouldn't last too long against Anakin. He's too old, and I doubt he would have been able to sustain the force long enough to match Anakins' youthful energy.

[@yeetboi4877]

@@justinklinck6575 Dooku realized he wouldnt be able to defeat yoda. Thats why he ran away. Yoda is far more powerful and a far superior duelist. At the time of mustafar yoda would most definitely have won against Anakin. However, as palpatine stated, Anakin would eventually surpass them both given his potential.

[@benjaminparker671]

What If Obi-Wan was at the Jedi Temple during Order 66

[@hamstey1603]

They were basically on par on Mustafar (though Anakin started winning near the end), so Anakin having clones would tip the scales in his favor. Basically Obi Wan would die.

[@hydrospace1]

@@hamstey1603I don’t think Anakin would kill obi wan then and there, he’d try to convince him, as he was the closest to a brother or father he hsd

[@Andrea-tz7bm]

KFv isn't conflicted as mfv, he would have killed obi wan

[@hamstey1603]

@@hydrospace1 That could very well be the case, especially since Anakin didn't like killing the Jedi (as shown by the fact that he didn't have sith eyes). However, this would only be the case if Obi Wan tried pretty hard to reason with Anakin. I doubt he would do this. He might try a little bit, but I doubt it would be more than he did on Mustafar. Obi Wan was seen as the perfect representation of the Jedi Order and because of that, he also shared it's faults. If he were to reason as much as Ahsoka (to the point where he'd be willing to sacrifice his own life), then there could be a good 50/50 chance. Other wise, I doubt it.

[@AlexStam]

that would give me a good headache

[@anthonywatson1508]

A few weeks/months after getting into the suit Sidious told Vader he is lucky that Yoda didn't fight him on Mustafar. That tells me Yoda would win the fight.

[@brianhatcher2799]

That was a great book!!

[@flemit35]

he got his limbs lobbed of and his entire body burnt but he was lucky

[@anthony_r985]

​​@@flemit35yeah seems luck was on his side😂😂

[@hoursofmusic0708]

What if Mace Windu agreed with Anakin when he was about to kill Palpatine

[@oliivey2302]

What if obi wan was the chosen one that would be epic

[@darenchadwick8610]

He is with the high ground

[@desaad1725]

then it wouldn't be so interesting would it. we wouldn't get episode 4 5 6.

[@wolfdotzip4053]

what if yaddle became a force ghost and helped dooku return to the light

[@UnitedWars]

If he was willing to kill her I doubt there was anything she could do

[@addictedtochocolate920]

That sounds beautiful

[@texasmles8158]

not yoda yaddle😎

[@wolfdotzip4053]

@@texasmles8158 yaddle had the best chance other than qui gon

[@Only1199]

What if just before Anakin force choked padme, she quickly used her blaster to stun Anakin?

[@irrel3vantt]

i'd love to see that

[@nikolassforos2644]

In the original script for the movie padme would bring a knife to kill Anakin but would fail

[@wargamesmaster]

Not gonna happen, only Han Solo can shoot first.

[@theknight3093]

@@wargamesmasternice😅

[@Darthkermit_frogo]

New vid lets go 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉 What if kit fisto was the chosen one

[@horrorchara7397]

Nah, what if jango fett was the chosen one?

[@kierendavidson3276]

Honestly, I have no doubts that Yoda would beat Anakin, and wouldn't be afraid to finish him off either. I think there was a book or a comic in which Palpatine pretty much stated as much to Vader, that he was fortunate it was Obi-Wan and not Yoda that went to Mustafar to face him, as Yoda would have killed Anakin if and when he beat him.

[@dakotalange2858]

What if Yoda went to Dookus meeting with Palpatine instead of Yaddle

[@BanksHicks]

What if Anakin lost the pod race

[@troylasher6646]

George Lucas already confirmed this several years ago. If Yoda had been the one to go to Mustafar, Anakin wouldn’t have won.

[@bobbykeenan7127]

He didn't win regardless

[@mur7ssec]

@@user-mk4or5yu9rit was because he saw the emperors shuttle about to land, knowing that he(obi-wan) had no chance to defeat the emperor so had to leave anakin there.

[@chasetauscher9544]

What if Count Dooku had a vision about the rise of the Empire?

[@Gabriel-by4fd]

After seeing the duel between Yoda and Sidious in the senate and that of Obi-wan and Anakin in Mustafar I think that Yoda would have killed Anakin in a short time without any problem

[@foxygamersbat647]

What if Luke brought Leia with him to confront his father in Return of the Jedi

[@wambutu7679]

What if Ezra Bridger missed Obi-Wan and stumbled onto Luke Skywalker when he went to Tantooine?

[@Voltar_99]

Owen Lars would likely either tell him to leave or where Ben lives.

[@wambutu7679]

@@Voltar_99 Or give him a job working alongside Luke on the moisture farm.

[@Voltar_99]

@@wambutu7679 lol, nice joke

[@aggrobob1972]

Great idea, I'd watch that.

[@lanceslyd4865]

Yoda: Anakin Over it is, High ground I have! Anakin: you underestimate my power! Yoda: do or do not, there is no try

[@nilesclifford9704]

Anakin jumps, and yoda cuts off anakin's arm, and legs with his lightsaber.

[@CelestQB]

In Legends Yoda would lose to Anakin but in Canon he would beat Anakin. Anakin in legends was already stated to be the most powerful force user and there are tons of statement stating Anakin was the most powerul jedi in the order when he was still in the light and when he began to use the DS he was quite literally in a league of his own far surpassing Sidious and even Yoda.

[@tekxae]

its true but we talk about canon so no

[@Dookusolosfr]

Fax master qb the 4th

[@TexasNationalist1836]

Why is there a difference between legends and cannon

[@CelestQB]

@@Dookusolosfr fancy seeing you here 🕺🏾

[@Dookusolosfr]

@@CelestQB indeed

[@sharedgoblin560]

That was honestly one of the best videos I had ever listen to nice job on the video man. I really enjoyed listening to it, especially the part where Anakin explain why he turned back to the light. it made sense. It was fun to listen to, and I even like how you explained how Anakin explained to the Senate. How Palpatine had manipulated him throughout his child head all the way until he turned to the dark side.

[@Sean-hn1vt]

I am currently watching the entire Star wars what if playlists and so far I am loving it! Also can you make what if Satine Kryze never died.

[@kenshin491]

What if Galen Marek killed Vader in anger and joined Sidious without losing most of his power.

[@danielmillward9947]

In the third game they were making, a full power galen vs a full power vader no holds barred, vader batters him and galen realises he was holding back against him the entire time so even the developers of the game even had vader stronger than galen

[@kenshin491]

@@danielmillward9947 Definitely interested, though I’m more curious of the mentality of Galen as a full Sith Lord and how he channels his betrayal into power, and what powers and skills could he develop on his own and under Sidious.

[@TheArnold360]

I think a more interesting story would be if anakin won the fight against yoda. We know who the most powerful is, obviously yoda, but what if anakin got a cheap one in like darth maul did with quigon? It makes for a more compelling mirror for anakin and more interesting narrative moving forward

[@darthnihilusreborn14]

That would be interesting since Sidious was mostly evenly matched with Yoda, so Anakin killing someone as experienced and skilled as Yoda might scare Sidious and any remaining Jedi survivors.

[@gamingwithcharlie413]

I believe yodas power in the force is just to great for a fast one, he would have sensed it a mile away

[@ricky2012100]

Anakin only gets arrogant toward people who connect him too his past life, after killing the separatists leaders the novelization says he fully embraced himself in the dark side. At that point he was ready to kill sidious once he figured out the secret to saving Padames life. Anakin wins moderate diff.

[@theromanmapper]

Plot twist: The prison of Anakin had sand

[@r6854]

What I never understood was how the jedi council thought making Anakin basically spy on Palpatine would turn out well. They know that darkness surrounded the Palpatine, they didn't know he was a sith, but they knew someone very close to him was very experienced with the dark side of the force.

[@michaelmcbride2670]

That’s the “wisdom” of Yoda for ya.

[@CloneCommander5929]

What if order 66 never happened? Mace windu kills palpatine before Anakin arrives.

[@aggrobob1972]

Good story mate. Always nice to get Anakin back. 🤘

[@justamessenger4577]

3:13 Is that obi wan in the background???😂 great stuff!!

[@Durwood71]

If Obi-Wan and Yoda had traded places, then Anakin and Obi-Wan would have been killed.

[@jarjchois3850]

What if anakin died in tpm What if maul killed everyone on tattoine What if sidious was causght in tcw What if people listened to fives What if anakin didn’t exist What if all the Jedi died at the battle of geonosis What if you did some of these

[@SuspiciousSandalsFromIstanbul]

Love the last one

[@NicholasJScott]

"High ground I have! Over it is." - Yoda

[@superrooster18]

‘Clapped, you are’

[@PumpkinEater9001]

Oh, Anakin would've been SCREWED. Yoda should be similar, in terms of power, to Anakin at that point, so with his smaller size, greater agility, oh, and NINE HUNDRED YEARS of experience, I don't see how Anakin could possibly defeat Yoda.

[@dragonborn6347]

exactly, thats why palpatine never sent vader to kill yoda in dagobah, he knew yoda could kill vader easily, he was much stronger than obiwan and even obiwan could handle anakin

[@erica.5583]

Wow! This is interesting indeed. A part of of me wishes it did go this way and Anakin redeems himself, but another part is glad it didn’t. He does go to the light side of the force in the end, redeems himself and Luke saves the galaxy. The Star Wars saga is a tragedy. Full of life, death, and suffering and struggle. Anakin does bring balance back to the force, but not the way we wanted to. His story is a sad and heartbreaking one but it was necessary for his son to be the one to bring his father to the light side. For without it there wouldn’t be a Star Wars saga and a story that is epic and unforgettable.

[@wolfdotzip4053]

What if after Anakin Married Padme obi wan marries the duchess after getting the darksaber and after if Ashoka still gets kicked from the order anakin and padme take her in or maybe she isnt kicked out with the help of kenobi anakin plo koon and maybe fisto

[@clamchowder622]

Over it is, Anakin. The high ground I have.

[@ashkanhooshmand6518]

had yoda gone to mustafar to fight anakin, then we would have had the shortest lightsaber deul instead of longest one. even shorter than maul vs kenobi final round

[@abekeddie]

Great video

[@alanfrost75]

So wait, Yoda alone had no issue handling Palpatine's lightning, but Yoda with two other Jedi just stand there and get torched? Also, I think Yoda would have made far shorter work of Anakin at that stage.

[@sithemperorpalpatine870]

If yoda went to mustafa to confront anakin, yoda wins. The end.

[@Xanarch_Vigil]

A 900 year old force train being that has managed the Jedi order over centuries vs. a 9 year old slave boy with 20 years or experience being a Jedi based on the knowledge disseminated by the former… Yoda would win with ease. Vader would have died on mustafar.

[@orlandobritt1460]

Anni would be in a body bag .Yoda don't play that

[@8rrows]

What If Qui Gon Never Found Anakin Skywalker? Now that's a FIRST!

[@lincolnrodriguez13]

IF Yoda went to Mustafar there would have not been a Vader

[@deshawnbrayboy]

Yoda: Anakin, it's over. The highground, I had.

[@newworldlifemysticmelech]

“What if yoda went” - the battle would be over in 5 seconds .

[@johnpittsii7524]

What if the Zygerrian Queen fell in love with Anakin

[@gerardocovarrubias3058]

Fantasy folklore did you get my comments about making these what if’s what if Anakin Skywalker trained more on his force abilities what if Anakin Skywalker became Jedi battle master? What if Anakin Skywalker was sent to kill grievous and Darth Maul killing two birds with one stone just like he did with Count Dooku

[@user-pf7kf6dt8q]

I really like the story. And I hope in the future you do a princess Leia her choosing to be a Jedi instead of a diplomat and how that would have shape the galaxy.

[@lajoyalobos2009]

Obi-Wan and Yoda should have double teamed Sidious on Coruscant first. It would have put the newly christened Vader into a unstable place if his new master was suddenly gone and then Obi-Wan and Yoda could have taken him even easier.

[@thegamingenderman]

Obi-Wan would have suffered the same fate as Kit Fisto and company just saying.

[@Voltar_99]

Meme one: what if anakin didn’t want the child Real one: what if bendu spoke to sabine when she kicked him

[@zhaff-ud6rh]

Great video!

[@anthonyp6896]

Dude I watched your videos I think you do a great job

[@SOB98]

Yoda - "Over it is, Skywalker. The high ground I have!" Anakin - "Master Yoda, that's just a small boulder..."

[@Zay3xxxx]

Anakin wouldn’t do that against yoda he knew he could beat obi-wan therefore his arrogance but he would not underestimate yoda and I feel sidious probably would have been on the way to fight yoda with anakin like how he was on his way when he fought obi-wan

[@5Demona5]

I love seeing Anakin get happy endings. I often wish those were the canon endings... but then I remember Star Wars isn't complete without Lord Vader. I will always love Ani, but Vader is too badass to leave aside

[@datingwiafusexclubdatingwiDOKI]

Agree man I absolutely love it as well. Yeah, I’m glad to see Anna can get a happier end.

[@charlesgrubbs8094]

The emperor would have taken Anakin's body at that point like he originally intended

[@oldmandan3884]

Hey I’ve got an idea that two military generals should have thought of ; You are both down the street from the emperor, why not go together to defeat him. Then go get Anakin , who’s just chillin on a planet not doing anything

[@teeterharris]

Sitting malevolently hahaha

[@Dookusolosfr]

Bro I was just abt to ask this question because I kinda skimmed back through the rots novel and obi wan initially offered to go for palps but yoda told him he would never be as powerful as him and die painfully

[@XKnuffiBaerchen]

bro those animations!!! i love it XD

[@Javier_Jimenez71]

This is a great version. Very enjoyable and I can see this on the giant screen. Cheers

[@michaelschweigart3517]

Aww, little Princess Leah

[@Nkosinati]

(Cough)..What if Yoda went to Mustafar? lol. Ok, i'll play. Here's what i see... First of all, Vader is the only one who talks. He starts spouting all his Sith sht, "You shouldn't have come Master Yoda..." "I have become more powerful than any Jedi, even you..." , blah blah blah. Yoda doesn't say sht; just sits down and looks up at him with those big, froggy, pity-filled eyes. Then as Vader continues to trash talk and threaten, Yoda just sits there, closes his eyes in meditation and waits. Vader, filled with rage at Yoda's calm, lunges with his lightsaber with all his force might right down at Yoda's head. Yoda, with lightning force speed, scoots over about 3 feet to the side, focuses all his force power to pull the weapon out of Vader's hand, leaves it ignited, spins it at Vader's head, all in one millisecond motion....and Vader's lifeless, headless body thuds to the ground. Yoda opens his eyes, picks up his walking stick, and limps away. End of Star Wars as we know it.

[@yc_knight6370]

If Anakin would’ve fought Yoda, the fight would’ve been over with. He would have not lost one of his arm and legs. I think Yoda would’ve use the force to knock him out in the beginning.

[@Palpatine-exegol]

The sensible thing to do would’ve been Yoda and Obi-Wan confront the emperor, then go to Mustafá together to defeat vader

[@pookerpoison8569]

I am now calling this version cannon and the movie version a what if. This is the good ending.

[@david10006]

Honestly, this was more entertaining then the sequels, nicely done!

[@karolclark791]

Anakin would get rekt

[@ONI1013.]

If Yoda and Obi-wan switched places on that last fight, there would be two people dead- Anakin and Obi-Wan. (Unless they kept that creepy puppet version of Yoda from the original Episode 1, then Anakin may had a chance of winning).

[@Rhys_The_Egg]

Ff I have the best one ever…. What if thrawn was force sensitive?

[@gerardocovarrubias3058]

Or make what if Anakin’s mother was never sold what if part two of what if Qui-Gon Jinn survived along with many more what if scenarios

[@fungusz_4292]

There is no way anakin would turn on sidious that quickly and dramatically

[@teddy-jc7rc]

What if darth jar jar

[@stevebrown7622]

Imagine how scary it would be if you were anakin and you watch as yoda steps out from his ship. The greatest Jedi, who hunted you through the universe to eliminate you.

[@jakub7894]

your what if videos are really acurate i lvoe them

[@romeoceron7445]

I don’t foresee this battle ever taking place. Anakin respected yoda , yoda was the only one Anakin liked on the counsel besides obi wan, and it seems that yoda arrived at the time padme would have, at that time Anakin was crying, he was sad, he regretted what he did in the temple, he cried for that and for the person he used to be, it’s stated in both novels of ROTS and The Rise And Fall of Darth Vader. So yoda would’ve sensed this coming from Anakin, and he would’ve seen this and would’ve realized this isn’t what he wanted because in the novels it tells how Anakin didn’t want to control the galaxy, he didn’t want to kill everyone, he just wanted to save padme and that those were the cards he was dealt in order for him to save padme. He planned to kill sidious and destroy the sith after padme gave birth, he cared nothing for the sith, he just wanted his wife and kid to live. Yoda would’ve noticed this, well sensed it but this is why I don’t see the battle happening, because it was padme that set Anakin off and obi wan to fuel the flame, but yoda, yoda wouldn’t have set him off, he actually liked yoda, even as Vader he still appreciated yoda trying to help him in the clone wars, good story but I feel this route I’m speaking of makes way more sense

[@rentoshine2038]

👍👏

[@Mattius.-_-.101]

Yoda found Anakin on his own without padme, obi wan would go search for ally's and not be able to tell padme so padme wouldn't go to mustafar

[@romeoceron7445]

@@Mattius.-_-.101 Ik that. I was saying that based on the story telling that yoda showed up at the exact time Anakin was crying and remorsing, about the same time as padme showed up in cannon continuity. So yoda would see Anakin regretted everything. I was also just saying that padme lit the fire and obi wan fueled it more in original timeline

[@patrickking4080]

My only thing is Anakin getting tired. The whole point of Anakin's horse potential is because he's like a motor that never stops

[@Baconisgood69]

What if mace windy went to Naboo to protect queen amidala instead qui gob and obi wan

[@cloudshifter]

You can only find one thing that describes a story using such specific words as "Electricity crackling in the air, a testament to the Emperors malevolence ect."

[@robyo1713]

At this point annikin was still good in the eyes of the people. No one would know he had turned to the dark side except for a select few..

[@Killdoomrodar]

The twist of anakin killing the emperor was good

[@kholbrook0859]

Yoda went to KILL Dooku. He went to KILL Palpatine. Imagine a “what if” that Mace Windu was not an egotistical maniac and actually waited until Yoda was with him to take on Palpatine. It would’ve been all over and done.

[@buffalojoe78]

I don’t believe that Obi-Wan, Yoda and Ahsoka would go into Palpatine’s half cocked and not prepared for a fight. Remember, Obi-wan and Yoda both have experienced Force Lightning from Dooku. You think they wouldn’t have expected the same from Palpatine? And Anakin as a deus ex machina?

[@bradfordross2088]

Wait slaughtering thousands of Jedi and only getting 5 years is kinda crazy

[@thoar81]

what if Anakin and Obi-Wan were the same age when Qui-Gon Jinn found Anikin. Then Qui-Gon raised them both together but Obi-Wan eventually turns to the dark side from jealosy because everyone always worshiped the "chosen one" Anakin his whole life.

[@NotGoodEnoughTheory]

I was hoping we would go into hand to hand combat and I would just step on him… 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@mukhlasmann309]

Only a 5 year sentence for multiple murders and treason ?!!

[@parisbasonidis1620]

What if order 66 failed

[@johnmyers9683]

Yoda would have wiped the floor with Anakin better and more powerful force user than Anakin.

[@zackcross7190]

What if Yaddle fell in love with Yoda?

[@jeffmuller1489]

I was just going to say that Yoda clearly wouldn't have the "high ground". He's just too short.. lol

[@HighValueMan24]

If yoda went. It would have been game over within 5 minutes.

[@thegriffin4049]

The flight with obi was personal. Thats why anakin was so aggressive. He wpuld not have approached yoda like that. Although yoda would use his emotions to his advantage. I would say yoda would have won just because of how he would have been able to focus and has hundreds of years more of experience and training over everyone

[@davidwillson3004]

well first of all Obi-wan would never be able to wriggle through the ducting the way Yoda did

[@ALF8892]

Today would have force crushed Vader like he did with the medical equipment after getting defeated by Obi Wan

[@grousedog88]

What if Yoda actually helped friends ? Was he Not a friend of Obi Wan ? Luke Skywalker ? Would he not help protect friends ? Did he not care about what happened to other Jedi ?