What If You Could Access the FOURTH Dimension? Interstellar explained

[@BeeyondIdeas]

Watch the Science of Extreme Time Dilation in Interstellar 👉 kzbin.info/www/bejne/aHvLgp-VmZmLbck

[@ManyHeavens42]

21 my lucky number

[@michaelccopelandsr7120]

I've figured out how to change the stars by stopping hurricanes. Don't worry, I've technically already done the easy part and changed the stars. My parents were teachers and for over 3 decades, they taught their students my constellation. Those kids will teach their kids. So on and so on. See, stars changed. I just need help to make it legit and with the rest. I need to get to Texas ASAP. No, I'm not kidding. Yes, I'm serious. I get 7 things. One of them being to change the stars and remember, crazy is a compliment. Will you please help?

[@mj-7444]

@@michaelccopelandsr7120 No NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO NO

[@anontwentytwo1380]

Can you cash app me 20$ plz

[@Foraszn]

Where can I download the movie?

[@speededits4289]

I want another space movie just like Interstellar where the science, cinematography, storyline and music amaze me

[@BeeyondIdeas]

Agree!

[@bradleywalker8642]

"The Martian" (2015) is really good.

[@rajanacharya1135]

@@bradleywalker8642 Also Gravity, though its all based on LEO.

[@Dr.SyedSaifAbbasNaqvi]

Nothing comes close to Arrival. It's one of the best of the last decade. My favourite besides Interstellar.

[@BellicV]

@@rajanacharya1135 we dont speak about that

[@explosivedude8295]

Everyone forgets TARS. The robot to actually quantify and relay the quantum data to Cooper. The robot who willingly abandoned it's life cycle to serve the transcendence of mankind. The unsung hero. The anonymous Gothamite. The DARK KNIGHT. *_Hans Zimmer's 'Dark Knight Rises' theme plays_*

[@Moveplaylift]

C'mon Taaaars!!!

[@koicaine1230]

This is the most beautiful thing I've seen all day.

[@douglaslang2218]

Tars had a poker face after all

[@douglaslang2218]

We cannot even possibly think or co spider what a tesseract is

[@koicaine1230]

@@douglaslang2218 Actually you can, but it's really hard because it's so abstract. The 5th Dimension is accessed by the mind.

[@katblickety]

That was the most elite transition into a video sponsor I’ve ever seen 😂 can’t be mad at it at all y’all killed that

[@kevinveyron6440]

yeah but its annoying😂

[@dadboard]

Glad someone else noticed that. I’ve never seen a more seamless delivery

[@stephenmartin9194]

Seriously

[@HomeDefender30]

It’s always impressive when a creator can do that, but also extremely frustrating because your listening intently like it’s part of the video! 😂

[@tamimhasan3084]

This is bs. How can it be a loop? Who started the loop at first place? Who was the first copper to go into teserract or who was the first murph who got that signal and equation? First murph doesn't exist without first copper, first copper doesn't exist without first murph. Cause murph fully depend on future copper from tesseract for gravitational signal. On the other hand first copper fully depend on first murph for the loop to start and start his journey for the tesseract. Two things which depends on each other for their initial start can never be the first reason for starting a loop. Anyway this story is bs. That's why we need 4th dimensional being for starting this loop also known as God.

[@MSE9107]

The fact that 8-10 years after the movie was made, people still make videos about this movie is a testament to how epic it is. This has to be one of the best movies ever made and I would argue it’s in the top 3. Especially considering how deeply it provoked that mind blowing feeling you get when thinking about our existence, reality and the purpose of life. A true timeless masterpiece

[@louiseharpth1267]

It’s important for every human, and that’s so magical

[@tooktheblunt7121]

What’s your other 2 films in the top 3 ?

[@onemoresamadams]

Agreed. I’ve been obsessed with this film since it’s creation.

[@crazybub11]

I “accidentally” stumbled into this movie in the theater when It released, never having heard about it. By the time it ended I knew I had just seen my new favorite movie. It blew my mind how incredible it was. The only movie I can ever remember wanting to watch again immediately after the credits played

[@JimSty-bh1os]

I think Christopher Nolan is one of the most underrated director and screenwriter combo in cinema history, at least in regards to the major Hollywood award ceremonies, like the Golden Globes and Academy Awards. I mean, literally nearly all of his movies are so damn good and thought provoking, from Momento to The Dark Knight Trilogy to Inception and Interstellar. He's a director and writer who takes his crafts very, very seriously and puts an amazing amount of research and effort into all of his projects. And I think that at the very least, Interstellar should have been nominated for 3 Oscars for Best Picture, Best Original Screenplay and Best Actor for Matthew M.

[@TheWaken]

No matter how many times I watch the movie or a video explaining the tesseract part, I never fully comprehend it.

[@slicein]

me too 😂

[@pillow1557]

Imma just stick to the 4D being only time even if it's wrong This shi hurts my brain

[@Ang_r]

Same

[@darksunrise37]

I can’t believe no one mentioned this but in the beginning when the dad explains “Murphy’s Law” and then at the end we find out that Murph proves it. It’s like one big circle. The whole timeline was predetermined so anything that will happen, happens.

[@DMRCapitalHill]

It’s just like tenet it’s very spiritual and metaphysical

[@ngaiya]

I remember that scene where he said that now it all makes sense damn 😂

[@indie_fisher]

can happen to "should" happen is such a mind fuck. should to "will" happen is so much trippier. bruh

[@ayanotanabe5220]

Dang this movie was waaaaaay more well thought out than I ever ever expected in a movie. And to me, it’s hitting me as if it’s NOT predetermined but my own free realization lol

[@thephilosopher7173]

Nolan's movies will do that. He plays a lot with these concepts of time, since its like the story itself when you re-watch it. If you haven't seen Momento, I highly suggest you do. Its not as science based but is more psychological. Or the cult classic, 100% independent movie called Primer.

[@alexclark4792]

@@thephilosopher7173 Memento. One of the best movies ever. If you haven't seen it, watch it. I can't describe it without spoilers. Just thinking about it makes me want to watch it again, see if I missed something. 20ish years, seen it maybe 5 times. Still one of the most memorable movies i've seen, I can recall more details than most movies I can just think of.

[@tamimhasan3084]

This is bs. How can it be a loop? Who started the loop at first place? Who was the first copper to go into teserract or who was the first murph who got that signal and equation? First murph doesn't exist without first copper, first copper doesn't exist without first murph. Cause murph fully depend on future copper from tesseract for gravitational signal. On the other hand first copper fully depend on first murph for the loop to start and start his journey for the tesseract. Two things which depends on each other for their initial start can never be the first reason for starting a loop. Anyway this story is bs. That's why we need 4th dimensional being for starting this loop also known as God.

[@rupambanerjee2066]

​@@tamimhasan3084 I agree with you that if it is a loop then who started it. If everything is a loop then the simulation hypothesis will be true.

[@mattseil9943]

@@tamimhasan3084 Mobius strip?

[@h.narula3495]

A movie so complex a physicist is explaining ❤️

[@MishimaZaibatsuCorp]

Don't be delusional. Listen I like movies, but you need to draw the line. These filmmakers take references from the Quran and distort them and create narratives that are meant to push you away from the actual truth. READ the Quran, just 1 chapter, even if you are not religious. You will be astonished by its Truth, trust me.

[@lukaytv6103]

@@MishimaZaibatsuCorp bro literally fuck that book. Just made up facts from ancient people who smoked too much and wanted to create a way to force people into their cult

[@action1093]

@@MishimaZaibatsuCorp bro they take inspiration from hinduism too the whole avatar thing and a lot of other famous movies are directly taken from hinduism

[@VishDumb]

Behenchod kya cringe phela rakha hai yrr harr jagah Dusare ki accomplishments m khud proud hote ho woh bhi aise Cringy comments krke. Behenchod khud ka krle kuch lodu

[@Ananya___]

@@action1093 exactly... They take inspiration from every religion... And they make it about them

[@VY-zt3ph]

You missed the fact that in the movie Cooper mentions that the human race is not limited to three dimensions but they have become five dimensional being and that's why they were able to create the custom tesseract with Murphy's bedroom because their history states that Murphy solved the equation.

[@randybaumery5090]

Well said..

[@ikt98]

time travel is a loop. everything happened bc it has already happened. and my no 1 question abt this time travel, if they created the tesseract to have Murph save them in 2090+, how were they able to make it to live to 5th dimension when none of them wouldnt have made it (everyone dead by 2100) if Cooper didnt send the morse code data via Gargantua black hole dimension. They needed Cooper and the team to travel to the wormhole in 2070ish now how would the wormhole exist if THEY didnt exist in the first place

[@VY-zt3ph]

@@ikt98 it's a paradox..it is at this place where my mind stops thinking about movies and tells me to come to reality

[@felixbatista9699]

@@ikt98 I have the same question, the only solution I’ve found is that the first time line of the first humans did not go with plan a, however they continued with plan b, and then somehow they extracted the quantum data and evolved years into the future to a 5 dimensional beings, after that they decided to help save the humanity that they left to starve and die, and since (idk about this idk about physics art all) they are 5 dimensional beings they are not affected by changing their own past and creating a paradox. I don’t know if this makes sense but yeah

[@BlakeBelladonna0119]

@@felixbatista9699 That wouldn't work because as mentioned in the video you cannot alter what happened in the past, they didn't go with plan B and then came back. Plan A was always going to work, since it did, and those people went on to become fifth dimensional way in the future and then placed the wormhole and tesseract there for Cooper and Murphy to find and use. Also, to answer @IKT nothing was changed imagine the time loop extending past Cooper and Murphy's full circle. The being in the future placed the wormhole and tesseract there for them in the past because that is what was meant to happen as it clearly happens in the movie. So, no paradox was created they existed in the future and created the wormhole and tesseract in the past as it was always meant to happen. The only thing that we can't explain is how they did it. But they are beings so advanced from what we are they found a way to place a wormhole and blackhole with a tesseract in it for us to use instead of just simple gravity like Cooper used.

[@AnymMusic]

I just adore this kind of stuff. With all its fault that humanity as a whole has, the fact we can think of this and wonder what it would be like to be in a higher dimension is amazing. Idk if it even could exist like this, or if we ever would somehow be able to access it like how we can access 2D, but just the thought is awe inspiring to me

[@fustercluck2460]

A time traveler would technically exist within a higher temporal dimension, which is what this movie was getting at. The beings themselves were quite possibly still bound to three physical dimensions, but used their abilities to manipulate a second temporal dimension via the warping of space-time in order to build this device. They themselves might have been unable to travel to the past themselves, as they were never actually shown in the movie. Most likely they built the machine from their time, into our time using the same techniques that he used to knock over the books in his daughter's past. It doesn't really explain how they would get around any of the various paradoxes of interfering with the past, or how they survived to their current time, if doing so required outside intervention in the first place. A chicken or the egg situation.

[@StevenErat]

Christopher Nolan or Ridley Scott needs to make Andy Weir’s “Hail Mary Project” into a movie. I think it would be on par with Interstellar and Contact.

[@dosomestuff1949]

@@fustercluck2460 no, the beings were NOT limited to 3 dimensions. They had FULL ACCESS to 5 dimensions so time itself is just another direction.

[@_numb]

@@dosomestuff1949 🥚yes

[@MishimaZaibatsuCorp]

Don't be delusional. Listen I like movies, but you need to draw the line. These filmmakers take references from the Quran and distort them and create narratives that are meant to push you away from the actual truth. READ the Quran, just 1 chapter, even if you are not religious. You will be astonished by its Truth, trust me.

[@Douglas_I]

It's pretty impressive how you worked the Nord advertisement into that analogy!

[@Bearsbeets.battlestargalactica]

Interstellar is one of the greatest movies that has actual real life application and I love it. What it doesn’t touch on is portals and I would like to see a movie that addresses that. It’s how the spirit world goes around.

[@charlesthomas7372]

I'd like to add an idea of predetermination, this might include a point to which the first idea was ever conscious. imagine a circle. in that circle, events flow from one direction to the other(left or right, depending on your preference, just like a clock) this comes down to string theory. our entire "PERCEPTION" can only observe the flat circle by going around it and not seeing it as a whole; meaning we cannot see the full of circle (a flat circle being a straight line for the occupants living within) and that's why we experience "TIME". The unknowing creates the illusion of time, if we don't know what will happen we have to anticipate events by measuring uncertainty with units(Time & space). But if you can access the 3D "PERCEPTION" of that circle, it will put you right in the center of it(point of origin). In the 3D Actions no longer play a role to determine events but rather consciousness in this matter. Consciousness express itself by projecting the probability of it’s ideas. In a sense, all the information would be available to you in all directions. you know what will happen and what did happen, and all the probabilities in between, always. experiencing those events would require you to enter a certain point you choose; imagine playing a quest video game, but now you can see the entire gameplay as it was written by it’s creator in real time. but other than that, all events would be experienced through observation. In other terms, it will be like watching a movie. And maybe when you travel through dimensions your consciousness gets split into all the layers, and only the consciousness from the dimension you are experiencing becomes the primary one pushing the others into the background. They're never gone, only operating silently without your awareness(intuition). So if you’re no longer in the centre, you move away from the observation point that has access to all direction. Kind of like whe you’re standing on vantage point that’s higher than every other point.. if you move away from that point, you only have the memory of what it felt like to be in that point, but because everything is happening; in the now, that memory of accessing all points kind of fades back and you only have the experience of the moment you are in. So a specific point ejects you from the advantage you had. And death is what sends you back to the centre. Phenomenons such as Deja Vu, although not proven invokes this sense of knowing that you already had long before an activity has happened. maybe each time we sleep and dream we get access to this higher dimension. lucid dreaming can be an example of being aware that you are in the center of everything, your thoughts are the key drivers of your reality. information: once stitched together and put into meaning anyone can have access to that information, even 1000000 years from now. But that information was always in existence. Perception through consciousness is how you can access information from any point you desire. understanding who we are could be a revolution within our species. Everything we need to our aid could be hidden in plain sight. Consciousness has always been the frontier within us that we haven't put maximum effort to understand.

[@RayaanWani]

Ok but the sponsor transition was so damn smooth

[@Eayodeji]

Good explanation

[@Bluegamerful]

pretty wild theory i‘d say

[@yolo4346]

Couldn't understand everything you said but I find this theory thought provoking!!

[@Handlebarnpc]

Marry me

[@sensibleplayer]

the tesseract is a gift from humans from a different dimension who managed to solve the equation and evolved. they thought, might aswell help the other dimensions who failed to leave earth.

[@vanessastanford]

I wish I could watch interstellar for the first time again

[@strawberrycough8911]

Watch it on shrooms

[@AryanSingh-on9id]

Totally agreed with you on the last chapter. I too have been thinking about this whole thing that if we could time travel and change anything in the future, how do we even know that we ACTUALLY have changed anything in that time. Because it just might be predetermined or say fate that you'll travel back or forward in time, change anything and that would go likely after that. This was a freaking loop afterall. Another way to understand this is lets say we imagine two different scenarios in our minds that what happen in the near future. Now if either of it happens, we cannot question that if IT was supposed to happen or not. Maybe we would have experienced the other scenario and still that would have been the only reality. Even if we could travel back and change our decision, that would again end up in a loop and it will be our reality that we'll first take this decision come back in time and change our decision. Ultimately, we would never know that whatever we did was OUR free will or everything just happened AS it was SUPPOSED to happen without a slight chance of mistake in it. This is confusing yet so marvelous!

[@mohamedshahrul1750]

Life is All about choice..

[@ethanaurora9580]

@AS-L yea, I like that explanation

[@luji2385]

bro is saying everything and nothing at the same time

[@jennyanydots2389]

What was the point of the animal abuse though? I don't understand the connection. I think Nolan just likes to beat dogs in real life.

[@Aobix]

But this create grandfather paradox. So I think parallel universes exist so when the changes are made in the past new timeline creates or it already exists

[@zeeshanshaikh9980]

I just love that serious tone for videos on this channel. No bullshitting around.

[@wesleytwala1474]

that NordVPN promotion was smooth. This man has to venture into Marketing and Communications.

[@silvanabolivar7615]

😂

[@aryan9637]

i don't know why this channel doesn't get much views but this channel is a 💎. I personally feel that, after watching the content it really adds value in my life, helps to expand my knowledge and increase my thinking capacity.❤️❤️

[@BeeyondIdeas]

Glad you enjoy our videos. I appreciate that!

[@myblueparadise5807]

Because the contents are very marvelous and good level of understanding...not all common people understand the depth of the words in the videos....so here's less quantity of people but good quality of people 😀

[@keegandecker4080]

I feel old but I’m just getting into astronomy and it’s content like this that really makes you want to learn more. Great stuff.

[@kassandercailliau8674]

Normally I wouldn’t agree with stuff like “love is a force that can transcend dimensions” and call it out is lazy writing, but in this movie it felt like you could let it slide because all of the other amazing writing prior to it. It feels like it’s _actual_ *science* - “fiction”, emphasis on fiction. No giant exaggerations, except 1 which blends beautifully with the story.

[@shinodaprime9182]

there was also the concept of " Love ". I think Cooper mentions it at the end. Love is a natural cosmic force, just like gravity, and can move trough space and time. At least thats what i got from the movie :D

[@alisaforster28691]

Ugh...

[@PM_____]

@Mitchell Brown love is gravity

[@renzojose6555]

🙄

[@Bushheadmonster]

@Mitchell Brown grow up and you’ll find that it’s true

[@parasxd6462]

@Mitchell Brown lmao nah bro idk why many ppl found it cringe....It was the "love" which made him do all the stuff.

[@migs6674]

Interstellar has to be one of the greatest films ever made.

[@deedots2878]

Or perhaps, the key was LOVE. Love propelled Cooper to take on an impossible journey, then love safeguarded him along exploring and all the way to reaching the tesseract. When it comes to Murph, she loved her father so dearly she went back to her bedroom after 25 years. Love is the moving force throughout the movie.

[@Mindfultay]

Great video. What I still want to know is if Cooper is constantly conscious that's he's in the tesaract. He only seems to be conscious carrying out all those tasks once, but if everything is in a loop, then where's the consciousness in that? Are there multiple coopers? It's mesmerizing.

[@ernelbustamante6330]

I think there is only one Cooper inside the tesseract. Otherwise, if he had done different decisions or actions that would lead into a different outcome of the loop.

[@domcatsup]

i know right wouldnt cooper be conscious enough to understand that his fate is predetermined? would that thinking cause a different timeline? so many questions....

[@swanubal508]

there is one time for one cooper .....so basically even the tesseracts are different for every cooper .....and so is everything..it's like everything happened like billion times before and will happen billion times again with every new cooper and every new tesseract I guess.,...more like different mirror worlds I guess (It's just my theory I may be wrong)

[@alexanderokak5112]

are you conscious right now? Yes, you are. Is your life also pre-determined by the composition and spin of atoms in your brain and everything around and outside it? Yes. Therefore you can be conscious while in a pre-determined universe as we exist in a (mostly) pre-determined universe. The only randomness appears to be the creation of certain particles and antiparticles but that's beside the point.

[@tomascarrizo2080]

We see this in the movie like a short moment where cooper realizes what he is capable of doing, inside the black hole the time has stop for him, maybe he spents months try to guide Murph, also TARS is somewhere there, they never met from what we see but maybe he can give Coop some thoughts. And Coop can go back and forth between time, so he can try again if he fails in sending the right message, maybe the movie is the first iteration where Cooper understands what needs to be done and get it right. So many questions and we all can answer them and be ok with it and at the same time come up with something different

[@thebutterfluffman6855]

I remember watching this in theaters when my friends took me, I cried because of the story line and left the theater questioning what I had watched, this entire tesseract blew my mind as 14 or 15 year old at the time

[@TfGamess]

The greatest movie of all time. Everyone should see it atleast once in their life.

[@-Neutron-Star]

Interstellar is great but think Arrival is more deeper in concept snd in content !

[@TfGamess]

@@-Neutron-Star saw both. They are great, but Arrival doesn't come even close to Interstellar honestly

[@-Neutron-Star]

@@TfGamess I would say if someone wants to experience a visual spectacle and scale of space-time then certainly Interstellar wins hands down, but if someone wants a cerebral experience then Arrival is the movie to watch!

[@sebastiancanoncastellanos4409]

I just finished watching this movie for nth time and this answers a lot of questions I had. Thanks for this content, great video!

[@BeeyondIdeas]

You're very welcome!

[@cicici]

I just finished watching this movie now for the third time, and was searching for the time dilation and tesseract , which I got to know from your channel. Thanks for the explanation.

[@BeeyondIdeas]

Our pleasure!

[@gabelincoln3608]

Just watched it for the first time it made me tearing and that’s never happened in a movie

[@npmerrill]

@@gabelincoln3608 Now that the floodgates have opened, you will never be able to watch another movie without tearing up. Surrender to the flow!

[@gabelincoln3608]

@@npmerrill lol

[@npmerrill]

@@gabelincoln3608 You’ll think about this comment every time a movie starts. “Am I going to cry during this?” you’ll ask yourself. The answer is yes.

[@genichiro77]

I've been rewatching this movie since it first came out in 2014, Thank you for finally explaining the tesseract in words and visuals that I can understand.

[@novygaming5713]

I actually have a theory for time travel/faster than light travel (like the wormhole in the movie) You can imagine cubes with the universe inside like frames in animation software as an analogy. Say we have tesseract. Just like a cube is made of infinitely many planes stacked on each other in the dimension perpendicular to x and y, a tesseract (hypothetically) is made of infinitely many cubes stacked on each other in a dimension 90 degrees from x y and z (we call this axis "w"). We can't access w since we are bounded by 3 dimensions (x, y, z). But what if we replace one of our axis (let's say z) with w? Z becomes the fourth invisible dimension so to an observer we appear as a cross section of our original shape since the rest of us is in w, but we see a cross section of the entire universe with the w dimension being all possible moments for that cross section. We can travel through w and be able to travel through time. When we reach our desired time, we switch z back with w and return to regular coordinates. Note that we can freely move in the x and y coordinates but not z because it is inaccessible while in flight. Also when we travel through time, to an observer we don't disappear unlike what most would think. Instead our time moves faster relative to the observer, so we appear to move in slow motion. Us on the other hand experience time normally. This is similar to what black holes do since gravity acts on 4 dimensions. If we move back in time though, we do disappear but we just appear before we started traveling so we might be able to catch a glimpse of ourselves exiting in the past. Here comes the fun part. When we look into the future while we move in the regular x and y axis, we see a linear path of where we will be if we don't stop (it even works with gravity acting on us since our trajectory is predetermined) if we change our velocity, our destined future will change too. Imagine the cube analogy In the second sentence. If we move in a certain direction in normal xyz coordinates then switch to xyw coordinates, then we move forward in the time dimension (aka, we move the slider in the animation software faster than how it normally plays) we skip ahead to where we will be in the future. Time dilation will take place since our time moved faster relative to the observer, but when we reach our destination, we can always go back in time to accommodate. That's all I have for ya. If anyone by any chance understood a word I just said, I would be happy to hear since this is a huge oversimplification.

[@ScottMurrayBestFamilyCars]

Her name is Murph. Her brother makes fun of her name, Murphy's Law: whatever happens, happens: the self-consistency principle.

[@photography_by_raj]

Another film like Interstellar is a NEED right now... May be a sequel or a totally different movie but should have scientific accuracy just like Interstellar

[@ReelDealOutdoors_TV]

Absolutely. This video just made me realize that WE are “they” in the movie because Murph solved the solution of gravity/time. Mind blown and I’ve seen this movie probably 20 times. Every time I watch it I learn something new. As an engineer myself, these type of movies are so profound and we need more educational/theoretical movies like it. This movie made me as a high schooler want to go into STEM!

[@lifeasdev7480]

@@ReelDealOutdoors_TV the whole movie is a time paradox, they saved themselves

[@vikasshelke5544]

Sequel would be great were lead actors meet on 3rd planet yhat was habitable and they discover different challenges not experienced so far. That movie should end with value of earth to humans

[@_golsa.ab_9912]

Your channel is madness! I am really proud of your contents and your effort to give the best you could to your audiences. Already in love with the curiosity you make!

[@sali313]

Finally I understand the ending of Interstellar after watching it for about 10 times thanks to this video. You are so good.

[@ernelbustamante6330]

I love how you illustrate why the tesseract looks like that in the movie.

[@jumarluis9599]

Warching this makes me understand the most mind-boggling part of the movie. I recommend that after watching the movie, watch this video right away. Unless, you are only after special effects then you wouldn’t understand the concept at all. The movie goes beyond just being a film.

[@LuciferMorningstar-zu1ud]

Interstellar has to be the most accurate science fiction film ever made. It's science fact disguised as a sci-fi film. Kip Thorne, Nobel prize winning Physicist was behind this film as well, giving it that much more accuracy

[@tunicshirts733]

I want to bring to your attention Tars and Coopers first and final encounter. Then every single time the robots spoke (I’ll come back to this). What I think Nolan was trying to tell us is that the reason for our “depression” or sense of inadequacy is because we are explorers and pioneers as a species. He specified a few times in during the film that we aren’t caretakers. “Take care of my kids” he told grandpa as he left for space because grandpa isn’t as capable as he once was. Coopers frustration was rooted in this sense of helplessness and being capable but no way of executing. Until opportunity presented itself. But compare the way coop interacted with Tars in the beginning to the final scene. Don’t be afraid of technology - use it wisely.

[@louisax4058]

From all the explanations i've seen this is the one that i understood 100%

[@DrDre-sy2kv]

The black hole interaction made Interstellar the legend of space time travel movies. Gargantua was basically the centre of Interstellar, that's why nobody gonna forget it.

[@alenpr5628]

INTERSTELLAR Christopher Nolan's MASTERPIECE ✨️💫

[@BeeyondIdeas]

Couldn’t agree more!

[@rugved3072]

In short, theoritically, time represents itself physically in the 4th dimension and all circumstances in this universe are nothing but an infinite never ending loop

[@mattiaskeinnn3317]

Why do i always get interested in sht we cant REALLY explain... thats why space and science is like 2 of 5 things in the world that can keep my attention for a longer time (i have adhd), because theres literally another question hidden behind every answer. It intregues me, and scares me at the same time. We're absolutely insignificant.

[@DiceDecides]

my theory is that if you fall into a black hole you enter a universe where normal matter becomes dark matter and dark matter turns into normal matter so it would look quite different to what we're used to

[@BeeyondIdeas]

Good assumption!

[@ThatBigGuyAl]

I believe that black holes and white holes are connected, and if you were to “fall through” a black hole, you would enter a different universe

[@DiceDecides]

@@ThatBigGuyAl yes! exactly, every normal matter would become dark matter so we wouldn't even 'see' earth lol

[@austinpeters2942]

@@DiceDecides i don’t understand how we wouldn’t be able to ‘see’ earth. can u explain?

[@DiceDecides]

@@austinpeters2942 earth would be made out of dark matter in the parallel universe, we cannot see dark matter as far as we know, I believe we can if there is a nearby light source but since the sun would be dark matter as well that would not be the case.

[@mr.nobody5028]

I somehow know less now

[@LettuceDS69420chinguun]

This made my 3 am

[@nmbr1ctrman]

It seems like even if time travel or time observation via the 4th dimension was possible, you wouldn't be able to change anything. You'd simply just observe it outside it's sphere. Changing anything would cause a paradox where a change would have no beginning, thus not existing.

[@luxxulyanite]

When and If time travel ever becames possible, the timeline is always fixed. Watch the tv show time travelers wife for one of best examples. It is called a block universe theory. Every time travel action was always ment to be so that the events play out just as they are. Something like a logic circuit in programming. The universe is one big software program with inputs, outputs and loops.

[@DavidMichaelCommer]

(Spoiler, kind of...) This is also the premise of the TV show Russian Doll. A character spends the series trying to change aspects of her own and other people's past lives to make her life better in the present so that she will be a better person in the present, and after all her travails, she realizes that everything she changed always was going to have been changed by her, anyway. She could go to the ends of the world to try to make her life better, but her life is exactly what it is supposed to be and there is no alternative. And that helps her reach a place of self-contentment because she stops blaming herself for past "mistakes" that always were going to have been made. There is also a suggestion in a fleeting moment, though, that although this is true, it's also true that there are multiple versions of timelines that go into different directions because different choices were made. So it's sort of a having-your-cake-and-eating-it-too philosophy that allows a person to forgive themself for their mistakes and accept they are who they are supposed to be while also feeling some relief that another version of them is living a different life because on a different timeline that version of them made the choice they wish they would have made. Physics becoming metaphysics is nifty.

[@npmerrill]

@Roberto Vidal Garcia no obligation, but sometimes it does us favors anyway. Is it random?

[@Ownyx]

I'd still love to go back and watch specific points in history. How shit actually happened

[@dosomestuff1949]

It wouldn’t cause a paradox. It would only cause one to 3d beings not to 4d beingd

[@PoiZo_NG]

That was one of the best ad deliveries I've seen so far

[@alenpr5628]

This is more than a sci- fic movie to a story between a father and his child.

[@rusparr2528]

So is Star Wars.

[@furerorban1488]

@@rusparr2528 leon the professional

[@furerorban1488]

So is Lolita.

[@ramongomez146]

My confusion still lies in the tesseract and worm hole construction. How would humans in the future be able to build this to self preserve themselves to make sure that Cooper sent the message to Murph? If future humans were trying to ensure their future to be able to even manipulate the 5th dimension why not communicate to Brand (the father) through gravity? Is that where Love comes into play? That in order for messages to be relayed through time and space that a connection of love allows it to travel to a specific person at a specific time? So many questions

[@TheMathewclaut]

The analogy and transition into the Nord promotion was smooth.

[@charlespackwood]

Time is intersecting space and both are being dilated: at the black hole both time & space are affected; in the tesseract, time is relative to location. Both of these "instances" are different, at the convergence of the black hole & in the tesseract; and because they are different, they must be different in either time, space or other factor. If this is indeed correct then there must be the possibility of other "instances" that could occur in either another time slice or in another space time, which means that "everything" can not be determinative (ie. ALL of reality cannot be determined) because of what occurs at a given, "specific instance". Furthermore, If gravity can transcend both space and time then every instance of gravity's force must be a constant within any given spacetime and must also be a constant within another spacetime, as well (ie. another dimension); otherwise, gravity fails to transcend spacetime in reality. I kind of thought through this as I was writing it down, so I reserve the right to ponder some more on my conclusion.

[@sandman516]

I've actually thought about this too. There's no reason why that tesseract should be limited to that room only. He should be seeing just about all of space and time in there.

[@ernelbustamante6330]

@@sandman516 the movie said that the beings capable of creating that tesseract only limited Cooper on the bedroom... because he has a mission to do that happens in that location.

[@TheCudder4life]

There's 2 different timelines in the movie. We are never shown when "they" (Us) built the wormhole but that in itself is a different timeline from what the movie shows from beginning to end.

[@shopsuper8197]

I love space movies. I swear I do and I have watch countless number of them but INTERSTELLAR is my all time favorite movie and I watched it millions and millions of time I can’t get over it. The music touches the deeper core of my soul and I always shed tears when I look at the relationship between Cooper and Murph… I am always thrilled watching it and I can’t stop watching it and as am typing this am still watching and even tomorrow I will watch it. Best movie of all time and best space expedition movie of all tome

[@pesektapisokarabz4622]

great, i dont 100% understand it but i enjoy it. thanks

[@kenka25101]

This is definitely one of my favourite movies but one thing I didn't like is that time can't be a physical dimension. Implying the 4th dimension is time means that a 4D world is unique. Even a 1 dimensional world experiences time. The reason why people use time is only because we can't picture a 4th dimension

[@zikishi4655]

Never thought this movie had so much foreshadowing and such complex and theoretical science in it, Great Video. PS: I'm now going to go watch this movie again

[@BeeyondIdeas]

It's great to rewatch it every once in a while 👍

[@Ridethebomb777]

Its all theoretical ..... that's all we have, even with our telescopes and spectroscopy, its all either theory or a guessing game. Man assumes spectroscopy works the same way out in the depths of space, but theorize's that time doesn't ....... make it up as they go along. One thing is certain ..... no one is leaving !

[@daniel-oe4et]

Thank you for keeping this movie alive.

[@mightybullcapital]

this is the movie where legends cried being amazed by the beauty of the whole movie

[@meyjung2004]

Finally someone could explain it so well! Well done!!!!

[@AfsanaAmerica]

In the movie Cooper said he was able to communicate with his daughter in the past because of love and that love is a quantifiable force.

[@muslimcel4581]

😂

[@alexshrestha130]

That Ad transition was the smoothest ive seen

[@GregBankin]

Are there any other movies as good as this one? This is mind blowing

[@slic_papa2671]

I'd like to posit a few ideas here. First of all in regards to why the tesseract focused on Murphy's bedroom, it is lightly touched on that our future 5D offspring beings that we evolve into focused it there as it was necessary to do so in order to save humanity as well as themselves - in other words, without Cooper entering the tesseract and sending the messages (both the one he created on the floor for himself and the one left in the ticks of the watch hand for Murphy) our future 5D selves would not exist nor would the tesseract interaction, nor would Cooper's flight of that mission - more than likely. Secondly, Cooper does indeed travel back in time. Recall that in the beginning of the trip to the other solar system he interacts with Dr. Brand on his metaphysical journey back through the worm hole. Though we don't know it is him until after the scene with the tesseract, the event did occur for Dr. Brand at an earlier point in time.

[@adarshjadhav3238]

Smoothest sponser transition ever!!! ❤️

[@iamtheprotagonist]

It’s not that Murphy is predestined. Nolan subscribes to Fatalism - that everything was fated to happen the way it does and couldn’t be otherwise. All of time is existing simultaneously too as he also believes in the Block Universe Theory of Time. The “causal loop” in the film has always been written on the block. Everything has already happened. Nolan expressed all of this in Tenet too (Neil repeatedly says to The Protagonist “What’s happened, happened” (which is expressing Fatalism).

[@r3l4x69]

The tesseract is not a time machine in the traditional sense. Instead, it's a construct that allows interaction across time through the manipulation of gravity, thanks to the advanced understanding and control of physics from future humans.

[@WisdomProclaimer]

Did anyone catch the movies notion that "love is not something that we (humans) have invented" and that "love is the one thing that we are capable of perceiving that transcends dimensions of time and space"? Is the movie eluding to a spiritual conclusion for the concept of love, since many believe "God is Love" and exists outside of our physical dimension and is Creator of time and space? Some also believe that God is the one who first loved us (humans) and taught us to love. What a great movie! Cerebral enough to illicit conversations and questions that make you wonder! ✨ 🧠✨

[@Localguitarman]

very well explained. Answers all the thoughts i had during the movie

[@BeeyondIdeas]

Glad you think so 🤘

[@jasonpatrickdeleon4701]

@@BeeyondIdeas thanks for the explain bec i cant understand the movie what happen

[@RobertMcKenzie-k3z]

For me, This is the BEST movie ever made. Many opinions may differ, but this is IT for me.

[@abuzarmehdi9782]

Finally you uploaded your video. I love your content

[@BeeyondIdeas]

Thanks. More to come!

[@TubeOnRichard]

I just find it so enormously wonderful that we can so seriously explain fairydust!

[@myonice.3097]

I still don't get it when time is shown with physical space, then what is space in that definition ? he can travel the time when murphy young and adult, but why he can't travel to another room (space) ?

[@empireravenshadow5]

That is the best segway to an ad i have ever seen

[@gingersnapuu444]

Do you have an explanation for how Cooper was able to be in two places at once? As he was still with Murph whilst future Cooper was communicating with her in the past.

[@npmerrill]

Easy peezy. All possible expressions of the universal wave function (let’s call such expressions “events”) are omnipresent throughout the universe. Observing (or “experiencing”) any particular event is a matter of focus. Spacetime is emergent (i.e., non-fundamental). By focusing on a particular event, an observer (“experiencer”) parses out a particular possible expression of the universal wave function from the myriad of all possible expressions. When focus shifts to another event, another expression is parsed, and so on. Since spacetime is emergent and all events are omnipresent (and omnitemporal), Cooper and Murph are together or apart depending on their focus (or ours or anyone’s). Everything and everyone is everywhere and everywhen. The mechanics and limitations of focus shifting are the subject of another post. 😉 Contemplating the above explication while listening to Vida Blue’s “Most Events Aren’t Planned” may be enlightening.

[@WooliteMammoth]

He wasn't "with" her, he was communicating through gravitational waves. He had no way of actually interacting with her in any other way.

[@NoNameIsBest89]

That was the smoothest transition into a sponsore message ive ever seen. Well done sir well done. Also the video is great

[@LemonChecks]

thank you. this movie has power. i'm not sure of which kind but it literally changed my life (and probably SAVED it.) & i see from others comments - i am NOT the only one. i think it's GREAT you broke this down to bite-sized edible chunks of knowledge for everyone!

[@kelseyobrien543]

Mine too. I see the world differently now and dimensions.

[@sombanik449]

Great explanation? I saw this movie but couldn't understand. Now I'm able to understand. Thank you..

[@minduran-gs6mf]

if you time travel into the past or to the future, you cant go to the same timeline that your into, instead you will be in the another timeline, thats why you cant alter the past or the future in your timeline, which means the one your altering is in another timeline and if you happen to meet yourself in that timeline it will cause a time paradox

[@jonasc1221]

I thought I understood this movie but you just revealed so much that I didn’t even realize.. wow.

[@roronoazoro8696]

How did the time loop actually started?

[@DarkXagami]

Kind of a mind trip to think that since the loop is infinite, they have been solving the gravity equation since the beginning of time and will continue to do so, always and forever. So trippy

[@prihnt1233]

I have always said this to my parents right since my childhood that somehow I feel we are living in a loop

[@stuartsmith8155]

Wow I should read the book . This blew my mind😎

[@wardog5537]

So what would being in a real tesseract be like? What would access to the 4th dimension give us? Would it be an ability to travel back and forth through time, or just space-time, so like a portal to another world across the galaxy or universe?

[@AL4NGDROE]

Um. All of that and this is purely speculation mixed with science and given factors. I see the Tesseract in this movie as a way to show the 4th dimension of time as a physical space that current humans could move though as if was accessible 3d data. But the only thing that could do or make such a thing would have to be in a 5th or higher dimension. Bc it could look at time the way we look at 2d events. From outside of it.

[@Jimmybrianmike]

@@AL4NGDROE i feel like we already have acess to the 4th dimension purely for just how time works IRL. Like yea we can't change the past yet we can change the present which influence the future like deciding when to meet etc.. but am i correct in saying that in the movie he has acess to 5th dimension which he's able to send messages to other time frames which already happened? my understanding stops here

[@wardog5537]

@@NorthLondon-pm6xy Good point

[@AbhishekMaurya-g7z]

This movie is giving so much inspiration to physicists.

[@TokzanTee1]

The Nordvpn ad was smooth 😂

[@UROOZFATIMA190]

Your channel content is REALLY commendable and so impressive love these topics interstellar is the best movie ever made and your explanation was also quite good

[@kailashjayaraman]

Neat!!! Thanks a ton for the explanation and the hard work of creating it meaningfully

[@MrSaturdayNightSpecial]

The big problem with videos like this, is, they show reverse interaction from 3 to 4 without notification or direct in space interaction from 4 to 3. If the 4rth dimension is time as thought by some of the scientific community, then time, being not spatial is not as they show it or think of it. Time is arbitrary and only exists to the observer of it in 3 forms, growth, degrade and non static(unaffected object of study). A 4rth dimensional observer may see you, may hear you if they have the ability, but until they enter or project sound or physicality into your space you would not have any idea a 4rth dimensional observer is there at all. The interaction from 4 to 3 would have to be rather direct. Shoving books and what not is not direct enough and would only appear to be nothing more than an accident to the 3rd dimensional observer of it. Or a blink of a shadow. We still have yet to prove the 4rth dimension exists as we think it does as "time". And since time is just our arbitrary numerical measurement from the 3rd dimensional observation point of things growing, degrading or doing neither then we may be chasing a 4rth dimension of which as we define it as time may not even exist itself. It may well be the 4rth dimension is not only not time, but something far different. Theoretical scientists talk about the 4rth dimension as though it is a concerted object definable, yet, only guess at what it actually is. So by modern standards, the 4rth dimension, could be anything and if it was time, the only way you would know of 4rth dimensional down to 3rd interaction would be because a being of the fourth dimension wants you to or some natural accident. Otherwise they would be effectively indiscernible to anyone they are not interacting with directly. Even then the sign of that 4 to 3 interaction may be indiscernible to the 3rd dimensional observer. Modern scientists don't even state weather the 4rth dimension has any of the other dimensions attached or operating in it or if its otherwise unto itself a singular dimension. 4 might have the other 3 dimensions to look at, or interact with, but may not be attached directly to them being outside of them completely. So really, the "4rth dimension" is raw speculation, and even if provable, it would only be provable from a 4 to 3 measurable interaction, either you going to 4 or 4 interacting into your specific 3 dimensional space. Then how do you measure that? Well, even if I told you, reading this, that I may have had a 4rth dimensional interaction, you would just think I was crazy or that I was on something or imagining things or any of the other excuses people come up with. I have figured out one way to determine if there is higher dimensional existence direct interaction, problem is, it could be any of them, 4, 5, 6, 7? Anything from 5 would appear to be from 4 and 4 from 3 at position of observation and so on. 4 would have to create a 3 dimensionaly limited object perhaps? Its all speculation. No, I won't tell you how to determine it. Its better if you just follow the greatest commandment, the commandment like unto it.

[@Bill-tz3wg]

IF it is fact that gravity can be used to send messages back in time, then shouldn't we create a protocol and machine for transmitting and receiving such messages RIGHT NOW? - If we create this standard protocol and machine for gravitational messages today we may instantly receive thousands of messages from the future.

[@codycis]

Best ad sponsor placement I'm all of KZbin

[@Shu2you]

Bro is so smooth with the NordVPN ad...

[@solarisleo1]

The movie states that the 5th dimensional beings perceive time happening all at once. This is what the 5th dimension is in this movie. It’s not a place, it’s an awareness of time happening all at once. Once humans became aware of time they were able to do things that could not be done before ( meet at specific locations in three dimensions, travel with the right amount of resources, etc). Unfortunately the 5 dimensions beings could not isolate a specific moment in time to communicate which is why Cooper was needed.

[@Tesoro1996]

Thinking about it, we might just be in a time loop and are already predestined to one outcome, navigated by our future selves.

[@onealexbond]

Anytime I see interstellar, I click. thank you for still making content about this amazing film.

[@gogox1136]

This channel is so underrated, people should start subscribing to you guys👍

[@hemanthnayak889]

That is the smoothest sponsor transition I've ever seen.

[@WildRiftGameplayandTutorial]

I was not watching the movie because I thought it wouldn't be as good as the other sci-fi movies like 2012, Knowing and Deep Impact but man, it exceeded my expectations when 1 day, i decided to watch it. It is superb. Makes me wanna watch it multiple times.