What is Wrong with 18th Amendment? Centre Province Relations in Pakistan | Federalism| Moazzam Lodhi

For Full Lectures of Sir Moazzam Lodhi on Pakistan and Current Affairs or for Complete CSS and PMS Session of All Compulsory and Optional Subjects, WhatsApp us NOW at 03036449744!

[@cepipakistan]

CSS 2024 hai sar per aur ye hai PATAY KE BAAT 🤫 ✅ CEPI has shifted to a WhatsApp NEW NUMBER! For admissions and queries, CEPI will be at 0321 1114880. Please delete the old number 03036449744 from your phones. Drop us a "Hi" on our NEW WhatsApp number 0321 1114880 to keep receiving "Free Lectures" and Free Monthly Bulletins! Ghalat jagaa messages mat karte rehna 👀 come to the right place! Come to CEPI at 0321 1114880!

[@ziaullah734]

Ap autonomy bat karti hai hum pukhtun Pakistan nahi manti hai pukhtunkhawa is integral part of Afghanistan shame on langmar rangit sing k puter pushtun jag GIA ab waqat tumari perbadi ka agia hai😊

[@K.Tabreek]

18th amendment was a necessary step in view of other provinces' grievances that the revenue is being spent on Punjab only. Also what Gen. Musharraf did to Balochistan's resources..provinces demanded to let them own their resources rather than the Centre (occupied by Punjabi elites). However, the proposal of introducing Quota sys. is pragmatic. Kindly Correct my analysis if it is wrong.. @CEPI

[@cepipakistan]

Kindly watch this video till the end to complete your analysis.

[@muhammmadnawazsabzoi5712]

What about Southern Punjab? Y its legging behind day by day? It is in worst situation than Sindh and Balochistan.😂

[@GKwithkhalil786]

Sir Moazam is one of the best teachers under i studied in lahore. ❤

[@cepipakistan]

Please Whatsapp on 0321-1114880 to register in our classes with CEPI! We offer all our subjects and all testing services online as well as on campus!

[@umairnawaz4458]

No one can explain this topic better than Sir Moazzam! Amazing!

[@cepipakistan]

👏👏👏

[@cepipakistan]

Sir Moazzam’s New Batch of Pakistan and Current Affairs is starting THIS FRIDAY! 📝 You can register here if you wish to learn more directly and personally from Sir Moazzam Lodhi! Click Here: forms.gle/jSCAUBLsA1Rmga3j8

[@hakeemkhan1118]

Ab pata chala k itna barha failure kyun ha css ma, ye argument ha😢

[@cepipakistan]

Thank you for your appreciation! Please WhatsApp on 0321-1114880 to join our full session with classes and tests included!

[@thequestboy]

Sir, your historical point is biased as you did not quote role of karachi which comes in Sindh even when Sindh was under Bombay. Karachi was most advanced and developed even more than of at Lahore.

[@aimanawan6341]

I am not a CSS aspirant but never enjoyed learning history like this. 👍👍

[@cepipakistan]

Binging you to knowledge is our goal 💊

[@Xebi_khan]

The quota system is primarily based on population rather than development. Punjab, with over half of Pakistan's population, receives 50% of the quota allotment. Similarly, KPK faces tough competition in CSS exams, with many candidates not being allocated positions each year. Secondly, Lahore was developed before partition, it's crucial to note that the entire Punjab province is not equally developed.Every political party is invested in the development of Punjab due to its larger number of seats in National Assembly. Simply, the party that holds the majority in Punjab often takes the lead at the central, which can lead to a disproportionate focus on Punjab's development, while potentially neglecting the needs of other provinces. Instead of blaming or criticizing other provinces, it might be more productive to consider the partition of the Punjab province to address disparities and ensure a fairer distribution of resources and opportunities.

[@cepipakistan]

Thank you very much! Please WhatsApp on 0321-1114880 to join our full session with classes and tests included!

[@madihaahmed9801]

potential of teaching ❤

[@cepipakistan]

We appreciate your words 😊 Sir Moazzam’s New Batch of Pakistan and Current Affairs is starting THIS FRIDAY! You can register here if you wish to learn more directly and personally from Sir Moazzam Lodhi! Click Here: forms.gle/jSCAUBLsA1Rmga3j8

[@mateenhashmi6076]

He is a real nationalist btw 😂

[@cepipakistan]

Thank you for your appreciation! Please WhatsApp on 0321-1114880 to join our full session with classes and tests included!

[@haroonmustafa997]

On point sir

[@cepipakistan]

🤗

[@syedtahirrasool1903]

full lecture link please?

[@cepipakistan]

They're all uploaded on our KZbin channel! Come visit our channel and click the "PLAYLISTS" or "LIVE" section to watch all complete lectures.

[@zeeshan2567]

I wished to learn sir muzum 😊

[@cepipakistan]

Sir Moazzam’s New Batch of Pakistan and Current Affairs is starting THIS FRIDAY! You can register here if you wish to learn more directly and personally from Sir Moazzam Lodhi! Click Here: forms.gle/jSCAUBLsA1Rmga3j8

[@muhammadasaad2681]

Nyc tech. Of teaching

[@cepipakistan]

Sir Moazzam’s New Batch of Pakistan and Current Affairs is starting THIS FRIDAY! You can register here if you wish to learn more directly and personally from Sir Moazzam Lodhi! Click Here: forms.gle/jSCAUBLsA1Rmga3j8

[@alishbahussain1061]

Excellent analysis!

[@cepipakistan]

👆👆👆

[@kiyyabadal1526]

How the capacity building takes place without authority? 18th amendment is the initiation of capacity building to not developed provinces. This point is procedural not strategic though the amendment has many negative points.

[@cepipakistan]

Thank you for your appreciation! Please WhatsApp on 0321-1114880 to join our full session with classes and tests included!

[@kulsoomkulsoom6799]

why noone talks about the evil of 18th amendment. lets shed light on how this amendment favored zardari nizam and helped his party loot the money, this is the ground reality , ye democracy sirf west ko hi suit kr skti hai

[@cepipakistan]

Thank you very much! Please WhatsApp on 0321-1114880 to join our full session with classes and tests included!

[@MRAadil-kr5hg]

I DISAGREE WITH SIR ON THAT DISCUSSION. AS PUNJAB HAD ENJOYED A LOT OF STATE RESOURCES AND ATTENTION. THEREBY, OTHER PROVINCES FELT NEGLECTED. THAT WAS THE MOMENT THE NEED FOR 18TH AMENDMENT WAS FELT.

[@cepipakistan]

Thank you very much! Please WhatsApp on 0321-1114880 to join our full session with classes and tests included!

[@MsAdeel66]

Completely disagree.

[@CSSAspirant-tk8uw]

After watching your lectures,I am thinking that would that I were your student.

[@cepipakistan]

Yes, definitely! Please WhatsApp at 03036449744 to join our classes Online or On-campus! Both Morning and Evening Batches are available.

[@masroorkhalil9655]

Brooo saaab seee pehleee toooo yeeee NFC award meee chsnges layeee jayeeee taxes koooo do parts meee banta jaye direct taxes collection kaaa ikhteyar provinces ko deeya jayee or indirect taxes collection federal govt koooo deee or jooo provinces keeee resources hain unki royalty 70-80% tak provinces koooo deeeya jayeee 2- New provinces on basis of populations and ethnicity banayeee jayeee 3- Directly elected municipal govt hone chahyeee with authority of taxation

[@cepipakistan]

Thank you for your appreciation! Please WhatsApp on 0321-1114880 to join our full session with classes and tests included!

[@marryambakhtawar9280]

Well done sir. Thank you so much for this lecture

[@cepipakistan]

Most welcome

[@سرداربلالکوسو]

This was done by the Zardari because he knew that, He will never came back in the central power, however you are right that capacity is not equal as campare to the Punjab , if the antogonist tried to overcome 18th amendment zardari is playing 'Sindh card', we have seen from the Bilawal zardari rhetoric example he stated that if you will not give right (here right means if you did check and balance on our corruption or second vow ) to the provinces you'll see conseques like Bnagladesh. Thes are the grassroot realities which we can't illustrate in neither in exam nor really life.

[@cepipakistan]

Thank you very much. Please WhatsApp at 03036449744 to join our classes Online or On-campus! Both Morning and Evening Batches are available.

[@Educationwire008]

Simply stunner.i isut came to cepi bcz of sir moazzam!

[@cepipakistan]

Most welcome 🤗 CEPI is always open to all of its online and on campus students! Feel free to WhatsApp at 03036449744 for your appointment with us!

[@shizasimab5592]

Fee ka bta skta he koi candidate inki

[@cepipakistan]

Yes ma’am . Please WhatsApp now at 03036449744 for all the details and fee.

[@Madanikhan421]

Fantastic sir

[@cepipakistan]

Thank you for your appreciation! Please WhatsApp on 0321-1114880 to join our full session with classes and tests included!

[@shahmi5973]

Well Explained..👌

[@cepipakistan]

Glad you liked it! 🙂

[@HassanAhmed-jd7nu]

While capacity building might seem like a viable strategy to promote development, achieving parity between provinces is a complex challenge that cannot be solved by capacity building alone. Even if efforts are made to upgrade education, infrastructure, and other facilities through capacity building initiatives, the vast differences in resources, investment, and effort required to close the gap may pose significant challenges.

[@cepipakistan]

👍👍

[@ishtiaqueahmed8358]

Great

[@cepipakistan]

Please WhatsApp on 0321-1114880 for registration and fee details!