What Makes Jim Croce’s Operator So Unique

[@peggymuehleisenstahlin8106]

Tears streaming as I listen to your commentary. Knowing that you have recognized our brother Maury’s musical talent is heartwarming. It’s 49 years now and the memories are like an unbelievable yesterday. Thank you for remembering and honoring their lives.

[@lee.suabedissen2156]

Well said! This is a wonderful video and tribute. This is one of my favorites.

[@dell5gibson]

I am so sorry for yours, and all of our loss with your brother’s passing. He has been an influence to many. I recall being enthralled as a kid watching him play with Jim on a Midnight Special. God Bless.

[@jerroldshelton9367]

I'm sure I'm just one of billions on the planet who feel this way, but here it goes....... Your brother is the reason I took up the guitar in 1980 and have been playing it ever since. I saw him play an Ovation Balladeer guitar on T.V. when I was a boy and so, when I was 15, I was beyond happy when there was a guitar just like the one your brother played on that program under the Christmas Tree. He was, is, and ALWAYS will be my personal "guitar hero." I could say he was an "inspiration" and still is, but "inspiration" seems so inadequate in describing what your brother's music meant to me, still means to me, and will always mean to me. I listen to "Gingerbreadd" and it sounds just as awesome and just as fresh fifty years on as it did when I first heard it as a seven year old kid.

[@pattih7]

God bless you and the families of these artists! They gave voice to our emotions and helped form our youth! Still brings back pain of years gone by, but there was euphoria in the mix, as well! 💞💕💖

[@63002]

Great memories and after all this x I'm still sorry for yours and the world's loss.

[@BlueSun4886]

I too was crying through the entire commentary. Before Jim Croce ever recorded, I was a friend of his and his wife, Ingrid's. I was 5 or so years younger, a folk guitar accompanist (I still play at 75) and part of a group who used to meet at Jim's old white farmhouse near Lindell (IIRC), in the western exurbs of Philadelphia around 1970. We'd sit around on the lawn drinking beer, playing guitars, singing traditional songs & some of Jim & Ingrid's earliest works (see his album "Jim & Ingrid Croce" from the late '60s for these) & having the time of our lives. Everybody could see that, if he ever got his break, Jim was going to be something extra special in the folk world. The songs that he had already written were among the best I've ever heard with "Operator (That's Not the Way it Feels)" in the #1 position ("Operator" was officially listed as written in 1972, but Jim recorded it on singles as early as the mid-60s). I have always loved the way Jim & Maury blended their guitar styles to the point where 1 + 1 was so much greater than 2. They combined to blend all of the best of Martin guitars' low & high ranges. I'd love to see you analyze "Time in a Bottle" (which reached #1 on the charts posthumously), another song I simply can't listen to without crying. Play it all the way through before you start to dissect it for its full effect. The thought of all that Jim and Maury missed in life that should have been their time to shine to the world is tragic. It is always crushing to lose a friend, but to see Jim & his brilliance, along with Maury's, which sadly passed almost unnoticed outside of the musician world) resurrected 5 decades later is a remarkable synthesis of Joy and Sadness. Thank you for rediscovering Jim's "Operator," one of the all-time most moving songs I've ever heard. Perhaps the perfect song. BTW, not only did Ingrid perform herself for a number of years before opening her restaurant in California, but Jim's son, A. J. does remarkable covers of his father's songs.

[@dlbstl]

Wow! Thank you for this remembrance. He was a blessing, and I bet you were a blessing and light in his life too.

[@Sabe53]

This song hits home with me so hard. Had same experience when I was in my teens, twenties. I'm 70 now and still miss her SO MUCH!

[@robertocosta7736]

Que privilégio ter sido amigo dele ! Naquela época não existia internet, por isso demorei anos para conhecer o rosto do cantor que com sua música embalou o meu e milhares de corações no mundo. Tenho essa música no pendrive do meu carro. Ouço sempre. Brasil !

[@kevintaal4616]

What a privilege to have been their friend! ❤

[@nharry9763]

I love the Jim and Ingrid album…’Age’ is my favorite

[@Souzawrites]

I saw his son in concert last year and he explained where this song came from. His father was in the army stationed at Fort Dix, and when the soldiers had free time, they'd line up at the only pay phone on base to wait their turn to call home to talk to their girls. While he waited for his turn, he heard one side of tragedies playing out before his eyes as soldier's girls moved on while they were away. As a song writer, he realized it was pure gold.

[@hatdrummer]

I believe his son became a jazz pianist and he and his mom, Jim's widow had a Jazz Club in the gas light district of San Diego.. I want there once.. I just stopped in.. But when you saw his son, did he play his dad's version, his own? A jazz version? Was he at the piano?

[@katjayurschak7039]

I think that story also appeared in VH1's "Behind the Music" episode on Jim back in the 90s. The other things I remember being mentioned there was that the "You can keep the dime" comment was a little bit of dark humor being thrown in - after all, the operator doesn't personally get the dime nor is the phone going to return it after the connection was made!

[@TimTheMusicMan]

What make guitar is Rick playing ?

[@392HEMI32]

Yep … I saw AJ Croce last month … and he told the same story about the origin of his father’s “Operator”

[@cyc4usa706]

@@TimTheMusicMan Gibson

[@kevingreen6939]

This song has always murdered me. Croce was able to communicate what the rest of us can only feel. Brilliant.

[@School-Of-Thought]

Wow. Perfectly said 👏

[@marksc1929]

Rick I hate to admit it … but every single time this masterpiece of a tune comes on … someone starts chopping onions 🥲

[@snap403]

They’re chopping in my house also.

[@marksc1929]

@@snap403 😰

[@snap403]

@@thomastimlin1724 Agreed, his songs remind me of family, trips in old cars in northern Michigan and both good and sad times. Love his music.

[@marksc1929]

@@snap403 that’s great .. My homes in the south.. but it seems we all have the same things going on , ultimately .

[@brianlane9534]

Even while watching this video.

[@mhsewbiz]

I'm 78 years old, and a former telephone and directory assistance operator, mostly all-night shift. Loved it! Every time I hear this song, he is singing to me! I can so relate to this! ♥ Such a classic and clever song!

[@helmutsecke3529]

Mum were an old school Lily Tomlin type telephone operator ... 😢

[@mhsewbiz]

@@helmutsecke3529 I started out on cord board, loved it!

[@aliciawilson9799]

Great video of a great song of maybe the best singer/songwriter the Bossman, Jim Croce. I really like "I Got A Name" but I don't think Croce wrote that one. Although he certainly made it his when he sang it. TY so much for this video

[@rickyrudd28texacohavolinef2]

My mom is 75 & was a long distance operator back in the late sixties. She said dudes would ask her out on dates. She always turned them down. She was already married to my dad at the time. Lol

[@brianeastman3547]

Keep up the good spirits ✨ man, Rest in Peace Jim Croce

[@pentaholicproductions5468]

i’m a 17 year old girl and i’ve had a strong emotional connection to Jim Croce’s music ever since last year. he’s gotten me through hard times 🤍 young people can totally connect to older music although the lyrics may describe a world we can’t fully relate to, the emotions held in the music transcends the barriers :)

[@theghosttourmusic7156]

Your post gives me hope for the future!

[@RowlandGosling]

So glad you posted this! Yes! It doesn't matter what age you are, pain is pain and his music is timeless.

[@leonardodalongisland]

GREAT to know someone your age knows about and likes anything from times before you arrived on this planet. Keep up the good work.

[@SterlingJames]

I’m a Gen Xr and it’s refreshing to hear such a young person enjoy a timeless classic. And, thank you Rick/Mary.

[@SyntagmaStation]

❤

[@ferdiremo]

Jim is just like a shooting star. A short burst of amazing that left us wanting for more.

[@anniejacs5750]

Love this.

[@kathywolf3575]

Wow, that encapsulates it.

[@deang8017]

I'm 33, and have never used a payphone and this song is still more relatable than 99% of what gets written these days.

[@butlerdawgs78]

@@A.L.75 I'm 32 and we were definitely born at an interesting time. Had some exposure to the "pre tech" era when I was younger, didn't have my first cell phone until I was 15 either. There was a pay phone at the bowling alley, etc. We pranked some poor guy named Frank Moscow we found in the phone book relentlessly lol. Another song I'll throw into the ring is "Callin Baton Rouge" by Garth Brooks... also payphone related haha

[@FlashCadallic]

I can still hear the cling cling sound when you drop a dime in.

[@TedBilk]

music is relatable its just not relateable to you anymore

[@savvymegs675]

Damn. 33 also haven't?? 37 and I guess I really was born on a cusp!

[@420Gold]

I’m 32 and remember using a pay phone a few times as a kid. I think it was quarters by that time though, not dimes. There’s actually an old, completely broken and disconnected pay phone right next to my apartment lol

[@garrett2980]

Jim Croce was such a phenomenal songwriter because he could make meaningful and deep emotional connections with the listener with conversational diction while being musically fluid yet deceptively complicated. I always recommend him to others in my generation (Millennials), hoping they will take the time to truly listen and appreciate his music.

[@thesisypheanjournal1271]

Yeah, my daughter's like, "Check this song out, Mom!" She plays "Sweet But Psycho." I sigh and cue up Billy Joel's "Stiletto" and mutter, "The crap you kids listen to nowadays."

[@Darkkfated]

This song and "I've Got a Name" give me goosebumps every time, no matter how much I listen to them. Just phenomenal lyricism.

[@robertsmith4019]

The other thing about Croce's lyrics, is that the story they tell unfolds in such a way that the lyrics are easy to remember.

[@mikegillettify]

I had a group of great friends in High School (graduated in 2005) and we all listened to 70s folk like Croce, Taylor, King, Cat Steven’s, Joni Mitchell, etc. The lyrics were just so… fantastic. Timeless even.

[@matthewtayloryowieresearch1912]

Millennials & the current generation will neglect this 'old school' music at their peril, theoretical musical ignorance & no small emotional cost. Much of the greatest blues is from the 1920-30's, rock & R&B from 1955-2000 is at it's artistic apogee - the vast majority of work is superior to that of most music post 2000-2022. Just my 2cents; u rock Rick🤘& you're a livin' doll Miss Mary❣. Curmudgeonly guitarcheopteryx & guitarcheologist since '79. Oz.🪃

[@alanclayton9277]

I love the way Mary slips in the vocal, in a seemingly casual way...and it's heaven.

[@ralfklonowski3740]

So it is🥰

[@davidanderson4091]

My goodness, I know its only tube quality audio, but I can really hear how smooth Mary's voice is.

[@ralfklonowski3740]

@@davidanderson4091 Like warm almond oil.

[@Inequities]

who does she sound like? her voice is magical

[@alanclayton9277]

@@Inequities Good question, I don't know but she's a game changer.

[@snausages43]

I've listened to this song hundreds of times, but still every single time the "you can keep the dime..." line gives me the feels.

[@mrmojorisin8752]

It’s the one time, the only time, his voice sorta breaks. Very powerful.

[@WendelltheSongwriter]

On the 25th anniversary of the song, Martin guitars issued a d-28 Martin that had instead of a pearl inlay in the fretboard, the guitar had a 1973 dime

[@ralex3697]

This song still makes me teary eyed, especially when he says, there’s something in my eyes. It’s a masterpiece, they don’t write them like this anymore. Jim Croce was a legend, what a tragic ending to a beautiful soul. Gut wrenching.

[@jazztime7186]

Mary Spender in this video is wonderful, but when she said it was revolutionary for a man to be singing about having tears in his eyes in the 1970s, I thought "she hasn't listened to much George Jones music". And the telescoping of a whole story into 2-3 lines of a verse is something that happens in the best Nashville songwriting (as Rick of all people should know, having been a Nashville songwriter for a time). All that said, this is an exceptional song by Nashville or any standards, and Croce married that older style of story song lyric writing with a very contemporary folk-pop sound that sets him apart from the world of country songwriting.

[@ZoydWheeler]

You know, it happens, every time

[@kevinlurker1]

Jim deserves incredible accolades for his gift of word. Storytellers always got to me. The complexity that comes out of a few well placed words, open up a canvas for your own mind to paint. That's a rare gift. Just look at how Rick and Mary react. They know!

[@KieranJBoyle]

If he'd been around some class songs 100%

[@oscardiggs246]

As a huge Croce fan, I need a cover album of his hits sung by Mary. Such a gorgeous voice for this material.

[@ralex3697]

@@A.L.75 Go check him out, he was a brilliant talent. Died tragically in a plane crash.

[@awboat]

@@A.L.75 There is a really good documentary about him floating around. Check it out. He is an amazing person.

[@chrisbrown6544]

Agreed - Mary please think about doing a cover album of his songs 🙏

[@markstandohar5977]

The World hasn’t heard me sing this song yet, hopefully soon 🔜

[@AnthonyL0401]

"There's something in my eye... you know it happens every time I think about the love that I thought would save me" What a sad yet relatable line. Great analysis, Mary and Rick.

[@Grindstaff09]

Super powerful

[@timpike1976]

So there are at least two people who appreciate this exceptional song as much as I do! My take on the lyrics has always been that he never intended to complete the call in the first place; he just wanted to pour his heart out to a disinterested party - one who wouldn't tell him where he went wrong or how he was better off without her, but someone who would just listen. Been there.

[@donh4330]

Well said!

[@leonardkurtz1383]

100% agree!

[@rgc1961]

A great take on a great song!

[@Siskos-pn7nd]

I like your take, Jim Croce was unique among songwriters and great guitar player, his sidekick complimented him as only he could. Great duo. I guess you have to be old to appreciate it, and experience some familiar emotion. I am proud to be a 77yo songwriter who admires other musicians.

[@timpike1976]

@Siskos-pn7nd Yes sir. The music he left behind in his short career is a national treasure.

[@joelpanetta4449]

One of the GREATEST songs ever written. Jim's writing & Maury's guitar was just incredible.

[@BenMJay]

I liked his voice.

[@daveowens271]

I think this quick chords changes are indicative of the narrator's feelings about the whole situation. Genius songwriting. Absolutely brilliant.

[@michellemichon]

I attended A.J. Croce's concert last night. What a wonderful storyteller & entertainer he is. We all laughed, cried & sang along to the songs. It was a magical night. Extra appreciation for your video. LOVE

[@sarradet]

There is more to this story. Jim's inspiration came from this time in the army in the 1960s. I served in the 80s and it was the same. There were pay phones near the barracks and soldiers would line up for their turn calling home to talk to their parents, wives, and girlfriends. That "old friend" Ray had the universal name of "Jody" among soldiers and he was the guy who would steal your girl while you were away. We even had cadences we sang while running and marching about what we would do to "Jody" when we got back home. Many times, the soldier found out during one of these not so private phone calls and the other soldiers in the line could hear enough to know that Jody has struck again. Any soldier who served before cell phones can identify with this part of military service. I recall an interview Croce gave where he explained all this as his inspiration for Operator.

[@sonny_toronto]

There is a youtube vid of Jim's son playing the song and explaining the time Jim saw this happen.

[@francavable]

I went through Basic in 2008 at Ft. Knox. We still lined up to use the payphone then.

[@josemagurascier]

Thank you Rick and Mary!!! You chose the perfect song for me. Exceptional emotional comments and also those tricky little chord changes.❤

[@cdub9416]

This is probably one of the most underrated songs in history. The guitar parts are unbelievable and the story is so well told.

[@J__C__]

And underrated is one of the most overused words in the music community. You can find people who think ANYONE is underrated. Doesn't matter who it is. Someone thinks they're underrated. You see it nonstop in the comments. They look just like yours. "so & so is sooo underrated" even though they're in the R&R Hall of Fame, they're on every Top 100 list, etc... For example, Dickey Betts of the Allman Brothers Band. People constantly say he's underrated yet he's consistently considered one of the greatest guitarists that ever lived and even Duane Allman said Dickey was better than he was. Maybe in the 80s he was underrated but today, Dickey gets all of recognition he rightly deserves.

[@cdub9416]

@@J__C__ Both are underrated

[@ChristianSmith-zf9tv]

@@J__C__dicky was for sure not better than Duane, especially before he died. That was just him being humble

[@SpikeG571]

​@@J__C__I get your point but objectively, Maury Muehleisen IS legitimately under-rated. In fact he's virtually unremembered and little known considering he was one of the smoothest guitarists ever to play in that style. He likely would be legendary today but for that tragedy.

[@kathywolf3575]

I was a 22 year old Jim Croce fan, knew all the lyrics, sang the songs all the time. I don't think the song "Operator" was underrated. But I'm sure Maury was underrated by the vast majority of those singing along. I didn't even know who he was. Now I do. @@SpikeG571

[@rogerwales5374]

Congratulations Mary and Rick, an absolutely outstanding and significant analysis of one of the greatest lyricists. I am a 77 year old guitarist, and I must say that the admiration and care you brought to this presentation put something in my eye. Please keep up the excellent work, you make a great team, we need more of this type of format. Thank you.

[@schtepke]

very well put. nothing to add ...

[@mickeyneal6374]

66 years old and been listening to this song for years. It still gets me. Goosebumps and tears. What a song. Great respect for your analysis and the respect you show the music.

[@JH-fz3hc]

'Operator' is one of the greatest examples of storytelling in a song.

[@rocconorth]

JIm Croce and Harry Chapin as well. Two great story-teller songwriters who died tragically in violent, accidental ways.

[@jostauffer6637]

@@rocconorthAnd John Denver, although his body of work was more complete

[@thewalkermuseum]

@@jostauffer6637 Love Denver, but many years ago, when I found out he didn't write "Country Roads," my perspective on him changed. Supposedly he had a hand in the bridge but the main song was already written.

[@LMacNeill]

This is why I love this channel *SO MUCH!* You take apart songs that I've heard literally hundreds, if not thousands, of times, and make me see something new in them. Every. Single. Time. It's a gift, man. Really wonderful!

[@WitchKing99]

And then there are people like me who love Rick's channel because we get introduced to awesome songs that we never heard before! :D

[@fablenewsnetwork7223]

Absolutely 🥁🥁🥁

[@johnhayes1641]

Mary's voice is such a great fit for that song. Beautifully done. Croce was a Philly guy, where I grew up, and still a local hero.

[@davedechants2956]

The joy on her face when singing along is awesome! That’s exactly how this music makes me feel! ❤❤❤

[@bradwitt7190]

I was at his last concert at Northwestern State University in Natchitoches, Louisiana. Such a solid performance that night, the singing, guitar playing, harmony... all of it. He did "I got A Name" which was released the next day. Such a full life, productively, in such a short time span. One of a kind.

[@NathanBentleyDance]

What a treasure of a memory, bless you!

[@DanEdelen]

“I Got a Name” is one of those songs that can’t not make the listener feel better about life. It’s a pick-me-up when I’m down, because there is so much winsome joy in it. Sadly, it also reminds us of what we lost with Croce’s untimely death.

[@john564holloway]

@@DanEdelen Said very well & precisely.

[@billobrien5140]

I saw Jim Croce in Detroit in August [Pine Knob] and he died in October. I was young and saw him from the top of the hill.

[@brentposs333]

Wow. You saw that last show. So amazing and sad. One of my all time faves. He died when I was 1. 😢

[@Opeckie]

In my opinion, this song should be the introduction to EVERY songwriting 101 class. Everything about it is just so perfect! Sorry I'm 3 months late to the party on this video, but I'm so glad you two did this! What a gift Jim gave us!

[@wannenburgwannenburg3695]

Probably way over the head of anyone doing a 101 course. Might be more appropriate for a 301 course

[@judsonkr]

Way more advanced than 101 Level. Should prolly save it for the 301 level.

[@mikedkc]

I’m 68 and you two have helped me appreciate this song even more than I have for the last 50 years. Your analysis took it to another level. Thank you.

[@roadglideusmc]

Agree my brother. Shalom

[@davidharris8658]

In the story, he lost his best friend, too. What a perfect raw display of struggling with grief.

[@williamrittelmann8338]

Such a great song. The upbeat melody is the musical equivalent of the exterior facade that he is conveying in the first verse. His true feelings are revealed more with each verse until we learn that he has tried to call on many occasions but can’t bring himself to accept what happened and he really just needs to tell someone how he is feeling.

[@eddiereece5050]

Excellent commentary

[@lukeaway]

Mary and Rick... you should release your version of this song. Wonderful chemistry and yet allegiance to the original. Love it.

[@thomasd9395]

Im so glad to see Jim Croce being recognized today .The object of all musicians is to make a connection with the listener . This is what Jim does so well . He writes as he speaks and the chords create the feeling that the words express . I never heard a Croce song I didn't like , all his songs tell a story and are expressive of the feelings that reach the listener . Keep on truckin Rick B.

[@chrisgirth7373]

One of my all time favorite songs. I have sat and contemplated the lyrics to this song. His cadence and conversation with himself is unparalleled songwriting. Unsung hero of this song is Maury. Could listen to this a million times and never get sick of it.

[@rickpaul4216]

Jim could have won an academy award for his vocal performance on this song. His delivery is upbeat but no one is buying it, and that’s intentional. “I only wish my words could convince myself.” Is the theme here. He’s incredibly sad and acting upbeat. It is absolutely perfect. His “I’m okay” act gets less and less convincing as the song goes on. His voice takes on more agitation, and then finally sadness. I’ve never heard a more perfect lyrical interpretation and he made it sound effortless. Breathtaking.

[@cindyknudson2715]

Agreed. Exactly.

[@stevewindisch7400]

Warning: Even after 30-40 years this song could make you cry... long after you have overcome the blow. Brilliant. A showcase example of what music can do to, and for us.

[@patrickbell5086]

Especially knowing Jim’s life was cut so tragically short…

[@jjacoby1010]

Yes, and I've Got a Name and Time in a Bottle make me cry often as well

[@gitaaa7740]

Do you think people 40 years from now will be lamenting over a Justin Bieber song? I don’t think so!

[@vincentleone4021]

Close to 50 years actually 1972 so 50 years. Trying to make people 10 years younger

[@alexanderwes5204]

@@gitaaa7740 😂

[@chrisazar9545]

There was no Jim without Maury. Great song writer, great guitar backing. Outstanding time to grow up.

[@shldnfr]

What a great team they made.

[@sharongaskell]

We were so lucky

[@whiplash_pants]

Im so envious of those who experienced this magnificent team while it was happening. Tears, chills, laughs …all the emotions come through on their songs

[@Jalleur14325]

Yes indeed, I think magic with music almost always happens with the chemistry of two souls connecting

[@The1rockerman]

I respectfully disagree....Jim actually used to back up Maury in his band when he first started out, and although they were a team, Jim was the star. I've often said if that plane had not gone down, people today would be saying "Simon and WHO?" God speed my friend.

[@ricklerch5339]

Rick Beato and Mary Spender, a songwriting tour de force. Rick discussing song structure and style, and Mary discussing the emotion invoked by lyrics and vocalization. They could teach a class… Outstanding content!

[@DanEdelen]

Few musicians who died tragically left as big a hole in music of an era as Croce. He was just getting started, just attracting fame, snd then he was gone. The loss is bigger than most of us realize. He was a quiet superstar and we were just beginning to come to grips with his genius. We were all enriched by his music, and all impoverished by his premature passing.

[@johnpjonesch]

Well said

[@karinberryman2009]

Our DJ’s were over-obsessed with their substance addicted music. They had no depth.

[@kebby8251]

I can't agree more. We lost a genius. Life isn't fair.

[@WoefulMinion]

It was even sadder than that. He had enough of traveling and was retiring from touring after a few more shows when he lost his life. He hoped to spend more time with his wife and son.

[@willfeen]

how did Jim Croce die?

[@ptrelc]

10:28 the depth of the singer’s tragedy is revealed in the line, “I think about a love that I thought would save me.” Thus, rather than overcoming the blow, he is interminably devastated by the loss of someone who was to be his savior. The upbeat melody aligns with the facade of recovery found in the lyric. This facade and its aligned melody make the listener’s discovery of the real meaning, all the more jolting. The song is a masterpiece.

[@georgebeierberkeley]

You took the thoughts right of my head. He’s still holding on, thinking of the life that could have been. A falsely cheery melody masking his pain.

[@garyneilson3075]

Yes!

[@brahmburgers]

akin to Doobie Brother's; What A Fool Believes, another great song, ...or... You Don't Know Me.

[@Fnipernackle]

The fact that Croce could play this complicated song but sing it in such a way shows just how great of a musician he truly was.

[@milamba]

He couldnt't play them - that was Maury.

[@jp022x]

​@@milambaJim played all the rhythm parts. Maury's lead parts are fantastic but Jim's rhythm playing is great and can be complicated, especially in this song. Singing on top of it is impressive.

[@zingzangspillip1]

@@milamba There is a really good live recording on KZbin of Jim & Maury performing this song together. Jim is playing rhythm.

[@deadpan80]

Jim was a pretty good player, but Maury does all the heavy lifting

[@tommack9395]

It's actually the duo between him and Maury which fills out the song... many people don't realize when you have multiple instruments they're layering to create the entire piece of what a listener is hearing. That's not to take away from Jim but what you're listening to are two guys playing really well in-sync but different parts. You may write a good or even just a decent song... but how it's presented and performed may make it a great song. i.e. Paul McCartney once said George Harrison's fills, licks and solos were the icing on the cake in most all the early Beatle songs they'd recorded... iow when they went in with an idea - for a song - they're not really written down most are winged in off the cuff - just made up on the spot and fit in well. Like any conversation with someone you know really well, when playing with someone long enough and mesh well it's like you know where each other are going. In a nut-shell, To be a good musician it takes playing with good musicians to become good at it.

[@jimmonia3962]

Both your commentaries and musical analyses are so moving as the song. This is my favorite video today.🎉❤

[@wesplybon9510]

Croce, in his very short career, set himself up next to the other great lyricists of the era like Gordon Lightfoot and Simon and Garfunkel. His ability to craft an environment and emotion succinctly and creatively was truly masterful.

[@fornostios8970]

Don't forget Bob Dylan!

[@bwat9365]

Wonderful description, your last sentence 👏🏿

[@safal4823]

Try where do you go to my lovely by peter sarstedt.Its in my playlist just after this song and also same level of songwriting with mindblowing verse at last

[@TimTim3000]

I would put J.D. Souther up there as well.

[@kodykindhart5644]

That’s why they all call big Jim boss

[@jefferyetheridge5287]

I still get teary eyed listening to some of Jim's songs. In my opinion, Time in a bottle is one of the greatest songs ever written. We lost an amazing human being, artist, singer-songwriter. His legacy goes on through his family, his music, and his fans. The world needs more people like Jim. Thank you Rick and Mary.

[@BRNRDNCK]

Time in a Bottle is arguably the greatest song of all time.

[@ShadRick2]

Jim Croce has always been my favourite singer songwriter. You guys had me in tears just listening closely to the lyrics. This man sang from his heart and soul, sorely missed.

[@ManduRugas-oe4kv]

He was a very good story teller, thats the reason for the many quick changes in chords, talking in melodies😊

[@steveturner7049]

I think Mary needs to record this tune. Her voice fits the song like a glove.

[@kengibson402]

For real!

[@davidpoche6715]

Wow! I'm in heaven. Two of my favorite KZbinrs talking about one of my all-time favorite song writers. I was 21 and in college when Jim Croce died. You guys were wonderful and I learned a lot from this video.😍

[@sesimie]

This is a major reason i don't listen to newer music. I want to hear songs that take me on a journey...or tells a story. We are over saturated with Beats. The older I get (44) the less I'm impressed by technical brilliance and the more i'm into the lasting memories. Mary Spender is a Treasure!

[@noelgonzalez9549]

Nuff said. As a 49 yr old myself - 100,000% agree.

[@Paul-D-Hoff]

Grace VanderWaal.

[@mwfmtnman]

Just like the rest of our society has become, all flash, no substance

[@Paul-D-Hoff]

@@mwfmtnman Grace VanderWaal

[@lisaspikes4291]

Yes. And it’s something that practically everyone can relate to. We’ve all been dumped at one time or another. We know, deep down, that we’ll get over it eventually. But while it’s happening, it’s very devastating. It feels like nothing will ever be good again. Doesn’t it?

[@justingreer4001]

Mary singing in that low register sounds so good! Rick you are no hack at anything you’ve played ever! Talented and fun to watch as always.

[@debbieboyd7457]

Going flat never sounded so good

[@milesfrommission]

The really poetic thing about this song is how the "operator" is the only one who hears his struggle between sadness and acceptance. In the face of the operator's absolute stoicism he forgoes his effort to reach out, his tenuous acceptance yields to his profound sadness. It's as if he's speaking to the Oracle at Delphi, to whom he leaves his dime offering. Maury's upper register embellishments make the melody.

[@marieroberts5458]

Ok, I just have to hand it to you. ... "Oracle at Delphi" is just brilliant! A perfect summation.

[@brunojaysutter]

Miles if I work for a Rolling Stone magazine, and needed a reviewer, I’d say you’re hired

[@l.alexander4696]

Spot on

[@imout671]

Dang, going all mike row on us

[@jamie49868]

Yeah, it's sad that we can openly and expressively tell our feeling to strangers yet find it impossible to tell them to who they are meant for. Rejection is a bitch.

[@raytull3922]

OMG!!! You & Mary should do this way more often. Amazing chemistry! I'd be good with weekly, but monthly is probably closer to realistic.

[@omhr9554]

@@shaharbar 🤣

[@gamer9]

@@shaharbar 🤢

[@davelindstrom6005]

Not only the great chemistry they have, but she's MUCH prettier (LOL) and she can actually SING (seriously). Just saying.

[@jpkatz1435]

She is stepping into her starpower.

[@hawnyfox3411]

' @@davelindstrom6005 = Also, hasn't Mary just got THE most beautiful speaking voice ? .

[@BMT3691]

Jim was one of kind talent. The way he translated the emotion or pain in his songs made you feel the heartbreak. I can listen to his music 24/7, and it never gets tiring. RIP Jim, RIP.

[@andykase]

I would immediately purchase these two doing a complete studio remake of this song.

[@Jerry_England1]

Great job guys! One of the first tunes I learned on guitar. Jim’s widow Ingrid said that when Jim was in the military the soldiers would line up to use the phone to call their wives and girlfriends and Jim took little tidbits that he overheard. Lots of dear John conversations. He took these bits and along with poetic license, he crafted a heartbreakingly beautiful song. Martin produced a Jim Croce signature guitar with a 1973 dime for the 3rd fret marker. Wonderful idea and tribute.

[@robbchastain3036]

The Army was an incredible gathering place, all those soldiers and all their lives and stories. And I like how Jim told his Army stories, it was like being in the barracks with everyone missing home and their ladies.

[@stephenpeterson7940]

One of the first songs I learned as well. Still love it.

[@5roundsrapid263]

@@robbchastain3036 I never knew Jim was in the service. My father was also in the Army about that time. I can definitely see the similarities.

[@robbchastain3036]

@@5roundsrapid263 O for sure, check out here on KZbin a video of Jim on stage where he is telling the story about bad, bad Leroy Brown at Ft. Jackson in South Carolina.

[@toddmcintosh83]

@@5roundsrapid263 Jim would often wear his long sleeved army fatigues shirt when performing.😉👌😎

[@keithsparbanie2108]

Jim Croce. Yes. I’m 63. We all had his three albums plus the hits package, “Photographs and Memories.” So talented. Brilliant. Even if we were rockers into the Stones, The Who, Led Zeppelin, Deep Purple, and Black Sabbath… we were also fans of Croce.

[@juliuswilliams4581]

So true Keith.👍

[@guywerry6614]

Agreed. I'm a rural Canadian guy whose soundtrack was heavily Beach Boys, BTO (Bachman Turner Overdrive), the Guess Who, the Stones ... but Croce and Gordon Lightfoot were also heavily in there, singing the "counterpoint", if you will, to the primary soundtrack.

[@UlisesTroyoB]

You are so right, Keith.

[@hubechen4982]

I love Jim croce songs..great songwriter and so many great songs which I do sing along and never tire .

[@coldcoffeebear7459]

You said it all.

[@larisonjohnson]

One of the first vinyl records I ever had as a kid. This song rips me open every time I hear it. Having you and Mary break this song down is simply a beautiful moment. This song seems to age like wine, and just gets better every time I listen. Jim Croce was just one of those people who was gifted with unbelievable talent and then taken from us far to soon. ❤ 🙏

[@micheleparker3780]

Me 😪😭😢

[@rendyandrian7149]

@Hyper Virtualist thx for the info. I almost believe it and then remember another channel reminds me of scammer looking for victim. Your comment makes me 100% sure its a scammer.

[@Bb-M4n]

@@rendyandrian7149 These bots are taking over so many youtube channels - not just Rick's - So annoying, but just ignore and move on

[@endermwatts]

You can also report the bots. Just click the three vertical dots at the right of their comment the select Report and then select the top option that says something about spam.

[@micheleparker3780]

I was referring to this way the song makes me feel. I know that message above mine is a bot. But thank yal'll anyway!!😁💖

[@howardlevinger4571]

Thank you, Rick, for this anatomy and the memories. I sat not fifteen feet from the stage when Jim sang this song at the Philadelphia Folk Festival, August 25, 1973. It was wonderful! And then, not a month later, to hear the mournful news that he and his bandmates were killed in that crash. I feel no less shocked today as I was then. But his music and poetry live on.

[@beekeeper63]

I would love to sit in a room all day and talk about music with these two people. The love of great songwriting. So glad that they honored this masterpiece.

[@YouMeAndAnAlbum]

I just realized watching this video that Jim Croce was the only musical artist that my whole family listened to and liked when I was growing up. My dad was into opera, my mom liked show tunes and my sister and I listened to top 40. But I remember all of us listening to Jim Croce together and enjoying his songs. Which makes this video even more emotional for me than it already is.

[@jim87vette]

I lost my father recently and we use to listen to this song together. It sure did pull on my heart strings in multiple directions, listening to this with you two. Thank you.

[@kipponi]

Yeah keep those gold memories. I lost my wife last year and I remembering songs we used to listen and sing.

[@gianfrancodefrancesco7117]

Rick, haven't seen all your videos but many, but this one is so poetical and digging so profound in our loved memories. This is really a special gift. Thank you.

[@robincochran7369]

Jim and Maury were both very talented individually but together were magic. Such a loss, RIP.

[@joemurray6750]

My god man, if you do more videos like this, I may never leave the house again. What an amazing break down. LOVE THIS ONE!!

[@Salty_Knuckles]

I agree with Joe here. I think you’re onto something. Lyrics breakdown is a whole cool thing that could take off for this channel. I’ll be looking for more.

[@Hindsight04]

I’m 18 years old and he is my favorite artist by far. I love his whole discography from Facets to the home recordings album in 2003, a year i wasn’t even born in yet lol. My friends all poke fun because i listen to Jim Croce and Bread, but I couldn’t think of anything else I’d want to listen to more!

[@jeffj318]

What a wonderful comment. My friends laughed at me when I played Bob Dylan's first album. You have good taste in music.

[@shaun374]

Thank you!

[@brahmburgers]

Try Los Lobos, or Michael McDonald with the Doobie Brothers.

[@valiantclapper4872]

I called up "time in a bottle" on youtube and decided to also check out your discussion of "operator". Thank you for your sensitive discussion of a poignant lyric. The abrupt "you can keep the dime" ending also seems to imply that the reason for calling the operator was more about having had the need to talk to someone about his heartache; to be listened to for a minute rather than to listen. Maybe reminiscent of Sinatra bending the ear of a bartender at 02h45 on the premise that said bartender, Joe, will remain true to his code. Powerful lyrics, deep and meaningful poetry. I still have the vynal, but always ran to "time in a bottle", with a relatively cursory listen to "operator" You and Mary's discussion compels me to listen and appreciate Jim Croce again. Btw - thank you, also, for an awesome interview with Keith Jarrett.

[@rickhanson8709]

I was in Junior High when he died in that plane crash. I didn't know who he was at the time, but I can still see my teacher in tears on the ground just loosing it and remember wondering just who this person was that could cause such a reaction. Years later I learned just what a great artist he really was. 💔😭

[@georgeperillo6421]

I absolutely love this song and Maury's guitar fills are so well done, it's timeless magic.

[@ronaldfohner1511]

What a great video, Mary's reaction to parts of the song are priceless. This song makes me glad to have grown up in the 70's listening to these great songs.

[@mddell58]

I was 14 years old when this more-than-beautiful song came out. I couldn't help but see my sweet mother's eyes tear up, & some facial tension appeared, too. ❤ In my naive youth, I remember thinking that the 'operator' and the man calling would actually get together, run off into the gorgeous sunset together, & live happily ever after. Yes. That is exactly what I had so hoped for. ❤

[@12menos]

It’s almost like the guitar is the operator responding back through the melody. Amazing

[@drewphelps1]

I have been imagining lyrics for the operator as responses in the guitar fills.

[@jessejamesburnitt]

I always kind of felt this as well!

[@bardsimpson1404]

I'm a mostly metalhead, but I love good music from all corners. Iv been fans of Jim Croce for decades👍

[@kannonmcafee]

Me too. I love Jim Croce. Absolutely necessary in any music collection.

[@brianloy7856]

I love good hard rock, too. One of my first musical genres. Deep Purple, Black Oak Arkansas, Uriah Heep, Jimi Hendrix - I loved them all in my pre-teens and early teens. One thing I’ve learned as I’ve aged is to never limit myself to only one genre of music. I love it all except rap and traditional country (but I LOVE good Blue Grass) and I’m not much of a fan of contemporary music - today’s top 40 unless it’s musical (to me). Don’t be afraid to check out all genres of music. Paganini was the Van Halen of his day. Baroque music can have an overwhelming calming impact and is oddly satisfying. Lute music can truly be awesome (especially if you like guitar). Chet Atkins, Tommy Emmanuel, Phil Keaggy - all awesome guitarists. Keith Emerson, Rick Wakeman, John Lord, great pianists and or B3 and or keyboardists. Glenn Miller, Tommy Dorsey, Linda Ronstadt with The Nelson Riddle Orchestra (What’s New) - one of my favorite Uber high quality 5.1 surround sound DVD/Audio (If you have a 5.1 or 7.1/7.2 surround sound system and proper DVD-A, Blu-Ray, Super Audio CD players. Pink Floyd - DSOTM, Dire Straights - Brothers in Arms, Rush - Moving Pictures, Steely Dan - Babylon Sisters - ALL of these and more are MIND BLOWING in their 5.1 DVD-A, Blu-Ray, or Super Audio CD versions. They are getting harder to find these days though! Don’t ever limit yourself…great music is great music. I’m listening to Pat Metheny and Lyle Mays right now. Jazz/Fusion at its finest! Jaco Pastorius! Al di Meola! I could go on and on. It’s ALL great!

[@jjfromthebigland781]

Yup. Good music is good music. We're all looking for that emotional connection...

[@sethcollins4940]

Croce is one of my all time favorite song writers and he died 5 years before I was born. I grew up listening to him and Lightfoot and all these greats from that era. Just an amazing writer.

[@rossmacdonald3880]

So glad you enjoy them both brilliant, Lightfoot just passed as you know buried not far from where I live. Croce just too young when he left is.

[@rjszrama]

And then there is Chapin

[@mytahiti1004]

They told great stories in their songs.

[@BarrackObamna]

Nah dude hes not dead he’s in Cuba with Tupac and Epstein.

[@floydthebarber9956]

Jim's "You can keep the dime" is the greatest throwaway line in rock history.

[@reneguzman2853]

for me the line " you can keep the dime" means he was just comforted to talk to someone and let out some pain,it was more then worth the dime,so he said keep it..amazing end to a amazing song

[@Grindstaff09]

​@@reneguzman2853Yes

[@BillVincent]

As others, sitting here in tears thinking about the beauty and tragedy that was Jim Croce. Thank you for taking this song and once again elevating it to your audiences. Jim, you were one of a kind. ❤

[@rickwebermusic]

Jim Croce and Maury Muehleisen were the embodiment of the most exquisite expression of lyrical content and musical composition I've ever seen. Gone too soon.

[@kvwebb777]

Indeed. Such a twist of fate. Hope they were both ready to meet God. -blessings, Keith

[@ffggddss]

@@kvwebb777 Could it be that God was a little too anxious to see them? jk. He's not selfish like a lot of us are. Fred

[@wolfhound2000]

This song and Time in a Bottle are two of my most loved songs ever. Two wonderful and unique talents that were taken way too early. The world needs more geniuses like Jim and Maury.

[@ffggddss]

@@wolfhound2000 Two excellent song choices, yes! Sometimes I find _I Got a Name_ also getting stuck in my brain. I, too, sorely miss all the songs Jim would have written, but never got the chance to.

[@nathanbannister8502]

I've listened to this song thousands of times and never fully appreciated the song like I did today. "You can keep the dime," and tears instantly welled up in my eyes. Thank you both for making me actually listen to the lyrics in a way I never did before. Keep making Rochester proud Rick! Love your channel! Thank you too Mary!

[@Inequities]

thousands of times eh? lol

[@LarryDavis-h3q]

I was in high school in the 70s and used up many a dime on a pay phone trying to get hold of my old crush who lived several miles away. For anyone who has gone through a relationship that went south, you can FEEL the emotion Jim Croce was able to put into song in such a great way!

[@joecrocco7850]

I had the privilege of seeing Jim and Maury perform live at the bottom line just months before the tragic accident that took both their lives. I sat in the first row just an arms length away from them. This performance made such an impact on me musically as a singer songwriter. What amazed me the most is how they effortlessly commanded the instrumentals and vocals live. It was a flawless performance both technically an emotionally. Thank you for doing a deep dive into the incredible artistry of his work. 👍🏻

[@thedys70]

Joe, you witnessed history there. I'm glad those short film recordings of Jim and Maury performing didn't get lost to time.

[@joecrocco7850]

@@thedys70 I feel very fortunate to have experienced that performance. Yes, those film clips are great music history. Hopefully any audio or video archives that exist will be preserved.

[@thedys70]

@@joecrocco7850 Absolutely Joe; I bought his DVD when it was first released about 15 years ago; such wonderful posterity. Great to see other lost gems appear on youtube over the years for the next generations to see his legacy to 20th century music.

[@michaeljosephmusic9977]

Thank you for analyzing this song, Rick. My dad was a huge Jim Croce fan, and I really feel in love with his music myself. I always thought the song was pretty amazing, and even more so now because my dad passed away last year. Hearing you break this song down reminds me what a masterpiece this truly is, and connects me to my dad again. I always enjoy your videos, but this one's special.

[@ludabam241]

This is why I love this channel right here. Rest In Peace Jim Croce thank you for your contributions.

[@jimmyayub]

Found this video just now and I must thank you both guys for dissecting this song for us. This made me love the song more than ever 🙂

[@theresae6071]

Thank you so much for this. I was a little girl in the 70’s. My Dad, who passed away earlier this year, loved Jim Croce. We all did❤️. This is pretty much a perfect song.

[@daviddemarco6041]

I’m grateful for content like this. I stumbled upon Rick a few years ago with “What makes this song great?” and have been hooked ever since. I always heard of Jim Croce (“It doesn’t have to be that way”) but never bothered delving into his music until this video. Since watching this video, I’ve been listening to Jim Croce everyday and I love it. He has so many truly great songs. One of the great joys in life is discovering great music. I can’t believe it took me this long. Thank you Rick!

[@BobSperber]

It took me decades to truly appreciate Jim’s talent - In the 70s I was a Zeppelin-or-nothing kid - but you two really unlocked the magic of his songwriting heart. Now have to play & sing this. Thank you so much, both of you.

[@LorenGold]

Love this so much. One of the most underrated artists of his generation. More Jim please!!

[@mikevanwyk485]

I went through a huge Jim Croce discovery period in high school, and I graduated in 1991, so his music was a little "before my time" so-to-speak. I have often described Croce's writing as that he had the ability to take 'War and Peace' and condense it into three verses and a chorus. A total and complete lyrical genius! Some of my favorite songs of his are ones that weren't even the biggest hits! He was taken from us way too soon.

[@eyesolatedrock]

Same, class of 93. At that point I had the Records, a cassette tape (Japanese export), a greatest hits CD and even an 8-track. Just recently bought them on iTunes.

[@chrisd7047]

I graduated that same year, but I knew Croce from the time I was little because my parents played mostly folk music in the house. I grew up hearing Croce, the Mamas and the Papas, CSNY, Simon & Garfunkel, and the like. The only rock albums my folks had were a couple of Beatles albums. It put me behind in recognizing pop music, but I'm thankful for the musical education it gave me.

[@eternallife9786]

All Die hard music fans should have a Jim Croce phase! he practically created his own genre!

[@eternallife9786]

@@chrisd7047 sounds like your folks had great taste in music my mom and dad was really into stuff like bluegrass Jimmy Rogers Woody Guthrie ramblin Jack Elliott a lot of that old timey folk music

[@chrisd7047]

@@eternallife9786 Mine split the difference. I got kind of pop-folk music topped off with classical training. Instead of Woodie Guthrie and Jack Elliott, I got Beethoven, Mozart, and Tchaikovsky. I could tell the difference between a bassoon and a bass clarinet, or the difference between The Nutcracker and The Marriage of Figaro by the time I was 8, but I had no idea who Michael Jackson was.

[@stevewilson134]

I am 66 and Jim Croce was and still is my favourite artist/singer/songwriter. I jhave listened to his music for decades, so much so that my 27 year old twin sons have joined me in my love for this man's timeless music. Thank you, Rick and Mary for your beautiful take on a beautiful song.

[@PlanetRockJesus]

I love this. All of the touches to the past. Matchbooks and scribbling notes on them, and a dime for a call on a phone in a phone booth. I'm 69, and this song was popular when all of these things were current.

[@charlie-obrien]

I'll bet we can all remember when a phone call went from a dime to a quarter...Yikes.

[@carolhorner7202]

I remember, matchbooks were always on the tables at wedding receptions, with the bride & groom's names, and sometimes address and phone number. I always thought that he had kept that 'souvenir' matchbook, given like a 'calling card' (also known as 'business cards'...I think we still have those).

[@charlesseymour1482]

Same with me. The sound track for my life till 37 years.

[@Erasmustherobot]

This young lady is moved to tears. It's heartwarming it speaks well of her.

[@mattiefee]

Imagine 1992 and a bunch of 12-year-old punk skateboarder troublemakers sitting around in a basement listening to this song over and over! That was me and my friends. Our parents were jaw dropped that we all love this song so much.

[@rwbullock4197]

Rick's love for the music is so infectious and even exceeds his great technical expertise. Great collaborative guest who share his passion!

[@poetsdreamsatc]

I was 13 when “Operator” came out. I still get goose bumps from the opening guitar. “Time in a Bottle” is another sad brilliantly written song. RIP Jim Croce 😢

[@HendrixFreakazoid]

"I got a name" stops me in my tracks every time I hear it

[@poetsdreamsatc]

@@HendrixFreakazoid Right???Hendrix I agree with you. I still get choked up sometimes when I hear this song too. This was the song the radio dj played then sadly said Jim Croce had just died.

[@MLFranklin]

Growing up, I loved his music. Still love it.

[@michaelraymond952]

Thank you for making this. I grew up with artists like Jim Croce and James Taylor playing in my parents’ cars and I feel grateful that I was exposed to such artful guitar playing and masterful songwriting. Please do more of this type of video and never stop working with Mary. She’s a gem.

[@Samantha-vlly]

I too listen to James Taylor, his song are like an Impressionism art.

[@AlexRodriguez-hl1vu]

Jim was the best and I loved his voice it was so pleasant

[@awboat]

Harry Chapin is a great one too.

[@NatesRandomVideo]

@@awboat Chapin was a master storyteller. Taken too soon.

[@chuckness5372]

I'm 66, and for the last 49 years I have listened to his greatest hits on an Album/8 Track/ Casset/ CD/ and now on my iPhone more than any other album I have ever known. His songs hit me so close on the lyrics. It's crazy how so many moments in my life are represented by his songs. Truly a great talent who would have reached phenomenal heights had he lived.

[@jonny-b4954]

Check out Elliott Smith. He reminds me of Jim Croce, not really in musical genre exactly, but in how their brilliant songwriters where it's really just him and his acoustic guitar. And they're both fantastic players and weave immersive stories and themes within their lyrics. Great stuff. Can't say which I love more. Croce has more upbeat melodies and Elliott Smith's song are all sad

[@gunnar1797]

29 years old and I get home to play walkin back to Georgia everyday. Jim is something else and one of a kind. Honestly tearing up seeing the respect in these comments for Jim and Maury

[@tpatrick44]

Simply Gifted…a perfect combination of music and lyrics moving the listener through the magic of it all! I cried when he died. I still tear up when I hear “Time in a Bottle.” I get goose bumps listening to the fingerpicking. RIP Jim 🙏🙌❤️