What REALLY Happened?! / Chapter 139 Ending(s)🧣 Deconstructed (Attack on Titan)

[@magnificentiPod]

When the world needed him most, he vanished, but now he’s back :)

[@MangaHorse]

I’m here 😃 👋 Recovering and ready to go 💪

[@sofiakaos5278]

good reference :)

[@handleneeds]

69th like

[@MangaHorse]

But did y’all like the video? 🥺👉👈

[@magnificentiPod]

@@MangaHorse of course!

[@FranciscoTornay]

This is simply genius! Best, most articulate presentation of the ending hands down. And among all the noise and misconceptions so many fell for, I appreciate the video even more. Totally worth the wait.

[@MangaHorse]

Thank you so much my friend! I’m so happy you enjoyed it, although it really took me a long time 🙏 I really appreciate your patience and I’m thrilled my video could add value to our community BTW, I’m back so more videos are coming 😃

[@MUHAMMADSaadKhan730]

That's a solid explanation about panel changes, memories and Alternate realities. Mikasa was a central character is all realities and Ymir was seeing her choices she makes to make alternate realities. Hiwever, Mikasa OVA reveals that no matter what she does, she can't save Eren.

[@MangaHorse]

Thank you my friend I’m happy you like the video 😊 🙏 And you are correct in her OVA it revealed she can’t really save him, and that is the case in every reality…the same in our story Her OVA falls into my theory perfectly, and I covered her condition in the breakdown video I did before that one

[@six7venbih]

Dude why didnt I found your channel before???? This is the most thecnical and acurated video about SNK ive ever watched in my entire existance! godamn mate, congratulations for the amount of detail and research on this. I cant even think of the work youve put on this. Thank you, from the depths of my little heart. Earned a eternal sub.

[@MangaHorse]

Wow that’s such a awesome comment! Thank you so much my friend, I absolutely appreciate you watching this long video and letting me know your thoughts, again it means so much to me because I really wanted to offer everyone a respectful and logical video, and super nice comments like yours make me believe I got through to people 🙏 I’m Happy you found my channel although KZbin kinda hates me🥲 And Thank you again my friend, your comment literally made me smile 😊

[@machina5]

Bro don't keep us in the dark when you're dealing with health issues

[@MangaHorse]

I’m sorry about that and thank you so much for your concern 😔 🙏 The truth is that I really didn’t know what is going on with me back then I was afraid to make promises I wouldn’t be able to keep Maybe I’ll even talk about it in a short video, if people are interested of course

[@machina5]

@@MangaHorse We're very interested. Stay safe bro

[@th3_ph4ntomreborn31]

@@MangaHorse if you want to talk about it yes

[@kartikprabhu4719]

I knew your video was gonna be a banger but it still blew my mind... Your cabin scene explanation, Eren's reason of flattening the world, Mikasa's possible connection to Ymir etc actually everything almost made me feel awe.... I hope you are doing good... Wish you good luck for your health and please keep bringing these type of videos no matter how much long you take or how long the video is

[@MangaHorse]

What a beautiful comment ❤️ Thank you so much, and I’m so happy you enjoyed it I compiled my ideas from things that personally made me emotional, so I’m really happy I could touch other people on the same level I have more vids ideas, aot related and others, and I’ll keep on creating 🤗

[@kartikprabhu4719]

@@MangaHorse yes please... It got unnecessary hate from many people(excluding some people who just want their headcannons) .... I hope your videos will be a sliver lining in the dark clouds... And I liked how you mentioned that not only Eren but everyone's fate was sealed from the start in AoT.... Most people just thought that Eren was the only person who was slave to his destiny... But it was because we/Eren saw his future.... You are the only youtuber I have seen who has mentioned this that AoT has a world like that of the movie "Predestination".... Anyways I was just excited to say this 😂😅

[@MangaHorse]

Thank you my friend! And yes, That’s why people always say you shouldn’t know your future 😉 I actually raised this fact almost 2 years ago in another video, the same one I recommended in this video, the one with the “Freedom” thumbnail And what do you think about Mikasa’s role? Did you like my Idea about her being the anchor that splits realities? It’s totally ok if you didn’t, I’m just curious 🧐

[@kartikprabhu4719]

@@MangaHorse yeah your perspective is actually very interesting... I liked it very much😁✌🤘... I think it might be the writing from Isayama too as he said that she would be the centerpiece of the story, so he might have thought about that too.... I liked it but I think that the universe doesn't create some individuals who are capable of doing that in real life... Although I want it to happen.... Aaahhhh😫... I know AoT world is a fantasy but it's so realistic that I am confused😂😂... To sum it up, I wouldn't and wouldve never considered that if you didn't mention it😁✌🤘.... I guess we have many questions to ask from Isayama😅😂

[@MangaHorse]

I will keep asking those questions…and also answer them 😅

[@madwarrior7698]

Glad to hear you're doing better! So glad you're back Manga Horse!

[@MangaHorse]

Thank you so much 😊 I’m sorry it took so long, I’m back, and I have A LOT to talk about 😉

[@madwarrior7698]

@@MangaHorse can't wait to hear it! Thank you for coming back to us 🙏🏻

[@MangaHorse]

My pleasure, thank YOU for listening to me talk about titans 😊

[@snowmanman4508]

I'm gonna be honest, I didnt like the ending at all, but I'm glad you enjoyed it. I'm even more glad your doing better now. Good to have you back!

[@MangaHorse]

Thank you so much my friend, I am doing better 🙏 😊 About the ending, That’s fine, everyone looks at it differently I will do another video about 3 major things that I disliked in AoT and that could have been better

[@NightmareCourtPictures]

i hope isayama ignores the ending haters. i thought the ending was perfect PLEAE ISAYAMA DONT CHANGE THE ENDING...its one of the best stories of all time...please isayama i beg!

[@MangaHorse]

I also hoping the ending will stay intact It was horrible AND beautiful at the same time, and I personally really appreciated it and the harsh message. Thank you for watching my video, and I hope you enjoyed it my friend 🙏

[@th3_ph4ntomreborn31]

I have waited for this video for like 2000 years

[@MangaHorse]

I know I’m so sorry for letting you all wait for so long 🙏 😭

[@lerneanlion]

After our last conversation, I decided to take a look at this video and oh my! The way how you described time and universe as separate entities got me thinking! Most of the times in nowadays, peoples often use "alternate universe" and "alternate timeline" as each other's synonym. But Attack on Titan reminded us that they are not the same! However, this also got into the way of alternate timelines that function as branches that spawn out of the original timeline of each universe as well. So I would like to see if you can reconcile the idea of "time and universe are not the same" with the idea of "alternate timelines that are originated from the original timelines as its branches" as well. Unless it is impossible to solve and can only be stated as merely a misunderstanding concept by us humans, I would like to see if it is possible or not to reconcile these two concepts. And since you basically described it as "what that is going to happen depended on what Eren seen after he kissed Historia's hand" as a way of determining the unchangable future in Attack on Titan because what the wielder of Attack Titan witnessed is considered as experiencing it as happening right at that moment, is it possible that if Eren saw the fragments of the soldiers of Survey Corps participated in the Marley Mid-East War along with the troops of the Mid-East Allied Forces, the defection of Zeke and the Anti-Marleyan Volunteers by sabotaging the battle for Marley to lose to gain the Allies' trust, Marley ended up being forced to surrender as the direct result of Paradis' intervention and the Partition of Marley by the Allies, it means these events are going to happen anyway and no matter what Marley tried to do, it will not change anything. I asked you about this because this video has finally given me the way out to explore what could have been in the certain universes in the vast multiverse of Attack on Titan since it is depending on what each Eren saw in their realities. And if you are interested, would you like to explore one of these universes with me?

[@MangaHorse]

Oh thank you my friend, I appreciate you watching and I’m happy you found it interesting About the timelines, I have a problem with calling it branches coming out of a tree because that makes them feel like “secondary” realities, which they are not, they are as real as this reality, only things there happen differently in the future but ALSO positively in the past. They have points that cross, like Eren touching Historia, but like I said and you mentioned, in each reality Eren should see something else, and yes, whatever he sees will undeniably happen in the future. And that’s why I didn’t refer to them as branches but as giat circles, all spinning while touching each other in a certain point. And I theorized that point is the Mikasa of each of those realities. For now we saw our reality, the cabin reality, and Mikasa’s OVA reality Those are the “canon” realities to explore for now

[@lerneanlion]

​@@MangaHorse Just so you know, this simply made me believe that out there in the multiverse, there are a portion of realities where Paradis joined the Allies and change courses of the histories of their worlds for the better. To say that there are none basically just stated that "enemy of my enemy is my friend" is a meaningless phrase. And there is no way that can be real. So yeah, I still believed in that. And no offesne, you seemed to be just wanting to explore the realities that have been offered to see at the moment instead for looking for more possibilities out there. Also, I do not think Mikasa has blood relations to the royal family or anything. I think it's just her Eldian bloodline from the Ackermann is being mixed with that of the Azumabito Clan that given her the immunity to other things the normal Eldians have to go through. Speaking of which, haven't you found it strange that all Eldians can be transformed into Titans? Isn't this supposed to be something limited to just the direct descendants of Ymir Fritz in the royal family? Sure, I saw a lot of princes that have beautiful female concubines. But that answered nothing at all. heck, it given more questions as why these Eldian Princes will discarded their concubines who are pregnant with their children in the first places?

[@MangaHorse]

You seem upset by my answer I never said that there isn’t a possible different realities out there I just said we only saw 3 different “canon” ones in our story You are free to believe in whatever possible scenario that may happen there. I just explained the science behind the possibility of those realities…but I never tried to actually explain them. I just addressed the 3 we were shown Mikasa is a close descendent to Ymir’s daughters … She said it herself “because of the life you created, here I now stand” And if it was simply her ackerman blood then Levi would be just like her and Ymir would have been able to contact him as well Her uniqueness comes from a certain mix that I also explained in that same video you watched and we are talking about. It’s in the Mikasa chapter

[@lerneanlion]

@@MangaHorse I am not actually upset with you. And I am sorry if you felt that way. But this is more of I see people complained this and that about the ending or even season 4 in general. I just do not like the fact that they only complained but did not try to find the solutions themselves. And when some people did it for them, they either take them as jokes or try to back the whole "Marley and the rest of the world are justified" up instead. I am sorry that I sort of lumped you together with those people. Really, I mean it. But that's my point. I don't get why people complained but do not wanted solutions sometimes.

[@ChangLU22]

Omg you’re backkkkk! I’ve been waiting for this for months!

[@MangaHorse]

hey 👋 😃 thank you so much for waiting for so long i really appreciate you coming back, and I really hope you enjoy the video

[@ChangLU22]

Thank you so much for working hard on these video! I’ve been waiting since the last chapter was released because so many people hate the ending but I enjoy it and I knew you would appreciate it. I love all the contents about AOT you made, they’re brilliant which makes me love this show even more. I hope you will make more video about AOT because I can’t get enough of it even the manga ended months ago lol. By the way, the numerology blew my mind!

[@MangaHorse]

Awww thank you so much! And I can promise you I will continue delivering AoT content, because I have a lot more to talk about 😊 Thank you for all your kind words, I’m so happy I could add some value to AoT that people actually enjoy 🙏

[@acridpunkpistol]

This was one of the best videos on AOT I've ever watched and never knew I needed to see. Bravo 👏 You've definitely earned a sub from me. I just wish I could give you more Likes as well.

[@MangaHorse]

Oh wow that’s so nice of you 🙏 And I’m so happy you found and enjoyed my video Thank you so much for all the support, more is coming soon 😊

[@MMD_16-95]

Man you deserve 1 M followers!!! It's shame that you have only 8 K

[@MangaHorse]

Thank you so much my friend, it’s so nice of you 🙏 Maybe someday it will happen 🥲

[@clauduchiha]

Seeing Eren be selfish and wanting Mikasa to himself made me so happy and love his character more, he’s just like anyone in love…. So adorable Honestly I hope you are right about the end but it all makes so much sense ❤️❤️

[@MangaHorse]

Exactly! That made his character so human-like, and that was just what I needed…I honestly don’t understand how some people can’t appreciate that. And yes I hope I’m right too, but I’m pretty sure that I am even after all this time, and I am also planning a special Mikasa video to tie everything into place 💪 And thank you so much for watching this very long video, I really appreciate it 🙏

[@darthstarfire]

Youre the reason the ending sucked. You fools just jumped the bandwagon to ship characters. And isayama that fool caved like a fat bitcch in a donut shop a week after new years.

[@JojoSmacks]

bro is killing millions of people. How can you see this as adorable. Im about to vomit by this eremika fandom

[@clauduchiha]

@@JojoSmacks lol his love for Mikasa is adorable and it’s dope to see you are triggered so easily you are gonna vomit 😂😂😂 what a lame

[@JojoSmacks]

@@clauduchiha his love for mikasa is out of nowhere. A relationship developed in 1 chapter even. Also Im going to vomit at the thought that you think a man murdering 4/5ths of society and whining about being single and not being able to get mikussy is adorable in any way. Its insane.

[@pasqualinichiara79]

Thank you so much, there are so many points I could not understand clearly just reading the manga one time, even if I can read it in Japanese. This manga speaks a lot with images nit only with words. Your explanation clarified all those points and I agreed with you in all the points, you really did a great work! The time circle explanation is perfect, and it fits perfectly to the panels flow, thank you again.

[@MangaHorse]

Aww thank you so much, that’s such a nice comment ❤️ I’m so happy I could add some value to the story for you, and if I could help you appreciate the story more or understand several issues better then I’m truly happy 😃 Thank you again for watching and for letting me know what your think 🙏 🌹

[@nausheensiddiqui8745]

Wow thanks for this , one of the most simplified version of explanation of AOT 139/ending

[@MangaHorse]

Thank you so much for watching my friend, I’m so happy you enjoyed my explanation 😊 There will be more videos analyzing it even deeper so I hope you’ll like them as well Thank you again for watching and commenting, I really appreciate it 🙏

[@MrigankSinha7]

Omg No Wayy I'm so glad that your safe and sound ;) Thanks for coming back

[@MangaHorse]

thank you for coming back! 🙏 I made you all wait a long time, so I am so happy that you waited and came back to watch and thank you, I do feel better and ready to get back to action...which means talking a lot more 😂 😉

[@EthanNuuu]

This video perfectly describes my interpretation of the story. The manga ended in a way that allowed many misinterpretations to occur, but you’ve explained my exact view on it. This video needs to be seen by anyone that was upset by the ending.

[@MangaHorse]

Awww thank you so much, I’m so happy you like it and that we share similar views of the story 😃 I wish more people would see it, maybe it will help them understand it better I knew it won’t get a lot of views because I posted it just now, but I don’t mind that, I just wanted this video to be available to the fandom

[@nausheensiddiqui8745]

50:18 the most logical explanation of see you later ch 1 panel. Thanks man, I see it was a different universe mikasa and it didn't had to be shown in the anime.

[@MangaHorse]

Thank you my friend, I’m happy I could make that more clear 🙏

[@HRM9425]

Just checked on your channel last weekend because I hadn’t seen any updates. Glad to see you back and healthy! Thank you for all of these wonderful videos.

[@MangaHorse]

I am so happy you liked it 😃 and thank you for checking up on me 🙏

[@williamflowerday3994]

Wow just wow, you’re one of easily my favourite AOT KZbinrs, this video was incredible but not only that, you cover such a specific side of the series which I feel no other KZbinrs cover such as the OVA’s, also when you mentioned the sopranos I lost it because it’s a series that comes second for me just behind attack on Titan. Overall I just want to say thanks for the effort you put into every video, not only have they been a source of entertainment but a way of seeing the type of Aot content I’ve always wanted to see but can’t find anywhere else

[@MangaHorse]

Thank you so much my friend, this is such a wonderful comment and I’m so happy you enjoyed my content 🙏 I mostly started making videos because I couldn’t find videos about the things I find interesting, so it’s so awesome yo hear you find something unique in my video. It means a lot to me and I absolutely appreciate all your love and support ❤️ And of course I have much more unique videos in line Thank you again for watching and for letting me know your thoughts

[@MangaHorse]

Thank you so much my friend, I really tried to offer a good reliable video for people who enjoyed the story as I did. Thank you for watching and commenting, it means a lot to me 🙏

[@smsprt_]

Finally I've been waiting since the release of the last chapter! I'm currently writing my speech so I might watch this later. Welcome back, Manga Horse!

[@MangaHorse]

Thank you so much my friend, And I’m really sorry i made you all wait for so long 🙏 I hope you’ll enjoy what I came up with And Good luck with writing your speech 👍

[@SabanLeon]

Had to pause it, so i finished it now :) Really nice job my man

[@MangaHorse]

I don’t blame you, what insane person makes an hour long video... 😀 👀 so thank you for watching! i really hope you enjoyed it 🙏

[@SabanLeon]

@@MangaHorse sure did :D

[@MangaHorse]

Yay!! 😃 I’m so happy to hear that

[@FaiaHalo]

I was FINALLY able to watch this because I'm finally free of my working duties and I want to THANK YOU SO MUCH for all the work you put into this.

[@MangaHorse]

Aww thank you so much for watching such a long video and for letting me know, I absolutely appreciate it ❤️🌹 And It’s my pleasure 😇 I wanted to offer a professional review for the ending, one that people can really appreciate, and I really hope you enjoyed it 🙏 I have much more to talk about, so expect more fun videos soon 😃

[@sabeetspongiinchowdhury3965]

What a wonderful video you've made! I really appreciate the depth you went into and hearing your perspective on the time loop itself and your approach to comprehending alternate reality. And again, I'm glad you took the time to take care of yourself. Cheers man!

[@MangaHorse]

thank you so much my friend, I am so happy you find my video and opinions interesting I really wanted to create a respectful and logical video review that will help our fandom, and comments like yours makes me believe I actually made it, so thank you again my friend 🙏

[@yoru6042]

FINALLY!!!!!! I missed your videos so much!!

[@MangaHorse]

Yay thank you so much for coming back 😃 I’m sorry it took so long, I really hope you’ll enjoy the video 😊

[@mustafa.abido95]

Wow , don't know what to say , i admire your effort , and more importantly , your analysis of the end of this story , thank you so much

[@MangaHorse]

Absulotly my pleasure 🙏 And thank you so much for watching such a long video. And there will be follow up videos about Mikasa and Eren coming real soon if you’re interested Thank you again for watching my friend and for letting me know your thoughts

[@WASDcrazy]

This was simply awesome and so insightful. This channel is so underrated

[@MangaHorse]

Thank you so much! I really appreciate it and I’m so happy you enjoyed my video 😊

[@guiyerod444]

Wow I was waiting for this review since the series ended and today for the release of the anime I remembered about your channel, so good to hear you are back and I hope you are in better health now.

[@MangaHorse]

Thank you so much my friend, I do feel better and ready for the new season 💪 I hope you are feeling good as well 🙏 I really hope you enjoyed this video…I made it with 150% love and respect for the story, wishing it could help more people understand and appreciate everything a bit better 🙏

[@mushroomguy5789]

Glad youre back, been checking this channel periodically as I waited for your return. Welcome back!!

[@MangaHorse]

Thank you so much my friend 🙏 I’m sorry it took me so long but I’m back and working on more vids 💪

[@ruteevora-jauad4892]

I can’t wait to watch this. I’ve been checking on your page for months to see your take. Then you suddenly came up on my Facebook the other day…glad to see you are well! ♥️♥️

[@MangaHorse]

Thank you so much for being patient and waiting for me 😊 I’m really sorry it took me so long, it’s wasn’t my choice 😔 I really hope you will like this video 🙏

[@FFSxFGR]

Welcome back, mate.

[@MangaHorse]

Thank you so much 😊 I missed talking to everyone, hope you’ll enjoy the new video 🙏

[@DorotheaKatehis]

I missed you! ❤️ So glad you’re back

[@MangaHorse]

Awwww I missed you all as well ❤️ I’m so happy to be back 🤗

[@keshavc2296]

Most satisfying vid on yt🤧 but still what about the symbiote ymir and the cordinate place

[@MangaHorse]

Thank you so much, I’m happy you enjoyed it About the Coordinates I believe I addressed it in this video 🤔 It’s basically (as I see it) the equivalent of the 4th dimension, or a place between life and death like “Limbo” When Ymir died, the organism inside her prevented her from moving on, and she was stuck in this place, like a ghost, unable to move forward and just kept doing the last thing she remembered, which was serving the royal family

[@keshavc2296]

@@MangaHorse Thanks dude ! cant believe that u actually replied btw sry for the cordinate part ,I actually missed it as the vid was an hour long (but u nailed it )

[@MangaHorse]

Of course I’ll reply 😊 If I see a comment I always respond And no problem my friend, I know it was a long one, that’s why I added chapters so people won’t get lost…and the last part of the video is about Ymir and Mikasa too Thank you again for watching and for letting me know your thoughts 🙏

[@eitantour8059]

Wow, Manga Horse returns with AOT content the same day as Kane Pixels, pretty spectacular

[@MangaHorse]

hey! how are you? 👋 😃 I’m so happy to be back 🤗

[@jacobkirk9013]

Watched this video twice it's so good, happy you're back.

[@MangaHorse]

Awww thank you so much! I could really use the views so I absolutely appreciate it my friend, and I’m so happy you enjoyed it 🙏

[@xyz_xyz575]

At the Dina scene, i feel like Armin actually stopped Eren from finishing the sentence about Bertholt's situation by gripping his hand harder, because he instantly understood what he was about to be said, so he tried to take Eren's mind away from the traumatic event. Maybe the anime will make this clear, if it's even the case. cuz i might be 100% wrong 😂

[@MangaHorse]

Yes, but I was talking about before that moment Armin asked him about the medal ceremony and then Eren started talking about how everything felt like it was happening at the same time and immediately started talking about his mom, and then armin took his hand 🤔

[@xyz_xyz575]

@@MangaHorse misunderstanding on my part then 😅😅😅

[@patu.m4384]

I am really glad I subscribed to your channel recently ...your analyses are amazing, helps me to understand much better our beloved AOT. Your theory on Mikasa makes a lot of sense. It fits to many little details in the manga. Hope you are feeling much better now...! Love from 🇹🇹

[@MangaHorse]

Thank you so much my friend, I’m so happy you like my ideas, and if I can help people understand the story better than I’m satisfied 😊 BTW, there will be more Mikasa related videos Also, I am feeling better these days, thank you for asking ❤️

[@MrSponge56]

Your accent actually makes this more enjoyable a perfect voice for narrating!

[@MangaHorse]

OMG really? This is such a nice compliment, thank you so much ☺️ I have love/hate relationship with my voice, so comments like yours really gives me the right motivation Thank you again my friend ❤️

[@Mimi_1988]

What a wonderful explanation and video!!

[@MangaHorse]

Thank you so much 😊 I’m so happy you enjoyed it, and thank you for watching and for letting me know your thoughts 🤗 🙏

[@MalcolmJones-bossjones]

I’m FINALLY watching this brother, I’m at the you are free part now and already this is one of the BEST videos you’ve ever made. Literally watching this with my breakfast. I’ll keep replying as the video continues 🔥🔥🔥😭😭😭😭😭

[@MalcolmJones-bossjones]

The LINKED HORIZON COVER OMFG!!!!

[@MalcolmJones-bossjones]

Attack on Titan will never reach 140, omg

[@MalcolmJones-bossjones]

Armins little friend, wow I remember that video you did 😯

[@MalcolmJones-bossjones]

THE SCARF BEING THE TRIGGER THAT MAKES SO MUCH SENSE. Idk why I didn’t think of that !

[@MalcolmJones-bossjones]

Bro I also teared up when everyone revealed they had personal chats with Eren. You aren’t alone. I hope they add more in the anime.

[@kamekarin2889]

Bro I've been waiting for this for so long.

[@MangaHorse]

I know , and i am sorry for letting everyone wait so long 😞 I really hope you like the video

[@guywithafunnymustache]

Honestly I was waiting for your video so eagerly. So glad that you're feeling better. And this video is 1 hour loongggg woooo it's gonna be a Ride!

[@MangaHorse]

Thank you so much for being so patient 🙏 I’m really happy to be back and I hope you’ll like this one, I really gave it a lot of love ❤️

[@guywithafunnymustache]

@@MangaHorse finished the video, it's so well explained (as usual) and honestly knowing that Eren felt all of the memories makes it even terrifying, like he have already experienced the rumbling, the genocide, that's why he broke down apologizing to those money saving kids(and probably the grieve sasha death too) but didn't exactly know the chronicle order or cause of the events and that's why when Sasha actually died, he laughed at fate as he can't change the future. And the cabin scene I also thought the same that it's different reality. Well we can now at least imagine a reality with Eren and Mikasa lived happily, and cope with the pain.

[@MangaHorse]

Thank you so much my friend, I’m happy you enjoyed it 😊 And about the cabin scene, you are right! That way we can imagine there are infinite Eren and Mikasa out there, having their own personal story

[@guywithafunnymustache]

@@MangaHorse BTW dude AOT is gonna end soon, what are you planning to do with this channel? I'd love to watch if youdo some other good Anime breakdown as well (like FMAB, RE ZERO, MONSTER)

[@MangaHorse]

I will still offer unique AoT videos, but not only I will do breakdown videos and I also want to do recommendations I’m also currently working on a site and blog, so it will all come together with my KZbin channel I also want to try and do some weekly show, like reviewing everything interesting on anime and TV, but I still need to see how I can make this happen

[@CRiver396]

You literally describe memories while not calling them memories. Also, glad your back and hopefully doing well.

[@MangaHorse]

I tried to differentiate between actual moments we are experiencing (Eren’s “memories”), and the electrical currents going inside our brains in the process of memory storage (actual memories) I just didn’t want to get into the whole science behind it because this video was already way too long 😂 And thank you so much for watching my friend, I really appreciate it 🙏

[@lllllllllllll3879]

Eren's freedom is the outside world he dreamed of. In Chapter 131 and 139, we saw his inner conflict and IMO, it makes him a GOATed character.

[@SabanLeon]

An hour of quality content 😳

[@MangaHorse]

thank you so much 😊 🙏 It’s long, but I believe it covers much more than only the last chapter, so I hope people will find it interesting

[@SabanLeon]

@@MangaHorse sure will :) Keep up the good work

[@MangaHorse]

Already on it 💪 😉

[@JoSmith-kn9st]

You’re the best! I’m glad you are on the mend!

[@MangaHorse]

Thank you so much my friend 🙏 I’m feeling better and keeping making videos…getting ready for the final season 🤩

[@keshavc2296]

Dude I might sound silly😅 But can you please say where did you get that thumbnail picture of eren and mikasa I am tired searching for it🤧

[@MangaHorse]

What do you mean where I got it…I made it 😃 You won’t find it because it’s an edit of 8 different layers, including my logo, baby Eren, the scarf double Mikasa etc.. I make everything on my channel, from the thumbnail edits to the animations 😎

[@keshavc2296]

@@MangaHorse bro can u send that hd image I really want to draw it it s soooooooo coooolllll🥵 plz😖

[@MangaHorse]

Thank you my friend, but I’m sorry, that was a really long time ago and I don’t have that specific edit and all the elements I used anymore, the final thumbnail in my channel with my logo and text is the only one left

[@keshavc2296]

@@MangaHorse Well I just wanted to draw that eren and mikasa facing back I found mikasa one but I'm not getting the eren one Thanks btw for searching

[@omit123456]

the horse with the fumy accent is back!!! I missed your videos and analysis so much!! glad to see you referred mirrai nikki in this video, we thought like this in your previous video! hope everyone feel ok and are all healthy! It's ok to rest and do breaks if you need to, we'll wait for your videos as long as we need! אחי התגעגעתי לסרטונים שלך, שמח שאתה בסדר ושכולם ירגישו טוב!

[@MangaHorse]

Thank you so much my friend, I’m so happy you are back after my long break I already posted 2 videos since then and I will keep on going And sure! Future diary has very clear similarities to our situation, only in AoT is a little more complicated 🤓 ותודה רבה אח יקר! ממש כיף לראות חברים מהבית שמקבלים את המבטא שלי באהבה ❤️ אני כרגע הרבה יותר טוב 🙏

[@josefernandez5329]

Take the breaks u need brother. This video was awesome and may God bless you and ur health!

[@MangaHorse]

Thank you so much my friend, I’m getting better and I appreciate your concern 🙏 Also, I’m really happy you enjoyed this video, I already posted 2 vids since I returned and I’m not gonna stop 😊

[@anakin-is-panakin]

If he couldn’t figure out what choice could alter the future, why didn’t he just not do the rumbling? That was a pretty big crossroads sort of scene. If he saw himself starting the rumbling, why didn’t he just choose to not do it. I think he felt as if the future was futile because he didn’t WANT to change his decisions because they would’ve gone against his ideals and go against his own convictions. Did he just get tired of fighting and give into the future he saw or did he just realize that all the choices he would logically make would lead to such an atrocity? Or am I just silly and missed something. Thanks for providing a new perspective on Armin’s gratitude. It always confused me because he calls Eren a mass murderer right before so it felt like Isayama was leaving us in ambiguity over if genocide was bad or good. I didn’t get why would he have Hange condemn genocide and outright state that their fallen comrades would want them to oppose genocide - including Erwin. So i just really appreciate this perspective shift.

[@MangaHorse]

Happy I could provide different perspective 😊 About your question, he couldn’t do that for the same reason I mentioned…he didn’t know what his future self did…Maybe his future self actions happened BECAUSE future Eren tried to prevent it? Maybe that was thr trigger…and Just like I explained in the video Eren had no way of knowing what happened in between. Another thing, I have a big issue with people calling it global Genocide for 2 reasons. 1st. The word Genocide was never present in the Japanese text, it is only in the translation in english. 2nd. There is no such thing as Global Genocide! Genocide is the act of singling out a SPECIFIC ethnic group, or a country. Deciding they don’t deserve to live. Eren didn’t discriminate against people skin color, beliefs or country. He targeted everyone equally which is the one thing you will NOT find in genocide…equality! His actions actually have a different name, and I talked about and explained it here, if you are interested 🙏 kzbin.info/www/bejne/l5vCZaucqJl5lcU

[@anakin-is-panakin]

@@MangaHorse adding that video to my watchlist 🙏🏻 wouldn’t killing anyone who aren’t your people genocide? Or at the least xenophobic mass murder?

[@superduperstapler]

By the end I was surprised to see I'd been watching for an hour. Thanks for your insightful analysis

[@MangaHorse]

Thank you so much for watching the entire video, I really appreciate it 🤗 And I really hope you enjoyed it 🙏

[@amandadonatti118]

This was just so beautifully thought out thank you for sharing.

[@MangaHorse]

Thank you so much, I put a lot of love into making this video, easily the one I spent most time working on so I’m so happy people find it useful and enjoyable, it was my pleasure sharing it, and I thank you so much for watching and for letting me know what you felt about it, I really appreciate it 🙏😊

[@obsidian_citadel437]

Damn it pains me to see how many like this video has. It need a LOT MORE

[@MangaHorse]

Thank you my friend, and yes it pains me too, I really gave this vid a lot of love and work, but still, I’m grateful people are still watching and I’m happy you enjoyed it 🙏 😊

[@undergroundproductions3937]

17:30 “Eren directed Dina away from bertoldt so that the [time loop] wouldn’t change” Isn’t that Erens goal though? To be free? Wouldn’t he intentionally stop the time loop (bc he knew that letting Dina eat Bert would save his mom)? By redirecting Dina to his mom, he continued the cycle which caused him all his pain and stripped any semblance of freedom.

[@MangaHorse]

That’s a good question and it touches the subject of determinism AND physics. The “simple” answer is that he couldn’t NOT do that, even if he wanted, simply because that event already happened. in a sense,some version of Eren has already lived that moment and did the same…this result will forever be the same, and it will keep playing this way over and over (Casual loop) theoretically, If OUR Eren would have done something differently that would translate into a different/alternate reality…because in this current reality the past, present and future are already set in motion, and that is directly because our Eren witnessed glimpses of his future (medal ceremony) that solidified everything I know it’s pretty complicated, so I hope I didn’t make it more complicated after this comment 😅 Thank you so much for watching my friend 🙏

[@charmendro]

i think eren was too held onto the outcome of the rumbling that he wouldn't ever are disrupt that even if it meant saving his mom.

[@MangaHorse]

That is correct, But I’ll just add something…he wasn’t waiting for the actual rumbling BUT for “that sight” that he once saw in a distant future memory. In order to get to that outcome he had to do what he did. Eren knew the outcome of Mikasa’s choice (he said it himself) but he didn’t know the exact steps to get there or what her decision was, this is why he did everything he thought is necessary to get to that desired point

[@FaiaHalo]

I personally feel that Paths is now gone as well. Mainly because the vision Hanji had when they died, of Erwin and all their friends saluting them was a near-death hallucination, according to Isayama, and not an actual after life. Isayama is a very secular person, so I don't think he would keep that aside the Paths shenanigans that only Eldians experienced. However, I think most interpretations, like yours, are valid (except for reddit bros that actively go against Isayama) because the story, like any work of fiction, is subjective. Once again, thank you for this awesome video!

[@MangaHorse]

Yes I agree,also I personally keep away from Reddit ever since they became extremely toxic…also I really got a lot of hate on Reddit for some reason…don’t know why, I’m pretty much a nice guy 😕

[@Martina-]

I'm so happy you're back!! Wish you the best 🌟

[@MangaHorse]

Awww thank you so much ❤️ I’m feeling better and happy to be back 🤗 Already posted 2 videos since I returned and I’m just getting started 😉

[@RainyBlue7]

Hello Manga Horse. It has been a really long time, and I am glad you are doing better now. I loved your video! There were some plot elements that I didn't quite understand or was confused about, but you have sorted things out perfectly. I was able to understand the story better. Thank you! I look forward to the anime.

[@MangaHorse]

Hey how are you 👋 😃 I’m so happy you came back to my channel, and thank you! I am feeling better now ❤️ I’m so thrilled that my video helped you understand the story better and I’m so happy you enjoyed it I also posted more videos since that one, and I will continue delivering unique content regularly 🤗

[@BobbyDaDan]

I haven't even watched the vid yet. I'm just glad you're back.

[@MangaHorse]

Awww thank you so much 😊 I’m happy to be back, and I really hope you’ll enjoy this one, I created it with a lot of love to all of you and with respect to Attack on titan

[@cOLiLLai]

I CAN’T BELIEVE YOU ARE BACK MH!!! I’ve been leaving comments on random videos asking what happened and how you were! I knew you were preparing something grand!!!!!!!!!

[@MangaHorse]

Hey 👋 😃 How are you! Sorry for not being responsive, I’ve had to take a little time out for health issues, but I’m happy to be back and I’m checking on all the comments 💪 I really hope you’ll like the new video 🙏

[@cOLiLLai]

We completely understand, MH! We missed your voice so much! How can I be friends with you? Do you have a community where you talk to your followers, so I won’t have to keep commenting on your videos? 🤣 Hope to hear back from you! PS. thanks for coming back. There isn’t any KZbinr on KZbin that is like you. None!!! Your work are gems in the AOT community! BUT also, you should prioritize your healthy FIRST, above all else. Take care! Much love.

[@MangaHorse]

Thank you so much for understanding and for all the love and support ❤️ I have a discord but I’m not so active there, I need to refresh it soon I do have twitter and facebook profile and groups And I’m also thinking about an option to do some live stream discussion, but I still need to see how I’m gonna do it 🤔

[@rochak9864]

great video. After rereading the manga and watching this video. my love for the ending has grown more.

[@MangaHorse]

Thank you so much my friend! That’s a great compliment knowing I could help you appreciate this story a bit more, that’s truly all I can ask for 😃 Thank you so much for watching and for letting me know, it means a lot to me 🙏

[@okuigokublack]

Ayo so glad you're back! Hope your health is better now!

[@MangaHorse]

Thank you so much my friend, it feels good to be back and to talk to everyone And yes, I do feel better, thank you 😊 🙏

[@okuigokublack]

@@MangaHorse Good to know!

[@user-fd8ve6cq5w]

Welcome back legend

[@MangaHorse]

Who…me?? 🥺 Thank you so much ☺️ I’m so happy to get back and I really hope you’ll like my video thanks 🙏

[@mudoken1557]

We're back boys

[@MangaHorse]

YEAH!!!!! 💪 😎

[@SierraLimaSL]

jeez 8 nonths? welcome back! where have you been?

[@MangaHorse]

Thank you so much my friend I had some health issues and it got to the point I had to take care of myself because it was really affecting me But I’m really happy to be back 😊

[@erenjaeger7563]

Finally you're back👌hope you're good now😄

[@MangaHorse]

I’m much better thank you ☺️ And thank you so much for coming back to my channel 🤗

[@winterthekid]

I kinda lost tracks of your uploads, maybe you paused for a little while; but I'm so happy you're back! Gonna watch this and discuss at the hand! Oh joyful occasion!

[@MangaHorse]

Thank you so much for coming back to my channel, and Yes, I was on some sort of a break because of m health issue 😔 But I’m back and ready for the new season 💪

[@winterthekid]

@@MangaHorse I heard in the video; I'm glad you're better; give you my best wishes: stay strong; I'll always watch and enjoy your content when you do upload it (by the high quality of it I understand it's a demanding task, and that makes it so much precious and something to be grateful for)!

[@MangaHorse]

Thank you my friend, I really appreciate it 🙏 And yes, the high quality and animation do take longer, but I really wanted to offer something special for our fandom so I used any minute I could while away to work on it by the end this videos was packed with around 225GB of content 😅 I was actually amazed by it myself, my mac almost had a heart attack trying to render everything 😂 I really hope you’ll enjoy it 🙏

[@winterthekid]

@@MangaHorse the quality shows, truly splendid work; thank you so much!

[@MangaHorse]

My pleasure my friend, more is coming soon 😊

[@rosta3030]

Thx man. All that is left now is for the anime to end and my broken heart shall move on then.

[@MangaHorse]

Thank you for watching my friend, really appreciate it and hope The anime will prove me right 🙏 Also, I humbly believe people will watch AoT videos years to come, I will be making them, hope you’ll watch 😉

[@rosta3030]

@@MangaHorse for sure homie. The way u explain stuff is fire.

[@spoontik2933]

Ok so I have watched your video twice. It’s incredible. The amount of work you put into it and the time you took to process all the information is breathtaking. You covered the most important part of the chapter with an impressive and reasonable explanation. Also your editing skills improved so much. Really I was amazed by how original and unique you presented your ideas. I had to wait a long time but it was worth it ! Clearly the best video you ever made so far. You can be proud. It may not get as many views as you wish but you did it for the sake of SnK, for your geniune love to the show. I wish we had more work like this in the anime community. True analysis and breakdown of what is really happening. Also, how is your health’s condition going right now ? Regarding your review. Your conclusions resonate with me a lot since I had the same conclusions on almost everything you mentioned ! It strengthens my interpretation/hypothesis since you are someone that I do respect and acknowledge the work’s quality. I do agree with the casual loop/eternalism analysis (Well its confirmed at this point of the story anyway) + the fact that Eren isn’t free (I would even say that free will doesn't exist in this specific case). He is just a slave to destiny because events can’t be changed. But Eren is also an expression of freedom, An excessive form of freedom that annihilates everything on his path because Eren was born this way (from the genuine desire Grisha infused in him. Wishing a bright future for his son). Eren is a mixture of both internal and external forces. And he fell in love with the true embodiment of freedom… which is Mikasa. Mikasa is the freest person in this world. Her choices lead to the end of the titan’s era and allowed Ymir to be free. Some stuff I really liked about what you said : -The small detail about King Fritz having a “path tree” chair ; -How you connected “everything happens at the same time” to the sight Eren saw chapter 121 and linking Eren’s childish vision of freedom in chapter 14 (an empty world) to adult Eren subconsciously wanting to replicate this “sight” without knowing why in chapter 139 (scene with Armin) ; -Eren's essence made one with all living things ; -You did a really good job at explaining Eren’s, grisha and Ymir’s psychology. Also regarding Armin thanking Eren. You are right. Isayama talked about it in his last interview and said that Armin didn’t approve Eren’s action obviously but since Armin benefited from the massacre he wanted to say goodbye to Eren by telling him he is also an accomplice somehow. -Eren saying good bye twice (2 differents Eren + the bird signifying the end of the scene) Your guess about Miksasa having royal blood… It may sound crazy and far-fetched but I also agree. I actually had the same opinion and talked about it with Sofia and some friends. But I think about it for other reasons...I didn't even made the connection with the "thanks to the lives you gave birth to, here I now stand". For me this sentence made no sense until now. Omg it was right in front of my face ! You know it but Isayma talked about the mix between royal blood and Ackerman. He said it would both reflect equally. Also, in chapter 50 it would explain why Eren was still able to control the titans even though he wasn’t in contact with Dina Fritz anymore. But with Mikasa on his back (who is like a little royal blood titan) it would make sense. Also I do think that the backstory of the shogun focused a lot on the “good relationship” he had with the royal family. And it would explain why it was so important to bring back Mikasa’s asian ancestry in chapter 107. It would also explain why both Historia and Mikasa have parallels to Ymir (ending 1 with Mikasa and ending 4 with Historia in the anime are very similar). And as you said this mixture of blood Mikasa is what makes her so special and why she was the only one being able to free Ymir. About the alternate realities. I also think it's similar to the many-worlds interpretation/Everett interpretation. The cabin scene is an alternate reality while Armin and Eren were in the path. Mikasa being « a bridge between realities » as you said. People tend to think Isayama gave up on logic for a "spiritual" approach while I think he just mixed both of it. It is just not that comprehensible for us right now and as you said the anime may clear things up with some original scenes not shown in the manga. Finally, something also really amazing about these last chapters that I want to point out is how many references/inspirations Isayama drew from other stories/art/history/philosophy/science while implementing it his way in his own story (without replicating it). The cultural symbolism underneath is beautiful. Thank you very much again for bringing this content to KZbin. I was really emotional watching your final thought of the chapter. We talked so much on discord and it will be forever good memories . It was an amazing journey my friend and everything is “still ahead of us” until the anime (or movie) finishes ! Edit : oh and I am glad I already watched Higurashi and Mirai Nikki because you would have spoiled me 👀

[@MangaHorse]

wow spoon, I am speechless...your comment is so detailed and nice, you actually explained things better then I did thank you so much my friend for watching and taking the time to let me know your thoughts you know I appreciate your opinion as well, so it's so nice hearing you enjoyed my ideas I also agree about what you said about Eren, and also about the video not getting a lot of views, like I mentioned in the video and as you said, I really made it for the fandom so people will have one, very long, detailed, and respectable review of the last chapter...and your comment makes me believe I actually made it, so again thank you so much, my friend I also intend to tell you all what happened to me in the last few months, which I spent mostly at the hospital, and now that I am home I am planning some new things, including of course reconnecting with everyone, I really missed talking to you ❤️ thank you again spoon for taking the time to watch and to tell me your thoughts 🤗

[@spoontik2933]

@@MangaHorse I see so you feel better I guess and your health is normal now. Good to hear. Feel free to come whenever you want and discuss about the chapter ! I think there is much more to dig about this masterpiece and we still have a lot of work to do. I can’t wait to see this animated and how the anime once again may change our perspective on the events that happened. But I think you are very close to the truth. If there is any truth ;)

[@MalcolmJones-bossjones]

Spoon omg, mikasa being on erens back when he touched Dina. WOW WOW WOW. That would explain so much and I don’t put it past Isayama do add THAT level of detail 😯😯😯😯😯😯

[@panoramagaming3301]

@@MangaHorse your video was a really nice one, though I had moved on from AOT months ago I really liked this video, and in the end I just think that the ending was not bad but really sad, Eren always wanted to be free but couldn't be, Mikasa always wanted to be with Eren but couldn't be, sooo many people died, and in the future titan powers ultimately came back. I always knew Eren was going to die but still hoped he would somehow live because I followed him from the start. Well I am still happy for Mikasa, at least she got to live a long happy life.

[@panoramagaming3301]

I too agree that Mikasa is the most free person in this world, you can see in the lost girls manga that she always had a choice to do whatever she wants, but in order to be free she literally had to be born with all these special bloods and royal ancestry, it reminds me of what Keith said, "Normal people can't change anything". People like Eren don't have any freedom of choice, which makes me sad as I myself is just a normal person born to a normal family with no extraordinary abilities.

[@trapenoone6904]

I really love more Mikasa as a characeter after your explaination, she is the only one who has the connection to the alternate universe or realities of the other Mikasa. That's why our Mikasa in chapter 123 think what if that day she choose another answer when Eren asked her what am I to you. Also, I agree that the concept of time in AoT is not a matter of when but where because when Eren experienced all thing at the same time as you explained.

[@MangaHorse]

Thank you my friend, I’m really happy you like my explanation 😊 About Mikasa, I think she is probably one of the most unique characters I have ever seen She was kept very quiet in the story, and Isayama “unleashed” her true power on the last 2 final chapters BTW…I have more Mikasa videos coming up, to actually explain how different realities is formed

[@FifoJournal]

U make best explanation !

[@MangaHorse]

Thank you so much ☺️ 🙏

[@howlingwolfandchelsea]

The extra panels at 01:01:20 means the anime will end in a movie. Isayama foreshadowed it to us.

[@MangaHorse]

Yes, that is possible, especially when there’s a good chance for a movie now

[@howlingwolfandchelsea]

@@MangaHorse Check Discord, I wrote you a message there!

[@skinnymatt64]

Awesome video, well worth the wait

[@MangaHorse]

Thank you so much! 😃 I’m so happy you like it 🙏

[@sauravrao234]

Looks like someone finally remembered his youtube account password....welcome back my friend. ..do let me know what you think about the insta message I sent you...that is when the Years in aot are counted from..

[@HassanAhmed-bs5fn]

Amazing video which I really anticipated for a long time, I just got some time to watch it fully and it sure was worth the wait, as always the content was fascinating, deeply insightful, and creative. Thank you so much, this high-quality video was like an early Christmas gift, as I wasn't sure what to make of the ending but now thanks to you I understand it much better and I can appreciate it. Gonna be checking out your other uploads soon. I also hope you stay in good health!! =))

[@MangaHorse]

Thank you so much my friend, I’m so happy you enjoyed my video although it took me a very long time, so I really appreciate your patience 🙏 I am feeling better and will be uploading more frequently now And Also merry Christmas! 🎁 🎄 I hope you’ll have a wonderful holiday 🤗

[@leoarjuncrasto]

Am so happy you are back ☺️

[@MangaHorse]

Thank you so much 😊 I’m really happy To be back and I hope you enjoyed the video 🙏

[@Reirae]

Welcome back! I'm glad you're feeling better ❤

[@MangaHorse]

thank you so much! it feels good to come back 😊

[@Reirae]

@@MangaHorse video was great BTW! Loved your more positive view of the last chapter compared to many others. I'm still having an existential crisis over the time stuff 😅

[@MangaHorse]

Thank you 😊 and Yes, time is always complicated, that’s why a lot of people tend to disregard it, while it’s probably one of the most important things affecting Eren I’ll probably make another video about time, decision making, and alternate realities

[@Reirae]

@@MangaHorse that'd be cool. I'll make sure to watch it if you ever do :)

[@ShadoGiow]

Beautiful video, you deserve so much more subs

[@MangaHorse]

Thank you so much my friend, I really appreciate it 🙏 😊

[@sohamsharma6149]

Man this was a great video. I love your videos and find them very interesting. I hope you are all right.

[@MangaHorse]

thank you so much my friend, I am so happy you enjoyed it and yes, I actually feel much better these days, thank you for asking 🙏

[@Me-rx4hq]

Thank you so much for another great video Manga Horse! I’m very happy that your health got better and you were able to share your perspective on the ending of aot. I love how in depth you go into the series and I enjoyed this video a lot.

[@MangaHorse]

awww thank YOU for waiting so long and for coming back 🤗 I do feel better now, so I am ready to share A LOT more...already working on the next vid 💪

[@smithdonte00]

Glad your back 😭

[@MangaHorse]

Thank you so much!! I’m happy to be back too🥺😭

[@WholeArmourMinistries]

At the end of 139 when Mikasa is talking to Ymir, she shows a memory different than the one Eren had of Ymir and the assassination attempt on Karl Fritz. Ymir's love was toward her children, not Karl Fritz.

[@ranidutta5754]

Welcome back, horsie👌

[@MangaHorse]

Hey 👋 😃 I’m happy to be back

[@karan_1990]

Man just perfect

[@MangaHorse]

Thank you so much 😊 I really happy you liked it 🙏

[@spoontik2933]

The video I was waiting for !!

[@MangaHorse]

Hey spoon 😃 👋 I’m so sorry it took me so long, I really hope you’ll enjoy it

[@melloy-2002]

Good thing u taken rest.... Your health is more important❤️....... And nice to see u back👍

[@MangaHorse]

Thank you so much ☺️ I’m so happy to get back as well, I really hope you’ll enjoy my video 🙏

[@someone-jx2cg]

Hey there manga horse I love your chanle and your vis it makes me understand so many things I didn't understand thank you . Can u please explain Evangelion series ? If u like I'm just asking cause I didn't understand the ending and thank u for this amazing vi I listened to it till the end it was so good

[@MangaHorse]

Awww thank you so much 😃 I’m so happy my video could help you understand things better, and thank you so much for watching ❤️ Because I do everything on my channel my self I have very limited time to create content, but I promise I’ll try to make a fun Evangelion video in the future too Thank you again so much for letting me know your thoughts and for supporting my channel, it means a lot to me And I hope seeing you in my next video comments or on any of my other social medias 🤗

[@someone-jx2cg]

@@MangaHorse you don't need to thank me your chanle is amazing that's why I'm here and so many other people because of your hard work you shouldn't be thanking thank yourself for working hard on this chanle and for making amazing content , and if it's going topresses you don't do it your mental health is more important than it and thank u for replying to my comment

[@MangaHorse]

Thank you again, and sorry, but I’m really thankful for all this love 😭 ❤️ And of course I’ll answer, I love talking to everyone and I always answer every comment I see And thank you for your concern, I’m doing much better now 😊

[@cdeleon3494]

Welcome back!

[@MangaHorse]

Thank you so much! I’m happy to be back and I really appreciate you returning to watch my video after my long break 🙏

[@cdeleon3494]

@@MangaHorse hope you're doing well and stay safe!

[@MangaHorse]

Thank you my friend 🙏

[@sofiakaos5278]

@18:05 sorry my friend but you are wrong. I said it before to you on discord and I will keep saying it again, Eren did that after he unlocked the full power of the founder, meaning he not only manipulated Dina (I told yah he would months earlier!) AND titan ymir to sleep for 60 years and wake up right where the warriors would be AND even manipulated that one titan who saves Zeke from dying. All after he paired up with Ymir inside the titan realm. A place time is endless, a place where Eren could in fact be connected to every titan and subject of ymir and change things as he pleases for as long as he need to.

[@MangaHorse]

Hey Sofia! 👋 😃 how are you? And about your comment, It’s a question of how you look at things, I guess we can look at it from several different perspectives

[@sofiakaos5278]

Hello, im well thank you. Perspective?? Okay then call it perspective, I always called it logic. Look, Eren could never have done anything with the founder before the vow of renouncing war was broken. The max we know he could do is erase memories right? This is facts mh. After breaking that vow and only after breaking it, both Eren and Zeke could meet with Grisha and finally make him do what he was meant to do all along, kill the reiss family. Eren even thanked zeke because if not for that he would never reach this path. And It was only after that event that Eren could send the memories he had always meant to recieve all along. By the way, during that whole chapter we also see how Eren and Grisha made even further contact prior to that day, like the day Eren told Grisha he would join the survey corps or the time where Grisha asked Eren why he wouldnt tell him if Carla would be okay moments before Grisha got to the church. When I told you Eren manipulated Dina back in 2020 I also followed logic and hey look, I was right about this.

[@kartikprabhu4719]

@@sofiakaos5278 actually the vow could have been broken with Eren touching Historia too... He just didn't know how to operate... As you can see in 121, Zeke wanted to remove the "brainwashing" Done to Eren so he took him to memories of Grisha... But I think that it required the will of both Zeke and Eren since even Eren needed to persuade Grisha to take the founding titan powers.... For controlling Titans, Eren could even do that when he punched Dina Titan's hand... I think he could only control titans around them because Dina titan didn't have intelligence... At the time of medal ceremony, Eren since he touched a Royal blooded member he could see some timestamps and that in turn may have caused that... All I'm saying is his perspective may also be possible... But the thing is it doesn't matter when it was done😅

[@sofiakaos5278]

​@@kartikprabhu4719 It does matter. Much more than you think. Why do you guys not question what is really important? Anyways, Young Eren, Grisha, Krugger and those who came before were actually following future Eren's "missions" all along and that was the BIGGEST take away from chapter 121 onwards but no one cared to notice or even mention it... And no, young Eren did not manipulate the titans after touching Dina's hand. All that happen was the future eren, that was already controlling Dina, made the other titans move in a way that would seem that younger eren was the one to make them move. Why? So the warriors reach out to zeke on the other side and tell him "eren YEAGER has the coordinate!" If this event didnt happen, Zeke would never hear about grisha having a son much less go look for him with such a plan like he does. Get what I mean? Can you follow my reasoning? Again, the time and place of every event in aot is of most importance because otherwise you will not understand the plot and the characters fully.

[@kartikprabhu4719]

@@sofiakaos5278 oh ok... So you say that when Zeke and Eren had the contact and they broke the vow and when Eren had the full powers of the founder, he helped his younger self to control the titans at the exact moment when he punched Dina... It might be the case but then you are saying that nothing happened/happens if he touches any Royal blooded member/Royal blooded titan Or he just gets the memories by touching the Royal blooded member like Historia and Rod(NOTE - Didn't write Royal blooded titan shifter ie Zeke via which the vow could've been broken as said by Xavier)... And why did future Eren decide to control the titans only when Dina titan was punched... I mean Reiner only drew out the conclusion that Eren had the coordinate and for that if future Eren had to help his younger version why did he wait till the contact🤔... Just want to know your thoughts about this

[@markgregorygacosta531]

Hi, is the concept of Causal time loop paradox similar to determinism? I saw another video explaining Eren's character from Invaderzz, idk if u know him but so far most of ur ideas and explanations about Eren's character and others are quite similar. Anyway congrats on this video i really like it and may you gain more subscribers!

[@MangaHorse]

Thank you so much! I’m really happy you enjoyed my video 🤗 About your Question Both concepts are pretty similar Casual loops are Physic way to explain certain events. Determinism is a philosophical way to explain those events

[@rafaeldanelogomez]

Nice content! Keep this up!

[@MangaHorse]

Glad you liked it my friend, thank you for watching 🙏 😊

[@queenkitty7947]

"Is Eren a bird now?" 🤣 oh gawd that made me lol after feeling sad with the stuff mentioned right before that

[@MangaHorse]

I felt I needed to give you some comic relief 😅 Glad you liked it 😁 And thank you so much for watching my video, I know it’s very long and I really appreciate it 🙏

[@magnificentiPod]

I don’t like that Historia became unimportant and just a side character that didn’t play any role in the end of the story. She had 10 lines of dialogue in the final arcs.

[@MangaHorse]

I agree, I think the "worst" thing was to make her seem important (with having the baby) but then, like you said, make her look less important I believe she could have been used in a better way to the story, but this is of course just my opinion

[@lazlonazario2499]

Nice to see you again Bro my best wishes

[@MangaHorse]

Thank you so much my friend, I’m happy to be back 😃

[@lazlonazario2499]

@@MangaHorse I really loved your theories very much and what are your honest thoughs about Mikasa in general?

[@MangaHorse]

I dedicated her a lot in this video Currently, I believe she is the most unique person in this story, Isayama just kept her secret twist to the very end

[@lazlonazario2499]

@@MangaHorse Yeah i understand it completely i really love the work you did around her , after the end of Attack on Titan i cant stop thinking about her and what are your thoughs about the extra pages in general?

[@AlternisLiz]

Fantastic analysis

[@MangaHorse]

Thank you so much, I’m happy you like it 😊 🙏

[@madao372]

مرحبا الترجمة العربية تختفي بعد نص ساعة وبالضبط عند جزئية حب ميكاسا وايرين اتنى حل المشكلة + حرفيآ اول نص ساعة من المقطع ممتعة حرفيآ لا استيطع الانتظار كثيرآ

[@MangaHorse]

لقد أصلحتها لك ، شكرًا لإخباري بوجود مشكلة في الترجمة 😊 🙏

[@lllllllllllll3879]

*Here's why WE GOT THIS ENDING* Sources are *Lost Girls Ova* which is semi-canonized in my opinion because *IT IS SUPERVISED BY ISAYAMA HIMSELF* and *Chapter 137* Now, let's take a deeper look: "Mikasa ran too, but STAYED BEHIND HIM ON PURPOSE" What purpose? Because she doesn't Eren to give up on his dreams(The Outside World). Mikasa and Grisha's conversation is straight up connected and important to the plot. If Mikasa wanted to save Eren then it would mean forgetting about the "Outside World" he dreamed of. Curiosity < Nature Love > Hatred Which is basically the "Summary" of Eren's character. Other SOURCES: "No Matter Where You Are" and "Call Your Name"

[@piyalidasgupta4190]

Ch 139 Analysis 😲Eren loves Mikasa😲 I think that it is a common knowledge 🙄

[@MangaHorse]

It is 😊 But I think a lot of people still have issues with that, so I’m just here to clarify 😊

[@piyalidasgupta4190]

@@MangaHorse Even, after reading the entire manga they denied it, so, no matter what we did they will be always in denial

[@waytoguidance]

seriously how are you so underrated..?

[@MangaHorse]

Thank you so much my friend 🙏 I really appreciate it, and I’m so happy you enjoyed my video 🫶

[@waytoguidance]

@@MangaHorse Really I saw this video and I was mind blown.. I thought I already knew what there is needed to be known about AOT but boy was I wrong 🥲 you're welcome you deserve many more subs and views..

[@MangaHorse]

@waytoguidance thank you so much my friend, I really appreciate it 🙏 ❤️