What’s the right tool? Drill vs impact driver vs impact wrench

Рет қаралды 4,905

Күн бұрын

Пікірлер: 40

@lancemill5683 11 ай бұрын

Yeah thats a big job for a drill. I mean the drill i gonna be way faster if it is able to do the job, but if it requires to much torque youre gonna need an impact wrench

@bleyz3557 11 ай бұрын

The reason why impact driver is faster and better for the job than a drill and impact wrench is because impact driver is meant for that kind of job, moreover everything comes down to the speed, even tho it is large bolt you don't need high torque type of power for that job, you need sufficient power and SPEED, thats where RPM and IPM of an impact driver comes into play. And that Hercules impact driver is no joke what so ever, top tier when it comes to power. It is like when a drill is able to drive something it is going to be the fastest, but when it can't it isn't

@Kaleb_RoSs 11 ай бұрын

Exactly, that’s pretty much spot on with what I was trying to say in this video.

@SMOKEY-JAYS-DIESEL 11 ай бұрын

You need his drill. He gives it the magic touch 🤣🤣🤣🤣

@SuS_NuG_It 4 ай бұрын

It sounds like what you're saying is having the wrong tool that can do the job is better than having the right tool. I mean you're absolutely right, if the drill can't do it it's not going to be faster than an impact, but saying that an impact is faster than a drill that can't do the job, is like saying doing a job with hand tools is faster than doing it with broken power tools. Like yeah, no shit. But you're quite literally saying that if you had the right drill, that had the power to do the job, it would be the better, and ideal option, which is correct. You should never try to do the job with a tool that isn't meant for it, or shouldn't be doing it, and an impact driver is not meant for running a long continuous lag. A long continuous lag should be driven by something that has the power to run it, and then it should be run at a continuous speed. Did you notice how the impact driver was generating fucking smoke? You know what smoke means? Smoke means that the wood was getting so hot that it was burning, which means the fastener was getting so hot it was burning the wood, which means that it was probably work hardening, and at a far greater risk of not having the strength to do the job that it might be intended to do. I'd rather have a drill that can't drive it than an impact that fucks up my fastener

@mrb3888 11 ай бұрын

We all know soAlz loves his drills and loves his boyfriends.

@SMOKEY-JAYS-DIESEL 11 ай бұрын

Lmfao 🤣🤣🤣 FACTS 🎯

@mtasubwaymartasubway 9 ай бұрын

soAlZ the whinny infant girl he is.

@keaganjones6330 11 ай бұрын

What soAlz fails to realize is it isnt always about speed of the drive but instead torque. And when you explain this to him he cries and gives a 🤓🍑 remark

@ImranAhmed-fm9zl 10 ай бұрын

100 percent. That guy is a complete clown. And he only replies with insults when people disagree with him. Pretty sure, he never saw a job site in his life.

@mtasubwaymartasubway 9 ай бұрын

What a Bozo soAlZ is.

@s.n2500 2 ай бұрын

This doesn’t prove 1 tool is better than the other, it just confirms what each tool has a different job it was made for, impact driver performs best with small to medium fasters that don’t need to be overly tight, impact wrench deals with large fasners that need a lot of power to unscrew/screw, drills deal with drilling through material

@engineer_alv 11 ай бұрын

I prefer the impact driver for any philips screws, Torx screws and small hex screws (like up to 3/8" x 4") The impact wrench for anything bigger And the drill for pilot holes and small hex screws (don't really like to use philips screw on those because they cam quite easily).

@anlam3224 11 ай бұрын

If there is a chance, I hope you will work on the makita ddf458 drill model

@johndill7826 11 ай бұрын

Please start some beef with @ToolswithSoAlz.....😂

@Kaleb_RoSs 11 ай бұрын

Not starting any beef just never been able to drive this big lag all the way down with a drill. Lol

@unclefester4626 11 ай бұрын

I would reccomend it. He gets kinda mean when anyone disagrees with him...

@lancemill5683 11 ай бұрын

I personally really like toolswithsoAlz but kinda lost interest that I had cause he was very rude to me for no reason, and I interacted alot on his channel and had even defended him to other youtubers. Kinda sucks to be treated so poorly for absolutely no reason except he thought I was disagreeing with him

@unclefester4626 11 ай бұрын

@@lancemill5683 he shakes from Parkinson's disease if i remember correctly. He knows he's facing major problems and i believe as a result he's gotten meaner over time. I saw a post of his on his electricians friends channel where he told some guy he was a panty wearing woman simply for disagreeing with him. I have no time for that kind of BS. Heated arguments are one thing but treating subs like that just because they have a particular fondness of Flex brand tools is not. My mother had MS and got really mean in the final stages of the disease. I do not miss her and i do not remember her fondly because of the way she CHOSE to act towards everyone....

@mrb3888 11 ай бұрын

@@lancemill5683 don’t take it personally. Just a dude pie by TTI to say the right words. Never seen a lick of manual labor in his life.

@TadpoleTrainer 5 ай бұрын

Like you said, your pilot holes aren’t properly sized… the first part of your hole should be the same width of the unthreaded portion of the lag for the entire length of the unthreaded portion. If you were driving the lag into two different pieces of timber, the top piece would be drilled out to the width all the way through then your pilot hole would be slightly smaller than the inner diameter of the threaded portion.

@fcoram72 3 ай бұрын

The impact wrench wins for that size lag screws without pilot holes.

@SuS_NuG_It 4 ай бұрын

I'd like to point something out. That quarter inch impact is the absolute worst tool for the job by one simple metric, it worked hardened that lag bolt. Did anybody else bother to notice the smoke coming out of the log? If your lag bolt is getting so hot from your impact driver running it, that it is smoking the wood, you need to fucking stop. That impact is putting so much unnecessary force into that flag bolt, that you have probably work hardened it, and put it at a substantially increased risk of being a weaker than it should be, and weaker than it was specked to be. I'll take a drill that can't do it over an impact that fucks up my lag any day of the week. If you had a drill strong enough, like you should have, the Drew would have been a thousand times faster than both of those impacts, because impacts are not meant for continuous torque, they are meant for high amounts of instant torque repeatedly. High impact instant torque, is not what you use to drill holes, or run lags. Constant torque is. Because constant torque lets you overcome static friction, something that those impacts have to fight every single time that impact rotation stops. Which is why that smaller impact was making your log smoke.

@Kaleb_RoSs 4 ай бұрын

@@SuS_NuG_It proper thing to do is drill a pilot hole and then run it in with the drill. Shouldn’t be driving lags without pilot holes ever

@leeedwardtayson9141 3 ай бұрын

Lags as big as shown in the video must have a pilot hole as big as the unthreaded part of the lag for a drill to work. A drill is a very versatile tool. Almost doing all power tool tasks just by a drill. But without a pilot hole, impacts are better. Because that's where torsional impacts shine. First of all, impacts are meant to metal works which includes nut busting, bolt tightening, and wheel nuts. It just so happens that it can rotate and can drive a screw. The only thing that impacts are good is preventing too much strain on the arms of the user. Nothing more aside from being compact. And yeah, I do agree with you with the pressure the lag is experiencing due to the repeated instantaneous impacts from the driver and wrench which causes the material to smoke weakening its molecular structure. But this is just an exception for lags this huge. Mostly, impacts are better and safer to handle. You can't be drilling this above a 12' ladder using a drill then kickback sets in.

@josephmerz2666 6 ай бұрын

i still use lags for work occassionally . i have results that reflect yours also .i find this is just to hard on the drill and me to use on lags . an anti kick back feature would help but still not the tool for the job . impact drivers break adapters ,though i like the speed they offer . could you try a bigger right angle drill .i would like to see your results . before impact drivers came on the market this was my go-to for big construction screws .

@Kaleb_RoSs 6 ай бұрын

@@josephmerz2666 definitely! I plan on experimenting with this a little further with say some corded drills, joist drills and so on

@Tom-x3m9g 11 ай бұрын

Good clip, did you try the drill on#1 setting, mine is more powerful on 1 and faster on 2

@Kaleb_RoSs 11 ай бұрын

Yea was on mode 1 the whole time, more torque. Same with the flex at the end

@ssergei 10 ай бұрын

Tools with Soalz left the chat😂 thank for demo, real life example of real things outside the garage, simple things that ma'am just cannot understand😁

@mtasubwaymartasubway 9 ай бұрын

soAlZ is a clown 🤡

@leeedwardtayson9141 3 ай бұрын

Bro. Wood is harder in the center

@TacticalThib 11 ай бұрын

Okay let's start by saying every tool has its own purpose, impact wrench large bolts nuts and occasionally the lag bolts but how often do you see a high torque impact wrench on a construction site? In over 30 years never!! This is why we have a drill to drill an impact driver to be compact and drive! And a high torque wrench to straight bust nuts. This a drill is all I need be is just that BS!! IN THAT CASE EVERYONE WOULD JUST BE WALKING AROUND WITH A DRILL LIKE ITS THE 90'S AGAIN. I remember when the cordless impact driver came out they were weak and so were the drills!! They were all brushed and if you needed power you grabbed a corded drill 😂 I think some of these older guys are just stuck in the past 😂 still listening 🎧 to the same rock and roll Eric the bearded fool guy is doing test that have no purpose but pure intertainment like everything was made to drive these same ole lags in stumps. And tools with trolls thinks RIGID is a gift to mankind and Makita lxt xgt are somehow gay lemme tell him Ridgid is for cheap bastards who can't afford Milwaukee. Not to say Ridgid doesn't have good tools but every tool company has good tools and they have straight ass tools!!! Seriously I'm in every platform except default because I felt played after owning a impact wrench and the board going out and I received a bill so I sold everything, dewalt and took a huge loss!! This shit is going to start adding up!! Watch what I'm telling you. To have the newest tools Everytime something drops is just not sustainable. Just keep doing what you're doing and you should get monetized humor bro works for you, it just takes time. And if anyone gets offended IDGAF 😂

@Kaleb_RoSs 11 ай бұрын

Well said my guy. I have a bunch of different brands already and just having a good time lmao. I like making the “comedic” videos but I can’t do only those type of videos lmao but those are the most fun haha.

@Kaleb_RoSs 11 ай бұрын

My dad always handed me a ratched to put a lag into a pilot hole. Never have I ever needed to drive one this large though. I’m sure people need to but not me. I am however putting in 1/2” x 10 tapcons to anchor guardrail bollards and product wracking daily. Using the Hilti rotory hammer and Milwaukee 2767.

@SMOKEY-JAYS-DIESEL 11 ай бұрын

At construction sites. There was mobile air compressors. At least that's the way we did it before. A lot of the battery stuff was any good and there was always air powered half inch impact guns along with air nail guns. Problem solved 👍🏼🎯

@Kaleb_RoSs 11 ай бұрын

@@SMOKEY-JAYS-DIESEL I do want to get a air compressor to start testing air tools as well