When Panzers Raced Against Time to Save the 6th Army at Stalingrad

[@jamesmullikin3045]

That is the downside of blitzkrieg battle doctrine, if your opponent isn't knocked out with a decisive blow. there isn't a plan B only blitzkrieg.

[@MD21037]

It would've been interesting to see how things would've gone if Manstein had the 12 divisions he had requested, and assembled in time for this operation.

[@user-vk6tn1ie7k]

Esp with unlimited land to retreat into.

[@tjanderson5892]

The biggest flaw w/ the blitzkrieg is that it inherently leaves your flanks wide open and vulnerable. If you're defending against it then it's not actually a bad idea to just avoid the heavy armor up front entirely and counter attack its flanks. You just have to make sure you dont allow yourself to get encircled or its gg well played

[@dittoditto7283]

It's not called the 6th Panzer Division for nothing. The army's commander throughout its existence, SS-Oberstgruppenführer Josef Dietrich said in early 1945: "We call ourselves the 6th Panzer Army, because we've only got 6 Panzers left. LOL

[@ToddiusMaximus]

The eastern front was insane

[@daleburrell6273]

...THAT'S THE TRUTH-(!)

[@JohnEglick-oz6cd]

My mom's pop was kia at Kursk mid July 1943 . He was a major in the 2nd Waffen SS Panzer Grenadier "DAS REICH " Div . Her uncle was a Colonel in the Luftwaffe , kia when his FW190 was shot near Anzio , Italy early March 1944 .

[@partygrove5321]

Glad he bought it @@JohnEglick-oz6cd

[@JohnEglick-oz6cd]

@@partygrove5321 I don't think he got any food allowance to buy food ; whether it was my mother s pop , or uncle . Hope that's what you meant . My mom went through hell fleeing the USA nslaught of the Soviet military juggernaut barreling it's way toward Berlin . She wound up in Leipzig , Germany ,vAnd witnessed bitter street fighting between American , and Nazi forces . Eventually she was sexually assaulted by an American soldier(s) . She had nightmares for years , but she was alleviated of that by being prescribed psych meds , which stop taking as she got better about 26 years ago . Part of her nightmares was the harrowing time her brother ,vAnd sister , andmom had in escaping Communist East Germany in 1948;.She and her sister , and bro ade it unscathed to the Western part of Germany .

[@hauntedmoodylady]

I very much commend them, you, and your memory of them..

[@davidkubik537]

thi is some good quality stuff, thanks for this, love the sounds background

[@FactBytes]

Glad you like them!

[@davidkubik537]

if I may ask what is the source of your material ? its pretty detailed regaring this important operation @@FactBytes

[@tonnywildweasel8138]

Excellent vid! Thanks, appreciate it a lot 👍 Greets from the Netherlands ✌, T.

[@FactBytes]

Glad it was helpful!

[@alexbowman7582]

Panzer general Hans Valentin Hube was ordered by Hitler to fly out the kessel to which he replied “I took my men into Stalingrad, I’ve ordered them to fight to the last bullet, I intend to stay and show them how”. Hitler sent in some of his personal SS guards and an unsuspecting Hube was ordered to Paulus’s HQ where he was jumped by the SS guards and dragged onto a plane out with a pistol at his head. Just over 1 year later Hube died in a plane crash.

[@kiowhatta1]

It has been proven Manstein procrastinated and never gave the actual breakout order even though Paulus urged him to do so.

[@jameswebber2943]

nonsense

[@anthonyaguirretorres3540]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/Y2Wbg2htqpp1eqc@@jameswebber2943

[@Le42975]

It's true Holy Mannstein never did!

[@captainhurricane5705]

Let me rephrase your comment - It has been proven that Hitler procrastinated and never gave the actual breakout order even though Manstein urged him to do so.

[@jayo3074]

Pure rubbish

[@creightonleerose582]

These vids are interesting, well done bearing top-notch editing/production value(s)! Thank you for sharing these historical data-points & participants accounts with us. A short 15 min vid takes some serious TIME to assemble, present & properly narrate. That fact isnt lost on me...;) I'd read in one of my books an account of either a panzer crewmen or associated/attached MOT panzer-grenadier trooper from within the pocket, being pretty close to the MLR/Axis=Allied termination lines, well outside/West of Stalingrad city limits proper. He'd said the weather was near blizzard/white out conditions during the OP, w/knee, thigh or even waist deep snow drifts in many places, he recalled the sense of buoyancy & lift in spirits of just hearing of the coming plan concerning the relief corridor being punched through to them... -Then when they began hearing the distant sounds of combat, flashes n' deep thumps on the horizon, growing ever n' ever closer by the hour, by the coming/nearing volume of sounds, flash & thunder of it all. Many of those motorized forward units had received orders & began furiously busying themselves with readying/inspecting/fueling/arming equipment, no matter how exhausted they or their machines may have been. As they would be the very units used to punch

[@jameswebber2943]

amazing footage and great material

[@FactBytes]

Thanks for visiting

[@edward6902]

Manstein never gave that breakout order to Paulus on December 19th

[@MunchyDean-h8x]

He should have done so as later Eric Manstein pulled out of Rostov and was able to stop General (spelling here?) Chukov and later retake Rostov and prolong the end of the war so yes he should have said break out , however those decisions were mostly down to the great battlefield fool , the corporal from Bohemia Hitler himself.

[@MD21037]

Hitler would've forbade it anyway.

[@briankorbelik2873]

Von Mansrein did everything but. It was Paulu's fault. He was a great staff officer, but had no place on the battlefield. Too bad fot the Germans that thaey didn't have a Model, Hube, von Manstein, or a Bayerlein commanding 6th Army. Instead they had a pencil pusher.

[@kolla5415]

Even if he gave the order, Hitler would refused the order and gave the hold at all cost order to Paulus.

[@AlaskaErik]

Contrary to what was stated in the video von Manstein never issued the breakout order to 6th Army.

[@davidkubik537]

this might be true,but also not, everyone can lie

[@AlaskaErik]

@@davidkubik537 It's pretty well documented.

[@davidkubik537]

it is not, basicaly what youre saying is that everything what is in Mansteins memoirs is right,well myself i dont believe it and stick to the narrative of this vid, doesnt matter anyway..@@AlaskaErik

[@AlaskaErik]

@@davidkubik537 von Mannstein's version of WW 2 lays all the blame of his failures on others. Consider it a work of fiction with some elements of actual history in it.

[@dedejod1199]

True

[@briankorbelik2873]

Von Hunersdorff and Franz Bake will be heard from again. 57th Panzer Korps achieved wonders considering it's size. However, before, during, and after Winterstorm, the 11th Panzer Division, (the Ghost Division from their adopted logo and the 16th Motorized Infantry Division, continually created small miracles from the German side. The 11th Panzer,before, during,and after,Winter Storm, would March into position all night, then fight during the days, over and over for weeks, and only gawd knows the times that they were successful at that. The 11th Panzer Division was Das Heer's miracle division. And one of the best PD's ever. This info I read in the late '60's from, Paul Carrell's " Hitler Moves East". And then there was the then 16th Motorized InfantryPanzergrenadier division, who got to the Astrakan rail line and dispensed false info to the rail yard in far off Asrtakan.

[@rogercude1459]

Stalin was always worried that the Allies would work out a deal with Hitler so they didn't have to invade Europe. That way he could bring all his forces to the East.

[@adrianariaratnam5817]

A well narrated piece, with excellent footage. Thanks.

[@FactBytes]

Many thanks!

[@jasonmussett2129]

Excellent documentary. Great footage. Thanks👍

[@FactBytes]

Many thanks!

[@jasonmussett2129]

@@FactBytes you're welcome😀

[@obedlucksom5636]

Thanks for the video, i have always been eager that even Heinz Guderian couldnot save the 6th army, i have heard that he nearly made it to the 6th army.

[@jameswebber2943]

I think you are confused with Moscow in 1941

[@obedlucksom5636]

@@jameswebber2943 you ignorant dont speak what you dont know abt, hope in your dreams you have heard abt fighting at Moscow.

[@captainhurricane5705]

lmao

[@BlorbusUnimax]

there was no greater commander than manstein, in modern history

[@obedlucksom5636]

@@BlorbusUnimax yes, he was a grest strategists, his ideas are even used today on modern battlefield.

[@mikesbaseballcards]

Great combat footage I've never seen b4. When i see this footage i just can't believe my Opa survived the eastern front in Army Group South. He was at the Maikop oilfields & Sebastopol. Was a Corporal. I actually have a photo of my Opa on the eastern front with a fellow soldier standing in the snow next to a kubelwagen. My Uncle Willie was captured by the Russians sent to Siberia & didn't come back until 1955. He was at our house one time when I was a little boy & was so drunk my Tante Martha had to take him home.

[@billd2635]

Decent doc, Thanx for this Some good footage here

[@phillipchapman169]

I incredible and sad for brother to kill brother. The war between Russia and Germany shows in no matter how well trained, or how good the equipment or tactics or strategy, or even how determined one is. If you haven’t got the numbers to realistically see it through you are far less likely to win and almost certainly likely to lose big - all the way to Berlin it seems. Russia had the numbers, Germany didn’t. If your going to fight a titan, you’d damn best be sure you made all necessary considerations and preparations, or don’t bother at all. I wonder if as I hear Mr H felt it was only a matter of time before Russia attacked West, he’d have faired better not exhausting his forces trying to conquer, but used the time to dig in and prepare. Then maybe the Russians will have been similarly ground down in their attacks and the people of Russia and Stalin’s armies may have become demoralised compared to the fervour and grit they had when defending their homeland and then pressing on to Berlin. Attacking scenarios often seem to use a greater amount of resources compared to a well dug in defence where you pick off your enemy as they come to you. Says me the arm chair general not 😂 . How about we don’t fight each other and just get on with our lives.

[@fazole]

He couldn't "dig in". He was getting oil from the USSR and his economy was dependent on it, since there were embargoes against Germany. Furthermore, he wanted OUT of the international trade and banking system in order to achieve autarchy. He needed oil, raw materials and land to supply his idea of empire, just as Great Britain had those things. Therefore, due to his plans, the only course was to conquer Russia and Ukraine. This has all been researched in many books.

[@scottjoseph9578]

​​@fazole Yes, but Stalin was supplying him. Supplying 2 more Panzer divisions in Africa and not invading Russia would have driven the British out of the Middle East. With that oil, and the ability to go North from Iran, the Russian German War would have gone differently. Hitler never thought methodically, Thank God. You understand, I'm discussing a change in April, 1941. No reason not to hold off invading Russia.

[@mirandela777]

If H. had 2 working braincells, and made a full trade pact with Stalin, and NOT EVER attacking on the East, we all would speak german today in Europe, and who knows, even worldwide... The best german troops free to block Normandy, raw materials and oil from Russia, will be no disembark from allies, Britain eventually collapse, and murica was busy with Japan more than enough to care too much about Europe. Just do the math : 9 of 10 germans died in East fighting Russia ( URSS). If these 9 were available in Europe, US and UK could never set foot in France.

[@johnnyb2909]

stalin said that without allied lend lense they would have lost in 42. The germans didnt count with the enourmos lend lense

[@mirandela777]

@@johnnyb2909 - BS dude, Stalin never said that ! Why do you invent BS ?? Do you think peoples are illiterate idiots who believe any BS you wrote ?

[@Gnosis639]

If the 6th Panzers were sent to the east on 14 Nov 1942 how was their mission to save the 6th Army? Operation Uranus didn't kick off until the 18th and the Army wasn't officially surrounded until the 22nd of November. More than likely they were en route to the east when Uranus began and were redirected to Stalingrad. Also, the Stalingrad relief force was never promised 12 divisions. Manstein asked for 12 divisions but was never told by OKH he would receive those 12 divisions. The 5 divisions that gathered for the operation were scrapping the bottom of German manpower at the moment as the Soviets launched Operation Mars on Army Group Center maybe a week after Uranus, which was a larger operation than the one at Stalingrad. The operation never called for the 6th Army to break out to the Myshovska(don't no spelling don't feel like looking it up) river. The 6th army didn't have enough fuel or ammunition to fight their way that far and was clear about that from the beginning. Manstein never ordered the breakout, he lied in his book about the 6th Army to save his prestige. Paulus never ordered his army to break out because he knew it was absolutely impossible for his Army to make it that far. The problem is most historians take their information from Manstein and it has been proven through records that he lied..... ALOT.

[@kiowhatta1]

The only hope in relieving Stalingrad Manstein proposed was to give him operational freedom over the 1st Pz army in the Caucasus. While risky, significant armoured units like the III Pz Corps and SS Wiking could have been withdrawn North to give Manstein the necessary forces. Manstein said to Hitler: ‘give me operational freedom over all of army group South and I will give you the oil of the Caucasus.’ This was the only option available and if 57th Pz Corps could almost reach Stalingrad then those additional forces might have had the strength to breakthrough-and even perhaps retain a position near the general area. Additionally, the II SS Pz Corps ought to have been rushed asap to the area despite it being involved in Case Anton, the occupation of Vichy France? What the hell was it doing there when standard German divisions could have done the job. Also, the evacuation of the Rhzev salient would have shortened the line in AGC’s area which held the 2nd & 3rd Pz armies. Every risk should have been taken to rescue 6th army which consisted of many valuable divisions capable of being rehabilitated, re-equipped and aided in the overall plan to retake the original positions on the Volga. I’ll never understand why Hitler didn’t allow Manstein a free hand in throwing the absolute very last gamble to stay in the war.

[@captainhurricane5705]

Because Hitler was an idiot

[@obedlucksom5636]

Hitler was delusional, he didnt care for his soldiers, your indepth analysis are amazing, thanks for the post.

[@Axelfl6161]

Hitler by that time was a physical and mental wreck and wouldn’t listen.

[@ElbertWR]

It would have been too little too late.

[@DavidKalnbach-vm3xc]

...because...the Germans did back then what we R doing now...ever hear of the Peter-Priniple ? it states that U must promote everyone to their own level of highest incompetency....

[@russbrown6453]

Wow Love that footage!

[@FactBytes]

Glad you enjoyed it

[@RememberingWW2]

18:12 Manstien never gave Paulus the "Thunderclap" breakout order. This is false.

[@Jan.99]

Cool stuff... Panzers were known to fight well however, they couldn't go beyond their limits as a matter of fact

[@jasonmack896]

If paulus had initiative to make a breakout its possible that some would have made it

[@skrayraja]

Had Paulua been allowed to break out of stalingrad, at least some of his men would have survived to fight another day. One more of Hitlers mistakes

[@asullivan4047]

Interesting and informative. Excellent photography job enabling viewers to better understand what/whom the orator was describing. Special thanks to veteran soldiers/civilians Sharing personal information/combat experiences. Enabling historians to replicate diaries/memoirs for future generations to better appreciate the hardships/sacrifices that those in combat endured. A valiant effort but it was all in vain to save the surrounded Stalingrad German military forces. The WW-1 dispatch runner 🏃‍♀️ corporal Hitler. Was to blame for that catastrophic military operations failure.

[@jimcase3097]

Very cool 💯

[@genekelly8467]

They never had a chance..plus Hitler ordered 6th Army to "stand fast and no retreats". Hitler had already written them off (and promoted Paulus to Field Marshal so he's commit suicide).

[@bernardantoinerouffaer7578]

Très bien fait.

[@michaelcodelmar9547]

Could have saved the 6th army if they were allowed to retreat early ..could have made a breakthrough...but wasn't meant to be ..Wrong clip during that time there were still no Tigers but Panzers Mark III and IV

[@jameswebber2943]

there are no Tigers I this clip

[@stevelopez372]

True, and Hitlers no retreat order really meant fight to the last man. Over 75,000 German troops marched off to Siberia. A tiny percentage would ever see home again.

[@mohammedsaysrashid3587]

Germans always fought furiously and stubbornly during WW2. 6 panzer army did the best they could to rescue 6 army in Stalingrad while General Manstein was not allowed 6 army to launched breaking out operations in meantime Adolf Hitler was not permitted General Paulus to retreat one meter from front lines...this video clearly explained and showed the bleak circumstances and furiously attacks of 6 panzer army to penetrating the encirculment form out of Stalingrad pockets.

[@juhopuhakka2351]

tik has very interesting series about this.

[@joegrossinger3381]

Yes the Germans had great soldiers. So did the Russians, Brits, Americans and the rest. There was no braver soldier than Americans going up against Tiger tanks with the early M4 Shermans. Those were real soldiers with real guts taking a real beating and still coming out on top.

[@juhopuhakka2351]

@@joegrossinger3381 They had shit loads of artillery,total control of skies,unlimited fuel and ammo,and numerical superority at least 5:1.But you are right,then there were cowards and heroes in all armies including Italy.

[@charlesc.9012]

@@joegrossinger3381 There were only 4 tigers in France during operation Overlord. Most reported "tigers" were Pz.IV-H and J variants. If you wanted "real" soldiers, the Finnish are unmatched. With no ability to make and maintain tanks, most of their stunning achievements were accomplished with light infantry with no bazookas or heavy AT guns, and against soviet tank units. Despite being outnumbered 3:1 and with no foreign aid, they achieved the best possible outcome against the ussr

[@footisman2059]

@@charlesc.9012Soviet troops managed to halt barbarossa, deeming it a complete failure, despite being outnumbered 3-to-1 too but on a much wider front, before proceding to, unlike the finns, win the war through sheer heroism and force of will.

[@zoltanszolnoki3093]

Franz Bäke 💥

[@davidalexoff1658]

I wonder when, exactly, the Germans figured out, maybe this wasn't such a good idea.

[@mirquellasantos2716]

Those brutes were too violent to get the hint.

[@recoil53]

Both the Germans and Japanese thought they could somehow turn it around even close to the end. I figure the sane ones that could take a step back started getting that feeling when their offenses were stopped. Look at the logic of come of the Axis operations. Somehow the Ardeness offensive (Battle of the Bulge) if successful was going to physically split the Allies while causing so much dissent that they would make peace with Germany. You know, instead of the Allies just bombing the hell out of the German supply lines and crushing the Germans in Antwerp. Meanwhile, the Japanese kept thinking they could somehow crush the US Navy. The odds were like winning back to back lotteries.

[@Axelfl6161]

1942

[@joegrossinger3381]

When they could not take Moscow.

[@davidcunningham2074]

amazing story.

[@FactBytes]

Glad you enjoyed it

[@marcelgroen6256]

Isn't it strange that they had their assignment to free up the 6th army on 14th November as Operation Uranus just started 19th November?

[@michaelcodelmar9547]

The Russians were just too many...Plain and simple

[@warrenlewis3977]

They had plenty of gas too 😂

[@oroyodowansingh9127]

Simple has that. Nazi Germany crumbled under the Soviet numbers alone.

[@СергейЗнамин]

Немцев тоже было не мало, но ими управлял авантюрист!

[@jayswanginfit8634]

A valiant effort by the Germans, they were closer to 6th army than I thought.

[@AmnesiaGm1]

Actually not. Even with twice more power they would have not reached them.

[@GuitarMan22]

Ultimately OKW esp Hilter were stuck in a ww1 mentality. Flexibility in command was needed after the original success of earlier blitzkrieg.

[@wattage2007]

I wish we could get humans reading these scripts. This explosion of text to speech technology isn’t cutting it for me.

[@robertmartinez4174]

"those Germans lost the war & their country for believing in Hitler". my late father a WW2 veteran of the European theater.

[@Dominic_Amoe]

You know nothing.

[@robertmartinez4174]

@@Dominic_Amoe maybe so but my father knew everything about the war in Europe during WW2. he was a guard at a POW camp in France. gestapo and SS . if you weren't there, "You Know Nothing".

[@duniagowes]

Was it true that Hitler didnt give Paulus permission to retreat & thus joined the 4th Army? Such a mind blowing decision if it's true. Soviet had gathered 2 million army to trap 6 Army with months of preparation. All I know is Paulus was reluctant to break, told Meinstein that his force is too weak with lack of amo,supplies, etc. Please CMIIW.

[@RafeHusain]

so many wins yet still lost. Soviet forces have a resilience that is ignored

[@jabersawaya7131]

Magnificent attack in dire wether and out numbered in men and equipment

[@TheSpritz0]

MAYBE with double the force they MIGHT have broken through but too little too late…they are lucky they themselves were not encircled!!

[@BlorbusUnimax]

if paulus would have fought at the same time to break out it might have worked

[@ElbertWR]

The 6th Army had no fuel, food, ammunition and very few troops available.

[@BlorbusUnimax]

they were receiveing at that time 50-100 tons of supplies per day -short the 400 tons necessary but certainly enough to provide for a sizable striking element. This is within a month of being surrounded some reserves were probably on hand. Manstein's relief force had gotten within 20 miles of stalingrad it is conceivable had this been coordinated with an attempted break out a corridor could have been established.@@ElbertWR

[@joegrossinger3381]

Exactly! The 6th army was already done for by the time Manstein got around to trying to break them out. @@ElbertWR

[@BlorbusUnimax]

it actually wasnt, the breakout was within in 3-4 week of being surrounded. There was still fighting capacity especially given in one direction. It is possible that a breakout could have occurred with the same results of the Cherkassy pocket. I am conceding the 6th army being surrounded at stalingrad allowed Manstein perhaps the most stunning victory of ww2 in halting and destroying the South Russian army front at the end of winter 43. I am just saying there was a possibility for a breakout given that they were at that time getting supplies and the supply chain could have supplied 400 tons a day if Goering had not been put in charge of resupply. A fraction of the German luftwaffe was committed to resupplying the 6th. There are alot of hypotheticals, the whole situation is hypothetical so it is ok to say what if. If the 6th army would have been savedArmy group A and B would have had a tough slog to save themselves and could have led to the the collapse of Army Group South i understand this. @@joegrossinger3381

[@JamesJames-jt3ts]

Something doesn't make sense here. Those panzer units were assembled for what purpose? To rescue the 6th army from the pocket right? So, if they arrived at 48km from Stalingrad why didn't Paulus receive the order to break from the pocket? If Paulus was not allowed to leave the pocket why this unit was sent there, just to cover the distance and retreat?

[@jamesmcdonald5026]

The English had broken the German codes, and they passed troop movements on to the Soviet Union. The Germans never had a chance.

[@ElbertWR]

They only intercepted a fraction of the German transmissions and of those they could only decode a fraction. The British had no receiving posts in Russia. Germany's real problem was lack of oil. That is why Hitler want to concur the oil fields in the Caucasus, but he and his Generals got distracted by Stalingrad.

[@jamesmcdonald5026]

@@ElbertWR People in the British government passed along critical information. They told the Soviets that the Germans had weak support on their flanks during the siege of Stalingrad.

[@ElbertWR]

@@jamesmcdonald5026 The Russians already knew that the Romanian forces on the flanks were weaker.

[@jamesmcdonald5026]

@@ElbertWR Perhaps. But it is a fact they did get information. Consider that fact while reviewing the above article.

[@ElbertWR]

@@jamesmcdonald5026 Operation Uranus was not the first counter attack on the flanks of the German 6th Army. For months the Russians had been attacking the flanks closer to Stalingrad and incurred tremendous losses. If they had British intel about weaker flanks further west and south held by Romanians they would have attacked there much sooner. The Romanians were actually hard fighters but thinly spread, with little anti tank equipment and they did not receive the German support that was promised.

[@yangho8]

It was the time german lack of strategic. Soviet already asmass force to drive to rostov. Even the panzer reach stalingrad, they could also cut out. But stalin affaird the 6th army escaped so he asked generals modified the plan. It helped german bought time for 4th tank army escaped but 6th army fate sealed

[@TheZdojcin]

No way that 6th army would be saved. The Russians had Zukov the genius

[@1974charlatan]

Zhukov is vastly overated as a military commander,if you have an endless supply of men and casualties mean nothing to you then its easy to just keep pouring troops into the fray even his own troops called him " the butcher" the loss rate in his forces would not have been accepted in any other army essentialy zhukov was fighting ww2 with ww1 tactics

[@billd2635]

At 18:00 Right there, thats where the "Blitzkrieg" image is misunderstood by so many Most of the infantry either walked or rode on horse-drawn wagons And this was tried in Winter no less?

[@Bledi838]

What an heroic fight under such weather conditions of the 6-th Panzer division!

[@mirandela777]

Heroic or plain stupid ?? Logistics ! They run out of ammo long before they could get near, and even IF they could enter Stalingrad - what the f... they could do there ? With no ammo, no fuel, no food ?? Idiots.... this was just a propaganda sacrifice, and ze germans, always brainwashed to follow their leaders to the hell, just swallow not only the hook but the line as well. Only an idiot could do something so stupid, lose so many man and armor, for a stupid objective - H. order was clear and loud - NOBODY retreats from Stalingrad - then, I ask - why those idiots rushed there, in first place ?? To do WHAT ??? Maybe they wish to die / fall prisoners - with the others ?? ...

[@towgod7985]

Informative video. Robovoice is a pain. Hire a teenager to voice the video if you have to.

[@Neapoleone-Buonaparte]

MEINSTEIN NEVER ISSUES BREAKOUT ORDERS TO PAULUS AND THE 6TH ARMY AT STALINGRAD!

[@petetrimble6124]

You need to read von Manstein's "Lost Victories" and you would think otherwise. Von Manstein did not want to enter Stalingrad for fear of getting trapped himself. He got within 20km and wanted von Paulus to break out to meet him.

[@Neapoleone-Buonaparte]

@@petetrimble6124 THE LAST BOOK I WANT TO READ IS THAT DISHONORABLE NAZI CELEBRITY VON MEINSTEIN'S SELF-EXCULPATORY AUTOBIOGRAPHY OF LIES, AS WELL AS CONVENIENT SLANDER ON THE HONORABLE HERO VON PAULUS! MEINSTEIN NEVER HAD ANY VICTORIES LOST!

[@joegrossinger3381]

The war was all over for Germany when they got kicked back from Moscow.

[@GetRidOfCivilAssetForfeiture]

Exactly. The Germans had more than lost momentum at Moscow, they had lost the aura of invincibility.

[@rowdied9829]

It was lost when they declared war on the US.

[@silversurfer640]

joegrossinger3381 As it turned out, thats probably it.

[@JohnEglick-oz6cd]

After the 1st6 months of " Operation Barbarossa " the Germans suffered nearly 800000 casualties . Although , many German positions held , and the Soviet Offensive wore out , the German Army attenuated forces were a result of the 1st 6 mo's. of brutal fighting . Attenuated German forces had a direct result in the not able to take Stalingrad , or capable to give a final knockout blow to take Stalingrad .

[@ChrisZukowski88]

if the Germans had settled down and defended instead of pointlessly driving on Kursk, I think the East wouldve stalemated until the West forced the Germans to retreat.

[@josephgraham4531]

Wasn't it the 6th army that defeated the french in 1940

[@silversurfer640]

josephgraham4531 Yes it was. Hitler said " the 6th army would march to the moon if I ordered them to".

[@Januszekm56]

The rapid recovery of losses and uninterrupted production ensured the USSR's victory.

[@aurorathekitty7854]

You didn't mention all the prisoners taken at Stalingrad only about 5k would see home again

[@georgen.p.6452]

I would like to use these videos with a voice over in another language and re-upload. What's your opinion?

[@p5parker]

Unsere tapferen Soldaten 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

[@joegrossinger3381]

Yes, German soldiers were tough and brave. So were Russian soldiers, British soldiers and American soldiers. Soldiers, sailors, airmen.

[@tkyap2524]

Despite the harassment by the Russians on the rescue column, success was a whisker away. However, its fighting strength was chipped away and had to retreat or face a rout. The 6th Army could have succeeded in breaking out had Hitler agreed to it. As a fighting force, the Germans were more disciplined. Bad planning can't make up for finesse.

[@mirandela777]

What you call "bad planing" I call incompetent, even stupid commanders. Those idiots were sent to die. Most peoples here have no clue even the most mighty tank is just a pile of scrap metal if it not have right on his trails several trucks with fuel, ammo, food, and technicians.

[@APOLON-bm7ym]

If I didnt know the outcome, after 15 minutes I would be convinced they will make it... Nice video, most of us just heard that Panzers failed to relief the 6th army - but they actually caused very heavy losses to SSSR... Germany was winning with inferior tanks and lossing with superior ones. I wonder, if they had jet fighters in 1940 and "big cats" in 1941....

[@ElbertWR]

Would not have made much difference, they never had enough oil and fuel for their aircraft and vehicles.

[@APOLON-bm7ym]

@@ElbertWR... and if they managed to take Caucasus oil fields? If USSR failed? If Wehrmacht had soviet supplies? That was their plan...

[@lisanalgaib555]

@@APOLON-bm7ym I always wonder why they attacked the USSR when they got the fuel and other supplies by trade. The Soviets delivered all they had agreed in the Molotov Rippentrop pact. To attack the USSR just for supplies, when they can have it by trade makes no sense. Since I have seen some alternative videos, I got the impression they feared the USSR could get too strong and would have attacked them a year later. So, they attacked them in 1941 and hoped they would collapse fast. The supplies would than be available and the danger in the east would have gone.

[@APOLON-bm7ym]

@@lisanalgaib555 Imagine 1940, Wehrmacht ocupied almost all f the Europe, Britain stood alone, but they couldnt do nothing else but try to defend their island. French army was considered stronger than German, yet Wehrmacht erased them in few weeks, together with british expeditionary forces. AH said about soviet army "we just need to kick d door and the whole rotten structure will colapse"... Beside, they didnt attack SSSR jzst for oil, but primarily "living space for master race" and AH thought communism is jewish creation etc.. Watching nowadays situation he was not that wrong when thought "jews rule the world"... He thought jews "infected" Earth, and even if he defeated SSSR he would go further, until last jew (actualy 25% jew)....

[@lisanalgaib555]

@@APOLON-bm7ym Well, first of all Britain didn't stood alone. They had their whole empire behind them. Also, Hitler wanted peace with Britain and France. He offered several times a white peace. Churchill didn't want peace. Second why would Hitler need living space? The birth rate in Germany was below 2.1 already in the 1920. He might have speculated on Ukraine's grain, since Germany was on Food Ration after Britain put a trade embargo on Germany. The perception that the USSR was a rotten structure might be a reason why he believed he could win within a summer campaign. But, since I have seen some of the videos (good ones) from a KZbinr called Zoomer Historian, I got a new point of view.

[@davidhimmelsbach557]

In all the histories, it is omitted that the Soviets were able to decrypt German Enigma signals -- for the first time. The British, via a Soviet mole, (Carincross) were feeding the Reds the critical code key solution every day. They could NOT figure this out on their own. ( They needed Alan Turing's 'bombe' to figure it out. ) The Reds HAD captured an Enigma machine which was -- contrary to orders -- co-located with the Hungarian army -- up north. The Red special forces grabbed it during a white-out. (!) Yes, they found it when you couldn't see your hands in front of your face. The TERRIBLE weather -- especially in the mornings -- is being omitted in every popular account -- both sides. But, it's grounding the Luftwaffe until the afternoon, every day. The fresh snow, every night, was removing all evidence of Red anti-tank guns. THESE are what was destroying the panzers. They were demoralized by these ambush kills, of course. THIS is why the generals stopped the panzer thrust. The unending amounts of anti-tank positions did to the 6th Panzer what minefields have done to the Ukrainian counter-offensive of 2023. That is, they just took tanks out of the equation. At this very hour, the UA is absorbed with de-mining. That's why the counter-offensive has 'stalled.' It'll pick back up once the liberated zone is cleaned up. In the meantime, it's a total shoot-'em up... attrition warfare.

[@kovesp1]

"... feeding the Reds the critical code key solution every day. " They could not do that, becasue there was no full break into the Enigma since the Poles accomplished that in the mid 1930-s. Turing's Bombe was just a further elaboration of Rejewski's Bomba the plans of which were handed to the Brits in 1939. The Bombe, together with Turing's heuristics ("Banbarismus" and "Turringery") only enabled breaks on some days, but not on others. As well, Enigma was used for tactical traffic between OKW/OKH and Army Groups, not for strategic traffic ... that was transmitted using the Lorenz SZ40 (and later SZ42A/SZ42B) which was partially broken in 1942 and fully (using Colossus built by Tommy Flowers and Max Newman with minor input from Turing) at the end of 1943. Enigma traffic was transmitted by radio and there was no concievable reason that tactical message traffic pertaining to the Eastern Front would be transmitted in Western Europe ... the only radio traffic that could be monitored in the UK. And of course the Soviets could not figure it out on their own, becasue neither could the Brits and Fench. It was due to a decade of pionerring work by Marian Rejewski, Henryk Zygalski and Jerzy Różycki in the Polish Cipher Bureauwhich the Brits received on a platter. Conclusion: your claim of Cairncross passing Engima initial settings of the day to the Soviets makes no sense becasue the Brits were able to work those out only intermittently on a day-by-day basis, sometimes so late in the day that the decyrpts were no longer of much use. Passing decrypted traffic makes even less sense, since the pertinent traffic could not be monitored in the UK. And in any case, how could Cairncross pass large amounts of decrypts?

[@Radrook353]

So Hitler expected that tank army to fight its way into Stalingrad and get trapped as well?

[@jacobjonm0511]

where were tiger tanks in this operation?

[@calebrush3833]

Nice cushy set up in France , "'Right lads load up ,we're off to the Eastern front '.

[@aurathedraak7909]

Too bad this wasn't in color, that would be neat. But I know I know.

[@aaweys5909]

I am not nazi sympathiser, I’m also not judging who’s write who’s wrong, but I solute those man who sacrificed their lives to rescue, their flow country man.

[@gaborkorthy8355]

"Paulus was not the type of general to disobey an order even if that were in the best interest of his army" said it all.

[@Radrook353]

Well, he wasn't that finicky when it finally came down to his own survival.

[@marklandon9058]

...and thus Stalingrad was relieved... not.

[@user-pu1xq9ef9u]

I think Moscow battle was beginning of the end. But El Alamein and Stalingrad was the final nail in the coffin for Germany.

[@bookaufman9643]

There's nothing much dumber than horses versus tanks.

[@antoniostamndley8272]

Can't believe, Eastern front , the biggest blunder, Napoleon taught them nothing, winter is the biggest enemy, in all wars , Korea as Well, a bridge to far, also, supply is crucial,

[@GlenBragdon]

The war was over the second Germany attacked . Should have kept treaty with soviets until they kicked British out of Egypt

[@paparucoontour]

And then... they all died.

[@alanburton1277]

I love how everyone has an opinion as if they're experts 🤣🤣🤣

[@joegrossinger3381]

If you don't have an opinion why are you here posting?

[@alanburton1277]

@@joegrossinger3381 I don't have an opinion on the video as I'm not a expert on the subject but I laugh at all these people who have opinions on what or what not to to as if they're experts so STFU!!

[@gorangoran6335]

Please, let me know the origin for this video. I would like to study some written stuff about it.

[@FactBytes]

1. Lost Victories - by Erich von Manstein 2. Panzer Aces - by Franz Kurowski

[@jimrich4192]

And then Adolf happily RETIRED to Argentina with his new wife & tons of GOLD !!! 😂😂😂

[@robertmiller2173]

Yes the Communist USSR b's had the numbers thanks to the British Empire and the USA. This is why the Battle of the Atlantic was so important; all those convoys going to Commie Land. It paid off for the west as well as on D Day Germany had 196 Divisions facing the Commie Hordes and only 65 Divisions to defend Italy and Western Europe. Thank God for the Liberty ship, the Sherman tank, the Jeep (Which was made by Ford, Willies or AMC and GM. Ford made a Liberator Bomber at the rate of 1 per hour! The Liberty ship was made in 7 days and then fully loaded with Ammo, Spam, Food, Tanks, Engines in 12 days from no ship to a ship loaded and ready to sail to Murmansk! So it was the British Empire and the USA that saved the Commies from the Germans. This is why Putin looks like a rat, but Putin has no heart, he is a ruthless killer of his own young people!

[@СергейЗнамин]

Учи Мировую Историю,а не амерскую баранья бошка

[@robertmiller2173]

@@СергейЗнамин write in letters that civilised people can understand

[@СергейЗнамин]

​@@robertmiller2173учите Русский (цивилизованный народ) и не пишите глупости

[@bobns509]

Looks that 6th Pz division was visionary: Started they journey on 14th November, 5 (FIVE!) days before Russian's offensive started. You should do a less marketing here, just give us a good story without blowing things to a not so deserved proportions. Can you tell us who insist on sending Pz.div. there and how does he knows it needs to be there ASAP? That would be more interesting part.

[@perun814]

and zhukov said there is no escape

[@bazzakeegan2243]

I like FactBytes...But why December 19th mentioned at least 4 times? NOVEMBER!

[@melvinjohnson2074]

Another example of how dumb the Nazi's were. Instead of the 6th army withdrawing while they could they stayed put. However if after encircled a relief force could punch their way in then and only then could they withdraw. What sense does that make?

[@Jerry-vx2hq]

Hitler was the idiot who blew up Stalingrad instead of just surrounding it for a siege. In Lenningrad they surrounded it but should have still traveled north to block lend lease deliveries from USA.

[@conceptalfa]

👍👍👍!!!

[@societateacomercialadegraf1796]

Raus lead 6th panzer division just amazing....i read his war diary...he describe in details this rescue operation

[@rockandroll7017]

Should regroup

[@edwardjj4224]

General Herman Hoth commander of 4 Panzer Division make Bolsheviks days very much miserable Even with less troops and armor Force's 🐯

[@joegrossinger3381]

So what? The Russians pushed the hitlerites all the way to Berlin. That's what counts.

[@palanka842]

As in all war videos german forces won every battle against soviets, but at the end, inexplicably, germans were defeated!

[@anupkumarmajumdar3997]

Always Germany under estimated the power of USSR

[@ronaldgrove3283]

Think the Germans should of won on the Eastern Front but through errors fumbled (aka gave up a goalkick). The 6th Army should of been able to breakout also if Hitler hadn't of vetoed the breakout plan.

[@theinfralink6598]

Watched the whole video. It’s clearly made from the German perspective. The whole time I was thinking Germany won and the Soviets were pretty useless 😝😀. I wonder what the Soviet would think about this.

[@ericarnow240]

Exactly! It reminds me of the US General who said to Vietnamese General Giap, "You never defeated us on the battlefield", and Giap said 'That's true but it's also irrelevant.. The video talks about all the Russia tanks destroyed, but in the end, it was German forces that were decimated. The video would have been more accurate if it described how the Germans lost in more detail. It's said that US military got its lessons from the German perspective. That is why the US keeps losing its wars, while Russia, which is constantly underestimated, usually wins, witness Ukraine.

[@theinfralink6598]

@@ericarnow240 absolutely correct

[@smoothbrush4722]

Nice video. What if the relieve force would have just push forwards and leave abtitank riergards in the city taken for a more time saving, instead of fighting every pocket of tabks near city's. Paulus was a pussy he could also brake out instead of being encircled.

[@skywings7676]

Russia Won the War Most Germany Tanks were destroyed. Dont Change the History

[@dissyduster]

They took way too long,They could have cut them off,,,,They moved fast 24 7 they were all on drugs,including .

[@peterkavanagh64]

Fait acompli. The metals object

[@erichaugustusvonmellenthin6954]

Rauss was appointed commander of 6th panzer in April of 42. Not during winter storm.

[@fshiravand]

And in the end, there was a HEROIC fight "ON THE ROAD TO BERLIN"

[@shunmohamedhassan8913]

DHIIG DHIIG

[@peterkavanagh64]

The respirves jave npt arribed . Ues its figured the metals but tjatneeds respurces ie it stops if not fed so it is death tp these debisons

[@richardkeilig4062]

Horrible war.

[@DavidISHERWOOD-iu1xn]

Photo reversed