When the ‘American Dream’ of an Indian middle class family ends in tragedy

An India family of 4 goes to cross the US border illegally. But they face their biggest enemy - the cold Canadian weather. Will they surpass it and live their American dream?
#americandream #nrilife #immigration #indianinamerica
Sources
Indian Express
Gujarat family that froze to death identified, left with all woollen clothes, toys; Vaibhav Jha; Jan 29, 2022
Hindustan Times
Gujarat family among eight who died along US-Canada border; Apr 3, 2023
Outlook
A Schoolteacher, A Baby: Gujarat Family That Froze To Death Chasing The 'American Dream'; Jan 28, 2022
Times of India
Will US illegal immigration kingpin spill beans on Dingucha deaths?; Feb 19, 2023
Dingucha victim's brother suspected of planning journey; Jan 17, 2023
Two illegal immigration agents held in case related to death of Gujarat family at Canada-US border; Jan 15, 2023
Dingucha family's last known footage aired on Canadian channel; Parth Shastri; Oct 22, 2022
Gujarat cops list 11 illegal immigration hotspots; Ashish Chauhan; Oct 13, 2022,
American nightmare: Gujarat man held in Mexico, kin ‘sent to US’; Ashish Chauhan; Jul 23, 2022
4.9k ‘left’ for US illegally despite Dingucha tragedy; Ashish Chauhan; May 10, 2022
How an Indian family froze to death on Canada-US border; Mar 18, 2022
On illegal US journey, 37 Gujarat families feared ‘missing’ in Turkey; Ashish Chauhan; Mar 14, 2022
Future citizens of US being planned in north Gujarat; Ashish Chauhan; Feb 27, 2023
Gujarat: Streets empty, shops shut as Dingucha villagers pay homage to four of family who died on US-Canada border; Jan 29, 2022
Why a rich Gujarati family paid $100,000 for illegal journey to US? Police seek answers;
Chidanand Rajghatta; Jan 29, 2022
Gujarat’s Patel family not the only victims, 3 more missing; Ashish Chauhan and Bharat Yagnik; Jan 25, 2022
New York Times
A Fatal Crossing on the Northern Border; Miriam Jordan; Mar 14, 2022
The Wire
Dingucha: A Gujarat Village Where Death Is More Lucrative Than Life; Deepal Trivedi and Janvi Sonaiya; Jan 30, 2022
The Gujarati Family That Froze to Death in Search of the 'American Dream'; Jan 24, 2022
The Week
Why and how people from Gujarat are trying to sneak into US; Nandini Oza; Apr 16, 2023
The Quint
Year After Family of 4 Froze to Death on Canada-US Border, 3 Arrested in Gujarat; Sakshat Chandok; Jan 19, 2023
The Print
Gujarat’s young men are migrating illegally to US, Canada. Only the dead get caught; Soniya Agrawal; Apr 3, 2023
Outlook
The Great Gujarati Migration And The American Dream; Darshan Desai; Apr 14, 2022
Deccan Herald
Nine US-bound persons from Gujarat go missing; immigration agent arrested; July 14, 2023

[@RijanKhanal-jh6t]

It may sound bizzare but how most land owners of Gujarat and Punjab are leaving state while having much more land influence than any other caste. Patel's of Gujarat and jatt Sikhs are the major illegal immigrants going to us why. Gujarati Jain's baniyas Nagar brahmins rajputs are not the one of immigrate from Gujarat to us. Even they have less land influence in politics than Patel's or patidars in Gujarat. Same with sikh Punjabi khatris brahmins bhatias or aroras or agarwals who have less influence in politics and land in Punjab. The main question is how a majority land owing caste of these two wealthy state of Gujarat and punjab are illegally immigrating whereas other don't why the question is that even Patel's influence and dominate Gujarat politics same with sikh jatts of Punjab

[@sparshsingla2533]

As land owners, are accustomed to easy money due to MSP based faulty procurement, reducing these communities with inability to diversify and innovate, whereas others have evolved with whatever little they had and have become affluent now, and can not leave the country to start afresh again (Darwinian cultural evolution)

[@RijanKhanal-jh6t]

@@sparshsingla2533 I think in Patel's case yes they have evolved. In my sight they have fully captured the Surat diamond market replacing palanpuri Jain's who were the rulers of a market few years ago. Billionaires like karsanbhai Pankaj Patel savji dholakia or chirayu amin are from Patel community. But again further divide happened with leuva and kadwa. These created further tension.I think rich Patel's should really help poor one's since the further educating and making Thier community more business oriented will help them in progress. Like I said Gujarat is diverse state they are 5 sections of baniyas 2 section of rajputs 4 section of brahmins. Every community is enterperneur in gujarat. I think Patel's are progressive and rich community. Even Patel's are getting trafficked by Thier own Patel's. So patidar community should think about it and focus and support patidars of north Gujarat. For the case of jatt Sikhs it's different they have hijacked Sikhism and brainwashing khalistan. Rather than enterperneur mindset they are targeting on hard labour. These people stopped and killed many Hindu Punjabi khatris aroras agarwals during 80s in the name of bhinderwal. So the whole enterperneur community of Hindu Punjabi khatris aroras agarwals shifted to neighboring Haryana and Delhi. Now kapoors oberois khanna thapars chopras are in Delhi than Punjab. There presistent hate towards enterperneur community never instited them to learn from khatris. This is the evolution stopped for jatt Sikhs hate grew the land which was sometimes mother to them is now just money source of kanneda Australia us nothing more than that. I hope they understood earlier

[@saroshvarghese362]

I think that they are fed up with the modi govt. I came to hear that so many farmers committed suicide and some farmers are roasting rats for food and eating. Thanks to the world famous modi govt. ☹😣😡

[@RijanKhanal-jh6t]

@@saroshvarghese362 😂😂😂 it's logicless reason bro. Patel's themselves control the politics of Gujarat. How can u blame modi it's out of sense. How's Ur reason for jatt Sikhs illegal immigrants to USA do u think Punjab is also ruled by BJP and modi😂😂😂 so they are migrating no bro😂😂😂the reason is simple brain drain among these 2 community is so high that they wanna go usa without having any proper skill and education that causes the problem. Same with haryanvi jaats. Brain drain is among other people as well but they dream about USA only if they education or skill. That's why tamilians malyalis teleguites kannadigas goans or Marathis himachalis or Uttarakhand or other state people don't dream of USA if they know they are uneducated or poor. This is the thing.

[@newbegining7046]

It’s not just Gujarat, across india traditional land owning castes and families haven’t prospered much. Key reasons 1) farming labor rates are no longer viable 2) traditional farming families are still living false pride with no real substance and they didn’t focus much on education 3) most of these farming lands were never split between amicably between next generations and most of these lands are under litigation

[@pramodhn1967]

Respect to American Soldiers for showing Humanity even in such situation. Also sad that indians are so much influenced to move to the states.

[@aleatoire6110]

seriously even i am thinking just that

[@-VAJRA-]

and gujarat police taking almost an year to make the first arrest

[@banurigopalreddy4014]

Arizona is always hot

[@pritalpawdeyeragi241]

That they risk their and even their children's lives.😢

[@rohitbhati3814]

India is becoming hell for common man becuase of taxes and worst shitty system and judiciary !!!

[@TheMsksk]

The sad thing is. With 190k dollars Jagdish could've easily entered the US through legal route and through hard work and a little luck settled there legally

[@BisboWorld]

Perhaps lack of good education makes it tough to enter legally

[@PHOENIXGAMING4HD]

us charges 1m got golden visa however 100k is enough to get golden visa of canada

[@manojramesh4598]

​​@@BisboWorldor just relocate in india somewhere where they have good state governance like goa........ thinking going US will make their dream come true is wrong thinking...... There are many countries like Vietnam, taiwan, Australia have good economic like US and need of labourers (even in Japan because of old age population).......... Indian government is been given too much power instead the economic reforms should be done by economists, industrialists and other experts instead of politicians favouring ultra rich for party treasury funds sake

[@arunk7408]

@@manojramesh4598 lol

[@veenukrishnashah610]

@@manojramesh4598 lmao , bro chill , i agree to first few sentences but gov is doing the work , its the people's mentality and flock mind which leads them to doing such thing , and compare Indias economy with other countries , India is at a much better position 🧿, western countries are going through a really bad inflation , even medical bills are high whereas in India the people below povery line or people who cant afford medical bills have scheme which covers up most of their medical bill , ik this bcus the servants who work in my house were benefited by this scheme , and u say gov favours ultra rich lmao , they give projects to them bcus they are Indian businessman , so what do u want shd india give its projects to outsiders huh ? + Indian gov also gives smaller start ups goverment projects , and i have seen this bcus my father previously was in a start up which had started only few years ago and government offered them their projects . government is doing what it can do the best . And every cause of a problem is not gov its ppl mentality .

[@Soopertraveler]

My business partner and I were green card holders, residing there for more than 15 years due to our Ph.D. pursuits and jobs. However, we eventually returned to India with a mission to contribute to 'Make in India' 🇮🇳. Our focus is on producing IVD devices within the country, replacing imports from China and other nations. While we've already achieved some impact with our products, our journey continues with a dedication to create positive change here in India, where our heart lies. This is our homeland and our community! We love to see that change happen!

[@umachouanumachouan3061]

Great job ,thank you so much ...we are proud of you

[@pranaypallavtripathi2460]

👍

[@rohanutep81]

Yes after getting US citizenship 😂

[@RJ-zp7ez]

Exactly @@rohanutep81 , they will leave whenever they want. Pretty hypocrites.

[@iidentifyMyselfAfemalepotato]

​@@RJ-zp7ez🤦 boy learnt a new word, hypocrite. But still you need to know what it means exactly and where to use it. 😂

[@ruchirlashkari6008]

I came back to INDIA after a 5 year successful career and achievements in USA. I came back even after having a 3 year valid H1B. But all i know is I am proud to be with my Family and in my country. I Love India..!! Although USA gave me money but India gave me reasons to live.

[@Ragnark98]

I had same opinion 👍

[@pritalpawdeyeragi241]

Nice

[@adityakadam5737]

Same here

[@swapnilkadam8410]

Chatgpt???

[@jayneel3137]

bro in which field you work in usa ?

[@disha_]

As a Gujarati, living in Gandhinagar i confirm that the background story of this Patel family couldn't be more accurate. And this is not the story of just one family, almost every Patel house in my neighborhood has at least one of their family members emigrated to the USA "illegally". Hats off to you for such a great work, man! Gujarati dialogues were really fun and Canadian accent too :)

[@Pk_1911]

As a Gujrati myself, I agree with your comment.

[@amanjotsingh6622]

As a punjabi I can relate to this story. The peer pressure of residing in India and not going abroad is outrageous. People will assume you to be a failure. Folks around me are ready to spent up to 70 lakhs for US Visa and 15-20 lakhs for Canadian visa. Just imagine investing this amount in India with all the resources you already have in your home country. But they are not entirely to be blamed for this. We do have a paralyzed governments as well as we are still struggling with basic needs like clean water, electricity (regular cuts in summers).

[@sriram181]

And still Criticising the govt for the inefficiently ends up getting you labelled as Anti National

[@think-tank6658]

It is failure of government and people mindset also

[@soham8208]

​@@think-tank6658especially Punjab Government

[@AlokKumar-uv5co]

with those amounts in bank I can purchase solar panels inverter and a diesel generator.... so electricity shouldn't be a problem

[@lindyswing4368]

Bullshit on the last part, its just pure ego and want of status.

[@shabnamkhatoon3364]

Respect to the American authorities for not leaving those people to die, however I agree with them taking strict action because at the end of the day they are trying to enter ILLEGALLY so it is their duty to stop this

[@iidentifyMyselfAfemalepotato]

They won't care for too long. The numbers are increasing every day.

[@Thoughtflux]

Glad to see people from the land of bulldozer raj appreciating humanity.

[@bruhaspati560]

​@@Thoughtfluxbulldozer only for illegal land owners and shops🤘🤣

[@drsandeep47]

​​@@Thoughtfluxif you do something illegal bulldozers will act or else follow the law they wont bother

[@SidFredrickson]

We are good people but our goodness are often taken advantage of.

[@akashsuresh1369]

"Alone in the snow, all that's left are your screams." That's very haunting.

[@BisboWorld]

🤗

[@aishr8125]

I am from Chennai currently living in the US but planning to comeback to India as I realized I can live a more comfortable life with my family with a very good pay in my India itself :) I know a lot of my friends coming back to the India in the same fashion..I think the "american dream" craze to my knowledge as reduced vastly..

[@deepmehta267]

I agree with you.!I am also currently living in USA and planning to go back to India

[@abhisek5050]

Welcome back and be comfortable in your own land.

[@amanjotsingh6622]

Good to know that and a reasonable decision too. Economy is booming and foreign investment is also increasing. Though we have few setbacks in terms of lifestyle probably because of authorities incharge. But things are changing and surely get those issues resolved too in near future. Good luck👍🏻

[@BroInPunjab]

@@amanjotsingh6622 Khalistan zindabad bro

[@meetube30]

H1b reject ho Gaya kya

[@vedantshukla8983]

The smallest coffins were the heaviest indeed.

[@Olive_Chap]

😭

[@shivamrai4939]

saddest line of the video 😭

[@vikramraghavan214]

This hit very hard. So sad

[@Cloud-zp4pu]

Not really. They are a testimony of The heights of Anti Nationalism people can reach to despite Gujurat being the most developed place in the world.

[@Interstellar2123]

Indians have taken ameican dream more seriously than americans themselves 😀

[@bharathidevi3092]

Because they don't know how good it is?

[@suryakantibiswal]

​@@bharathidevi3092 because they know how bad it is 😂

[@ryanrodrigues1166]

Actually United States of America is a real El Dorado just that Americans don't know that.

[@nsja3920]

😂

[@ahmedbin100]

😀😀😀

[@yesicanhearyouclemfandango]

Feeling so sad for those little children. They had to freeze to death because of the utter stupidity of their parents. What a horrible death. They were just children!

[@fearwhatisinsideyou]

Dear Indians, there's nothing life changing in any other country outside. The belongingness you'll find in your own country will never come anywhere else. The other countries will always treat you as outsiders and misbehave. Money is important, but not worth your life and family at home land. Work hard in your own country, make your own country better. ❤

[@indrajitghosh4415]

On the contrary life changes in other countries...the point is that one should try doing it legally!

[@jaibhavani6454]

😂😂 i suppose you're a 12 yo kid roaming around the internet

[@AmritenduRana31082000]

False 😂,it depends on a person.i know people who's life turned around for the better in us 😂

[@fearwhatisinsideyou]

I agree with all of you. Point is, you shouldn't risk your life to go abroad so desperately. Your own country isn't that un-livable. The peace of living with your own people is unique. I earned a lot of dollars for years there. But i knew i went to loot them and work my @$$ off for the money, live peacefully back in my homeland. Some choose not to return, because they've found peace there... But if you're killing yourself and your family for going to a country, sure you're doing something wrong.

[@Sauravwtf]

I'm in US, and i assure you, the life here is not worth all that money and loneliness. I'm planning to go back as soon as i can.

[@SuranjanaVlogsUSA]

Indians should understand that USA is no dreamland and immigration is extremely complicated 😢As a non immigrant in USA I can say STOP jeopardizing your life and draining entire savings as it’s so not worth it💔

[@rohitnijhawan5281]

Here's the funny thing, many indians who came to the US and Canada and didn't have medical or CS degrees, may spend their old age in south east and south asia. My father is one of them. He did OK for himself but nothing that will leave me a glowing inheritance. He earned it - it's all his. The weather along with the cost of living and mandatories - cell phone, car insurance, cost of gas, cost of food, taxes not to mention housing have made life absolutely soul-crushing for those who are in the middle class on this continent. I hate to ponder how the lower class and poor people of all races are managing.

[@Aftermath-News]

Your definently an immegrent.

[@SuranjanaVlogsUSA]

@@Aftermath-News first understand the difference between immigrent and non-immigrant :p

[@noobplays3818]

What you mean by non immigrant in USA lol.

[@rohitnijhawan5281]

@@noobplays3818 it could be somebody who is a visitor or someone on a temporary student visa or a temporary work visa

[@hazelnorewood7782]

Back after watching Dunki, and have to say, your video is much more heartbreaking, empathetic and well researched than the entire film

[@SD_003]

Have spent few years in US, Australia and Europe. Happily back in India now. Never even applied for GC/PRs, just enjoyed the time there and returned back. I seriously don't understand the craze for going abroad. Somehow I feel people like to show-off their NRI status and its funny people back home actually give that weightage. I mean how shallow are we? 🙄

[@young_turk]

The 'craze' for going abroad is till perfectly valid for countries that have better living standards than the US/Canada or Europe. If you're making anything less than $350k/year there just come back lol

[@SD_003]

@@young_turk only a tiny fraction would be making 350$/year. All these Infy/Wipro brigade isn't even getting 100k$/year even in manager positions. I know as our vendors while there were all from Wipro/infy/TCS etc. Its majorly the 'NRI status' draw which has been hard-wired in Indians since birth. We still live in a 'log kya kahenge' setup where parents/relatives/neighbors love flaunting anything about videsh. 😅

[@young_turk]

@@SD_003 I agree w this. Know a lot of people who make around $140-150k a year in Canada and flaunt their 'NRI' status back here. After taxes I'm not sure there's much left, living costs are so high and if you're in the US, healthcare bills can literally bankrupt you if you don't have health insurance. Much better to immigrate somewhere with better HDI, and a social welfare system that works.

[@young_turk]

Or just stay here, the Indian private sector is growing at a reasonably fast rate given how late out economy was liberalised. If I get an offer from India at par with what I'm currently making I will GLADLY move back.

[@rohanutep81]

@@young_turkwhich country is that tell us???

[@manofsan]

"American dream" doesn't refer to illegal infiltration of the country.

[@mrarun1889]

This is an excellent depiction of the desperation to achieve the so-called "American dream." I lived in America close to where these crossings took place. Life there is very tough, much tougher than India. Unless you are guaranteed to make over $10,000 per month (which is over Rs 8.3 lakhs monthly), don't even think about moving there. You will suffer like never before. You will have to deal with racism, discrimination, gangs and gun violence, tough weather, no government control of the prices of any products and many people with no moral values. Many in the US Indian community are doctors, IT people, scientists, engineers, business leaders, university professors, etc. Unless you are in these sort of fields or in some professional field in which you want to do research and advance, don't move there. You will also be looked down upon by the Indian community and never be able to fit in. It is a cutthroat system financially. America can easily take back whatever it gives you and much more. You will suffer and maybe even turn into a beggar. Americans are suffering a lot with great debt and so much mental illness. There is no American dream. This is a complete myth. Many Americans move to other countries south of their border like Mexico, Costa Rica, Panama, etc after retirement since everything is too expensive. The American dream is only for multimillionaires and billionaires. As long as you can afford the basics of life, you can manage in India, etc. India has its problems but these are nothing compared to America. I am glad to be back in India. Be wise and may God bless you 🙏🏼 ✝️

[@MARIOLOVES]

Bro I agree with you on what you said about racism & gang & gun violence in US but when it comes discrimination, it even happens in India like when Indians move within their own country for example When north eastern people are moving to other parts of India, they’re being discriminated & even beaten to death. Speaking of people with no moral values, India has enough of them too like think about they are many in India who says rape is consensual, do you think they have moral values.

[@HumourusLAV]

Yeah true!! People don't understand that Gold is always kept hidden in lockers and Shit is always polished and presented to others to sell

[@Crazytesseract]

People like @Thoughtflux cannot understand these things, maybe because they have experienced only the bright side of things for now.

[@swarupbanerjee147]

Welcome back home brother 👍

[@VedantTaneja]

Definitely no crime and filth, no rape in india, no poverty in india. India is super clean? A super power right? Definitely salaries are good in india? No competition in india?

[@abhishekyadav-ne6wl]

Someone having one crore in India and still craving to be in US.... You can easily live a good life in India if you have that sum of money

[@hughanus8415]

Nah Being in us is much better

[@FUHRER___]

Quality of life is tatti in India.

[@hemantsandal9281]

​@@FUHRER___goro ki tatti kha fir tu Bhai..

[@MonuSharma-nz2pf]

​@@FUHRER___😂😂😂 bitter but true

[@chikukumar-tj1ml]

​@@MonuSharma-nz2pfstill better than giving up your life.

[@MOHAMMED-gi2uh]

I never expected that end of a 3 yr old and a 11 yr old 😔😔, they died for no fault of their own

[@ks-cf9mn]

It's very tragic for an entire family. Condolences to this families. 🙏🏼🙏🏼🌹 It's perfect example for other to understand the concept.

[@a.b.__iii]

I lived in Switzerland for 4 straight years and after returning in 2019 I found India changed so much! there is ample opportunity and venues to find your success. Its sad people dont see that while living in India. Edit: My stay and visit was entirely sponsored. But please don't spend your parents money or sell land or take loan... In all honesty it's not worth the trade. Because I've lived in Switzerland and India I am giving you real facts. Believe me there are hell lotta opportunities in india both for job and business. If you have a business idea there is no limit how much money u can make. )) Please don't make the mistake of selling, taking loan to go abroad .it's not worth it. Good luck 🤞💯

[@jayneel3137]

bro in which domain / field you work in switzerland

[@aek12]

Visa lagva do bhai. Me vaha jana chahta hu.

[@vladtheimpalerofd1rtypajee316]

Let's be realistic. India will never be a developed country in it's lifetime. Even if India grows, it will get stuck in the middle income trap forever. India will also face major resource shortage due to overpopulation and face the wrath of climate change. India's resource base isn't large enough to support an economy too large either. Also the West and China can sabotage India in a jiffy if it grows too much. Also most Indians don't have unity and are still backward minded and tribalistic. Corruption and being unethical has become so deep rooted that it's become impossible to fix it. Also, the number of talented Indians leaving India is increasing at an alarming rate every year and many of these Indians who left India brag about India being the next big thing which is extremely comedic. The most mind boggling thing is that even if God comes down from heaven and says that India will never be a developed country, pa jeets will call him anti Indian and continue living in their fantasy of India being a developed country. Moreover, countries that actually became developed bragged less and did more. India brags more and does less. To conclude, India may improve in some areas, but it always stay a corrupt 3rd world uncivilized sh8hole. Hence, forget your dreams of being a developed country pa jeets. India is an utterly failed experiment. Adios

[@a.b.__iii]

@@jayneel3137 family.

[@ErFazil]

So you have settled back in India?

[@desi4peace]

There can be no better example of 'grass appears greener on the other side' than this. Tragic for the innocent children who lost their lives due to parental greed and lack of common sense. There are people from other genuinely struggling nations, dirt poor and brutalized, who seek asylum in the US. For an affluent section of the Indian community, generally well off, to take this kind of a step, and shelling crores for it, beats me. If only their brethren back home see the true picture. These are the countless, sad and lost faces slaving away like machines behind subway counters, cleaning toilets in motels or risking their lives in shuttered up gas stations in high risk areas. I know a patel who was shot at and gravely injured in a gas station robbery attempt.

[@boneyachayan26]

I was waiting for your video... such awesome contents everytime.

[@pie3601]

Gujaratis voted modi and ran away to the US? 😂

[@sd1888]

just imagine, even after having the most prosperous state, 200000 DOLLARS , greed sometimes make people so blind

[@kdm.1579]

your point being?

[@FUHRER___]

@@kdm.1579 point being the loss of quality life in India. Since baba ji came people are just hating each other and shouting trillion dollar economy.

[@RalphdeSouza]

Wow! I love your channel, just watched two videos back to back. I just stumbled on it today. Great story telling skill you've got.

[@jestswcjx1259]

the line, the small coffins are the heaviest to lift...... what a great content by bisbo

[@thewinner754]

Bro your narration style is such that even the hardest of hearts would start crying ! @13:36 :,) Om Shanti to the family ! May they Rest in Peace !

[@shajiljohn]

A common Punjabi friend of mine was caught at the Mexican border and was detained and sent back to India.. His exact words were "I have seen death face to face, but i will try again"..

[@jamesmartin6319]

Hopefully, he won't end up like this.

[@tree3y763]

He’s pagal😂

[@SidFredrickson]

@@jamesmartin6319 The Southern Border is only going to get worse.

[@springsummer7138]

The kids are the real victims. The irresponsible parents caused all these

[@tanishqshukla1252]

RIP, the video summarized the news nicely!

[@shaikmasoodali9552]

i was just wishing tht the end wasn't so cruel to the family but alas.....

[@the_welldressed_hippie]

With 190k he could’ve done any business in india and live well!

[@sd1888]

it think it wasnt just about money as it is portrayed in the vdo, people may be looked down upon if they didnt go aboard. Psychological conditioning is more responsible here in this case.

[@andaz777]

Think about your children before attempting anything of this sort, they are the most precious assets you have, heart feels sad for the children, try the legal routes or use the money to make a good life in India, itna bhi bura nahi hai desh humara, god bless the souls

[@psrideviforutube]

Very well made video, puts the required message across effectively 😢

[@krishnakant3399]

I can say you will go far ahead in your journey. Great content, animation and story telling style.

[@rose72100]

I live in us, there’s not a single day I don’t think about moving back to India. However it would be a shock to my 10 year old. If you’re upper middle class life is much easier in India. Here the cost of living is so high and we would be forced to do every work by yourself including cleaning, cooking, handyman works around the house otherwise getting help for these work would dig holes in our wallet. Life is short if we don’t have time to do things we like or spend quality time with our family or friends what kind of life is this.

[@shauryasharma7647]

No point living in the US if you can't maintain the same standard of living as in India. You are literally poor in that country while you're not in India

[@cooldude2106]

You really dont think about it , dont talk about it .

[@youtubeuserxix]

What about those Indians who also undergo the same hardships every day and yet never even think of coming back?

[@jatredmik6352]

Don't hide behind some excuse like "my 10 yr old kid will be shocked" .the fact is u don't want to go back , which is understandable, but don't fool u r self with excuses

[@karthikeyan-zh1zm]

I appreciate bisbo from the heart for creating this...Awareness video❤

[@BisboWorld]

Thank you 🙏

[@shahnaazabbas2998]

A very well made video. Loved it❤

[@FabSia]

That's a fantastic video. Gripping till the end.

[@vkps108]

I was crying seeing this. This obsession for US has killed so many

[@kartickkumar7013]

Greed makes to pay for karma

[@jestswcjx1259]

thank you for such an awesome video

[@Kayash_Kino]

Thanks

[@gamingtemple5731]

One of the biggest mistake other than trying to illegal immigrate is he should have done it alone first and once he settles than his family could have joined him on dependent visa. RIP, I hope there are in a better place

[@padmasrinivasan5410]

Seeing this is heartbreaking. I lived in US and UK for couple of years, and returned back to India. There is always pros and cons of living in abroad. Even though you earn in dollars u spend in dollars and the saving is less. We will always be treated as immigrants, the education in public schools are not so good like in india. Your children will be raised in American mindset only. Visa problem will be there, they have hire and fire policy, you can be thrown out of job at any time for no reason, everything you buy house, car etc will be by mortgage and the saving potential is very less. It is not at all worth taking so much risk. I have seen people who have become American citizens sell their homes, car and go for small homes with no money saved for retirement.

[@KAN443]

Reasons For Mass Migration Of Indians to Developed Countries Like USA, Canada and UK Are 1.Low Quality Of Education in India 2.Reservation 3.Poor Living Standard and Pollution 4.Lack of Employment Opportunities 5.Difficulties in Establishment of Own Buisness 1.5 Million People Left Indian Citizenship After Settling in Developed Countries Like USA, Canada and UK Since 2011

[@KAN443]

@@abishekrauthar3946 And Thoose Hard Working Young Indians Moving Abroad For Higher Studies and Getting Settled There For Employment Opportunities

[@ptj1ptj172]

​​@@KAN443you missed an important point - population explosion - the root cause for all miseries in India

[@KAN443]

@@abishekrauthar3946 Really 😂 Then Say How Many Indian Universities are in Top 100 Universities in the World

[@KAN443]

@@ptj1ptj172 True

[@vinodkumargola1274]

More Respect to American Soldiers ❤

[@Worldaffairslover]

I went to college with a 20 y/o indian man, his family was living good, he was in a frat, involved in college activities. Ended in tragedy in early January of this year. Rest in peace

[@chikukumar-tj1ml]

It's heartbreaking to hear such news. Our people need to realise that not everything you see on your television screen about some other country is true. Every country have their own set of struggle and challenges. We need to better our own village, district, state and our country.

[@gastronomistmd5078]

Whooping 1.5 crores 😮 for four family members. OMG. GREED HAS NO MERCY !

[@BisboWorld]

Indeed, really sad

[@asyongmatipid2]

They were already in Canada where the parents just by landing a job could've easily transitioned from tourists to temporary worker and eventually PR for their entire family. Judging by how many Indian vloggers make videos about how relatively easy it is to settle in Canada compared to the US one wonders why they never chose that opportunity instead.

[@ahmedbin100]

you have a good point, but the reason is they are innocent people who don't know much about this can also be done.

[@homegrown6999]

It is a made up video. Only some people do that.

[@EsoteriaHealing]

​@@homegrown6999it's not made up. It is a real case.

[@robertbeurre1825]

To those who don't feel deterred by this video, do not come to the US illegally unless you have absolutely no other option(life or death). Even if you manage to surpass the dangers it takes to get here, you can't do much without proper papers and credentials. You will be forced to do the most shady jobs and you will have to do it for very little. India is ripe with opportunity and is on the verge of an economic SUPERBOOM.

[@debanikgoswami4834]

India's biggest problem is it's population . Acceptance rate in Ivy leagues is higher than IITs . Research opportunity in USA is amazing .

[@shivraaj3742]

Really sad for those innocent kids 😢

[@saroshvarghese362]

A very sad story. Thanks and respect to the American soldiers for showing so much concern. 😪🙏 What if it was my father, mother, my sister and me?

[@manasbehera7368]

Well explained bro .keep going ❤

[@BisboWorld]

Thanks Manas

[@pruthivrajpanda4494]

THANKS BISBO FOR PROVIDING THIS TRAGEDY IN EASY MANNER ALTHOUGH IT IS SAD AND LESSONFUL LOVE FROM SABARMATI ASHRAM GUJRAT❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@personalviews6950]

Smallest coffins are the heaviest indeed. 😢

[@pritalpawdeyeragi241]

Very sad to learn about loss of children in such a risk.

[@coolsand]

This is just unimaginable. Truly tragic Just imagine what the parents may have felt in the last moments

[@shekharmodi]

Nice animation. Last part was so chilling! Mr Patel never tried to work in prosperous cities like Mumbai, Pune, Delhi, Bangalore! But he was ready to lose everything to go abroad!

[@AllMadeVlog]

If people from Gujarat send their family members to USA for financial stability, it means Gujarat Model is a failure.. isn't it 💁🏻‍♂️

[@viralbarot3203]

Not it really doesn’t mean that. It just means gujarati people are more hungry for money.

[@yuurishibuya4797]

It just means one of the 7 deadly sins “Greed” disguised as dreams.

[@Rohitweasley]

then other states will be much bigger failure anyway and Gujarat will be a winner in comparison.

[@Rohitweasley]

@@viralbarot3203 because no other state has people going to US ?

[@LuckyBombay]

@@viralbarot3203you mean greedy , right ?

[@rooftopmunda]

What a shame! Such parents are curse for the children. They could've used that 1cr for their children's education and they would've made their way into any country not just the U.S. Such fool people don't even know the actual geo politics and that U.S may not be the world power in the coming future.. Shame! I pray for the deceased children and I am ashamed to learn what the parents did. 😔

[@saiyedakhtar3931]

1 cr is nothing these days. Second, the US will remain a global power for the foreseeable future

[@raoshuaib589]

Gujaratis are known for selling their honesty for money and power! And one gujrati had reached a top in this

[@mmalavdesai4509]

This is so Stupid of Parents and their peruse of going to USA... Such a Sad Story

[@orthonext]

People who hate their own motherland should be ashamed of themselves, feel very bad for the wife & innocent kids, proper financial management would have given them a much better life in India, US is all false hope and dreams, very few will understand 😢

[@AdityaKumar-eg5tn]

This trend was there even before independence, we Indians have no problem working in McDonald's and Domino's abroad but we cannot do the same here back in India. List of reasons why most of the Indians wants to go abroad- The demand for NRI grooms has rapidly gone up almost everyone signing up for the matrimonial sites wants an NRI groom. The problem is you don't get any benefit for the taxes which you are paying in India The work culture in Europe and the U.S is far better than India

[@a1aurobindo]

thing is there is no caste based discrimination based on occupation in USA... and in india lots of discrimination... that;s why people prefer USA...

[@AdityaKumar-eg5tn]

@@a1aurobindo it is the vice versa, most of the general category people leave India because of caste based reservation.

[@ChipsAndCurd]

​@@AdityaKumar-eg5tnthey have no one but themselves & their "rotten mistaken as rich" history to blame. Even in the video it is speculatively shown he gave some 1 to 1.5 cr to go illegally. That is a huge amount to live happily in India

[@AdityaKumar-eg5tn]

@@ChipsAndCurd the problem is we don't understand it. Middle class people dream big so they leave this country in search of better opportunities, for instance the cost of purchasing a 2bhk house in a metropolitan city is from 50 lakhs to 3 crores. The cost of living is also increasing day by day. The main problem is the population and the limited opportunities. For every one job opening there are approximately 5000 people applying for it and sadly most of them are either unemployed for long or they are overqualified for the job. The government is not doing enough. The reservation system is also burdening the general category people.

[@ishaan6512]

Exactly. Idk how people are blaming the people who leave India to go to the states or other places. Treat your own citizens as second class citizens, and then blame them for brain drain.

[@PraveenKumar-kj8rq]

Wow you're a great narrator. This video is different from others. Keep doing it brother ♥

[@prashantachandrapanda]

Well made and well researched

[@husainsariya4060]

It was never a financial problem for this man, I can see he had managed crore rupees just to immigrate, which he for sure can use himself to start any kind of small business, anywhere in India. It was psychological pressure, FOMO and little bit of NRI who boasts in their village, and fake social media narrative. I have friends their, who did great degrees here in India, cracked GRE and IELTS and still struggling to find part time job their. I could have even understand if India was a war torn nation in world, that he took risk to flee, as dying was imminent here or there. But this act of risking family lifes is just a failure of social support, family values and logic within these part of gujarat

[@Suzyusil]

Good for India🎉🎉🎉smart people cheers

[@kyachannelhey5895]

I am Gujarati and It makes me cry

[@pritamuttarkabat8537]

We don't need to be or live like someone else. We are all unique.

[@a1aurobindo]

ofcourse u r unique with a lot of caste based discrimination

[@ErFazil]

​@@a1aurobindoand financial inequality. Politicians looting people's hard-earned money in the name of taxation.

[@a1aurobindo]

@@ErFazil is USA zero tax ?

[@ErFazil]

@@a1aurobindo You get the service for what you are paying.

[@bulb6222]

@@a1aurobindo Yes, discrimination against upper caste

[@mayurnayudu3376]

One of the things that drive people is to go is to up their self respect. People go thru all the pain ..just to increase their self respect amongst the society. They do whatever it takes…

[@revatiy]

Storytelling technique used is excellent.

[@guruofficial2]

Bismillahirrahmanirrahiim. I subscribed and almost every I watch Bisbo's video, no matter I understand the story or not, no matter the case spread to Indonesia, where I live, or not. I just like to listen your voice, the way you telling the story, just like my father or mother, told me stories before I slept, when I was at the age of 1, till 5 years old. I also like your animation. Best regards from Indonesia, South East Asia. Wslm.

[@J7pat7]

These parents were selfish and greedy. They were not suffering in India. They just saw the bragging posts of Indians on social media and wanted luxury . They ended up killing their kids for selfish reasons.

[@thewhatorwhy]

I've criticized the parents but I would not say they were not suffering. He even ended up selling kites to make a living.

[@deepakcm5714]

“Smallest coffins are the heaviest in deed” 😭😭

[@manfromearth4346]

Bisbo is simply too good👍

[@angkitmoirang3042]

The story is very sad and heartbreaking 😢

[@itshreyammm9020]

uss time pr 1-1.5 cr me vo banda apne family ko ek bhot acchi life de skta h ... cant understand this fucking fetish to go foreign ffs...shameful

[@ChipsAndCurd]

Yeah it is a lavish life

[@a.b.__iii]

Yaar 1 Cr ki jagah 10 lakh ka share trading hi kar leta India m. Daily min 10-15k guaranteed income

[@Utsav_Viradiya]

I am from Gujarat and while I have a net worth exceeding half a million dollars (I mention the amount not to brag), I am actually the least affluent individual in my family. In Gujarat, many local Gujjus possess a significant wealth, which leads to intense peer pressure in this regard, my friend.

[@Utsav_Viradiya]

@@a.b.__iii I'm quite skeptical about that. Could you share information about your net worth?

[@a.b.__iii]

@@Utsav_Viradiya this is actually a very very superficial way to look at things man... What about clean air and water? What about fresh, good quality food which is the Real factor in improving quality or life ?? U know many wealthy people are leaving Delhi and moving to countryside for a 'better life' which in many cases is much much cheaper than their lifestyle in Delhi. Now Delhi is just an example. But u should that only money is absolutely not a yard stick to measure quality of life or wealth in general.

[@rockysridhar]

My dream also came true in 2007 January like any other middle class boy from India 🇮🇳 who went to USA , but now I am back to India in 2022 finally for good , but during those years had immense struggles of loosing jobs quite often and H1b not picking and then after green delayed, which made me heavy alcoholic , due to that lost my career and it took years for me to quit, and last but not the least it happened only with me , not necessarily has to happen with others , good things do happen and do hope for the best 😊.

[@markchristi2649]

Very good message & nice presentation, I hope people understand it’s not worth it to risk life for USA 🇺🇸

[@User-qrcjknc]

Don’t dream anything, just stay here in India.

[@muhammedjaseemshajeef6781]

8:48 so sad😢

[@user-vg9ct5gz9i]

They got what they deserved. I feel sorry for the kids. Pubjabi and gujrati community do all illegal sorts to enter US Canda illegally showing zero respect for law of land here.

[@jyo901]

Good edits👍

[@rajesh35hsp]

It made me cry poor kids😢

[@salilkumar6397]

Problem in India- at sudden we cannot be americas, europe or Australia where one get high salary, due to high population that's understandable but we are paying high taxes and in return getting nothing, poor infrastructure (though that is improving in fast pace), politics in every things etc. Even we are middle class my elder brother moved to Australia in 2022 after taking risk of 2500000 loan. Once he will pay loan n some big saving he will be back to India.

[@rohanutep81]

No won’t come back

[@user-ww2lc1yo9c]

India is a super power isn't it? @@rohanutep81

[@Awakenbeing]

I wish Jagdish family could have thought of using the money to start a business in Indian cities. with that amount of money he could have a successful business in almost any sector like construction material, but risking lives of his small children in crossing the blizzard cold storm was never a good idea from start. Very sad incident

[@sssl9528]

I have heard horror stories of similar journeys taken by Afghans for years. It makes sense for Afghans to take such drastic and dangerous risks to migrate as we are suffering from decades of war and Statelessness but it is extremely unwise decision for a middle class Indian family to take. As an Afghan-Canadian I was really sad when I heard about this family’s tragedy but was even more heartbroken thinking about the freezing pain their kids must have suffered before dying.

[@nishanthviswa5459]

such a heart wrenching story

[@shrishkapoor206]

but if their already in Canada they might as well have found a way to stay there, it would have been so much easier.

[@amitabhapatra4339]

Too much greed leads to doom.

[@erroldcruz]

Heart wrenching

[@ramkumar-lc1st]

Which animation software you used? Thanks

[@ArjunPakrashi]

This is not dream. It's irresponsible and stupidity to endanger your entire family. Although main responsibility is on the horrible agents. If someone can pay 1cr. Then they can do very very well in India. This is just stupid in all dimensions. It's too sad that the family suffered such a big loss.

[@oindrilaroychoudhuri273]

So true, normal people cant even gather 1 cr, they were fools, they are chutiyas

[@dhruvdoshi56]

You dont get that easily in india

[@davedarius7346]

It's not about doing very well in India(where minority religions are looked down), it's about chasing your dream...

[@davedarius7346]

​@@oindrilaroychoudhuri273No, they had the courage to chase their dream.. something u wouldn't know

[@ArjunPakrashi]

@@davedarius7346 That's not chasing the dream. That's something different.

[@sonalshekhardash7088]

People who are educated enough realised that they can live a good life in India. And the ones who are struggling here and ready to do odd jobs and earn in dollars, are fleeing away illegally. I too wanted to live my American dream but after finding out about these illegal immigrants from our country, I don't feel like even trying to go there anyway. There should be strict punishment to people who are trying to immigrate illegally and their families as well, so that people wouldn't even think about it at all.

[@FunfactswithVK-oe4qc]

My heart cried after listening to this. Why these people take so much risk 😢.

[@rohanutep81]

For US dollars and passport

[@samsingh9592]

First provide 24 hours Electricity, clean water, clean air , clean roads, free of corruption, then many people may be think about moving back.

[@LifeGeneralist]

Let's all just make India better and see Reverse Immigration happen!

[@Ritesh-pv4yi]

Aukat nahi hai