Whisky Review/Tasting: Macallan 18 years Sherry Cask

[@iLuvsPie]

As always Horst, your reviews are a pleasure to watch. Thank you for being unpretentious, honest, and for considering the viewpoint of the average consumer. And don't worry when you take time to search for the right words. It adds character to your reviews and makes it much more engaging/human.

[@Whiskycom]

Thank you for the nice words

[@yanksrule311]

Perfectly said. 👍

[@jacobpalmer127]

looks like this guy is wearing a rolex submariner 16610. good taste. nice watch

[@ZaDude1970]

He is, I own the same Sub 16610, a genuine classic!

[@FraldinhoBJJ]

Another watch guy ! I love it . High end whisky and fine timepieces go together I suppose

[@carolespohr2110]

@@FraldinhoBJJ I hate Rolexes! And I love Mac Callan.

[@Richmexicogdl]

yeah! I always thought it was a Rolex.

[@triplecap4307]

In the mid 90s, I bought the 18 for $60. I should have bought a hundred.

[@SamStam12]

Good way to make some money. Those bottles now are worth major $.

[@factfact9339]

LOL

[@auricgoldfinger8249]

Haha

[@S3v3n13tt3r5]

Was the 12yo $10? What a bargain

[@isaachatton4463]

As odd as it might sound, this was actually my first single malt from almost 20 years ago. It simultaneously opened my eyes and ruined me to other single malts from that point forward. It is the bar to which I hold all other whiskeys to, and for all this time, remains my favorite expression of what a single malt can and should be. A true masterpiece in all respects.

[@johnharrell7219]

One could never actually say enough to entirely express how good this whisky really is. I am not wealthy, but decided to buy myself a bottle in 2012 as a Christmas gift for myself. I had never before tasted a whisky that had compared to The Macallan 18, and I have yet to taste one that I prefer.

[@bill-qv3er]

I am just getting into the world of fine whiskey and I am enjoying it immensely. I have been watching a lot of reviews and have just purchased a bottle of Macallan 18 Sherry Oak and a bottle of 18 Glenlivet. I am enjoying them tremendously !!!!!!! Thanks for the excellent review, looking forward to my adventures in the world of fine whiskey .

[@carsandwhisky2002]

Another fantastic review. I have discovered many great drams from Horst's tastings including a few real bargains. Thank you

[@diegolara2806]

Just bought this bottle and a 1991 as well. Looking forward to celebrating a very special moment in the near future. Thanks for the review

[@PeatLova]

Definitely the best Scotch whisky out there. I have been comparing with another Macallan 18yo that was distilled in 1994 and this one that was distilled in 1996, the color is much lighter. The 1994 is much more darker and intense.

[@rickslade340]

At $260 a bottle for the current 18 year it's very overrated and overpriced. Glenlivet 18 for $110 a bottle and Glenlivet 21 for $150 a bottle both in my opinion taste better than Macallan 18 and cost a lot less. In general Macallan 18 is a very fine tasting single malt whiskey but at $260 a bottle it has become a joke and is not even close to being worth that price tag when there are far superior options out there for a lot less money.

[@blackmantravel6954]

@@rickslade340 but the resell value on the Macallan is clearly higher. This 1996 bottle right now sells for $900 online

[@elktime]

I tried the McAllen 18 from 2022 this past Sunday. At $300 I thought it was good, but not phenomenal. I would love to get my hands on that bottle that you sampled.

[@johnw1597]

This is the bottle I one day want to own. I am relatively knew to whisky, but am already acquiring a pretty decent collection of quality whiskies, partly thanks to very good reviews like yours, Horst. Keep up the good work and I will keep on learning! Many thanks, John.

[@kennyhill9238]

You should be the most interesting man in the world.

[@StevenCryar]

Ron White used to drink a fifth of this at least 5 or 6 days a week. Insane

[@coffeecup7]

I dont drink. James bond brought me here. After watching this video, i truly believe what you did was art. The tasting , identifying the various flavours.. Made me think of old world goodness. I may not be able to go to these depths as far as spirits are concerned but i'm subscribing because you enjoyed it and it radiated off the screen! Ah

[@randomninja4705]

Skyfall?? 😏😏

[@andrewsmallwood1858]

I always enjoy your reviews, Horst. You’re always very knowledgeable and informative. Keep up the good work!

[@FrankBennett-kb7xs]

Up until the past few years I would treat myself and my family during the holiday seasons once a year to a bottle of Macallan 18. The cost of such a bottle has increased exponentially so much that it rarely justifies a purchase. However, knowing what kind of experince it offers and the wonderful, intense flavors it delivers, I just might have to buy one more bottle and hold on to it for the rare special occassions....

[@Whiskycom]

Sounds like a good plan!

[@forrest42]

Was just given a bottle from a friend. Knew nothing about how it until now. Great review. It's New Years Eve, I will have to ring in 2018 with a glass of Macallan 18 =)

[@johnharrell7219]

forrest42, So how did you like the Macallan 18? It is a beautiful whisky isn't it? My favorite.

[@forrest42]

John Harrell Total game changer! It was fantastic. Savoring every bit of it.

[@krzysztofkoodziejak6879]

Macallan 18, reportedly one of the best in the world, is that true?

[@SoftBank47]

+Krzysztof Kołodziejak It's quite true, IMHO. I admit to being spoiled by having Macallan 18 early on in my life as a whisky drinker, but after introducing my friends to it, they are now Macallan drinkers, and general whisky fans now because of it. The only hangup is the price. My local dealer has it, but it's prohibitively expensive at around $250 USD. Only way I can truly afford it is dram by dram at a local pub.

[@krzysztofkoodziejak6879]

SoftBank47 So hello :) I'm Polish and here, Macallan 18 costs about $ 250.

[@bormanten]

Krzysztof Kołodziejak that's what it costs in New York.

[@johnharrell7219]

It is worth the price, but people like myself can seldom afford it. When I can I do buy it though.

[@jez443]

I personally think there’s much better scotch out there for much less

[@remix30us1]

I recently had this Macallan 18 year old and it truly is the best!

[@pokeround]

9:48 "Oh, a generous dram!". Ah, yes. How unfortunate! :D

[@mikecronis]

Macallan 18 is my favorite, though the tasters deviated over the years from 1987 to 1997 by a bit. There's a significant difference over 10 years!

[@ThePatriotsway]

Buddy of mine just got one of these.....told him to let me know at once when he opens it. Love your reviews! 🥃

[@rob28803]

This is $AU550 per bottle where I live. Now, my palate is no-where near refined enough to be able to discern much difference between this and a "more affordable" bottling. I can however, discern the difference on my Visa bill. So until my palate develops a bit more, I'll just be watching other people drink it on KZbin.. :D

[@8354graham1]

Interesting and informative.

[@matthewvick3982]

I have 16 bottles of the Macallan 18 vintage years!! Dare I say sell them or enjoy them all.

[@Frank75288]

if you're feeling generous , you could always give one to me 😁

[@matthewvick3982]

@@Frank75288 long gone!

[@edlane123]

I found a bottle of this 1986 in perfect condition with its box in my dads cabinet. Very nearly opened it.

[@ajbajbajb1]

I’ve been watching the auctions on this range and your dads bottle is fetching between £1k - £1.5k :)

[@hillardwilliam5183]

@@ajbajbajb1 😎

[@linerich2342]

Do you like the Glenlivet 18 more or this one

[@thiagoximendes3552]

Saudações do Brasil, excelente canal, devido o preço ser exorbitante para nós Brasileiros, apenas por encomenda se adquiri esse belíssimo whisky.

[@jeremiahjohnson4306]

My guy is like a mix of hannibal lecter, hans landa and bob ross... love this guy!!

[@RaposoAnibal]

Love your reviews and look forward to them

[@Whiskycom]

Thank you

[@1270Redwell]

Old leather, armchair.....no no that is China.....:) priceless

[@mysteryone1195]

Hi, I have come across a few of your videos and admire you’re passion for whisky! I drink a lot of wines champagnes and gin and I’m looking to understand and get into the world of whisky can you recommend me a good bottle of whisky for a beginner? Thanks from the U.K. .

[@Ronmszlaifer]

Best Review of the Mac 18 Sherry Oak I've ever seen. Well Done Horst!! I have added this review to my Macallan Collectors Group on Facebook for all to enjoy facebook.com/groups/870081293073408/?ref=bookmarks

[@Whiskycom]

Ron Szlaifer Thank you!

[@jeremyh4710]

They have the 18 in the USA for $200 USD. Not sure what year the vintage is. The image on the site is 1994, but its probably 1997 most likely.

[@jeremyh4710]

Jeremy HI noticed on some UK sites the 18 sells for more money each year you go back. Are you aware of which vintage is most sought after by collectors? Or just the older the better?? Ive heard the 1994 and before are the best quality, but after 1995 there is a noticeable downgrade in the whisky.

[@franklempka2159]

Drinking glenlivet 18 while watching a great history of scotch, great!

[@JDBLU824]

Question...once opened, how long can you keep the whiskey ? Does it spoil/lose any attributes after opening? My question is will the whiskey still be drinkable after 1 year 3 years 5 years after opening ?

[@carolespohr2110]

Danke, Horst umfassende video.

[@1luv4j]

I got a 2019 18y for 400$ that a good price? It something special love in this drink. You got the best nose. Ya crazy good $$$.

[@TheFortuitousFazzy]

Just had a question. I was led To believe that a scotch had better flavor when made with a used barrel, however I believe you made the point that a barrel used for 5 or so seasons actually lost it's aroma. I was wondering if you could clarify this for me.

[@Whiskycom]

You cannot give this answer in short. It is about Subtractive and Additive Maturation and the Influence of a strong (fresh) cask or a weak (5 times) cask. Hopefully this will help: www.whisky.com/information/knowledge/production/details/maturation-in-casks.html

[@nigel900]

As expensive as it is, I'll have to take your word at it....

[@kri1612box50cal]

Could you review the Macallan fine oak as well? Both 12 and 18 years.

[@jesusarriaga9419]

How much is a 1987 version of this 18 year old. I have one and trying to sale it but not sure of the value?

[@martingrahan1437]

11:20 he finally takes a sip of the damn whiskey

[@tamastarczy6262]

Im always dying on those leather chair jokes 🤣🤣🤣

[@Food_Bev_Tube]

I love the 12 would I like the 15 year fine oak, 17 year fine oak and the 18 sherry?

[@johnharrell7219]

socalfoodie_ Adventurer , The 15 is a totally different taste. I would guess that if you like the 12 you love the 18 sherry.

[@andrewstevenson1955]

It’s as smooth as the late frummer suits lol 😂

[@skiwabasis]

Does the 1995 vintage compare well to this one or is 1994 much better?

[@nickvaughan8100]

Loving the review why watching with a famous grouse whisky 😁😁

[@ItalianGreenEagle]

Great review, amazing scotch.

[@MrRey2711]

Great Review, MACALLAN LOVERS here

[@Iceman-xe7jo]

I would have to sell my first born for a bottle of this. Wasn’t a fan of the 12. I don’t think I would go out of my way to spend for this bottle. Just my preference. I’m sure for some they love it.

[@se4821]

What is a dram.

[@lily051482]

a serving of whisky

[@johnnyrendon3245]

Hey, great video ! Quick question your at a bar. macallan 18 Sherry vs balvenie 15 single barrel Sherry. What do you do.. ? Thanks

[@emie3403]

Is that even a question?

[@israelnisser9436]

How much money should be a 18 year 1985

[@terouusimaa7534]

I enjoyed this video. It made me thirsty...

[@Whiskycom]

:-)

[@RedGhost1990]

I Got a Bottle of Macallan 18 1994 as a gift from my brother, but i havn't had mush whiskey and i wat to get used to drinking whiskey before i open my bottle, any ideas on what whiskey i should start with?

[@lily051482]

Don't start with any cheap stuff. try at least $50 bottle Glenlivet founders reserve- Aberfeldy 12yr. -but if you want to move up a little Balvenie Doublewood , Ardbeg 10 yr old, Glenmorangie Lasanta 12yrold or Aberlour 16yr old are my favourites and good value for your money

[@nickvaughan8100]

Jameson a good start nice smooth easy going whisky

[@mikethered123]

My absolute favorite. Well, the 12, anyway.

[@Whiskycom]

The 12 year old is also a very good malt. I find it more on the "normal" fruity side while the 18 is more on the dark fruits side.

[@ScottAReid]

nice submariner? year?

[@CooleJanssen6]

What is a good starter whiskey? I want to start drinking whiskey. I would like a smooth whiskey could you recommend me a good one.

[@Whiskycom]

The Macallan 18 is definitely a good whisky. It is a bit pricey for a beginner. I would start with advice you to start with Balvenie or Aberlour and maybe order a miniture of Ardbeg TEN on the side. This way you get a nice overview between the two extremes. The Introduction whiskys I usually recommend: Balvenie 12 Jahre Double Wood (mild) Aberlour 10 Jahre (mild) Glenmorangie 10 Jahre (mild) Auchentoshan 12 Jahre (mild) Glenfiddich 15 Jahre (mild) Lagavulin 16 Jahre (smoky) Ardbeg TEN 10 Jahre (smoky) Caol Ila 12 Jahre (medium smoky)

[@glavatan]

Mefias Boom Try Glenlivet Nadurra

[@wesleytaylorviadomus]

Whisky.com In late 2010, I loved the Balvenie 12 D.W. When 2012 hit, I started to notice the decline in quality. Shame! I have heard the same thing happened to the Mac 18. I am the expert that most envy or hate. Live and learn people...

[@leroyhamilton5509]

Mefias Boom for a starter out i'd go with Glenlivet 12 HP 12 and get a 20cl Talisker . Enjoy

[@wesleytaylorviadomus]

leroy hamilton Glenlivet 12 is crap, HP12 is not well aged and balanced, and I have not tried Talisker yet.

[@bartoni572]

This really looks like it was a special Rolls Royce bottle.

[@badkid73]

Really the standard-bearer of sherried whiskies but on the decline. It's clear that their cask selection has changed in the past few years. Recent Macallan 18 bottlings (1996, 1997 vintage) are a pale brown color. The 1993, 1994 vintages from a few years ago are intense deep red. It's clear Macallan is using a higher percentage of second fill sherry casks. The same applies for the Macallan 12. Just look at the color change.

[@Zerojquan]

How rare it is to find a bottle of Macallen 18? Would you say that is more rare than Blue Label?

[@felixsvensson5244]

A lot!

[@JensThestrupToft]

Something which you can find in your local supermarket isn't rare...

[@jamestran2056]

total wine has plenty of mac18 for 199.99 AND JW Blue Label for 197.99 here in Houston, Texas.

[@JensThestrupToft]

My Mac 18 set me back $300 plus international shipping since it isn't available in my country at all. And that was even a good deal compared to what most shops in Europe ask for it.

[@jamestran2056]

You need to take a trip here and stock up...

[@OilmanMJ1984]

Today that bottle will cost you around 440£ and a Lagavulin 16 can cost 44£.

[@e92drama]

Sold!

[@ckimnj]

Pouring one right now. Thank you.

[@maytagvapor3582]

sounds very good my friend

[@JohnGrove310]

noticed your dram got bigger with this one. 🧐

[@MrNiceKnife]

Saw this for $350 recently.

[@chrisholt4804]

how much is this lol

[@jamesmartin9873]

so....is it better with coke or ginger ale?

[@Minecraftletsplayer-tb2mq]

James Martin cock non liquid one

[@Paiva1Henrique]

Dei valor nmrl!

[@matheusmotta4044]

Vá a merda

[@matheusmotta4044]

Falando merda no youtube

[@SweatyWalrus]

No, seriously, where is this guy’s microphone??

[@subutaynoyan5372]

Apparently, they're at his vocal cords.

[@jez443]

I love the microphone, it’s like whiskey ASMR

[@ModularLanding]

These videos would have half the views if the mic’ing weren’t so good. You can practically taste the whiskey yourself from the sound.

[@AtifAziz0077]

lucky man.

[@mekore]

whisky demystified

[@cgavin1]

I wonder what happens to all these bottles after he's opened them! I'd like to offer my services in recycling them. I won't even charge you a fee! ;)

[@Whiskycom]

I don't think that sending a bunch of empty bottles around is in the spirit of recycling ;-)

[@RS-ec6ik]

Whisky.com HAHAHAHAHA....GREAT RESPONSE. GREAT VIDEOS. I HAVE PURCHASED SEVERAL BOTTLES BECUASE OF YOUR VIDEOS. THANKS SO MUCH. MUCH LOVE FROM NYC.

[@Whiskycom]

Thanks. Have fun with the whisky.

[@Cdubp01]

Whisky.com I think he was referring to the contents of the bottle rather than the bottle itself. haha

[@williamgrand9724]

LMFAO!!!!!!!! the mouth noises

[@Paiva1Henrique]

o vei é rocheda msm!

[@Paiva1Henrique]

_|_!!!!

[@tylergavin4757]

11:38

[@Wekotin]

I really hate the look of the new 2018 Macallan bottles. Same goes for Highland Park. It seems that Edrington is in business of ruining everything. For a whisky connoisseur the presentation (packages, labels) are at least equally important than the drink inside.

[@MrAlgonz]

you need subtitle and english is my first language

[@onedirection3510]

To some degree he was as enthusiastic about the 12. 🤷‍♂️

[@jez443]

Not a fan of Macallan. Much better highlands scotch out there

[@iancrombie8862]

Insanely expensive...not worth the big pricetag like most Macallans!!!👎👎👎

[@luish1341]

i wonder if he has dentures 😅

[@MrKitkennedy]

add some coke

[@mirak026]

You have a lot of saliva we can hear it.

[@robertsaurer5815]

Stop with the advertisements during the review, very annoying and you loose your focus on the review.

[@Theologian1.]

Just bought a bottle to celebrate Trump being gone!!! Cheers!

[@cryptojihadi265]

That didn't age quite as well as the Macallan. But then anyone with an IQ over 18 could have seen that coming.

[@900nrg]

2:59