Who Are The Most Underrated Players In Baseball? | MLB Mailbag Episode

#mlb #justbaseball #mailbag
Subscribe to Just Baseball and never miss a video here: @JustBaseballFans
*Use code JUSTBASEBALL when signing up on BETMGM: bit.ly/40eqL7x
*7 Day Free Trial - Outlier Data: shorturl.at/ewxHP
*Download the Gametime app and redeem code JUSTBASEBALL for $20 off your first purchase (terms apply) - gametime.co/
Questions:
1. Build the most underrated starting lineup based on the season so far - calvin_medcalf
2. When they retire will Verlander and/or Kershaw be top 10 pitchers of all time? - JacksonJobe1 on Twitter
3. If I told you three players who have debuted in the past year (since June 2023) are Hall of Famers, who would you predict and why? - CJ_Harris_9 on Twitter
4. Who are the most disappointing players (position players or pitchers) so far this season compared to your expectations? - Dylanwinick32 on Twitter
5. Which one of your pre-season takes were horrible, and which did you get spot on at this point? - Alex_Cornell26 on IG
6. Which rookies are not getting enough praise? Specifically for being overshadowed by the elite top rookies this year? - rgaretson24 on IG
7. More of a question for Jack, and maybe Aram, what percent of challenges through ABS are successful? - L_woo_23 on Twitter
8. For Peter, what’s the most you would pay for a tender bucket and judge burger if it meant the Yankees made Juan Soto a Yankee for life? - Mattcolumbia on Twitter
+++++
Time Stamps:
Intro: 0:00
All Underrated Team: 2:35
Top 10 Pitchers Ever: 25:41
Rookies to HOF: 34:29
Disappointments: 41:50
Best/Worst Takes: 46:02
*Underrated Rookies: 52:01
ABS System: 1:03:06
Juan Soto: 1:12:16
Download and subscribe to the pod!
Apple Podcasts: bit.ly/JustBaseballApple
Spotify: bit.ly/JustBaseballSpotify
Buy merch: justbaseball-merch.myshopify....
Subscribe to the newsletter: www.justbaseball.com/newsletter/
Subscribe to our other KZbin channels!
The Call Up: / @thecalluppod
Just Fantasy Baseball: / @justfantasybaseball
Who’s Better Baseball: / @whosbetterbaseball
Behind The Seams: / @behindtheseamspod
Marine Layer: / @marinelayerpod
Just Basketball: / @justbasketballfans
Follow us on social media!
TT: / justbaseballfans
X: / justbb_media
IG: / justbaseballshow
Twitch: / justbaseballfans

[@blakepriddy8641]

Ryan O’hearn has been consistently DHing at the 3 spot for the birds. Guys clutch hitting has been amazing. Worth a mention in the future

[@CapnReign]

Agreed as an Os fan he has been one of our best player this year

[@germanrottweiler2811]

Is he that good ?

[@teambigv]

Ol Reliable

[@darrellwilliams3405]

Yes he is totally underrated

[@damiansamuels367]

Peter is a national treasure lmaooo

[@ryanfoster2936]

peter is cooking with the chicken tender take. couldn’t agree more.

[@RyanReed-zl3sm]

"Bougie Peter" villian arc confirmed

[@villuminati5063]

agreed with the pitchers i think u guys kinda left out bob gibson tho

[@trentmeehan5482]

.300 xwOBA for Paredes, .362 for J Naylor. Naylor having the better year of the two and it isnt close

[@markmyers8808]

Peter said before the season he’d take Carlos Correa over Gunnar Henderson

[@peterappel2704]

Swing and a MISS

[@MinerMinesMinecraft]

Lamonte Wade Jr is more underrated and better at first imo. He’s been cooking this year.

[@teambigv]

LWJ also very underrated.

[@DerekDominoes]

I like Gunnar Henderson's HOF chances and I wouldn't pick ANY new pitcher.

[@C21-hv8ch]

The Hall of Fame will meet decade-long+ elite pitchers where they are statistically. The game has changed.

[@DerekDominoes]

@@C21-hv8ch And that's a big part of why I'm not betting on any pitchers in their first or second season.

[@brandondillman5841]

Why not have the ABS system in baseball as a guideline for umps? They don't have to agree, but if they're unsure on a close pitch they can opt to go with the ABS.

[@ajfredrikson2433]

Before I watch… I am hoping you guys mentioned ZEKEY Tovar! Or Rob refsnyder.!

[@brennansmith8636]

Where’s the love for Nick Gonzales? Kids been ballin

[@paradiseproductions1313]

Facts he single handedly saved our offense

[@JustBaseballFans]

This is a PRO Nicky G podcast!

[@germanrottweiler2811]

Yup under rated

[@THEOXECLEAN]

No Jurickson Profar in left? Or is he not considered underrated anymore

[@christophercampbell2929]

Having 1 good season in 10 years doesn't make you qualify for underrated. He's been rated correctly for 10 years.

[@kylestelter7550]

@@christophercampbell2929he was good in 2020 and in 2022

[@LuisRobert1234]

Go Bulls Jack!

[@craigturkel5624]

ABS human error, leave the human error in the hands or the players not the umps. Vegas now in bed with leagues, they want right, integrity of game. Also actually saves pitchers arms

[@LilBit4J316]

Bill Ankeny------- What about David Fry, Clevelend

[@BensPitchingClips]

David Fry yess, hes my all-star vote for DH

[@kylesheahan3992]

Alec Burleson got a sneaky decent baseball savant page