Who Are We To Say

[@graemeloyer]

Beautiful song. I have this on pianola roll which I play often. Don't write songs like this anymore. I lived in the wrong time.

[@maxinebombara7024]

So so Beautiful the look and hands say it all.

[@annamariaedvi5880]

There were problems between Jeanette and Nelson during the making of this film according to the research of Sharon Rich, but I feel this song helped to make peace...they seem both so sincere, and Nelson's caressing Jeanette's hand during the song is very touching. Thank you for sharing it.

[@katherineleonowski7289]

Yes I love how he always seems to reach for her and touch her hands but this song seems to touch them both so differently than most other songs it seems...like they truly are hurting....so sad...I wish they could have had their love lives the way they wanted and truly deserved!! Such a beautiful but tragic love story.....

[@maryleone2023]

@@katherineleonowski7289 You have said it so well. The movie which they did that portrays their tragic love story the best is Maytime. Perhaps they are together now as they were in the end of that wonderful but sad movie.

[@richardstien-o6s]

Maytime: greatest romantic film ever!

[@sheilasweeney1947]

My dad could sing all of nelson Eddy's songs had a voice just like nelson Eddy we grew up listening to that type of music who are we to say beautiful

[@christinedubois5954]

Nelson Eddy was a magnificent Baritone! Even though Nelson Eddy is dead, I will love him forever!!!!

[@lynettejacobs7151]

The words are so true. .❤

[@stellajennings2265]

These are two people who are loved forever my heart melts. ♥️♥️♥️

[@christopherpuleo5650]

I wore this hat and was in this!

[@CarolBeach-g7g]

Nelson, jeanette will live on in there love and music

[@maryheart1845]

I am glad to know that I watch there films and loved them very much

[@barbbrasgirl8]

The way she breaks down gets you every time she sings this song Thank you. Anne.

[@shirlthegirl631]

Lyrics: Love may fill your heart with a strange delight Love may build a world that is new Love may leave your heart like a winter night No one knows just what love will do Who are we to say Just what love will do? Love may live a day, or all life through Who are we to say How a rose will grow It may fade away or bloom and blow You and I may plan and scheme And every thing's arranged Then there comes a vagrant dream And all the world is changed! Who are we to say When to say goodbye Or to wonder why we two must part So we live today loving while we may dear Knowing love would say Obey your heart Who are we to say When to say goodbye Or to wonder why we two must part So we live today loving while we may dear Knowing love would say Obey your heart

[@maryleone2023]

Thank you so much for posting these lyrics, Shirl. I always loved this movie since it shows Jeanette & Nelson without the frills and showy costumes from other films. The love between them is so obvious in this scene. They truly had a love that transcended time and space.

[@maryleone2023]

Just the way they look at each other, in all their movies, is enough to know how much their love was real. When Jeanette married Gene Raymond, it broke Nelson Eddy's heart and he rushed into a loveless marriage. Jeanette married someone who resembled Nelson but was gay. Gene Raymond had an affair with another man while on their honeymoon.! How sad for Mac/Eddy!

[@maryheart1845]

It's sad they didn't married each other they were soulmates

[@patriciafilley2883]

She really did break down. This song was originally to be a duet between them. Nelson had to sing as a solo. Shame on Louis B. Mayer for keeping them from marrying each other.

[@davidking9197]

'She really broke down' come on It's called acting. She loved her husband Gene not Nelson.

[@richardbutcher3630]

Who are we to say, what magnificient voices, lost. Forecver oh darn darn, stunning duo, my life is lost with out such brilliant voices, miss you pair

[@almeggs3247]

Patricia Filley I understand she was under contract and even had an abortion?

[@LadySeraphineCC]

@@almeggs3247 she had miscarriages. Yup. Plural

[@eileenelliott6292]

David King you should get your facts right. Read their biography before making such crass remarks.

[@nilviafrossard9520]

Comecei bem o domingo bem acompanhada por essa música que adoro...

[@marycrim3352]

It would fulfill one of my earthly dreams to be myself and not be self conscience or shy.

[@walterbrady8424]

I never knew that Gus Kahn wrote with Sigmund Romberg. I mostly know him from lighter fare like "It Had to Be You"

[@EllisonBallard-m4y]

FriendlyFire: Who are we to say love might live a day or whole life through ...Who are we to say when to.say good bye, or to wonder why we too must part for we live today loving while we may dear, knowing love will fade, obey your heart ... Eddy w/good strong voice shows clearly his love. No sentimental dribble. A lot that passes for "love" now is just an excuse to be promiscuous w/no comment.

[@brucekogan7980]

The only original score for any of their films was the one for The Girl Of The Golden West. Sigmund Romberg and Gus Kahn did the score.

[@nilviafrossard9520]

Queria conseguir comprar os filmes deles...será que tem em São Paulo

[@RobinPratt]

Fans were disappointed that there was no major duet in this film.

[@Bettywhite12345]

TUNE THATPIANO n

[@stantopor3491]

Romberg wrote such a beautiful score ...Who Are We To Say is so poignant.

[@pamplayer4086]

🙋🏼‍♀️👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻😢😢😢😢😢😢

[@Лада-д4ы]

Классика жанра