Who Can Make the COOLEST Song in 24 HOURS?

[@RoomieOfficial]

All songs so far are up on Spotify & elsewhere under artist name ”Roomie Demos”!

[@cat8234]

Im ur first liker...

[@yesnt1228]

Okie

[@funtoriano]

I love your content but you need to make your video more fun. And try to make video with other. KZbinrs whose have more viewer and maybe change a little your content title.

[@MrNeon-fz3gg]

@ MR UPLOAD bruh I cant tell if your a bot if not dude his content is great and it doesn’t matter about views there is friends besides what do you know about content you don’t even have any vids

[@funtoriano]

@@MrNeon-fz3gg I said I love his. Content but. Change something is sometimes useful

[@willow4407]

I’m addicted to this entire series of competition song writing and producing, it’s all amazing

[@willow4407]

So proud of Joel for winning this time round!

[@blackmoon5620]

same here

[@mylowhighmind]

Yeah, same. It's really fun to watch.

[@genesistabuena1563]

I agree

[@ewelinakarlinska4005]

Me too, these are my favourites

[@PremiereGal]

The editing 😍. I don’t think many realize how much time, humor, and genius goes into these edits. Bravo!

[@damn6362]

e

[@jokybones]

yes i think one of the most entertaining Videos editing wise it adds so much

[@zainebhidoussi1498]

actually i respect them so much for editing and working so hard ik how much time they spent on that ..but personally i find the editing so cringe and they make so much useless editing ...like for example the 1st 1 minute of the video is so cringe ..if they all sat together in the same room and talked and the editor afterwards edits it in a simple way that will be simple informing and calm ..but the problem here they edit for the smallest things they say ..they say water they edit them with water ..they say it's cold ..they edit them with some snow ...it's okay if that was just 1 time or two ..but if it's with literally EVERYTHING roomie says that is so much ...anyways glad there are ppl who like that

[@snjert8406]

Yeah, it's nuts how much work this takes. I really appreciate it.

[@Name-oz4lq]

The edits are all corny as hell though

[@NoobieDoo]

daniel being a professional bagpipe player just fits for some reason

[@alecrechtiene558]

Because he never lets us know his next move!

[@jennyvonne5147]

This was such an amazing revelation and I was so disappointed he didn’t whip em out!!

[@SpyroShurtagul]

Right?! Like I was amazed but like... Not surprised hahahaha

[@crossbowcat]

it really does, he just be like that

[@jolantaglas910]

Thanks

[@RoomieOfficial]

Thanks for the superthanks Jolanta! :D Our first ever one on this channel, we just turned it on!

[@Jinturpie]

👍👍👍

[@XEAZUR]

wait why did i never see one of these dono comments

[@kontinued5823]

@@XEAZUR they just turned it on, as mentioned their reply earlier

[@XEAZUR]

@@kontinued5823 the ¨we just turned it¨ on was later added, you can see roomie edditted it

[@NathanJamesLarsen]

This was dang fun to watch - also this editing makes my head hurt thinking about how much effort it takes to do all that keyframing. unreal

[@Name-oz4lq]

It just hurts my head by being so corny

[@sagnikdas4168]

IT WOULD BE GREAT IF THEY RELEASE THESE SONGS ON SPOTIFY AFTER PROPER MIXING AND PRODUCTION AND STUFF WITH TAKING PROPER TIME....THIS SERIES IS AMAZING BY THE WAY....

[@sanjastajdohar6684]

Yeees, i want to listen to all three songs

[@jenay66]

I need Roomie's song!!!

[@xpaartan6916]

I especially want this for the satisfying songs! They were so amazing too!

[@sagnikdas4168]

@@jenay66 of course..

[@sagnikdas4168]

@@xpaartan6916 totally agreed

[@Juri121]

I enjoyed Jonas's lyrics the most, I liked Joel's sound the best, and August's song was the chillest and easiest to listen to while working (had it on the background on loop while working actually haha) so my only question is: when are all these songs, as well as the previous batch, going on Spotify?

[@tclaunchpad8813]

They are all on Spotify under the artist name “roomie demos

[@gamingtalent2888]

All songs were fire af - joel's beginning was too saameee to me but the rap was lit August's song was a bit too soft jonas' song was perfect in my opinion Love this series.

[@simonegalagar6751]

agreed but I think Jonas' song could've been "cooler" with a more powerful drum beat but other than that I still I preferred his song to the others.

[@gamingtalent2888]

@@simonegalagar6751 yeah, imagine the same song with a more powerful bass and a higher pitch, medium decay snare. It would slaapp

[@esme_4540]

Roomie is My Inspiration for music, I hope one day to be as good as him

[@rjpearson]

"you may call it cheating... But I call it!!!" "let's move on" 😂 Super cool vid joel! I've been dying for a roomie upload :D

[@rjpearson]

Ahhhhh!!! I got a heart from Joel!!!! ❤️❤️❤️

[@paisleylovesyousm]

@@rjpearson so did I! I nearly screamed!!

[@rjpearson]

@@paisleylovesyousm ay!! I nearly screamed too 😂

[@paisleylovesyousm]

@@rjpearson Lolll

[@paradigmengineering]

super happy to see this channel starting to really do music production stuff again

[@burcopresents]

Roomie's was my favorite one. Aside from the "I wanna be done" being kinda repetitive in some parts, I think it sounds the "coolest" as in it could be used as a soundtrack for a movie. And the rap part to finish was just pure fire and hype. I think the only part I didn't like about it was the beginning part. Edit: tho Jonas’ was my personal favorite, I still think Joel’s was the “coolest”.

[@arnevandeperre6931]

That synth loop of Jonas do be fire. I feel like it carries the whole vibe of the song. Would be cool if that synth was automated/played with more. Definitely imo the best and most unique song, but not really 'cool'. Augusts song was beautiful and mysterious, but also not really 'cool'. While Joel had the 'coolest' and the most professional sounding song, I feel like the pitched down vocal and the long breaks between some vocals threw me off a little bit. Overall, these songs were amazing. I wish I had the talent to do this in 24 hours. Great video, keep up the good work! :)

[@lawrencelopez9839]

It's nice to see the different creative processes and shenanigans different artists go through to create something.

[@kaitiep3007]

On Jonas's side of the guitar pads gives me a vibe of Gravity Falls and it's a good thing. On the second hand Roomie's version gives me a vibe of the Delinquents theme song

[@hart.6230]

Love this series, fire idea, highly underrated.

[@JennaEmbers]

if you like this series check out Andrew huang! he has this incredible series he’s done for years where he takes 4 producers and has them remix the same thing, it’s freaking amazing!

[@hart.6230]

@@JennaEmbers have watched them all loll

[@andidrogynous7347]

Jonas: “got stuck watching KZbin until 2:00 am” Me: watching this at 1:52 am

[@JaiLeeroy]

Joel's song definitely sounded the 'coolest', but I don't love the distorted voice. For that reason I like Jonas' song the best. Well done guys. 👏

[@ENVreal]

Yeah I agree I liked Jonas's the best but By definition of cool roomie wins

[@ronndenxltmallabo5717]

Same

[@dylanlockemp3]

if august was my dad my life would be better i just know it

[@focus_n_flow]

Hehehe, life is already better with August thanks to Joel 🍭

[@paulalmenana3354]

Roomie's song can fit well in Imagine Dragon's Discography lol Edgy and the beats are quite bombastic, I personally hate songs or bands that try to be edgy but Joel deserves the win because his song just succeeded in the vibe it is trying to portray

[@rennertje2]

it made me think of enemy a little bit

[@beard6329]

fr its just as bad!

[@shredded_cheese]

I thought the exact same XD only because I listen to them a lot

[@clairer342]

Roomie was the clear winner for a “cool” song, but they all were good songs. The judge comments were also spot on 👍 I love these songwriting videos!!

[@mariahmademusic735]

I love Joel’s song so much it went the hardest but Jonas comes in second with the cool sounding chord thing

[@ajbp95]

Wait, Daniel Thrasher has played bagpipes for five years?! Why haven't we seen anything concerning that on his channel? I demand some bagpipes!

[@paisleylovesyousm]

Been waiting a week, and ITS WORTH IT AGAIN!! Also, am i the only one who watches all his old videos (from 2020-2021) while i wait for a new one?

[@paisleylovesyousm]

@@lux704 good to hear 😅

[@paisleylovesyousm]

Also, thanks for the heart Joel, I'm rlly happy rn :)

[@siennamontoastcrunch]

CGGGGG BESTIE

[@paisleylovesyousm]

@@siennamontoastcrunch TY LOL

[@siennamontoastcrunch]

@@paisleylovesyousm YW

[@weaselqueen811]

I love, love this series so much. Maybe get other online song writers online involved. Jax and Shuba as guests in the series would be super exciting and fun!! ☺️☺️☺️☺️

[@bsidethebox]

Seconded! CG5 occasionally does stuff like this on stream (Twitch), too. I'm not musically inclined at all but for some reason I love watching the process of vague idea>actual product, even if it feels like black magic. :)

[@SprinkleGirl]

I think Jonus had the best song even though usually I think Joel has the best song. All of them were cool of course 😎

[@thunderbirdice]

I love both. They are in different genres I love listening to. It really depends on my mood.

[@thl2416]

I like his melody, it sounded so nice

[@ornys.]

Well earned Joel! "Cool" is the utmost feature in your songs. It almost feels like the challenge was made specifically for you to win! 😇

[@noush4835]

dude these songwriting challenges are THE best! keep it up pllsss maybe next challenge can writing a song with only 1 instrument? you can see how far you can stretch a single instrument!

[@BertoLaDK]

Love these songwriting challenges/videos. for the songs, Joel's definitely the cooler of the bunch, as for the best song and the one I see myself listening to that would be Jonas, just has more feeling in it.

[@Casett]

Special appearances by Bianca and Larissa! Now that's content. Love them ladies.

[@Olix466]

Omg 1 min ago 👀

[@nathancarmichael5600]

I’m addicted to this entire series of competition songwriting and producing, it’s all amazing.

[@mxrvrl430]

The swedish accents just makes it funnier😂 Great video as always

[@greenvampbun6332]

I couldn't pick which one sounds so cool until I just unconsiously say "Omg thats so cool." on Roomie's song. I love this competition song writing and all, and the behind the scenes and all was so fun to watch!

[@D.ONeill]

Beatboxing is WAY cooler than rap, Joel! Missed opportunity.

[@AppleFanBoiAFB]

beatboxing is not singing i guess

[@igorkoveklipy3018]

@@AppleFanBoiAFB but its music too!

[@brian576]

he doesn't really like justin timberlake for the beat boxing though 😅

[@D.ONeill]

@@AppleFanBoiAFB Neither is rapping...so...🤷‍♀️ At the end of the day, it's all just making noises out of the whole in your face. Lol I was just joking.

[@D.ONeill]

@@brian576 That's because Joel isn't cool enough 🤣 Again, I'M JOKING. Don't take everything seriously, y'all.

[@FaythInluv]

This type of content is different than usual, I love this type of content! Very educational and fun to watch! (Congrats, Joel!)

[@tahmidun_nahar]

this series is amazing ngl, well joel and jonas did really good in my opinion, the vibe joel gave me was great but jonas' one just took my heart

[@caramaena]

Loving this series. My favourite today was Jonas' - I love that indie vibe.

[@sophiegustaf18]

Everyone else: makes a love song Roomie: makes an emo song

[@foop2954]

Joel's song is a lot of things but definitely not Emo

[@undeadknight01]

@@foop2954 His song was literally called I Wanna Be Done and talks about leaving this earth, which can be taken to mean death/giving up.

[@gracechen624]

@@foop2954 I think it’s that Joel wrote an emo song this time.

[@foop2954]

@@undeadknight01 Emo isn't necessarily about that, and it's a very different genre to what he picked

[@foop2954]

@@gracechen624 As I said, the song isn't emo

[@fayesversion]

1:13 Jonas is me every time I tell my self to wake up early and be productive on Sunday morning

[@MMM-gb5ob]

“F*CK that I’m going back to sleep” Relatable as hell.

[@nightninja3632]

Why is Jonas such a relatable person 💀 I think Joel’s rap was dope but personally I loved Jonas’ song

[@bvttercvpx]

The fact this is one minute ago and there are already comments is so wholesome

[@pointlessprocrastination]

Username doesn't check out?

[@bvttercvpx]

@@pointlessprocrastination shhh

[@MMM-gb5ob]

ultimate crossover

[@bvttercvpx]

@@MMM-gb5ob wdym

[@comfortkabwe1547]

Joel you did it. Congratulations 👏 🎊 On a side note today I graduated with a MA in HRM. I sponsored myself from my savings. As a 35 yr old African woman am proud I hope to make a difference in my country. 👩‍🎓

[@kingakonyecsik2088]

These videos keep getting better and better. On every level. I looped the previous one too, I have my weekend programme. Again. Thank you for it.😊😊😊

[@SilverFangedWof]

Yeah this series is really amazing, it's really cool when friends try to do different type of music styles and emotions, it's really cool to see this stuff amazing looking forward to the next one

[@nzam82]

It's amazing how much creativity shines through in each one of these guys in such a short amount of time. I can barely accomplish basic, everyday tasks in 24 hours. Hope to see more of these challenges!

[@carlycharlesworth1497]

I absolutely loved all of these songs and would totally download them and sing along with them in the car if they were published online. They were each really good but each in a different way. My favourite lyrics were yours Joel. They were edgy and I love the way you sang them, like you were kinda numb inside. Very cool. Sad to say but the darker the lyrics, the more I relate to them from a time when life was equally dark for me. Thankfully that period of my life is long gone, and I am in a way better place, but I still felt the emotion when you sang those lyrics. God bless you, and all those you love. Have a great weekend!

[@ejayy29]

Even tho this video isn't meant to "teach" there is so much to learn even for a non-musician

[@paigewright152]

Omg! Joel yyyeeeesss!! I freaking LOVED that song lol I was vibing pretty hard to it! I love singing but as a writer that like a huge brick wall lol. So much talent between all of you!!!❤❤

[@__Helga___]

Cool bois writing cool songs in the cool songwriting video 😎🔥 This is definitely a great treat for us!

[@marmaniac]

Great content, guys. It’s very interesting to watch and useful either for people learning composing songs or just inquisitive minds. Top-notch

[@noush4835]

I'm kinda surprised no one did hard rock. imo, that's definitely cool :)

[@vupert9324]

Yeah, I mean rock or guitar heroes aren't really considered to be cool anymore, but a badass guitar riff will always be one of the coolest things to me. Examples would be Can't stop by the Red Hot Chili Peppers, I want it all by Queen (the beginning) or basically every AC/DC song.

[@noush4835]

@@vupert9324 AC/DC was my exact thought when I made the comment hehe

[@rmdavidov]

@@vupert9324 all of black aabbath

[@DoiInthanon1897]

Right? Same with me, hard rock is awesome. It’s probably why I liked Joel’s the best :)

[@randomish4285]

Same thoughts

[@BoxedbyArrowFN]

I love that there is hip-hop music constantly playing in the background, it is cool

[@jaredjohnson5976]

Make sure the cat subscribes 😂 6:57

[@irisamelia9787]

Most important thing learned in this video... DANIEL CAN PLAY THE BAGPIPES!

[@MicheleeiRettili]

its clear i have a COMPLETELY different concept of cool 🤣 all of that sounded so whimpy

[@loonylovesgood]

Jonas doesn’t even live with Joel anymore and he still has to make himself look shorter on the green screen. 🤣

[@melinawiltgen8450]

I love the amount of support they have for each other but still humorous criticism in the videos. So wholesome but entertaining!

[@Casett]

This is the content I love! Great work everyone and keep it up. Only downside I found was there were a few too many greenscreen edits. I love when they are used a bit more sparingly to punch things up. No need for the number used. Overall, super video going into my favorites right away!

[@kimcass4440]

I love how people can have such different opinions-I loved the green screen edits so much! It felt like a 2018-2019 Roomie video and I loved every second. 😂

[@Casett]

@@kimcass4440 I do enjoy them but I think we would get more videos and the jokes would hit better if there were less. 🤷‍♀️

[@yellheahtris]

Roomie's had total Imagine Dragons vibes to it, and I really really liked that. The lower / distorted vocals on that, was something I wasn't expecting to like as much as I did!

[@__Helga___]

This type of videos is my favourite! Keep up the great work 🤩

[@missrobinhoodie]

Agreeed!!! 🤩

[@thenamesbarretto]

Jonas: "...I'm going back to sleep." P.S: "I'm Batman" Such a deep wake-up voice!!

[@maryortiz5806]

I liked Jonas song the most but the coolest sounding to me was August, Joel's song being a close second imo.

[@noahclark7300]

PLEASE MAKE FULL VERSIONS OF ALL THESE AND PUT THEM ON SPOTIFY

[@derrickgott007]

“Done is better than good….” Words to live by

[@JL-ji7xw]

Really love the new content Joel’s been putting out. More original music and less reaction content. I know it’s not easy to create and takes more time but I’m glad he’s been taking the time to create things he can be proud of.

[@adrianna203]

They are all very talented. My fav= Joel, but I absolutely loved Jonas's song too!!

[@vic5597]

The evolution of Joel"s hair is showing the struggle of making music lol

[@MR-LOBO]

If u want to hear the final songs 7:49 9:35 11:03

[@FallOutKidd]

Please keep doing these types of videos! They’re amazing!!!

[@power-player]

I really like these challenges, and your Voice is amazing.

[@aya_nz]

Loved August’s very scientific process. Joel’s technical prowess is amazing. Jonas’ process was ridiculous, but I liked his song best!

[@PlumberryPuppet]

That was such an abrupt ending to the video. "Jiva, who was the winner and why?" You get the immediate reactions but no explanation of why Jiva chose the winner.

[@glockfinnagiveyouaclue]

I have an addiction to this series

[@kendrakissimmee]

Now do "who can write the best rock song in 24 hours." These are fun.

[@AmberlashMusic]

I love this series so much! Great job guys! 👍

[@Nannonoys]

Love this series so much! It's a lot of fun seeing what directions you guys take. I didn't know what a "cool" beat would sound to me, but as soon as I heard Joel's beat I was like "Yeah, this is it."

[@ukrainegaming2167]

Joel's Rapping is like Eminem Rapping,it starts of slow and then at the end is goes fast

[@IAm-No1]

Even when his hair is a mess, Joel still looks great!

[@jessiatca]

Man, I do love a good, deep horn section. I think it's so cool how different you all went! Really loving this series!!!

[@missrobinhoodie]

The music is cool but the editing makes us laugh!👌🏻

[@joshuaadams9232]

Anime music defo is the coolest music genre imo. Songs like black catcher, mukanyjo, gurenge just hit hard

[@beckylorion6391]

Love this series! Gotta give this one to Jonas though!

[@brningman]

Please keep doing these series! I love the music writing challenges all over youtube and these are super great. It makes me want to get back into writing music as well!

[@_eIIa_]

here's my opinion that nobody asked for: jonah: i really loved this song! the background synth was so catchy and the chords were awesome in the chorus. i think the lyrics were pretty good too, even when they were a bit lacking, everything else like the chords made up for it. in terms of coolness, i wouldn't say it was the most cool song in the world? i mean thats just my personal opinion, but i dont think it really has the components of a typically cool song. maybe if it had some percussion? anyway, all in all i really really loved the song and the intervals in the vocals were so cool. august: this was a great song in general, but in terms of coolness i wouldn't rank it very high. it's more soft and sappy lol. i loved the sound of it though! i think maybe the vocal production couldve been a little better? idk. it was a great song overall, just maybe didnt have the coolness factor they were aiming for. was a really pretty song though. joel: this was honestly such a good song. it perfectly hit that coolness factor! the vocal production and distortion was great and the horns and percussion was perfect! i think lyrics in the verses were maybe a bit basic? i think there couldve been more there. but they were amazing in the chorus, as was the melody. and the rap bit was epic! the whole production was amazing! just a very stereotypically cool song, which was the goal. i'm not a trap/rap fan, but this was pretty awesome. overall winner of the challenge (in my opinon): joel my favourite song: jonah

[@Penmacie]

Ok boys! Please do this but inspiration through the decades!!!!! And a grand finale “in the future” edition! Set some trends! I’m loving this!

[@genesistabuena1563]

This series is truly one of the best. Keep it up guys!

[@MrMafiks]

If it hasn't been done before, two ideas are: 1. Most successful band member replacements (like AC/DC) 2. Famous songs with unknown singers (or where the singers names aren't in the title) (like How deep is your love and Wake me up)

[@arkiharrisonvolleyball]

Roomies song sounded like trendsetter with the horns

[@jblen]

This series is really cool. You've got the process of songmaking, but very fast paced, so much so that you get 3 songs in 15 minutes, plus you learn a lot about the elements that give certain vibes rather than most composition videos which just stick with their style.

[@ziggystardust3263]

well, I would immediately do an 80s metal type song, guess I'm way too out of the loop

[@tylercady3985]

I would have either done 80's metal, or early Linkin Park (Hybrid Theory/Meteora era). So you aren't the only one way out of the loop

[@quickflash2studios232]

This video is an interesting look into what pop-fans think is “cool”. I’m with you guys, I would’ve done a rock song

[@_eIIa_]

yeah my immediate first thought was a rock song, but i also think like an indie rock song with an awesome guitar/base line (or even a solo) is really cool too

[@ziggystardust3263]

@@_eIIa_ yeah, my baseline for coolness is like metal, since that's like the only thing I listen to xD

[@ziggystardust3263]

@@quickflash2studios232 yeah, like all of my knowledge on pop music comes from watching Joel's videos, I basically only listen to metal.

[@MirikaNL]

I really love these challenges between you guys.

[@simondanielssonmusic]

Jonas is my favourite this time. The chorus is cool af in my honest opinion

[@tobiaslofi]

Who ever edited this video spend more time on editing all of the jokes&memes in than the time it took to make all these 3 songs combined. Great work!

[@kaymarie252]

I really want a full version of Joel's song. I would actually listen to it so much.

[@NotSoberShober]

I want a full version of Jonas' song

[@potato_girl]

I feel like Jonas' song was something that I usually listen to so I'm gravitating to it. I'm not an expert in music but I was waiting for August's to do something? I don't know how to explain it lol. Joel's I would say was the coolest but the beginning was too repetitive for me but still really good! All in all I think everyone did an amazing job!!!

[@maurycy_gnc]

In comparison, Roomie just outclassed them. That's not even an argument

[@admiralthrawn717]

This series about songwriting is the best series on this channel! So cool!!!! KEEP IT GOING PLS

[@Mayarmageddon]

Joel, you are cool, you can say anything and it'd be cool.