Writing the most satisfying songs of all time - challenge

[@RoomieOfficial]

All songs so far are up on Spotify & elsewhere under artist name ”Roomie Demos”!

[@amogus----------5231]

Yay

[@d0gstone763]

Gay

[@jamessodaa]

YES PLEASE RELEASE NOT THE SAME FULL VERSION IT’S SO GOOD

[@rugbynoogi]

You should track down people in internet that sounds like what you've pictured, just to see If It actually works! If I was talented, I would love to help with my voice. 😉

[@pebblewolfz1340]

How only 4 replies?!? (Well 5 now)

[@juniperloo]

Roomie: gets straight into it Jonas: panics August: tries to figure out what satisfying means

[@xdimitrije]

What does one mean when one is "satisfying"

[@thijnhogendoorn6598]

One does not simply *satisfy*

[@csz5794]

There are three types of musicians

[@bucquoismusic]

@@thijnhogendoorn6598 True. And it's not easy to write songs, I can attest to it 😅

[@hadinasrallah8928]

August the philosopher

[@WillaGaming]

Joel: Most catchy song (it has been stuck in my head all day) Jonas: Best vocals and singing voice by far August: Song best fitted the prompt - most satisfying

[@dudkover0133]

Nah, Jonas is best fitted.

[@irisamelia9787]

I love it when Joel's proud of himself. He needs to be aware of how awesome he is.

[@bucquoismusic]

😀 I agree, because it's not easy to write a new song. I can relate and attest to it, because I try... 🤪😇

[@irisamelia9787]

@@bucquoismusic Same 😄

[@PremiereGal]

Jonas got them pipes!!! Super satisfying belting.

[@kor3481]

Im the 100th like

[@carlycchapman]

100%

[@wilson7612]

699th like

[@that_one6339]

RIGHT? Jonas is my favorite singer out of the three. He’s great.

[@pebblewolfz1340]

4 replies only?!? (Well 5 now)

[@nizaramirmusaffa8243]

I love Jonas' song, I think his definition of "satisfying" really nailed it for me. Kudos for the video, beautifully done

[@krackacka]

Joel's chorus gave me chills- that's a massive thing for me to find satisfaction in a song.

[@EpiphoneShredzzzzz]

He really nailed it with the gang vocals. Great idea

[@alphoricproductions3786]

bruh same i've never gotten chills from a song before and this did it

[@nadinetheband]

I like them all differently! Joel had the catchiest melody (that's been stuck in my head all day) I loved August's lyrics. Jonas's voice sounded amazing. I really like this series, and can't wait to see where it goes!

[@korarose5665]

I actually liked Jonas’s and Joel’s songs more, honestly would love a full version of both their songs! And Jonas’s voice and tone were awesome and very satisfying to listen! Would love to hear more of his singing.

[@aptthedoctor2703]

Its so funny to watch the saga of Joel's hair getting messier and messier as the video goes along 😂 Really fun vide guys, 😂

[@reallifemediaco]

🤣🙌🏼

[@cruisematt8585]

I loved it! Lol

[@isaamaandaa]

joel's hair really said ⬇️⬆️⬆️⬇️⬆️⬇️⬆️

[@jennamenzies3652]

Yes! It must be a self soothing gesture because it gets messy as hell when he's stressed 😂

[@renro4435]

YES XD

[@stephanieblakey1338]

Here's me hoping Joel releases his song as a single, I would just have it on repeat all...day...long. gives me so many vibes Roomie!!!

[@ingridn0g]

YESSSSSSSS

[@ajbp95]

I would like to have all three!

[@kacarnahanabmm213]

It’s a fucking bop and a half!

[@ajbp95]

Found that all are linked i the description, so at least you can listen to them on YT at least.

[@asrith2720]

@@kacarnahanabmm213 Fax

[@Raev222]

ROOMIE, THAT CHORUS. SO GOOD. I agree that Jonas' belting is always satisfying. Generally such a good voice. Love his style. I loved most of August's song. Very dreamy and pleasant. It was maybe the most coherent song. Few things that pulled me out of my dreamy relaxed state lol, but it was good.

[@lizadarkness]

I honestly liked all of the songssss- Joel's lyrics were(for me) more relatable(also the vocals), and I really loved August's music... and Jonas song gave me a great vibe- I'M TORN- it's harder than choosing favorite parent

[@Penmacie]

Yep… I love Jonas’ voice! Joel’s song had great oomph with the gang vocals… August had that mellow satisfying sound. Too hard to schools!

[@roastedporkchop]

Hyphens

[@GeoZoo-official.]

Who’s your favorite parent? 🤪

[@chargerscutiepie101]

Not really my dad sucks

[@meredith71607]

joel’s song literally gave me goosebumps like jonas said haha, it just seemed like everything went together really well. i feel like when i hear satisfying i think of something hard executed really well or powerfully/with impact, so i feel like joel’s was the best there! i know nothing about music though haha, and the other two songs were really chill too! and i love to hear jonas sing again! great job august for winning 👏👏

[@rainbowzgrqce]

I don’t even need to watch this to know that it’s gonna be epic- every collab video is AMAZINGLY EPIC!!!

[@icecream5464]

I agree!

[@joshuamyles4992]

The only real unsatisfying thing? Learning that these songs aren't completed and on Spotify D:

[@nsabella2608]

I need Jonas and Joel's songs FULLY released. ASAP!! I FREAKIN LOVE IT.

[@MrNotAGamer]

*sad august noises*

[@kensingtonvanhouten5565]

Joel: "Check out this hot wings song writing challenge we did just the other day" The other day: "5 months ago" 🤣😂🤣

[@martypfeiffer1529]

This was a very satisfying video. Usually, these song-in-a-day challenges are kinda stressful, but not this time. Filming “thinking about what to write” segments and “calling a friend” felt very natural. Hope you do more of these!

[@hijabiloser313]

I know August's song was deemed the most satisfying, but can we at least agree that Joel's song was the best? Just saying, if satisfying doesn't work out, he still got a bop on his hands

[@sarahprince2412]

I would have honestly either picked Jonas or Joel’s over August. His song may be good but their’s was just better and caught my attention more. That’s just my thought.

[@Sassyt5]

I want a full release version of Joel’s tbh

[@Upper_echelon_exotics]

I actually liked Jonas' song best...

[@tenniehall829]

I agree Joel best

[@chewiyminecraft1495]

@@Upper_echelon_exotics Same

[@__Helga___]

I need all three songs on Spotify or somewhere else so I can listen to them on repeat depending on my mood, pretty please 🥺

[@magalieleplus]

Oh yes please.

[@lydiahuff541]

Yes yes yes yes yes please!!

[@TylerLeeJones]

Jonas: *writes song for the first time in 3-4 years* 10:15 Joel: "that's really good man. ok so MY song-" but on a sentimental note, i'm genuinely so excited to hear new Jonas music, ive been a fan of both of them since the Skyfall cover (2012), incredible voice and musician 💖

[@kingakonyecsik2088]

I know what I'm going to do this weekend: watching this vid on repeat. This is amazing, the hard work, the songs, the editing... all incredible.

[@alexislarsh1074]

Joel's gave me goosebumps and no kidding caused my eyes to water, the chorus is exactly what I think of when I hear 'satisfying'. Joel's voice stood out and I loved it so much. (my favourite) Jonas's song gave me chills at the chorus and I love his low voice and his lyrics were so beautiful. August's voice was so gentle and it fit the song very well, his lyrics were clever and really pretty.

[@marmaniac]

When August’s song started playing my first thought was “it would be hard to compete with in satisfying category”. But J&J did make me admit that it’s a tight contest. Thanks for your art, guys🤗

[@andidrogynous7347]

Wow, roomie’s gave me legitimate chills. They were all satisfying, but good god, roomie nailed it

[@musicalifornia49]

Your talent never ceases to amaze me. All three songs gave me goosebumps, and when I heard Joel's chorus, my jaw was on the floor. They are all so good!

[@bucquoismusic]

I agree. It is not easy to do, I can relate to that 😄😇

[@kobzyy]

how your jaw stretch that far 🤨

[@musicalifornia49]

@@kobzyy TMJ 😂😂

[@annelisehorne6615]

I loved all the songs so much but personally I think Joel won. His lyrics hit harder for me and the beat and melody just was so groovy. Also the transition between a quiet verse to a belting chorus is just genius to me it just sounded amazing. I loved all three songs a lot, it would be so cool if y'all made a full song out of it and posted it on Spotify!

[@franzir1298]

All three songs are awesome but I really love Joel‘s song. I’m super impressed they made them in just 24 hours

[@bucquoismusic]

Agree. And it's not easy to do, I can relate to that 😇

[@Outpost31band1]

The best part of Joel’s was that little adlib at 11:54

[@JelenaMajic]

I have to admit I expected August to be miles ahead (I find his music really satisfying), but J&J blew me away too! As dusty as Jonas might be, he knows what he's doing, and Joel's approach was refreshing and made me kinda emotional ngl so, well done everyone!

[@poludelisismis]

I follow Roomie because he and his guests are showing their talents in almost every video. We need more of those 👌👀😃

[@nathanvarghese.]

Roomie already recording the vocals… Meanwhile Jonas pulls up an article on what is the meaning of satisfying sound 😂

[@mitchstokes7903]

You need to do this more, this seems very similar to what corridor crew does in a lot of their videos and this is great. Do more of this it’s so fun to watch

[@rainbowzgrqce]

Generally, Joel’s voice is quite powerful, so I wasn’t expecting his song to work as well as it did! (The first thing that comes to my mind when I hear ‘satisfying’, is ‘calming’, but now I’ve seen this, I suppose not!) Also- DAMNN, THOSE LYRICS!!! Y’ALL’S LYRICS!! Omfg, they were so good!

[@gabrielavukota2]

I need a full release of August’s song on Spotify, ASAP! That one really hit the nail on the head for me 😍👏🏻

[@RevvyShorts]

Sameee idk why nobodys talking about august's song!!

[@DoiInthanon1897]

Dang when was the last time Jonas was on a Roomie video? So glad he made a reappearance! Now we just need Dave and we’d be golden

[@walkerforever5361]

Yeah, I miss dave so bad. 😢 hope he's doing well

[@DoiInthanon1897]

@@walkerforever5361 I know, he’s a great dude! Really would like him back uploading too

[@kendrakissimmee]

I didn't know Jonas had such a beautiful voice. I would like to hear more from him.

[@MelissaRogers_natesLilgirl5]

It was so nice seeing August and Jonas!! I love hearing Jonas sing…I’ve really missed it!! All three songs were very Satisfying to my ears, ngl!! I agree wholeheartedly with you Joel…Jonas’ belting is really nice!! 💙💛💙💛💙💛

[@MaMaeViElle]

Okay if I'm being honest I wasn't expecting them all to be this good!! I loved it! Also, it was great to see Jonas again in one of your videos!

[@the_eryn8336]

please do more of this it is so entertaining and also interesting because we see how songs are produced

[@mochacoffeebear]

Yes! I agree 100%.

[@ILoveYou-bv7mf]

The lyrics from Roomie are definitely my favourite! I love different parts of the other 2 songs, but I think the most complete one for me would be Roomie's, also Jonas' is superb with his belting and the little silence, I loved how he started the song ngl! For August, I liked the "waiting for you" part, I liked lots of different parts but not everything. Joelle's though definitely feels so so satisfying and full, like it's complete! It really seems like you're going on the journey, and the lyrics are definitely my favourite, it was also quite motivating ngl!

[@nathanvarghese.]

August definitely killed the “satisfying” factor. Even his lyrics were satisfying (unlike Joel’s😂 no hate but how did he so happily belt out sad lyrics?😂)

[@jazz_meh]

Joel was going for the emo vibe and having happy sounding sad stuff is 100% it

[@MikhailYT]

Basically 2009 fall out boy

[@idontknow_whattowritesooo130]

@@jazz_meh I think he was going for a Paramore thingy

[@overwhelmedmama1962]

See Shawn Mendes "When You're Gone" haha. On "happily belt out sad lyrics". xD

[@bIeaq]

watching everyone vibe to each other's music is so wholesome. also these songs gave me chills

[@confetti8003]

Joel, kindly release the full song on Spotify, I need that on my playlist forever. Thank You.

[@Maddest_of_Hatters]

I loved all of their songs. Super impressive and amazing job, gentlemen! Jonas' singing and songwriting is always a pleasure to listen to. I wish he would record more.

[@markdavidfernandez2752]

petition to have all of them release all these songs as singles

[@_AshishKumar-jk9uh]

August's song lyrics were the most satisfying, the rain tapping and the sunlight hitting, etc etc 😌🎶🎶

[@miguelmarques6672]

This is one of my favorite videos Joel has made. Really liked all the songs and I think we got just the right amount of time of watching them produce them

[@JOEDUCER]

Loved this video format!

[@regular67]

F1 driver, professional curling player and now a songwriter. Another person in the Bottasverse

[@hungry_goldfish]

😂 😂 A man of many talents

[@micholitzia5726]

“A satisfying song must not stagnate” well said. This is why I love so much “tale on me” by aha. Catchy riff invites you in, flowing yet poetic lyrics guides you through a very quick verse, straight into the iconic chorus. Not a single dull moment no matter how many times I’ve heard the song

[@aryabanerjee9294]

Love ur vids been a fan since a long time...lots of love (when can we have dave back with those sounds like music but isnt series ?)

[@walkerforever5361]

Yeah, we need dave back!🙏

[@dale_agameroftheworstgen]

This was amazing to watch. All three songs were incredible. Great job guys!! 😀

[@zanichellialessia2815]

Jonaaaasss! I may be crying right now. Great video idea Joel! btw, I love watching you guys having so much fun at what you love, your smiles are everything!!

[@63angel]

This is a really good video. I enjoy the videos that shows that your enjoying yourselves. It makes a huge difference when anyone shows what they enjoy and are happy to be themselves. I have enjoyed your videos for a long time. There are some that has stood out to me and this is one of the videos I will save. All of you did an awesome job.

[@theirlmess]

You know you're having a good day when Joel uploads, with his friends ofc✨✨

[@IHW14]

You guys GOT to finish and publish these songs! I want to put them in a playlist! AMAZING job!!!

[@Kloothommel]

Dammmm I really like Joel’s voice in this one, it’s so strong and the layers rly work well with it!

[@isabelle5597]

I definitely need all those songs on Spotify to listen to on repeat ❤️‍🔥

[@loonylovesgood]

I am visiting my hometown for the first time in 3 years. Let me tell you, all 3 songs got me SUPER emotional. You’re all super talented songwriters, my dudes. ♥️

[@jennamenzies3652]

I love all the songs!! They all need to go on Spotify please 🙏 Also, I love how Jonas seems to get super proud and happy when listening to Joel's song.

[@Paradigm7977]

I can say with complete confidence that each of these songs would have been added to my playlists. Great job you guys.

[@jordanlemay8996]

I just loved Joel’s song!! I have to hear a full version of that song plz complete it and put it online (i can see that song became the next great Lil Pitchy song)

[@JaiLeeroy]

Fantastic work, great songs. I agree August's song was good, as much as I love Joel's voice in the chorus.

[@Intheshadows18]

Liked all songs for different reasons but agreed with Alex for the most part. August’s verse was so strong that the chorus could’ve been different instead of the same phrase. Jonas’ inclusion of (… was that syncopated?) drums was a bit confusing but holy hell I forgot how great your voice is dude 🤯 (also are you done with your channels? 🥺). Joel’s song is the closest one to songs that I most likely already listen to. Powerful lyrics and voice as usual. Nice inclusion of the G note editor(s). This was an amazing video 💜

[@petrakonecnaportaits]

Really nice video. I think it was interesting to see the process behind making the songs. I liked all of the songs though I liked Joel's song the most.

[@bucquoismusic]

Wow you are really talented. Your drawings are beautiful and excellent. 😀🙃

[@simantasaha4051]

Yeah, the tapping sounds that were going from left to right along with the peaceful sounds really did make alex's song, the most satisfying to listen to......Jonas' song was really interesting and the prechorus harmonies were pure gold.....Joel's song had the most pop vibe and was the most enjoyable since pop is my favourite genre, and that surprising minor chord was a cherry on the cake, also that i-i-i part on the verse was really cool....Kudos to the boys

[@NikitaKLo]

Jonas is such an amazing musician and singer. I wish he made more music.

[@Cannot_handleit24]

I seriously need full versions of these songs! Especially Joel's, it's absolutely my kind of vibe!

[@YayHappens]

I loved them all. Everyone did an amazing and impressive job. Loved the lyrics in each sample. Would love to see some cleaned up takes.

[@gradesgobrrrrr1539]

Each of them have different styles and I really liked all of their approaches!! August had a very melodic symbolism of rain and it felt very experienced in the ‘satisfying’ aspect. The special instrumental sounds created a mystical effect that made me feel quite relaxed! Jonas was great with vocals, and just like the judge said, the use of rain was great too and the mute before the chorus was absolutely amazing in creating a wholesome effect for the chorus Joel’s was wonderful instrumentally, I liked all parts of the instrumental and it came together beautifully. From this video, Joel has the best vocals out of the three and it helped to convey the most emotion in this which makes it satisfying as it becomes more relatable to the listener.

[@bleh-0608]

JONAS!!! I missed you two together so much! 😭

[@GAWOP00]

Would love to see you three do a relay challenge, one makes the music, one makes the lyrics and one sings and mixes the song. We did mix relays in sound engineering class, where we have to pick up leveling and adjusting a musical without knowing exactly what the other person was going for direction wise.

[@annelisekraft-williams7365]

Joel needs to release this song and the one from the hot wings challenge, they're both absolutely amazing!!

[@AlineVerdade]

Oh, you guys are talented AF. August really achieved the target of satisfying, Joel created a Hymn that any musical TV show should record, and Jonas' one, c'mon, made me so emotional, I love it. Please put all 3 of them out

[@D.ONeill]

I think it would be interesting to hear you look through a friends' Spotify playists and comment on them. (obv you van blurr their info.)

[@aboynamedsue6912]

Honestly till today , I never knew that August lives in the Netherlands or maybe even was born in the Netherlands .Just because most of us Dutchies talk English in a very special way but I didnt hear it and I still don't hear it when August is talking. For the rest , I was hooked since I came randomly across one of your video's . The skill and quality along with a good amount of humor makes this channel good enough to binge watch.

[@Trashpanda04]

these need to be put on Spotify right now

[@susanbourque]

Me here finding everyone's songs satisfying and also falling in love with Jonas and August's voices since I already loved Joel's so now I'm just mellow and happy. And all of them being super supportive and non-competitive while showing each other's songs was so heart-warming too. Just overall good vibes from this one and would love music like this from you guys to add to a playlist in Spotify (LilPitchy made it to my 2021 what's it called at the end of the year... Wrapped? the summary thing so I actually do listen and still listen to that playlist because obviously I love love). Thanks guys for a great wholesome content collab

[@colefetherston1431]

These are all really good! Honestly I would listed to all of these a lot if they were on Spotify

[@OttomanWarriorWoman]

Fantastic video. All 3 songs were fab and unique. My favourite song was the one from August. Very downloadable

[@bingus4life]

I love how Joel’s hair gets crazier the longer the video goes on 😂

[@that_one6339]

Joel’s song was my favorite! I love the bass in the verse, and the gang vocals in the chorus.

[@Lizoja]

It's so funny to see how far away Joel has come from the Swedish "no brag"-culture which gets extra noticeable next to his fellow swedes 😅 August song was my fav! (And also - got so surprised to see Daniel Caesar in frame, who's one of my husbands best friends. Totally burst out a HA!, paused the video and called in the hubby😆)

[@bucquoismusic]

Hehehe... Swedes are known for making good music 😄😇

[@Lizoja]

@@bucquoismusic indeed!

[@dylanlockemp3]

god i love august

[@yaboitheaceofwall4032]

all three of you guys are insanely talented I cannot pick a favorite

[@fhtvchannelofficialyt7385]

11:40 - 11:45 When your song was in goosebumps, that Jonas feeling... Jonas: (seeing in side of the hand) GOOSEBUMPS! 😄 Joel: (laughing face) 😂

[@Not_Nasra1]

Every time I’m in the middle of a roomie official video another one comes out I’m so excited I love satisfying videos

[@Scholz23]

The second song sounds like a nakey jakey song and I love that

[@edieyown]

Oh finally, a much needed Roomie content. ❤️

[@isaamaandaa]

*in conclusion, y'all have such amaazingg voices! also i find it so adorable when all three of them just vibe to each other's songs hehe.* ✨

[@__Helga___]

Woohoo! I love songwriting videos on your channel ❤️

[@GamerBlake-xy7gu]

This has to be the best songs y'all have made on your channell they are so good keep the great work!

[@debasmitdey1132]

I'm personally a huge sucker for those songs which have a super catchy chorus and a not so catchy verse... So Joel's song might not be the most satisfying one but it was definitely the best one for me! But then again August and Jonas also made super amazing songs too! Hats off :)

[@adrianna203]

They all did great, but I LOVED Jonas's and Joel's songs. Awesome video!!

[@laurawr_c]

interesting, all the songs were very satisfying and it was actually impressive yall produced it in a short amount of time but i gotta say in my opinion, i liked joel's and jonas' songs more. guess different taste in music 😄

[@authenticallyk]

i agree. but it was a fun video & everyone did a good job for the time allotted :)

[@anajbako5067]

I agree. I kinda hate too many repetitions and August´s song was a lot about that so...

[@Sanity016]

you NEED to do more songwriting challenges. they're so much fun to watch.

[@SarahM4519]

I'm soooooo looking forward to a sequel!

[@GivenFailure]

I'm surprised that nobody mentioned harmonic resolution as satisfying, the melody is obviously super important, but chords are basically just fancy voice leading.