Who danced LOONA SO WHAT the best? A Dancer's Analysis

The whole purpose of this video is to help non-dancers, beginners, or anyone who is in the process of learning Kpop choreographies to learn key points in dancing.
⚡ Read the following for your concerns :)
• HOW THE SCORING WORKS?
otsdanceanalys...
• Q&A with ON THE SCENE
otsdanceanalys...
• WEEKLY DISCUSSION
otsdanceanalys...
You can also have a direct discussion with me about your favorite idol, or about yourself if you're a dancer.
• ASK HERE
otsdanceanalys...
MORE BLOG CONTENTS:
otsdanceanalys...
=================================
© Copyright Disclaimer under Section 107 of the copyright act 1976, allowance is made for fair use for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favour of fair use. ©

[@onthescene7897]

This week's analysis is LOONA's So What! For non-fans, the members' names are placed just before the analysis. Visit www.otsdanceanalysis.com to get to know the channel more! Please read the description for your concerns :) Those who have requests, reply in here the song/group and the reason on why should I consider them for an analysis, so I can surely read it :) Thank you for watching! ♥

[@arsenelli]

Hi! Can you analyze NCT Dream’s Ridin? All of the members have different styles of dancing, so I think it will be very interesting if you analyze them ^^ They are also known to be one of the best dance groups in Kpop. Thank you!! edit: I just checked her playlist and apparently she is going to analyze Ridin. Haha looking forward to it!

[@xcyurel8918]

Please Can you make Gfriend dance Analysis ?. kzbin.info/aero/PLQlOCrTx64Ml4TQ0tkbgX5KOlbB4qaUYY Sinb said that Gfriend member dance ranking is: 1.Sinb 2.Yuju 3.Umji 4.Sowon / Yerin 5.Eunha there are two members on the same rank. so can you make Gfriend dance analysis. If you want to use FEVER, I hope you will also see CROSSROADS, because in this era the ability of Gfriend Dance members is increasing compared to FEVER. but FEVER has many of the same moves, so you will be able to analysis it more easily. I hope you Read this. Thank you.

[@beomgyusmullet]

thanks for the names it's helpful since i don't stan them but i rlly like ur videos :)

[@hannifiedseventeencontent]

Please do twice too, as a whole tho, we all know that they have good dance line tho. kzbin.info/www/bejne/h4XJq6WviqefhZI

[@doriart1038]

Hi can you do an analysis for bts-on. Because most videos about them are pretty old and I think they have improved a lot, and their dance is more difficult this comeback. I've also heard some people say that jhope is no longer the main dancer or something like that so I think it's gonna be really interesting

[@patriciaa5469]

The feeling when ON THE SCENE says "same points as earlier" and you forgot what it said.

[@pattyh2089]

😂😂 Yeah It's sometimes too fast :c I have to repeat multiple times

[@cassie8844]

Same

[@azra_70s]

Technique for that is to comprehend the analysis & watch the idols' move/step after, so that when that comes, you knew already what the OP meant.. 🤗

[@cassie8844]

@@azra_70s we arent experts we're fans who dont know these kind of things so it mist be kept simple for the audience

[@azra_70s]

STAN ATEEZ STAN TALENT it clearly explained in the video that this is for the non-professional dancers to understand the depth meaning of the dance.. I just shared my technique in comprehending so that others that had a hard time understanding may adapt..

[@serendipity9627]

Yves in A Tier...I'm not surprised, this girl is the epitome of powerful, her movements have this fierce vibe but also very elegant....she deserves to be there, thank you so much for this analysis!!

[@valentina99962]

I don't see many people mentioning that this is one of the few channels that really express their opinions with valid and professional arguments, I love your videos too

[@estherbunny]

this, shaky raindrop and reacttothek are really the pillars of kpop analysis

[@kivikivi1882]

Esther E. E. Oooo i love reacttothek!

[@estherbunny]

@@kivikivi1882 good stuff

[@sasukeuchiha-mq4ou]

Yeah you're right. For kpop analysis, I watched these channels ON THE SCENE and Fresh tofu for Dance Analysis ReacttotheK for Music Analysis Form of Theraphy for Video Analysis

[@jeeewhyyypheee]

@@estherbunny Forgot FormOfTheraphy

[@aracamgarciamontufar6868]

Yves is such an incredible and amaizing underrated Main dancer... She deserves more fame Edit: Thank you all for the likes, i'm in shock... I'm happy more people share my opinión

[@killbethy]

Not to mention that New is still one of the greatest K-Pop songs I’ve ever heard.

[@NatWarrior1]

Rin And one of if not the only Kpop song with the soultronica genre

[@aracamgarciamontufar6868]

Rin OMG... I love that song, is one of my favourites

[@jeroyah8537]

Bonjour. there are no official positions but if there were, yves would SURELY be the/a main dancer. i feel like part of the reason why yves dance skills arent so known is orbits always reiterate how loona doesnt have official positions

[@ch_rlotte]

jeroyah why are there no positions?

[@istan8159]

yves being second to only chaeyeon wow,,, i hope more ppl start realizing her talents soon!

[@only0221]

there are two of them tho

[@syalalala1172]

@@only0221 who

[@only0221]

@@syalalala1172 the other one is mia from everglow

[@syalalala1172]

@@only0221 yves is still second tho mia is third 😅

[@zmz7795]

d a n y Mia is ranked in low A tier while yves is in mid A so technically she’s second only to chaeyeon.

[@strawberry3150]

Loona is such a well-rounded group, especially with dancing

[@kyooongie]

so is IZ*ONE. hitomi aka the weakest dancer out of the dance line is just as good as hyunjin, but then you also have chaeyeon who is better than yves by a whole tier. even the non dance line members (minus sakura and hyewon) are low C tiers, which goes to show how stacked their dance line is really. what I’m trying to say is Loona isn’t the only group.

[@strawberry3150]

bbh's puta what... i never said that loona is the only well-rounded group dance wise

[@Homeschooledjunglefreak]

@@kyooongie Why are you so pressed about people praising Loona ? The comment didn't even mentioned Izone so what's the point of bringing them in the conversation?

[@chaeyoungslovie]

@@kyooongie IZONE have 4/12 amazing dancers and that is Chaeyeon, Chaewon, Yena, and Yujin. Then we have Eunbi who is decent. But the rest of the girls are not decent dancers. They either have bad technique or under dance too much. Some members have no idea of how to dance with energy. Even if your a weak dancer you can still give your best and find a way to catch attention. In LOONA, we have 6/12 amazing dancers. Heejin, Yves, Hyeju, Lip, Choerry, Gowon. The top 3 are main dancers material. Heejin has surpassed dancers like Lisa, Seulgi, and Chaeyeon. Yves with her clean moves and Hyeju is just so powerful. Lip, Choerry, and Gowon are lead dancers worthy. Loona’s non dance line members are better than Izone’s. Chuu and Hyunjin are good. Jinsoul, Vivi, and Hasuel may be weak, but Jinsoul makes up for it with her stage presence and Vivi, Hasuel can stay in sync with the choreo. Loona are just better than Izone in every way. If you want some other well-rounded dancing groups, there’s TWICE, ITZY, Stray Kids, Gfriend, or Dreamcatcher. But I will pick Twice, Itzy, Loona, and Gfriend as the best.

[@xloveshelly]

I got excited for this, I had a feeling Yves, Heejin, Olivia Hye would be top in that order. I feel like Gowon and Choerry is underrated in dance line, I just like how clean and consistent Gowon is. I would consider Yeojin dance line, but I don't know if that's just me?

[@shravberri]

Yes!! Yeojin also has potential for being in the dance line. Also GoWon and Choerry are really underrated dancers, especially Yerim who is a choreographer too

[@valenyosas]

If I had to pick only 7, I'd pick Hyunjin instead of Yeojin like what the creator does. In my opinion, Yeojin is a good dancer, but when I see Yeojin and Hyunjin dance together (was it on Idol Radio?) Hyunjin is much more precise (dance angles?) and much cleaner. I think that's because Yeojin is short lol, so naturally she tends to underdance.

[@thathumanbeingnobody3468]

@@valenyosas if anything yeojin overdance, she a lot like wendy, full of energy but really bad placing making their angles and placement quite bad, but wendy improved a lot and like the third best in groups so maybe the same thing will happen to yeojin but for now hyunjin is still a better dancer cause of sharpness and better control

[@janverelonon206]

i consider yeojin but she is too small (cute) his arm execution is not like the others because she is too short

[@sooyoungfanclub]

Yeojin is such a good dancer and truly shines when dancing to girl groups, I hope she gets more recognized as a great dancer in the future

[@alfred-dx4dh]

we just can't deny the fact that loona's dance line is one of the strongest in the 4th generation groups

[@hjnhynjnhslyjnkhjngnjnslyr7330]

@@bread3987 yeah till they disband but loona doesnt have dance position tho.

[@bluesoul06137]

@@bread3987 and they will disband and loona will continue so 🤷🏻‍♀️

[@Homeschooledjunglefreak]

@@bread3987 No hate to Izone but Loona definitely have a better dance line. In izone only Eunbi and Chaeyeon truly stands out but in Loona everyone can at least be a lead dancer while I can't say the same about Izone. Loona also have better dances and have shown more consistency in their performances.

[@MBAbhay]

@@Homeschooledjunglefreak Loona as a whole is stronger but yikes you cannot say Yena, Chaewon, and Yujin do not stand out (Particularly Yena)

[@wendywilliamscrustyq-tip3735]

@@MBAbhay so true

[@hyunjinssoul2354]

To see Gowon 5th is honestly amazing! Gowon should be recognized as part of the dance-line more.

[@larkspuralforque4051]

@OrbiTzen LOONA’s gay cupcake Godmother Park Chaewon forgives you. Now stream One&Only.

[@l.o.c.1719]

period. ppl see over dancing as better but fail to realize technique is what counts. and gowon is a trained dancer. yes there are areas in which she can continue to improve upon like any idol. but she is very much overlooked. i personally would've ranked all the girls who were in C to B.

[@oliviacolombiadontraiseupndown]

as expected from X AE A-Xii's godmother 😌

[@emmaontoast]

i feel like gowon gets overlooked for her dancing abilities because she’s in yyxy which is really sad

[@misomoon]

@OrbiTzen LOONA’s gay cupcake SAME, when i saw her fancam I was like "holy sh- Go Won stans forgive me!"

[@darrrinwarrior]

_Lia don't worry I'll join you there_

[@helmy2815]

Don't forget about me ;)

[@liz2668]

Me too

[@dimples.2776]

same

[@ahmedbarakat2809]

If he did all of loona and iz*one a lot will be with her or lower it is so unfair for lia to be compared to a lot of dancers

[@chickennoodlesoop0320]

i'll be at F 😂

[@ralala657]

Can we talk about Kim Lip, I’ve seen some people not acknowledging her dancing skills. But here she is 4th and slaying the choreo. 🤩

[@noahahaha6432]

wait for real? tbh I always thought she was the main dancer of the group

[@larkspuralforque4051]

@@noahahaha6432 They don't have official positions.

[@jdizelle28]

Tbh, she’s being acknowledged when OEC era but due to ot12, she was overshadow by others.

[@ralala657]

@@jdizelle28 I also think she stands out more in choreos like the Butterfly choreo but in choreos like So What the other members shine more.

[@notpongi]

it just “who dances so what best” not “whos the best dancer in loona”, i think kim lip has better chance in songs like eclipse or butterfly bc that might suit her more ig

[@kiwioberry]

they’re all such good dancers!! was not surprised to see yves up there with mia

[@pabbie7467]

Have you seen Yves' dancing to Taemin's 'Drip Drop'? What's your thoughts on that. I think her footwork is super clean and her movements is fluid.

[@pabbie7467]

I'm not a dancer but this is just my thoughts...

[@chelhana1951]

i don’t see a lot of comments about heejin but she’s really great! i feel like people always expect heejin to do well, so whenever heejin actually does well, she doesn’t get as many appreciation as the other members who make people go "wow surprisingly (members) can do so well!" :( that aside, i’ve been noticing that she is indeed a great dancer, back in mixnine she was admitted as one of the top dancers next to itzy’s ryujin. she’s also a pro performer, she can do any concept just fine!

[@dindaodeliakirana5626]

yesssss, heejin deserve appreciation😭

[@johaseul4538]

yes!! she's one of the best idol-dancers in my opinion. she has the best facial expressions compared to other kpop girls, she slays every kind of concept and has great technique.

[@theabrasileno1921]

I feel same. The expectations are so high with this girl. That when she gets it people tend to shrug on her because that’s already expected. I wish fans would also commend her for achieving such expectations.

[@nela_]

@@theabrasileno1921 True, as a big Heejin fan, I noticed that so many times. People often forget about her and praise other members. I feel like Heejin is underappreciated most of the times.

[@biazacha]

@@nela_ I feel like people overcompensate - Heejin is the Face, but she also gets lines and key dance parts. But the thing is, this isn't HER choice so may not be by malice but hyping other members because they aren't showcase that much is a bit of unfair to Heejin. I noticed that now Chuu is receiving the same treatment, when back in the debut days where Jinsoul and Kim Lip.

[@lillycamp8892]

This was so interesting! Also yes Gowon!! Underrated dancer!! I’ve been saying it! Also I understand that the ranking comes from this video strictly, but I’d love to see you (down the road obviously) do some analyzing of the boy group dances Loona has done (especially cherry bomb, that would honestly be a lot of work though) Just from what I’ve observed on my own in their boygroup, Choerry seems to have a TON of precision when dancing, also seems like she could have some potential with popping/locking the way she can cleanly put powerfully hit certain moves. I watched a fancam of her doing love cherry motion live once (the second dance break) and was absolutely blown away because until then u hadn’t realized how good of a dancer she was.

[@milkflavored]

Lilly Camp seconding all of this. i remember watching this episode and being a bit disappointed bc Choerry is my bias and i know she’s better than this particular execution of “so what.” I won’t make excuses since as an idol im sure she’s aware every performance counts, but she’s definitely one of the most underrated dancers/members of the group. *insert LCM duality meme here*

[@valenyosas]

The ranking doesn't come from this video strictly, but more like from the whole 'So What' choreography execution. OTS analyzed the dance practice(s) before describing each member's 'technique' of execution. I agree that Choerry is a power-centered dancer, but it's true that she doesn't 'shine' as much in this particular choreography/style. I also agree that she totally shone in boy group dances though, along with Olivia Hye. I think their ranking will be (much) higher if OTS ever analyzes their boy group dance covers.

[@thathumanbeingnobody3468]

@@valenyosas or analyzed them overall, i feel like choerry and go won would be a b while hyunjin would be a c+ while yeojin following behind her and the rest being a c or c-

[@ralala657]

Yves is in A tier 🤩 and wow Heejin, Olivia Hye and Kim Lip were so close in the tier it must have been hard ranking them. Let’s also appreciate Hyunjin, Gowon and Choerry’s dancing skills all of them are so great! Thank you for this great analysis!

[@anh4465]

1:24 X Æ A-Xii's godmother ya’ll

[@blinkonce3934]

anh You just didn’t...😂😭

[@rarIRL]

PERIAT

[@russelljuderodriguez3086]

THIS MADE ME SPIT OUT MY DRINK

[@supportloonaonqueendom9755]

OMG HAHAHAHA

[@wendywilliamscrustyq-tip3735]

THE WAY I FUCKING SNORTED 💀

[@floatyredballoon]

Yves will definitely get more of a spotlight as time goes on. Sooner or later people will notice her prowess. Loona’s dance line is pretty underrated, especially Gowon.

[@hyunjinssoul2354]

Honestly, Gowon, Choerry and Hyunjin are overlooked in the dance-line. Probably because they have one of the strongest dancers.

[@dreamsomnia9813]

I'm not trying to be rude here, but gowon choerry and hyunjin are pretty average when it comes to dancing. Just an opinion btw.

[@hyunjinssoul2354]

@@dreamsomnia9813 average or not, they still are great dancers. LOONA might not be the strongest dancers individually, but as a group, they're outstanding!

[@dreamsomnia9813]

@@hyunjinssoul2354 personally I don't really view their group performances as outstanding. I think anyone can say that about any group. It's just up to professionals to prove whether the groups actually are outstanding, amazing or not.

[@adel.mtl31]

@@dreamsomnia9813 well Lee Sooman the CEO of SM entertainment found their cover of Cherry Bomb outstanding and that they have a lot of potential, that's why he participated in the production of So What and the whole album

[@thathumanbeingnobody3468]

Rebecca KPOPsvt the all above average but so what doesn’t highlight their strength as an dancer so I recommend watching their cherry bomb cover

[@briannap2426]

You have no idea how much I love this channel because it points out the positive from the groups in a very specific explanation. Amazing.

[@izzydog158]

loona’s improvement as they go on will be so scary.... the power and potential they hold.....

[@wendywilliamscrustyq-tip3735]

Imagine choerry, heejin, olivia, yeojin and gowon being the best all-rounders in kpop, knocking everyone out of the water with their all-roundedness

[@hwangy3ji258]

izzydog158 there song sucka though

[@단하나의오빛]

Ongxie Ong Have you listened to their othet songs? I mean, they got idk, 60+songs :)

[@mostlybeloved4663]

@@hwangy3ji258 Just because you don't like their songs. Doesn't mean it's also sucks for everyone🤷🏻‍♀️

[@staith]

@@hwangy3ji258 ok. but that's just like... ur opinion, man.

[@yachishairclips2250]

Me: I just Love how you emphasize on "LET'S RESPECT EACH OTHER'S OPINION"... this is what the community really needs... HUGE RESPECT!!

[@starm4225]

The way I couldn’t tell who was the main dancer when they were dancing lmao

[@user-qm8gt8lf7l]

the fact that u put yves in tier A got me rly excited omg it's what she deserves!!!

[@randomperson-vm4yc]

yay thank you for doing this!! i'm sad yeojin isn't on the dance line so she wasn't analyzed though, i think her dancing is good enough that she should be and her facials are always great as well! this was really interesting to watch though i was so excited when i got this notification

[@fangirlmode8705]

True

[@papagowon386]

no one: not even a single person: on the scene: 2:31 same as earlier, same as earlier, same as earlier, same as earlier~

[@camilapaz3007]

Choerry is so underrated, my baby deserve more love

[@BadAss2895]

I have noticed that Go Won has gotten a lot lot better since Butterfly era, all those dance covers gave her some practice.

[@arcaivz]

YESSS, i've been waiting for this! as always, great analysis - so many details about the choreo i never noticed even when i tried learning it. o: loona's choreos, dance line and literally all the members never disappoint. hehe, thank you so much!

[@218is]

LOONA is so well rounded! I just wish more people could recognize that

[@kattostakku186]

And Hyunjin has the best vocals while performing live, I'd say she was the most stable during the So What era. Her training is no joke!

[@Purplesims55555]

We love a perfectionist queen!

[@end3rl0tl54]

im highkey curious on if any idol would be at an F tier since all idols seem to be at least semi-good dancers

[@therasilvi]

That one IOI member? But even she worked hard to keep up.

[@adyasamund7736]

She has been doing only the dance line for bigger groups . So I am pretty sure Hyewon and Sakura might be there. No hate to them, they are amazing and improving really fast but just not good dancers in my opinion

[@ice_bear_oaia3743]

@@adyasamund7736 as a wizone I have to agree that they aren't good dancers but I think they are around the same level as Lia

[@adyasamund7736]

@@ice_bear_oaia3743 I love both Izone and Itzy but my thoughts as a trained dancer are- D tier 1. Lia (Lia actually has above average upper body control and good arm movement.She also is able to perfect the angles required for arm movements. Her biggest weakness lies in leg movements. She tends to be very stiff which results in either missing the beat or underdancing. She also lacks an eye for details(however that tends to come with experience so it's okay) She also has good facials however ) F tier (just belowd D though) 2. Sakura - (That girl has amazing facials. That's her biggest strength. Unfortunately she lacks flexibility. This leads to very stiff movements,underdancing, poor angles. Her control over release of energy is very weak too.However she actually tends to catch quite a few details of the choreography and manages to complete the movements) 3. Hyewon - (Hyewon is still very stiff though she has improved loads since pd48 and I am proud of that. Her biggest weakness is that she undercuts her movements a lot and doesn't get proper angles. It tends to seem as if she rushing through the choreography or being extremely slow as it results in fractional changes in timing. Her facials have actually also improved a lot)

[@ricecakesforlife]

Adyasa Mund this is cool! What do you mean by angles? Are there any examples you can give about poor angles versus good ones? If someone isn’t flexible does that mean they’re screwed at dancing haha

[@starkcompanyteam5638]

Finally, ive been waiting for our favorite ANYLAZER!

[@syalalala1172]

we really need to include yves in 4th gen best main dancers

[@MC-rj4ex]

Is she not included in that debate?? Because it's absurdity if not

[@syalalala1172]

@@MC-rj4ex rarely. and if she was included, often times she was ranked low :( i think it's because she was not able to show her full potential yet, and we all hate bbc for this cause

[@jennie-pm1xy]

yves is ranked so high 😭 QUEEN

[@chaerily1187]

I never looked into Loona’s dance line but these were the same members who I thought were the best dancers especially yves I also like heejin and Kim lip dance alot

[@oohmyjooy]

I'm so happy Yves is in A, people often disregard her dance talent.

[@eady4836]

*olivia again proving why she's only a one day trainee*

[@johaseul4538]

yves too

[@wendywilliamscrustyq-tip3735]

and gowon, a trainee for only a few weeks

[@margot356]

olivia trained for about a year at another company tho

[@ABCslurpthatD]

Lol it's 2020 and her fans are still spreading fake news. Olivia used to train at FNC Academy. Then she moved to BBC and trained for a day there lmao

[@eady4836]

@@ABCslurpthatD well she trained in bbc for one day then debuted the next day that speaks volume????????

[@depaaade]

I just saw your community post and minutes later this pops out haha

[@killuazoldyckhunter]

Honestly never thought Loona had a dance line as I was convinced every member is a dancer.

[@babyapple_]

they are 😌

[@darkhearttantibus2766]

Honestly same

[@zeytipi8945]

killua tf what are you doing here go protect gon from hisoka or smth

[@-m-cv2iv]

I feel like people dont pay attention to olivia hye's dancing as much as she deserves, that leg execution was so clean as satisfactory, her dancing is the most pleasing to my eyes, she is not my bias but she is always the one I am looking to... Also I am curious of why you didn't had yeojin (a great dancer) chuu, jinsoul and vivi ?

[@go3un]

i’m too early to say much but thank you for providing these🥺🥺 it really helps give a interesting insight on individual styles and how to improve!!

[@CraftFoxy]

Yves is an INCREDIBLE dancer, just watch her drip drop cover 💅

[@ABCslurpthatD]

I know Yves is a top-tier dancer but I never thought she's even better than Yeji/Chaeryeong. LOONA never fails to surprise me.

[@IgoIgoIgo]

Ikr

[@zmz7795]

Really? I’ve always thought she’s one of the best of 4th gen

[@IgoIgoIgo]

@@zmz7795 she's one of the best

[@cassie8844]

Ofc

[@silverdiangelo8117]

I think one of the most obvious reasons is that Yves is a more versatile dancer than Chaeryeong and Yeji.

[@ska8ey576]

ITS SO GOOD TO SEE YVES IN THE A TIER 🤩🤩🤩🤩🤩

[@eris9349]

Yves deserves the spot period! She's a great dancer, powerful and elegant. For me, Heejin is top performer material. Facial expressions and dancing on point and can pull off any concept. Literallt an ace of an idol if you ask me

[@tontzy7106]

Wow, I'm totally inlove with Heejin, she's not just a pretty face.

[@loonaorbit4037]

😭 Heejin is multi talented! She can sing too.

[@supportloonaonqueendom9755]

@@loonaorbit4037 and rap! Versatile queen! plus great facial expressions

[@mikoylerio9934]

❣️

[@BooksSongsStuff10]

"This choreography is currently the best out of all girl group releases this year" 💗💗💗

[@yvessmissingswan2512]

Yves is such an amazing dancer 💗 All dance line are amazing too! Thank you for this content, ohh can we have OH MY GIRL - Nonstop next please 🙏

[@isidorapino8895]

how many dance details we are missing thou and yves such an underrated main dancer love your videos btw

[@amaliap]

hello, could you do analysis of oh my girl's - nonstop? there's individual dances too on weekly idol, you also can check it. thank you very much! ps: sorry for my bad english.

[@wannaboe5687]

a m e l she/he will, just wait

[@cantputashrugasausernameso5105]

@@wannaboe5687 But we'll have to wait a while. They're doing 4th gen groups, and OMG is 3rd gen (very close to 2nd gen too).

[@rmj9693]

Yes please do Oh My Girl!

[@phag4eva]

@@cantputashrugasausernameso5105 not really close to 2nd gen? 3rd gen started when exo debuted

[@cantputashrugasausernameso5105]

@@phag4eva I'm pretty sure 3rd gen started in 2013/14

[@usernotfound7155]

aw as a Heejin's bias I never thought that Heejin will be second omg I thought Olivia would make it to second Heejin is such an all-rounder

[@haruza5239]

Right? I was surprised! I've always felt like Heejin is in the top 3 in Loona but since it seemed like Oli and Lip were getting highlighted more during the video, I thought it probably wouldn't match up with my personal ranking. That said, it's not that surprising... she's so freaking talented!!

[@usernotfound7155]

@@haruza5239 yea, I really like her dance but I thought I was biased.

[@nattanicha3591]

Heejin my bias

[@euphoriacover2653]

I'm a dancer too and i can say that all your analysis are very clear 🔥 Great work !!!

[@adel.mtl31]

I think Gowon, Choerry and Hyunjin coulf be placed a little higher on the C tier because i don't think they're lower than Wonyoung in dancing

[@chelhana1951]

thats what i was thinking, at least choerry shouldve been higher than or equal to wonyoung 🤔

[@wendywilliamscrustyq-tip3735]

they are defo better than wony lol im saying this as a wizone and orbit

[@tsunami3963]

It's probably because Wongyoung did better in Violeta than how they did in So What. This analysis ranks them based on how well they do in one choreo, and based on what I've seen here, So What may not fit them as well as other choreos, but I don't know since I'm not a dancer or anything, that's the conclusion I've got from this video

[@adel.mtl31]

@@tsunami3963 ah okay, that makes sense

[@Homeschooledjunglefreak]

Where do you see the tiers please ?

[@slaven8914]

heejin has such great stage presence, i love it. all of them are great dancers

[@wxy7119]

Thank you so much for doing this analysis! As a part of the orbit fandom, I really appreciate your opinions and comments. I'll look forward to more dance analysis videos from now on.

[@valssoul]

im glad you did this loona's so what analysis mostly because you didn't point out roles like main dancer for example, because loona don't really have roles apart leader and maknae. Love your videos! take care

[@hannahdumlao8180]

my sister's smiling really wide again because it's her og group being analyzed 🤣💗 Thank you for this analysis, it was my first time watching these girls because of this channel and woooow, i'm impressed! 😳 This channel makes me appreciate a lot of group's talents and efforts 💗

[@multi_sungie]

YASSS LOONA ❤️ Heejin and Yves' mistake though. Cute 😂.

[@ughgowonsscalpandcrunchyvo4926]

multifandom_in_kpop kim lip too at the end

[@multi_sungie]

@@ughgowonsscalpandcrunchyvo4926 I was just watching your how would video-

[@ughgowonsscalpandcrunchyvo4926]

multifandom_in_kpop girl it better not be my video on the shower singing eye-

[@supportloonaonqueendom9755]

Thank you for doing the analysis! LOONA is truly a group with best dancers! Im happy everyone's complimenting Go Won on the comments, she's really a good dancer but sometimes was outlook for her dancing skills. Stan LOONA, Stan godmother go won!

[@SCCKeyboardist]

I 100% agree with kimlip being a good potential popper. Even on the bridge part after the slower half (2:56 where you commended olivia hye on that additional leg movement), you can notice kimlip's version being more "poppy or popping-like" and it looks unique on her.

[@lilz9603]

Dude I just want to say THANK YOU for all your effort, and that this is quickly becoming one of my favorite kpop channels

[@WiCkEdPLANET1]

I’ve been waiting a month for this video ever since you announced your posting schedule 😭 I’m so happy someone is technically analysing the loona members abilities I’ve been so curious to hear about this!! also I’m really glad you included gowon in the dance line since I don’t see ppl talk about her dancing often enough

[@mariajohn2722]

Yess!! I really wanted loona - love your videos. Thank you!

[@megsalina3486]

One thing I've noticed in So what's stages etc is that, Choerry always seems to walk a far distance to a particular area for the 'SO WHAT?' part in the chorus. By that I mean that whilst everyone else in Loona is doing the foot choreo in one place, Choerry walks to another place and she seems to walk a good few footsteps too, to get to her location. I thought that , that's where she lacked the footwork for that certain part in other words display 'weak footwork". She probably wasn't accustom and learned the choreo that way. I'm not a professional dancer or anything it's just something Ive noticed. She probably lacked in other footwork movements in the dance too, but to me that stood out the most cause it's one of the most obvious. In Butterfly she displayed alot of good footwork and control. Thank you for doing this, you have a very good way of explaining and expressing.

[@syalalala1172]

ohhh that makes sense since choerry's part is in the chorus and need to switch places several times. thank you for pointing that out since i was a little surprised to see OTS said that she lacked in footwork especially since she's the center for fire cover dance break which required fast footwork, now this explains a lot 😊

[@hanguyenhoang902]

Thank for making this video

We need any oh my girl's análisis please ❤️❤️❤️

[@Idekmane]

Thank you for doing a video on LOONA. I hope yves gets more recognition soon.

[@soo6992]

Yves is an amazing dancer, she deserves more recognition :/

[@Lanzeon]

i love how positive, fair, and insightful this video is in its critique, it doesn't come off as you putting the girls down even when you point out their weakness!! ❤️

[@andre_3578]

Thank you for doing this. Ive been waiting for loona for such a long time but im thankfull you did it. I know that there are a lot of members to analyse and i respect your hard work. Thank you again. ❤️💜

[@polinabessoltseva8051]

Choerry is sooo underrated and at the same time she is the most improved member since "Hi high".Just look at her in Loona's covers, especially Cherry bomb Fire and Eclipse.Her facial expression are really unique,she can change it from happy to serious (in Love Cherry motion)in 1 second.She is one of the most charismatical members.Of course,Gowon and Hyunjin are very powerful and great dancer but for me Choerry isn't just lead dancer she is like average main dancer together with Kim Lip and Olivia

[@dindaodeliakirana5626]

choerry has great stage presence and this video just include about dance technique

[@wendywilliamscrustyq-tip3735]

honestly it hurts to be gowon, choerry and hyunjin biased due to how underrated the are

[@sam6719]

i think vivi and yeojin both improved a lot since hi high too

[@polinabessoltseva8051]

@@sam6719 yes,Yeojin is now like great lead dancer,if we look at her fancams,but Vivi also improved her dance but for me her vocal now is amazing,she really can sing very very well and also she finally has a little more lines(especially in "Yes I am) and in their cover Vivi is in the middle of line distribution

[@polinabessoltseva8051]

@@wendywilliamscrustyq-tip3735 it really hurts,they all are lead dancers, rappers,vocalists and beautiful visuals,but now i notice that Bbc really give them more opportunitis:more center,sometimes more lines, Gowon is godmother, Hyunjin, Choerry and Olivia had a photoshoot. But I still hope that people will appreciate them more

[@electrafying]

Yay! Now we can get a better idea of what their positions should be! Thank you Also, this is my first time being first 🤩

[@guineverecasuyon8533]

I'm so proud of my girls, They are all so underrated, I'm glad you analyzed them. I'm waiting for this for so long

[@dreamstarry2579]

YVES IS SO UNDERRATED MAIN DANCER!

[@notachannel1846]

Thank you so much for this, I was really waiting for you to know your analysis on Loona! Your insight on this was very informative and it was nice to get to know more about how each member did here :)

[@_Moonlit_]

6:04 Wow Yves stamp went perfectly with the music!

[@mrknt2929]

I really love this series! It gives us non-dancers a glimpse of how dancers see other dancers, or what their perspectives are. Its really educative for me too (coz I have a lot of dancer friends)! Please keep doing this series~~~

[@calling.moon.twelve]

2:57 I'd never noticed that Olivia is the only one who adds that leg movement. I watched a different dance channel video which pointed out that she also added neck isolations in a move in Why Not. I get that when you dance in a group you need to blend and match well with the other members but I personally like how she adds her own little flair to moves. I think it often makes the moves more interesting.

[@jihantag3979]

ahh me too

[@hyunjinssoul2354]

the only difference is that on the scene pointed it out as a strength, while whiteravenkpopfan pointed it as a weakness. I personally agree with ots more, but with loona's choreography where synchronization is needed to show it's true beauty, i see whiteravenkpopfan's point

[@chilliyimani]

Whew! Thanks for doing an analysis of the girls choreography. Just wanna say I love your videos and appreciate your opinion, looking forward to the next one!

[@PauloLima-gk2uh]

OMG I’M SO PROUD OF OLIVIA, love u girl

[@greencap1606]

Thank you for this video, I liked how honest and also positive your review was. Keep up the good work

[@kyulkyung6924]

When all of my biases are on top S, A and B😌 chaeyeon, yves, mia, chaeryeong and soojin i just keep on winning

[@hazingdawn]

your analysis have been incredibly helpful and entertaining to watch thank you for making such great and thank you for doing an analysis for loona

[@PunktStrichPunkt]

Yves, it’s what she deserves still think yeji and chaeryeong deserved A tier tho 💕

[@Blazikev]

i've been waiting for a so what analysis from this channel and it finally came!!! wow the end ranking is crazy; to see yves right below CHAEYEON is such an honor honestly.. I can't wait to see where other ggs would rank here, definitely excited to see where sinb / lisa / momo / seungyeon / seulgi / rosé / mimi / yooa etc would all rank!!!

[@queenanna_edits]

I've been waiting for this and I'm so excited to watch it!!! Now that we have seen so what, maybe butterfly is next???

[@sircabooci4506]

They´re a really good dance focused group. Thanks for analyzing them!

[@lstars1329]

Not gonna lie I’m really learning new things with this channel

[@oliviahyejoo12]

Thank you so much for making this analysis. I really appreciate it. I've been waiting for this. Thank you.

[@Legendaric]

"Yves: Powerful" It feels correct.

[@andallthatjazz5796]

Great video! You're one of me favourite dance-focused channel! I would love to see Gfriend or Red Velvet (I'm very curious about Irene and Wendy abilities) in another video . Thank you for your work and insight, it's very refreshing!

[@jaden183]

Hi I'm hoping you'll do a dance analysis for why not~

[@BeyondTheBoundaryEp620mins]

💛 thank you for putting in hard work for these videos whenever I watch I can only think of have difficult it must have been to watch each video and then compare them. So thank you especially as a self taught dancer reading what you put in these videos really helps me improve

[@chanukidahamsa3140]

On the scene, can u do NCT Dream - Rindin? Pleaseeeeeee🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@vessg221]

I got so excited and tried to guess who it could’ve been and *YES SOMEONE FINALLY DID AB ANALYSIS ON LOONA!!!! THANK YOU!!!* 😍❤️

[@sweetdaemon]

I was always shook when people didn’t give Yves any spots in top 10 dancers.

[@sarahodiorne6119]

Yves's dances moves in 6:03-6:08 hit right on beat with the song