Who is Lyra Heartstrings? | MLP History

Let’s take a trip down memory lane and look through the My Little Pony fandom's golden age. Starting off with none other than Lyra Heartstrings!
Feel free to join: / discord

[@tmfz6]

I love the fact that we don't know much about bonbon since she IS a secret agent

[@lunakingsley.7247]

According to the fans she can make candy and sells candy.

[@vocalist92]

I remember reading a fan fiction that revealed Bonbon was a Changeling hiding among ponies hence how she was able to change her voice in early episodes. That fic from what I recall was about Changelings living in hiding among ponykind until their existence was revealed during Canterlot Wedding. Brony peak days were wild and I miss them very much

[@aliciascott7]

​@@vocalist92 u a dumbass

[@renamon5658]

There was a book called the agents of s.m.i.l.e where it said that that flim and flam use to be agents and the agency is under a pizzeria in ponyville

[@kowhaifan1249]

chocolatier im pretty sure.

[@pinknblueheartz]

something interesting about lyra is that even though her fascination with humans was never acknowledged in the actual show, there was a card that said something like "of all the ponies twilight told her story of the mirror portal to, lyra was the most interested"

[@EffMinus]

interesting!

[@Top10Dylan]

I'm glad they did it like that and never mentioned humans in the show, humans have no business being in Equestria.

[@lunakingsley.7247]

@@Top10Dylan they have business being in ponyland though. (Also I think it would be fair to let the original Williams siblings visit Equestria. Especially considering Megan's bond with the rainbow of light.).

[@Top10Dylan]

@@lunakingsley.7247 Yaks, griffins, hippogriffs, and changelings should get lost too.

[@crystalmuffyn]

Canon Sunset might have been like Fanon Lyra, since Sunset was curious about the portal and the creatures in it.

[@theratedrshimmer]

One thing I love about Lyra is, she used to be a blank canvas, and Hasbro initially never saw her as another thing more than just a background pony. People noticed her. Hasbro gave her a name, then the fandom gave her a Surrname. People saw her sitting oddly, so they gave her personality. Then a Relationship, took some time but Hasbro accepted. With that, also Bon Bon/Sweetie Drops received her own personality... Thanks to Lyra. The Background Six are the ultimate proof of how much Power the fandom had during G4

[@TheDanteEX]

I think the whole "push and pull" between Hasbro's merchandise names and fanon names is really interesting. Like, most of the early toys were clearly inspired by some of the background designs, but the names never matched what fans would call them. Some things Hasbro accepted and changed the names on the merchandise, which is a pretty big nod since those new names would likely need trademarking. And the fandom eventually adapted to the names Hasbro never budged on, like Minuette. And of course Lyra Heartstrings is when there's basically an undiscussed compromise. It might be a hard topic to cover, but I would love someone to chronical a lot of these character names and how they evolved and such. I imagine a lot of information is lost to time. It was funny to me when Hasbro finally accepted the name DJ PON3, just for the fandom to have already given her another name: Vinyl Scratch. Then a few months later I saw comments from young fans saying "her name isn't DJ PON3, it's Vinyl Scratch" on Hasbro social media as if they didn't just try throwing the fans a bone already. Which brings me to another topic that can be covered: fans that were into the fandom before/without watching the source material. It happened with a lot of characters and ideas, but Button Mash was probably the biggest one. Some fans were shocked when they discovered Button Mash was actually a character design that existed in the show first. When the Christmas album came out and there was a song sung by a unknown character called Pop Fly, a lot of fans speculated it to be Button Mash because it "sounds like him". Which is hilarious since Button Mash not only doesn't have a canon voice, but also doesn't even have a canon name.

[@georgiagalaxy]

Yeah I’m glad I listened to that Christmas album, Pop Fly is interesting 😊 it’s funny how many ambiguous things are in the Pony-Verse

[@somethingwithbungalows]

@@TheDanteEX interesting read. Thank you!!

[@patatoquack1684]

Srs I love how fandom affected mlp fim so much at a point where they dedicated a whole episode to background ponies that were fan favorite

[@DavidMuri-rm4ym]

I love your profile picture! It's just so cute! 💕💖💗❤️♥️❤️

[@CookieIsMyCat09]

Literally just realized that maybe the whole anthropology obsessed lyra joke could be a play on humans believing Unicorns (like Lyra) exist or have existed, and it makes a lot more sense to me now lol, and the idea of humans being a unicorn myth equivalent is lowkey funny to me

[@georgiagalaxy]

True!!!! I like how she sits with her legs crossed in Slice of Life lol.

[@CookieIsMyCat09]

@@georgiagalaxy lol same! It was nice to see

[@Rebekalinker]

"🎶everybody tells me that its old and fake mytholigy🎶"

[@glenngriffon8032]

You know how some Christians have paintings of Jesus riding a unicorn? What if Lyra has a painting of Celestia riding a human?

[@CookieIsMyCat09]

@@glenngriffon8032 that is the very funny to picture ob my God

[@camponotusinflatus9920]

You forgot to mention that Lyra was one of Twilight's friends from Canterlot.

[@aliabuhammoud7706]

Along with Moon Dancer, Minuette, Lemon Hearts, and Twinkleshine.

[@camponotusinflatus9920]

@@aliabuhammoud7706 yeah

[@DreamingNightmares]

One thing I wonder is that since many think Lyra is obsessed with humans... Would Equestria Girls Lyra be obsessed with ponies?

[@Edward256]

Cross-obsession fics and arts have been made. ;)

[@DreamingNightmares]

@@Edward256 yeah I've seen some of those before, some are quite funny when human Lyra meets pony Lyra lol

[@danielsurvivor1372]

She was kinda confirmed to be obsessed with ponies in EqG. There's EqG short where Lyra fights BonBon over something (forgoe) and one of the costumes Lyra uses to one up Bon, is basically pony costume of herself(I think it's herself) Ain't that a bad obsessed with her ponysona? 😅

[@Someone_Idk-yx7sn]

It would be more logical if she was obsessed with unicorns lmao

[@memethyst]

i feel like im the only one who likes bonbon more than lyra, i like her design and i think the fact that shes canonically a secret agent is just really funny. its like everything we "know" about lyra was all made up by the fandom where as everything we know about bonbon comes from the actual show.

[@lilsunny7399]

Oh no i like Bon Bon better too, mostly her design and fan personality. Fanfics tend to write her has fun and down to earth while lyra is a little more goofy. And I like that.

[@georgiagalaxy]

That’s kinda true lol ^_^ I like both equally as well 🎀🎼

[@Froggo_e]

I do too :)

[@coalminez]

I personally really like her curly mane and overall character more than lyra's, but I like the both of them together a lot. such a cute canon ship!

[@lilacselkie]

BonBon has always been my favorite background pony even before I knew any of their names

[@Rainbow_Sish_Kabob]

I think the secrete agent thing was done as a joke about how the fans were ignoring her. “Oh, wait, Bonbon had the more interesting backstory? What a twist!”

[@Edward256]

Huh. Thought it was because she had a different voice each time she spoke.

[@jenniferstewarts4851]

Lyra actually has a TON of information about her.. She's seen jumping on a cloud in cloudsdale during the flyer competition. This shows that she knows the cloud walking spell. She's a "gifted unicorn" and part of the unicorn 6. (the mane 6 unicorns that Celestia tried to set up with twilight.. Lemon hearts, moon dancer, Lyra, twinkle shine, minuet, then either sunset or twilight as the leader... sounds like Celestia was planning something there.)

[@trashbasset]

I'm surprised he didn't mentioned that. that is a pretty huge thing for Lyra

[@jenniferstewarts4851]

@@trashbasset Yep, her being "gifted unicorn" means she was in the top percentile of powerhouse unicorns. She likely would have been a candidate for element of harmony likely replacing laughter with musical harmony, citing how songs bind friends.

[@EnriqueLaberintico]

Celestia wasn't expecting the sonic rainboom to set up smth else.

[@organichotchoco]

damn mane six, background 6, unicorn 6, wonderbolts 6 maybe i forgor. are there any OTHER 6 pony groups named after their main trait + 6 i should know about

[@TheDanteEX]

The fact the fandom was so potent in even early 2011 that there was a theory about Sweetie Belle's family during the month-long gap between Call of the Cutie and Stare Master where Sweetie Belle was revealed to be Rarity's sister speaks for itself. Unless the theory started from Sweetie's cameo in the second episode?

[@dsmithrus]

I can accept the theory from 'Anthropology' that Lyra is actually a human fallen to Equestria being a baby and transformed to a pony by Celestia. This is a very catching idea I'd like to use in my own fanfic I'm writing now.

[@foxxyytofficial]

That's interesting Sometime ago i did started a fanfic about an earthling ending up there but more like a Terminator "hear me if you want to live" than "being reborn there"

[@dsmithrus]

@@foxxyytofficial My idea is that in her research on anthropology (under the auspices of the Office of Interministry Affairs), Lyra came to the conclusion that the whole world of ponies is a fiction embodied by Lauren Faust. Then the zebra bombs fell, and later she discovered the existence of the Fallout Equestria fandom, in which she now had to live as a ghoul. Lyra hated the human world for the way they treated her world, and developed a mega-curse to destroy it, as if it did not exist at all. In the fictional universe, time is plastic in relation to the base, so for 200 years of the post-apocalypse for ponies, about 10 years have passed in the human world. Lera found out that her human relatives died during the riots in 2020, and she had no ties to the world of Earth left. And just according to the plot of my fan fiction, she is looking for an energy source, powerful enough to launch the spell. In addition, she wants to cancel the war with zebras thrown into the lore by humans, and for this she has a time travel spell which also requires more energy than the whole Equestria has. And also, actually she is straight, her relationship with Bon Bon is a rumor spread by detractors from the OIA to discredit her research.

[@StrawberryMoo-qc7ci]

@@dsmithrus links?

[@lunakingsley.7247]

According to a lot of fans bonbon knows how to make candy and owns a candy shop. So that's pretty cool (and it makes sense considering the cakes are more focused on cakes and stuff then candy like hard candy or chocolate bars.).

[@kittycheshire5099]

Can't wait to see more of this series. Maybe make one on Button Mash.

[@EffMinus]

great idea!

[@alex_ho]

A shame what happened though, many more chapters could have been told about Button Mash had Hasbro's CnD not strike

[@larsn97]

There is a second fanfiction about Lyra that is nearly as popular as Anthropology. It is called Backgroundpony. In it Lyra is curesed such as everycreatur is constantly forgetting her actions and her existence. I can highly recommend Backgroundpony. It is by far one of the best fanfiction that I have ether read or heard as an audiobook (in my top 5 of over 500 fanfictions know).

[@silvadelshaladin]

Yes, Background Pony is my favorite depiction of Lyra.

[@Ronin20181]

It made me cry, it’s an amazing book

[@silvadelshaladin]

Another thing is Heartstrings -- that is a comic that it would be nice if they made more of.

[@Edward256]

#who #DigTheSwellHoodie #deepdepression

[@BikerDash]

An audiobook? You have my attention!

[@lunakingsley.7247]

I know a way to see if lyra likes humans. Let her go to ponyland from MLP 'n friends universe and let her meet the Williams siblings. Just don't be surprised when she comes back with three human kids and adoption papers.

[@somethingwithbungalows]

This kinda makes me wonder if anyone wrote anything good of a human going to the MLP world who’s from Equestria Girls (they’d lean up against that statue thing and fall in)

[@lunakingsley.7247]

@@somethingwithbungalows heck I would be happy to find a good slice of life story about the G1 Williams siblings being in Equestria (especially if Danny and scoots meet.).

[@OwningGayonelCryonelFraudPessi]

@@lunakingsley.7247 Tf does that make sense when she’s married too BonBon?

[@lunakingsley.7247]

@@OwningGayonelCryonelFraudPessi her being married to bon bon doesn't contradict what I said. Plus bon bon probably wouldn't be against adopting kids (especially when one of them has a very powerful and noticable artifact.).

[@OwningGayonelCryonelFraudPessi]

@@lunakingsley.7247 Oh ok in the fanfiction world i guess but humans are messed up lets not drag the MLP universe into that/our hell hole aswell

[@StargrazerComet]

“She drinks coke” And this is why Lyra is best pony

[@canalso5806]

so the my little pony fandom is obsessed with background characters?

[@EffMinus]

you don't know the half of it

[@kittycheshire5099]

If only it was that simple

[@rieluvs]

every character 😭

[@rieluvs]

every character 😭

[@moonblaze2713]

I just want to say, I lived through what you called the Golden Age and I feel like it was more of a Bronze Age. Important, foundational, but way better times were ahead.

[@shangothunder1055]

Awesome one of my favorite background characters! Can’t wait to see more from the series.😁

[@mao-sama6446]

Lyra was also said to be one of Twilight’s friends before moving to Ponyville and meeting the Mane Six. Though I don’t remember her actually interacting with Twilight and I’m pretty sure there were flashback moments where Lyra was adult and Twilight was a filly.

[@Edward256]

"Moondancer's having a little get-together. Wanna come?" "Sorry girls, I got a lot of studying to catch up on." >runs away from them and right passed Lyra, also holding a gift, and waves at Twi. >Lyra appears in Ponyville by the time Twi lands there. -Lyra also knows duplication spell- xd

[@nameynamd9212]

She was also mentioned twice in "Amending Fences" when Twilight asked for a list of her past friends and when Pinkie first appears in that episode

[@vegetafan9922]

Please do more of these! Maybe one about Vinyl. I'm really interested to find out where the whole "She's a vampire" thing in the fandom came from.

[@DavidMuri-lm5vy]

The whole "vinyl scratch is a vampire" stuff came along because some bronies misinterpreted vinyl scratches maroon eye color for the eye color of red which gave her a very vampire like look, And now you know why this all came to be! 😅😅😅😅😅😅

[@lilsunny7399]

Great vid as always. I also love how there's that one newspaper shot in the very last episode showing Lyra and Bon Bon got married. Show canonically confirming a fan pairing. Pretty much the only one (Well ok there was that one Equestria Girls special with Rarity and Applejack) I'd love a video on Vinyl or/and Octavia I know you did a vid about why Vinyl is mute but like, going over her history, the whole fan theory of the red eyes before it was debunked, her pairing with Octavia. That would be cool.

[@FluoFIM]

2:59 hey! The 16 hour read was worth it

[@robbietheweirdo]

i no longer consider myself part of the community but I love how the fans made her obsessed with humans

[@pencilsanimation]

lyra used to be friends with twilight too😭

[@ME0WMERE]

only for her to basically not appear in 'amending fences'. bit miffed about that :(

[@alex_ho]

In great parts due to the Anthropologist song and Lyra's design, Anthropology was one of the few Brony fics I've actually read especially given how long spanning it was But I really appreciate and enjoyed it, especially since the Author went to great lengths to fit their story with show canon at the time. Though I much prefer the first and second act over the last where the author kind of fumbled the ball trying to conclude it

[@DavidMuri-rm4ym]

I really love that fan created song! ❤❤❤❤🥰😍

[@badoomching]

Ngl I really like this style of video cuz I was never truly in the early fandom, I didn't even have an email account let alone youtube, deviant art, my space, etc account! So hearing about the early fandom talking and theorising about characters in the show, it's just so cool and despite me not being a part of it, it's kinda giving me warm nostalgia! Idk but I'd love to see more vids like this!!

[@WormZzz]

I need a video like this about Berry Punch!

[@fluttershyisnotadoormat4678]

Lyra may have the same model as some ther ponies but she still is one of a kind :3

[@georgiagalaxy]

Agreed, I also like how another Unicorn is based on G3 Minty. If I was in G4 I’d be an Earth pony or an Alicorn :3

[@DavidMuri-rm4ym]

I agree! ❤❤❤🎉🎉😊

[@aguywhodoesstuff1116]

the void stares back

[@nameynamd9212]

Kind of reminds me of DWK's comment on arguments on their favorire character boiling down to most pleasing color scheme and mane style given the body shapes are basically the same

[@BikerDash]

In my fimfictional universe, Lyra studied ancient civilizations, and wrote her master's thesis on how there are subtle bits of evidence that point to an ancient civilization that pre-dates all other known civilizations on Equus, which also has another name... Earth.

[@firekrakenglarbonoker354]

Very nice video. This is good. I would perhaps say that it was enjoyable. In fact, the premise is actually interesting. It even is a fun type of experience. Anyway, it was good.

[@renamon5658]

Lyra is in my top 4 favorite background pony

[@mrtoast244]

I stopped watching this video when the Anthropology song played to go and read it and it's unironically really good... The premise is weird but it delivers on everything it sets out to do. Lyra's friends were pretty likeable characters and their roles in the story as well as their dialog had a nice flow. There was actually some really good tension (and a few logical and cool twists and reveals) at times and there was always plenty of incentive to read the next chapter since the story direction never felt repetitive. The author somehow made me as a reader feel like I was in Lyra's position and it really helps to get immersed and experience things from her perspective. I actually got chills from the ending speech as well, the climax to the main conflict was so well done even though everything happened so quickly. It really does a good job in letting you use your imagination for the visuals of the story. Not just at the end either, the entire story is really fun to read. There were a few things that could have been done better (like, in the epilogue Bon Bon was a bit more dismissive than I would have liked) and it's a little cliche sometimes but all the characters, the pacing and the direction of the story were super tight (not a single chapter felt stale or wasn't memorable) and it was a genuinely enjoyable read (I literally did an accidental all-nighter because I couldn't stop reading it lol). Essentially, there were far more positives than negatives. I unironically think that Anthropology is better written than Equestria Girls. It plays off the original show really well while feeling like it could have easily been canon, had the show committed to a few things differently (no spoilers). edit: removed some spoilers

[@DreamingNightmares]

Since G5 is canon to G4 (as much as many fans including myself hate) maybe that means previous generations are also canon to each other with just many centuries in between... If this is true then it'll explain why humans became a myth in the first place. They used to exist in G1 afterall so maybe they just died out one day and became nothing but a story that was passed down from generation to generation until one day Lyra came across the almost forgotten tale...

[@blakdeth]

I remember 1 bon bon thing that wasn't lyra related and it was her many different voices. Completely different voice every time we saw her.

[@valsfilms9200]

"rolls off the tongue doesnt it?" LOL :)

[@patatoquack1684]

I love the fact that mlp makes a lot of fanon stuff canon and actually finds what the audience thinks important and it’s a nice feeling to know there will always be a place on the internet where we can talk about mlp without being judged and seen as childish

[@nyocaingram9271]

I love how Lyra got a fan song about anthropology it’s like she really wants to know what we do and how we do it she even wants to look like us and be us. It’s like she really wants to know what makes us a human. And that doesn’t even stop there she has tried and tried to know part of a human like eyes toes, and even fingers an anthropology is just like a mystery to her, but she never gives up. She just takes it off the roof that’s what’s making her exciting. #anthropology

[@sommercrisp2234]

I love content like this! Keep up the good work 🎉

[@axolotlfairy2473]

Oh I LOVE this style of video: It feels a lot like therealjims’ simpsons history videos, and that has a LOT of potential. For other ponies I’d suggest: -Dr. Whooves -The Flower Girls (Roseluck, Daisy, and Lily) -Princess Erroria (THATS an obscure one) -DJ PON-3 (I know you made the video on her being mute but) -Octavia Melody -The Wonderbolts -Changelings (The fanon lore around changelings was INSANE around seasons 2-3)

[@EffMinus]

thanks for the suggestions!

[@crystallotus3422]

It's a mystery... ANTHROPOLOGY!

[@crystallotus3422]

P.S I recommend doing Dr. Whooves next

[@supersonic2175]

I like how your character is on the right side of the screen he looks really cool

[@pepperthe2008]

i like how the fandom built up lyra as this person who knows and studys about humans while sitting like one along with a secret agent while bonbon is just her gf and is a secret agent with her

[@thethreekings9120]

Definitely don't forget about Colgate and Dolphin Dream. Lol.

[@femlicious]

love the new format

[@quinnhouk5369]

New editing format?

[@Zerathina]

I love that the creators were so invested in the fandom, and made certain things canon… now, on the subject… Vinyl Scratch has MAGENTA EYES, NOT F*KING RED!!

[@Place-Holder]

I have never heard of the Sweetie Belle is Lyra's daughter theory.

[@fjgaming7666]

me too

[@OwningGayonelCryonelFraudPessi]

@Place Holder Soo Lyra and BonBon are the mothers too Sweetie Belle? Makes sense I guess

[@fjgaming7666]

I really enjoyed your video and as someone who joined the fandom in 2019, the tail end of the show, I have alot to catch up about the lore and ideas, the fans had came up with. Though I do know A good amount of things but I like to learn more, so I have two separate suggestions for future MLP History videos. First being characters both canon and fanon from Vinyl Scratch, Octavia Melody, Dr. Hooves, Carrot Top, Trixie, Spitfire, Soarin, Fancy Pants, Fleur De Lis, Braburn, Flash Sentry, Startswirl the Bearded, Pipsqueak, Dinky Do, Rumble, Tinder Tabs, Babs Seed, First Base, Pound Cake, Carrot Cake, Princess Flurry Heart, Prince Blueblood, Princess Luna, Nightmare Moon, Queen Chrysalis, King Sombra, Discord and Tempest Shadow. To like Fausticorn, Bonniecorn, Nyx, Cream Heart, Princess Skyla, Rainbow Blaze, Sweetie Bot, Screwball, Anon and the many nextgen children of the canon and noncanon characters. Secondly the Fanbase’s Interpretations and worldbuilding of the MLP Universe. Like with the History of Equestria as a nation state, along with the many other countries existing thought up by fans, bringing in characters and concepts from the previous generations of MLP into G4, the countless sentient and nonsentient creatures the fans brought into the Equestria, from creatures with mythological origins to made up creatures like the Spider and Tetzelponies, the many different ideas of who’s related to who, from the concepts of who is the parents of like Applejack, Rainbow Dash and Scootaloo to the fanon families made of many different ponies who, look similar or showed up alot together the most famously being the Hooves family. And that’s everything I’ve got phew, hopefully you find inspiration in my ideas.

[@exodd1]

A bit salty you didn't mention Background Pony and the hoodied Lyra, but good analysis after all!

[@magic_pink_horse]

Finally found your channel, glad to discover more quality pone content as of late!

[@EffMinus]

Welcome aboard!

[@michaelbuehler3897]

I've been reading Anthropology.

[@Jackson_Christ1]

I never pay attention to the background mlp characters except for Lyra and bonbon ❤those to are my favourite background characters ❤

[@Chloe_hi117]

In the last episode when twilight is looking in the news paper we see a picture of liyra and bon bons wedding

[@campbellblahblahsvlog7797]

3:14 Lyre is my instrument, but humans strum their sweet guitar, it’s a mystery, ANTHROPOLOGY

[@Phoenixstorm36]

I got attached to her cause of the fan comic by TriteBristle called Heartstrings.

[@SmokeTheHorsehog]

I miss you being a pony in these videos

[@malachiwonder6800]

I never knew about the Tootsie Flute and Sweetie Belle lore! Thanks!

[@xXSKY64Xx]

Lyra Heartstings is such a perfect name. This is probably one of the few instances where a fan name and official name were combined together to make a better name.

[@ImmaLittlePip]

Love these videos going over memes, fanon and just fandom moments There's a ton of brony history through out the years and its fun to see videos like these that celebrate the more positive parts of the fandom or at least its talents from the past instead of demonizing bronies or mlp fans in general

[@edwinve4112]

I didn't expect to see you here.

[@soundwavethedragon1977]

i refuse to call them a couple since they call each other friends countless times

[@lunakingsley.7247]

They are literally married and a lot of couples call each other friends in real life and especially in cartoons.

[@Top10Dylan]

They got married in the same episode that big mac got married

[@soundwavethedragon1977]

@@lunakingsley.7247 they're cartoon characters though so i can still think of them how i wanna think of them right? gay couples make me uncomfortable when females are involved (cause i am female..)

[@lunakingsley.7247]

@@soundwavethedragon1977 that's worrying. dude lesbians exist suck it up.

[@blitzn00dle50]

Hasbro had the script writers do that so they could cover their rump when homophobic networks took notice edit: take the above with a grain of salt because I wrote this before hearing that dreamworks explicitly told the creators of voltron not to do the problematic gay tropes and since then I've stopped pushing this narrative until I can directly prove it was the executives' decision Well goodness me, darn tootin, lesbians make you "uncomfortable?" Terribly sorry 'bout that sugar cube but that's life so suck it up

[@Zeldas_Stars]

I think its funny bc lyra was just my favorite character because i had a toy of her as a kid and she just happened to be my favorite color at the time

[@HandheldGamer1991]

There is an old fan animation called ponies with hats and they have a line where lyra says she cooked the hand and eat them and in episode 100 we have the same scenario but its oats and not hands coincidence i think not!

[@trexadvent4726]

Are you going to do a video about how and why Spike is part of the MLP FIM show if Twilight Sparkle and her friends can't treat him like an equal since he's struggling with the fact that he's both an orphan and an outcast among ponies? Would it have been better if he stayed back with Princess_Celestia in Canterlot throughout the series which Twilight Sparkle and her friends did whatever they want without him?

[@MILDMONSTER1234]

Spike isn’t an outcast, pretty much everyone in ponyville likes him and the crystal empire worships him.

[@trexadvent4726]

@@MILDMONSTER1234 I'm saying that he feels lonely when everyone around him is completely different from him both physically and mentally

[@MILDMONSTER1234]

@@trexadvent4726 Thats true he did feel that way but mainly in the early seasons, hes long since accepted himself for who and what he is and now has friends and is on good terms with dragons anyway

[@robertomaciel9281]

Elas sao a duplinha mais fofa de toda Equestria.

[@DavidMuri-rm4ym]

I agree! ❤❤❤🎉🎉😊

[@ThatOneTigerdeer]

One of the best and still one of my faves! 💚 Keep ya life silly like Lyra! ^^ And i love the whole "I wanna know and research hoomans"-factor. XD Also the "Background pony"-fanfic book has a preetty good storyline tho~ The "Agents of SMILE" Book was something good with LyraBon again! 💜 But don`t put Bon Bon in a bad space, she`s lovely too!!!💛💛 NEVER ENUFF LYRA!!!!!!!!!!!! #NEVERUFFYRA :`) Also you forget Berry Punch... They always forget about Berry Punch..

[@georgiagalaxy]

Berry Punch is funny. X3 🍇

[@Place-Holder]

Do you think there is a 'resurgence' going on in the brony fandom? I've been seeing a number of new analysis videos and reaction videos that have been getting a lot of traction recently. #AskEffAnything

[@georgiagalaxy]

That’s very true and I’m glad about it :3

[@lj2659]

Could you do the flower shop girls next? Lily, Daisy and Rose

[@aziyyahworldofmusic6422]

One thing I like is that in the fan made song “anthropology” she wants to see humans and the creator of mini pony’s Made hugging pony’s and the last one Lyra met a human, and the song made it into “brony poka!”

[@NessaTheBat1]

The video was good pased and thanks for the little background info I didn't know. ^^ Lyra was always outstanding and I just thought she was cut eand had a very nice cutiemark.

[@lemody-YT]

even though animators did reuse the models cause flash can be a nightmare to animate with especially in the 2010's. It wasn't as bad as g3- like their body and hair were the same with just changed colours. I supposed the mlp generation 3 dolls did have similar hair too so maybe that was partly why the hair was the same creating the g3 show, but even on the dolls there was still some variation in the styles of manes which had to kinda be "brushable."

[@magnapopus]

I thought you were gonna mention the fact she makes "hands" when she uses her horn...but honestly I can't tell if that's a canon thing or a fandom idea. It all blurs together

[@Xeorboom]

damn it you got it stuck in my head again!

[@seekingabsolution1907]

2:32 well if you think of the jump from gen 6 to gen 7 as indicating that each gen of MLP is actually a massive time skip, we can trace all the way back to gen 1 where the ponies did interact with humans sometimes. Add this to the equestria girls spin off conveying that there's just this one mirror that teleports folks to a world with humans in it we can posit the theory that, as with the Telmarines in C.S. Lewis's the chronicals of Narnia, in ancient times, a portal opened in Equestria which allowed humans to travel there from where they lived before. Perhaps trying to settle or even colonise the new land. Either way, some of them were corrupted or changed by the magic they found there, becoming monsters which threatened the land. We can see this by the fact that Gen 1 Tyrek is a magic warped human, (and he lives in a castle, which is historically a type of buildimg you only use when you're trying to assert military control over hostile territory) and we see in the equestria girls show also that magic very frequently causes physical mutations in humans who use it. This provides an explaination for both why Lyra would know about humans (oral history, archeology, old history books etc) and explain why humans arent present in the setting any more, *and* why the princesses just have this big techno magic mirror portal in one of their rooms because of course since these magically mutated humans caused so much damage to the world they would want to contain any avenue by which they could return. They may even have been trying to find a way to streamline the effect of the magic on people, given that the portal through the mirror converts human world organisms into pony world organisms and vis a versa.

[@CarlyIsSleepy]

i love this kind of video! Keep up the good work /)

[@Qwer-teaBinch]

On the whole clone problem, i always just thought of it as being related to having dominant or recessive traits. Maybe having a lyre mark or a teal coat are dominant traits while having something like rainbow hair or an unusual bodyshape were recessive. Also i just like to think of the "accidental alicorns" as people with the equivalent of an extra didget. Very THERE, but it doesn't work at all.

[@Rebeca1013]

She use to be my favorite poney bc it was the only g4 poney I had growing up all my other poneys where g3

[@ang_jpngg]

The anthropology song was my favorite when I was little

[@btsrosaline3559]

How I think the main six died was there was great evil stronger than any they have fight before, and that’s why discord took the hermit crystal in the comics to stop magic completely to prevent any other pony getting hurt because he was so upset and depressed about Fluttershy

[@ThatOneTigerdeer]

We need a Berryshine/Berry Punch Video!

[@vampires4life]

LOVE THIS KINDA VID, if ya wanna do more uv these PLEASE DO

[@Chloe-Dream]

Love your content love the good work 💞💕

[@kandisoda331]

Loving your animation man!! Keep it up!! >:3

[@EffMinus]

thank you for noticing haha

[@m488thunderbird3]

Can you do a video topic that is quite META because interesting analysis from my POV the Height of Brony was also the same time as a really great video game The Last of Us and makes it feel like 2023 is like you are Pucci Made in Heaven bringing it full circle.

[@ItsCooper]

I liked the video and topic. Keep it up!

[@EffMinus]

Thanks, will do!

[@bentlithealien]

Do Dr. Hooves

[@robertomaciel9281]

E eu adoro quando ela esta do lado da Bonbon , porque eu sempre gostei da parceria delas.

[@FluoFIM]

7:11 according to me. It first got adopted in s5 e12 amending fences in 3:00

[@christopherrawlins85]

Hmm I always wondered where twilights old friends came from bc weren't they in canterlot? But then once twilgiht is in ponyville she appears in ponyville

[@sagaswp]

Two ponies exist. Shipping ensues.

[@adamsaltus4152]

Awesome videos please keep up the awesome work

[@Lucky_Lyra]

Lyra is best pony in my opinion ❤❤

[@ClypssiusStar]

Whenever I see lyra I just think about those Lyra with hand magic pictures If you know you know.

[@evanmak7837]

I believe that one of the reasons LyraBon became a thing among bronies was the designs themselves. Lyra has a sharp edged mullet that can be translated into a butch boyish cut and BonBon has curls which is mostly imagined as wavy long hair. As much a stretch as it is and no matter how stereotypical it sounds, they fit the pop culture, retraux lesbian couple in appearance: the butch and the femme.

[@RedPaint477]

This teaches me better than school

[@Luke-uf3jw]

I'm really like these kind of videos.

[@karlsaggan]

The same can be said about the character Minuette, who was previously called Colgate. But I found a more logical way. Personally, I believe that the canonical name Minuette and the non-canonical Colgate, despite the fact that they look alike, are two different characters in names and personalities, even though they look like twins. I believe that in Equestria, most likely, some ponies still sometimes look the same and are as similar to each other as two peas in a pod, but at the same time they are not actually considered twins. That is, if you only like the first three seasons of the fourth generation animated series and you think that subsequent seasons after the fourth were not needed, and you also like online fan games from the “Pony Platforming Project” series, then you can generally consider that this canonical character’s name is Colgate, and if, on the contrary, you love all nine seasons of the fourth generation animated series and you don’t like that some of the fans falsely came up with Minuetta not an official name, to which Hasbro did not give any of the fans the rights, then just consider that the pony Colgate is just a different character, but 99.9% as close as possible to the pony Minuetta and that’s it, don’t worry! Fan fiction and fan art with fan characters help to please everyone.

[@Strawberry_milktoast]

Can you talk about doctor whoves please

[@Krueger_ai]

I have a theory that DJ Pon-3 is Vinyl Scratch’s real name.

[@EffMinus]

it's the other way around lol

[@kawaiidragons7732]

I head cannon Lyra as a reverse Sunset Shimmer

[@Horsesanddragonsand_more]

Here’s something interesting. In mlp G1 there are humans! Maybe Lyra Heartstrings was a background character in G1! She would’ve seen humans and maybe even grew up with one! That’s where she learned human behavior and became obsessed with humans!