Who is the Best Packers QB of All Time?

[@janevasquez1061]

Okay real talk Matt Flynn will always be a legend for coming in clutch when Rodgers was out.

[@patrickturk8957]

Yes like that lions game and cowboys

[@chuckfreisinger1508]

I was at that 6TD Lions game. The look on Aaron Rodger's face on the sideline was priceless!

[@patrickturk8957]

@@chuckfreisinger1508 Flynn Tore the lions up

[@zacharysnyder2520]

To be fair a high school freshman could have torn up that lions defense.

[@Lycan4647]

Jordan Love obviously 🙄

[@patrickturk8957]

😂😂

[@OpIvyPunk]

I mean he was slated to start the sb last year, unfortunately we didn't make it. Rodgers literally tweeted about love starting the sb

[@Tackle_NFL]

Duhh 🙄

[@GlacialScion]

@@OpIvyPunk One of the unfortunate things about the Internet is that it's impossible to tell if you're joking or not.

[@OpIvyPunk]

@@GlacialScion I guess half joking? The media was reporting that Rodgers would sit out the sb to protest vaccines or something like that. Rodgers saw it, linked the article, and tweeted @ Love to be ready. Rodgers was obviously joking at the ridiculousness of these articles

[@epiclionsault92]

I'd love to see more videos like this! (e.g. best Packers RB, WR, etc.)

[@em299]

I could listen to Tom Grossi talk for hours. Please continue to make these types of videos. I really like them and the research that goes into these types of videos.

[@spencerbacon]

I’d say do a best QB for the Carolina Panthers but that would not be a hard list, it’s obviously Sam Darnold

[@em299]

@@spencerbacon Obviously I can't believe people say he isn't

[@grantgholson6233]

This is one of my favorite videos you have made, love the editing and all the details. Couldn’t have made the video better 10/10

[@brosephin]

You should do more of these NFL history videos. Really well-made

[@kta9169]

Wow loved this video Tom! I would love more videos on Packers history as well! The quality of the stats and info was amazing and the video production was perfect

[@midnightrose124]

I loved it, Tom! If you keep making these, I'll keep watching them! :)

[@michaelc1205]

Matt Flynn. No doubt about it

[@hottakessports6113]

Been saying this about Bart Starr forever. At the time he was the QB for the Packers, it was unheard of to have a great passing QB as it was implied that the offense would run through the run game. So to have a QB that could pass as he could, especially for at the time, was unimaginable.

[@mattnelson7775]

Also Championships! It's why you play the game! Non packer fan an it goes Star farve Rodgers

[@mattnelson7775]

Rodgers wins a another ring he will pass farve

[@kipgaming6139]

I love the style of this content Tom. Would absolutely be awesome if you did other positions too.

[@miguelduarte8120]

Loved this new content, congrats Tom! :D Love from Portugal 🇵🇹

[@Vrunge90]

Vc acompanha a NFL desde quando mermão?

[@chenrayen]

very well done, going to rewatch this a bunch

[@gman8557]

When I was a kid… I was a magik fan…thought he was awesome…until Brett showed up. One of my favorite Brett moments, I believe it was 92 or 93 season playing Da Bears…Brett got hit sooo hard he threw up. He sat out one play, went back in, threw a touch down. I so mad Rodger’s first year, I wanted to become a Jet’s fan…but I did kept one eye on Rodger’s that year, he just didn’t make any mistakes…favorite game…gotta be 2017 against the Cowboys Rodger’s Cook combo with 3 seconds on the clock…Packers win with a field goal…I agree with your top QB … Rodger’s 100%

[@andrewchristenson5963]

Great video! You are spot on. Roger's gets a LOT of hell for the preseason but everyone forgets about ALL the times he bailed us out in the Regular Season games under McCarthy

[@jaydendoucette1347]

no one forgets anything, EVERYONE knows Rodgers is that guy

[@Slaqin]

This was a dope vid, kept me entertained at work

[@soupernewb]

Fantastic Video Tom👌👌

[@-._._._-_._._.-]

Greatest, Starr. Best, Rodgers. Funnest, Favre. I've always seen a difference between the terms greatest and best. Rodgers has the skills to go toe to toe with anyone that has ever played. Starr has the "clutch factor" that makes you dread seeing him when the game matters. Favre just seemed like he wanted to have fun, he would be sick of winning and throw three interceptions in a row, or he would decide he wanted to win and put up three touchdowns. (Head cannon is that Favre threw that last interception to the saints to screw the Vikings one last time.)

[@spartanworrior4519]

Greatest and best literally mean the same thing

[@Uncultured_Barbarian465]

Favre coming ot Green Bay made football fun again. It was Reggie White coming to Green Bay that opened the door for more quality Free Agents arriving in town. As a young Packers fan, that was a great time to be a fan, watching your team go from a laughing stock to very successful. And Nags would argue with you that Starr is the best QB of the lot, but you have your points. Good vid, Tom.

[@collinzcruel4190]

You should do a video in this format for the worst bears QB

[@BankBeaters]

Starr was the best at winning championships Favre was the most fun to watch Rodgers is the most accurate Great video Tom! Would love to see more similar vids!

[@tjk9263]

Rodgers has made A LOT of throws or plays with his legs that have made your jaw drop over his career. If he was the leader that Tom Brady has been over his career Rodgers and the Packers would have gotten at least 1 more maybe 2 more SB trophies.

[@Rjunior204]

Hey everyone 👋. My first time being here and I'm a huge packers fan. Love your channel tom. GO PACK GO 🧀🧀🧀🏈

[@guilhermemoritz7353]

I would choose Starr over Rodgers until he has more good post seasons and a Superbowl win.

[@dudelove69]

Supwr bowl wins are not what makes a qb great. So to diminish what rodgers did because he didnt play on as many great teams as starr did plus the fact theat there were way more teams in the league when rodgers played making playoff success harder to achieve... anybody basing their ranking that includes super bowl wins doesnt know wtf they are talking about at all

[@PewterGaming69]

Kurt Benkert, no question

[@WhaleOfAStory]

I was so disappointed to see that Kurt wasn't included on the thumbnail 😔

[@PewterGaming69]

@@WhaleOfAStory Fr tho 😭

[@ambikaerin458]

Great vid with good stats analysis. It was really good to see Bart Starr as a QB appreciated, though I concede to Rodgers being even better. KGM and Go Pack Go

[@rjhaney2614]

I love conversations like this just because of the way that sports have changed. I’m a huge hockey fan, and the closest thing in hockey to the importance of a QB is your goalie and goalies have changed so much over the years. I love cross-era conversations.

[@thomassingleton2104]

I say Bart Start with A Rod a very close second, by the way the Matt Flynn thing was also because Arron Rodgers was calling the offensive plays

[@GingerSalmon]

Good list, Farve and Star are both legendary QBs but it’s become clear that A-Rod is the Packers quarterback in franchise history

[@jessehaskins7849]

When someone says the word “Packers”, I always think of Brett Farve.

[@sawyerprincl4102]

Brett farve has been better because he of a team leader then any other quarterback i have ever seen before

[@Xaddre]

I really enjoyed this video. I know you don’t normally make videos like this, but I think you should do this kind of thing more. As you said this video is not monetized so maybe next time you could try to find a sponsor?

[@thehound9086]

It's Bart Starr hands down, if you go by playoff stats, where it REALLY counts!

[@lenin17301560]

Bart Starr came out looking quite GOATY after Tom’s analysis.

[@markwheeler202]

As I recall, Starr called his own plays. No offensive coordinator calling in plays over the radio headset. No elaborate hand signals from the sidelines. Most QBs in the NFL today would be lost playing in Starr's era.

[@debbaedke3170]

I agree with your ranking. Absolutely do more content like this! 🙂

[@Cardinal2442]

Come on Tom, you know you're the greatest QB to ever play for the Packers, you don't have to modest.

[@PwnageEngage]

idk. There's something to be said about throwing as many picks as he did (Favre) and still having as much success in playoffs / superbowls as the stat machine A Rod. To me it makes it even more impressive that he was able to give the Packers so much success despite that insane flaw

[@davidlazarus67]

I think this is an absolutely fair ranking. Favre was a gunslinger but so many interceptions really kills his overall ranking. Also Rodgers holds the record for fastest to 400 TD’s as well.

[@TheBirchwoodVampire]

My ranking would be 1. Starr 2. Rodgers 3. Favre. While Rodgers is undoubtedly the most accurate of the 3 ,and I believe the best individual performance from the 3 was Favre’s dad game vs the Raiders. I simply cannot overlook how seamlessly Starr ran the offense of the GOAT Head Coach and the near unrivaled post season success.

[@jimc.goodfellas]

That is actually a really tough call....Starr, Favre and Rodgers? Really tough decision. All legends

[@darkhawk4863]

Some fun stats popped up on this vid that, as an Eagles fan, I have to chuckle about... Like how Tom Brady's best passer rating year is below the best passer rating posted by Nick Foles. Thank you for that list. :P Also... was y'all taking Reggie White from us a long-brewing revenge for the Eagles being the only team to beat Lombardi in the post-season? Mostly kidding... I was glad to see Reggie actually win the big one. RIP to that Legend.

[@thatotherguy9818]

Love this video! Would definitely be interested to see if you could somehow monetize this format because I would love to see this sort of content continue.

[@colby707]

Holy wow I assume you finally hired an editor these vids just keep getting better and better production value.

[@vandad13]

Would love to see you rank the rest of the Packers quarterbacks

[@dundermifflinregionalmanag5607]

It’s obviously Matt Flynn

[@nicholassmith479]

I remember when the Cincinnati Bengals defense injured the Packers Quarterback(Magic Man) and the Packers were forced to use their backup. Both teams went in different directions ever since.

[@FlyingGuillotine100]

The packers 1966-68 nfl championship 3-peat, of which number 2 and 3 were also paired with super bowl 1 and 2 wins, is the most underrated achievement in the nfl.

[@Alex-lc6vi]

Love the music in this.

[@jacksonconley5117]

Best Packers Player By Position: QB: Aaron Rodgers RB: Paul Hornung FB: Jim Taylor WR: Don Hutson TE: Paul Coffman C: Jim Ringo G: Jerry Kramer OT: Forest Gregg DE: Reggie White DT: Henry Jordan LB: Ray Nitschke OLB: CB: Charles Woodson SS: LeRoy Butler FS: K: Mason Crosby P: KR: LS:

[@yessirskii6973]

Olb is clay

[@ZombieMayhem19]

Tom! You helped me out with my fantasy this year. I flashed back to all your videos and picked up on who was good and who wasn't

[@DRez-Productions]

Bart Starr… No Debate 🙏🏼🙂

[@cstrutherskgs]

^

[@dillpickle3535]

Let’s all be serious…..it’s Kurt Benkert

[@redwood1542]

Glad we have HD footage of Farve (even if it's in purple)

[@cadensunila]

The real question is who is the Packers greatest backup quarterback of all time?

[@sugtheavenger2705]

A-Rod for those 3 years probably XD

[@cadensunila]

@@sugtheavenger2705 That's a good answer lol

[@dundermifflinregionalmanag5607]

Kurt Benkert

[@sportsnstuff5557]

Surprised you didn't bring up Arnie herber. He did play in the 30s but he's still a hofer but I agree with what you said about the big 3.

[@aquacoyote1995]

Kurt Benkert is the best qb hands down 😂

[@dennisvoss7517]

great video tom! awesome!

[@ebtv7663]

This is how it goes 1 starr,2 favre,3 Rodgers..Starr is 1 because he won the most 2 Favre is the most important and 3 Rodgers is the most talented. You should do one on the best defensive player

[@DaveReviewsThings]

Hey Tom are you doing the Pick ems league this year? I enjoyed that so much last year

[@DannieDecentVlogs]

Great video I enjoyed it

[@iamironkanute8750]

I think you did a great job of presenting each player (though if you look at the details a lot of Favres INTs were after the Packers fell behind and had to play catch up, even after the game was seemingly over he kept trying). So, under Rodgers1 of those disappointing playoff years, the first 5 offensive tackles were on the DL by the playoffs. Then there is 'Run the table', where all the cornerbacks were injured and a street free agent was the top CB by the playoffs. Then the year that after injuries the top running back was a wide receiver. Don't forget the year when James Jones was resigned due to injuries and lead the team in receiving touchdowns. Under McCarthy, no idea why, but this team seemed to have an injury bug at 1 position or another every year from 2012 on.

[@MountainTop750]

Well done sir!!!

[@paulweston8408]

Really good video! Even I, a lifelong fan of PURPLE SATAN loves your channel. Please make another with other Packers players, I was thinking Wide Receivers. Your team has the OG GOAT in Don Hutson, who was imho the NFL equivalent to Babe Ruth. Then you have Sharpe, Adams, Driver, and many other really good players to highlight. Again thank you for the entertainment and I'm almost sorry for just how badly I feel Green Bay is going to lose in week One this season....almost!

[@dudelove69]

Well u were sure wrong about game 1... packers slaughtered da bears and will continue to do so forever. Like rodgers said, we own you

[@Packnation25]

GOPACKGO BBY W VIDEO 🔥🤘🤘💯

[@dukewilson14]

Really great video Tom! Can't argue with Aaron at number 1. I'd put Brett Favre over Starr personally, because of his physical ability as a passer and his peak years from 1995 to 1997 where he was MVP each year. The high number of interceptions (with three of them being awful, game losing picks in the postseason) keep him from being number 1. I'd say Starr is a top 15 QB all time; underrated passing ability, but he did play with superior teams and a superior team. Goes to show the great quarterback history with the Packers having so many legends play for the green and gold.

[@mattnelson7775]

Talent wise it's Rodgers. But when it comes down to it he can't beat the 49ers

[@LessGo7921]

What kind if question is that?? It’s not only the greatest Tom in Packers history, but in NFL history Tom Grossi!

[@yedayafinkelman6024]

Kurt Benkert, no question about it

[@CooperDoesSports]

That’s ridiculous l

[@pridelander06]

To go along with this theme: most memorable/important Packers games?

[@HipsterShiningArmor]

shout out to Arnie Herber, hall of fame QB for the Packers who played before any of those guys

[@not_my_real_name9500]

Tom can't be the greatest qb of all time for the packers, he's going to be the goat of packers wide receivers after all

[@jefferyzielke7665]

Bart Star is the original version of Tom Brady. A winner. A leader.

[@issacpalmer4715]

I want more of these. I want the Donald Driver career breakdown

[@logantom8233]

Many people don't know or forget that back in Bart Starr's day, defenders could tackle receivers, ride their backs, hold them, whatever. As long as the ball wasn't in the air, it was legal. Also, you could hit the quarterback every play. Intentionally hit their heads, knees, etc. Late hits were very rare. Defenders could get 3 full strides after a pass and still take out the QB. Another thing is that the West Coast, dink and dunk, air raids, short precision passing games didn't exist. These are reasons why you can't compare modern stats with the past. QBs that had better than a 1:1 TD to interception ratio, completion pct in the high 50s or low 60s, were considered elite. Great video, btw.

[@SNG_PlaZma]

I want to protest that grossi can get into the hall of fame

[@haydendickerson4973]

Damn this is the video on your channel Tom

[@MichaelPiz]

Nope, it's Bart. Five championships, end of story.

[@sugtheavenger2705]

No mention of Benkert on the list? 😢

[@dukethecat]

Sterling Sharpe would be a great video

[@brettrice4017]

BRETT FAVRE

[@DRayArt505]

You are totally right!😀😀

[@jtm0003AU]

Holy shit Tom. What a video.

[@blizzdog3881]

As a 62 year old Bear fan I have always said Bart was the packers all time best QB back then it was a hole different game with different rules they had to go by.

[@brandoncarter8963]

Nice video!!!

[@sawyerprincl4102]

Growing up i wood think farve But all time it’s Bart Starr because of his 5 championships

[@wakkawakkagaming3710]

Bart Starr is the greatest Packers QB Rodgers is the best Packers QB Favre is the most Packers QB

[@ctbd7774]

Kurt Benkurts knee is one of the best in NFL history

[@greaterfool1176]

Hey Tom. Something I've always been curious about is the pocket time difference between Rodgers and Favre. You were talking about the teams they played with, but I'd be super interested in seeing how their O-lines compared.

[@Dylosophy]

Matt Flynn or Brett Hundley for me (this is a cool type of video to see from you)

[@Scott-J]

To broaden up on the 80's, how about a Lynn Dickey retrospective?

[@ye.ha.8378]

to me Rodgers is the 2nd greatest qb of all time only behind brady but ahead of peyton and montana to me rodgers having almost as much mvp's as Peyton with much lasser talent around him is incredible and he is batter in the playoffs than peyton the same goes for joe although he did play great in the playoffs but his teams where almost all the time more talented than the other team it has before salary cap the only thing that rodgers really lakes against these guys is closing games

[@kylersmithtx]

Nothing against Bart Starr, underrated QB legend, but that first Super Bowl MVP should have gone to Max McGee. 138 rec yards, 2 TDs on 7 catches, while brutally hungover because he wasn't supposed to play.

[@thelonebuccaneer7777]

What I also say is that Aaron Rodgers will always own the Bears but the 49ers will always own Aaron Rodgers

[@Biden_Bluh]

Obviously it's Jordan Love

[@syncifyjuice8562]

I would like to see your top 25 qbs all time grossi

[@stevenplayz9636]

If you put it in the poll the majority is gonna vote Aaron Rodgers

[@jadendewar4694]

you should do the same video but with who the best wide recievers are

[@fruitsi150]

What's the song at 9:04? It's been bothering me to no end.

[@johnny_barks]

"Round Up" by Sam Spence.

[@ryanhedge3587]

The best qb in packers history is Lynn Dickey

[@ryanhedge3587]

@@sawyerprincl4102 Its a joke but in all seriousness the best Packers qb is Aaron Rodgers

[@Goldenblade14]

The answer: Jimmy Garoppolo (in 3 years time)

[@baknights14]

Bart starr is fight me

[@jakematter1819]

1. Farve had a worse WR core then Rodgers. 2. Farve teams ran a lot more the Rodgers. They ran a true West Coast in a time where most teams ran A LOT. I mean the Bears won with Rez Grossman. The Bus, Jamal Lewis, Shaun Alexander, LT, AP, ect. The League was slower. Rodgers is the better QB but Farve had that Grit/homeboy feel that people just got behind, both players and fans. I feel like this is a Street Baller vs Hooper debate. Also, if Randy gets traded to GB we wouldn't being having this debate 😜