Who killed Benazir Bhutto?

New insights into Benazir's murder.
Source: Nine Lives of Pakistan-A book by Declan Walsh(ex New York Times bureau chief in Pakistan)
#baynazeer #بےنظیر #bhutto #benazirbhutto #benazirkilled #liaquatbagh #pakistan #politics #assasination #bibi #peoplesparty #declanwalsh #ninelivesofpakistan

[@saeedshaikh12]

I'm disappointed to see such a small number of views on this amazing channel

[@govindsshekhawat2011]

Hum is channel ko pakistan no 1 kare gai har channel inke video reaction hoga. Bus wait.. hum pakistan dusman nahi, but terrorist accha nahi mante.

[@georgecarlinn6288]

Because many do not like to see truth which may confuse or paralyze their thinking

[@AwesomeVideos590]

True thanks bros love from pakistan

[@Noorslamokz]

Im also bro but pakistan😂😂😂😂

[@MehulKamdar]

I remember the aftermath of both the Rajiv Gandhi and Benazir Bhutto assassinations distinctly. I was in India when the former took place, and I was supposed to leave a day after the latter, a trip that never took place. In the case of Rajiv's assassination, the Indian government and media co-operated to show photographs of the assassination every day, asking the public if they had seen any of the people in the pictures. Within days, everyone knew the names of all of the individuals on the film, people came forward to talk to the police and it was just a question of time before the assassins were found and killed in a shootout. In Benazir Bhutto's case, it was the exact opposite. Until today, I have not found out any details of the young man who shot her at close range with a handgun before he was himself killed in a suicide bomb explosion. No one seems to know his name, what family he belonged to, where he was from, nothing at all. And, there seems to have been no effort to figure this out. Perhaps, this kind of investigation was outside the skills of the Pakistani authorities. That said, that was the case in India too, but with complete transparency, the Indian government was able to piece together the entire story of the Rajiv Gandhi assassination. Sadly, that opportunity seems to have been lost in Pakistan.

[@nativer1358]

The alleged person who shot her is said to be a boy named Bilal. He was professionally trained at shooting and shot Bibi.

[@mariarauf3280]

Well, Pakistan has a lot of censorship, there's a really high chance that they were aware of the killer but did not disclose the details. Same thing happened in the case of the plane crash of general zia too.

[@devashishrane476]

Kudos to the Indian Intelligence and co-operation of locals as a sign of tribute to patriotism of Tamils towards the nation. But DMK's approach towards LTTE was also proven to be great catalyst in solving this issue. Karunanidhi literally showed the "kiss my ass" kind of indications to Prabhakaran.

[@sabrinakhan8217]

Rajiv was killed by indian deepstate hired poor people so India can launch an attack and kill the freedom movement of LTTE. The same is true with the assassination of Indra gandhi.It was done to destroy and finish khalistan movement. Benazir and every other leader , politician, journalist and people dead in so called Terrorist attacks were killed by ISI. These two failed creations of the British were created to destroy the useless human population.

[@harshitpaliwal63]

Wrong RAW was supporting LTTE that time .There is strong chance that RAW fcked up or intentionally let Rajiv to die bcuz of his pro Sinhalese stand

[@himansusekhardas4526]

Ye to Pakistan ko badal dega. As a human, I appreciate.

[@Hafiz_G_Lumber_1]

Black vigo dhoondrhi hy isko 🤣🤣

[@tulsiparmar5461]

Never, too much expectation

[@bossiseverytimeboss4046]

Bro ek day e missing ho jayega dekho

[@ziarahman3235]

Sabr kar black vigo ko bolne de

[@satyenpatowary6697]

But he has a miniscule of followers in Pakistan. May be one or two hundreds.

[@PritamSingh-lv2cd]

She didn't die for nothing! She sacrificed her life to inspire people like you, in return you are inspiring millions.🙏

[@snsosho]

Sayed Muzzamil Shah, my dear son, be careful or leave Pakistan. I listen you since four days and could judge that you are an intelligent and honest person. But you born in the wrong country. Surround you there are dumb people in majority. Your feeling to your nation may not be interpreted in right perspective and your life can be in dangers. One of my friend in Islamabad, who was Pasto but highly educated and great thinker is either eleminated or missing since one and half year. I worry about you. May God bless you.

[@shanivollges1933]

You are right

[@muhammadaliclay8976]

i think he eats meat so he should not come to india...he should move to US or canada

[@faizanmehmood.abbasi1110]

Oh bhai why leave the pakistan khair haa this is a big problem how much fear of death one day hundred thousand of peoples copies him and no one supres them so let him spread truth Leave pakistan LOL

[@ak99-to1gz]

Yes you are right, better for him to leave Pak.

[@auspak1281]

Every Crime behind ARMY order , They are the corrupt mafiya in Country . Zalim ARMY , Kuch nahi to Otha lyti hy ..😮

[@Mohammad-rq4jc]

He just screwed my mind up with that straight face All his videos makes me think about the reality and whats right He is a true gem

[@vsjhs5531]

Because he i is anti PTI

[@nsiuss8a8q8]

@@vsjhs5531 it's you who can't think rationally. I feel sorry that you have lost your ability to look for the facts and deny anything that is said to your leader because in your mind, he is perfect...can't do anything wrong but the facts state otherwise

[@nsiuss8a8q8]

@@vsjhs5531 good luck living with that mindset and in messiah complex

[@malarvannan3400]

Excellent analysis and coverage of each and every fact with absolute clarity.

[@zairsaeed4824]

The facts shown on Media only

[@muhammadkhan861]

4th january is coming pls don't forget to make a video on shaheed e insaniyat Salman Taseer. Because you seems to be a brave person

[@pubgistan5879]

Lanat tari souch pa

[@ritesharora6032]

@@pubgistan5879 lanat teri soch pe

[@pubgistan5879]

@@ritesharora6032 tere souch par lanat

[@Amir-fr7dl]

TLP ky deshat gardoon pr Lanat.👍 Society ky maary nikaalay loog Yani TLP waly roads pr violent protest krty Hain.

[@pubgistan5879]

@@Amir-fr7dl tari souch pa lanat

[@WeddingInvitationVideosMrGFX]

One word "Establishment"

[@jghosh2006]

Apart from a very meaningful discussion, the narration was also splendid. Muzammil you've made an outstanding vedio.

[@samrafatima285]

Great an eye opener video a lot of things I didn't know about but found out through your video.👍👍

[@kamrankhan-qm6hb]

Brother you are doing such a sacred work. I wish our journalists can learn from you

[@saeedshaikh12]

Excellent analysis ❤️ We need more of your work🙏

[@animeshpurohit1287]

क्या मार्मिक प्रस्तुति की है सर,,,,,thanks sir.....आप जैसे व्यक्तित्व की जरूरत है मुल्क को,,,,🙏❤️🙏,,

[@saimaashfaq3532]

God bless you son our youth need awearness keep it up

[@engr.a.d2850]

Allah also bless you aunt

[@AbbasiOfficial]

“The surest way to corrupt a youth is to instruct him to hold in higher esteem those who think alike than those who think differently.”

[@xenabidin8788]

you mean youthias...........

[@AbbasiOfficial]

@@xenabidin8788 Yes :)

[@satyenpatowary6697]

This is exactly what Muhmmad did.

[@smaratranjanpanda7290]

Your Analysis is really awesome.All the best

[@psgovindpur]

I am daily viewer of your analysis Muzammil

[@MrMMO-rs9ds]

May Allah SWT Protect you from evil eyes. Aameen Summa Aameen You are a Gem💎. Keep remember us in your prayers. JazakAllah Khair

[@patrioticpaki2337]

Bro u r highly intellectual. Keep making videos for us

[@Farhankhuwaja]

Excellent Analysis.

[@pinakichanda3062]

You make very good vdoz. You sound quite educated and sensible. Luv to you bro from India....

[@ashishtrivedi8253]

Your video is timeless, it's relevance was one year back and is equal now and will be same after five years or so on ..

[@tushar4u82]

I love to listen you because you come with facts.

[@Sfren5336]

Oh God. Never knew so many details that you shared. You even shared the name of killer.

[@ibrahimBhutt99]

Excellent work Brother 👍 Keep it up 👏

[@Fitness5forAll]

I remember a video where she is telling muslims on loud speaker to attack kashmiri pandits, kill them, become jihadis. Jo booge wo paoge. Innocent people got killed, lakhs of hindu pandits lost everything. India paid the price of being secular country. My heart feels sorry for every lost innocent life of any (hindu/ muslim)

[@muhammadusman5454]

Plz send link

[@UmerFarooq-lb2uy]

proof? link?

[@muhammadabbas454]

Great Sir, I watching every video. Keep it up

[@baljeet-sandhusingh3369]

Thank you so much.

[@baba-ly7vj]

زبردست تجزیہ

[@arunredddy]

Best of the best narration bro !!!!!!! Salute 🫡

[@ZafarBhattiOfficial]

Assalam o aalaikum Shah ji, remain blessed, safe and happy always.

[@adaborfun]

You always tell truth🥀❤️

[@nadeemrehman5466]

Good stuff of information

[@ZafarBhattiOfficial]

Assalam o aalaikum Shah ji. Remain blessed, safe and happy always.

[@aimtorise]

I always try to get behind your words, the hidden truth. God bless.

[@ramachandraization]

Great information.

[@prep4mdcat]

You are a sea of knowledge!man❤

[@JS-tx8vw]

Arif ajakia is right in saying 'Pakistan is a banana republic'

[@asifiqbal4451]

Nice, Very iNFormative Programe

[@zebmohammad3776]

I see Christopher Hitchens and Richard Dawkins photos in the background. Which one is your favorite? I like your way of critical thinking.

[@armaanpatial3281]

Christopher Hitcher ka level Kuch aur hi tha.In this world, no Muslim, no Hindu, No Christian, no Jew had the balls to prove him wrong.

[@SASA62180]

When a person alive is a traitor When died is an asset 😢

[@rizacramson9416]

Good to know about your authentication of NRO

[@niaziyounus]

It was a good analysis but you failed to mentioned the aftershocks of her assassination. Hundreds of people lost their innocent lives, business were burnt down, the poor factory female workers were molested on the streets. Although she was assassinated in Punjab but Karachi had to pay the biggest price. I know her murder mystery will never be solved but what about those innocents? Who will raise the voice for them?

[@mahamalikhan2976]

Absolutely

[@newsprint323]

Ask ur mulla & Allah 😂actly he did it bcoz they didn't followed Islamic law.

[@RaviKumar-wy9vr]

It's been a long time . So no-one

[@nabeelmn39832]

100 percent

[@Talksense87]

Such events are bound to have ripple effects. Same happened in India when Indira Gandhi was assassinated where over 2000 innocent human lives were lost.

[@AliRaza-ev5hs]

I like your real working❤

[@r.slearninghub7795]

Madrassay ko highlight krty hain pr kabhi Kisi Cambridge ya Oxford k student criminals ke baat ni krty

[@Missandra1]

I believe if any women of this generation talks about women empowerment then they should be just like Benazir Bhutto. What a strong fearless woman she was yet fully covered and elegant. Unlike so called feminists who thinks that wearing revealing clothes will empower them. Learn something from Benazir Bhutto she studied abroad was part of a elite society almost spend half of her life abroad yet look at her clothes. Her aura was very charismatic. Love you Bibi May your soul rest in peace.

[@imdk_pk]

The army did it and we have been deprived of great leaders by these gangsters in wardi.

[@victorysonhidden]

Pak fauz zindabad.

[@imcuteasduc]

@@victorysonhidden sarcasm, right?!

[@noobtoo2243]

@@imcuteasducno sarcasm he loves his corrupt army

[@globalcitizen1856]

All these great leaders are also butchers of a different kind! Jinnah butchered Hindus in 1947, Bhutto got the Bengalis butchered in 1971, Benazir got Kashmiris butchered in the 90s. Musharraf brought huge fame to Pak, in Kargil, by getting more than 3000 Pak soldiers butchered by the Indian army. Other famous leaders of Pak are Mr. Ten percent, the Shemale Bilawal who is confused whether he is a Zardari or Bhutto, and lastly the Sharifs who are known for corruption.

[@aqsahashmi8796]

Rip democracy💔

[@sunnyahmed7182]

بہت ہی خوبصورت ویڈیو ہے

[@na789]

Fabulous, thanks

[@salimaziz3131]

syed muzamil, always best, stay bless

[@TheAsifNoor]

Courageous Allah mjhe b itni himmat or gairat de

[@NadeemAzam]

Great job

[@teiko_edits7751]

I remember i was about 4 years old my mum told me Benazir Bhutto died. I still remember that day of my life for no reason.

[@AminSiraj-]

Lumber 1 army ne brbd kr k rkh Diya hai Pakistan ko

[@RahulSharma-uh1me]

bhai, syed, felt very sorry seeing this. I still remember my mother in India crying helplessly seeing her shot in news years ago. today while seeing your video I came to know, no one took investigations seriously. sad bhai, very sad. she was a good women, and if not. a good leader of Pakistan. very very very sad. may Pakistanis get an amazing leader and as a neighbour we work together not on war, but eradicating illiteracy , to bring food for every child, and happiness. take care syed. the kind of opinion you have, frank , honest and against the tide, Pakistan is not a good place for you to live in. kisi din koi mobbb apkeee picheee bhej dengeee TLP wale., my prayer and blessing for you, your father and mother gave you an very good education, and honest perspective. stay honest, keep helping all. --- BROTHER FROM INDIA, RAHUL.

[@aashiq-e-fazool]

मज़हब के सूत्रधार- अपार हिंसा, जबरी मज़हबन्त्रन, अपार जनसंख्या वृद्धि☺️

[@pkroninverse7307]

All happens when Hinduism Began to increase in India

[@AhsanKhan-yn9fv]

Muzamil bhai App Kal Uop agye the Mai bohot excited tha but ak emerjency ki wja se naa saka ... i really wish to met you directly❤

[@nitzkr1761]

This youth has power to change the Pakistan

[@muhammadwasim9861]

Huge Respect for you. ❤

[@samihaq5682]

What a great leader she was. Pakistan suffered a big loss.

[@samihaq5682]

@tayyaba javaid get a good book to teach yourself some history and politics.. Otherwise you'll remain an idiot like this.

[@nhmp692]

@tayyaba javaid is such brutal assassination the punishment for corruption? Keep your smelly mouth shut if you don’t have words to defend your fathers.

[@abdullahsaif9196]

@tayyaba javaid papa jhones

[@12345678986742]

@tayyaba javaid shame on u to follow propaganda machine .

[@shahedkhan3916]

A very delicate operation bro - you very cleverly remove any mention of Asif Zardari in your long detailed report. The number one suspect is Zardari - the biggest beneficiary is Zardari. The connections with all actors exposed regarding the assassination of Benazir were all connected more to Zardari than anyone else.Why, the big effort to avoid any mention of the number one accused? Why?

[@victorysonhidden]

True bro. The police washed away the crime scene soon after the incident. I am sure they were taking instructions from Mr. Zardari. And don't forget zardari was hands in glove with Musharraf to kill Benazir.

[@xenabidin8788]

so the biggest beneficiary of Zia's death was Aslam Baig??? right??? that is just too speculative..........unless you have anything to even suspect such and so, just because mathematically it is possible does not mean it is probable....

[@samibabar9543]

listen again and read some book. start from Perpetual crisis of Pakistan. then make your opinion

[@vasukinagabhushan]

Who was in charge of security? Musharraf was responsible.

[@MoHa-pu7uk]

She was not Shaheed but murdered. After her murder in Punjab by some Pathan or Punjabi hit man, Muhajirs have paid a heavy price in Sindh. Thousands have been slaughtered, women got raped, cars and properties have been looted and burnt down.,.in Karachi by her supporters.

[@riseofai8492]

The question still stands without "a clear and distinct answer", "Who killed Banazir Bhutto?"

[@songscreen]

Is that a picture of Christopher Hitchens on the wall?

[@azharhussain3376]

Ap ka styLe of expression La jawab. Shah sahb ap ka hhussn_ byaan Hussan_e yousaf jesa

[@aamirsalahuddin2277]

Who's Bilal Sir Pahli dafaa qatil Ka Nam app say suna hai

[@yogendrakumartewari1077]

15 sal ka bcha

[@usamazafar3928]

Ye sab kam Lamber one Army karati ha. State ko har trah sy yahi log sanbal rhy hen. means barbad kr rhy hen.Kisi dosry edary ko kam is liy nhi krny dety k kahen wo in k samny a kar khara na ho jay. Lanat ho esi Army py.

[@Farwaaliart]

I was 7 years old jab wo Shaheed huin🥺🥺😭😭 Mery parents bht ro rahy thy...or ab jab mainy Benazir k interviews dekhy ..unki speeches suni..mujhy bhi unsy pyar hogaya😭💔💔💔 Kaash wo hoti abhi

[@Seeker89]

She was an evil minded person

[@geetaprabhakar4261]

Respect for your work, Truthful impartial journalist❤❤❤

[@SmartAnlayst]

Very valid point about questioning assassinations of such democratically elected leaders in your country. On the contrary, it should also be noted that Benazir reaped what she sowed. Her unnecessary provocation of Kashmiris in India had led to the murder rape, and exodus of Kashmiri Pandits. She tried to use that as an instrument to gain popularity in Pakistan. Years later, the same militants that she had funded killed her. What a sad but truly karmic irony for Benazir, isn't it?

[@kaleemkalwar5827]

Good brother

[@zebmohammad3776]

Sorry Richard Dawkins in not showing in this video but many other videos of yours 🙂

[@shershah2012]

Sir u r great

[@fakesake1928]

Mujhe yaad hai hmare India me benazir bhutto ke baare aksar khabre dikhayi jaati thi itni jyada kisi aur Pakistani politician ke baare me nhi chapa Krta tha

[@malikaamir4341]

This incident jolted Pakistan and still shaking the country.

[@hanikhan9192]

Agreed on all , Time magazine k front cover per to imran ki tasweer bhi ae he Astonishing Saga of Imran Khan 🤷‍♀️😅

[@littlestar2145]

more courage to u👍

[@mujeebyousafzai9364]

May Allah protect you ❤

[@m.ytechs]

Some people who are above the law and consider themselves ultimate knowledgeable

[@saravananperiyasamy5730]

Benazir Bhutto was killed by then pak President / chief of Army staff General Pervez Musharraf Inorder to clif the wings of pak army 's intervention in civilian government by BB.

[@hashirawan4000]

Very contradictory

[@ijazulhaq9560]

Plz make a video on Khan Abdul Ghafar khan(Bacha khan) kia bacha khan waqaye ghaddar thy

[@aliyanshah4592]

Kiu

[@saurabhdiwan5512]

The pictures behind you speak louder.

[@alishabbir4298]

How u know about murderer??

[@sheelkhirbat9857]

So sad and depressing 😞

[@SM_PP]

It's ironic that an ex PM of two times was murdered and After 14yrs still no clue who did that and nobody got punished otherwise Pakistan agencies are no 1. I'm not Pakistani but it broke my heart when she was murdered hope Mariam Nawaz takes her position these brave woman are true face of feminism.

[@georgecarlinn6288]

She was warned by many people and inspite of experience, knowledge of threats, she took the decision, maybe she got used to routine threats atleast she was smartest among all leaders however she was helpless against establishment

[@ramshairshad4142]

bruh maryam nawaz is a sadist herself . She alongside with her family looted this country to such an extent that we are bankrupt now . Neither does she know how to do a public speech and neither does she know how politics are done. She deprived hundreds of women in pakistan from the basic right of education , heath and food and you are calling her a symbol of women empowerment? . Her family is involved in killing , kidnapping and blackmailing activists and journalists. She came back in power to gather more money and everybody knows how much she cares about women in pakistan especially when her political party is involved in a scandal of shooting pregnant women in model town during a protest.

[@sanjithkmemon8525]

A 15 year old boy named bilal with mehndi in his hands killed Benazir.

[@muhammadaziz8245]

I wish you were mention the name who ordered CPO Rawalpindi to wash the crime scene????

[@zahidhassan348]

What a man

[@arrahman6325]

Actually lumber one army (the emprors of state)Ka shahana dimagh set ni ho ga tb tk mazeed aisy waqiyaat hoty rhain gy. Black Vigo zinda baad

[@kishasuthar9574]

Kese kese bhadwe hai jo bolte black vogo zindabad 😂🤣 wah kature

[@Fitness5forAll]

Bhutto has blood of innocent people on her hand

[@noorulbasar37]

What a brave lady she was. 😢

[@Gemuc7]

The answer is simple, it was the establishment

[@alialaas3761]

She is the queen of hearts and of Pakistan democracy

[@NimrahTalks]

epic

[@fahmad7194]

Benazir Bhutto never challenged ZA Bhutto's judicial murder. Bilawal never probed BB's assassination. The culprit remains at large

[@zahidhassan348]

I love this guy

[@saleemsuliman3062]

Sir the Major question is who benifited from Benazirs murder? Who was given the highest seat and who was given Testastation (wasiyat)?