WHO’S RATED TOO HIGH AND TOO LOW IN NHL22?

[@WahlstedToronto]

Marissa thank you for showing us tendies some love, and you’re totally right of course ♥️

[@MarissaRoberto]

I gotchoo, always

[@TheBdog]

Goalie is the best position no doubt

[@boomshocks]

The entire rankings get mangled because they don't want to move McDavid above 95. He should pretty obviously be put at around 97, it would give enough room for created player to surpass him (although that should be exceedingly rare). Or they should allow players who are far and above better than everybody else to have stats that surpass 99 (which would help create seperation). You could have McDavid with greater than 99 stats in Offensive Awareness, Speed, Acceleration, etc.. while keeping his other stats realistic.

[@Mistahpope]

I don't think McDavid is that good I think 94 or 95 is good

[@milanek1527]

@@Mistahpope REALLY? HES THE BEST BY FAR HE HAD 1.8 POINTS A GAME LAST YEAR SND THIS YEAR HIS AVG LAST YEAR SHOULD HAVE BEEN 150 POINTS BUT BECAUSE OF CORONA HE PLAYED ONLY 56 GAMES NOW IN THIS SEASON WITH 5 GAMES PLAYED HE HAS 13 POINTS AND IF HE PLAYED LIKE THIS THE WHOLE SEASON HE WOULD HAVE 213 POINTS YEAH DEFINETLY NOT GOOD

[@Mistahpope]

@@milanek1527 well I just think there are better all round players in the league sure he's the best in terms of points but he's not great defensively or physically

[@milanek1527]

@@Mistahpope he is good defensively not the best yes I agree iwth that but still they should allow more than 99 to 1 attribute atleast 125

[@milanek1527]

@@Mistahpope you cant say you wouldnt want mcdavid on your team than anyone else by a big ton tho. Also They mainly are talking About the ovr as in franchise mode because mcdavid in franchise puts up 80 points max when in irl he puts up rn more than 120 which is a Very big difference

[@AlexRasdfghjkl]

They're way too stingy with the ratings, even with the potentials. They should add more individual stats so they can make the best players in the NHL higher

[@Ryan-jv8bw]

They gotta take a note from 2k and add in badges

[@AJSmith-jh2mi]

@@Ryan-jv8bw They kinda did with xfactor but its no where close

[@Ryan-jv8bw]

@@AJSmith-jh2mi for sure

[@jacksondavila721]

"What could he possibly do this year that makes him a 99" McDavid* "hold my beer"

[@ryantrylsson6462]

The only thing that sickens me about McDavid's 95 is that in 21 he was a 96 overall at the last update. You're telling me that his season he put up deserved a -1 rating?

[@sierramccool6131]

Yeah totally, he’s truly only getting better irl

[@lyleholtrop517]

You got it wrong he was 95 last year to gpforthe last update

[@xenonpoison7440]

Hol up, John Gibson on any other team would absolutely drop top 5 save% every year

[@tomashabs]

Buffalo or Detroit?

[@iZxrzz]

literally. feel bad for Gibson man. hopefully either he gets traded to a contender or the ducks get better

[@Ryan-jv8bw]

Hendrix Lapierre is a 62ovr but starting in the nhl on a playoff team, it’s nonsense

[@zacharymanack7593]

As of now a goal a game player too lol

[@davebernard2951]

Lapierre is elite potentiel not top 6 🤦‍♂️

[@Ryan-jv8bw]

@@davebernard2951 mcmichael too

[@brendan9868]

They fucked a lot of caps prospects. Fehrevary is like Top 6 med despite being a 1st line defender rn, McMichael is like top 9 potential despite already being in the top 9 at like 19-20 on a pretty deep team and Lapierre is like top 6 med despite having clearly shown he’s the top prospect for them. I really just don’t understand how they can justify some of their potential ratings

[@Ryan-jv8bw]

@@brendan9868 Mcmichael is med top 6, but yeah I feel you bro

[@BlakeKubeska]

You have to remember that these ratings are based on everything combined and averaged. Everyone claiming McJesus should be a 99 overall, doesn’t understand that THAT would mean he’d have: Bergeron’s defensive game, Ovechkin’s shooting, Reaves’ physicality, Chris Tanev’s shot blocking, O’Reilly’s faceoffs, Keith Yandle’s durability, and Crosby’s backhand. McDavid is the best player. But he’s not the best at everything.

[@aidanlos]

i think juuse saros should be in the top 10 for goalies

[@caoticx4930]

was thinking the same thing.......tbh Lehner has no business being in the top 10 he was replaced last year as starter by Fleury. Saros, Binnington, Jack Campbell and even Bobrovsky should all be rated higher than him and when it comes to the defensive rankings those are atrocious.

[@semi6125]

If your putting saros in the top 10 then Igor shesterkin has to be there too

[@caoticx4930]

@@semi6125 not necessarily top 10 I was just going to show how absurd it is that people actually think Lehner is better...its clearly just bias because of his interaction with the media and he is not the only player EA did this for in NHL 22 there is clear bias that is total bullshit.

[@buffaloben15golf88]

@@caoticx4930 Yeah and as a Sabres fan he SUCKED in Buffalo. Good riddance we have Anderson now. He’s not the best but he’s an elder statesman and Tokarski is a good young backup with some XP with a division rival team MTL.

[@caoticx4930]

@@buffaloben15golf88 yeah I am a Sens fan Anderson is a good goalie just lost some gas.........Lehner is overrated because of his interactions with the media he gets credit for some dumb reason..........all the goalies I mentioned before are better than him...his stats are padded because of the team he is on and he had 1 good year with a very good islanders team at the time.

[@choms]

Is it just me or does anyone else feel Marissa is saying “also” differently then how other people say it? It’s almost like how they shouted Jesse out for pronouncing Colorado the way he does.

[@GoFeverGo]

Corwins reaction to McDavid at 1 is HILARIOUS 😂😂😂😂

[@StefanWB]

"The best player in every other sports game is a 99". Not true. Lionel Messi is the best player in FIFA 22, and he's only a 93. And I don't think either he or Cristiano Ronaldo has ever had a rating above 95.

[@leo-vb5jq]

That's because they would make team of the year cards and prime icons and it wouldn't make sense to have a rare card and a normal card the same rating. I don't actually play nhl tho so maybe im missing something.

[@snowleopardseal]

And giannis curry LeBron and kd are 96 in 2k

[@hbonordic4k]

@@leo-vb5jq Even before FUT FIFA players weren't rated this high.

[@SuperAngryWalrus]

McDavid should be higher than 95 overall

[@DRANGOFEET]

Agreed, I think a 97 overall, at least 96 overall

[@briann23cgy81]

His defence would have to be higher which he’s awful at. 95 is fine

[@whitneysmiltank]

Luca doesn't seem to understand how overalls work, imo. 99 would mean that the average of all of his stats would be 99, but that's almost impossible as McDavid probably has lower ratings for faceoff, physical, strength, fighting, shot power, etc... Also, it would mean there's no room for growth for him (especially for franchise mode). It would make a lot more sense to have 4th liners at around 50-60 overall to allow more room between each players. So instead of going up (where the margin is really thin with only 4 possible rating points possible), you go down for as much as you need it. Example: Average prospect 30 ovr, AHLer 40 ovr, 4th line 50-60 ovr, 3rd line 60-70 ovr, 2nd line 70-80 ovr, 1st line 80-90 ovr, elite 90-92 ov, franchise 93+ ovr.

[@arrows4910]

I cannot believe that Auston Matthews is on the cover again

[@Jake_borkowski]

Yeah I should have been pasta Mac or bread man

[@zugbrugh6472]

@@Jake_borkowski that rangers tease before the trailer came out got me so hyped, even as a pens fan panarin is my favorite player

[@Brn934]

Pasta and Mac will get a cover in the future but Panarin will not have one. Return in the 5 yrs and this comment will be true

[@samuelmarchyyy63marchand75]

@@Jake_borkowski honestly should’ve been Price (if he won the cup it probably would’ve been a lock

[@moneydynamicmatanya9541]

Yea what were they thinking?! It would've been nice to see a player from Vegas on the cover like Mark Stone for instance

[@Dane233]

Am I the only one who doesn't think Mcdaivd should be a 99, because he's not defensively the best or physical play

[@freedy1696]

and despite that he is still the most dominant player in recent NHL history, thats why the 99 is justified

[@arlofleenor1838]

@@freedy1696 for him to be 99 he would need to have 99 fighting, body checking etc and thats just not realistic

[@joshlovely4696]

@@arlofleenor1838 but it could be like Madden where you can have 110 speed and that compensates for the 89 fighting (just using examples) and that averages out to 99

[@arlofleenor1838]

@@joshlovely4696 i disagree. ratings are out of 99

[@Dane233]

@@freedy1696 he's the most offensively dominant, not defensively, while I do think Mcdaivd is the best and could go up to a 97 but he shouldn't be the perfect player, If they changed the rating system in the future he could definitely be a 99

[@Cacuna]

Overral are base on offensive, defensive, physical and skating aspect of the game, Mcdavid cannot be higher overral if he doesnt deserve it, his physical and defensive game arent the best. The only way would be that they increased the influence of stats base on the type of players they are.

[@Bleighckques]

I agree. Especially if you look at a pair of guys like Hedman and Makar. You could argue that Makar should be number one based on play or based on skill/talent, but if you include even just physical stats Makar is 5'11 190ish and Hedman is like 6'6 225. Unless you discount those stats completely, Hedman is always going to have that slight edge over smaller guys based on raw size alone. I think the only thing that really matters is looking at the underlying stats for every player and comparing them there. For example, McDavid should have one of the highest ratings in the game for speed, stickhandling, offensive awareness, etc. Matthews would be high in wrist shot power and accuracy, and puck protection. Someone like Slavin wouldn't have super high skill stats but would make up for it in defensive awareness and positioning. Those are the things they should be comparing, not just overall numbers.

[@Cacuna]

@@Bleighckques I agree as well but size shouldn't affect stats, we just asume that bigger players are more physical but that is a mentality, if a small player is angry to throw hits even if they are not highlight real stuff, he should have a high physical stats.

[@pawnypawny4496]

I dont agree with the argument that the best player should have 99 rating. I think the rating is perfect, because its an over all stats rating and mcdavid is not the best in for example checking or faceoffs.

[@Jayzon666]

Why not 100 though?

[@milanek1527]

Then its bad they should allow mcdavid to be higher because this season hes averaging 213 points in 82 games They should allow skating And off awarness to be above 99 for players like mcdavid because his strength is so strong it should be above

[@kassianisthegoat5101]

fair enough but theres gotta be more than a 15 point difference between him and 4th line scratches

[@TheGameTripleX]

Jack Campbell if he continues the season he’s having now is going to have the highest boost rating this year, too much of the media craps on the guy because of his past with injuries and having not a big workload but he’s at the right age to mature as a goaltender

[@MegaMagnus007]

Yeah 👍

[@Solafar_VB]

I wholeheartedly disagree with the discussion around 2:36. A player should be a 99 IF he is the best at EVERYTHING. 99 is a perfect player and no one is perfect there is a lot of stuff other centers do better than mcdavid hence he doesn't deserve a 99 rating there. In my eyes ratings should be even lower but more internally different.

[@tyham12345]

To add to this. Let us say Mcdavid is 99 rated and then improves his. That would mean everyone elses rating would drop. That just would not make sense from practical point of view.

[@Catho90]

I love your videos, TSN. But have you ever tried creating a player? The overall rating is based on a player's attributes. In order to give McDavid 99, they'd have to boost up his attributes just to get him there. Would a McDavid with 99 strength be realistic? No. Discuss individual attributes all you want, but this is quite silly to me. The overall rating gives a general idea about how good player is on their position on NHL 22, including strengths and weaknesses, it's not based on how good a player is in real life.

[@milanek1527]

Then its bad they should allow mcdavid to be higher because this season hes averaging 213 points in 82 games They should allow skating And off awarness to be above 99 for players like mcdavid because his strength is so strong it should be above

[@Hedgehotdog]

Thats why the game needs to fix its rating system and make it so that certin attributes affect a position and player types overall more than others. For example if you are a playmaker having less strength shouldnt affect your overall as much as if you would have less passing. Another example would be offensive attributes if you are a defensive defenseman shouldnt bring your overall down heavily.

[@captainsolo5514]

Corwin screaming at the beginning of the vid had me on the floor laughing 😂

[@MrTheTank654]

honestly i want hellebyck to be 2nd best but last year and already start of this year he lets in the first goal on the first shot like every 3 games, its brutal to watch that happen, it happens way too often for him to be 2nd best

[@Enraged.]

With Price being my favourite goalie, he 100% deserves that spot. He had a phenomenal playoff performance but a poor regular season. Based off of playoff, 99. Based off of regular season, 85. 90 is a good middle ground.

[@TheBdog]

There is no way Conner Hellebuyk is better than Carey Price. Price should be higher than 90 based off of what team he is on right now.

[@-gumby-3381]

Lol if Price isn't a 90 because of the season then Matthew's isn't a 92 based on the playoffs 🙃

[@bradybrabant476]

Didn’t know 5 points in 7 games isn’t good? Mcdavid only had 4 points so should he be lower? 🙃

[@c0dysports]

@@bradybrabant476 McDavid was only in 4 playoff games, Matthews in 7. Huge difference

[@Callzorify]

the lack of Shesterkin is disturbing

[@TheZombiemofo]

How is last season's Norris winner 8th on the list of top defencemen in the game?

[@Jesusluvz]

Probably because the other seven aren’t only good at defence. 🤷🏿‍♂️

[@Cacuna]

Does Chabot have Panarin in his line up?

[@markusmarosits7888]

Demko's gotta be in the top 10 by the end of the year.

[@TheBdog]

As of FEB 21 2022 Demko is definitely top 10 and he is definitely better than Varlomov

[@tiger5869]

As a goalie, if you aren't a goalie, you don't get to say a dang thing about our position compared to yours. That said, as a Wild fan, I know that a good defensive scheme can make a mediocre goalie look like a star, so I understand the sentiment.

[@jordawesome1716]

I love how you don’t mention how low McAvoy is….

[@rynoxgd]

Ikr he should be at least 89 or 90 ovr.

[@jordawesome1716]

@@rynoxgd McAvoy should have been a Norris finalist. Probably didn’t deserve to win it but he was a top 3 D man easily last season. But hey Ea sports can’t get ratings right 🤷‍♂️Matthew’s should be a 93 or 94. McDavid should be higher for sure. 96+ easily.

[@MegaMagnus007]

Matthews 94 McDavid 95

[@jordawesome1716]

@@MegaMagnus007 maybe after this season yes. I’d argue Matthew’s an mcdavid are on par with one another. So 94 each or 95 each

[@MegaMagnus007]

@JORD AWESOME yeah 👍

[@lotion7452]

Saros should be a top 10 goalie low key, so underrated and stats back me up

[@TheBdog]

Saros is probably better then Semyon Varlomov or Robin Lehner. Saros should be 87 or maybe 88 overall

[@insertgenericusernamehere2402]

They don't give 99 players out in fifa until they get special edition cards in fifa. For me how the hell backstrom isn't up there annoys the shit out of me.

[@snicky3594]

Is nhl ultimate team they just straight up lower all the overalls to make the new cards better

[@carterdickinson5804]

I love Backstrom but how tf is that the name you came up with 😂😂

[@jaredsteier1868]

Who would he even be above?

[@insertgenericusernamehere2402]

@@jaredsteier1868 I'd put him at 10.but put stamkos where eichel is. If eichel actually played I'd not be complaining.

[@insertgenericusernamehere2402]

@@carterdickinson5804 the dude is a monster. And with how decimated the caps where last year in the games he played he made a huge difference (sure the post season wasn't great but he's made it there unlike other players on that list who didn't)

[@justinkramer8665]

Point should be on the list and Jack should be lower than Barkov

[@dakota8045]

shea theo at 86 is insulting

[@jarljonah4577]

Coming from a wild fan yeah agreed

[@logans5443]

Yes it is. Him and Nurse should both be in that top ten.

[@holofech9744]

There shouldn't be 99 overall players, give people some headroom for be a pro and custom characters to be (significantly) better if they want that

[@aus8604]

You only need ratings to average 80-90 to be rated 99 overall. There’s plenty of room to be the best player if you really find it fun to skate circles around the ai.

[@shadetends]

The girl looks identical to the girl who was doing interviews at the Rocket League NA invitational event thing a few years ago

[@MarissaRoberto]

IT ME

[@chiefbeanus3224]

You can’t group Gaudreau with any other flames player from last year. He played extremely good especially considering the team he was on. I love Tkachuk but it’s no question that Gaudreau is the best player on the flames

[@Tdawwg18]

Chabot's rating is justified. He is definitely a top 10 defensman. The minutes he plays and his solid defense keeps Ottawas d core together. Though I do agree that Makar and Fox were rated far to low.

[@ragejohnson1567]

Gaudreau had 49pts in 56 games. How is that a brutal year😂

[@chocolatemoose7761]

His standard is way higher than that.

[@ragejohnson1567]

@@chocolatemoose7761 he had 2 really good years in 18' and 19'. Other than that he has been a 70-80pt player for every single year of his career. And even if his standard is higher, 49pts in 56 is by no means brutal

[@Weewization]

I'll be interested to see if the change of scenery gives Kuemper a boost

[@Joe937]

They better add marissa,Corwin,luca and Eric to nhl as playable characters

[@Dwrryabtit]

Man I Love These Commentary Videos

[@TheDenigreur]

I've been ranting about all that content for yeaaaars on overal in EA games. IT'S NOT A RANKING OF PLAYERS, IT'S A WEIGHED VALUE OF ALL OF THEIR ATTRIBUTES, SOME ATTRIBUTES WITH MORE WEIGHT ON THE OVERALL THAN OTHERS.

[@FowTTaDropsIt]

I may be biased but the fact they’re saying Gibson has a pretty bad team in front and that’s a good reason to be "bad" stats wise but basically Price is still average even tho their team on paper is like 22nd in the league players wise and that for the past 4 years, Price is great but the team in front can barely score, since 2016 no one except Domi has pass 70 points and they still missed the playoffs by like a point, I’d say that’s why Price is still on top cause he’s great but he can’t get shutouts every game you know

[@davidwilson7344]

In terms of Luca's argument about why ratings don't go past 95, my theory is they want to leave some leeway. For example, in franchise mode in NHL 21 I had McDavid grow to a 98. If he started at 98 or 99 then either he has no growth or he surpasses 100. Personally, I don't like the idea of someone surpassing 100 overall so I think the current system makes sense. What I think they should do is leave the ceiling the same at 95 but scale everyone down to make better use of the entire scale of 1-99. I'm not saying we need 1 overalls lmao. But make like NHL 21's 80 overall equal 22's 70 overall, for example. Doing so would basically accomplish exactly what Luca is saying but wouldn't yield 100+ overalls in franchise mode.

[@cbjgirl23]

i'm just thrilled that zach made the top 10 and seth didn't, that seth contact is already bad

[@sully_99]

Kaprizov is overrated at this point. 9 million a year for a guy who scored less than a point per game and he isn't a 2 way player. He has the potential to be great but right now he's just not that caliber.

[@redherring4119]

Mark Stone is easily better than both Marner and Rantanen.

[@MikeVernonProd]

As a goalie myself, here is how I would rank the top ten: 1. Andrei Vasilevskiy 2. Carey Price 3. Connor Hellebuyck 4. John Gibson 5. Semyon Varlamov 6. Marc-Andre Fleury 7. Darcy Kuemper 8. Robin Lehner 9. Jacob Markstrom 10. Juuse Saros

[@honzakret7984]

Just out of interest- do you not rate Tuuka Rask as a top 10 goalie?

[@MikeVernonProd]

@@honzakret7984 Not anymore. He might not even play again.

[@honzakret7984]

@@MikeVernonProd well if you don't have him on the list because he might retire, then ok. But if he doesn't, I would have him above a lot of these guys

[@willg1618]

Demko over Markstrom

[@MikeVernonProd]

@@willg1618 In the future, probably. But Demko still needs to prove he can carry a team into the playoffs. He hasn’t done that yet.

[@MrCrockaG]

Must say I appreciate Corwin's Arsenal 4-2 Tottenham front page in the background.

[@masonmitchell2186]

eric needs to tone down as a bruins fan gaudreau had 49 pts on CALGARY

[@jackb7632]

Corwin Campbell played 7 games Price played how many in that playoff run?

[@isaacfrohlich4575]

Lmao I got the 7/11 ad with Jesse during this video

[@aamirlila2428]

I get the idea that players should be 99 overall. But how the ratings are built, this would mean that mcdavid should be rated at elite numbers on defense, body checking, stick checking, strength. I would assume that these numbers are rated low on mcdavid, which brings him down to a 95 overall

[@ARutherford0220]

What's up BarDown?

[@samsteinman5187]

Backstrom should be in the top 10 centers no question.

[@logan4680]

idk why yall think makar is getting the biggest rating boost by year end, lucic exists people

[@fifteepahphahazz9377]

So does loui

[@jotsky3668]

They should make an overall for playoff play. like if you have them in playoffs for franchise mode, etc. like marner 90 regular and then 86 playoff…

[@Nixonbutcher]

Marner in playoff should be 81

[@AntonioHernandez-tj6er]

*Prediction of how the Z and Corwin's chel 22 review is gonna go*... "It's really cool other than the fact that like if we're being honest, it's kinda garbage."

[@pkfreeze175]

For center... I would bump Kopitar, Stamkos, and Eichel (due to injuries) out of the top 10 for Barzal, Point, and Couturier.

[@Willitgo]

Not a Minnesota fan but I dissagree with Luca. I think Kaprizov on number 5 LW at 88 OVR is pretty accurate. He have been the best player in khl for a long time and is the Minnesota Wild by himself now.

[@co2angel899]

Scheifele got snubbed of top 10 but at minimum 90 rating

[@damoniqt]

Eric is putting on his best bobblehead impression

[@FiRsTnAmElAsTnAmE-bc4mn]

WHERE IS GIROUX bro the disrespect like is he not Elwood anymore??? And COOTZ BRO where he’s ovbviosuly better than kopitar bro how he not atleast a 90

[@mcpaasec420]

How is eichel better than barkov??😳

[@reese457]

Corwin Headman had an off year. Everyone else: he played injured all year

[@AvsFaithful_3xSCC]

erick: Theres a Avs player for some reason Me: 4 of the list of haves players and the goalie has 2 former Avs players (Grubauer and Varlamov)

[@Ian_D_Kemp]

My issue with the lists is how has a player like Nikolaj Ehlers been left off? Are you keeeding me?

[@cheesepleese_]

Mcdavid is a 95 so they can sell packs with the chance to get a 99 mcdavid in the future.

[@aus8604]

Bruh these aren’t Ultimate Team card ratings. They update these overalls free in every update up for the offline modes. You can also edit players/rosters yourself.

[@shaymerten173]

How is Miro not too 10....

[@roryvonmeyer2643]

Holy fuck 30 seconds in Corwin has me wheezing here

[@rnovy0918]

Ok. I’m a CBJ fan and we don’t even have Seth Jones anymore but he is better than Zach and Charlie (arguably) and should prob be like 7th. Also Adam Fox should be in front of a Chabot and maybe Hamilton. Possibly Makar too. It’s arguable but Fox is def better than Chabot.

[@jaym8346]

Campbell needs more games but he is the #1 goalie in the nhl rn in 10 or more games played im pretty sure.

[@6BURG9]

I think Puljujarvi is going to see a massive bump by the end of the season

[@joshbribiesca2803]

I don’t agree that the players ratings should be higher - that’s too simple a solution. The problem is that the individual stats should matter more. The difference that 1 point in any attribute makes should be greater. That way 99 speed vs 96 speed actually feels different and mcdavid is much faster than everyone else. It doesn’t make sense for any player to be 99 ovr since no one truly has 99 in every attribute

[@alinaswick8268]

Risser out here lovin’ on us Tendys. Respect 💙

[@mickmassimo7852]

I need your opinion about Ullmark, thanks🙂

[@mac21vb]

Post season jack campell is easily top ten, Roman rossi is insane and deserves better. Cale makar should be better. Krill kaprizov deserves his rating.

[@goaliepro6887]

I feel like McDavid should be 97 rated. We know they hate rating players 99 but I feel like McDavid should be set apart and 97 would be perfect because it would be the highest rating and it’s his jersey number

[@buffaloben15golf88]

After the awesome Buffalo performance +8 differential 3-0 start. Thompson and Girgensons need to be at least 85+, Colin Miller is quite good as well 83+ at least for him. Tyler Myers should be top 10 defenders 88 Overall that guy is a legend and you know it Boston!

[@mikeS-ow7lc]

Do you know what oloffsons rating is

[@buffaloben15golf88]

@@mikeS-ow7lc Naw man I haven’t cracked this game open yet.

[@Ilkkajoel]

Im sorry but barkov is way better than eichel

[@R0CKtheR3D]

NHL could have a 99 club like Madden. It would be a little tough though because Mcdavid is the only player who has been 99 material since prime crosby, so maybe not. But the best player should be 99 so they use the full range of overall possibility

[@terrancegore1fan461]

Yup. Or do 1 99 by position

[@mahockey3]

I don't see why they would make McDavid a 99 when he hasn't hit his ceiling yet.

[@HouseOfHockey14]

Because he has hit his ceiling

[@mahockey3]

@@HouseOfHockey14 lol

[@Brn934]

I will not stand for this Tuukka slander from Marissa

[@ryanschlaud]

The best player in the world isn't perfect. McDavid isn't the best defensive player in the league so he can't be 99. He'd have to be the best on both sides

[@sharpie74YT]

I’m shocked nobody talked about how low MacAvoy is

[@vipersnipes101]

It’s obvious why they don’t put the players higher! EA loves money grabs and without that room between 95-99 you can’t make special HUT cards worth it.

[@Maddiebruinslover6373]

That defenseman list is just terrible man, I agree with most of the changes you guys said, but I also think Charlie McAvoy should get moved up, he single-handedly plays defense for the Boston Bruins.

[@jakecarroll2241]

Is kopitar better than malkin?

[@mattkolmer]

To be fair everyone in washington wanted to trade both of them too

[@snowman22ism]

You so-called hockey people do understand that offense isn't the only rating in the game. If you look into the ratings you will find out why McDavid isn't a 99. Just because you're good at one part of the game doesn't mean you're good at all of them

[@virtuosobertzzi2321]

0:25 ”of course” with Yeah men of culture you will understand

[@joshkass9710]

Why is Panarin BEHIND Marchand?!

[@williambennett5989]

Because he is way worse im surprised he is even top 5

[@JohnSmith-jb2jf]

Marchand is a far better defender. It's not even close.

[@williambennett5989]

He is also better at offensive

[@ryanlichtenfel4817]

John Gibson is a top five goalie in the nhl no doubt.

[@incognito2822]

The bruins entire tip line made the top 10

[@MetalOcelot90]

Is there a bardown for people who aren't leafs fans?

[@n00RBERGx]

Why Mcdavid is "only" 95, one of the reasons is that they later release new cards for the players that are having an good season and the max rating is 99 so if Mcdavid starts at that it would be no point in getting an new "better" card for him in the game so they would not make any more money from people that get Mcdavid from packs in the beginning because they would have the best player in the game for the whole year. Its about money, its always about money...

[@DirkStarlight]

Ratings are different for HUT

[@Arca9ine91]

Marner is right where he should be. He's a top 5 point producer in the NHL. The hate is unwarranted. That whole damn team blew it in the playoffs, not just Mitch.

[@bradybrabant476]

Ikr top 5 scoring in the nhl and people say he’s not even a top 10 right winger just cuz he’s on the leafs 😂😂

[@JaydenWorth]

ARE YOU KEEEDING ME!?!?!?!