Why Ceasefire is Not the Answer to Israel-Hamas War

[@etafilenirg]

The clarity of your argument is commendable. May it be heard far and wide, especially by the decision makers.

[@AnthonySteyn]

Thank you, Rabbi Goldstein. You speak truth with wisdom and compassion. A formidable combination. Please keep talking.

[@JedidjahSlagter]

Chief Rabbi Goldstein can you explain this to the European Union, the USA, UN, South Africa??? It is hard to see the blindness of al these countries.

[@michelepascoe6068]

He is explaining, with other sane voices, but it falls on corrupt or deaf ears.

[@dovbarleib3256]

Majority Reprobate populations in concert with Islam. It explains everything about the EU.

[@adamnbayley]

Rabbi, I totally agree with you. No other country would be held to such standards.

[@hlits6310]

Brilliant, thanks

[@GrandWazoo-w9i]

Glad to see a South African speaking out and is not cowed by the criminals in his government.

[@pamelawinson3192]

How can Africa speak up with the corruption trouble there . Always people starving in Africa adverts and more. Each country governments should look after their own..

[@LadyMesha8511]

We do have food we are fat and thriving. Thank you.​@pamelawinson3192

[@susisjardin2459]

@pamelawinson3192 Hullo Pamela - I think we may have “met” on YT previously . Your comment no doubt is well intentioned and is noble to a point. Especially with South Africa accusing Israel as it is! However, if every “country” thinks only of its own people and is not willing to join others in the fight against evil then those countries will eventually fall prey to those evil forces themselves. In this current war Israel is not only fighting for their own existence but for you and for everyone of us in the so-called “free world”. Rabbi Goldstein is correct making mention of the Global Jihadist terrorists. They could be on the way to your country/city/village next if Israel is coerced to compromise.

[@IsmailPatel-w2r]

And they keep saying it's the racist white people that are to blame. Well maybe just a wee bit

[@2910ct]

RABBI GOLDSTEIN MAY YOUR WORDS OF WISDOM BRING LIGHT AND DISPEL THE EVIL DARKNESS 🙏🇮🇱🕊🌕

[@GayleLevy-y3k]

Amennnn !!!!!

[@shasha14779]

This evil of darkness

[@tophamshaba4764]

This is wisdom at its best.

[@jenniferanthony3162]

Spot on Rabbi! God bless. 🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@shasha14779]

There not believe in god .

[@bevsue06]

Thank you Rabbi

[@heavenlightlyimo4323]

I agree with you 100/percent

[@barryklarman2720]

Very clear & very true!

[@DrGELier]

I totally agree! Thank you for speaking out, Rabbi Goldstein.

[@MariéHorgan-u6l]

God has never lost a battle, and He will not lose this battle now.

[@glaubs65]

But we have to get involved.

[@everythingandmore5537]

The Book of Joshua contains several passages that describe the conquest of Canaan, where the Israelites, under Joshua’s leadership, carry out what could be interpreted as acts of genocide or mass killing of entire populations. One of the most notable verses is in **Joshua **6:21**** (ESV): > "Then they devoted all in the city to destruction, both men and women, young and old, oxen, sheep, and donkeys, with the edge of the sword." This verse refers to the destruction of the city of Jericho. The term "devoted to destruction" (in Hebrew, **ḥerem**) signifies the complete annihilation of everything within the city as an offering to God, according to the narrative. Additionally, other cities like Ai (Joshua 8) and Hazor (Joshua 11:10-11) faced similar fates. These events have been subjects of theological, ethical, and historical debate, with scholars discussing whether they represent historical events, theological allegory, or cultural memory. Israeli Jews are brought up on the Book of Joshua from the time they are in Grade 1. That's why Israeli born Jews or Sabras are genocidal in nature.

[@MariéHorgan-u6l]

@@everythingandmore5537 Go look in the book of Revelation then you will see how the story ends.

[@glaubs65]

@@everythingandmore5537 And Islamists are obviously not genocidal. Poor victims of manic genocidal Jews who read Joshua. Even though their religion clearly states there will be no peace until everyone on earth surrenders to Allah. Even though they are taught to hate Jews from less than 6 months old. Even though they kidnap, behead, beat, execute, even their own. How ridiculous and out of touch with what is in front of everybody's faces. There's a reason almost every prolonged conflict in the world involves Islamism.

[@everythingandmore5537]

@MariéHorgan-u6l That's in the New Testament. It's not taught in Israeli schools, so not relevant to make them genocidal

[@hanaaa6394]

Thank you for your support. I agree with you.

[@giselapfeifer4666]

The demand for the release of the hostages unconditionally - because it was a crime to take hostages in the first place

[@shawnwatson1419]

100% correct rabbi!

[@PS-xp1ii]

How true! May Western people hear your voice and think about it by mind and heart. Time is running. Thank you, dear Chief Rabbi Goldstein. May God bless you and protect you and all Israel.🕊💖🫂

[@michellevaughan5969]

Thank you. I could not agree more

[@ZAR797]

Well said Chief Rabbi.

[@lynndavid1066]

Holy HaShem has the final Word! Blessed be His Name ❤❤🙏💙

[@pamelaleibowitz3019]

Todah Rabah ! Brilliant !!!

[@chavelebatmiriam4123]

Thank you Rabbi - Keep up your pursuit of Truth and Justice in the world - b'hatzlacha rabbah

[@schofield4836]

Spot on! Bravo!

[@LinstonErasmus-lg1fs]

Well said Rabbi ..thank you !!

[@gillstraker1994]

This terrible situation is affecting people all over the world. I feel so heartbroken knowing that there are innocents at the mercy of monsters.

[@ClaudioM-s2f]

I completely agree + 40k almost kl ds, lsr has to stop 😢

[@Danielseven-ir2mq]

Well said. If only the Israelis on the left would listen and stop the protest.

[@simchalebovitch6944]

Unfortunately, it seems they're being led by a left wing media who has not put Hamas' full demands for a 'ceasefire' to them.

[@junelehmensich3386]

THANK YOU RABBI. PRAYING FOR THE PROTECTION OF GOD'S PEOPLE IN THEIR PROMISED LAND. ABBA FATHER WE LOOK TO YOU FOR PEACE. FOR THE RELEASE OF EVERY HOSTAGE. GOD BLESS YOU RABBI.

[@lindagoh6222]

Thank you, Rabbi, for speaking up! I absolutely agree with you and totally support the points you have brought up. I simply do not understand why Israel is being pressured instead of Hamas who have committed such unheard atrocities against innocent citizens of Israel. No one in his right mind would negotiate or compromise with such a terror group who is still holding many hostages!

[@arifmohammedyasars937]

Knew ur cults entire history and the lies u said about germans...the barbarian cult who declared war on germany in 1933 and reasons behind expulsions

[@howardschwartz1350]

Many thanks for speaking out strongly !!עם ישראל חי

[@samtheresearcher]

Certainly! A ceasefire is NOT an option.

[@Carlos-kt1wo]

That sounds like the remaining hostages are already doomed

[@baruchben-david4196]

@@Carlos-kt1wo We don't even know whether any of them still live.

[@Carlos-kt1wo]

@@baruchben-david4196, you are right; we don’t know whether any of them are alive for sure. However, so far, Hamas has proven true to their word with regard to the status of the hostages, ie so far, none of the hostages they said were alive have been found long dead. When they said such and such hostages are dead, none of those hostages have been found alive. In other words we have no reason to doubt Hamas word with regards as to how many hostages are alive

[@Rebecca_Sunnybrook_Farm]

Rabbi Goldstein, you said so well what I have been thinking.100% percent.

[@lindajacobson588]

Brilliant. So powerful.

[@edwin-win]

Totally agree with every word u said. Spot on

[@kathrinlarsson5804]

I agree ,from Sweden! I am sure that most of us stand with Israel.🏊‍♀💏🧑‍🤝‍🧑👭👫👩‍❤‍👩

[@rocklynfigredo1982]

Totally agree 👍

[@ct9400as]

Absolutely

[@Wikus-p6o]

Chief R Goldstein, jy is nie net n stem vir die Jode nie, maar vir n wereld wat smag na reg en geregtigheid, al wat ek vra moenie ophou nie, seen vir jou en jou huis en jou volk (Jode)

[@hannaberaja3682]

Thank you Rabi

[@sandramanter5608]

Well said Rabbi. Let me people go unconditionally ❤

[@casienwhey]

Rabbi Goldstein, I agree with everything you said. Thanks for posting this video.

[@ForexdailytradingsystemsCoZa]

Thank You Rabbi. With Such A Clear And Precise Message One Must Believe The Israeli Government Is Set In Their Discision. Pray Love, Protectìon And Unity For Israel. And May The God Of Israel Be Your Rear Guard And Your Fore Guard. Love To You And Love To Israel. 🤍

[@blessed-u31]

"When the battle is between good and evil, compromise becomes an accommodation with evil, which is not only immoral but also dangerous" ~~ so terribly true when fighting against those who wish to annihilate one's family.

[@rosaravich5783]

Thank you for your wisdom!

[@AsserYarafatso]

I agree 100%

[@ridasz7954]

תודה רבה

[@yellowtapemeasure3741]

I am astounded that the whole world does not / cannot see this. How is it possible, with all the modern communications technologies out there, including social media (including X) that there are still people that are so blind? Release the hostages! Am Yisrael Chai!

[@glaubs65]

Please see my comment about the Western globalists somewhere here. Thank you.

[@amelialeroux1907]

Thank you for putting truth out there. ❤️🇮🇱🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🇮🇱

[@janiceridsdale2904]

EXACTLY !❤

[@ChildofGod-g8f]

We mourn with you. Israel always ridiculed. Hamas don't want compromise. I'm too angry to comment further. May God protect His children and bring them home.

[@effsandilez6026]

You mourning with devilish barbarous atheists

[@MrRoshanf]

Absolutely❤

[@Cecilia_181]

Very true

[@honeyho9890]

The hostages families should understand Pm Netanyahu is in a difficult situation. Cant afford to sacrifice the whole nation to making deals with the serpents. They never honor ceasefires.

[@godfreyberry1599]

Rabbi your comparisons to compromise situations being options not negotiable in past conflict situations are extremely relevant to the Israeli and Ukrainian nations. Just one glaring example of a forced compromise which caused untold suffering for many years was the compromise deal between Stalin and the Allies regarding Berlin and East Germany which didn't end well.

[@benqurayza7872]

Point on, Rabbi. I am ashamed of the Biden-Harris administration's equivocating conduct in this crisis.

[@veluccivelluccimusiker4340]

YOU FORGOT TO MENTION SO VERY ASHAMED OF ANC

[@MarkKaipua]

Very very TRUE❤

[@decalogueten]

May the Eternal King of Israel who established her boundaries - the Lord Jesus Christ - bless and prosper her

[@erpollock]

Rabbi Goldstein is a distinguished Chief Rabbi for South Africa, a Jewish community I perceive is under siege. The South African Jews, and we too, need Rabbi Goldstein's clear moral voice.

[@FurianXX]

For your information, dont equate all Jews with Zionists.... just a thought....

[@lindaschmill3238]

You are asking to OBH Administration what they aren't. Courage and loyalty. Not even once they didn't ask the Red Cross for our hostages!! You are religious, when you talk always wisely you add always hope, your heart too. Be Blessed 🙏 Thank you 👍

[@tophamshaba4764]

Amen

[@Kingdom3in1]

Love this man. He speaks pure and simple truth

[@louisegalante2094]

Chief Rabbi Goldstein is a well-educated well-spoken gentleman

[@desjustdes939]

And the sheep hang off his every word.

[@hilarymeyerov2934]

@@louisegalante2094 and a man of the book

[@iehb505]

@@desjustdes939 And you savour all the evil rhetoric of the ANC and Hamas

[@desjustdes939]

@@iehb505 no,they simply want back what's there's.

[@Carlos-kt1wo]

@DixieC-vj2sg, Israelis have recently immigrated to the region…. most have less than a 100 year history with the land, unlike Palestinians who have a history that goes back centuries… Even Benjamin Netanyahu is the son of Polish immigrants…. His Father Benzion Mileikowsky changed his surname to “Netanyahu” to sound more Jewish Even David Ben Gurion, the founder of Israel, was a Polish immigrant himself. He was born David Grün and changed his name to sound Jewish

[@sandrafisher7505]

YHVH'S Judgements are on the way. YHVH is in control! Our All seeing Elohim.

[@tehilovely]

❤God Bless ISRAEL❤❤❤

[@shasha14779]

There not believe in god .

[@tehilovely]

​@@shasha14779i did not ask your 0pinion!!!

[@hquarmyne]

God bless you

[@maaritrantala-y7y]

Thank you rabbi Goldstein for your wise statement👏 Thrue words 🤗 God bless Israel and its people🎗🎗🙏🙏🇮🇱🇮🇱🇫🇮🇫🇮 Shalom 💙 Peace for Jerusalem 🕊🕊

[@michelebarkway3853]

So so true Rabbi Goldstein..........it's ridiculous that you are one of only a handful of people that see the whole picture so clearly. You should send this direct to Biden, Starmer, and the UN...............

[@godfreyberry1599]

They're all on a devious and satanic liberal power trip - wouldn't help at all.

[@hilarymeyerov2934]

RABBI AND DOUGLAS MURRAY

[@hilarymeyerov2934]

Starmer the bstrd with his half baked jewish wife

[@Anna-rt3id]

I agree with everything said in this video. This is the voice of reason. Thank you for speaking this wisdom and understanding Rabbi Goldstein. 🕊️💙🇮🇱🪽

[@veronicapetersen8915]

I stand with Israel. I am praying for Isreal and the whole of the Jewish nation. You so right Rabbi. I agree with you 💯%. 🙏🙏 From W. C.

[@sherylkruger3344]

Agree. Thank you Rabbi

[@lindasaunderson4428]

Amen and Amen! Thank you Chief Rabbi for your boldness and speaking the Truth.

[@SPsalm24]

Touche. Baruch HaShem 🙌

[@patti-jeanlima3904]

Amen to everything you say. It is Truth.

[@GreatSwordFightingforYis-dg2xj]

Thanks Rabbi. Preach it brother. The Jihad/Ghamas evil must be defeated, and they must surrender and let the hostages go. I disagree totally with the SA Government; they must read the Bible (Tanakh). I stand firm with Israel/IDF in prayer. Am Yisrael Chai. Shalom.

[@geoffreydrew4810]

May the covenant to Abraham and Moses prevail.

[@brendakruger2597]

Hashem is Israel's only Ally.

[@baruchben-david4196]

Maybe not exactly the *only* one, but the most reliable one, for sure...

[@christopherj.l.watson3560]

May God bless and keep the IDF and Israel

[@shasha14779]

How do you know god bless Israel and IDF .there not believe in god

[@AnnetteDangel-i9n]

May Israel be under the protection of the God of the heavenly angel armies.

[@Maryanne-j2e]

God do not support mass killers of children,10000 raped prisoners without valid judgment

[@anchoragealaska3104]

Once Hamas is defeated Israel should bring a case to the ICC against South Africa for the ANC's role in aiding and abetting Hamas in the latter's long and continuing list of acts of genocide against Israeli citizens.

[@SamsonZionist]

Amen and well said , Retribution will come on our country sadly because the wicked ANC government has a deep hatred of Israel.

[@yellowtapemeasure3741]

Read Psalm 37. The wicked will get their deserved justice.

[@rutbrea8796]

Read Ezekiel 20 until the end. The Jewish people need to return to our God, Adonai Elohim Tzevaot!!! Those who call themselves Jews but are not , instead are doing wrong things and not recognizing their God and follow through the Covenant of HaShem promised by our forefathers to HaShem!! Together, we stand, divided we fall !!! Baruch HaShem!!!❤❤❤🎉

[@brendakruger2597]

I am a Jewish South African and am ashamed of the ANC Government. 🙈

[@ChichigalCheen]

Do you think the ICC will give a fair hearing to any litigation filed against hamas? ICC, UN,UNWRA, ICJ are all hamas supporters. Let us soley depend on our GOD to protect Israel and win this war!

[@johnhenryivirepotgieter323]

Peace is the key it's like an olive tree extending an olive branch but it's not just about Good vs Evil it's gone beyond that It's God vs Satan and I pray for your peace and safety Israel but I also pray for those outside your territory for there peace and safety for those people who are innocent in this Israel needs to put there trust and faith in God Almighty and not the world like the west etc

[@deborahgreene1432]

Toda Raba Rabbi❤🙏🙏

[@cogriffioen183]

Thank you, Rabbi Goldstein!

[@Jo-AnneFielding]

Makes sense

[@ckyam7331]

Thank you Rabbi. You Just brought Light to The situation. עם ישראל חי

[@krishrajah]

Rabbi, for such a time as this, God has given you Wisdom to speak out. God Bless and guide you 🙏

[@b2tz7g]

Well said. As always, thnk you Rabbi Goldstein for saying so clearly what most Jews around the world know to be the truth.

[@rosenjambi3374]

So far i haven't heard from the UN condemning the muderers of the six hostages, let alone the hamas hesbolla Iran terrorists

[@everythingandmore5537]

Israel has not brought a resolution condemning the murder of 6 hostages at the UN, probably because of a lack of evidence.

[@dogzdigital]

You obviously haven't been listening then.

[@everythingandmore5537]

@@rosenjambi3374 The United Nations has condemned Hamas multiple times for its actions, particularly for attacks targeting civilians. Most recently, in October 2023, a group of UN independent experts condemned Hamas' deadly attacks on Israel as "horrific" while also criticizing Israeli responses for collective punishment against Gaza civilians. This condemnation highlighted that no side should target innocent civilians, as it constitutes a war crime under international law. In a broader context, the UN has struggled to pass resolutions solely condemning Hamas. For example, a 2018 US-led resolution aimed at condemning Hamas for rocket attacks and violence failed to pass due to procedural requirements in the UN General Assembly, despite receiving a majority vote. These instances illustrate that while the UN has condemned Hamas' actions, efforts to adopt formal resolutions have been complicated by the wider political dynamics at play.

[@erad05]

There can’t be a compromise because the objectives of Israel and the enemy are 180 degrees opposite! As long as the Arabs will not surrender and accept the right of Israel and the Jews for an own state and to exist, there can’t be peace! 💙🇮🇱🙏 Am Yisrael Chai.

[@hermanjolink7647]

Well Spoken Rabbi Goldstein. You should hand out Israel flag stickers for all supporters of Israel to put on their vehicles worldwide. Very few cars will not have a flag. God bless Israel!! Amen 🙏

[@paulhofer1794]

We stand with Israel. Pray for the peace of Jerusalem.

[@shasha14779]

God not accept

[@paulngarua15]

Thankyou Rabbi for standing strong Best regards from Kenya

[@carolliebenberg698]

Praying for Israel 🙏and for Prime Minister Netenyahu May Yeshua give him wisdom and discernment.

[@shasha14779]

God accept your pray .there not believe in god

[@SelwynGolomb]

Very well said, but unfortunately the world is not listening

[@everythingandmore5537]

The Book of Joshua contains several passages that describe the conquest of Canaan, where the Israelites, under Joshua’s leadership, carry out what could be interpreted as acts of genocide or mass killing of entire populations. One of the most notable verses is in **Joshua **6:21**** (ESV): > "Then they devoted all in the city to destruction, both men and women, young and old, oxen, sheep, and donkeys, with the edge of the sword." This verse refers to the destruction of the city of Jericho. The term "devoted to destruction" (in Hebrew, **ḥerem**) signifies the complete annihilation of everything within the city as an offering to God, according to the narrative. Additionally, other cities like Ai (Joshua 8) and Hazor (Joshua 11:10-11) faced similar fates. These events have been subjects of theological, ethical, and historical debate, with scholars discussing whether they represent historical events, theological allegory, or cultural memory. Israeli Jews are brought up on the Book of Joshua from the time they are in Grade 1. That's why Israeli born Jews or Sabras are genocidal in nature.

[@marionjordan2638]

Dear Rabbi, you are so very right! ❤❤❤❤ Am Israel chai

[@MosesFineanganofo]

❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@patti-jeanlima3904]

I pray for the peace of Jerusalem!! May they prosper who love thee.

[@ColeCollinsCostance1673-q7l]

Amen 🇺🇸🙏🏾❤

[@brentriley4911]

Saying greater Israel wants peace is up for dispute.

[@dogzdigital]

It's not up for dispute, it is an outright lie.

[@sandrawarren4926]

A terrible sin has been committed by the International community because theyve been expecting Israel to bear the sole responsibilty of Western standards,principles and valued lessons given to us by God..What will persons knowing these matters have to yet go through now to face Almighty God with such disgrace and failure to speak out..for the sake of His honour...May there be a new wave of Gods revelation of what sin is.... and the grace to repent and tell God how very sorry we all are for shrinking away from standing with Israel by honestly looking into their complaints.Whether they thought Israel to be wrong or right...We aught to be ashamed of ourselves trying to shield the Muslims who have been darkened in their understanding and also hardened through the deceitfulness of sin....The Bible says this..... who can know the heart? It is desparetly wicked.. I remember what an impact it made upon me when Dr Billy Graham quoted this verse from the Bible while watching one of his evangelical films...The world are not decerning and should seek God before criticising Israel.Church and state used to respect Dr Graham's preaching.The world needs to return to God very urgently.!!..The restlessness and bad conduct or behaviour all over speaks of a world that has ignored Jesus Christs love and instructions for decades...

[@ninajensen246]

Leaders are denying the truth. So true Rabbi 😢

[@kimschmidt7617]

Amen absolute truth!! Israel is forever!! God’s Blessing to you Rabbi Goldstein ❤