Why China is rattled? • Lt Gen Ravi Shankar (R)

[@sanjivsinha5023]

Very good discussion. Thanks to Gen Ravi Shankar and Shree Iyear ji. Jai Hind.

[@umeshgupta7730]

Shree Iyer ji you are deshbhakt and Hindus as well. Keep it up your good work 👍.

[@shrutiChandak74]

Namaskar Shreeji and Lt Gen Ravi Shankarji 🙏💐

[@VG-bf9cy]

AIM said exact opposit on JD with Sanjay Dixit that India made a blunder by recognizing Tibet as One China policy. That was started by Nehru and continued till now. But here General says India didn’t recognize. What is the truth?

[@emerald-u6q]

Thanks to General.very informative.

[@aryaman05]

After a long time, I had to constantly rewind 30-60 seconds just so I did not miss anything !😊 Thank you gentlemen.👍

[@RanjeetSingh-lt1uy]

There is Bharat Tibet border & we should start using it every where, on domestic & international platforms.

[@seagreenblue4052]

I always enjoy listening to Lt Gen P R Shankar. He has much to say about India's military & strategic position with it's neighbors. 💖🌹🌺

[@vasantikulkarni13]

Awesomely awesome session ! It is always a pleasure to listen to Gen. Ravi Shankar ! It is indeed a treat ! My Namaskar to you both🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

[@k.asureshbabu6597]

I request Sree Iyer sir to please take sufficient rest and 8 hours sleep. We don't mind even if you cut down 1-2 videos. Don't think otherwise sir. Your health is uppermost importance to us. Thanks sir. Jai hind Jai Karnataka Jai shree Ram Jai shree krishna Jai bholenath Jai MODIJI

[@nagarajarao8358]

I would wholly endorse this statement

[@SavitriSingh-bx7yk]

Jai hind jai Bharat namaskar vande matram

[@adarshabadrinath1304]

Some people say the program is long. I think listeners who think so, can watch it in parts. It can be done in KZbin. Difficult topics like this need time to be discussed. So Sree Iyer sir, please have the podcasts for as long as you feel it's necessary.

[@abhilashn2993]

Vandemataram

[@sweetguy0]

Excellent Analysis by Ravi Shankar Sir.

[@adc12345100]

We are really grateful to Gen.for his forthrightness. Indebted to Sri.Aiyer for magnificent platform created to enlighten us. Thanks again both of you

[@Haveagodday-w8m]

Great discussion 👏

[@dineshgupta-ir9zi]

India shoul raise the voice against the oppression of Uyghur Muslims in Chinese province of xinxiang.

[@malarrganesan2008]

Thanks

[@atulkulkarni8260]

Ram Ram ji

[@katyarkhukri7003]

Illuminating discussion. Political action can only happen with some military backing.

[@ravindranathhebbar2109]

Good analysis. Very good information. Congratulations to NDA Govt, for taking various initiative in developing border connectivity. Enforcing, missile units in border.

[@kay--2]

India didn't defend Tibet against Chinese aggression..now, India should help Tibet in their freedom struggle!

[@santhoshbalu7310]

GREAT INSIGHTS SIR❤ THX

[@krishnasutra6296]

Good session . 👍

[@purplecosmos4325]

🙏🇮🇳

[@balakrishnakumarchamarthy8772]

Well said

[@Bejust389]

Vande matram 🇮🇳❤️

[@lajranitalwar7173]

🙏

[@ajaysinha-zv3sy]

Great analysis by general sahib as always

[@kannanwh]

Shree ji please allow the guest to talk freely. You are interupting untimely affecting the guest's thought process. Please park your questions till the guest complete what they are planning to deliver.

[@amarseetharama8734]

Nice analysis

[@105vivek]

India should mark tibet as a separate country in its maps

[@supriyosarkar8581]

They had enough before this govt. came to power in India. Now let them keep ratling and test their fangs with this govt.

[@105vivek]

India and the west need to call tibet an independent country and give it a place in the UN

[@nfuryboss]

Historically, China's emperors in past dynasties have always been afraid of divided devotion to the imperial throne in China. Even though China had conquered those weaker vassal states, yet non-Han population's loyalties were always suspect, and rebellion was always an issue. Culturally and religion-wise, Tibet is closer to India than China. That's why the US/India Dharamsala visit rattled China as fanning a latent threat to the CCP's message of national unity.

[@pramansharma2117]

Why should we not name entire China as western Taiwan?

[@essm4179]

Master stroke by Modi...

[@bimal2011]

China doesn’t give peace at the border and it doesn’t do a war. Obviously we have to do a full scale galwan at sea and Mountains ,Terrain and Plateaus. By that, I mean Pakistan Surrendered territories under the umbrella of CPEC and conqured and pending disputed Land at Tibet Sikkim Arunachal Border also. The Height is neither Modi nor Xi wants to fire bullet as this is not the Era of War. They both need ENO to delay war decision And US Russia are trigger happy for a dangerously stretched war with Palestine and Ukraine

[@dineshgupta-ir9zi]

India should raise non trade barriers to undermine chinas exports to India.

[@ranganathmahapatra740]

When China can break agreements wri LAC India too can break agreements wrt Tibet even if we have one. But the good part is India has never recognised Tibet as part of China formally

[@kvprasad2019]

Does this (China_Tibet) has 'bipartisan" support of 'all' opposition parties?

[@abhijitbais2460]

The situation in China is not good...

[@nagarajarao8358]

That China unconditionally withdraws all claims on the high seas in South China Sea, Indian Ocean, Sea of Japan and ALL other sea spaces.

[@shashimohangosain136]

What China had been doing to us,now we will pay them back with interest.This includes some of our political parties/ Jaichands who are hell bent supporting Pak and China,our sworn enemies.Don't know their majboori?

[@UBdrive01]

A major problem that India is facing, in my opinion, is that China is rapidly building large numbers of twin engine fifth generation fighter planes. While India is stuck with the idea of single engine fighter planes, for whatever reasons. At present we have the capability of manufacturing engines of smaller capacity (Kaveri), why not apply the 'jugad' principle and build fighter planes that have two of these Kaveri engines? Definitely these fighter planes may not be as big as Su-30, but surely they will be of larger capacity compared to Tejas. They will have longer range and more arms carrying capacity as compared to Tejas. Having a world class engine is always desirable, but the policy makers need to have their feet on the ground and be practical. To learn from our nemesis 'China', they built a plane and were initially using Russian engines. When their own engine completed it is development cycle they have switched to the new engine. There is no other recourse but to change our approach, if we want to avoid the repeat of previous Pakistani misadventures. Do not forget we are looking at a two front war in future. Every time the Pakistanis get a better fighter plane or weapon, they have been invariably tempted to wage a war (1965, 1971). Hope the big wigs and top brass in the Defence ministry and the Indian armed forces are considering this danger from future, which is staring us in the face.

[@prophetsj1180]

India is on way to build 5th Gen. Fighters. It's on Drawing Board stage now . Recently confirmed. It takes time. Tejas took 30 yrs. This Probably much less . India's manufacturing capability has much increased.

[@nrprabhu555]

What about Indian names for Aksai Chin and its locations?? First fix that in global maps.

[@SantanNoronha-r3d]

Sir I like you program but please try to make it short

[@NoName1k56]

Very True Too long to watch full Time consuming

[@Tibet-India-Taiwan]

Thank you,Sir. I SUPPORT ONE CHINA POLICY.[ . ONE CHINA] I SUPPORT ONE TAIWAN POLICY [ ONE TAIWAN]. ONE TIBET. CHINA CLAIMS THAT THE SOUTH CHINA SEA BELONGS TO CHINA. IF SO THE INDIAN OCEAN BELONGS TO INDIA. INDO-PACIFIC BELONGS TO INDIA AS WELL BASED ON CHINA'S CLAIMS.

[@sln52]

Irresponsible opposition which is not able to accept the defeat

[@gyaltsenwangchuk7669]

1 don't think that China is rattled as yet. But if India and the USA work together with true trust in each other with a sense of purpose and determination, China or Xi Jingping would have to listen to the reason and see the reality of its position on Tibet. A sense of purpose and determination don't mean just talking - sometimes sweetly and otherwise and posturing but hesitation to do the heavy lifting. India's plan to rename 30 places in Tibet is a bit of childish idea. If India tries to rename places in Kailash Manosvar ( Ghangrinpoche and Tso Mapham-yumsto ) region then India would have fallen into the Chinese trap. In such eventuality China will quickly and conveniently accuse India of trying to colonize Tibet. To many by standers Indian action is not really to help Tibetans to get out of the black hole but to demand a slice of Tibet to do business with China. I truly hope India can see the trap.!

[@gbhatia9809]

The Resolve Tibet Act "Rejects as 'inaccurate' China’s false claims that Tibet has been part of China since ancient times.” That is absolutely true. "In 1842, a peace treaty was indeed concluded between the local authorities of China's Tibet and the Kashmir authorities". "As per the Chinese Government official's statement made in 1847 to the British representative that this section of the boundary was clear." On the Eastern Sector, McMahon Line, frontier between Tibet and Assam in British India was negotiated between Tibet and Great Britain at the end of the Shimla Conference (1914). That means Tibet was independent entity for over hundred yrs with right to do international agreements at least from 1842 to 1949 when Communist China illegally occupied it. The Resolve Tibet Act strengthens India's position Vis a Vis China. It is clear that Aksai Chin boundary was well defined but Chinese changed their mind after Nehru unilaterally surrendered Tibet. China then cleverly incorporated Aksai Chin into Xinjiang to eliminate1842 treaty & Tibet's right on it. China has also reduced the original boundary of Tibet & incorporated its areas into mainland China. India's Indo-Tibetan boundary lines have as much sanctity as Vladivostok, Sakhalin Islands which became part of Russia & Hong Kong which became part of Britain with well defined agreements during that period which China calls its Century of Shame. After Modi's victory despite massive Western echo system against him, US has realized importance of India & need to concentrate on Tibet. However, India must be careful. The US & its 5-Eyes proteges have been supporting Khalistani terrorists jeopardizing security of India . India should treat US as Frenemy country keeping good relations with Russia. India must extract full advantage to eliminate western interference in Manipur & in internal affairs of India. Bangladeshi PM Sheikh Hasina has warned about Western attempts to create a new Christian country in India's eastern neighborhood...

[@narujohn6984]

One should also keep in mind that the Koumingtan govt. which was driven out of China and in to Taiwan does not recognize Ladakh and Arunachal Pradesh.

[@bharatshetty9560]

Maharlika, the supposedly old name of philipines.😊

[@Tempmam]

COT - China occupied Tibet POK - Pakistan occupied Kashmir

[@pradipkumarmazumdar9429]

Say about Chinese gandhi

[@winglo1697]

opssss wrong place. . excuse my comment below.

[@dineshgupta-ir9zi]

China exports 200 billion worth of goods every year. It's open secret that china's exports to India are heavily underinvoiced to ivade import duties in India. A 100 rupee item is imported at 20 rupees. It's five times under invoiced. Assuming 100 billion billed at actual prices and 100 billion under invoiced. Actual imports from China are at least 600 billion dollars. India should ban low technology items from China forthwith. At one stroke reduce Chinese exports into India from 700 billion dollars to 100 billion dollars. Indian manufacturers will soon fill the gap. And the kind of scale our domestic market is, we will soon match the Chinese prices. It will be best detterent for Chinese aggression.

[@winglo1697]

My comment deleted 3 times.

[@balbirmahal1853]

I would like you to ask your guest here - Gen Shanker to give his views on one other way of looking at the issue here. So during the 1971 war, when the west did ask China to carry out some activities against India, it did not do so. One can say partly it may have been that it was aware Russia was there to support India. But it has thereafter carried out aggressions on our northern borders. So even if one can look at it this way that it does not get drawn into any aggressive posture at the behest of others unless it itself wants to do so. In the present situation are we getting pushed into a situation in which the locus of control rests outside India? The reason being that possibly the intention is to shift the arena from South China Sea to our region. The reason being that in region close to China with some small countries dependent on the west for coming to their rescue, the west would have to jump in the clash itself, which it probably wants to avoid at least for now. Because, China has become more aggressive with those small nations close to it and support from N Korea as also Russia developing greater relations with North Korea, if the attention can be diverted from that region to the Tibet, it could be buying more time to support those small countries in the future, at the same time knowing that India can handle China if things do turn ugly in the Tibet region. Because so far although India had been looking for a greater support from the west for Tibet it did not happen but suddenly there has been a more keen interest shown now. China has all along tried to avoid any large military action anywhere but its philosophy now is to strangulate nations in its way of expansion by getting them under its influence and actions economically. ( Shift from the flaming dragon to that of a python). This is what it has done with small nations around India and now in its expansion strategy in Africa. It knows that the west was now looking at other options to reduce its dependence on it for goods and hence needs to have other poor nations to continue its trade. It is definitely also building its military capabilities to match the west to take them on when it knows that the west market is longer looking at it for cheap goods. So, what is the best option for India - wait and watch what the west does beyond the recent visit of Nancy Pelosi and China’s reaction or jumps into the arena to make it look like a WWF game.

[@诗刘-p2i]

印度朋友你这是在做梦吧

[@nrprabhu555]

IMHO A strong opposition is not the one with bigger numbers, but interest of the nation and its people in its mind. The current opposition is the worst.

[@nagarajarao8358]

Free Tibet! Get back ALL the Territory that China has illegally held being India's. That Taiwan will continue to be a separate country and regain its rightful place in the UN. That China unconditionally drops claims of territory against ALL countries

[@RanjeetSingh-lt1uy]

Please do program on How to create offensive forces along Bharat - Tibet border.

[@hiteshdas845]

General Sahab is it possible to get Kailash by india

[@dibyaraj108]

Kailash - Mansoravar

[@MehulKamdar]

The Good General is always among the finest guests you have on your channel, Sri. And what he referred to (among a lot of points) about the Karakoram pass connecting Xinjiang to Ladakh, has a historical significance that has mostly been forgotten in India with the exception of a few individual academics - Prof Madhu Kishwar comes to mind. For centuries, the Uyghur rulers of Xinjiang paid obeisance to the Maharajas of Kashmir before the 18th century Chinese conquest of the province. In addition to the renaming of Tibetan territories, India needs to help it's historical allies in XInjiang with recognition beyond helping our people in Tibet. PS And, perhaps, you might consider inviting Prof Madhu Kishwar to your channel too? Both you and she have much in common...

[@prophetsj1180]

Hmmm ! Interesting. Good points. Well done.

[@biggpicture2930]

How xxan tibet gge part of india? They are yellow and india is blavvk?

[@AnkushDey1]

Great talk. Very insightful & assuring. Regds

[@vasudevatantri1880]

Indonesaian Prambanan Temple is bigger than Angkor wat temple Cambodia.

[@srinivasanvaradarajulu3556]

What’s P gurus call on singapore-China-India and singapore-USA-India and Singapore+Asean-china and India. Please do watch CNA how it covers India and how it covers China and the documentaries presented by CNA on India and China.

[@LeenaLal-h8x]

India must tell Tibet in Exile to open its embassy in New Delhi & in Europe.Illegally occupying Tibet since 1950's & changing Tibet's name doesn't make Tibet a part of China.

[@dineshgupta-ir9zi]

India should raise questions against debt trap diplomacy of China. India should offer a counter by offering ecomomically viable solutions in collaboration with the Western world.

[@sundarks2005]

The interview with Mr. Jagdeesh Shetty to understand what went wrong with BJP not performing as expected was extremely apropos. I was bewildered when at the overconfident statements from BJP before the election was getting to be too much. Now we can understand that the beraucrats were as incompetent as they always are when required to defend their position expressed. Also not following the established management procedures in BJP party affairs which has been exposed also by Sri Subramanian Swamy would have avoided lot of the problems in the minds of constituents. If they had followed their own principled position we would have come out well. I also understand that when they started looking into corruption problems they were so all pervasive that if exposed it would have destroyed the economic functioning of the country. Let’s hope that this will be taken up forthwith in the new term of Modi Government. Sundaresan

[@umakantgajjewar8898]

Instead of spending money on minority ministry, same funds must be used to raise more corps. PM Modi must drastically cut down on appeasement of peaceful minority.

[@rakadus]

Tibet as a buffer between India and China is like Ukraine as a buffer between NATO and Russia.

[@prophetsj1180]

52:50 Thailand also. Their names and language is Sanskrit Oriented. there's a Market in Bangkok called " Indra Pratika." Indians will notice a lot of Sanskrit scripts in Thai movies.

[@ramkurup48]

Can you comment on strengthening Japanese military ? They defeated China in the past.

[@madhurapatil5252]

Glad to hear news on Agniveer

[@ravigovindaraju5572]

There is talk og big game on Tibet but what about the resolve of Tibetans to get free?

[@alekhaprasaddas8663]

WHAT IS THE MENTAL CONDITION OF INDIAN VOTERS ?

[@vidyutmulki2807]

Las Islas Filipinas.

[@rajeshtanwar2445]

Iyer Sir thank you so much for hosting Gen.Ravi Shankar.Gen.Ravi Shankar possesses great knowledge i.e.first hand on strategic military and political affairs w.r.t.China and India as well as global geopolitical affairs. This is a very insightful and significant analysis..🎉🎉🎉

[@venkateshsubramaniam1386]

Does Chins have good military training and equipments

[@mervanwachha2209]

NO, ABSOLUTELY NO!

[@narendrasinghchauhan4829]

Respect to Both of you, Jai Hind, Jai Bharat ❤🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳🇨🇵

[@srinivasm3726]

@Sri Ji, Philipines was probably called Panyupayana the Sanskrit name.:)

[@meenakshikashinath8394]

Great session

[@perfopt9077]

Finally, a great guest

[@TiendaRutadelSol]

SIR, The old name of Philippines is Las Islas Filipinas.

[@dibyaraj108]

There must be a native name before european colonizers came to exploit.