Why do some rocket launches look like this?

Rocket launches always produce a spectacular display. However, every now and then, they create the Twilight Effect. In this video, we are going to look at some SpaceX launches that have recently caused the Twilight Phenomena, we are also going to look at what causes this effect and why it's so rare.
Thanks for watching this Primal Space video. If you enjoyed it, let me know in the comments below and don't forget to subscribe so you can see more videos like this!
References:
primalnebula.c...
Support Primal Space by becoming a Patron!
/ primalspace
Special thanks to these creators for their Twilight Effect footage!
Skyes9 - / skyes9
Jonathan Redman - / sneakytikiman
Jeremy Perez - / @beltofvenus
Tony Qin - / @tonyqin9481
Visual Burrito - / dopplerizer
Thom Parkin - / parkinthom
Twitter: / theprimalspace
Facebook: / theprimalspace
Music used in this video:
» Long Road Ahead B - Kevin MacLeod
» Oceans - Bobby Renz

[@chris-ke4jo]

What the falcon?

[@jackterjack4010]

Most know (flying) rocket

[@jeevashrutiramkumar7355]

Widely regarded as the world's most technologically advanced aerospace company. It's a business jet.

[@starfrost276]

90% sure it was a joke. . . talk about r/wooosh

[@swagorange8975]

Has no one ever heard of this or something

[@patman0250]

You can't be that dumb bro.

[@GuildOfCalamity]

LOL, "the world's about to end bro!"

[@odbytkonia1649]

I'm sure he meant the world we used to know, after SpaceEx launch it is no longer the same :)

[@theangrydweller1002]

“Dude I saw this in forte night

[@johnmaco]

Mindset of people who dont understand something ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

[@sdubbeld]

That guy was higher than the Falcon rocket

[@easygoing2479]

Sounds like he just learned of the 2020 election results.

[@kodyheskett7964]

What gets me is how it looks like a boat on water. Also how bright white almost like the heavens are opening.

[@saramelito2560]

It’s hitting the firmament. That’s why it looks that way

[@islandqueen3407]

Yesss hitting and scraping the firmament.!!!

[@fernandolozano9898]

@@saramelito2560 why doesn’t it happen every time then?

[@audrey_alane]

Because it curves before hitting it. I encourage you to find a full footage video of nasa sending a rocket into space form the rocket itself. I’m talking you see the sky turn from blue to black, and then be freely floating in space. It doesn’t happen. The closest thing is the red bull sky dive, and that’s a fish eye lens.

[@fernandolozano9898]

@@audrey_alane I actually don’t understand your message. Your first sentence doesn’t satisfy why the twilight effect would only happen sometimes. Unless you’d like to expand on that? And then the rest of the paragraph, I don’t understand. I’ve seen a few videos of launches, and I also understand why they don’t launch straight up.

[@Durrdalus]

Premieres leave content creators with significantly lower view numbers as alerts often don't go out for those who have them on and for those that view via sub feed the video has left their main view area.

[@_xenderr1]

I saw this in person. One last deliver for the day. It was unreal, everyone on the streets pulling over to observe, the job I was doing didn’t seem important. All sorts of people coming out on the streets to ask each other what the hell is that thing

[@michaelsw0rd]

I saw this in LA and it was the coolest thing ever. These videos don't show shit for how incredible it actually is in person!!!

[@ssabykoops]

ehh yea it does , looks awesome to me

[@mattcounts6851]

I agree, shit It blew my mind from Arizona....

[@peluchinpower]

Even the news next day said that the military said it was a testing of some sort when it wasnt even military lmao

[@saramelito2560]

Pictures never catch the actual beautiful

[@born_again111]

Hitting the waters above producing wake like a boat on a lake

[@Ethan_Roberts]

There are no waters above

[@RonnyCoalman]

Watch the video and learn about what actually happened or stay willfully ignorant but know that you choose to be stupid if you do.

[@NotHere2SellCookies]

I can't get enough of these firmament videos!

[@sectorrrrr]

it's rocket exhaust being illuminated by sunlight

[@santythehamster]

The ❤ 💀🙏🏿😭

[@AlejandroAdria]

​@@sectorrrrr I'd strongly suggest you learn the true science of God and our enclosed realm.

[@bettyGish]

I absolutely love this comment section! 😂!!! So many people actually understand what’s happening here instead of being stuck on that BS they pedal to us❤️ Love it

[@JamesOberg]

Just to make it clear -- are you saying the 'rocket explanation' is BS, or the 'UFO explanation'?

[@Ethan_Roberts]

More like so many ignorant morons that reject fact to keep believing nonsense

[@katstorm13]

@@JamesOberg well... considering that in another comment on this video they mention that recently they're starting to think flat earth theory might be true, I'm gonna guess the first one you said 🤣

[@TheExplosiveGuy]

​@@JamesOberg They're flat earthers dude, don't engage or you'll stoop to their stupidity.

[@BooBooYuk]

And whats is there to actually to understand here?

[@cgbreeki849]

Beautiful. Perfectly made video. Perfect lenght to explain the phenomenon, perfect editing, music, and writing about the beauty of spaceflight. That's the way to go man.

[@primalspace]

Thank you so much! So glad that you enjoyed it. It really means a lot!

[@NewWorldCloud]

This is the funniest explanation ever 😂 the "twighlight effect" hahahaha or there is a firmament and the rockets are skipping across it.

[@jonathansinkamba9355]

Psalm 19 verse 1

[@annabel8675]

The reason why they wont let you go to antartica is so you wont see the dome@AdventureChannel0

[@metaleirosincero6317]

aether

[@cokfordollie]

Wow a comment chain of 4 different types of crazies that's rare

[@jordonlongley6576]

A rocket would explode if it hit a wall of water or a hard shell

[@Delatta1961]

As a young boy living in Montclair, CA in the late 1960's I remember seeing rocket launches from Vandenberg AFB and they were terrifying. There was no internet, no warning on the news, just rumors. With the Cold War in full effect and a civil defense alert of some kind every week, the sight of this twilight launch by a 9 year old felt like something horrible was about to happen. Now, I see it as an absolutely amazing thing. Thanks Elon

[@JynxedKoma]

Have you seen our Lords and Saviors Richard Burnish and Steven Chilton in Montclair?

[@dbrathaman1137]

Firmament

[@pintdinkler7521]

You baphomet fan boy you!!!! Get back to sleep ffs

[@CyberUtilia]

@@dbrathaman1137 elaborate?

[@G4Y8u9]

Hahahahaha What the FALCON is this? Great one!

[@kevinheggs2679]

Had ha Yall thought it was a UFO.

[@imzayn]

WTF? = what the falcon?

[@CrazyFunnyCats]

@@imzayn Falcon Beach

[@bobbytailor]

@给虫Official It was the SpaceX Falcon 9 Rocket Launch from Vandenberg AFB on 10-7-18

[@mattiemathis9549]

I just watched the launch tonight. 6/18/24. I don’t know if what I just saw was what you are describing exactly, but it was the most amazing thing I’ve ever seen in my life. It was more blue and looked like what you described but there were no “bubbles” (I’m sorry I don’t remember what you called them). But everything else was just like you showed. I’m so glad I looked this up! Now I understand that this was even more special than I thought. Thank you!

[@spencodon5905]

They can't get through the firmament never had never will

[@SerUno29]

They’ll never break it

[@Ethan_Roberts]

There is no firmament to break

[@SMHman666]

​@@Ethan_Roberts It's quite sad that in this day where information is right at our fingertips, people happily choose to remain ignorant. Education and the ability to think is alien to them, I feel.

[@AlejandroAdria]

Amen 🙏

[@klloyd7]

So that's what happens when you reach the firmament.

[@antonycasanova4067]

THE TRUTH IS THAT THEY HIT THE DOME OF FLAT EARTH, WATERS ABOVE WATERS OF HEAVEN!!!!

[@viberstrike3773]

Have you ever seen a bottle rocket under ice...looks just like it!!

[@jensejnar2502]

ahh, a "good" education i see?

[@Gdonnald]

Aint it crazy I searched for Johnathan Redman (channel name) & this shit pops up first. It aint crazy. Its the big corporations algorithms, showing there propaganda first. Whatta fucking shame. Blue dot here research Flat earth everyone. But don't use Google...

[@test-rf8xr]

@@jensejnar2502 BIBLE

[@philipsmi-lenguyen8155]

They should always time the launches to make the twilight effect. Looks so cool

[@zorro456]

Not practical. You have to hit a predesignated orbit.

[@twocyclediesel1280]

@@zorro456No you don’t. It’s simply in the timing. A launch approximately 30 mins after sunset, or before sunrise, is all that is needed. The Earth is shrouded in darkness but the rocket reaches an altitude where it’s illuminated by the sun.

[@agapetus1]

Yeah! As long as timing of the launch isn’t important then they should always do it!

[@anzaklaynimation]

0:27 you can see the blocky jpg compression around the bright blue area. This is how KZbin saves the data when video is uploaded.

[@xtraguac]

I observed this in the sky over the south SF bay area this morning at approximately 630am and it blew my $%^^ing mind, man.

[@JamesOberg]

Date, please... and direction of the observation? Thanks!

[@xtraguac]

@@JamesOberg december 11th at around 630am. I have later learned that it was a launch from vandenberg space force base. I saw it from palo alto CA looking south.

[@JamesOberg]

@@xtraguac == Thanks! It's easy to see how it could freak people out who didn't understand what was happening. MISSILE FREAK-OUT IN CALIFORNIA [NOV 7, 2015] satobs.org/seesat_ref/misc/misperceiving_missiles.pdf

[@AlterWido]

looks like diving into the water

[@johnsmith23ist]

Water above the firmament

[@gentlespirit4]

@@johnsmith23ist Exactly

[@therealeyezic]

No it doesn't 🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️🤦‍♂️

[@annabel8675]

Genesis 1:6 And let there be a firmament dividing the waters from the waters

[@WhatismanwithoutGod]

​@therealeyezic Of course to you it wouldn't

[@mrtommypickles8635]

I came here to jump on the anti premiere train.

[@TomTM_ST]

Premiers suck but video doesn't

[@13_cmi]

Premiers are awesome

[@mrtommypickles8635]

@@13_cmi I can appreciate them when they're announced just a few hours in advanced, but when I get a premiere in my inbox for a few days from now it just feels like spam. "Oh look, here's a video you can't watch yet."

[@davidcostello5318]

@@mrtommypickles8635 lol anyway now if u no like I do are u aware.?

[@mauricedarden893]

Looks like a boat gliding across the ocean 🤫

[@ishallneverdie2445]

Genesis 1, the sky is a glass wall separating us from literal water & heaven there is no solar system nor galaxies

[@AnonyRekrap]

​@@ishallneverdie2445finally someone who believes it🙏🏻🙏🏻

[@AshtonRiley123]

@@ishallneverdie2445I couldn’t agree more with this comment💯🤝

[@santythehamster]

​@@ishallneverdie2445Someone has never used a telescope in their life...

[@ishallneverdie2445]

@@santythehamster Amen, google _"sonoluminescence"_ and then youtube the most powerful telescope zoom _"Nikon P1000 stars"_ and observe God's angels singing underwater inside the sky

[@halymenia_durvillei]

Saw this tonight over the sky in San Antonio, just after the sun went down. It was really beautiful. So nice to understand what it was, thank you for such a great video!

[@thelonemovistar2795]

I saw this while I was in california, I had no idea what it was at first. It looked incredible

[@baatitaoufik]

It's the dome. The rocket collapse with water in the sky

[@Ethan_Roberts]

There is no dome

[@SMHman666]

baatit.... Do you really believe that? How can there be water "in the sky"? What would keep it up there? Have a think about what you are saying. Does it really make sense?

[@baatitaoufik]

@@SMHman666 they tried before to break through the firmament but they failed. That's why space travel is impossible. Review the starfish prime and operation Dominic experiments when USA and USSR launched atomic rockets on sky to brake through but they failed.

[@SMHman666]

@@baatitaoufik I asked you some questions.......

[@baatitaoufik]

@@SMHman666 kzbin.info/www/bejne/b4ObamqqbayGj7Msi=KgmFWB3SCnlseBxl

[@str8choc]

; - 0 you might good at spinning senarios, but this was a direct hit of the firmament, period

[@saramelito2560]

Yes sir. But the majority of the people will not critically analyze what they are seeing and just believe what they are told.

[@str8choc]

@@saramelito2560 😊 your totally right, haha. But if they saw my '7 Rockets hitting the Done' they would agree 😊.Plus i shoot astrophotography and i can tell u for sure, that all of the so called Planets_Stars are less than 150 miles from earth. And im using my nikon p610 and nikon p900 😊

[@str8choc]

@@saramelito2560 man 0ver God 😀

[@saramelito2560]

@@str8choc you sent off 7 rockets? That’s amazing. Did you video it?

[@str8choc]

@@saramelito2560 🙄 dang, my bad Sara. I thought when i saw my name in the notifications? 😅 i thought it was something i had Posted, lol, oops to answer your question no i didnt video the 7 rockets hitting the Dome, these were NASA's rockets, 🤗. In fact, the image you have up? tell me what you think it is, 🤗 and i'll tell u next, k ? again sorry for missing your reply 🙁

[@kenjohnson1041]

I’d say the firmament was pierced.that blue looked like water and the puffs of “smoke” looks like the firmament is filling itself back in

[@Critteryanky]

Is this satirical? Or do you really believe in the firmament?

[@kenjohnson1041]

@@Critteryanky I do believe it’s there

[@raptorwhite6468]

​@@TheCrystalShip51 No need to write anyone, the explanation is simple - we're going to space and retarded braindeads aren't stopping us

[@gagoxff6611]

Eu acho que nada pode penetrá-lo. É o poder de Deus

[@1Waarheid]

It's not, although 'they' are trying it.

[@LITWITTY]

What gets me is how the one ripple made rings like it was up against something like it hit something and bounced off. Very weird to me

[@Ethan_Roberts]

That was due to the cold gas thrusters firing.

[@c.walk.6823]

That is exactly what happened. It hit the firmament, as described in Genesis chapter 1. The firmament is above this earth, and it is solid, like glass. A literal “glass ceiling”.

[@codywalton3698]

It hit the firmament, look into it. We don’t live where they say we do.

[@JL_Cascadia]

@@c.walk.6823 There is no firmament. Just stop with that utter nonsense. He explains in perfect detail what is happening. Go look at the installed camera views on the craft from the actual launch. It clearly shows it going onto space and the curvature of the earth. If it actually hit a dome it would come crashing down into pieces. Sorry but your goat herders that wrote genesis are wrong.

[@JL_Cascadia]

@@codywalton3698 did you not hear what he just explained or are your comprehension skills that bad. It didn't hit any firmament. That os just ridiculous. Like I told the last person, go look at the video footage from the camera attached to the rocket during takeoff and landing. It clearly goes into space and you can see the obvious curvature of the planet.

[@CarlosAM1]

Premiers suck. This video on the other hand, doesnt.

[@chriswhorror6658]

I seen so many of them trails here in Florida. It’s spectacular seeing them. You get this special feeling like your part of the mission.

[@IaintStoopid]

i keep seeing them on the beach here in florida too, it's beautiful

[@Hollyweed1]

I just discovered you and Im in awe of your attention to detail and your narration voice, pace and volume. This is such a premium quality stuff you're creating. Thank you!

[@PWEIcom]

Shame he didn't explain it like he said, but nice narration voice 🤷

[@nitropete5]

"What the falcon is this"! Lol good video

[@vintagethunderbirdrepair9426]

I grew up in the San Fernando Valley in Los Angeles California in the 60's and we would see the rocket launches from Vandenburg all the time and this was quite a common occurrence. It was not uncommon to see exactly what you pictured here. I guess today it is very uncommon because they don't have the frequency of launches they did in the 60's during the Gemini, Mercury, and Apollo programs.

[@ShannonWedgley]

Video links?

[@summerfarrell3291]

Lompoc

[@chriswesney]

I was on the base with my family during the launch of that Falcon-9 launch. It was a once in a lifetime experience. The twilight launch followed by the landing and sonic booms.

[@TBU2012]

So your are saying you with your very own eyes saw a space x rocket booster land? Not a video of the landing but the actual booster come down reverse it self and land?

[@michaelcalderon4523]

I live about 30 minutes north of the base. It blew me away when I saw it.

[@JamesOberg]

@@TBU2012 == "So your are saying you with your very own eyes saw a space x rocket booster land? " == Thousands of people have seen this in past few years, mostly at Cape Canaveral. What's your problem in believing it's the 'new normal' for Falcon-9 rockets?

[@magnetmountain33]

@@JamesOberg Try implausible physics and impossible logic not to mention the fact that Elon Musk cars have a habit of driving themselves onto the local error drome and then ramming a plane or two instead of simply parking in a space 10 foot away if Elon Musk could design a rocket that can go up and then spin around and come down Backwards and make a perfect landing yet Tesla owners are still waiting for a working self park system??? Space is a complete hoax and whatever is outside of that dome has a habit of blowing smoke rings of charged plasma through any holes that breach the blue oxygen solids When you start seeing that Red shit come through that’s when we really need to panic remember there are two colours in the bull’s-eye red and blue the blue is on the outside the Red is in the middle Just so happens to be a solid state oxygen That is bright red in colour and one more even denser which looks like metal like a hammered bracelet say So it looks like those cuneiform tablets will miss translated never made any sense that the God EA used pressurised hot water to breach the dome until recently! Tell you what find me a single sped up video of a comet that move is entirely on its own speed relative to the stars around it Comets are fixed holes in the firmament presumably just like every other star in the sky!!!

[@UriahGiles]

@@TBU2012 There is an area on the north side of Vandenberg called Point Sal State Beach Park and you can drive in there (at least you could 15yrs ago when I was there last) and get an awesome viewpoint of rockets launching from Vandenberg.

[@LeJimster]

Nice explanation, I hadn't thought about this. Fantastic.

[@Amezis]

Please do not use premieres. There are two reasons to avoid them: Firstly, you are just annoying your subscribers - we all get a notification for a new video, and then it turns out that there's nothing to watch. Secondly, premiered videos lead to fewer views than regular videos, so you'll lose out on a lot of views. Don't do premieres!

[@asasnat342]

shut up

[@marclapin]

@@asasnat342 u shut up

[@asasnat342]

@@marclapin no you shut up!!!!!!!!!

[@CarlosAM1]

@@CloroxBleach-ms7eo you are also being disrespectful tho...

[@CloroxBleach-ms7eo]

@@CarlosAM1 "yOu ArE aLsO bEiNg DiSrEsPeCtFuL tHo" says the nigga who plays minecraft

[@eightsixtrey2587]

This stuff kinds freaked me out when i saw it driving to work with my dad to work to Orlando. He woke me up and thought a space ship crash or exploded. Or even getting bombed. Since he's 61 years old, I'm sure it was crazy for him to see something like that in person

[@mattcounts6851]

Saw this in person from Arizona and it blew my effin mind..... That was one of the most crazy things I've ever seen( at the time, I didn't know what it was until 30 minutes later)

[@antonycasanova4067]

THE TRUTH IS THAT THEY HIT THE DOME OF FLAT EARTH, WATERS ABOVE WATERS OF HEAVEN!!!!

[@MarioKart7Fanatic]

We could see the launches all the way in Phoenix, AZ. Definitely thought aliens were coming for us haha

[@mattcounts6851]

Yeah I agree, I was at GCC and thought someone launched something from the college, I didn't realize what it was and that it was all the way in California until later.... Craziest thing I ever saw, that was it lol

[@DonCramon]

Thank you for explaining this phenomenon. Saw this a few years ago and i was convinced that the video wasn't fake. At that time i couldn't find an explanation for it. So thanks for clearing that up.

[@mushihimesarna728]

It's the firmament.

[@twocyclediesel1280]

@@dooomwake8759So a 230 ft long sheet metal tube traveling at 3000 mph, hits “glass” in the sky and doesn’t explode into a million pieces, huh? Not only is staying in school important friends, but also paying attention while you’re there! Also, let’s support more pay for our teachers. We can turn this ship around folks, it’s not too late!

[@devoid24]

Thanks for explaining that. appreciated.

[@M4DGremlin]

Riding the dome. "we cannot leave earth, we are stuck here" nasa quote.

[@Ethan_Roberts]

Source for that quote?

[@LordDeBahs]

@@Ethan_Roberts kzbin.info/www/bejne/iYeXcmeVaN12gLM

[@wolfie_studio1082]

To the person, whom is trying to direct the owner of said channel. This is their channel, they put in the said time, effort and dedication. Though we may not like a certain format, it is not for any of us to say anything about how to run said works. The video was very well edited, the content was direct and to the point. I just don't agree with trying to tell someone how to do something. Pemier or not I will continue to watch and support the content. Thank-You for your hard work. Love from Ohio

[@SweetassTea]

It's called crashing into the firmament.

[@lAlwaysHopel]

Because it hits the firmament

[@Ethan_Roberts]

There is no firmament

[@Ethan_Roberts]

@@GOD_AND_FLAT_EARTH_MUSIC_VIDEO prove its existence then

[@reggaerootz71]

Rraahh.. That's hitting the firmaments.Can't you see it bouncing off the water like that?See the ripples

[@gjl7022]

it's the reflection of the inside of the firmament before the rocket lands in the bermuda triangle with the rest of them.

[@Ethan_Roberts]

There is no firmament

[@Ethan_Roberts]

@@GOD_AND_FLAT_EARTH_MUSIC_VIDEO what triangle? Stop with the dumb conspiracies

[@cgdis_marc112]

2:35 ,,WHAT THE *FALCON* is this“ 😂 i looovee it

[@SMELLZ-ME]

THATS ALL WATER UP THERE , WHEN YOU ARE ON A AIRPLANE LOOKING DOWN THE OCEAN LOOKS JUST LIKE THE SKY”

[@qwwertyyuiopp]

go back to 3rd grade and learn about atmospheric scattering

[@OthoKARL]

This is the firmament

[@OthoKARL]

@@qwwertyyuioppshut up

[@RonnyCoalman]

​@@OthoKARLYou belong in a labourcamp for being willfully stupid

[@RonnyCoalman]

Its not. Watch the video and it will be explained to you.

[@bamm86]

I bet Musk launches them with the intent of producing that effect. It’s incredible marketing.

[@Anthony-he3yn]

Not!

[@havish530]

No

[@henrikledin4166]

No

[@jordonlongley6576]

You managed to piss off some people lmao

[@santythehamster]

↑ Weirdos (except the three of us ∆)

[@officialspock]

Everyone is complaining not to use premier and i have no idea what the falcon is premier

[@jellymop]

Yea what is it? I enjoyed this video. I’m not sure what people are complaining about

[@Soyong1]

A premier is like the un live version of a stream starting. The premier the video so it won’t be 360p when uploaded

[@blew1t]

@@Soyong1 its in 1080 p tho

[@enveloreal]

@@blew1t if you havent found out yet, the reason why it is 360p is because the video initially uploads at SD, then youtube processes it and it becomes HD. If you've ever uploaded a video you know this.

[@BlinkinFirefly]

I live in LA and have been seeing tons of rocket launches the whole year, always around twilight. I even saw a launch while on top of the roof at the Griffith Observatory one night. The trail it left was very rainbow-colored.

[@josephhubert7907]

Hopefully this video will be getting a whole lot more views here in January of 2023. Excellent video!

[@anakinskywalkerrr]

Dude, you're animation is so easy to understand. keep it up, I'll subscribe for that.

[@xGaLoSx]

With SpaceX launching almost weekly now, we'll hopefully see many more!

[@ahmadschannel6112]

You will Never see that again from SpaceX because they are not saying the trouth

[@saramelito2560]

Yes you will. They are spy satellites. Look into it closely.

[@paralaxae]

@@ahmadschannel6112 🤡🤡🤡🤡

[@ahmadschannel6112]

@@paralaxae 🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡

[@paralaxae]

@@ahmadschannel6112 you can see this xD

[@jnixon800]

Some people believe that they are trying to shot thru the dome

[@tomekkazmir7089]

That's exactly what spacex is trying to do.

[@mushihimesarna728]

That's what's happening.

[@paaat001]

When I was the Air Force at Vandenberg, we would notify the media and law enforcement of possible Twilight Phenomenon launches. Still, incredibly, we would get phone calls and see breathless reporting alluding to extraterrestrial sources of the effect. It was incredible to find so many low information people out there. One program on a "science" channel was promoting the effect as an opening wormhole on a nationally televised TV program.

[@JamesOberg]

Thanks for your service, Pat. I've been collecting popular misinterpretations of rocket launches since I retired from NASA-Houston. Can I show you links to some of the most spectacular public panics?

[@serjoschaerasmus5512]

Well i sorted it out kinda.😉 Just imagine that the bleu ice, that's only found in Antarctica, is frozen oxygen. Frozen oxigen and liquid are bleu. So what if the dome is made of frozen oxigen, through the warmth oof the sun and earth it's getting liquid, just before it's boiling point. Liquid oxigen has about the same density as water. But that's the way you can create water upsidedown. The bleu color also seem light up with bleu light

[@raczoscarable]

We cannot leave the earth! Get up up!

[@Yezpahr]

came here to copy the link cuz some people use rocket launches as UFO video material..... so tiring....

[@laurieeasley7836]

We experienced a beautiful example of this effect last night over the Arizona skies. Thank you for the explanation of what I saw!

[@infernosgaming8942]

that bit where you censored fuck with Falcon had my chuckling for at least a minute lol, good stuff man.

[@lumberc]

spacex as of recent has been doing most of their launches in the twilight period snd i love em for that

[@lazydoctorr]

I see these quite often, and it's not during sunset or sunrise. There's footage online as well, is there another reason why? I thought that the Earth's firmament was thicker, or something, and it causes that to occur when piercing through ?

[@Ethan_Roberts]

No, it's after sunset or before sunrise. There is no firmament

[@LeavingBabylon_]

It’s definitely the firmament. God created day (light) and night (darkness). It piercing the darkness of the firmament at night. Water gushing out and light piercing through.

[@CyberUtilia]

@@LeavingBabylon_ what's god?

[@danielbrausch5730]

It’s hitting the firmament

[@Ethan_Roberts]

There is no firmament

[@SDsc0rch]

great video - and great soundtrack (looking that up!)

[@Pune122]

Thanks for the video !

[@stephane-nicolassimon813]

This is the most beautiful fantastic fable like explanation î’ ve ever heard. I’ m flabbergasted...

[@SavageLeeGaming]

That’s the firmament not no rocket exhaust 😂

[@metaleirosincero6317]

its aether

[@furarior3698]

Its been 3 years, genuinely hope you grew out of being a retard

[@CyberUtilia]

@@metaleirosincero6317 your m

[@stevepeluso9385]

It’s hitting the firmament, curving on the dome!

[@Ethan_Roberts]

There is no firmament

[@1-9KOKO]

It banged into the Dome.

[@Ethan_Roberts]

What dome

[@qwwertyyuiopp]

conspiritards will believe anything

[@gumpreeengthegumpreeeng]

Area 51 conspiracies: aliens Some people: ASTEROID WE'RE ALL DOOMED spaceX: LoL launch look pretty(twilight)

[@FormsInSpace]

saw one of these a few weeks ago from nothern az. thought it was a comet/meteor entering the atmosphere.

[@aminch168]

dome made of water

[@Ethan_Roberts]

What dome?

[@aminch168]

the sky is made up of a water dome watch the rockets swim like motorboat@@Ethan_Roberts

[@Ethan_Roberts]

​@@aminch168no it isn't, quit the drugs as you're clearly hallucinating

[@qwwertyyuiopp]

@@aminch168 The only thing you've proven is your lack of intelligence

[@Wutzmename]

2017 effect I saw while in San Francisco. Everyone was a little nervous.

[@cn8299]

I remember the 2017 one and it blew my damn mind. I pulled over with 3-4 others at a parking lot and we thought it was aliens or some shit. Funny thing is that it really looked like it was coming down and towards us but in reality, it was moving up and away from us, it was very trippy.

[@mrdr1ggy]

it actually scraped the waters above(firmament) and his spending all its last energy rocket fuel to try breaching it - it never does so it scrapes itself downwards(further away) just like the sun "sets" downwards because the sun is actually moving inside the firmament but away from your country and your angle of view.

[@KevinMartinez-yp7md]

Yea 2017 was the first time they actually hit and didn’t blow up so it scraped I don’t remember a time where we would see anything like this happening in the past.

[@trirahmat5384]

​@@KevinMartinez-yp7md kzbin.info/www/bejne/hJ_Th32Bmduml5o Trident missile

[@twocyclediesel1280]

@@mrdr1ggyYes, sounds perfectly plausible; a 230 foot long sheet metal tube traveling at 3000 mph water skiing along a wall of water and not exploding into a million pieces. Thanks for displaying your complete lack of common sense to the rest of us.

[@mrdr1ggy]

@@twocyclediesel1280 well you can observe it here, and SPACE is bs so it is very plausible.

[@holipori]

虽然一直没看到什么中文评论，但是这个频道都在一直坚持做中文字幕，感激！

[@TommyJ]

Thank you Heavenly Father for the firmament. They are trying to escape their impending doom. We aren’t here to convince anyone but research “firmament” with an open heart and mind. God bless you all

[@Ethan_Roberts]

There is no firmament

[@Friedolays]

The waters above

[@ITubeYouK]

Looks like an impact with some electromagnetic field/aether/water firmament. Clear explanation to your Twilight Effect.

[@dogteam6178]

🤦‍♂️

[@gaurav386]

Looks just like it hit water look at the ripples

[@HarshVardhan-bx4pv]

Bro you explain it in a very excellent way . 👍👍

[@pakdolan]

Bro I LOVE your narration. So calm, clear and full of easy to understand facts. keep up the good job.

[@primalspace]

Thank you so much. It really means a lot that you're enjoying the content!

[@TheTrout26]

Yeah. Not digging the premier thing either. Love your vids though.

[@1994christos]

Its them hitting the firmament. Lol.

[@BoxingAndGod]

are you dumb

[@mrdr1ggy]

1:43 - no sir - it's hitting the waters above - the waters above can never be breached - that is why you see those crazy lights while the rocket is scraping under the waters ABOVE.

[@Ethan_Roberts]

There are no waters above

[@beerme27]

@@Ethan_Roberts have u even been to space? i mean very few people have in the world or so they claim. all we get are pictures and videos but that can easily been edited with green screen, photoshop, or other methods. you also have to keep in mind that the people are kept in dark about what kind of techonology they have in these secret underground bases in the world. they also hint to the firmament in movies and television. for example, in the 2007 simpsons movie they place a huge, glass dome over springfield. then there is a simpsons episode where homer is dreaming. he's playing baseball and hits a homerun. the ball hits the sky and it begins to crack like its made of glass. are they hinting at a firmament as mentioned in the bible? hilary clinton also hints to this in some of her speeches where she talks about the glass ceiling. hmm... its starting to get suspicious. just as God can use people so can satan who has decieved the world as it's written in the bible.

[@Ethan_Roberts]

@@beerme27 I haven't been to space but I do take pictures of it using my own telescopes. This includes the ISS and other satellites like Starlink. There's no denying spacecraft exist and orbit the earth when anybody can take their own photos of them showing exactly what they are. Clearly you've spent way too much time basement dwelling, watching TV and making absurd conclusions based off cartoons. The Simpsons also go to space in one episode therefore rendering your 'argument' invalid. Stop being so delusional.

[@emcgee911]

That is the firmament!!! How deep is this denial???

[@Ethan_Roberts]

Judging by your comment, the denial of reality is very deep.

[@tgstudio85]

Please do tell me Timmie, why that rocket didn't blow up when hitting this magical firmament?

[@damaniabdou2116]

i don't know why i can't belive that

[@BroughtTheSmoke]

Looks like water up there

[@KATY03160]

IT IS !! FIRMAMENT

[@twocyclediesel1280]

@@KATY03160So a sheet metal tube traveling at 3,000 mph, slams into a wall of water, ice, glass, whatever…and doesn’t explode into a million pieces? You haven’t thought this through, have you?

[@KATY03160]

@@twocyclediesel1280 Lol its plain to see !!

[@KATY03160]

@@twocyclediesel1280 it is as MOLTEN GLASS.. now,... ponder on that. Its biblical.

[@genesutton6383]

They sent a bunch of nukes up trying to bust it and get through. Operation fishbowl. Hince the glass ceiling.​@@KATY03160

[@LottiDotti76]

You should see that from Vandenberg itself. I was 3 miles away from the launch pad when that Falcon went up. I have some awesome video and pictures of it. The sonic boom from the landing 1st stage was amazing!

[@tetouani100]

Because of the water above

[@clarkkent3730]

The Egyptian astronomers always had a false explanation to explain away the supernatural miracles during Moses day as well

[@ytrebiLeurT]

It is submerged in water

[@yacineboudebouz4195]

After seeing this, i am now 100% sure that the earth is flat

[@Ethan_Roberts]

Why? Are you stupid?

[@SPACETVnet]

I really don't see the point of this. Premieres might be good for some types of videos, but for something like this I feel like I have to come here twice for no good reason.

[@MortyMortyMorty]

*STOP THIS PREMIER FEATURE! JUST STOP! (Or do it 1-2 hour before the video.)*

[@asasnat342]

he will be doing the premiere thing

[@marclapin]

@@asasnat342 how do u know that, are your the primal space super secret account ?

[@asasnat342]

@@marclapin shut up!

[@CarlosAM1]

@@asasnat342 inmature.

[@marclapin]

@@asasnat342 no u

[@thegarethdav]

It comes when the rocket hits the firmement and scrapes across it, spreading the smoke across it

[@therealeyezic]

You're stupid.

[@jasonl34]

They don't. Usually the end up flying horizontal then land somewhere. This one actually hit the firmament.......bounced slightly and hit it again. If you don't know what I'm talking about.....it's np.

[@Ethan_Roberts]

It went into orbit. There is no firmament

[@jasonl34]

@@Ethan_Roberts indoctrinated much.

[@Ethan_Roberts]

@@jasonl34 indoctrinated is what you people are. You deny reality in favour of ridiculous beliefs. Spacecraft launched by rockets can be seen in orbit which shows that the earth is not flat and these rockets don't crash into the mythical, nonexistent dome.

[@jasonl34]

@@Ethan_Roberts right, and over the years these "pictures" of the earth show the continents drastically changing in size. Use some common sense. With the information out there now the only way you can't see it .......is if you choose to too.

[@Ethan_Roberts]

@@jasonl34 ever heard of persective? If the camera is closer to the earth, the continents will appear larger than a camera further away. It's a basic concept also used in photography. How do you think they get those pictures too? Satellites, which can be seen and imaged at night so there no denying they're up there.

[@joeglover2070]

Man look they tried to break through the dome but couldn't that's what that was about if you look closely you can see the other rocket couldn't break through but the other one was going through water then it drop out of sight do your math

[@fuckednegativemind]

The dome?

[@theimperfectgod7140]

Ah yes... the *Dome* of our *flat earth* 🗿 Seems legit, i shall now proceed to put my tinfoil hat right about now so that the government can't track my thoughts or something.

[@antonycasanova4067]

YES, I KNOW: THE TRUTH IS THAT THEY HIT THE DOME OF FLAT EARTH, WATERS ABOVE WATERS OF HEAVEN!!!! BUT ON PURPOSE TO BREAK THROUGH THE DOME? DIRTY BASTARDS WHO DO THEY THINK THEY ARE?!?!