Why Does God Create People That He Knows Will Go to Hell?

[@mikeyhuerta63]

This exact unanswered question and the response he gave is the reason non Christians stray even further, they don’t get the question answered and on top they’re told to simply submit to him by using scare tactics such as hell, I’m a firm believer in Jesus Christ, but I’m not wrong about this statement. I’ve struggled with non believers when they hit me with this question, and I have no response for them

[@adrianofficialmusick]

The thing is not everything is answered in life, that's just how life is

[@gailhurst6255]

I asked jesus christ to save my soul

[@nuggets4357]

Good bro

[@nicholascarter6543]

Awesome! Praise God!!

[@fernandounda3681]

db**-This is a really bad apologetics video, it doesn't answer why God creates people that God knows will reject him. Is he forced to create all humans even the ones that go to hell. if not why not create only those who go to heaven? Free will is not a solution because in heaven we will have free will and there will be no sin please help.

[@jpatherton2415]

Video ends at 0:12

[@braxtonoertwig9191]

That's a great question, I mean why go through when the end result GOD already knows wear that person is going at the end of their life.

[@mlady8137]

😂😆 "I. Do. Not. Know. Sorry um laughing my head off because i came here for an in depth answer and was greeted with that.

[@hamoditahan4891]

he dosent know nobody can perfecly answer this wise qestion

[@bunnyofficial9704]

I used to ask this question myself but then I realized God isn't going to withhold the possibility of some going to Heaven for the sake of those who reject him and go to hell. Those who go to hell are doing so based on their own accord anyway so God isn't to blame. I found the parable of the wheat and the tares to be EXTREMELY helpful when answering this question. (Matthew 13:27-30) In summary of this parable Jesus is saying if you take away all the tares (unbelievers/ evil doers ) from the field you might uproot the wheat ( believers/ those who will come to Christ) with them. Both grow together and even those who choose to reject Christ still in some way play a role in those people lives who will come to Christ.

[@hussainiqbal9623]

Bunny,it appears you do not understand the point of the question brother. The question is basically why doesn't God prevent the person who is going to hell from being born? Why allow that person to be born if they are just going to suffer in hell?

[@joshuashakir2772]

@@hussainiqbal9623 by some unbelievers being born, their relationship to others will cause those ppl to go to Heaven and accept Jesus. If a murderer kills someone, another may think "now that I've seen death this close, I wonder where that person went!" This they search for Jesus and accept Him

[@hussainiqbal9623]

@@joshuashakir2772 Hello Joshua. I hope you are in good health. That again is not the point. The point here is that the person who is going to burn in hell could have been prevented from being born at all. By allowing this person to be born, God is allowing the person to suffer for eternity. We are not talking about a couple thousand years or something. We are talking about endless time. A billion years can pass and still this person will suffer. I personally am an ex-Muslim. I do not believe in God or any supernatural power. My question and point above is to illustrate to you how ridiculous the concept is of an all knowing being who allows people to suffer. Again, in case you did not understand: The point is that given that God knows a certain person will burn in eternity, God can just prevent their birth. It is such a simple thing for an all powerful being to do so.

[@joshuashakir2772]

@@Artixou you said "why does He need to?" He doesn't need to. He wants people to love with. If you had the power to create a world with anything you wanted, I imagine if your a young man like myself you'd prolly make a world with a bunch of women twerking on you 24/7, but God decided to make humans with free will. Whether you like it or not, some ppl would rather not love God and go to Hell, then obey His commands. He literally has 10 rules, and doesn't require a lot, unlike Allah or Brahma. Hell is separation from God, that's why it's tormenting. You people hate and don't want God, so Hell is the perfect gift for some of you, but at that point you will realize that God was with you just to give you strength in your body when you see that He'll is absent of peace, joy, pleasure, and everything that is like God. I also don't like the idea of people going to Hell, and no one deserves it, but we don't deserve Heaven either

[@hussainiqbal9623]

@@joshuashakir2772 Joshua, it appears you still do not understand the question. I will explain in a more detailed and loving manner. According to you, is God all knowing? Does he know in advance who is going to burn in hell? If yes, God can just prevent this individual from being born and just allow the heaven dwellers to be born. My issue with this is that God supposedly knows that this individual will be in eternal suffering, but is not doing anything to stop that. It is immoral and severely unjust. It is unethical to the highest degree. Secondly, you presumed about Cletus that if he was given God's abilities he would pursue physical pleasures. How do you know this? If I was given God's abilities or even a miniscule amount of them, I would use it to better the world. You are unnecessarily making assumptions about people. Third, You referenced the 10 commandments. Honestly, do you truly believe that this is the epitome of morality? Is there absolutely no way to make better laws than these? One can easily come up with more righteous rules or laws than the 10 commandments. What happened to not having slavery and racism? I just thought of all this at the top of my head. Replace observing the Sabbath with no slavery and it instantly becomes better. Which is more important according to you? Lastly, I hope for a civil and respectful response from you. I am not trying to offend you or something. I am just sharing my views.

[@martynas8804]

Gods hands to bloody i can't go with him

[@customvegandiet9491]

If God is 100% love, and is 100% good, he will never make people who are going to hell. So we are all going to heaven, or God is not 100% good, and 100% love. Also if hell really exist. Someone needed to create it. Lucifer created hell. When God was making Lucifer, he knew that Lucifer will create hell in future. God could create Lucifer who will never create hell. So God created Lucifer who will from God's perspective 100% sure create hell. So God created hell by creating Lucifer!

[@JoSh-ge4kc]

God created hell for Lucifer and and his minions After they rejected God

[@JoSh-ge4kc]

He doesn’t make people go to hell, people choose to go there by denying God.

[@customvegandiet9491]

@Jo Sh Oke God is omnipotent. God knows the future because He is omnipotent. God has 2 options: Option 1: God can create Lucifer who will become an evil angel, become the chief in hell, and there eternally torment human souls who do not keep God's commandments, without the possibility of returning to God. Option 2: God can create the good Lucifer (who will not become evil in the future). And no one will suffer in hell for all eternity. In fact, hell will not even exist. The fact is that all “evil people” only want pleasure for themselves, not for others. Why can’t almighty God create a universe where everyone gets pleasure, without the ability to go to hell? For a simple reason: Either he is not omnipotent (he does not know the future), or he is not infinite love (he created Lucifer whom he knew would become evil), or simply Christianity is not true

[@customvegandiet9491]

@@JoSh-ge4kc I first didn't answer on english, sorry

[@JoSh-ge4kc]

@@customvegandiet9491 it’s cool, and I honestly came across this video because I was asking the same question. I believe he knows the future, and I believe that he gave lucifer the option to continue to go against his will or to turn back to him and show humility and honor to God which could’ve been a sacrifice that God would’ve liked. I know that isn’t stated in the Bible but it makes sense because if we have the option to be forgiven, then why wouldn’t angels have that option to as well? I dont know if they were given that option. However, if they were, and if they denied that option then, it would make sense that there would be a place for them to be separated from God. Since God is love, joy, peace, happiness, merciful, etc. they wouldn’t have those things since those Characteristics are God. If that makes sense? Secondly, I understand wanting to have pleasures. I believe that God wants us to enjoy life, and everything about it. However, I do believe that he doesn’t allow us to do certain things for protection. Even though there are hundreds of commandments in the Bible, there were only meant to show how sinful we are (Romans 3:20 NLT.) Like I said before, it’s honestly about what we do with our free will, and giving up the “evil pleasures” of this world and building our relationship with him is all he wants from us. I don’t want to cause an argument or anything, but I hope this was understandable.

[@DaveBowman345]

If Calvinism is true, then I also wonder why God would allow people to exist whom He knows from eternity past are going to go to hell. Is this a heretical question for a Christian to ask? It's got me a little upset and disturbed.

[@jdoe7674]

The church would call it a heretical question but a true Bible believing Christian would say it’s a reasonable question and the answer is that all the eternal hell verses are mistranslations of the word aionios which means age lasting but Catholicism had to make god a scary monster so we would do whatever they said but in all reality YHWH loves us dearly and would never send us all the hell for eternity he saved us from death through Jesus Christ

[@janaimes4070]

Absolutely not heretical to ask. God will not be upset w u for asking ANY questions.....I feel like I have asked every one

[@heypodig6074]

I think there are two ways to create the human race. One is by creating every individual separately from clay with no relationship to each other.....in which there is no reproduction and no family....i don't know what kind creature it would become. So in that case God creates only those He foreknew they will be saved. Second is to create one man and one woman and let them fill the planet.....so in this case there will be reproduction and family. So for some people the reason shey must come to existence is because may be their children will be saved. For others may be their descendants after 20 generations will be saved. Despite this every one goes to hell or Heaven by choice and God do not want to force anyone against their will.

[@SerendipitousProvidence]

God could kill those who would end up in hell as a baby

[@customvegandiet9491]

@@SerendipitousProvidence Yes, and also: If God is 100% love, and is 100% good, he will never make people who are going to hell. So we are all going to heaven, or God is not 100% good, and 100% love. Also if hell really exist. Someone needed to create it. Lucifer created hell. When God was making Lucifer, he knew that Lucifer will create hell in future. God could create Lucifer who will never create hell. So God created Lucifer who will from God's perspective 100% sure create hell. So God created hell by creating Lucifer!

[@myballsitchsomethingfierce6319]

@@SerendipitousProvidence No child goes to Hell

[@mlady8137]

This answer helped me thank you

[@martynas8804]

Hi,Free will must be respected,like any creation.(Bad or good doesn't matter). However, I think there are no limits to God's cruelty towards creation. The strangest thing is that cruelty is not called a sin. Well, bearing in mind that God created hell and puts everyone there who does not obey his will, even though he gave us free will, this tells about his cruelty and hopelessness, jealousy, and we should not forget that god hands bloodier than anything he's created. He gave free will, which I think he does not respect, because only one path leads to life and happiness - this alone is a very big injustice directed against free will. Why didn't he make any effort for those who, before they were created, he knew that they were going to hell. He didn't create a separate world for us, he didn't even try, because of free will - to do something right. Joshua is a perfectionist and he wants a family that will come to him of their own free will - the selfishness and lack of respect for free will in this place is crystal clear. I cannot go to such a god. It would be unfair to other personalities who ended up in hell as a role model through their stupidity. But his "good" plan is not so good in my opinion, when over 80% of humanity ends up in hell after death. Considering he knew it, it's just a disaster. I cannot go to serve such injustice, which still calls itself justice. It is not for nothing that people in heaven will not remember their loved ones who went to hell, because it is unethical. And for her, we are talking about justice - because this is what I really want (I don't want love, happiness, or communication with God - but real justice. I think this is possible only when this god is destroyed, not overthrown from the throne but specifically destroyed. As an example you brought me into existence I will erase you from it. Only then will we end the suffering.

[@fernandounda3681]

b**-This is a really bad apologetics video, it doesn't answer why God creates people that God knows will reject him. Is he forced to create all humans even the ones that go to hell. if not why not create only those who go to heaven? Free will is not a solution because in heaven we will have free will and there will be no sin please help.

[@craigkelly4278]

No where in bible does it say Jesus ever went to hell or entered Hell he suffered real pain and death on the cross.

[@bigfreedom9998]

Well where did he go to pay and atone for the sins of mankind?

[@craigkelly4278]

@@bigfreedom9998 he suffered for it physically on the Cross See Isaiah 53:3-5 you really think that he entered hell to to torment lost souls nowhere in the bible does it say you get a 2nd chance in hell He was put to death in the flesh and rised by God in the spirit

[@myballsitchsomethingfierce6319]

He drunk from the cup of God's wraith which is poured out on sinners. The physical pain of the cross is beyond compare but the emotional pain of separation from God, a feeling Jesus never experience before was even worse. Many Christians don't comprehend what Jesus endured but soon enough we will.

[@Debertan1998]

So does he talk about hell as a place or hell as suffering as a result of living a large negative life?

[@craigkelly4278]

@@Debertan1998 it is the result of largely living a life not believing in God and largely living a life of selfishness and giving over to your negative desires for harmful things

[@katkuch7496]

GOD dose not send us to hell! WE send ourselfs!!

[@fernandounda3681]

df**-This is a really bad apologetics video, it doesn't answer why God creates people that God knows will reject him. Is he forced to create all humans even the ones that go to hell. if not why not create only those who go to heaven? Free will is not a solution because in heaven we will have free will and there will be no sin please help.

[@anotherway6427]

This is like saying God creates the ocean knowing that some people are incapable of ever swimming or floating and getting mad when we drown.

[@haitaelpastor976]

There are people who are physically and mentally incapable of choosing. Take Richard Trenton Chase, the "Vampire of Sacramento". He was BORN a paranoid schizophrenic and suffered from Cotard's Syndrome. He was totally incapable of choosing between good and evil. While this does not disprove the existence of God, for sure makes it hard to believe he's all love and goodness and it's just our choice to be so, that is us and only us who send ourselves to Hell.

[@truthseeker3187]

According to Indian path god didn't create the soul ..we were ever existing... and there is no eternal hell in Indian path:)

[@andrealeduc8551]

Hinduism does't have a living God, they all died. Jesus is alive. Ill take the livings Gods word over every other one, especially since he said "I am the way, the truth, and the life" no one else in any other religion has made that claim.

[@truthseeker3187]

@@andrealeduc8551 what's with living and non living thing ? God can manifest .. we can never deny that .. God is limitless .. Not just jesus every religion has a path and claims to be true and has a life to the path .. god is inclusive:) .

[@truthseeker3187]

@Joseph well if that makes you happy you are free to assume so.. its your mind ..if you create hell mentally then it's going to affect you only not me.. I know god is not cruel to put someone into eternal hell . If you feel like that then its upto you .

[@Debertan1998]

@@truthseeker3187 i agree. I'm starting to think maybe the world was created with good and bad for a reason because it helps us understand what God's love is truly about. I dont think hell exist. I think we all go to heaven but maybe when someone dies early and hasnt fulfilled their purpose, they might get reincarnated until they understand their true purpose in life before they are welcomed to heaven with God since he wants everyone to join him in heaven. That's a true loving God i believe that exist.

[@fernandounda3681]

@@Debertan1998 **-This is a really bad apologetics video, it doesn't answer why God creates people that God knows will reject him. Is he forced to create all humans even the ones that go to hell. if not why not create only those who go to heaven? Free will is not a solution because in heaven we will have free will and there will be no sin please help.adf