Why don't perpetual motion machines ever work? - Netta Schramm

[@TEDEd]

Thanks for watching! If you want to learn more about feats of engineering, wacky creatures, hidden historical figures, weird body questions you don’t want ask aloud, brain-busting riddles (and *so much* more!) make sure to subscribe to our channel ➡️ bit.ly/TEDEdSubscribe Stay tuned and stay curious!

[@Frinxxy]

You a couple years late

[@sianlol]

Your 4 years late

[@confused4971]

Only around half a decade later, no biggie

[@daniel4647]

Don't we sort of have perpetual motion though? Superfluidity has no friction so if you stir it it'll keep spinning forever. Don't know is that breaks any of the physics laws or whatever, but from what I read it'll never stop, and they can definitely be created.

[@coiners9426]

yes

[@jibifufu3540]

Me trying to charge my power bank with itself

[@DieBubbiesPlays]

Lmao

[@terateak6903]

IQ 100

[@dalefausto3383]

Me too lol

[@ambilir2925]

Me same

[@arnoldfandel1918]

Which equals keeping it disconnected lmao

[@JackSmith331]

"The only perpetual thing is our never-ending search" So the perpetual motion machine... was inside us all along?

[@michalviktorin6758]

Not inside us. More like absolutely everywhere, since energy itself is never ending motion.

[@amalabishek4463]

Exactly

[@trentyoung6791]

Philosphy

[@eliozagreus]

Or maybe we'll disappear from the face of the universe in a few years and we'll have to go on searching even if we'll not be able to do that🤔

[@corvidmorgue]

mabye the *real* perpetual motion machine was the friends we made along the way

[@mclovin2408]

Damn, the devs didn’t leave any bugs or glitches in this game.

[@williamsmith6921]

No there are many, this just happens to be an exception

[@NetheriteMiner]

@@williamsmith6921 Agreed, for example, deja vú (or however you accent it)

[@williamsmith6921]

@@NetheriteMiner or quantum mechanics

[@kakyoindonut3213]

@@williamsmith6921 is quantum mechanic a bug?

[@williamsmith6921]

@@kakyoindonut3213 I mean it kindof depends on how you define it, it's not like we know the developers of the universe, or even know they exist, so it's not like we can ask them what is a bug and what is a feature, but these parts of our universe are definitely strange

[@blue-1079]

The real perpetual motion machine was the journey we made along the way.

[@ReySchultz121]

This turned into an anime real quick

[@JoShuaQXV]

HAHA

[@Pochonesian]

Evehtualy the journey will end as well.

[@sataorikarganaka4818]

@@Pochonesian both nihilistic and realistic

[@bantehayes9973]

And the real treasure was our friendship.

[@alexniggins1799]

Humans: Why don't perpetual motion machines ever work? Friction: *Laughs in Heat*

[@VisualJoey]

This made my day lol

[@phamdunk3345]

Friction: *F R I C K*

[@jinwu7788]

@@phamdunk3345 Fric*

[@timothyshannon5187]

Friction! Hah! That's gonna rub some people the wrong way! "So...you're saying that resistance will cause things to lose velocity?" You're getting warmer! I tried to come up with a third friction joke but that's all I got.

[@reidb9422]

Gregory Sullivan are you refuting that friction due to air molecules is a real thing?

[@iambatman2303]

Why don't we just get rid of these laws of thermodynamics, seems like a simple solution.

[@mashrafialam682]

I love this comment

[@yt.rebeloutionkael5490]

Genius!

[@WilbertLek]

Just change the gravitational constant of the universe. Simple...

[@joseph-mariopelerin7028]

Ya... let’s gather all the Greek in the same room and make them change their own laws

[@wellshit9489]

@@WilbertLek hey the gravitational constant might be wrong on a quantum level so you never know

[@sleepyysleep]

Humans: *gets idea that sounds reasonable and easy to make* Physics: lol no

[@leosolis3214]

Hahahahahaha

[@adolforosado]

physics is wrong

[@timmyturner6575]

Okay what about that capillary action thing with that goo that if a little bit spills the entire thing spills with it. I don't remember what it's called but its blue and looks slimy and I'm sure some fellow nerds know what I'm talking about. Lmk how it goes.

[@nutmeggaming11261]

Action lab did that experiment. Didn’t go so well

[@darkdragonx2911]

I'm not liking this comment because it already has 777 likes

[@ahG7na4]

another (and simpler) way to look at the overbalanced wheel is that while those weights that stick out should be turning the wheel, there's also fewer of them than of the weights on the other side that don't stick out

[@VidhanShrivastava-iu2xx]

If the weight on the other side will be larger how can they even rotate.

[@Puskar3K]

​@@VidhanShrivastava-iu2xx inertia

[@VidhanShrivastava-iu2xx]

@@Puskar3K but doesn't it will break symmetry and eventually stop??

[@Puskar3K]

@@VidhanShrivastava-iu2xx I didn't quiet get what you said but I think my answer to your qsn is yes.

[@TheRishabhkumar]

The animators of TED Ed should be given an award..

[@matthewneubeck4421]

Rishabh Kumar ain't that tee truth

[@EyesofMangekyou]

Rishabh Kumar I think you shouldnt compare adventure time with this animation as it were good. Just average Joe animation here. Y'all lack taste.

[@EXHellfire]

edgy

[@CHRISTCHURCHUNITEDFC]

Rishabh Kumar I

[@mikefutcher]

You're not comparing like with like. Most TED Ed vids are created by a single animator who also storyboards, designs and interprets, rather than a cog in a huge machine.

[@jrkws]

"For now, the one thing that seems truly perpetual is our search." Just put the perpetual searchers on a treadmill.

[@jaredtandle2596]

Connect that to a generator and we could have enough energy to make one, tell them.

[@soldiergaming-n4b]

@@jaredtandle2596 but then they'd stop searching and won't make energy, machine will then stop

[@markthurst9751]

And when they die, soylent green for everyone!

[@rhabeldibabeldi6812]

@@soldiergaming-n4b what if we dont tell them which machine they are strapped to? Or we tell them its a perpetual machine searching machine

[@Meeeeeeeeeeeeeeee]

your pfp gives me chill. Edit: why did you change it :/

[@anibaldk]

"As long as you live under my roof, you're gonna live by my rules" - Thermodynamics.

[@anibaldk]

@synchromorph Somebody took the red pill

[@MarkusAxunIllianus]

The Simpsons did it

[@hitkid2456]

If only it would be kind enough to let us be able to go outside that.

[@Someone-ll1rc]

Me:Then I’ll move out Thermodynamics: that’s called death.

[@anibaldk]

@matthe ai Really!? I didn't know Satan was Dutch!

[@timothybradek3560]

What... ? Here I am at 70 f__ yrs old and never really knew that! Their art, design and engineering is truly jaw dropping.

[@Ragzzy-R]

The most difficult part of building a free energy device is figuring out the complex Engineering in how to hide the battery.

[@ZaPpaul]

This did give me a chuckle. Thanks.

[@Landoftheignorant]

The difficult part is not getting murdered for the ideas.

[@TheRenwickp]

i think if it has a battery and generates its own power forever its a good build

[@Acehamster]

@@TheRenwickp true but forever hasn’t happened yet

[@ohelio2766]

@@Acehamster forever will never happen 😊

[@chanralewis]

Lol it worked before it got patched in universe v0.013

[@girieditx]

Underrated

[@Seedx]

lel

[@hassanahmadi4882]

this comment deserves more credit

[@JB-to2nz]

don't forget, there's always the One

[@mariafe7050]

How do you patch the universe?

[@nut2964]

*“in this house we follow the laws of thermodynamics!”*

[@henrybusse7513]

Pfft, follow the laws of thermodynamics? What a nerd!

[@julianverdugo5957]

If you say so Homer

[@lionelhuts875]

*Obey. I sure hope you get fired for that blunder.

[@garygrim9235]

Make me

[@mkechandler5776]

Well then your house is probably extinct by now so it's all good

[@kylew2165]

I've been asking myself this forever. It never ends.

[@donatedflea]

Your Neverending thoughts on it are a perpetual motion machine

[@prashantsamaiya1793]

"There is just one problem: THEY DON'T WORK." such a small problem.

[@johneygd]

I really really hate when he just says that.

[@ilovecairns5181]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/oqXNg6KEqLWBr5Y&feature=share

[@psilocybemusashi]

so many successful hucksters out there this really is a small problem in practice. can't wait to have myself injected with the covid vaccine for a disease that hasn't killed anyone and there is no gold standard test for.

[@carlosvasquez6054]

@@psilocybemusashi I know people that have died from it stop spewing your conspiracy theories

[@dari9345]

@@psilocybemusashi Jeez dude, go out and get sick if you think it ain't real, because right now, me and my family are indeed sick, it's a real thing, thanks to my aunt, now I'm afraid, since it puts in danger my family.

[@1polyron1]

"The one thing that seems truly perpetual, is our search." I felt that

[@j2csharp]

And that perpetual search is exactly why we'll find the solution. We don't quit! :)

[@ishaanmurarka9082]

@@j2csharp There is no solution. Because there is no problem. They are two sides of the ever moving same coin. Exactly same things divided into problem and solution by us for our entertainment.

[@TelepathShield]

Me too

[@1polyron1]

@@ishaanmurarka9082 I love these types of philosophical debates

[@phatrickmoore]

Ted Ed is just the best.

[@muffincrumbss]

Humans: Can I? Physics: No.

[@BerryAB]

Wtf lol 😂

[@Mike-uv8sy]

live interview with physics itself

[@ardiansyahputra03]

I hate you, Physics

[@jxp7555]

TechnoWimp ask physics we can find a way a new way make one, one that can change the world as we know maybe on a different planet

[@walexia]

seeing as we still know so little , the most appropriate answer would be : "not like that"

[@SunbleachedAngel]

A few other things: 1) If a closed system could produce more energy than it consumes, then it would just infinitely accelerate until it.. explodes or something? 2) There is no way to actually prove that a machine would never stop, the same as there is no way to check beforehand if a computer program would loop forever or stop at some point (Tom Scott made a very good video about that)

[@henriqueferreirao559]

"perpetual motion doesn't exist" redstone: am i a joke to you

[@todabsolute]

Fully underrated

[@aretard7995]

RCT2 Corkscrew: Am I a joke to you?

[@metallabx407]

Fun fact: redstone uses real electricity.

[@Snugglelol]

Red stone is technically powered by ur computer

[@jonlincoln5133]

It does our solar system is one, but we are a bionary system witch means, two stars or suns pushing off the other keeping both systems running at same time

[@vkze]

"Lisa......in this house we follow the laws of thermodynamics!"

[@tuketound7944]

"YOU CAN'T TELL ME WHAT TO DO" starts making 10 more perpetual motion machines

[@benjackhenry]

Obey the laws, not follow!

[@t0mtom49]

But mom!

[@benjackhenry]

@@t0mtom49 oh my god does anyone watch the Simpsons?? First off it's Homer second Lisa doesn't say anything in response!! What is happening?!?!

[@francesco_fd_2212]

Stonecutters everywhere

[@whiiffed]

Law #1: You can't get out more energy than you put in Law #2: *No*

[@coolelectronics1759]

but what about stepup transformer but that only changes the voltage Im probably just wasting my time commenting

[@cherrysatin730]

I don’t know why I laughed so hard at this

[@TunaBear64]

Law #2: You will get as many energy than you put in but only a fraction will be usable

[@magosexploratoradeon6409]

@@coolelectronics1759 The power is still the same in a transformer. You just increased the voltage while lowering its current.

[@lebronjames4705]

what happens when you split an atom with one tiny process to cause an explosion large enough to wipe out of town. Technically an atom bomb is less heat and energy before it separates the atom to create exponentially more energy with the help of nuclear fusion

[@Aerational]

I feel like this is one of those things humanity really shouldn't give up on.

[@angelcano4567]

But it really isn't possible, and even if it was somehow done, there would be no real use. Like he said in the video, the most it would ever be able to do is just run itself forever, with no energy left for anything else

[@NGOANHKHOIA-]

If we could make a perpetual motion machine with >100% efficiency then we could do a LOT of things.@@angelcano4567

[@IrisWasTaken1]

Why?

[@un_tip_obisnuit]

​@@angelcano4567 a self powered lightbulb would be kinda useful

[@radianzero]

Bhaskara: *Creates Idea of perpetuarl motion machine* Newton after creating Thermodynamics: "Sorry, we patched it."

[@mariafe7050]

He didn't create it he discovered it

[@micheal5117]

@@mariafe7050 the joke

[@nachomartinez4758]

Thermodynamics were described many years after Newton died. He had nothing to do with it. Newton did not even used nor understand the term "energy".

[@chocofrolik834]

@@mariafe7050 r/woooosh

[@Movie2Documentary]

salty

[@NPCrash]

1st law of thermodynamics: We don't talk about thermodynamics.

[@fortnitegaming4187]

tyler deez nuts was never real

[@nachiket7565]

2nd law of thermodynamics : WE DON'T *TALK* ABOUT THERMODYNAMICS..

[@doublehit9165]

1rst law of thermodinamics: Cold does not exist 2nd law of thermodinamics: hot air will go up adn swirl, radiant heat will go all around 3rd law of thermodinamics: we dont know all kind of energy so changing one into another will cause part of it to become something unexpected

[@Papa_Reecio]

Great minds think alike!

[@Zamu273]

It's funny because the guy who discovered it AND his assistant commited suicide

[@Leyla-dx3su]

I was in an interview for a really elite school and they showed me a picture of a perpetual motion machine and I knew what it was thanks to this video, I’m pretty sure the only reason I got in was because of this. Thanks so much!

[@CC-hx8gj]

Leyla Banana wow

[@GandalfTheSilver]

They accepted you because of their affirmative action policies.

[@michaelparker9435]

@@GandalfTheSilver lol gottem

[@michaelparker9435]

nope

[@billygoat5765]

Elite kindergarden

[@nosleep9494]

“The only thing that is truly perpetual is our search” is fr a hard line. Cause at the same time I feel like we are gonna become energy ourself in the future.

[@danielordonez7760]

I really liked that like too

[@burgerbun2207]

Me: *Connects an extension cord to itself* Physics: Hehe I’m in trouble

[@monal9918]

get this man a nobel prize

[@yourmum3479]

i am weird i am weirdo r/woooosh

[@canuckeraust]

Me: I like memes xXSlurpJuiceXx: *chuckles* I’m in danger

[@atharvabendre973]

xXSlurpJuiceXx Internal resistance of the wire: *Am I a joke to you?*

[@animationfreak6552]

this is a good video.just saying guy's.

[@Isagiyoichi7K]

Imagine if Newton hadn't invented the laws of thermodynamics

[@esquire981]

waiting for an r/woooosh comment

[@wave8447]

SsanzZ r/woooosh

[@107_javidmuhammad3]

Lmfaoo....Newton didn't discover laws of thermodynamics tho... People like carnot, kelvin etc., Did.

[@CM-dx6xu]

this needs more like

[@ПавелСамойлов-с4б]

Well, they're false so he technically did invent them

[@ezucra]

Me who has made insane theories: *hmm what if....* Rules of physics: *no just stop*

[@imfunaplaymahgames8880]

Mev Cilbox Rules of physics: everyone/everything must follow the rules. Super liquid helium: Step aside.

[@stixinst5791]

@@imfunaplaymahgames8880 or neutron matter

[@imfunaplaymahgames8880]

Connor Toriello 😱 THATS GENIUS! 😱

[@Ryan-d3j]

5:03 Bro roasted all of humanity with one line

[@Snakethug-k6u]

How

[@parzival8786]

"No machine is 100% efficient because energy is lost as heat" Sad electric heater noises

[@GIRGHGH]

In that case energy would still be lost through sound and air friction, so it still can't.

[@lyger_playz]

@@GIRGHGH Sad electric heater which plays music and act like a lamp noises

[@ptrinch]

I'd like to know why my electric heater claims to be 100% efficient, yet somehow manages to power the LED display.

[@parzival8786]

@@GIRGHGH r/woooosh

[@GIRGHGH]

Stating why your joke doesn't work doesn't mean I didn't understand what you were trying to say. Don't be a poor sport.

[@kacper8435]

This glitch was patched in the V.01.2 Update

[@Megasterik]

r/outside

[@Megasterik]

@@ThumbsTup Have you ever questioned the nature of your reality?

[@shemidreamer8701]

R/whoosh

[@ノヨイチ]

@@Megasterik The matrix has you...

[@Megasterik]

@@ノヨイチ Yes.

[@makutamon]

I once saw this in a Dilbert Comic: Dilbert: I’m obsessed with creating a perpetual motion device. Most scientists say it can’t be done, but I have one thing they don’t have. Dogbert: A lot of spare time? Dilbert: Exactly.

[@SkySilverKnight]

i love dilbert

[@whothefrickareyou8106]

5:03 "the one thing that seems truly prepertial is our search." *THE SOLUTION LITERALLY ON THE SCREEN*

[@josephrennocks8098]

Actually the first law of Thermodynamics is don't talk about Thermodynamics.

[@Shiny100L]

Sepy Thirteen but since so many people seem to know of thermodynamics I figure that law has been broken

[@ethan6223]

Sepy Thirteen nice pfp

[@josephrennocks8098]

You're kicked out of Thermodynamics club

[@ImAmalox]

Sepy Thirteen Hey that’s Mumbo’s profile pic

[@andregon4366]

What is the 34th law?

[@DlSASTERCHlLD]

Perpetual motion machinery has always interested me, not because I think it's worth pursuing in particular, but because the field is a breeding ground for thoughts about how to overcome energy loss to the extremes. I don't want a perpetual energy source, I want to see a piece of machinery that is so efficient that ones interaction with could be so intuitive and low frequency that practically anyone and their dog could use them to make energy, in the future.

[@timelessadventurer]

Yes! I agree with your statement!

[@pizzaman9859]

Oh yeah, it’s big brain time.

[@rennsoy]

Omaayghadd, I'm thinking the same thing. For years now.

[@graves5371]

Solar panels, all you need is the Sunlight and a battery

[@CMogula]

congratulations you just invent what called as "gears" a complex gear could manipulate small energy collectively overtime into task that needs big and quick energy in other terms delaying powers needed into small but continuous cycle

[@brodyelliott6181]

Ever heard of something called an infinite red stone source?

[@deivisony]

This man right here is a geniud

[@chaosakazero]

Sounds like a philosophers stone and I wouldn't call those infinite

[@AWSMcube]

@@thedude___dude4399 Take a quick look at your username

[@greasypablo1315]

@@thedude___dude4399 your username makes me think that you secretly play minecraft.

[@kisuke80]

Color itself is infinite but not with stone until the universe exists the colors will remain but not the stone heard of it but is half right and half wrong

[@Gen-X-Memories]

Such a simple yet fascinating video.

[@caschew]

".. one thing that's truly perpetual is our search." what a great ending !

[@Zex-4729]

that is bullshit, human will extinct anyway.

[@horrorpill]

Robots will find the way to create it.

[@serektaibah4091]

well technicly our searsh is powered by the sun eenergy cz without it we wont get food to get energy to searsh

[@jvcmarc]

Casper Chew spoiler alert

[@Despotic_Waffle]

Casper Chew SPOILERS

[@jeffminder4067]

if I scratch my dogs belly in the right spot his foot will start to scratch the air. if I keep scratching his foot will get closer and closer to the spot on his belly until he starts scratching there himself. I remove my hand and he continues to scratch the spot that makes him have to scratch. BOOM: perpetual motion machine.

[@GoogleHelpYou]

Jeff Minder But you need to feed your dog

[@nathancraig4710]

Quick somebody get this man a Nobel Prize

[@maximoooooooo8os]

Genius.

[@temptation6006]

Jeff Minder your dog would get tired

[@Mike-uv8sy]

10/10 Issac newton would read again

[@d0da719]

I broke the laws of thermodynamics..... Now I'm in physics jail.

[@arandomseal4793]

Zed YT how long until you get out

[@f1rebreather123]

Meme Goose forever

[@khiemhoang419]

f1rebreather123 you mean perpetual

[@mayankraj2294]

@@f1rebreather123 why is your name f1rebreather lol.?

[@marianskodowski8337]

Some physics policeman arrested you? "You have to pay us for energy!" Even if it is free like an air to breath. But listen.. the boss of Nestle said that the water, say from rain, should be taxed. They are crazy.

[@zboy365]

Love how to the point these videos are

[@RandomPerson-kf6qm]

“Oh look a self watering bowl of infinite energy!” Gravity : *Thats cute*

[@brucemiller1696]

What happens if you take gravity out of the equation of some of the machines?

[@bobamsd5559]

@@brucemiller1696 if you did, it would theoretically be wrong as gravity always acts on the machines.

[@brucemiller1696]

@@bobamsd5559 not in space.

[@bobamsd5559]

@@brucemiller1696 yeah I was talking about earth

[@christianmohammed3728]

@@brucemiller1696 gravity occurs with everything, you exert gravity on something but it's just miniscule compared to earth.

[@littlecreature1328]

Ted ed: Perpetual Motion machines never work Minecraft redstone: Im about to end this mans whole career

[@lucadascalu5727]

*laughs in flying machine*

[@nickwilson3499]

j a it’s funny because if you think about it, a button or a lever is literally infinite energy.

[@garettjohnson2234]

@@nickwilson3499 a button is temporary, a lever lasts for as long as it's on

[@lucapowell5502]

If you consider the "Redstone System" as the code running in your computer's processor/s and being stored in memory, then the system is in fact drawing power from an external source. Interesting to think that the redstone's "energy" is just virtual - virtually infinite - though still limited by the physical energy which you can give to your computer.

[@littlecreature1328]

@@lucapowell5502 god, why you gotta ruin everything (jk)

[@adolynx]

That last statement is deep.

[@katowo6521]

It's so deep, adele wants to roll in it

[@ragnaroksora8129]

very deep

[@blueshanks1]

Ignatius talking balls deep?

[@groznyentertainment]

they show the planet earth spinning in the last statment , and they overlook the fact the orbiting planets are perpetual in motion

[@briandiehl9257]

That is not perpetual motion

[@hailegabriel5771]

Human: We will make PERPETUAL MOTION. Universe: No Human: Why? Universe: Just suffer.

[@acrsclspdrcls1365]

The Universe is a cold and cruel mistress.

[@WomenCoalition]

@@acrsclspdrcls1365 YES They don't care you and you should not giving F on it

[@Kuiinedits]

Acrsicles Pedrcles yet it seems possibilities are endless

[@FhargaZ]

Universe: i hate you now.

[@BillAnt]

"In Soviet Russia..." ok enough of that sh*t already! ha-ha

[@jsbaldo5556]

I always pictured Perpetual motion machines as God checking his first draft and then saying Ooooh yeah gotta patch this one, that could get crazy lol

[@sirisaacclarke4964]

Would be interesting to read all the patch notes throughout our history 😂

[@bigstronkbee]

@@sirisaacclarke4964 🤔👍

[@joey7107]

@@ten3195 guess God just abit lazy on patching that one, leaving earth a it is for hundreds of year ( its a joke )

[@knuxuki1013]

Lol

[@Samuel-qc7kg]

@@ten3195 How are catholics supposed to patch things up?

[@KYLE-zo4bm]

we need to legislate and change these laws!

[@evilotto9200]

The current US administration is hard at work repealing and replacing all scientific law

[@KYLE-zo4bm]

Evil Otto oh good

[@sushantahuja9067]

well let me tell you that you are in luck!.. Trump just became POTUS!

[@joaovitormatos8147]

First thing we need is democracy! Who voted for Carnot? I didn't!

[@dabiskitt]

KY LE oki

[@maicholor2849]

Gotta love explanations of things that can't ever be solved!

[@NintenUnity]

"He chose the path of perpetual torment"

[@revthescatman137]

I got that reference

[@revthescatman137]

@@user-tj4ee6si7x KK

[@randeegunthunter1062]

The doomslayer

[@Mek_scarlet]

In his ravenous hatred, he found no peace, and with boiling blood,...

[@Nyghtrid3r]

@@revthescatman137 KKK

[@reversesin]

When you try to plug the extension cord in to itself

[@Carl-LaFong1618]

I tried to buy a cordless extension cord.

[@ladyhaha7548]

@@Carl-LaFong1618 wait,tthats illegal

[@user-xt4gh7tn9p]

@HZB OcYpcWr'Ctwu Odzs this sounds really, really wrong

[@KemestA7X]

i have a friend that asked me why his computer wasn't turning on. I checked it out and he had plugged the power bar into itself....

[@Joshuaxiong2]

Lol ikr. I was thinking of this too. I thought of this too when I was little.

[@itsMKiAM]

KZbin: Reccomends me this Also KZbin: “How To Make An Infinite Water Fountain Out Of Two Bottles and Some Straws”

[@Sarimae23]

and nevertheless it does not procude more then invested

[@Ilmichakkar]

🤣🤣

[@EliStettner]

I made one of those with a little fish engine pump. They're really cool. King of Random has a tutorial I think.

[@montemardelaraofficial]

i think the middle bottle will run out of water and air pressure to continue it cycle. Ill try to experiment on it in the future.

[@कश्परैना]

I got... Infinite Hotel Paradox

[@ejunky66]

The hardest thing about building a perpetual motion machine is hiding the batteries.😆

[@crashwebb4715]

He obviously doesn't know about taping a piece of buttered bread to a cat

[@robertoolaverria455]

🤣

[@noyew2325]

🤣

[@dikephobia]

🤣

[@blakechow8294]

The cat would die

[@zerne6334]

@@blakechow8294 bruh

[@alve__7777]

KZbin : you want to learn some physics at 3am to avoid depression? Me: say no more

[@Bigstepperunderground]

😂

[@chedddargoblin]

2;45 close enough

[@shreearyanshrivastava6302]

Ha ha 2 : 26 am

[@jackstephens5353]

😂😂

[@sheachampagne6812]

2:57 this comment scared me

[@sireanthony1793]

Infinite water source just make it 2 by 2

[@mis_l5858]

lmao amirite?

[@darkhorsearmor3513]

wierd dog lol Minecraft logic.

[@fitzjordy]

Or 3x1, take the water from the middle

[@mis_l5858]

Jordy Manurung Ew, nobody uses that at all.

[@sireanthony1793]

@@fitzjordy i have played for over 5 years and didn't know that was a thing

[@skatepark02]

It seems to me that perpetual motion is possible so long as you can convert 100% of one source of energy into 100% of another source and then back again.

[@Carlbarl.]

He obviously doesn’t know about Afk machines in Minecraft

[@Vodka6329]

Didn't know imprisoning villagers to take advantage of their farming behavior could pass as a Perpetual Machine.

[@morgajoka838]

@@slivyo monkaW

[@joescofield8459]

using water to continually move a ball in circles should count

[@TylerJayWalker]

@@joescofield8459 what? Do you mean something in minecraft? Thats impossible

[@caniget600subscriberswitho5]

500th like

[@Wildash]

Yoo, ted just tricked me into learning for 5 minutes

[@adityadabas9408]

Lol 😂

[@UeusD]

your ancestors: shame

[@gordonh9921]

Yeah what were they thinking?

[@amp4105]

i couldnt imagine not wanting to learn things like this, its so interesting.

[@MessedUpBrainspike]

It's the narrator's voice, I swear. I could listen to him talk about things I'm not even remotely interested in for hours.

[@DariusSergal]

Succesfully builds a perpetual motion machine powered by our search for a perpetual motion machine *It stops.*

[@LeXiKonCore]

a guy has a perpetual motion machine using implosion to drive it this is all lies to promote tariffs on energy sick of the lies

[@arturo7478]

@@LeXiKonCore Source?

[@reneye1813]

@@Minecave1 No one can say which outcome will happen, it's a paradox

[@iamleighgend3195]

@@arturo7478 hey look, it's already a week. where's his 'source'??

[@ggbadgg8692]

​@@gotchatroll8109 Then that endless loop would become a perpetual motion machine xD

[@abatcat426]

One thing I say is that if you see or otherwise interact with a perpetual motion machine, that means it doesn't work. For example, if you saw any light from a lightbulb powering itself, that means it let light out and therefore lost energy.

[@jessepinkman2291]

trying to invent one of this must be the same feeling of trying a gta5 glitch for 2 hours and then figure out it was already patched

[@GandalfTheSilver]

*_gets glitchers ptsd_* damn... patches...

[@GhostRobey]

The worst feeling FrFr

[@the_furry_inside_your_walls639]

It's the equivalent of trying to install a bunch of mods for Skyrim.

[@ferddoesweirdthingsinlife1040]

TED-Ed: Perpetual motion machines dont work Me: *Connects powerbank to itself

[@nirmala9698]

The most underrated comment

[@nyanSynxPHOENIX]

It would eventually run out of energy because of heat, but yeah.

[@ferddoesweirdthingsinlife1040]

Alex Meseck bruh I’m not even sure it actually charges

[@gabrielcruz3997]

@@nyanSynxPHOENIX bro does your brain have the capacity to understand a joke

[@Palladiumavoid]

My sisterdid it... And it exploded

[@ItlsWhatltls]

So they’ve obviously never plugged an extension chord into itself🙄

[@Schnort]

Can't believe we've been trusting these "scientists" this whole time. They just don't want to give the populous infinite energy!

[@mikejohnson3338]

* extension *cord* _you're too musically inclined, Ben_

[@smashpillow8513]

@@mikejohnson3338 Gold

[@squindle.]

@@smashpillow8513 copper

[@jay1185]

@@squindle. Titanium

[@Mercuryrisingquick]

Power adapters have step down converters for lower outputs. Car alternators increase the output with a rectifer bridge. We just need to amplify the output

[@exucaviera9084]

I remember trying to conceive of a perpetual motion machine as a kid, before I knew what it was called. Didn't take long to realize it was physically impossible.

[@caricue]

Doesn't the Earth perpetually go around the sun until the sun dies or an outside force pushes or pulls it? A plant around an isolated red dwarf might go round and round for a trillion years, right? You might not be able to get any work out of it, but it would go on "forever", or am I missing something?

[@joshbond8391]

@@caricue You're missing the meaning of perpetual (which is never ending or changing), even a red dwarf ceases to exist at some point... Literally nothing known is perpetual. As stated by thermodynamics, all matter tends to entropy.

[@caricue]

@@joshbond8391 But if a system keeps turning until the heat death of the universe, that's as perpetual as it is possible to be. I just wonder if it is true. Would not the planet spiral down into the star eventually, or maybe the gravity would dissipate and it would spiral away? From the video, we know that it might actually work with magnets, but the magnets would wear down and lose their magnetism eventually (I think that is what he said). You seem to be on board with the idea that a planet could theoretically orbit a long lived object for trillions of years, as long as nothing outside perturbed the stability, right? I'm sure we are missing something, besides, it is not entirely certain that the universe ends in heat death. I don't know, but something doesn't add up.

[@tacosmexicanstyle7846]

@@caricue the force that keeps Earth moving around the sun I suppose is limited itself; the sun’s gravity depends on its mass, and it is constantly burning through fuel until eventually it will explode outwards and its pull will weaken. I read somewhere that stars are always trying to collapse in on their own gravity, all that is stopping them is the huge amount of energy pushing back (fusion). Ultimately you could say that fusion is an external energy source to the gravitational pull that keeps Earth in orbit, and that is not perpetual.

[@caricue]

@@tacosmexicanstyle7846 You're correct that it probably wouldn't go like that with a star like the sun. It will become a red giant and eventually a white dwarf, or so they say, but a red dwarf is supposed to last for trillions of years since it doesn't burn its hydrogen so fast. It seems like it would not work in any case, but I don't know why, especially since the Earth has supposedly been orbiting for so long.

[@enjolraswaters7491]

“There’s just one problem. They don’t work.” *_hm yes that would be a problem_*

[@nullbeyondo]

Okay, that one made me chuckle 😂😂

[@hindugoat2302]

@@nullbeyondo Heres a concept for a perpetual motion device... You take a steel ball, put it in space, and give it a push... Now it will have motion, perpetually...

[@the_tube2]

@@hindugoat2302 u just yeeted a ball to space it has the same energy as long as it doesn't get, you know, universed. It still doesn't make any extra energy so newton don't need to come knocking at yo door

[@hindugoat2302]

@@the_tube2 the motion is perpetual, i win

[@the_tube2]

@@hindugoat2302 yeah but that just one thing a ball, not a machine like in the videos

[@albertm7178]

Simple because physics says we cant have nice things.

[@arthurtancredi]

have you ever seen a gyroscope???

[@mds19238]

Arthur Leite ... again, who caused the motion to get the gyroscope started in the first place?

[@arthurtancredi]

Vsauce did kkkk

[@Billy-I-Am-Not]

Albert M DAMMIT PHYSICS, THIS IS WHY WE CANT HAVE NICE THINGS

[@saavestro2154]

that is why scientist are so excited about high temperature superconductivity, it allows to have a very little amount of energy loss when transporting electricity

[@willgordon5737]

04:03 That's me walking into the kitchen at 2 a.m. for a 'quick snack' that turns into a feast.

[@cameronmueller-harder3916]

When I was around 12 I had a great idea for a perpetual motion car that had a magnet and a coil of copper wire in a wheel so the turning of the wheels would give the engine power. Excitedly, I told my mom all about my plan. She informed me that I had just reinvented hybrid vehicles.

[@jackett_2122]

But physics doesn't turns out to be so easy😅😂

[@eeromakinen4222]

Just to clear things up, the charging resists the turning of the wheel, so you cant charge infinetly

[@Cautionary_Tale_Harris]

About that same age for me, I "invented" a revolutionary propulsion system... I glued a permanent magnet into a piece of plastic pipe. Then glued in a rough electromagnet that I'd made out of a steel rod, some wire, and a 9volt battery. Then I added wheels! Lol...the idea was when you powered the electromagnet it would repel the permanent magnet and thus propel the "car." Several years later I learned about magnetic ride control on Corvettes.

[@akidclay7644]

i said why not shove some hamsters where the engine is and instead of gas u feed them and go boom zoom

[@elfrogman1428]

That’s still actually pretty impressive for a twelve year old who didn’t know how hybrids work

[@yourjunes]

Short answer: Entropy Long Answer: Entropy

[@pilentus]

Under appreciated comment

[@AnteaterAshley]

Nice

[@holdge5382]

Shouldn't it be eeeeeeennnnnnnntttrrroooopy?

[@yourjunes]

@@Nordkiinach The universe is finite, its expansion is infinite. Very different.

[@SophiaMostlySofi]

@Déjà Siku I don't understand your thought process. In my opinion you have said a lot without really saying anything at all.

[@nickrutsky242]

Maybe the real perpetual motion machines were the friends we made along the way

[@ThaFuzzwood]

No, because those require a constant investment of energy.

[@ioneiroi8350]

@@ThaFuzzwood yeah sorry nick he got a point

[@joseph-mariopelerin7028]

The perpetual motion in this case would be having all these friends trying to stab you in the back...

[@irfanhossainbhuiyanstudent3757]

Is this hunter x hunter reference?

[@onilord1830]

1 sin for the "it was not the megaffin at the end it was the friends we maid" cliche

[@nickirmen6671]

This makes a lot of sense actually, the first law says you can't use physics and certain natural reactions because there's always an imbalance, and the second law says that energy will try to escape no matter what materials you use or how much you spend or study there will always be troubleshooting. Even if a perpetual motion machine was created that could break those laws it's going to be affected by so many other factors such as gravity and acceleration and aerodynamics, you name it.

[@stevenpollard5171]

And friction.

[@trazyntheinfinite9895]

What my physics teacher said ages ago: "does it have moving parts? Congrats, you failed."

[@Termerpores]

@svenm sandity Perpetual motion machines are machines that can work infinitely without an energy source.... If the rocket gathers materials as it flows through space it means it is receiving an energy source. And nanomachine cannot be considered a perpetual motion machine because it receives energy from the body, which means it has an energy source. What you have listed are self-powered machines. self-powered machines and perpetual motion machines are two completely different things But I do agree that nothing is impossible and maybe, just maybe, it will be possible in the far future :)

[@Termerpores]

@svenm sandity yo I would suggest you check on your sources before you embarrass yourself any further. Just a quick search on Google literally says it in bold. Heck even this video's discription stated the defination of perpetual motion machines

[@notalanjoseph]

You two shuld get a room

[@ohnoitsdead]

@@notalanjoseph lmao

[@0623kaboom]

what i told that science teacher ... the solar system .. proof ... 4.5 BILLION years ... the universe 16+ Billion years how much more perpetual would you like ... proof science IS wrong.

[@haydenzielinski2168]

Just abolish the laws. It’s so simple

[@George83_Thomas]

Space jail

[@fish4225]

Space gulag for thermodynamical devients.

[@frankblangeard8865]

Sounds like something President Trump would do. He would insist that Mother Nature agree to a better deal...or else.

[@Strangeship1997]

Frank Blangeard the sad thing is, he was the best candidate in 2016 which actually had a CHANCE at winning

[@bradenreily5220]

That would violate the universal constitution.

[@ryang6745]

Learning more stuff on youtube than I do in school

[@rafaelg4878]

Columbus verɪfɪed He said learning more, not that their aren't learning anything at school

[@David_Larkin]

Uptown42 G sure, colombus is a great example when you know that he was thinking america was india

[@Foxy02016]

SimplyDash that should be part of Game Theory's channel description

[@nousername12127]

Lol true

[@bobgoldham69]

non vitae sed scolem discimus.

[@TheQuietKidsBackpack]

I see this as a challenge

[@ame367]

Just ask Stanford, he made one for his science fair

[@elmywelmy4103]

I am Deyvohn that’s literally the first thing I thought when I started watching this vid

[@emmavrijburg6676]

I was just thinking about that

[@bruno9005]

standford: Im making a perpetual motion machine physics laws: oh no you dont! (some years later he is on an other dimension and then he has to fight an inter-dimensional cosmic entity who wants to destroy the world)

[@woohoo1092]

Lol

[@preposteroustoast]

GRAVITY FALLS FANDOM

[@PsypherWolf]

Because in this house we obey the laws of THERMODYNAMICS!

[@emeraldoracle8706]

You're not my professor, I can do what I want!

[@TheWorldsStage]

There's something about flying a kite at night that's so unwholesome

[@viniciusgheolan]

I see the simpsons reference here

[@brdfnick3886]

things that violate laws of thermodynamics don't belong here! they belong to a house called fantasy!

[@stuffhappensdownsouth9899]

Doh!!!

[@Hivlik]

Left me blue balled for the third law of thermodynamics

[@no5139]

Hivlik the entropy is 0 when you hit absolute, 0 K, or -273.15 °C

[@jz4774]

the entropy of a *perfect* crystal at 0K will be 0

[@maxh1976]

Haha

[@PTNLemay]

I'm more interested in the zeroth law. What was with the four numbers on the tablet?

[@88Nieznany88]

PTNLemay its about thermal equilibrium. If A is in thermal equilibrium with B and B is in thermal equilibrium with C then also A is in thermal equilibrium with C.

[@chilo_world]

Perpetual motion machine: Don't let them know that I have a battery inside my body. 🗿

[@TypetwoAbsolute]

"In this house we obey the laws of THERMODYNAMICS!"

[@k4z3ryuu]

The moving parts would still create friction against themselves even though there's no friction against the air. So for example the robot walking on the conveyor belt creates friction against the belt and the gears that turn the belt create friction when they contact the belt; this results in heat energy being created which would be lost in the vacuum due to entropy.

[@alejandrolaguna203]

TypetwoAbsolute the simpsons

[@shanekusak4345]

TypetwoAbsolute came looking for this comment. Wasn't disappointed

[@TypetwoAbsolute]

I made this comment because I came looking for this comment, and was.

[@wli2718]

2 things. 1 - vaccum is not empty, only extremely low density. we know this because "vaccum space" has a temperature about 3 degrees kelvin. 2 - the machine itself is made of atoms, which will absorb some of that energy one way or another. for example, the heat can cause chemical reaction, absorbing that energy. or emit black body radiation.

[@COMMANDandConquer199]

Something like this might seem minor, but solving this issue would literally evolve our species into something unimaginable.

[@petern.327]

i hope they never solve it

[@aidenmcknight2884]

​@@petern.327 Yes, because nobody includes you in _our_ species. It would inevitably help everyone _except_ you.

[@COMMANDandConquer199]

@@petern.327 If you're not interested in the betterment of our species then do us all a favor and quit using up resources, if you catch my meaning.

[@abdulwasey3506]

@@petern.327 ok why do you don't hope they solve this issue. Don't you want to see all people getting access to electricity, water and good food. And ofcourse we can settle on other planets to accommodate all the population.

[@Shanoyu19271]

4 people just roast an alien to death lmao

[@MrMagyar5]

Anyone with a child has encountered a perpetual motion machine. They constantly put out more energy than they take in. I mean... jeez.. One bowl of fruity pebbles and zwooop.. off they go for 4 hours. I eat a bowl of fruity pebbles and All I can do is nap.

[@minihalkoja590]

So power created by child slaves is our solution.

[@qnimations]

this needs more likes lmao

[@phareye5079]

sleep. they sleep better then you. that's how.

[@Shadow-il7xh]

@@phareye5079 *HARVARD WANTS YOUR LOCATION*

[@phareye5079]

@@Shadow-il7xh let them have it. they won't be able to comprehend the powerfulness of this mind.

[@kabelomasilela8145]

"The one thing that seems truly perpetual, is our search." I felt that😵‍💫

[@Kasadilla1]

This is actual so facinating. I have gone down a rabbit hole learning about entropy in my freshman year of engineering.

[@StephieRomero]

Sameee

[@peshal0]

Ted Ed : Perpetual Energy Source Do Not Exist ! Minecraft Veterans : Hold My Redstone !

[@aidancleveland2022]

Lol

[@jamianderson2847]

i made a redstone clock that uses an observer detecting the piston it extends making perpetual motion

[@peshal0]

@@jamianderson2847 jami redstone are perputual themselvess 😂😂😂

[@randomtidbits961]

Infinite water source

[@aidancleveland2022]

Jami Anderson the external power source is Minecraft lol

[@msun6526]

The real perpetual motion machines were the friends we made along the way.

[@bearthatrun]

i dont have friends =(

[@oxfordcommaisthegreatest]

@@bearthatrun Then you don't have perpetual motion machines

[@torrent8446]

@@bearthatrun i'll be your perpetual motion machine anytime

[@EmanuelRay3232]

here were dragons Hunter X Hunter?

[@ThomasonCG]

@@torrent8446 can i be the third wheel in the motion machine?

[@dancing4990]

You’re living on one dear inventor🤯

[@larrytruelove7112]

The conclusion of the video. “There is no perpetual motion machine or environment. But, there’s always hope.”

[@chadzahirshah2588]

Hope requires a conscience capable of feelings, humans who have those are limited to how long they live which is most certainly going to die out by the end of the universe, therefore hope is limited

[@larrytruelove7112]

@@chadzahirshah2588 Sometimes, hope is a mental exercise expecting the unlikely.

[@sudoku0095]

Actually, Tesla was able to create such a machine. It has been invaluable in the company's growth. Here is a video explaining how their machine works: kzbin.info/www/bejne/pXvPY2iYdqeMl8U

[@Mark-Wilson]

@@sudoku0095 bruh its not perpertual it needs external energy and will finish even tesla would not claim this dude the problem with ehse comments is misunderstand of waht perpetual machines actually are edit: I hate you som uch worst rickroll grr I will get you one day sudoko00

[@Farzlepot]

@@sudoku0095 This is life-changing.

[@gerpsie8891]

Oh, you've fixed the first law of thermodynamics, well here's a second.

[@AmericanClassic2000]

you forgot about the third and forth

[@ZachAttack6089]

@@AmericanClassic2000 And the zeroeth, apparently...? 1:30

[@JackL3141]

Zeroth law of thermodynamics - If two thermodynamic systems are each in thermal equilibrium with a third, then they are in thermal equilibrium with each other.

[@JackL3141]

the 0th is the "4th"

[@TheVeryHungrySingularity]

Buttered toast on a cat, you're welcome science.

[@neutronstar6739]

William I have seen that GIF

[@LightStorm.]

William but doesn't the universe Use perpetual motion?

[@squidwardo7074]

Nghtstorm161 Holy shit... EVERYTHING IS A LIE!! FUCK ALL THIS SHIT! IM GONNA THINK ABOUT THAT IN MY SHOWER! sorry for all caps

[@TylerDurden-oy2hm]

thats a VERY good point....respect

[@kornx10]

Nghtstorm161 It only seems like it is due to the enormous scale of time and mass. But eventually everything decays

[@prostreetgsxr]

I watched a documentary on perpetual motion. It went on forever.

[@MrCrisTheRo]

I like that you have simplified this. Even the most "eloquent" versions of these devices don''t take many factors into account;

[@thisshouldbeavailable797]

If we can turn rage into energy twitter would be a nuclear reactor

[@darrelleaster5381]

Man if that’s the case, if we could turn human stupidity into energy then we would have the tesseract already🤣🤣

[@MariOmor1]

Nah, Twitter would actually be a perpetual energy source

[@d4viidtv]

*Violating first thermodynamic law* Second law: hold my beer

[@paskky913]

It's like the second stage of a boss.

[@Otalonrye]

Solves a big Mistry of my childhood