Why Europe Chose ISRO Over SpaceX for PROBA-3?

[@neelagrawalla9449]

We indians are proud of ISRO !!🙏🇮🇳❤️

[@Bittu_knk]

Isro is not proud of you. Because you can't clear their exam.

[@neelagrawalla9449]

@Bittu_knk But Your words say You can !!😂😜👍

[@sciencespectrum3855]

No no

[@sciencespectrum3855]

I love ESA and NASA over ISRO

[@OswaldSoans]

Thanks for the great Isro insight . Aaj hi dekha proba 3 launch . Great launch by Isro as usual . Clients were happy with the launch of the 2 side by side satellite payloads .

[@soumy1986]

Thank you for your service Ariane V.... May your sagas be sung in accordance with Human Endeavour

[@pranavrathwa7866]

Dedicated pslv Launch for Singapore 🇸🇬 satellite and LVM-3 Ka commercial Launch ka contract mila hea isro ko .

[@kartikkumar2453]

Sir please make a video on Gagnyaan

[@SubhashishBagchi]

While Bangladesh busy proving that there space mission is better than India 🤣🤣🤣

[@JasashreeChoudhury]

Proud of our ISRO

[@ravinagaraj7003]

Nice presentation, keep it up!

[@AshwaniKumar-fh8zh]

Excellent explanation.

[@rajeshparab9200]

Sir your videos are informative for science and space lovers, Love from Mumbai 🙏 Jai Hind and Jai Bharat

[@Aman-hz6hu]

Sir Love your content on space Requesting to bring some free courses on yt also ..

[@GuardianOfGalaxies]

Bharat jitna Hindu hoga, utna hi vikasit hoga

[@Vivekkumar-vu4kz]

right

[@7777linpaws]

Bewakuf type baatein mat karo..aadhe scientist to ISRO mein Christian hain.

[@vijaytiwari676]

2rs 😅

[@mercedesbenz3751]

​​@@7777linpawschal be aadhe scientists christian hain🤣? Tell me what Christianity speaks about the universe and cosmos?

[@Alpha-oj1il]

100% true

[@ajaysinghrawat8835]

Amazing insightful video sir ❤

[@masoodalimalik]

Love ISRO from Pakistan ❤️❤️❤️🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰

[@anurag3510]

thank you bro love from us hope one day we will rule over western countries

[@amitkumarmandal2453]

Love from India 🇮🇳 ♥️

[@masoodalimalik]

@@anurag3510 yes sure, best of luck from Karachi Pakistan 👍❤️🙏🇵🇰

[@masoodalimalik]

@amitkumarmandal2453 Love and Respect from Karachi Pakistan ❤️❤️❤️👍🙏🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰

[@Qwerkywoop]

Nhi chahiye Tera love

[@jagrutishirsat6702]

good Anna lesise best information you have been shair us Estro has .done, good job

[@arbindsharma5983]

Excellent dear Manish sir.

[@Sandeep-o1p7h]

Congrat ISRO.

[@nabarunmondal3314]

Nice information, wow!

[@naimahmad9372]

I really wanna know why pslv from your proba 3 video

[@manishpatil1869]

Yes sir that's why I commented on that video

[@manishpatil1869]

Thanks sir

[@ShyamHazari]

Excellent, Loved the explanation

[@Sankriti100]

Good description .🎉

[@TejanChaudhary-d9t]

very informative video sir! being a space enthusiast myself, it's good to see such good content.. jai hind

[@Gamezone-sd3er]

Back in 2017 when IRNSS was launched on pslv it was payload fairing failed.

[@okman9684]

Sir kya ye launch Rocket lab ke Electron rocket se ho sakta tha?

[@abhilashray380]

Uska payload capacity dekhna padega na

[@Manav_14k]

Not possible

[@sandeepk846]

Wo 3d printed rocket part use kate hai

[@mohaksawant703]

I appreciate Ariane Group/ESA partnering with ISRO. I have a question about JAXA rockets. Why are there fewer launches of JAXA rockets with private satellite providers?

[@Manav_14k]

Bro, JAXA doesn’t launch much for private satellites ‘cause their rockets like H3 and Epsilon S had delays and issues. They’re still tryna catch up and make things work better in the market.

[@amanchoudhary8339]

Recently another rocket exploded midair

[@dr.tushar5222]

What ISRO's price tag was attached with its launch of ESA's PROBA-3? May I know please?

[@hem22ku]

Can you make video simple and easy to understand

[@anshuuu3648]

Reason is cost cutting

[@nareshprashar2491]

ISRO is great experienced space agency.nasa jaxa and others space agency great believe in ISRO save launch satellite mission.jai hind Jai bharat Jai maa bharti

[@Notdeba]

Comments main kanglu nai dikh rhe

[@AniruddhaChatterjee-h4h]

Very good isro aur hal main iss channel se euros aur dollars ayenge.

[@aritrakumar093]

One of the only things i can be proud of India !!

[@RANDOMSHORTS-cw7dh]

Does India have any launch vehicle which can lift more than 4000Kg? If not, Is ISRO working on any such vehicles with a capability upto 10000Kg?

[@Vasudhaeducation]

Namaste sir ji

[@Optimistix28]

Just wondering..why did you leave ISRO sir?

[@HartajTrehan]

🚦By the way many times a rocket can only be launched from certain latitudes for orbit insertion (to keep things cheap). So many times a launch organisation is chosen based on the latitude + the orbit type. So there will be times when we launch sometime from somewhere else and someone else will launch from here.

[@rathanapparathanappa5077]

INDIA'S ISRO charges are reasonable. In contrast with other global Space powers.

[@jaymehta0098]

@NimbusJEENEET what materials should be used for balloon filled with Helium to lift 100 tonnes plus till lower earth orbit?

[@s.k4969]

Kindly make a English video also ji for us Tamil people, while we started realising the necessity of Hindi language also to keep our nation United ❤️ Jai hind !

[@priiiithvii]

Or ask him to provide tamil or english subtitles 😊🙏🏼

[@Ad-is5zh]

Why you are always trying show contrast between ISRO and Space X ? There is no need of comparison between ISRO and Space X. They works by their way and we do our ways, don't try to show that Space X is nothing than us. Why you had not make video on why NASA don't use its SLV but they use Space X's Falcon 9 ? And why ISRO too used Space X rocket instead of its own? We must try to improve more rather then trying to show someone lower.

[@SunnyGoikar]

Jai hind ❤

[@Doeverything2.0]

Isro ki problem hai ki voh satisfaction bhot jaldi ho jata h

[@jortor2932]

6:09Sir toh jo astronaut ki training hi rhi hai vo Russia mai ho rhi hai ya esa ke through

[@mehtapramod23]

WE SHOULD INVEST HEAVILY ON ISRO IF WE WANT TO BE SUPER POWER UP TO 2047

[@Doeverything2.0]

India main ab contractor ka hi kaam chal Raha hai toh voh jyada uchal rahe h jyada din nahi chalega ye😂😂

[@vlc705]

Beautiful but Video to long, please take care

[@amit.D_K]

Humara 8000 kg payload ka semi cryogenic rocket kab banega

[@commieTerminator]

SCE-200 program got approved in 2009 for ₹1,798 crore. Sabar karo, 100 saal baad ban hi jayega

[@skbosebose2545]

Modi ji hain to mumkin hain

[@jpajpaassi6614]

🕉 Satyameva Jayate: Truth and Honesty and Reality gets created when Good Thoughts, Good Deeds, Good Acts are allowed to achieve the small steps needed for the correct choices and correct decisions to be made. Satyameva Jayate

[@PIYUSHKESHRWANI]

Sir aap kuch mark rober jesa hi kuch karo nn aapke hi jese wo bhi ek former nasa scientist hai

[@n2201]

How much have we paid ESA for the services they provided for Aditya? Is it "ek hath do, ek haath lo"?

[@ananthram]

🙏🙏🙏

[@ramanujan414]

❤

[@megaknight3705]

That's Falcon not Folcann

[@Avtar010]

1)आप जब बोल रहे है स्पेस डिप्लोमेसी मतलब आपका रेट पर किलो ज्यादा है। 2)आप उनका लॉन्च बहुत दिनों में करते है जबकि स्पेस एक्स 1 से 2 हफ्ते में कर देगा। इसका मतलब आपका कोई सर्विस ऐसे नहीं है जो स्पेस एक्स को टक्कर दे। इसी कारण आप देखोगे कि इसरो के इस वर्ष लॉन्च कम हुए।

[@abhilashray380]

लेकिन एक कारण यह भी है कि स्पेसएक्स ज्यादा लॉन्च इसीलिए करता है क्योंकि उसका खुद सैटेलाइट का बिजनेस है इंटरनेट का। और बाकी इंटरनेशनल स्पेस स्टेशन से आना जाना, उसके अलावा बहुत कम लॉन्चर्स बच जाते हैं जो जल्दी हो सके।

[@मगरमच्छG]

सीधे-सीधे भी बता सकते हो

[@dilipsawant4391]

Good

[@achlan5000]

Should use more schematics and labellings in video, like flashing full forms of abbreviations, flashing country's names with their launch vehicles etc. For a new person, unfortunately all the info may sound little gibberish, even though you taught nicelyy. Jayy hindd

[@realMNorganic]

But Amazon they are making smaller rockets

[@abhilashray380]

Abhi uska rockets sub orbital flights karte hain, orbit koi nahi banata New Glenn ke aane ke BO bhi aajayega race me

[@xtremtech5600]

Sasta aur Location aur pslv ka bharosa.

[@pradyumnanayak9844]

👍🇮🇳🇮🇳🇮🇳

[@NoahMoses88]

ISRO vs. SpaceX: "My Critical Perspective" 1. Technological Gap ISRO appears to be operating with technology from the 1960s and 70s, while SpaceX leverages advancements from the 2000s. This raises questions about ISRO's progress over the years. SpaceX’s Falcon 9, capable of carrying up to 22 tons into space, is human-rated and reusable. Meanwhile, ISRO lacks reusable rockets and has yet to develop a human-rated launch system. The PSLV engine was developed using technology transferred from France over 50 years ago. Solid boosters still dominate ISRO’s designs, which reflects limited innovation in propulsion systems. 2. Reusability and Market Leadership SpaceX has achieved significant breakthroughs in reusability, reducing costs and advancing rocket technology. ISRO, in contrast, has not introduced reusable rockets to its portfolio. If SpaceX’s Starship becomes operational, it will further solidify SpaceX’s dominance in the space market. Falcon 9 is already the industry leader, making it difficult for ISRO to compete. 3. ISRO’s Achievements and Limitations ISRO is primarily focused on launching small satellites and has not yet achieved significant milestones in human spaceflight or heavy-lift rocket development. There’s a perception that ISRO’s work reflects a "small dream" mentality, focusing on modest goals rather than groundbreaking innovation. Issues such as the lack of advanced onboard cameras in ISRO’s rockets point to areas where improvements are needed, even in fundamental aspects of their missions. and I swear, when I heard ISRO's CEO's response about the camera quality of rocket on a KZbinr's podcast, my mind was completely blown hearing that 4. Perception of Innovation and Work Culture The perception is that ISRO scientists work primarily for job security, without a strong emphasis on pushing technological boundaries or fostering innovation. In contrast to SpaceX, ISRO’s designs and developments often lack the “wow” factor, contributing to a sense of disappointment among some observers. 5. Public Relations(PR) and National Pride ISRO’s public relations efforts are often criticized for being ineffective. A stronger, more engaging PR strategy could improve public perception and global recognition. Patriotism sometimes prevents Indians from critically evaluating ISRO’s shortcomings. This lack of accountability might hinder the organization’s growth. 6. Broader Reflections on Indian Innovation There’s a belief that India’s space program reflects a broader hesitation to innovate, with a tendency to rely on repurposed or transferred technology rather than developing groundbreaking solutions. While comparisons with countries like Pakistan may offer some satisfaction, they reflect limited ambition when juxtaposed with global leaders like SpaceX, Rocket Lab, or Blue Origin. at the end I believe that if ISRO needs to change anything first, it is the CEO of ISRO. Because as long as people who are only interested in having a job hold the CEO position, with their goal being just to have a job, no real change can happen. ISRO needs an ambitious person like Elon Musk, Jeff Bezos, or Sir Peter Beck-someone who won't just run ISRO as a job, but will guide it towards bringing change and provide direction to the coming generations of this country. How long will ISRO remain just a medium to launch satellites? When will there be an invention that will make the new generation of the country dream of working at ISRO and contributing to the space field? Whenever ISRO goes to an IIT, no one even shows up to listen, because they are neither offering good salaries nor providing ambitious people with the space to fulfill their ambitions. The private companies, even though they don’t offer extraordinary packages, still have people working with them because those people are ambitious-they want to make a name and create inventions. When SpaceX recently caught a booster with chopsticks, it became a huge sensation, and people even came from Europe to see the next rocket launch, while the entire America and Canada showed up. You can imagine how happy those ambitious people must have been when the whole world appreciated their work. The entire nation of America went back to the moment when America first landed on the moon. God knows when India will stop relying on technology from others and start focusing on doing something on its own. How long will we continue to rely on outdated technologies from the past? I do not want the coming youth of this country to go abroad after getting education here and work towards making other countries more great. And if I have to criticize the institutions of this country for that, it will be my privilege

[@buntysinghal1487]

Ah yes completely agreed they have ambitious project but neither money nor technology to achieve that our budget is so low when I look back at Artemis 1 launch it is equal to the entire space industry budget I don't know and I don't think they will be able to establish space station by 2035 and land on moon by 2040. These are too ambitious project our gaganyaan mission started in 2008 but still not finished while a private space company started by elon musk in 2000 have achieved it. China is investing too in space and research and they have the technology too they will land on moon and even by 2050 if we land on moon it would be a great deal because maintaining a space station and landing on moon is very expensive and the way our space budget is increasing like 1% or 2% a year it would take long before we could make up for technology gap for these difficult mission

[@Suvedhanapandi]

Comparing a private player who has a lot of funds to a state owned organisation with limited funds is not the right way to look at it. ISRO can't afford failures. So they always go for stability over experimentation. The role ISRO ultimately is to provide for the nation and its development through space research. So ISRO isn't limited to the propulsion system. It has to secure funds on its own and that's where these satellite launchers come in. They are cheaper, affordable and reliable. Apart from this ISRO is also doing space exploration, managing communication satellites through satellite navigation systems, remote sensing etc.., So it is not appropriate to compare ISRO with SpaceX. This is why there are new space related startups in india. And ultimately they will solve this issue. They as a private party will come out of the comfort zone. Also ISRO funding is very small when compared with giants like NASA, CNSA, ESA, ROSCOSMOS, JAXA, and even some European space agencies like CNES, ASI, DLR have higher funds than ISRO. But the achievements of ISRO are comparable or sometimes exceed some of these agencies. And India as a country is still at a developing stage. We are 20 years behind in semiconductor technology and infrastructure,10 years behind in fighter jet technology when compared to china. We don't have space stations like the USA, Russia or China and finally our economy is not as strong as the USA, Russia or China. So the ultimate verdict is that India isn't yet ready for a space race. I know brain drain is a major concern but the situation is improving. The living standards in india is improving a lot. And it's not easy to catch up with super powers like Russia or USA in a single decade. And we are not an autocracy like china either. So in a big democracy like India with a lot of diversity, it's not possible to achieve fast paced growth, results or achievements. It happens in its own pace. But our progress never halted. And we don't really use outdated technologies. It's just the past 2 decades have seen a massive growth in technology and tele communication. But I can guarantee that India will reach there eventually. We are relying on technology from others because we can't afford to put the same amount of money or time that was invested by those countries. And Technology transfer doesn't mean outdated technology. Also no country will sell its state of the art technology to any other country. Unless we reverse engineer it(which will result in severe scrutiny and sanctions from other countries) ourselves like china, technology transfer is the only other option and it's not cheap or affordable either. Technology transfer is way more costly than reverse engineering. It will be generally 3-4times the cost of the actual price. In the era of globalisation technology transfer and brain drain is inevitable. Our country just have to keep improving until it reaches them.

[@Deathdealer-f7u]

Get a Fupping Job Bruhh !!! You've got way too much free time 😂 😂

[@vermag4662]

❤❤

[@krishansingh3259]

Who!!

[@bediscover3067]

kya isro aur bhi new launcher pe kam kar raha hai,

[@Pakalo_Papito]

Offcourse , ISRO new launch vehicles pe kaam kar raha hai NGLV pe

[@GurCharanChoudhary]

जय श्री राम ॥

[@soumyadipsaha8834]

Ex muslim sahil jindabad ❤❤❤

[@RimaSherry-vo7ct]

BRAVO ISRO. JAI SHRI RAM.

[@Rajput-Sunny-r1o]

Bhart ko Motta Paisa Lena chyie inse Jo Ameer he desh

[@The_social_hero]

EX ISRO?

[@akhileshkumarskn32925]

Aapki baato ko samajhna bada kathin h . Phir bhi accha lagta h. Because you are true

[@15keshaw]

सब पैसे का चक्कर है बाबूभाई।

[@easwaransanthakumar297]

Still ISRO unable to build Heavy rockets like SpaceX.

[@anulearntech]

The funding needed to research that hasn't been provided by the central govt yet, hence.

[@magiceyes0]

Scientists itney handsome bhi hotey hain.?

[@piyushsrivastavjaipuriasch8356]

ISRO wala sasta launch Kahan milega.😂

[@mayurkanth6987]

Change ur channel logo. It looks like a govt. channel. Bet many get ur videos in their feed but don't click on it due to unattractive thumbnail and dp

[@Shrm_Saksham]

Bharat jitna bhartiye hoga,utna hi viksit hoga......Jai hind

[@prakxyz]

India uses Arian and they are using ISRO, untill their launch vehicle gets ready. Thats all. Bhaad may gaye ye gorey

[@hilwaamanamankiyar-pp5bf]

LOOK

[@TempMail-e8t]

We are very cheap😂

[@Doeverything2.0]

Ariane ki copy h gslv

[@Daughter_of_hades_]

it's all about cost of launching and nothing else..

[@persaud1]

🪔 🚩 🇮🇳 👌 🙏 🙏 🙏 ✊️ 🇮🇳 🚩 🪔

[@yojo619]

ISRO OUTDATED USELESS ROCKET

[@Doeverything2.0]

Jhat ka baal toot jaye toh technical glitch aa jata h isro main 😂 software toh supreme h

[@Spinster87]

Why is this guy dancing great Mudras but need decoding 😂

[@subhayandas6122]

A brainless fellow always focuses on unnecessary things....study

[@raj33317aka]

cost cutting

[@premkumarpandey992]

❤