Why farmers in Haryana are leaving their fields vacant?

[@Aditya-ok9hl]

Sustainable farming and water management will save the mother earth . Main stream media should do this type of coverage which down to earth is doing.

[@ParveenKumar-vt3si]

I wish punjab farmers also understand this and start to grow other crops instead of rice.

[@Globalhindu296]

😂😂 nahi samjhenge .. MSP lo kanneda bhago. Badlav Lao to protest kro

[@iqbaldhillon6293]

Firstly give them another better alternative crop to farmers they will switch automatically 🙏🏻🙏🏻

[@Dik.Muhammad.quranovirus]

Sikh jat ego😂😂

[@arshdeepsingh6757]

Same bro 👏🏻

[@navymaanjaniwal]

Govt.told them to grow rice

[@OnlynewsYes]

बहुत बहुत धन्यवाद हिंदी में बनाने के लिए ☺️ हमारा टीवी का मीडिया ऐसी समाचार नही दिखाता है।

[@Rocket_T2]

मीडिया को सेलिब्रिटी का कुत्ता बीमार हो जाए तो न्यूज दिखती है

[@ankurkapasiya6094]

Water and Soil cisis also exist in Western Uttar pradesh because of crops like Sugarcane and Rice. But there is no attention to the issue because of lack of political Strength & Will while West Up is bigger than Haryana in Area. West UP have the largest belt of Sugarcane in India stretched from Sharanpur, Muzzafarnagar, Meerut, Bhagpat, Ghaziabad, Bijnor, Moradabad, Amroha and Bulandshahr. I requested to D2Earth to give the light to the issues of West UP

[@ruchinkumar8358]

Wow! you have hit the nail, soon this doaba area will be in crisis

[@dksingh5291]

Sugarcane is not using so much water. It is issue with Rice only

[@sachinrajgure8490]

समय के अनुसार बदलाव आवश्यक है 🌳 Save Nature save water 💧

[@Hritiksharma749]

Ground level reporting and analysis. I like it ❤

[@jamesatlas5204]

im from jhajjar it is situated on geographical borders of Gangetic plains and semi arid area of western haryana. this land is not suitable for paddy cultivation. big canals have made water accessible so people started growing rice in rohtak, jhajjar districts.

[@sethkritarth]

Good reporting. Coverage from both, farmers and scientists, and no interview or debates between political parties. Aaj Tak and India TV have no clue what journalism means.

[@sadaffatima164]

Happy Republic Day. May the spirit of freedom inspire us to build a future that is prosperous, just, and inclusive for all.🇮🇳 On Republic Day, let’s pledge to uphold the ideals of our Constitution and work towards a brighter and more harmonious India. Jai Hind!! 😊🧡🤍💚

[@Globalhindu296]

What's your optional

[@sadaffatima164]

@@Globalhindu296 Sociology

[@blast473]

The problem is the lack of alternatives with the farmers. They'll skip rice in a beat if they're provided with a better market for an alternative. Just need to set the industries for other products first.

[@axel3895]

Haryana is close to delhi, they can plant vegetables and earn good money

[@RiteshSharma-xrs333]

They do have alternatives such as millet, sorghum, vegetables etc but the alternatives don't yield enough money. The problem with farmers is that they don't earn enough despite all the efforts.

[@gaeig]

That's because the government invested in big farmers to grow rice in semi-arid areas like Punjab and Haryana without investing in the human resources of the uneducated but rich Northwest regions, which would've made farmers more conscious about the environment, society and sustainability but more importantly encouraged them to strive for a more equal and fair society The contrast between rich Jatt farmers owning big properties and Audis exploiting poor labourers from UP, Bihar and poor farmers committing suicide along with their whole families because of racking up enormous debt is only the result of such shortsighted government interventions Sadly the governments in Punjab and Haryana at this are controlled by the powerful Jatt community who care the least about an egalitarian society and would rather talk about Ram Rajya or Khalistan to distract the public from the appalling wealth inequality in Punjab/Haryana with many of them migrating to Canada using the same wealth the government invested in them

[@JatinderSingh-hv6uh]

किसान करने को सब कुछ कर सकता है पर बिना सरकार के सहयोग के कुछ नही हो सकता। और सरकारों की नीति ये है की किसान खेती ही छोड़ दे। गेंहू धान के इलावा और बहुत फसलें है पर उनका समर्थन मूल्य नही मिलता। चाहे वो जो हो चना हो बाजरा हो मूंग हो उड़द हो। जब किसान की फसल आती है तो किसान का चना 50 रुपए बिकता है और वही चना दुकान पर 80 रुपए बिक रहा है यही हाल दूसरी फसलों का है। जब तक ये भावांतर रहेगा कोई किसान गेहूं धान के फसली चक्कर से बाहर नही निकलेगा। चाहे पानी खत्म हो जाए चाहे जमीन बंजर हो जाए

[@ashwanipanwar6556]

What's bad in cotton?... jabrdsti ki kheti h dhaan bss...log ek dusre ko dekh dekh k pagal hue h...dhaan mai jitna paani lagta h...utne paani mai gehu aur cotton ka pure saal ka kaam chal jaaye..tab bhi paani bchega

[@chromeyoutube505]

PLEASE STOP EATING RICE EVERYONE !!! Switch to millets, jowar, bajra etc. #NO MORE RICE

[@Acharya_Slideshare]

Agree to this specially put South Indian guys need to stop

[@studentkumari8540]

Tum apne gharwalo ko bolo bajre ki roti Roz khaye,, Dhan barish ki fasal hai barish ke dino Mai iski kheti hoti bina water waste ke lekin hariyana aur Punjab ke log profit ke liye isko underwater se ugate to unko nhi ugana chahiye na ki rice khana chhodna chahiye

[@edmarga]

but i like rice😥

[@hib1s]

Punjab and haryana don't even eat rice, they are the one to be given incentive to stop

[@ROADToFUNLAND]

Not possible now

[@Sagar-wn1po]

DTE can grow exponentially if content is delivered in regional language. No other channel creates local content. DW Hindi is the nearest competitor

[@sheelbhardwaj2]

आपने बहुत उपयोगी स्टोरी दी है राजू सजवान जी। आपका बहुत धन्यवाद

[@HRGaming08]

I suggest the farmers that grow paddy in July month instead of June month because in July there is lots of Rain in this month and also lots of rain in August month

[@Hanuman-r6s]

Ask Subash palekar ji how we can reverse the salt contents. This might be due to overuse of fertilizers. We can do crop rotation like legumes and lentils and also now millets are gaining traction. They can grow in any type of climate.

[@shivampathak9064]

Basically crop rotation is necessary

[@kumarvipinverma]

Jaha jaha barish acchi hoti hai waha dhaan production karne me koe problem nahi hai. Need to add organic matter to hold more water for longer time

[@HRGaming08]

Paddy crop should start in 7th month instead of of 6th month because there is lots of rain after 6th month

[@greenheaven_30x]

ground report - covered well, repoted well, documentaed well, DTE thank you, How can we post this to policy maker or public enegenmnt now...

[@desiskool2102]

The main reason for growing of paddy is the rate of other crops like cotton and millet is very low comparison to rate of paddy .paddy destroyed the fertility of soil but farmer have no other option,if government increase the price of cotton than paddy sowing in haryana is decrease and save water and soil.

[@mohitkulria]

धान लगाना किसान का शौक नही बल्की मजबूरी हैं क्योकि बाकि फसल सरकार मिनिमम सपोर्ट मूल्य पर ही नही खरीद करती सब्जियां पर लेबर और खाद खुराक की लागत अधिक हैं और बाजार मूल्य जब 25 se कम हो जाये तब लागत भी नही वापिस हों पाती अगर सरकार बाकी अनाज पर सरकारी खरीद करें तो किसान धान लगाना खुद ही छोड़ दें

[@vishaalbhatnagar3924]

Very interesting perspectives shared here. Thanks for educating your viewers.

[@spjagatsingh1771]

Officers of agriculture and irrigation department should take measures in the welfare of farmers.

[@rationalmind3567]

Growing rice in Punjab and Haryana on Govt subsidies and avail Govt subsidies has killed farming activities in the Konkan region of Maharastra, Goa, and Karnataka. You will find water-rich agricultural land left barren in these three states.

[@bekabeka71]

For how long for the soil to recover

[@priyamjoshi2667]

Absolutely right farmers of punjab haryana does farming from subsidy. Govt have to give them subsidy just to take votes all labour is from up Bihar.

[@neutral5793]

How does inability to grow rice result in barren land? If you can grow rice in a land, then you can grow anything. And growing rice doesn't make sense in the states you mentioned..

[@santdalal5906]

​@@priyamjoshi2667to kya kisi ne invite kiya hai tumko labour krne ko

[@kanwar061]

Good pls make vedio about issue of organic farming in india. Some states started it. What are challenge faced by their farmers

[@sudarshan3965]

Bajra, jawar jasi fasal hi is area ki asal fasal hai

[@hib1s]

True

[@ROADToFUNLAND]

Bajra ajkla khata kon h bhai

[@sashilemla6229]

Is it bcz of too much fertilizer or iron water???

[@abhijeetgupta_]

Too much water is being pumped out of the ground. This water evaporates and minerals and salt in the water stay in the soil making soil infertile. Groundwater level is decreasing and may lead to droughts.

[@sumitpawankumar585]

Punjab should also leave paddy and other water intensive crops. Punjab is not a fertile land inherently, rather a semi-arid area which can't naturally sustain water intensive crop.

[@mazinboo9406]

Rice is tragedy for Haryanavis it also affected health, soil quality. But ye majboori hai

[@ajitkumarsahu503]

Rice grows naturally only in heavy rain areas like the coastal areas in India. Hence it is suitable to grow in coastal areas only.

[@hib1s]

Monsoon heavy, they should be grown only in such places like CG odisha Bengal

[@ayazshaikh862]

Drip irrigation lagakar koi alag fasal lagaye

[@saurabhrai5461]

This was a mistake Haryana and Punjab made, paddy cultivation was never for their fields but they used excess urea for the production and the result was fatal. Their fields were best suited for wheat but just for the sake of profit they destroyed their future. I am from eastern UP and I know exactly what it takes for paddy cultivation. We have black soil best suited for paddy cultivation but we grow chana(gram) also so that it can fix nitrogen from the air to the fields. Paddy cultivation need huge amount of water that's why we installed tube wells for the water supply.

[@debasishsahu3082]

How can I join in down to earth.

[@jameelahmad-oh8vz]

We should allign our agricultural activities to the behaviour of climate is the need of the hour but at the same time non agricultural population should also join their hands in the process by modifying dietry habbits, otherwise we can't contribute in the mass awareness. Regards Lecturer Geography & Disaster management

[@raosaheb5637]

heard it long time ago. grains growing farmers stay poor, veggies growing farmers make money and fruit/ tree farmers becomes rich

[@nitishrana9710]

Bhai Mahinder Singh (Karnal) ki saari baat jayaz or bilkul sahi hai. Aakhir m kisaan ko hi kyu ghasita jaaata hai paani to or duniya bhi use kr rahi hai. Jo paani upr hai usko to bachalo Yamuna ka paani itna ganda hai usko aajtk saaf kyu nahi kiya gya.👍👍

[@amank1939]

bhai jo bhi keh... kisan hi sabse jyada pani barbaad karta hai... 1 kg rice ugane mein 5000 litre pani lagta hai... isse badiya toh pani hi bech lo...

[@AJ-zg5xw]

Phir 400ft pe bhi borewell ka paani nhi millega phir sarkaar ko gaali matt dena

[@RadheKrishna69610]

I am from Jhajjar haryana and this is true issue in my my area so much water level up 5to 10 fit only

[@debangana9964]

Please provide subtitles in English. Had to understand with great difficulty

[@ARVIND88ful]

The overdemand of paddy in the market instead of other whole grains (e.g., barley, corn, fruits, and vegetables) is the problem. People on the demand side must change their attitude as the salty and undesirable farmland reflects their mindset. In addition, fruits, vegetables, barley, and corn are much healthier than paddy. Please look at their benefits. The government should encourage other whole grains. DIVERSITY IS THE KEY!

[@AjayTiwari-en9nz]

Corn is not healthier than Rice but others for sure are!

[@lautheimpaler4686]

Corn is healthier than paddy ? padhai kar

[@TheTreant]

Switch to tree based farming only way to save soil

[@manikanta-gc7tj]

Very good idea sir

[@aastiksharma5842]

I have started tree planting on my fields . Results are looking good.

[@mauryan1214]

What would we eat then

[@SangramBhardwajSirOfficial]

Permaculture

[@bekabeka71]

@@mauryan1214fruit trees

[@akarsh5871]

Same happened in mesopotamia, usually people followed cyclical crops, where weed was allowed to grow sometimes which would eat excess salt, but with larger population starting kiving, farmers started intensive farming and causing descrease yield and famine.

[@bhanwarlal6090]

Good reporting thank you

[@apr3807]

There’s a Swiss or Northman research about how to use such salt issues that has something about growing certain potato crops that only only grow fine but remove the salt due to their biological metabolism that breakdown salt molecule for growth. That made sense because potatoes also remove excess salt from cooking pot when added for the purpose. Knowledge shouldn’t be held back from anyone in need. 🇵🇰 from your neighbor!

[@soumyaranjanbagarty7618]

This problem is occured due to excess use of fertiliser that form salt with react with mineral of original soil. If some one says that due to excess cultivation of rice or lack of rain but it may be not. From the last thousands of year rice was cultivated but why this problem happened now only. This is due to excess of fertiliser that lead to hardness of soil when it dry. If I am wrong correct me.

[@brrbbb]

Dhan tropical area ki kheti hai. Mein assam se hu , humlogo k yaha mostly monsoon mein he dhan ki kheti ki jaati hain jisme koi irrigation ki jarurat nae padhti hain. Punjab haryana jese area mein saal bhar dhan ugane jaoge to ae sab hona to tai he hain

[@ajmahara32]

It is called calcification of soil...which is due to use of excessive use of canal water

[@Bondjamesbond0000007]

Hatsoff to Haryana Government

[@prasadkarsharma5849]

We need 16000 lt of water to produce 1kg of meat .we need to reduce our consumption and production too.

[@mastimacaroni]

How much did the farmer spray on growing off season cauliflower?

[@davidsarkar6108]

Can you plz share the data of Punjab where farmers are recklessly using water of future generations to earn profits and fulfilling their greeds.

[@soumitronagpal3619]

Good information in the video but title is misleading.

[@sunnysuraj197]

धान के बजाए चना,फल्ली, गेंहू का मार्केट बढ़ाना चाहिए तथा इन फसलों को बोने पर सब्जिडी देना चाहिए, फूड प्रोसेसिंग यूनिट सहकारी समिति स्तर पर होने चाहिए

[@BhavanaPatil-ii9tt]

Paddy cultivation is not suitable for North india , it's only for humid climate region but due to excess water they cultivate paddy. So it's most suitable for future to leave paddy.

[@calisingh7978]

If they do more permaculture and not mono crop.

[@deepeshkumargavel2991]

Dhanyawaad team down to earth

[@navneetkumar5421]

Five years back travelling through rural Sirsa belt i had seen farmers growing paddy there. Enquired from locals about it as it is not something that naturally is suppose to grow there as Harayana is not a heavy rainfall state. I was told all of it would be exported.

[@felixdayalan9786]

This is due to access use of urea switch to organic farming

[@andycric]

Love Haryana ❤ from South 🇮🇳

[@mexicanmomo]

Punjab, Haryana or UP are not suitable for paddy cultivation. East Indian states like Assam, West Bengal, Odisha and Konkan regions are suitable for paddy as they are blessed with heavy monsoon. Gov of India should think about it and do accordingly.

[@sukhbirkalirawna626]

Hamne bhi dhan ko alvida kah diya hai or mein puri kosis kar raha hu kam kam 20 jamidaro ko dhan se alag kar dunga mein ab sabji ki kheti ki or mud gaya hu jisme bhut hi jayada fayda ho raha hai

[@DeepakRao.01]

Aap ek baar jhajjar district ke Mundahera gaon me jaon, gaon ke saare khet banjar ho gye vaha pe.

[@abhijeetsingh7061]

Dsr ke liye land levelling sahi honi chahiye wrna ground water ki khapat r jyaada hogi puddling wali dhaan ke comparison me

[@mahanpathak24]

Millets are so costly. Much more than rice or wheat. Then why the farmer is saying that growing millets is not profitable? This point should have been explained more.

[@zaqs1970]

the solution is there and its simple, the need of the hour is the government should sit with all the stake holders be if farmer, the scientists and the experts

[@nirajmaths5209]

Bhai beri ka bagh laga lo ,iss soil may best hoga

[@maheshbabar5358]

Thanks form this very informative ground reporting.

[@saireddyamalla6649]

Crop rotation should be must

[@simranlakra511]

Nice explanation

[@felixdayalan9786]

Crop rotation is must

[@AnjaliNair-n6t]

these places doesn't look like places with excess of water that would justify a paddy planting opportunity to start off with. Places like kerala where there used to be enough water reserve , wetlands and marshes and rainfalls to justify paddy crops no longer have enough water resources to sustain paddy at scale. I can only imagine the case of northern states which doesn't receive enough precipitation to sustainably support a regular paddy crop.

[@yugdarshan]

This was bound to happen, rice farming needs to be stopped immediately there, farm some other crops

[@ViralIndianTV]

01:35 real reason

[@aggarwalkaoor9002]

Phal aur sabzi nahin laga sakte kya

[@TheVkaz]

good governance

[@amitabhpandey1970]

Good Story

[@manojnagre6710]

कुछ हद तक तो सही है और नहीं भी क्योंकि सरकार कहती हैं तो बहुत आसानी से कि आप ज्यादा पानी वाली फसलों को उगाना बंद करके कम पानी वाली फसलों का उत्पादन करें और सब्सिडी भी लें परंतु बागवानी फसलों में जो द्रीप, पाइप लाइन, मल्चिंग,बांस, मजदूर, दवाईंयां अधिक लगती है और सरकारों के द्वारा समय-समय पर सब्सिडी का भुगतान नहीं किया जाता है और सरकार कहती पहले आप राशि लगा हम बाद में देंगे, यदि किसान इतना ही सक्षम होता तो आपसे मांगता क्या - जवाब है -नहीं ,तो ये जो शासन -प्रशा सन में जो भर्राशाही है वो बंद हो और समस्या को अतिशीघ्र हल हो तभी किसान खेती करना जारी रखेंगे नहीं तो जिस तेजी से युवा पीढ़ी खेती छोड़ रही है उससे भी तेजी से छोड़ेंगे, धन्यवाद,❤❤❤

[@JyotiSingh-b6w1b]

More initiative need from government to give efficient subsidies for other subsidies

[@sureshchandsms9913]

Very good information for Farmers 🎉🎉

[@tremendouspoweroflife7453]

Rice is for coastal side

[@Bornbhus171]

Govt. should apply this method

[@ameyapatil2424]

Groundnuts (Singdana) lagaa lo.

[@puneet.budhwar]

Do you know how much farmer make in one acre for paddy ? @downtoearth ?

[@puneet.budhwar]

Mahinder Singh from karnal also saying 50,000 ₹ from one acre and govt giving 7000 acre 😂 disgusting 🤮

[@puneet.budhwar]

35000 loss 😢

[@royalclasher4895]

​@@puneet.budhwaryou can produce other crops in that land

[@AKhan-jg7dz]

Use more water in farming helps more rain in regions

[@sb37154]

One should grow crop that suits their climate and soil.

[@SandeepBishnoiAgroVlogs]

धान की फसल में जो कैमिकल्स डाले जाते हैं उससे भी जमीन बंजर होती है और वो कैमिकल्स दूसरी फसलों के लिए भी खतरनाक है।

[@ndahiya3730]

These people don't listen to anyone. थळी की नळी बणवा दी मिट्टी उठवा-उठवा कै - "धान लगाउंगा।" जब कहते थे कि चोआ ऊपर आ रहा है, जमीन रेही हो रही है, तो इनका जवाब होता था - "तन्नै क्याहें का ना बेरा - you don't know anything." अब जब जमीन रेही हो रही है तब रो रहे हैं। पहले नहीं बताया था क्या।

[@ranchifs9577]

Very informative

[@Shubhamforall]

6:40 it's COMBINE harvester. Not Command Harvester. CHANGE the CAPTION

[@pradeepkharta5953]

Only one answar to this problem plantation agriculture.

[@vipul_singh]

Put in more organic stuff as manure, to counter the salinity. It is a solvable problem.

[@rampal1921]

Unique documentry

[@Ashribad-v9f]

To produce 1 kg of meat it requires 16000 lt of water .so we should think about that too.

[@sandeepmann5899]

Iam from sonipat. Bachpan se dhan ki kheti dekh raha hu or abhi bhi joro se chal rahi hamaare ynha. Koi dikkat nhi

[@prataproy2220]

Lekin dhaan Punjab or Haryana ke liye suitable nahi hai. Punjab or Haryana ke Kisaan har saal jitna Rice ka production karte hai, Bengal ke kisaan usse 3 guna jyada Rice ka production karte hai

[@shahabazshaikh7113]

PQNK is the solution, science based natural farming, with zero input in the form of seed cost and harvesting cost.

[@pr1570]

Punjab and haryana is bound to become saline in comming decades if they didn't go crops like urad, ragi, jowar, bajra, etc

[@siddharthamitra4092]

Why have the govt. promoted paddy cultivation inwestern India? That area doesn't receive that much of rainfall like eastern Indian states. It will deplete ground water levels naturally. This shows how Agriculturul sector gets neglected, no proper planning.

[@santusanturohit4832]

Watch Pavnit Singh..he has mentioned the political background about it..and another reason is MS Swaminathan wanted a fertile,easily available of irrigated area to end food scarcity in India..

[@vinsin328]

In India, the farmer owns the agricultural land and does farming, not agriculturalists like in other countries.

[@harshittiwari2915]

Good work 👍

[@unbiasedhuman1659]

Use drip water irrigation

[@jayendrasingh9721]

Nonsense

[@BBCLIPS9]

chemical ka use aur kuwe ka pani ka use karna pada reason hai ...jamin ka kharab hona ...borewell ka pani use nahi karna chahye ....

[@gauravnilay]

punjab farmers should learn form this

[@Rocket_T2]

Better to switch to millets, need way less water than rice n wheat plus they are rich with nutrients.