WHY Hadith If The Quran Is ENOUGH!? (Will Nouman Ali Khan CONVINCE Me About Hadith? )

#Islam #christianity #quran
Why do we need Hadith if the Quran is enough? - Nouman Ali Khan Original Video:
• Why do we need Hadith ...
Hadith are the recorded sayings and actions of the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) and are considered an important source of guidance for Muslims. However, understanding and interpreting them can be a complex task. In this video, renowned Islamic scholar Nouman Ali Khan explains the meaning and context behind various Hadith, providing valuable insight into their significance and relevance for contemporary times. Whether you are a student of Islam or simply curious about this important aspect of the religion, this video is a must-watch. Join us as we explore the world of Hadith with Nouman Ali Khan.
God bless!
Consider Supporting by becoming a Member!
Members:
/ bobbysperspective
www.subscribes...
GRASSLAND NUTRITION 10% OFF with code " bobby10"
www.grasslandn...
NEW MERCH:
bobbys-perspec...
Use my referral link crypto.com/app... to sign up for Crypto.com and we both get $25 USD :)
The CODE IS: rayzxvkp5v
💵💵💵💵💵💵💵💵💵💵💵💵💵💵
Donate to my Crypto Wallet via paystring:
bobbysperspective$paystring.crypto.com
Donate via Stream Labs :
streamlabs.com...
Donate via PayPal :
[e-mail]
Contact:
[e-mail]
[e-mail]
/ bobby.yesss
/ bobbys.perspective
Bobby's Perspective DISCORD: / discord
Bobby's Perspective TELEGRAM: t.me/Bobbysper...
SECOND CHANNEL: / @bobby1903
Ban Rumble Phase 2 What Is Tate's Phase 2 Emergency Meeting Who Is Andrew Tate Tates Return Tate Support Tate Reacts To Mom G The Based Grandma Reacts To Tate Funniest Moments Tate Wild Takes TateConfidential TateSpeech Tates Final Speech Money Cars Hustle Motivation Grind Stocks AlphaTate Entrepreneur FinancialFreedom Biz Business Sneako Top G Manifestation Bugatti Rich Alpha Male Finance Andrew Tate Millionaire Young G Inspiration Make Money TikTok Yung G Side Hustle Sonny Fazio HU Hustlers University Sneako Funny Moments Tristan Tate Andrew Tate’s Brother TateSpeech Tate Ban Reaction To Tate

[@HumanbyGod]

Al-Qur'an 33:21 Indeed, in the Messenger of Allah you have an excellent example for whoever has hope in Allah and the Last Day, and remembers Allah often.

[@alimwanyasi6844]

Perfect. The answer

[@thesocialartsclub9095]

Exactly.

[@berimbolo010]

It says pattern instead of examples on other sites. A pattern is like praying every day doing ramadan every year. Examples can be that but it can also be something he handled on his own and not based of the Quran. Because he gave the Quran to us and how to pray etc. So no sorry this doesn't proof anything yet.

[@aishaarshadalam3412]

​@@berimbolo010 Explain how to perform Hajj using the Quran. Hint, you can't. You need the Messenger pbuh for that. How do women know what they can and can't do in terms of worship when they are on their monthly cycle? That's not in the Quran. The women of Ansar and the wives of the Prophet pbuh asked him those questions and he told them. You have a misunderstanding of what hadith is. We aren't saying its infallible, actually by showing that hadith has categories of authentic, weak and even fabricated, is proof that hadith has been vigorously tested and authenticated by the narrators ie the companions and the wives of the Prophet pbuh. We're saying if you completely disregard hadith you would come up with your own interpretations and you would not be living Islam as the Prophet pbuh lived it and he was the best of Muslims, the best of us all. Why would you take the example of the best Muslim and throw it away and assume that your interpretation, your way of practicing Islam is better? When the Quran clearly states the importance of the Messenger pbuh and that we should obey him and follow him then I really don't see why you're completely disregarding his whole life, sunnah, sayings and actions. We respect him, we ask Allah to shower His blessings on Him but we only do what Allah does Himself and we do not exceed it. We always refer to the Messenger pbuh as the slave and servant of Allah, we know his position and we do not give him a status that belongs to Allah alone. By not giving him the status Allah has given him in the Quran you are actually refusing to obey Allah. All the prophets were given a high status by Allah and are to be respected and obeyed by their people. They are special people. They are definitely above us and better than us. This doesn't mean we are worshipping them. It's a shame that many Muslims who reject the Messenger pbuh do not think about this and have completely misunderstood the Messenger pbuh and his importance.

[@S_Mo129]

​@@berimbolo010 no I am an Arab and it says اُسۡوَةٌ which means an example

[@Lord_Escanor_Sama]

We need the Hadith because without them, we wouldn’t even know how to pray in detail. If the Quran has to contain ALL the rulings, imagine how big the book will be.

[@ashcomics13]

do you think allah would miss that?

[@Shyek_14]

@@ashcomics13 ALLAH say in the Qur'an follow ME and follow Prophet MUHAMMAD SALLALLAHU ALAIHI WASALLAM

[@Lord_Escanor_Sama]

@@ashcomics13 Quran order us to pray, but not the details of the prayer.

[@neku2741]

@@ashcomics13 Allah didn't which is why Allah send a prophet together with the revelation.

[@saidzihmmou6426]

that makes quran incomplete which is unbelievable.

[@inessuarez8878]

I perfectly understand Bobby, coming from Christianity, studying and searching in different religions, it is difficult for us to accept everything that is human interpretation for fear of being diverted from the sacred text, I ask God to give me wisdom and a lot of faith to understand the truth and accept it. Thanks Bobby.

[@umairbutt1355]

Understandable. But also dangerous. One of the problems with Christianity is people drawing their own conclusions with little evidence or knowledge. If you truly want to understand the Qur'an, you have to put the work in, for example, learning Arabic. If you don't have the time for this, then you have to rely on the works of the scholars, because relying on translations will not do the Qur'an justice - Arabic is too rich and comprehensive (for example, the ـك when Allah is swearing by himself as Nouman Ali explains). Whatever path you choose, insha'Allah, you'll be led to the Sunnah and the works of the great scholars that have come before. "I ask God to give me wisdom and a lot of faith to understand the truth and accept it" Yes ameen!

[@carefullychristian8657]

@@umairbutt1355 you make it appear as if arabic is a heavenly/Allah's language. No sir. It is semitic and akin to syriac hebrew,aramaic,ethiopic. Second there were no dots and vowels initially. They were added to the arabic by al hajjaj and his guy So dont claim Arabic is special Thirdly the quran ,words of allah are clear below 1.quran is clear in arabic 2.it is an explanation of all things 3.it is in detail It does not say hadith will be a guide in the future It is allah or mohameds order Why dont you do mutah,wars ,marry 6/9 olds or who havent menstrated,why dont you marry eomen of your adopted sons,why dont you have sec on beds of other wives as your prophet did plus many other absurdities in hadith About.your prophet. Does your Allah hear only Arabic You worship mohamed like ctians do to jesus. In shahadah not in quran Prayers Grave You include him along side Allah Listen to quran only

[@710125]

Allah in the Qur'an says that "You are the best of examples for them" surah ahzab verse 21 and "You are on the best of character" Surah Qalam first few verses So ofcourse we're gonna value the sunna of the man Allah complimented & made an example for us.

[@muslima2505]

Ameen Ameen

[@plug_65]

Beautiful comment!

[@saadparvez165]

Yes. But how do you know that Sunnah is accurate. There's no way the words and actions of a man can be passed down with full accuracy.

[@MuhammadHosny0]

@@saadparvez165 you know nothing about the process.

[@sacredrider]

​@@saadparvez165 you know there is a whole science behind deciding whether it is a sahih or weak or a forgery

[@imzlm]

I worked for a motorcycle manufacturer in Germany. It was assembly line work. On my first day I was given a book that explained step by step how to do the work. I understood the text. I understood the words. It was all clearly described in the text. But when I stood in front of the motorcycle, I didn't know what to do. It was not the same. A worker had to train me. And only when I was trained by another worker, I really understood what I read in the book before. When you get your driver's license, there's theory and practice. Just because you can do theory perfectly doesn't mean you can drive the car.

[@saranpatel1114]

Amazing explanation 😊❤️

[@RenderingUser]

same for me and documentation for programming the docs are impeccable a lot of the time but i first need to be taught how to use it, what methodologies it follows, the patterns it recommends etc... otherwise i cannot make heads or tails of that documentation

[@abdo4khalil1001]

Amazing bro, and nice career as well :)

[@muhammadmahat6692]

Well said Subhanallah.. May Allah give you strength and fortune

[@azferahseng3411]

This is the best explanation in a very lame terms. I seek permission to use your analogy brother if it is ok

[@ejaj1783]

An-Najm[2-4] Your fellow man[Muḥammad (ﷺ)] neither misguided nor astray. Nor does he speak of his own whims. It is only a revelation sent down ˹to him˺.

[@Just_A_Stranger]

📜 Surah An-Nahl - 44 : *﴾ And We revealed to you the message [i.e., the Qur’ān] that you may make clear to the people what was sent down to them and that they might give thought ﴿* 📜 Surah Al-Ahzab - 36 : *﴾ It is not for a believing man or woman-when Allah and His Messenger decree a matter-to have any other choice in that matter. Indeed, whoever disobeys Allah and His Messenger has clearly gone ˹far˺ astray. ﴿*

[@ayeshheene4927]

Well quoted, brother ! One cannot be a muslim if s/he discards our beloved prophet's words.. It's clearly mentioned in the Quran. Rejection of His (peace be upon Him) sunnah (that are authentic, ofc), is Rejection of the requirement set by Allah to being a Muslim.

[@sacredrider]

Yes you are 100% right. Some may argue whether the hadith was protected or not, they can study the science of hadith to calm heart. But we are not in right to straight up reject what Allah has given

[@EuphoricPlaz]

If we stood behind different imams in prayers and during surah Fatiha one imam pronounced it "Malik" yawmi’d-din and the other pronounced it "Melik" yawmi’d-din is who said it correctly? The answer is both are correct. This is what nouman ali khan meant by if you question hadith. If you said one of them is wrong then this person does not know quran and you just claimed the word of Allah is wrong and this makes you not a muslim. Both Imams are correct because the prophet s.a.w said “Verily this Quran has been revealed in seven styles so recite it in a way that is easy for you from out of these.” Bukhari and muslim as stated in Mishkat vol.1, pg.414, hadith no.2211. This is why Quran and hadith cannot be separated "Malik" means king and "Melik" means owner. The prophet s.a.w lived the Quran he described as a walking Quran and without hadith, we would not know how to recite the Quran.

[@sarahyounes7509]

Sura 53: AN-NAJM (THE STAR) وَمَا يَنْطِقُ عَنِ الْهَوَى ﴿۳ ﴾ nor does he(Muhammad) speaks out of desire. (3) إِنْ هُوَ إِلَّا وَحْيٌ يُوحَى ﴿ ۴﴾ Indeed it is not except a Revelation which is revealed, (4) that is why we take hadith seriously

[@saidzihmmou6426]

you appeal to hadith by ambiguity: the messenger cannot say something on the religion except if God told him to. does that mean they have to be included to another source other than the original source that God gave him?

[@aikaadmi193]

'Why do you need a driving INSTRUCTOR, when the instruction MANUAL is enough?' Helps put the instructions into practice!

[@spag5296]

Perfect!

[@Ali-oj1sm]

Exactly

[@paulfast1893]

The difference is nobody ever claimed the manual instruction is enough

[@aikaadmi193]

@@paulfast1893 If the instruction manual isn't enough to explain what the car should do, don't buy that car! They don't know what they're doing :-)

[@saidzihmmou6426]

in the field of programing and in linux manuals are indeed enough. most skilled are those who read manuals and interpret them correctly

[@Cryprorax]

Don't worry Bobby, understanding the relationship between the Quran and Sunnah is actually quite simple. The Quran gives us the general guidance and principles, while the Sunnah provides us with the specific details on how to apply these principles in our daily lives. This is important because without the Sunnah, we would not have the specific instructions on how to perform important acts of worship such as prayer and fasting. Per example, Allah tell us to pray , but is not in the Coran how to do it. So, when we read the Quran, we should also seek guidance from the Sunnah to better understand how to apply its teachings in our lives. By doing this, we can achieve a deeper understanding of Islam and its teachings.

[@Leil2221]

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@abuethio23]

May Allah guide you in return of your effort in seeking the true religion

[@taherahmed650]

Please do a show with Muhammad Ali of the Muslim lantern channel. He has addressed this extensively.

[@sacredrider]

​@@taherahmed650 bro you should comment on the video, not reply on a comment

[@User-fc8pp]

The hadith explain praying hadsch fasting and many other things that are not in the quran but still in law our prophet sallalahu alaihi wa selam vorbade tho shave off one part of the Hair and letting the other Parts or leting the beard grow its a hadith but at the same time the same law is in the bibel and thora 3moses 19:27 You shall not cut your hair all around, nor shave your beard. Thats just one example of tons

[@syedmaazahmed6006]

AAMEEN-YA-RABBIL-AALAMIN

[@IQandRaceDifferences]

lol

[@mahdimohamedsani7410]

The prophet was a walking Qur'an. So learning the Qur'an from him is obviously incredibly important.

[@calebzeman3818]

Walking Qur'an !😕 Do you even understand what you are saying? Did our beloved Rasool (SAWS) ever interpreted Qur"an? He(SAWS) never did that because it was not required by Him (SAWS). It was not allowed to interpret , his (SAWS) role was just to deliver the message as it is. And Qur'an speaks by itself and one has to read pause and toil over the scripture to unravel the nuggets and true wisdom concealed there in every single word. Learn ... learn Abrahmic locution (Millat Ibrahim) to truly understand Qur'an. If you walk behind such Mullas and sheiks and Imaaams blindly with a herd mentality you would definitely mislead. And that is what happened to Islam since 1400 years (The dark age ) of Islam.

[@TheAdrianSmith]

@@calebzeman3818 well said

[@Fm-fz8dp]

​@@calebzeman3818 Beware my brother disbelief in the prophet's teachings is kufr. The prophet's teachings were only by revelation from Allah so you are required to follow them just as you are required to follow the Quran. Please go to scholars an have them clarify for you because not acknowledging the Sunnah and denying it and disbelieving in it is not acceptable in Islam.

[@Fm-fz8dp]

​@@TheAdrianSmith ​ Beware my brother disbelief in the prophet's teachings is kufr. The prophet's teachings were only by revelation from Allah so you are required to follow them just as you are required to follow the Quran. Please go to scholars an have them clarify for you because not acknowledging the Sunnah and denying it and disbelieving in it is not acceptable in Islam.

[@calebzeman3818]

@@Fm-fz8dp I believe in Qur'an, and that is what our beloved (SAWS) brought for us muslims, yes He (SAWS) taught many things as a Nabi and remember (SAWS) was a last Nabi for bani Israel and a last messenger for muslims and all humankind. Brother who proclaimed them as scholar? They even does not know the real interpretation of Qur'an and by the way which scholars are you referring to? is it Sunni, Shi'a, Maliki, Hammbali or Sufi? All of them have their own scholars and they all differ from each other and yet they all claim they are right !!! So kufr and Shirk happened and they all got divided and yet proclaim themselves as scholars of Islam and many follow them blindly only if they have understood the real essence of Qur'an this would have never happened. May Allah guide us all.

[@AlbaMBBT]

“Our Lord, and send among them a messenger from themselves who will recite to them "Your verses" and "teach" them "the Book" and "wisdom" and purify them. Indeed, You are the Exalted in Might, the Wise.” (Al-Baqarah 2:129).

[@deutscheislamischevereinig6814]

Dear Bobby, According to Christianity, Judaism and Islam, when God created Adam, he told the angles to prostrate before his creation. Then he commanded all the prophets to prostrate before the Kaaba. Then he commanded all believing people to love the prophets more than anything else in the world, be it their children, their wife or their parents. Loving the Prophet and expressing it in the most beautiful way is not worship. Worship means to believe that someone else has the power to help, cure or affect the world and submitting to this entity. For example, all scholars of Islam agree that taking medicine and believing that it cures in itself and not by Allah is disbelief (kufr). Doing Worship for someone else is also kufr. Then it becomes worship of that thing and not of Allah ta ala. However, it does not mean that one must not do anything to make one's parents or children happy - nor does it mean that doing something for the Prophet out of love, for example, is kufr. Moreover, scholars of Islam anonymously agree that all prophets are alive in their graves. The Quran states that they the martyrs are alive but we don’t perceive. What for would Allah ta ala keep the prophets alive if they weren’t important for us anymore or the message? Furthermore, the Quran says „If you love Allah, then follow me (my servant Muhammad) and Allah will love you etc. Allah clearly tells us to follow prophet Muhammad peace be upon him. But how do we follow him, through the Sunnah (his life). The Muslim Ummah is not flawless and some of our understanding of Islam of worship is based on trust and Hadith sciences. The important thing is that the Quean has laid the foundations of the believe and showed the way to God. The prophets weren’t there to prove that God exists but to prove that there is only one God to be worshipped, the one that created everything and has knowledge about all matters and things.

[@missb9628]

Yes and that wisdom are the hadith ❤️❤️❤️

[@AlbaMBBT]

@@missb9628 We understand islam upon the understanding of the Prophet saws and the sahaba without that everybody can come with their own version of Islam..

[@muhammadhamadan9951]

I was wondering why Mr. Noman Ali Khan didn't refer to this verse.

[@TheQuranist]

THE HIKMAH (WISDOM) IS NOT BASED ON THE HADITHS The mushriks like Sunnis and Shias love to twist Qur'an verses in an attempt to justify their fabricated sects that is leading them to Hell. And I've many times come across Sunnis who refer to this verse while they claim that the kitab is the Qur'an and the hikmah is the hadiths: رَبَّنَا وَٱبْعَثْ فِيهِمْ رَسُولًا مِّنْهُمْ يَتْلُوا۟ عَلَيْهِمْ ءَايَـٰتِكَ *وَيُعَلِّمُهُمُ ٱلْكِتَـٰبَ وَٱلْحِكْمَةَ* وَيُزَكِّيهِمْ إِنَّكَ أَنتَ ٱلْعَزِيزُ ٱلْحَكِيمُ (2:129) But in reality the kitab (book of rules) and the hikmah (wisdom (i.e. insight behind the rules) is refering to the same source (the Qur'an) since the Qur'an is both an important book that has rules which should be upheld, and a book with great wisdom. And here's an example from the Qur'an itself for proof: In the previous verses before 17:39 Allah mentions rules of wisdom, and then He says: ذَٰلِكَ مِمَّآ أَوْحَىٰٓ إِلَيْكَ رَبُّكَ مِنَ ٱلْحِكْمَةِ وَلَا تَجْعَلْ مَعَ ٱللَّـهِ إِلَـٰهًا ءَاخَرَ فَتُلْقَىٰ فِى جَهَنَّمَ مَلُومًا مَّدْحُورًا That is from what is revealed to thee (oh Muhammad) from thy Lord from the hikmah (wisdom). And make thou not with Allah another deity lest thou be cast into Jahannam, blameworthy and banished. (17:39) So, as you should see, the hikmah (wisdom) that the messenger would teach people according to the Qur'an 2:129, that is refering to wisdom which we may access from the Qur'an itself which contains wisdom from Allah.

[@RenderingUser]

34:17 one example off the top of my head, is the verse about killing the disbelievers used by extremist groups to justify unnecessary violence using the context from the hadith, we understand clearly what those verses talk about a time of war and Muslims were actually otherwise going to be killed by the enemies

[@muslima2505]

Bobby wallah I understand what you are going thru it took me years after becoming Muslim to finally understand, accept and have true love for the prophet PBUH

[@curious493]

The Hadith have been a blessing in my life. I especially appreciate the Duas of the prophet, saw. I feel closer to him when I try and do things as he did. My heart is lighter and it strengthens my faith. I lose nothing by following is example. May Allah guide all those who seek him, and May he bring us closer to the prophet, Amine.

[@omelett7579]

Aamiin

[@saidzihmmou6426]

i advise you to start reading quran. it is more powerful

[@Dont-worry1618]

@@saidzihmmou6426 I advise u to understand the Quran by the tafseer and Hadith. It is more powerful and gives a better understanding. Did u know without Hadith u cannot even understand Arabic or translate it. Cause of the ancient Arabic would’ve be extinct.

[@saidzihmmou6426]

@@Dont-worry1618 what to do if tafseers clashes?

[@Dont-worry1618]

@@saidzihmmou6426 The authentic ones don’t, if they do for some impossible reason. U choose the “majority” opinion

[@apagofie]

Brother, it seems your videos always answer the questions I have, I started watching your videos out of curiosity and it slowly turned into much more, thank you brother.

[@ahmedkhaledhussien8788]

{He who obeys the Messenger has obeyed Allah ; but those who turn away - We have not sent you over them as a guardian.} (4:80)

[@homer1273]

that verse that you are misusing is about those who turn away from the revelation and the messenger who came with the Quran, its not about the hadith of abuhuraira or bukhari which came later as you falsely trying to distort the word of Allah

[@ahmedkhaledhussien8788]

@@homer1273 Go learn instead of revealing your ignorance to people.

[@AbuAbdullahAlHanbali]

@@ahmedkhaledhussien8788he just said Abu hurayrah رضي الله عنه Didn’t he know that he was a companion😂😭🤦‍♂️ He lived at the time of the prophet ﷺ Aslam al-Qibti reported: The Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him, said, “Let me not find one of you reclining on his couch, when a command or prohibition of mine comes to him and he says: I do not know, we only follow what we find in the Book of Allah.” Source: Sunan al-Tirmidhī 2663 Grade: Sahih (authentic) according to Al-Albani عَنْ أسلم القبطي أَنَّ رَسُولَ اللَّهِ صَلَّى اللَّهُ عَلَيْهِ وَسَلَّمَ قَالَ لَا أُلْفِيَنَّ أَحَدَكُمْ مُتَّكِئًا عَلَى أَرِيكَتِهِ يَأْتِيهِ أَمْرٌ مِمَّا أَمَرْتُ بِهِ أَوْ نَهَيْتُ عَنْهُ فَيَقُولُ لَا أَدْرِي مَا وَجَدْنَا فِي كِتَابِ اللَّهِ اتَّبَعْنَاهُ 2663 سنن الترمذي كتاب العلم باب ما نهي عنه أن يقال عند حديث النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم 2663 المحدث الألباني خلاصة حكم المحدث صحيح في صحيح الترمذي

[@homer1273]

@@ahmedkhaledhussien8788 so you are lying and claiming that Allah was referring to the hadith when the Quran says "but those who turn away We have not sent you over them as a guardian"

[@muhammadtareq7191]

@@homer1273 how to pray tell me from quran ?

[@okdk2362]

Bobby as you said you are still learning, and so are we all. I would recommend you to ask an expert in Islam these questions, there are thousands of them that would each be more than happy to clarify any doubt and question you have. Watching videos can be useful, but they are not able answer follow up questions that may occur during the video. May Allah guide you and everyone inshallah.

[@mynmeisname4825]

Sheikh uthman bin Farooq could be asked I guess

[@melidali1]

I absolutely agree. It's not enough just to listen a video or two on this subject rather speak to someone who is knowledgeable who can answer everything in between.

[@haa8793]

Exactly yah let him ask mufti menk omar suleyman and son

[@Ravenoli10]

may allah guide you the straight path im really happy and proud of your sincerity brother i hope you find the answer that satisfies every question of yours

[@jejakakacak1220]

I love watching your journey to islam.. Allah put nabi muhammad as role model so hadith is a must.

[@Quran_Alone_Dawah]

Anything about Muhammad that is relevant is in the Qur'an. Following any hadith other than the Qur'an is forbidden: And in anything over which you disagree - *its ruling is [to be referred] to Allah.* [Say], "That is Allah , my Lord; upon Him I have relied, and to Him I turn back." 42:10 "One day We shall raise from all Peoples a witness against them, from amongst themselves: and We shall bring thee as a witness against these (thy people): and We have sent down to thee the *Book explaining all things* , a Guide, a Mercy, and Glad Tidings to Muslims." 16:89 "O People of the Scripture, there has come to you Our Messenger making clear to you much of what you used to conceal of the Scripture and overlooking much. There has come to you from Allah *a light and a clear Book* ." 5:15 "Alif, Lam, Ra. These are the verses of the *Book and a clear Qur'an* ." 15:1 "Shall I seek other than Allah for judge, when He it is Who hath *revealed unto you (this) Scripture, fully explained* ? Those unto whom We gave the Scripture (aforetime) know that it is revealed from thy Lord in truth. So be not thou (O Muhammad) of the waverers." 6:114 " *A Book whose verses have been detailed* , an Arabic Qur'an for a people who know," 41:3 " *Thus do We explain the signs in detail* ; and perchance they may turn (unto Us)." 7:174 "And when We read it, follow thou the reading;" 75:18 "Nay more, *it is for Us to explain it (and make it clear)* : 75:19 "For We had certainly sent unto them a Book, based on knowledge, *which We explained in detail* ,- a guide and a mercy to all who believe." 7:52 "And they do not come to you with an argument except that *We bring you the truth and the best explanation* ." 25:33 " *Allah has sent down the best hadith* : a consistent Book wherein is reiteration. The skins shiver therefrom of those who fear their Lord; then their skins and their hearts relax at the remembrance of Allah. That is the guidance of Allah by which He guides whom He wills. And one whom Allah leaves astray - for him there is no guide." 39:23 "These are the verses of Allah which We recite to you in truth. *Then in what hadith after Allah and His verses will they believe?* " 45:6 "Then in what *hadith* after the Qur'an will they believe?" 77:50 So obey Allah, and obey His Messenger: but if ye turn back, *the duty of Our Messenger is but to proclaim (the Message) clearly and openly* . 64:12 "Say, "Obey Allah and obey the Messenger; but if you turn away - then upon him is only that [duty] with which he has been charged, and upon you is that with which you have been charged. And if you obey him, you will be [rightly] guided. *And there is not upon the Messenger except the [responsibility for] clear notification* ." 24:54 *The most merciful* 55:1 "It is *He* Who has taught the Qur'an." 55:2 " *The guiding of them is not thy duty* (O Muhammad), but Allah guideth whom He will. And whatsoever good thing ye spend, it is for yourselves, when ye spend not save in search of Allah's Countenance; and whatsoever good thing ye spend, it will be repaid to you in full, and ye will not be wronged." 2:272 "And We have certainly diversified in this Qur'an for the people from *every [kind of] example* ; *but man has ever been, most of anything, [prone to] dispute.* " 18:54 "Say, " Allah is most knowing of how long they remained. He has [knowledge of] the unseen [aspects] of the heavens and the earth. How Seeing is He and how Hearing! They have not besides Him any protector, and *He shares not His legislation with anyone.* "" 18:26 “You worship not besides Him except [mere] names you have named them, you and your fathers, for which Allah has sent down no authority. *Legislation is not but for Allah.* He has commanded that you worship not except Him. That is the correct religion, but most of the people do not know.” 18:40

[@samkerzal]

​@@Quran_Alone_Dawahit's sad these people on a path of extremism. Literally says this book is complete.

[@simu3503]

The last point he made is very important. Little knowledge is a dangerous thing. There is so much depth and context that you cannot get by just reading a translation of the Quran.

[@naimahmed3720]

Definitely addressed Bobby with that last point, in my opinion.

[@asikalahi7770]

I think Bobby is finding it hard to understand it. He is kind of going round in circles. Without the Sunnah we will become like Christians make up interpretation as we go along. Also if he wants to take his Shahada tomorrow he has to follow the prophets sunnah to take shahada. For some reason it seems like he doesn't want to believe in hadiths constantly playing devil's advocate.

[@simu3503]

@@asikalahi7770 everyone goes through this learning phase. I'm sure as bobby goes more deeper beyond surface level understanding of Islam he'll understand.

[@asikalahi7770]

@@simu3503 that's correct. I am more worried about our lay Muslims falling for this type of thinking. So it could be at times dangerous for us to be consuming someone else's perspective on our deen. It might be a good idea for him to go meet a real sheikh and ask his questions to him.

[@muhtasimmahin5057]

@@asikalahi7770 i agree 100%..he should ask proper student of knowledge or sheikh.

[@abdoutech6861]

We submit to what the prophet pbuh has said NOT to him there's a huge difference, because everything he says, literally everything, is directly from Allah whether it's Quran or his day to day judgments and sayings, as Allah said: "your companion is neither astray, neither errs, (2) nor does he speak out of desire. (3) Indeed it is not except a Revelation which is revealed, (4) taught by One who is Stern in power. (5)" Surah:53

[@muslima2505]

Truth

[@sacredrider]

Well, there is a difference in submitting as well. I submit to my father too, he is superior to me in our household. Does that mean I worship him?

[@muslima2505]

@@sacredrider Valid point

[@EuphoricPlaz]

💯

[@TechnoMazing]

This is about the Quran itself! If you say the Quran is inseparable or even comparable to anything else, that's condescending to the Quran, not raising to the other. And Please note that Allah blamed the prophet pbuh twice in the Quran. The submission is to accept the judgment of the prophet in the matters they fought/argued about because he is the prophet and messenger of Allah. Of course, the hadith (the Mutawatir) is essential for religion. But the dilemma here is due to having hadiths that are in complete contradiction to the Quran and sometimes seem "heresy" and "blasphemy"! And before you call me names, here are some unacceptable examples: 1- Hadith that says there was a verse allowing "Breastfeeding Adult Strangers" for the woman to remove her hijab in front of those strangers! 2- Hadith about a verse that was eaten by a goat and didn't make it to the "written Quran"! (The stoning verse), even though the Quran was memorized and recited! 3- Abrogation of a Quran verse with a hadith! the whole Abrogation/cancellation of the verses of the Quran is a complicated and controversial subject, but, the prophet would never abrogate/cancel the judgment of Allah and implement his own! 4- The "satanic verses" hadith, in which the prophet confused Satan with Jebril and told the people to worship Ellat and Elozza idols thinking it was a revelation from Allah, but Allah sent Jebril to correct him! 5- All the hadiths about the prophet's sexual interactions (arguably all were told by a single individual) don't adhere to the prophet's nature! Would the prophet share his private life with his wives with anyone? Was that person there with him (May Allah forgive me)??? Of course not, yet many hadiths of this nature exist in the sahih. - The main point is, of course, we wouldn't be able to properly implement the Quran in our lives and worship Allah in the right way without the Mutawatir hadith. The Mutawatir hadiths are the teachings of the prophet to all Muslims, not to one or two persons. The goal is to please Allah and hopefully earn his mercy and forgiveness. May Allah have mercy and forgive us all.

[@Nerumonn]

Hello Bobby, I truly respect what you're doing and I am so excited for you to join Islam Inshallah. The Sunnah is to demonstrate what is in the Quran, so we know how exactly to pray or do hajj for example. Allah instructed us to follow him and his messenger Mohammed PBUH, his teachings, his lifestyle, his manners, his choices, etc... and Sunnah is there for us to follow him. All in the end to please Allah SWT.

[@omarhassan1897]

Allah says, "O you who believe, obey Allah and His Messenger ... " [Al-Qur'an 8:20] "Say: obey Allah and obey the Messenger ... " [Al-Qur'an 24:54] He says, "Obey Allah and the Messenger and perhaps you will be shown mercy." [Al-Qur'an 3:132] "If you obey him, you will be guided ... " [Al-Qur'an 24:54] "Whoever obeys the Messenger has obeyed Allah ... " [Al-Qur'an 4:79] "That what the Messenger brings you and leave what he forbids you ... " [Al-Qur'an 59:7] "Whoever obeys Allah and the Messenger is with those whom Allah has blessed." [Al-Qur'an 4:68] "We did not send any Messenger but for him to be obeyed by the permission of Allah." [Al-Qur'an 4:63]

[@Soul-N-Shell]

This issue isn't disobedience to our beloved prophet I don't believe the Hadiths are actually his actual sayings

[@sajidulislamskilled]

@@Soul-N-Shell yea fair enough, also nobody is asking to believe every single hadiths blindly, then why you're given brain? right? now, it's very simple that hadiths won't be preserved for eternity like the Quran, but rejecting completely would be wrong and foolish. Don't need to be an extremist. Quran an instruction manual and the Hadith as an explanation on how to act upon instruction. I have faith in Allah alone but Allah instructed me to trust his messenger because Allah chose him and Allah is the best of decision makers. Now just because hadiths are not preserved one have to reject it completely? it's ridiculous. Just because some science theory proven wrong doesn't mean one have to reject science facts completely. That's absurd.

[@Soul-N-Shell]

@@sajidulislamskilled I find no error in your statments , Thank you

[@keyonwilkins7085]

It’ll help to hear the entirety of what somebody says before arguing against it

[@rahmanwaelah4522]

agree

[@cheikhsaadbousall6695]

Im getting sick of it tbh

[@TheBobbysPerspective]

Wouldn't be a live honest reaction then.

[@rahmanwaelah4522]

@@TheBobbysPerspective u can hear it untill someone speak the argument and u can argue later if u want so he can make the point . sometime if u interupt in the middle u not understand the whole what the person want to say. im not good in english -_- . good in listening only. i think its really simple why u need hadist but i dont get it why u not understand

[@shansiddiqui4953]

This video cements your channel as one of the Top Ten on KZbin in my opinion. Well done. Your desire to learn is pure motivation for me.

[@mohammedh1106]

Simple way to put it, the Quran is the word of Allah and hadith is based around the life of prophet (saw) and also his companions where we learn how prophet (saw) lived his life and we do our best to replicate as much as we can, as he lived his life perfectly with no error in accordance to the Quran. We are told to pray in the Quran, with hadith we are taught through prophet Muhammad (saw) on how our prayers should be prayed. That’s just one example and i hope this helps.

[@AbuAbdullahAlHanbali]

Aslam al-Qibti reported: The Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him, said, “Let me not find one of you reclining on his couch, when a command or prohibition of mine comes to him and he says: I do not know, we only follow what we find in the Book of Allah.” Source: Sunan al-Tirmidhī 2663 Grade: Sahih (authentic) according to Al-Albani عَنْ أسلم القبطي أَنَّ رَسُولَ اللَّهِ صَلَّى اللَّهُ عَلَيْهِ وَسَلَّمَ قَالَ لَا أُلْفِيَنَّ أَحَدَكُمْ مُتَّكِئًا عَلَى أَرِيكَتِهِ يَأْتِيهِ أَمْرٌ مِمَّا أَمَرْتُ بِهِ أَوْ نَهَيْتُ عَنْهُ فَيَقُولُ لَا أَدْرِي مَا وَجَدْنَا فِي كِتَابِ اللَّهِ اتَّبَعْنَاهُ 2663 سنن الترمذي كتاب العلم باب ما نهي عنه أن يقال عند حديث النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم 2663 المحدث الألباني خلاصة حكم المحدث صحيح في صحيح الترمذي

[@User-fc8pp]

The hadith explain praying hadsch fasting and many other things that are not in the quran but still in law our prophet sallalahu alaihi wa selam vorbade tho shave off one part of the Hair and letting the other Parts or leting the beard grow its a hadith but at the same time the same law is in the bibel and thora 3moses 19:27 You shall not cut your hair all around, nor shave your beard. Thats just one example of tons

[@antoniobanderas1906]

▪️Islam is not based upon a Religion. ▪️Islam is not based upon sectarianism. ▪️Islam is not based upon empty rituals. ▪️Islam is not based upon wasting money on Hajj and Umrah ritual. ▪️Islam is not based upon man made hadith books ▪️Islam is not based upon following man made sharia laws. ▪️Islam is not based upon superstitions, dogmas ▪️Islam is not based upon Idol worship. ▪️Islam is not based upon Prophet/Messenger worship. ▪️Islam is not based upon saints/clerics/mullahs/Imams worship. ▪️Islam is not based upon grave worship. ▪️Islam is not based upon ego worship. ▪️Islam is not based upon committing Jihad for political or sectarian reasons. ▪️Islam is not based upon torturing oneself and abandoning the enjoyments of life. ▪️Islam is not based upon applying blasphemy laws to suppress minorities. ▪️Islam is not based upon myths, illusions, absurdities, ignorance, blind imitation of others, assumption (conjecture), prejudice, whims and desires. ▪️Islam is not based upon regression and isolationism. ▪️Islam is not based upon extremism. ▪️Islam is not based upon radicalism. ▪️Islam is not based upon terrorism. ▪️Islam is not based upon racism. ▪️Islam is not based upon Arab culture. ▪️Islam is not based upon wearing beard and cap. ▪️Islam is not based upon wearing Hijab, Niqab or burqa. ▪️Islam is not based upon superiority complex or inferiority complex. ▪️Islam is not based upon building lavishing sectarian label mosques. ▪️Islam is not based upon committing suicide. 🔸 The Quran The COLLECTED AYATS, -The Final and Complete Message from GOD Proof that the Quran is final, complete and the one and only acceptable source of Islamic guidance-law : ▪️Some AYATS muḥ'kamātun-absolutely clear and others mutashābihātun-allegorical for a reason (3:7) ▪️GOD never runs out of words (31:27) The Quran is without a doubt clear guidance (huda) (2:2) ▪️The Quran is clear proof (burhan) from GOD (4:174) ▪️The Quran is complete (6:115) (6:38) The Quran is fully detailed (fussilat) of all things (6:114) (12:111) (41:3) (11:1) ▪️The Quran is clarification (tibyana) of all things (16:89) ▪️The Quran provides its own best explanation (ahsan tafsir) (25:33) The Quran is the ultimate scale (mizaan) (42:17) ▪️The Quran is evidence (bayyinah) (20:133) ▪️The Quran is the criterion (furqan) between right and wrong (25:1) ▪️God forbids people from following any law except THE GOD’s laws in the Quran (6:114) ▪️Whoever judges by other than the Quran, they are Kafir (ingrates-disbelievers) (5:44) ▪️The best HADITH (statement) is GOD’s statement (the Quran) (39:23) ▪️The Quran forbids you from following or believing in something without understanding it (17:36) ▪️The Quran expects you to study and think deeply about its AYATS (47:24) ▪️THE GOD protects the Quran from human tampering / corruption (15:9) ▪️No one can alter GOD’s words (6:115) Don’t spread false information / say a lie against THE GOD (16:116)  ▪️The Quran is in Arabic but only due to circumstances ▪️How the Quran was transmitted and preserved ▪️Muhammad is the seal of the prophets and the Quran is the last book of THE GOD (33:40) 🔸Islam is based upon a system❗️ ▪️Islam is based upon monotheism. ▪️Islam is based upon GOD ALONE well as HIS WORD ALONE ▪️Islam is based upon doing good deeds-acts-works ▪️Islam is based upon setting aside portion of earning for those in need ▪️Islam is based upon helping poor and needy. ▪️Islam is based upon doing betterment for society. ▪️Islam is based upon doing good for humanity. ▪️Islam is based upon helping people regardless of their age, gender, race, ethnicity, color and religion. ▪️Islam is based upon wearing decent dress. ▪️Islam is based upon applying equality, justice and freedom in their societies/communities. ▪️Islam is based upon human rights. ▪️Islam is based upon giving rights to minorities. ▪️Islam is based upon enjoying happy and peaceful life. ▪️Islam is based upon learning, thinking, logic, reasoning and intellect. ▪️Islam is based upon emphasizing on education and globalization 🔸BEST GARMENT IS THE CONSCIOUSNESS, QURAN CONDUCTS CONSCIOUS IN MANKIND'S LIVES

[@IQandRaceDifferences]

like the satanic verses as proposed correctly about muhammed taking diction from shaitan

[@MOF-H]

His question is abt the credibility of hadith where it is written 100 years after prophet passed away.

[@mudassirhotak7131]

📜 Surah Al-Ahzab - 36 : ﴾ It is not for a believing man or woman-when Allah and His Messenger decree a matter-to have any other choice in that matter. Indeed, whoever disobeys Allah and His Messenger has clearly gone ˹far˺ astray. ﴿ "Say (O Prophet): “If you really love Allah, then follow me, and Allah shall love you" Quran 3-31

[@shahid1071]

Thank you brother ❤️

[@kamellechekhab_official]

i feel like Bobby seems to have made up his mind on this subject, and he doesn't seem to be anticipating any other opinions to the contrary, so perhaps he needs to speak with an authority about it one-on-one so that he can ask all the questions he has. Perhaps that's a more effective format than reacting to videos.

[@rukkyxarat]

You are right , he has alread made up his mind , there are so many people who translate quran the way they want . Which is make me so happy that we have hadith to guide our understanding

[@asikalahi7770]

I agree. I hope he goes to a scholar and asks question instead of reacting to a video. Causing nothing but fithna

[@saidzihmmou6426]

he wants things clear. and hadith is not.

[@mynmeisname4825]

@@saidzihmmou6426 really? Without hadith u won't even know detailed way of prayer

[@kamellechekhab_official]

@@saidzihmmou6426 hadiths are clear, but you need to put some work, but if he's research is only reacting to videos on KZbin then good luck .

[@SasukeUchiha-pv4xn]

In simple terms the Quran repeatedly calls us to follow the Quran and the sunnah as the sunnah is also on the commandment of Allah. Hadith are a primary source of that sunnah as there is no other source that records the sunnah so meticulously.

[@MizzHayat]

We are Muslims here from years by birth and still learning Quran and Islam. Personally i read a verse and derived or understood it in different ways in different phases of my life. you have just started it. There is long way for u to go. If Quran each word has to be explained, it will make thousands of books and still it wont be explained sufficient. This is its miracle. We are blessed and thankful to Allah for making it somewhat easy for us to understand by looking at Prophet Mohammed PBUH life. If this Sunnah was not there I don’t think we would be able to understand what we have understood till now. Do not get yourself stuck on this point. May be not now but over the years when your knowledge and understanding will expand, you ll come to the conclusion your self that Prophet’s life and saying are absolute guidance. We do not worship the Prophet PBUH as shirk is the biggest of all sins. We are very cautious of it.

[@AbuAbdullahAlHanbali]

Aslam al-Qibti reported: The Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him, said, “Let me not find one of you reclining on his couch, when a command or prohibition of mine comes to him and he says: I do not know, we only follow what we find in the Book of Allah.” Source: Sunan al-Tirmidhī 2663 Grade: Sahih (authentic) according to Al-Albani عَنْ أسلم القبطي أَنَّ رَسُولَ اللَّهِ صَلَّى اللَّهُ عَلَيْهِ وَسَلَّمَ قَالَ لَا أُلْفِيَنَّ أَحَدَكُمْ مُتَّكِئًا عَلَى أَرِيكَتِهِ يَأْتِيهِ أَمْرٌ مِمَّا أَمَرْتُ بِهِ أَوْ نَهَيْتُ عَنْهُ فَيَقُولُ لَا أَدْرِي مَا وَجَدْنَا فِي كِتَابِ اللَّهِ اتَّبَعْنَاهُ 2663 سنن الترمذي كتاب العلم باب ما نهي عنه أن يقال عند حديث النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم 2663 المحدث الألباني خلاصة حكم المحدث صحيح في صحيح الترمذي

[@atlasatlantis8447]

Allah would not make following him, something you need to study extensively for. Infact, every single person when they are about to do something wrong, feels it in their hearts they are doing wrong. He tells everyone his law, through their hearts. People often choose to follow a book, over this feeling. And they hen do what is wrong. Make no mistake, Satan uses these books against us. By the book without thinking and felling out what Allah wants, will get you in trouble.

[@tazkiyaharts]

Bobby, I really appreciate your sincerity in trying to understand it and look for answers that satisfy you and if you choose to come into Islam, you come with 100% of yourself, which is sign of your sincerity. I am really appreciating the process. For other Muslims, I would like you to grant grace to Bobby as he is literally being vulnerable and sharing his thought process and looking for the answers. You are seeing him discover Iman using his rationality. Make dua for him and help him because you don't know what will open the door :) and provide the satisfactory answer,. have patience.

[@muslima2505]

Absolutely ❤

[@ahmadmanga]

Yes, I'm actually amazed at how I'm learning from him... When I tell him what I know, I'm not saying it to hasten his understanding. These things take time. I'm just answering his questions... You never know which statement gets you on the right path.

[@saidzihmmou6426]

ibrahim believed because of God because he was rational

[@xGemz_]

The context of every revelation is huge to the understanding of it, hadith has records of when, why, how. Also says in quran obey allah and obey the messenger. How do we obey allah? Through accepting and implementing quran teachings, how do we obey the messenger? Its not like we obey mohammad by obeying allahs words, well sunnah ofc.

[@salammaamur735]

For God so love the world that HE sent to us a clear BOOK and a capable TEACHER.. so that we would be rightly guided.

[@muhammadnursultan9704]

Isn't that fabricated bible verse

[@mdoumair6897]

You have an excellent model in the Messenger of Allah, for all who put their hope in Allah and the Last Day and remember Allah much. (Surat al-Ahzab :21) You should accept whatever the Messenger gives you and abandon whatever he tells you to abandon. Have taqwa of Allah... (Surat al-Hashr: 7) O you who believe, obey Allah, the Messenger, and those in command among you. If you disagree about something, refer it back to Allah and the Messenger, if you believe in Allah and the Last Day. That is the best thing to do and gives the best result. (Surat an-Nisa`: 59) When Allah and His Messenger have decided something, no believing man or woman has a choice about [following or not following] it. Anyone who disobeys Allah and His Messenger is clearly misguided. (Surat al-Ahzab: 36) Why we should follow Hadith? Because Allah says to follow His Messanger.

[@abdullahalawadhi7489]

Yeah exactly if one were to deny the Hadith then one would deny the Quran as Nouman states I.E you cannot accept the message without accepting the messenger if done so it wouldn't even make sense that's why we have the SHAHADA.

[@mahatabdiabdullahi5527]

Quran is the message . The Suna is the practical implimentation

[@monjurrahim3950]

Please read: sura 5:92 and sura 16:82 [5:92] “You shall obey GOD, and you shall obey the messenger, and beware. If you turn away, then know that the sole duty of our messenger is to deliver the message efficiently.” [16:82] “If they still turn away, then your sole mission is the clear delivery (of the message).”

[@sphinkstrenic462]

Prophet Muhammad pbuh is the walking Qur'an. 😊😊😊❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@Mm-so7to]

Well this man is way out of his mind. He want to Jerry pick. Too bad for him he has to believe allah and prophet Mohammed (saw) if he doesn't he see someday.

[@sacredrider]

​@@Mm-so7to give him some time. When you were lied to about your religion your whole life, it is normal to be very skeptical.

[@LearnFromTheLight]

@@Mm-so7to Don’t assume brother, I was once like Bobby when it comes to the Hadith, and I sought out to learn as he is learning at the moment, it takes time. May Allah guide those dealing with this.

[@sjappie5034]

He is still learning. I hope he learns about the Rasul SAW more and more inshallah

[@angryzombie8088]

@@Mm-so7to being skeptical is good. A blind faith is what makes Trinity, Original Sin, eating body of Christ & drinking blood of Christ a thing in Christianity. Verifying the Hadith requires skepticism.

[@shahidhafiz]

Dear Bobby, Alhumdulilah you have a lot of knowledge already. Of course, we all still have a lot more to learn to improve our understanding of our beautiful deen. But most importantly we need to learn to passionately love and respect our beautiful Prophet Mohammed pbuh. In fact , as you know, we need to love him even more than we love our own dearest parents. Wow - that takes some doing. InShaAllah we all will have such love for Prophet Mohammed pbuh as soon as we can - and definitely within our short lives. Ameen. Praying Allah SWT guides you towards His only decreed Deen very soon - Ameen. ❤

[@samirasaid2144]

“Indeed there is in the Messenger of Allah a perfect role model for the one who hopes in Allah and the last day and (who) remembers Allah much.” لَّقَدْ كَانَ لَكُمْ فِي رَسُولِ اللَّـهِ أُسْوَةٌ حَسَنَةٌ لِّمَن كَانَ يَرْجُو اللَّـهَ وَالْيَوْمَ الْآخِرَ وَذَكَرَ اللَّـهَ كَثِيرًا Surah Al Ahzab, v.21

[@Kobenoz]

Once, a teacher said to me: "I challenge you to practice - minimum - the 5 pillars of Islam only from the Quranic text, not from any other sources. Come back to me when you can do it...". I met him in the daytime, and then I come back in the evening after I exhaust my brain trying to do so, and end up with none (even for just one pillar; salah)...

[@090909RjJ]

Because 5 pillars came after God completed his deen, sectarian following.

[@mikael9540]

I do everything Allah commanded me to do without looking at the hadith.

[@bartstecca]

So you're basically saying that the Qur'an is not enough

[@Kobenoz]

@@bartstecca Did you ever watched the video?! If you did, but you still asking that question, I don't know what else...

[@090909RjJ]

@El Kobenoz you surrendered to the obligations of a teacher, man! I wonder what source of law you comply to since Allah said produce one surah like this (2:23) [Quran 6:114] Shall I seek other than God as a source of law, when He has revealed this book fully detailed? And some foolish teacher asks you something, you don't even question his authority?? And you've exhausted your brain too? [Quran 6:36] ..We did not leave anything out of this book.. WE MADE THE QURAN EASY TO LEARN [54:17] You're not very wise, are you?

[@walidbinmusa]

Hi Bobby.. to give an example of dangerous conclusions, I would use one your other videos where there was a debate between liberal and conservative Muslims. In that video, there was, although labeled herself as conservative, gay and interpreted the Qura'an as saying yes it is ok to be gay in Islam. That is why we need the Hadith.

[@yousless1592]

You should talk with uthman ibn farooq now that you have more insight into islam then you did before you talked to him, he can clear up all your doubts about islam.

[@khairilzikri7]

He already did that. But he still skeptic about it even after Sheikh Uthman's explanation.

[@yousless1592]

@@khairilzikri7 Not really his first conversation from what i can see cleared up many of his doubts, but since his first conversation he has gained much more knowledge and thus can ask more questions.

[@TheHaloSeries]

Prophet Muhammad PBUH is the best of humanity and Allah himself chose him to be the last of the prophets and messengers which is the greatest honor a human could get. We as worshipers of Allah have to love prophet Muhammad more than we love ourselves. He is the role model Allah chose for us therefore we have to know him more so we can be more like him.

[@TheHaloSeries]

Every human being needs a human role model and since God is not human then who would be the perfect candidate to occupy such a role?

[@najehaltaher7988]

We know that we have to pray from the Quran, but we know how to pray from the Hadith. Hope that helps

[@mehakkhan9575]

Even the transitions of Quran are done wrong and are not reliable than how come you trust hadith

[@Zak-gl4ig]

Not from Hadith, not primarily anyway. On the contrary, we learn to pray from the living Sunnah. Practical elements of our religion were passed on practically via the living tradition of the Muslim community. I'm sure you'll agree that you learnt to make wudhu, to pray, fast etc from your parents and the Mosque teachers. You didn't just pick up a book of Hadith and learn it from there.

[@unscripted_mobile8238]

​@@Zak-gl4igmy brother you have missed the point, where did your parents and Muslim get it from?, from the hadith which is the words of the prophet. Don't complicate simple things

[@Zak-gl4ig]

@@unscripted_mobile8238 I disagree. They got it the same way we did: from their parents and from the community. It's a living practical tradition that started with the community of the Prophet (pbuh). I'm not saying they didn't look at Hadith when they were older, but that's not how they first learnt it.

[@TheQuranExplainsItself]

The idea that prayer has a “how” comes from Hadiths so it has nothing to do with the Quran does it.

[@ghazialwan8121]

You can be Muslim with only belief in the Quran, this is completely true in the 5 pillars if Islam. Anyone who says otherwise is directly contradicting Islam and there are alot of people that do. Bless you brother you are right 100% and people fall into idol worship and we see this happening in multiple places in the Muslim Omah

[@a4482921]

Keep on learning Bobby. We are learning with you. These questions you have are shared by many Muslims as well. Regarding Hadith, with time and experience you may see how the process of actualising Quranic guidance in real life needs further elaboration. Now this elaboration can come from our own desires, the scholarship, culture and tradition, hadith, etc. From this need arises the multiple disciplines of jurisprudence, usuluddin and usul fiqh. You will soon see that it’s not as simple as opening the Quran and interpreting it personally. The Devil, they say, is in the details.

[@dawoodwilliams3652]

It doesn't need further elaboration from outside sources, you were born with ability to use reason and logic, so use it.

[@RsZ789]

One thing to remember Bobby is without the sunnah, we can interpret verses however we want. Deviant Muslim groups do that today, and you know a common characteristic of them? They put down or completely reject the hadith Because it clarifies the true meaning.

[@mtl_yg]

cant comes with a t

[@byooob]

I'm a muslim and it's crazy how far some sheikhs have to go to make hadith part of the quran, they're willing to follow a hadith that explicitly contradicts the quran and just ignore the verse, because they've decided that hadith is like the quran. And Nouman here 8:16 is falling into, he's literally saying that God didn't say that we should follow the quran (?????)but he said that we should follow the prophet, that's a dangerous thing to say and to do. the problem here is that he's reading the verse through the lense of trying to proving hadith, which actually distorts the true meaning of the verse which just says if two people are in conflict they should seek the prophet to solve the issue BECAUSE the prophet received the word of God and he's gonna use the word of god to judge between the two. The verse has absolutely nothing to do with hadith.

[@dilarakaratas9939]

Bobby as a born Muslima, I am learning so much more together with you because of your journey to Islam. As I listen to you, I already can hear that you have accepted Islam, may Allah give you the courage to take the Shahada because you deserve the truth after so much research. Your research will even continue after you become Muslim Insha'Allah because there is so much to learn. I wish nothing but the best for you and your family, may Allah bless you! 🥰✨

[@IQandRaceDifferences]

about 25% of born muslims are leaving the faith and others cannot leave because of family or societal pressures so they can only try to convert westerners hence the validation they seek.

[@magzumboyalcapone]

Sis you seem to be fellow kazakh ) I really encourage you to go to sheikh assim al hakeem's channel and also shiekh salim al amry.

[@hamadalkhalifa2323]

But he doesn't accept that Hadith is another revelation from Allah. And he doesn't accept that the Prophet Muhammad Pbuh is the greatest of all messengers.

[@TheBobbysPerspective]

@@hamadalkhalifa2323 why would I accept that hadith are revelation from God, when it clearly says that those are Sayings and not revelations. Why would I accept Muhammad as the greatest, if the Quran says to make no destiniction between the messengers?

[@Shafin15]

​​@@TheBobbysPerspective some laymans in the comments will make baseless claims. And if you have questions why not ask them(people with knowledge) directly? You did this before. Why not do those instead of just click baiting the laymans.

[@toobamukhtar2103]

This is the same question that was raised in my mind about Hadith. The verse you quoted, Bobby, I got it as I believe you got its meaning. Quran is simple. We don't need to complicate it. Where I was raised, I disliked certain things in Islam. Later on, I got to know the truth that those things were never mentioned in the Quran, so my heart automatically rejected them.

[@saadmalik1016]

Beautiful 👍 reaction brother. As its mentioned in the Quran that the Prophet Muhammad (SAW) don’t talk by himself what he tells or talk is from Allah so follow Allah and his messanger, thats why hadiths are very important.

[@AbuAbdullahAlHanbali]

Aslam al-Qibti reported: The Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him, said, “Let me not find one of you reclining on his couch, when a command or prohibition of mine comes to him and he says: I do not know, we only follow what we find in the Book of Allah.” Source: Sunan al-Tirmidhī 2663 Grade: Sahih (authentic) according to Al-Albani عَنْ أسلم القبطي أَنَّ رَسُولَ اللَّهِ صَلَّى اللَّهُ عَلَيْهِ وَسَلَّمَ قَالَ لَا أُلْفِيَنَّ أَحَدَكُمْ مُتَّكِئًا عَلَى أَرِيكَتِهِ يَأْتِيهِ أَمْرٌ مِمَّا أَمَرْتُ بِهِ أَوْ نَهَيْتُ عَنْهُ فَيَقُولُ لَا أَدْرِي مَا وَجَدْنَا فِي كِتَابِ اللَّهِ اتَّبَعْنَاهُ 2663 سنن الترمذي كتاب العلم باب ما نهي عنه أن يقال عند حديث النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم 2663 المحدث الألباني خلاصة حكم المحدث صحيح في صحيح الترمذي

[@homer1273]

you make no sense!! so if prophet Muhmmed went to the market to buy tomatoes whatever he says to the tomato seller you consider that also from Allah???? the hadith itself even says prophet Muhammed told people to ignore what he says from himself and only follow what he received from Allah, which is the Quran

[@allawi4605]

@Will Simp I see u commenting alot haha, what's your faith brother ?

[@jazzjazz7627]

@@homer1273 quote the Hadith that said so I challenge you

[@aliselmani8207]

MashaAllah, glad that it was crystal clear to you, but you got to have this on mind, not everyone has your understanding, everyone is tested differently! :)

[@blackseasultan]

I like ur thought process and agree with u I have a problem with a loot of Hadith because the first Hadith book was written 200 years after the death off the prophet Mohammad sallallahu alaihi wasallam and am from his family and from sulyman ben daoud sallallhu alaihom wasallam

[@NurSa3id]

"Say (O Prophet): “If you really love Allah, then follow me, and Allah shall love you" Quran 3-31 ALLAH Himself directly orders us to follow His prophet, meaning following the Sunnah, which we learn through Hadith.

[@sacredrider]

This really gives me the vibes of I am the way, the truth and the life. No one comes to Father except through me. Prophets do get the same message, from the same source

[@abdullahalawadhi7489]

​@@sacredrider oh that's amazing I just saw the connection, man people trying to take the Quran but not take the teachings of the one who was sent to bring us the Quran

[@sacredrider]

@@abdullahalawadhi7489 Allah says He Himself would take Prophet's life if he had spoke lies, I am not sure where this quranist view came from except ignorance of a person

[@omij6790]

In Arabic, 'you' has a singular, for just one person and a 'you' for multiple/plural. For example, inta is masculine for saying "you" to one male. And inti is feminine to one female. But intu is 'you' for multiple people, hence inta for one male, and in the verse, that one male is Muhammad (as).

[@samattulpar506]

I have been watching your reaction videos Boby, I like your way of stating the facts and asking the rational questions. When I was learning Islam at first that question crossed my mind too, later I am in love with reading the life stories of prophet Muhammad pbuh and my understanding of islam depends. My conclusion is no body can truly represent islam as prophet Muhammad pbuh, it doesn't matter how much great of a scholar or whoever great person is, Prophet Muhammad is the living example of the Quran. We understand and appreciate the Quran better through understanding the life stories of Prophet Muhammad because the revelation itself is very tightly related to the events of the prophets life. On top of that believing the prophets of Allah is one of the articles of the islamic faith. What does it mean believing the prophets it means following their examples and their teachings therefore Headith and Sunnah is important.

[@nothuman1640]

Nauman Ali khan is such a gem for this ummah right now ❤️ His story about how he came closer to Islam is such wholesome 🥺 you should watch that

[@nothuman1640]

@@chiccojunior5235 shut up fool... Don't bark here if you don't have any work to do go do some work I know him pretty well even if I haven't him in person Such a pity 😒

[@nothuman1640]

@@chiccojunior5235 oh so now you jumped to this new topic i see... I've talked to many Hindus and all of them are the same,they don't have anything g4to speak after 1 or 2 comments then they just start talking BS like what you are doing right now... Why are you so concerned about does Islam teaches us manners or not, rather I would like to tell you that Islam teaches us that Allah is the only God worthy of worship and prophet Muhammad (p.b.u.h) is the final messenger Then believe that as well

[@ahmedkhaledhussien8788]

As you said it yourself before, Bobby: "Where else would we know it from, if not from the hadiths?"

[@ahmedkhaledhussien8788]

Quote from Bobby's live with Daniel.

[@mikidias]

Your Holy Qur'an Kareem 📖 isn't it enough⁉️❓ Astaghfirullah❗ 😨 Glad I'm not even Muslim myself, 😰 Gente LOCA 🤯

[@ahmedkhaledhussien8788]

@@mikidias Your "Book" is less authentic than our weakest hadith.

[@Achrafu1]

@@mikidias you'll come around. give it time 😊😊😊

[@nasserfirelordarts6574]

​@@mikidias Atleast I'm not a human sacrifice, Paul-ytheist, 3 in 1 shampoo worshipping pagan

[@oneofakind90]

@Bobby you should have a chat with Jake Brancatella (The Muslim Metaphysician) He is also a convert and in the starting years of his conversion he too had trouble accepting the Hadith. But now Alhumdulillah he is properly on the truth.

[@AhmedAbdalaa]

You're a good student, your questions are great but you need a good teacher to guide you through research. You're looking for deep detailed answers. Watching videos on KZbin isn't enough.

[@TheBobbysPerspective]

I agree bro

[@asbeku]

As you agree that you need a teacher Bobby, everyone needs a teacher. Prophet (PBUH) was the biggest teacher. I studied law and I see it in a similar manner. We have law books and in uni sometimes we would ditch the class and try to learn through books only and we could pass the test but not with a perfect score. Don't get me wrong all the facts and the law and theory is there in the books. However, as young minds, we would not fully grasp it. And even though studying and memorizing like crazy, sometimes I would be so lost and so off from the correct answer, I would get 0 from that question. The ones who get the highest scores would be the ones who go to the class and take notes on what a professor is saying, which he was teaching how we should understand the text, how we should apply it, and why there is such a law, why it's important. And he would answer all of our questions. Which we would have many. And professor would be a person who has a lot of knowledge and experience, he would pass that to us, and he would teach us how the understanding must be and for what reasons. That's why universities exist, especially for the professions like law and medicine. You can just read all the law books in the curriculum, and they can be well-researched and clear, however grasping the full meaning of it won't be easy without a teacher. You can't call yourself a lawyer without learning from those teachers. And as hopefully, I grow older, I'll gain the experience and knowledge and I will pass down the knowledge to my students. It would be wrong to say I didn't need all those professors to guide me in classes. If I would be lazy in one class I would be begging for the notes even though, the code and the book are there. Because the professor's words would be essential and highly valuable. I still look at those notes when I need to understand something. As I said the prophet (pbuh) was the biggest teacher, with his character, with his lifestyle, with his walking, and his smile. Everything he was the perfect example. And Muslims back then would have many questions even with the Quran, they needed a teacher, as you have. As I've had in uni with the law. Some of those questions would be easy questions, some would be deeper questions. And the prophet(pbuh) as a teacher would answer. Sometimes he would show it with the way his living, sometimes he would verbally answer it. And he was the walking Quran. He was the perfect example, he was the guide like all teachers. Muslims learned how to apply, how to interpret, how to live Quran from him. And tried to get closer to that state by replicating him. And they loved him because of the Quran, they saw the living Quran. Must be very beautiful. That's why we love him so much as we read and learn about him, his personality fascinates us, he was so kind, so compassionate, so just, so forgiving. He was like that because he was the walking example of a person who Allah wants humans to be. Reading about the Quran moves us. imagine seeing the walking human who succeeded to live it flawlessly. Must be so beautiful to see. This fascination and admiration are very different from worship. Because at the end the demonstration of the words of Allah moves you this much. That is why you love the prophet (pbuh) that much. And he shined among people because of that, his personality was the reason people were interested in the religion before they were being thought about it. Many people today, first start to read about Prophet( pbuh) and get fascinated by him and get interested in Islam. I know it was different for you as you started right away with the Quran, if I'm not mistaken. His job didn't over when the Quran was completed, he had to teach, answer and show demonstration. How are you gonna settle daily disputes and still be in the path of Quran. How are you even going to pray? Prophet (pbuh) answers and shows. Quran is complete and perfect of course. The Quran, the core of belief and Islam is never the dispute nor it's confusing, the oneness of Allah, the power of Allah, your place in this world, your aim here, His orders, etc. However, Without the prophet (pbuh), the way of living, the way of practicing, the way of interpreting would be missing. So a generation get the knowledge from him and pass it down to the next. So when we have questions we can look at how the prophet dealt with them, and how he answered them. What was his thought pattern and reasoning was? If someone raised a question about an issue with the Quran, with Islam, we can say this is what the prophet did, this is what he said, and it will and should be the end of that discussion. we follow his example, and try to be like him, it is challenging but if you follow his path, you will be living the Quran. Sorry for the long answer. Great content, you push all of us to think deeper:)

[@asbeku]

I also love that you answer and you are active with the comments. It feels like a conversation. These are the discussions and conversations that matter. May all of us be witnesses to each other hereinafter.

[@handrianiv]

not the kind of attitude you would expect coming from a knowledge seeker. The lack of humility is mind blowing. This is why it’s said “to know a little is much more dangerous than to know nothing at all…”

[@salmaomar7208]

That is what i see here with all respect learning a litle from islam and talking like that is not how someone learn he already think he know islam and claim he want to learn but he already make up his mind!! No one learns anythink just watching vedios this videos are for those who knows islam already not beganers!!!

[@manihabibti]

I absolutely agree

[@curiousmind_]

@@salmaomar7208 true. Learning Islam from the internet is not the right thing to do.

[@salmaomar7208]

@@curiousmind_ he is not muslim yet but he is already falling to fitna he takes one verse and he runs with it he thinks talking and prising rasulullah leads us to shirk when allah says to send salawat to rasulullah to remeber him even in the salaah. He dont understand mohamed salla llahu aleyh wasalm is our nabi of our time.other prophets did not came for us but we already respect them and love them, how we should do. they already had there people to prise love and respect dem like we do for our prophet and he speaks like he has knowledge of islam more then the sheikh. that makes me feel sad for him coz i know when he learns islam out side vedios he regrets his locked of knowledge.

[@handrianiv]

@@salmaomar7208 I got goosebumps reading the first line of your last reply “He’s not muslim yet but he’s already fallen into fitna. He takes one verse and he runs with it..”

[@DontKnow-hr5my]

I do remain highly sceptical of the hadith, how they were produced. For me it was the fact that the hadith and what was written in there nearly pushed me away from researching Islam, that alone tells me a lot already, in the beginning i did not even know Hadith and Quran were a seperate thing, if this is what i as an outsider gets from researching the religion, that alone is already a problem. Once i started reading the Quran itself and not taking any cultural influx into the equation, i got a very different picture of what Islam means, further i found multiple verses that indicate to not follow hearsay and therelike. As someone very interested in History with a Christian background i also came to the conclusion that the Muslims made similar mistakes as the christians, especially due to Church Traditions coming from Apostle Letters written after Jesus (which is very close to the concept of Hadith), which in turn was a major point of the corruption in Christianity. These were the things, combined with the almost laughable things that some people graded "Sahih", that even go against the Quran, made me arrive at the conclusion i have now. "And on the day when We will raise up in every people a witness against them from among themselves, and bring you as a witness against these-- and We have revealed the Book to you explaining clearly everything, and a guidance and mercy and good news for those who submit."

[@gameboard12]

Allah says To Follow Allah and His Messenger that's why We Need the Hadith of Rasool ALLAH PBUH to understand in details whole story.

[@Abeer-Essa]

The Prophet’s words, actions, behaviours and manners are the live transmission of Allah’s teachings. Which we need to enact and follow such as the way we Pray, the details of our daily activities

[@Zak-gl4ig]

I think that when Nouman Ali says that the people that give us the Qur'an are the same people that give us Hadith, there are actually two major differences: (1) They gave us the Qur'an in their *collective,* and ever since, it has been transmitted by the Muslims in *their collective.* The Ahadith were transmitted via *individuals* in the first 3 or 4 generations. (2) They gave us the Qur'an *verbatim* from the Prophet (pbuh), whereas most Ahadith are in the words of the narrators. As Bobby says, the Ahadith are a great source of the life of the Prophet (pbuh), but they are not a *primary source* of the religion. Also, we should not confuse Hadith with the established Sunnah like the prayers, the fasting, and Hajj. These Sunnan were transmitted like Qur'an, by *the collective,* except that they are *practical* and the Qur'an is *verbal.* This is important because both the revelation and the practical elements of our religion are completely free from the fallibility of people's understanding and interpretation.

[@YourBrotherDjamal]

Hi Bobby, I think that especially today, it is very relevant to have the example and the teachings of the Prophet Muhammad (صلى الله عليه وسلم), What happened during his time is not exclusive to his time. We can discuss it if you want, you can also try to talk to Nouman Ali Khan or Sheikh Uthman ibn Farooq 🤝

[@mshaz452]

He is becoming a future Quranist i guess. May Allah guide him to the right path

[@theconformist]

Quranist? Isn't that MUSLIM without a doubt? Versus, say, SUNNI, or SHIA etc? "Say, we are Muslims..." Lol. Beware of Shaytaan, who loves the ego...

[@mshaz452]

@@theconformist no a Quranist is a person that believe only in Qur'an and don't believe in Hadith. Your eman becomes incomplete even if you are called a Muslim. How can a person believe in what was revealed to the prophet Muhammad ﷺ but doesn't believe in what he says? That's a contradiction

[@theconformist]

@@mshaz452 That's your opinion. Mine is that one who takes the Quran as his guide and nothing else, cannot be called anything else other than a Muslim, without doubt. Believing in what the Prophet said and what he may or may not have said in the debatable Hadith are different things and is very similar to what the Christians have done and hold their hearsay Bible in the same regard. You cannot go wrong with the Quran alone, anything else is playing with fire and to date, the weakness of Muslims could be attributed to holding onto misconceptions and diluting Allah's words...That's my opinion. Not looking to further spend my time on this, so "to you be your way, to me, mine. Allah will Judge. InshaAllah.

[@AMMAR-911]

​@@theconformist No scholar of Islam consider them (the Quranists) Muslims, so NO they are not Muslims, even if they said they are, they are ḋἷṩвἔłἷἔvἔʀṩ without a doubt.

[@EuphoricPlaz]

​@The Conformist I don't think you understand what you are saying. Do you hold your own opinion and desires over the Quran? There's no way you read the Quran or understand Arabic and miss the Quran saying "obey Allah and obey the prophet" surah al Nisa 59. If one rejects all hadiths you're rejecting Allah and his Quran which makes a one a disbeliever. You can't obey the prophet if you don't know what he said 1400 years ago. This is disobeying Allah like the Jews did they knew the truth but rejected it by following their desires and changing the book Allah gave them. This is in the quran as well.

[@OVERKILLGAMING786]

11:52 Its not that Allah is telling the believers to submit to Muhammad (AS) instead of Allah. Rather it is saying that they have not submitted to Allah until they have submitted to the Prophet (AS). Obedience to the Prophet is obedience to Allah, as stated in the Qur'an: 4:80 مَّن يُطِعِ ٱلرَّسُولَ فَقَدْ أَطَاعَ ٱللَّهَ ۖ وَمَن تَوَلَّىٰ فَمَآ أَرْسَلْنَـٰكَ عَلَيْهِمْ حَفِيظًۭا ٨٠ He who obeys the Messenger has obeyed Allāh; but those who turn away - We have not sent you over them as a guardian. - Saheeh International In other words, you cannot obey Allah and not obey the Messenger by ignoring his sayings and his teachings relating to the Qur'an.

[@AirBatuCampur00]

Its not just for them only, its for us also. who live hundred years latter. We are his follower. as he is the last prophet

[@MoBawazir]

9:20 totally agree with you after years of research. Man, you really study well, not a shallow student who accepts whatever comes to him

[@youityou]

Dude I don't want to mock your name but in my language Hindi, if I replace z in your name with s, it will mean Bawasir(Hemorrhoids/piles)😅😁

[@MoBawazir]

@@youityou HAHAHA... Yes... It's the same in Arabic. Some mates in the school used to make fun of that. 😂

[@rtxz5697]

Bobby, when the Ayah mentioned the unspecific verses. It continued by saying the deviants would try to interpret the unspecific ones. But the people of knowledge believe in it ALL. So therefore believe in it all using the specific ones to interpret the unspecific ones (that's why it mentions people of knowledge believe I it ALL)

[@Muhh1982]

Wow, Bobby, this is the most impressive reaction video I've seen from you. I don't need to say more than what you said. «Did you not see those who dispute about the revelations of God, how they have deviated» The verse you mentioned "It is He who has sent down to you the book.....". For me personally, this verse is the cornerstone of the methodology in understanding the Quran. For a book like the Quran, there’s a way that you have to approach it so that you’re the least likely to deceive yourself about what you’re doing, you have to approach a traditional text in the spirit that the text fundamentally embodies, or you bend it to your own will.

[@TheBobbysPerspective]

Glad to hear that it resonates with a few people here. God bless you

[@Islam.is.the.truth..]

@@TheBobbysPerspective listen my friend the reason you still don’t understand or trust hadeeth yet is because you don’t know or understand who the men are that passed on these narrations. These aren’t regular men if you learn the biographies of someone like Ibn umar or the sahaba or the ones who preceded them you would understand how hadeeth can be trusted also with the science that is used to preserve them. This isn’t the same concept as the Bible being preserved through unknown men today. Also my friend at this point shaitan is playing with you and tricking you on accepting Islam. You’ve done enough research and if you know there is no other god worthy of worship except Allah and that Muhammad is his messenger it’s upon you to say the shahada. My friend tomorrow isn’t promised. You could walk out your house and get hit by a car and die without saying Shahada and at this point shaitan has won the battle against you. As a former Catholic and Colombian revert I understand where you’re coming from and I didn’t want to enter Islam yet until I was pure because I felt guilty from my sins but an Arab friend of mine stopped me one day and said to me if you took a test and got an F would you retake it if your teacher gave you a chance to get a C? I said of course ! He said well ok in this life Allah is your teacher and this life is your test. Are you just going to just fail without even trying or at least try even if that means you aren’t perfect? And right there a light bulb went off in my head and it made sense that I needed to accept Islam even if that meant I wasn’t going to be following all the rules yet because at least I would die as a Muslim and a sinning Muslim is better then being nothing my friend because every Muslim will eventually enter jannah even if they enter hellfire where as the non believers will never enter jannah

[@ekonugrahaputra2317]

​@@TheBobbysPerspective . Why Al-Qur'an need Hadith? Because Al-Qur'an say so. Simple right?!

[@fadouabouzambou5834]

Bobby you need to listen to people how are students of knowledge like are brother Abu Khadija en Bilal Davids

[@hshdss1318]

The sunnah is incredibly important because its more than just the life of the prophet, from it we learn how to pray, and from it we learn dhikr which are both extremely important in Islam The dangerous conclusions are becoming a Quranist

[@AbuAbdullahAlHanbali]

Aslam al-Qibti reported: The Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him, said, “Let me not find one of you reclining on his couch, when a command or prohibition of mine comes to him and he says: I do not know, we only follow what we find in the Book of Allah.” Source: Sunan al-Tirmidhī 2663 Grade: Sahih (authentic) according to Al-Albani عَنْ أسلم القبطي أَنَّ رَسُولَ اللَّهِ صَلَّى اللَّهُ عَلَيْهِ وَسَلَّمَ قَالَ لَا أُلْفِيَنَّ أَحَدَكُمْ مُتَّكِئًا عَلَى أَرِيكَتِهِ يَأْتِيهِ أَمْرٌ مِمَّا أَمَرْتُ بِهِ أَوْ نَهَيْتُ عَنْهُ فَيَقُولُ لَا أَدْرِي مَا وَجَدْنَا فِي كِتَابِ اللَّهِ اتَّبَعْنَاهُ 2663 سنن الترمذي كتاب العلم باب ما نهي عنه أن يقال عند حديث النبي صلى الله عليه وسلم 2663 المحدث الألباني خلاصة حكم المحدث صحيح في صحيح الترمذي

[@Ihtesham-zq2np]

Bobby, great reaction video and I love your curious and critical mind. This leads us to question our pre existing beliefs and rediscover the truth and understand them in a better way. You said something like how can Hadith takes precedence over Quran and that is not true, the chain of command goes like this: the instructions and commandments of Allah in the Quran takes precedence over everything else that follows and then comes the Sunnah of the Prophet which is the interpretation and the implementation guide of the Quran. He basically said nothing new or anything that contradicts Quran. On the contrary, he presented himself as the living example of the teachings of the Quran. As Allah mentions in Surah Al Ahzab Verse 21: Indeed in the Messenger of Allah you have a good example to follow, for him who hopes in Allah and the Last Day, and remembers Allah much. You also mentioned somewhere in the video that the sunnah of Prophet was only for the people of that time and that is basically true about the previous prophets but not the Prophet Muhammad Peace Be Upon Him. He was sent for the generations during his time and the generations following him until the day of judgement. That’s why he was referred to as the last and final prophet. Things will become more clear to you as progress though your learning journey Insha’Allah. It is very common to have such confusions as part of learning Islam. May Allah guide us all to the straight path. Ameen

[@luqmti6634]

Great reaction as always Bobby. From what I can tell is that hadith enhances what has been quoted from the Quran, like in the Quran we are told to worship God, but through hadith, we know the pattern of worship by observing how the prophet did it, when he did it, what he spoke during worship and the likes. If I'm mistaken, feel free to correct me. 🙏

[@resulramadani5775]

Brother, people had to follow Messengers of their Time. Just as a professor who teaches to their student. We can of course read the Quran but our prophete alejhi Selam gave us the best example of how to live our Life in the light of Quran. Assalam Alejkum

[@malicacidissour]

Bobby, a perfect example on the hadeeth is that the “Quran” is a language and the Prophet (pbuh) is like a translator of that language.

[@sameeralwazani6344]

Respect bobby. I really pray to god that he guides you and me to the right path. I totally agree with you on your arguments and suspicions about Hadith. Islam is the one and only religion accepted from God, it has nothing to do with all the prophets from Adam to Mohammad, in fact god may forgive anything other than sharing his status with anything and anyone else, not even prophet Mohammad. I was born and raised by a Muslim Sunni family but now as i approach my 50s i question my old tradition and alhamdulellah i only Believe in god and Quran alone. Sunnah is an unreliable source of knowledge at its best, it contain lots of valuable lessons and wesdom but it is not part of the one and only true universal religion of god,ISLAM.

[@salammaamur735]

The verse quoted by NAK is indeed more powerful than what Jesus Christ pbuh said in the Bible. " I am the way the truth and the life, no one comes to The Almighty except through me"

[@laithoni]

An example to understand the reason for hadith and Sunnah, when Allah said in the Quran to pray he didn’t explain the number of prayers the way to pray .. etc . All explanations where teach by prophet Mohamed SAW to us through hadith and sunnah reports.

[@kafeelahmed2458]

"what was given to him" . As you know prophet Muhammad was illiterate and after becoming the prophet Allah blessed him with knowledge and its a fact that whatever tribe , city or kingdom u have a leader who resolves your issues and as you know Islam is a very deep , It answers every question like how to pray ,how much zakat should be given , buying and selling goods , issues of interest . The Quran tells you to perform salah but we can only know how to perform salah correctly if we look at the hadith . Remember one thing That "Allah didn't only give us the Quran he gave us his beloved Messenger too not just a Prophet but also a Messenger".

[@Nermeen.]

God clearly says in the Qur'an that the hadiths came also from him not from the mind of prophet Mohammad himself { (2) Your companion [i.e., Muḥammad] has not strayed, nor has he erred,(3) Nor does he speak from [his own] inclination.(4) It is not but a revelation revealed(5) Taught to him by one intense in strength [i.e., Gabriel] } Al-Najm surat.

[@AbuAbdullahAlHanbali]

Oh Allah keep us safe from the ones who spread kufr on their tongues. The Hadeeth rejectors are disbelievers and worship their own desires If the Nabi ﷺ was in front of them and he forbade them something would they say “this isn’t in Quran” They are callers to jahanam May Allah ‎ ﷻ bless you with knowledge of this religion

[@muhammadrezazulkarnain9139]

For example the quran say we need to pray, but how the way to pray? we know more about it in sunnah and hadith by following the example of how Muhammad SAW pray

[@sembl4nce1]

Well as a Muslim I must say honestly you have a valid point right there... Keep researching bro inshallah you'll find your answer one day, Indeed God is all seeing all hearing. Please keep sharing your research as well cuz its not only helping you to understand islam but us Muslims as well💯

[@mtl_yg]

which point ?

[@glorious8429]

Brother please learn from authentic scholars and sources and not from people who are not learned or are still in their baby steps on their learning journey

[@theshieldofthetruth1963]

The blind obedience to scholars or madhaabs is called Taqlid and is totally forbidden in Islam, at least according to Ahl Sunnah wal Jama'ah. Regarding hadiths, they are very much needed. For example, the Qur'an never makes the claim that it's enough, it's only enough as a miracle. Anyways, the Qur'an commands us to obey the Prophet (s.a.w) and when we fall into disagreement, to take it back to Allah (s.w.t) through His Qur'an and the Prophet (s.a.w), and how can we reach the Prophet (s.a.w) and his sayings if he is dead, that's we have these traditions preserved by the salaf. [Qur'an 4:59]: يَـٰٓأَيُّهَا ٱلَّذِينَ ءَامَنُوٓا۟ أَطِيعُوا۟ ٱللَّهَ وَأَطِيعُوا۟ ٱلرَّسُولَ وَأُو۟لِى ٱلْأَمْرِ مِنكُمْ ۖ فَإِن تَنَـٰزَعْتُمْ فِى شَىْءٍۢ فَرُدُّوهُ إِلَى ٱللَّهِ وَٱلرَّسُولِ إِن كُنتُمْ تُؤْمِنُونَ بِٱللَّهِ وَٱلْيَوْمِ ٱلْـَٔاخِرِ ۚ ذَٰلِكَ خَيْرٌۭ وَأَحْسَنُ تَأْوِيلًا ٥٩ "O you who have believed, obey Allāh and obey the Messenger and those in authority among you. And if you disagree over anything, refer it to Allāh and the Messenger, if you should believe in Allāh and the Last Day. That is the best [way] and best in result." Tafsir ibn Kathir on the verse: ((And) if you differ in anything amongst yourselves, refer it to Allah and His Messenger). "Mujahid and several others among the Salaf said that the Ayah means, "(Refer) to the Book of Allah and the Sunnah of His Messenger.'' This is a command from Allah that whatever areas the people dispute about, whether major or minor areas of the religion, they are required to refer to the Qur'an and Sunnah for judgment concerning these disputes."

[@muslima2505]

Bobby your followers are giving you some very enlightening information to ponder on and research.

[@shababhsiddique]

The unspecific words specified by the ayat you mentioned 16:30 is actually about the fawātiḥ words

[@MN-vw3rp]

Try reading a karate fighting book that describes what karate focuses on and learn karate from it, you won't learn much because it doesn't have the little details of how to do it and even if did you won't learn it because it is a thing that requires someone to teach u how, and that is pretty much everything in islam.❤

[@MindlesslyAi]

May Allah guide us always

[@Drojas24]

I’m with you on this one Bobby.

[@minnimouse445]

Your not guilty brother we the ummah are as a whole we are asleep I was born a Muslim alhammadallah but I wasn’t practicing and just following what I was told to because they said so. I thought the same as you when I started practising again Quran is sufficient we don’t need anything else so I met a quaranists sheikh cause I thought I can’t go wrong with just the Quran since it’s all sufficient and it is. So when I started saying allahuakbar or Labayk allahuma Labayk the quranists started saying this is shirk I backed off right away and came back to Sunnah. I mean alahamdallah Quran led me to Sunnah of prophet I use my logic with hadiths ofc during the prophet times and how to implement it. True rightousness is not the one who turns his face to the east or west but true rightesnous is the one one who believes in Allah , the Last Day, the angels, the Book, and the prophets and gives wealth, in spite of love for it, to relatives, orphans, the needy, the traveler, those who ask [for help], and for freeing slaves; [and who] establishes prayer and gives zakah; who] fulfill their promise when they promise; and [those who] are patient in poverty and hardship and during battle. Those are the ones who have been true, and it is those who are the righteous. I saw this video before it didn’t help answer my questions but brother be patient seek Allahs help in knowledge so that he may guide us to the straight path remmember brother your not gonna learn everything in one day but guess what you’ve learned more than many Muslims today and help teach Muslims more with your videos especially me your one of the reasons I expanded my knowledge and know I went and expanded it more towards hadiths as well but Quran no matter how many times I listen to it’s not enough cause I keep learning more and more from Quran something new that I didn’t know before see brother we forget it’s why we should keep opening Quran every day to remind ourselves what Allah wants from us it’s clear and we just need to implement Quran so Allah can send his blessings inshallah on the ummah

[@minnimouse445]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/anrEc62VhK6Ee6M thumama Ibn uthal

[@ibflozz_gg4546]

9:35 Every muslim that is devout should aspire to become like the prophet (S.A.W.), I’m all for him being the decision maker over me or any other human. we, to this day are able to come to him for judgement through…. Hadith

[@bridezorko9031]

The hadith is record of how the prophet Muhammed (PBUH) lived his life. All the way down to the minute details. Although much of it is not compulsory it's the record of the example that was recorded and left for us as Muslims. We have to remember he was given the knowledge of the universe, probably the only one EVER to this degree. Much of what he taught us through this knowledge is in the hadith and that is why it is so important.

[@tesschaabani1951]

I want to start by thanking you for your effort, may God bless you. A lot of experts in Islam from arab countries talks about this subject, I am genuinely glad that you bring it up also in the western world in order to spread knowledge. I was born a Muslim but didn't really feel like a believer until last year, now I'm studying the quran with my poor arabic and it's so exciting. I strongly believe in God alone as creator which identifies me as a Muslim according to the Quran and also the meaning of the word Islam. Also I believe in Gods all prophets and messengers, note that there is a difference between them. Muhammad was both in the Quran. What I think that the prophets are the ones who received the revelation and were given the task of spreading it, messengers on the other side will remain until the day of judgment in the form of warnings and guidance. But that's my opinion. I share the same opinion that the quran is a totally complete book, if you say otherwise, you claim that God's words are untrue. Some say that Hadith is important to perform prayer and fasting correctly, but prayer (salat),washing, time for prayer as well as fasting and fasting times are already mentioned in the Quran right? maybe not as detailed as the books and videos that are available today, but maybe that's the point? the quran is there to facilitate and not make it difficult according to the quran itself😊 So between the quran which I believe is the true word of god or books written by humans at least 100 years after the death of the prophet? I hope I haven't stepped on anyone's toes, as I said I am new on my journey and only sharing my opinions 🤍Peace to all

[@TheBobbysPerspective]

We agree

[@fay4569]

Totally agree with you but people can be very stubborn and do t want to challenge conventional thinking. Islam is meant to adapt to society and evolution with time and the Quran being the word of God is universal and beyond our limited conventional thinking

[@ML-jw8kf]

@@TheBobbysPerspective Anti-Hadiths (Draft - 19 Feb 2023) Following only Quran: Chapter 6, Verse 114: "Shall I seek other than God as a source of law, when He has revealed to you this book fully detailed?" Chapter 7, Verse 3: ‘Follow what has been sent down to you from your Lord; do not follow other masters beside Him. How seldom you take heed!’ Chapter 29, Verse 51: “Is it not enough for them that We have revealed to you this Book (The Quran)which is recited to them? Most surely there is mercy in this and a reminder for a people who believe” Chapter 45, Verse 6: "These are God's revelations that We recite to you truthfully. In which Hadiths other than God and His revelation (the Quran) do they believe?" Quran - Perfect, Clear, Explained, Detailed & Complete Chapter 6, Verse 114: ‘’Should I seek other than God as a source of law, when it is He who has revealed the Book (the Quran), clearly explained. Those to whom We gave the Book earlier know that it is the truth revealed by your Lord. Therefore, have no doubts.’’ Chapter 6, Verse 115: ‘’The Word of your Lord has been complete, perfected in truth and justice. None can change His Words. And He is the All-Hearing, All- Knowing.’’ Chapter 6, Verse 126: ‘’This is the path of your Lord, made perfectly straight. We have explained (and detailed) Our revelations to those who take heed.’’ Chapter 11, Verse 1: ‘’Alif-Lãm-Ra. (This is) a Book whose verses are well perfected and then fully explained clearly. (It is) from the One (Who is) All-Wise, All-Aware.’’ Chapter 12, Verse 111: ‘’In their stories there is truly a lesson for people of understanding. This (Quran) is not a fabricated tale, rather a confirmation of what came before it, a detailed explanation of everything, a guidance and mercy for people who believe.’’ Chapter 16, Verse 89: ‘’The day will come when We raise up in each community a witness against them, and We shall bring you (O Prophet) as a witness against these people, for We have sent the Scripture down to you explaining everything, and as guidance and mercy and good news to those who devote themselves to God. Chapter 17, Verse 89: ‘’And surely We have explained for the people in this Quran every subject in various ways. Still most of the people obstinately persist in disbelief.’’ Chapter 18, Verse 1-3 ‘’All praise is due to Allah, Who has revealed the Book to His servant, allowing no crookedness in it, an unerringly straightforward (and clear) book, , to warn (the disbelievers) of a severe torment from Him; (and) to give good news to the believers who do righteous deeds, that they will have a fair reward, in which they will remain forever and to warn those who claim ‘Allah has offspring.’ Chapter 25, Verse 33: ‘’Whenever they bring you an argument, We come to you with the right refutation and the best explanation.’’ Chapter 27, Verse 1: ‘’Ṭâ-Sĩn. These are the verses of the Quran; the clear Book.’’ Chapter 43, Verse 2-3: ‘’By the Book that makes things clear, Indeed, We have made it an Arabic Qur'an, so that you may understand.’’

[@saranpatel1114]

Say pbuh wen u mention the prophet saws name. And u call urself a muslim 🙄

[@farzam99]

Dear Tess, please do not try to mislead the public. Indeed the Quran is perfect but so is the character of the Prophet PBUH. If hadith is unnecessary, then please care to elaborate on how to do the Hajj (1 of the pillars of Islam) from the Quran alone as the Quran states that the days of Hajj are known to all (not actual translation), without specifying any of those days.

[@SR-tx3dj]

"Looks like I have been called, and I answered (my time of death has come), indeed I have left the thaqalayn (two weighty things) among you, one of them is greater form the other, the book of Allah and my 'itra (family), my ahl al-bayt (household). So look after how you will behave with them after me, indeed they will never separate from each other until they enter my presence by the pool [in the paradise]." Sunan al Nisaei

[@ghazialwan8121]

You are correct brother , there are over 1 billion Muslims you will find incorrect ideology . You said your self you will not disregard the Quran. You are already better then alot of us. Bless you sorry for the long comments

[@darajabar93]

I will say this before watching the video.. If nouman ali khan does not convince you, it is impossible to be convinced by anyone else! Nouman Ali Khan is a LEGENDARY thinker and scholar of Islam.

[@licha7531]

Simply speaking, the hadith and the Sunnah are the application of the Qur’an or an explanation of the provisions of the Qur’an. God made the Prophet Muhammad a judge between us in this world

[@MohammadRxGamer]

love the videos, but would appreciate if you dont add pictures of people when talking about prophets. like in 5:10

[@06mimoun]

Hi, Like other commenters said. Allah told us to pray. The prophet showed us how? Command and explanation.

[@Lord_Escanor_Sama]

When is the 2 months deadline ? I forgot 😂

[@ahmedkhaledhussien8788]

8th of March.

[@Lord_Escanor_Sama]

@@ahmedkhaledhussien8788 you’re the best