Why I chose a Giant Schnauzer over another Doberman.

I wanted to share my thoughts on why I did not get another Doberman Pinscher after Kazi passed away. Kazi had so many amazing qualities and I plan to instill those into Tux as we raise him. I thought it would be nice to share why some other working dog and herding breeds did not make the cut as my choice for family dog.
Some of the breeds that were recommended were Mastiff, Pitbull, Great Dane, Cane Corso, Rhodesian Ridgeback, Dogo Argentino, Boxer, Rottweiler, and Australian Shepherd.
The breeds I was interested in were the Doberman, Dutch Shepherd, Malinois, Border Collie, and Giant Schnauzer.

[@jamaal3270]

I’ve often thought of my giant schnauzer as a fuzzy Doberman.

[@Keyser_Soze739]

After two Dobies, i am now on my 2nd Giant. Two things you should know. 1. Always keep in mind your Giant is smarter than you, and 2. They are also referred to as Peter Pan dogs because they refuse to grow up. They are clowns and where most breeds reach the adult status between 1 and 2 years, count on 4 years for your Giant 😂. You made an excellent choice and i wish you all the best!

[@carnebrant]

best description !!! My 9 year old believes she is 2. a pure clown but also the greatest guarddog of the family or workplace. She lets noone get in the office but when the "fun persons" comes she acts like a pup. also have a 9 year old labrador and shes just an old fart. she never runs unless there is food at the goal.

[@robynwhite5662]

They say that about Boxers too.

[@jcnieves2992]

Great choice my friend, sorry for your loss. I had a miniature schnauzer for 14 years and he was awesome

[@robynwhite5662]

I have a mini schnauzer. He’s my first. He’s so completely awesome! I LOVE him so much..

[@inquisitive1911]

​@@robynwhite5662Me too!! ❤

[@TingTingalingy]

Everyone thinks their kids & dogs are awesome, even when no one else likes them.

[@donielleharris3988]

😂😂😂​@@TingTingalingy

[@easternhotrodder]

We've had both breeds. You really can't go wrong with either. We rehearsed (didn't need to train) my dads Giant Schnauzer about 6 times to carry our rings down the aisle when my wife and I got married. He did it flawlessly. I loved my female South African Boerboel, too.

[@Barikade]

Boerboels are great 👍🏽

[@easternhotrodder]

Yeah. Amazing dogs, though males can have dominance issues.

[@Barikade]

@@easternhotrodder 🤣🤣🤣 our boy is just stubborn ( hard headed as hell) 🤣🤣

[@easternhotrodder]

@@Barikade Mine would get pissed and growl if you baby talked him. Which my dad thought was a great party trick, though... the other people didn't. LOL.

[@Barikade]

LMAO now that's a great boerboel 🤣

[@heathercouch4068]

Many people do not know that the original pinschers and schnauzers were once the same stock from which the individual breeds came. This was before there were formal standards for “breeds”. Smooth coated pinschers and rough coated called “schnauzers” were often in the same litter before the “breeds” were refined and developed into what we see today.

[@davidwindmueller6000]

News to me! Very interesting. Thanks for sharing.

[@markoratar5488]

I had 2 giants, both german working line. Extremely clever, extremely protective. The first one was also cuddly 😂 Cautious with strangers, dominant with other dogs, but never agressive. And as i lived in a flat, i went with them for long walks, 3-4 hours a day, plenty of energy. You made a perfect choice.

[@carlosmier4380]

David, I went through the same process, but over time. Had, in order: Rottweiler, Schnauzer Standard, Giant Schnauzer, Malinois, Great Dane, Spanish Mastiff, Italian Mastiff (Cane Corso) and German Shepherd... all great dogs, each with it's tops and downs, but no doubt, the Giant Schnauzer is my nº1. Checks all boxes to me, and very importantly, natural instinct to know how to behave in all circumstances (more than any other). Very balanced character. Not sure if I was just lucky, but from other owners, it seems to be this way. Deep connection. However, the 1st two years of age, they are pure energy...that goes down to "better than normal" from year 3 onwards. Be careful with extra exercise in the 1st 6-12 months, as all large breeds are sensitive to over physical stress when growing... Have a great life with your Giant. Cheers from Spain.

[@davidwindmueller6000]

Thanks for the advice!

[@michaelo1676]

Carlos, how was your experience with Giant Schnauzer compared to German Shepherd? Our GSD Just passed and we have been considering a Giant Schnauzer in the future (for now, we'll get another GSD first). Cheers.

[@carlosmier4380]

@@michaelo1676 Hi Michael. After the Giant turned 2 years old, he was that kind of dog that knew how to behave well in any circumstance. Incredible balance. Before that, it was all play, play, play. The German Shepherd is not as confident as the Giant, and this compromises his behavior at times. Even after the 2 years of age, he is still on a play mode regularly. When he wants attention, he tends to bark w/o other purpose. The Giant was more of a gentleman. Both very attached to me, but the Shepherd a bit due to dependency, the Giant of simple will. Regarding having them at home, the Giant looses almost no hair, wheras the Shepherd is a rug production plant, haha. Not sure if I was just lucky with Kuro (the Giant), but he was a truly amazing dog. I hope this helps.

[@JosephSalinas-r4r]

I laughed when this guy said that pitbulls are not that intelligent...buddy they're up there with the border collie as far as intelligence is concerned, apparently you've never had one. And the GS you have to worry about the grooming. I've had a miniature before and I didn't care for taking him alot to the groomers.

[@MelanieTalley]

Love the video….. your dog is so happy….. so glad for him. You’re giving him an amazing place to live….. much love sent to you and yours

[@aaronharris3091]

I just got a giant about 4 weeks ago. Honestly, it's surprising how much he's exceeding my expectations. Incredibly smart and very confident and protective already of my two year old. There seems to be a nice curious respect and apprehension when people see the giant schnauzer. I like that it's unique but, under that fur it's a controlled beast. They look like werewolves too lol😂

[@davidwindmueller6000]

Yeah, they definitely have the presence I wanted from a dog. Confident and imposing. I'm loving the fur.

[@jonathanpark7658]

My giant is a giant goofball. 😅

[@terylbrandonteodosio3371]

What's there in the schnauzer that a doberman doesn't have? Im just curious. Thanks

[@davidwindmueller6000]

@@terylbrandonteodosio3371 long hair

[@terylbrandonteodosio3371]

@@davidwindmueller6000 ok. I see. Doberman is the smartest dog I had in my whole life. I can't explain it. But even I don't teach them, they understand what I want them to do. Very obedient. But as he grow older he gets more protective. More aggressive. More prey drive and it's hard to control.

[@kathrynfahm6762]

Welcome to the Giant Schnauzer Family! Check out Schnauzerfest in Rome, GA from 28-29 October.

[@davidwindmueller6000]

Sounds great, maybe next time.

[@wolfden8979]

A Beauceron would be a good choice too. They're one of the breeds that Doberman's & Rottweilers are made from. They always get mistaken for dobbie/rot mix lol. They were known cattle dogs too but not like how brdr collis are on the herds heels, Beaus are more lax & do it at a calm distance, less stressful for the cattle. They're sensitive & intuitive too but not for first timers, they need something to do. Some do bite work too. From what i hear they're on the more gentler side of guard dogs. Some folks use them for service dogs too. Plus they can either look really goofy & friendly or they can look terrifying, just depends on if u crop their ears or not.

[@4legkids388]

Congrats on your Giant pup! My hubby and myself have had all 3 schnauzers breeds ( mini, standard and giant) and I grew up with Dobes too. Due to a few back surgeries we had to downsize to standards, which are great, but my heart will always be with the Giants! Be patient with Tux, as I found that Giants are more rambunctious than dobe pups...it's like living with the devil for two years. Then after 2yrs they are awesome! Yes, people will cross the street when they see you coming...lol

[@davidwindmueller6000]

@4legkids388 rambunctious is the perfect descriptor for GS vs Dobe pups 😆.

[@bradleysamson7325]

Great dogs, both of them! Thanks for sharing, hope your new pup has a long amazing life as part of your family.

[@danarussell4246]

We’re on Giant Schnauzers #6 and #7 now. We’ve typically always had 2 at a time. We’ve had Giants for the past 33 years now. My wife and I absolutely love this breed.

[@davidwindmueller6000]

@danarussell4246 wow! Must be a lot of fun.

[@brandont5211]

Have you noticed premature passings of any of them? I’ve heard stories about illness that creeps up fast. more than most dogs. is that true ?

[@danarussell4246]

@@brandont5211 All of ours have lived 12-13 years before being put down for typical health issues of all dogs.

[@edmundleblanc9508]

I found Dobermans had very little maintenance. Do not shed that much, no brushing or hair cuts.

[@emmanuelkusi7212]

Great video !!! VERY THOROUGH explanation for your choice. Awesome presentation...gave LOTS of explanation, straight to the point

[@deborahholliday1600]

Hello, I really enjoyed your video. I’m so sorry for the loss of your beautiful dog Cozzi. I’m also a dog lover. I currently own three dogs: a GSD, a Schnoodle and an American Staffordshire mix. You stated that, “pitbulls aren’t very intelligent.” After raising multiple pits, I’ve learned different! They are very intelligent! They may not be as athletic or active as you may like but very intelligent. My Amstaff has been the most obedient and easiest to train. I’m recovering from a traumatic brain injury and it’s my pitbull that gets me out the bed and is by my side daily, on and off leash. I’m an experienced dog owner. Over the years, I’ve raised pure breeds (Labrador retrievers, American Staffordshires, Toy Poodles, German Shepherd Dogs, Beagles) and mutts and my preferred choice is a pit bull type dog. They are very loyal and obedient with the right training. My dog Buddy (American Staffordshire mix) is protective yet non-aggressive, will fetch, run laps, follow commands, guard the yard and family and simply be a couch potato. I think you made a great choice for your family - Giant Schnauzer - an amazing breed! I lot of versatility in the breed. ❤

[@ingerpamp2388]

Once a giant schnauzer always a giant schnauzer ❤ You made an exellent choice. Good luck./ 35 years whith the breed. (From Sweden)

[@strausd02]

I have a Doberman Pinscher. This is my third Doberman. Before I decided on the breed or type of dog to get, I researched the working class breed thoroughly. This was the class that I wanted to pick or select my furbaby from. When all was said and done, my selection was narrowed-down to two dogs. The German Shepherd and the Doberman Pinscher. I loved these two dogs due to their history of guarding and protecting. They were also the only two breeds that law enforcement and the military used. They are highly regarded by security firms, as well. The things that tilted the decision to the Doberman Pinscher, was its hair. It had short hair, and required less maintenence. I had visited homes that had German Shepherds, and the hair was a no-no for me. The thought of seeing hair floating across the room, indicated to me that dog hair would get into everything, even my foods. This was a deal breaker for me. I could not be more happy with my furbabies/furbuddies. The Dobermans have excelled in every way. They are everything that your read about them. They are excellent in every way, if they are trained and socialized very early. You must be seen by them as the Top Dog! The leader of the pack. They responds and respects a strong leader.😢

[@davidwindmueller6000]

Yeah, the hair is a big issue. My Doberman did shed, but it was unnoticed.

[@Terry-ib5zc]

Just saw the video. Very nicely done. Love the Giant schnauzer but we went with the BLACK RUSSIAN TERRIER which has Giant schnauzer in its creation. It’s excellent breed. I have had 3. love them. I have 8 kids a we got our first girl when she was 10 she is now 24 we currently have two boys. Great dog in my opinion! The schnauzer is a great choice and I hope all goes well for you

[@scottkozinski6199]

We loved our GS, Baron. He passed a year ago after 12 years. Came from a great breeder and was even better than we hoped; bigger, too! Went 135 lbs of muscled athlete! We're spoiled after him and would prefer a large breed. He was a breeze to train, but then as a family we were EXTREMELY consistent and diligent with our commands and socialization of him. I definitely want another dog and have been enamored of the BRT. You've had both. How do they compare? I have severe allergies; so does daughter #2. Our GS did not bother us at all! Do BRT's shed more or less? Any allergy problems? Our GS was extremely perceptive. He was kind and gentle to all neighbors and even strangers, and yet, he somehow knew when to be aggressive, rarely necessary, and never excessively. It was wonderful to let him out on yard patrol knowing that he'd represent our family well. He was a giant, loveable goof who would welcome all, but also protect the entire neighborhood if needed. Are BRT's as perceptive? Are they reasoned and balanced or overly aggressive?

[@rpinarreta]

Congratulations, the Giant Schnauzer is a great all around farm dog. Two other similar looking dogs are Russian Black Terrier aka (Chornyi Terrier), Briard aka (Berger de Brie ) and the Bouvier aka (Bouvier des Flandres).

[@delilahklenk6658]

The Bouvier de Flanders is also a great dog, and similar looking to the giant schnauzer

[@lamara8497]

They are cousins

[@melblacke5726]

If I were looking for a black guard dog that did not have a smooth coat I would choose a Black Russian Terrier. I am curious to know if your giant schnauzer is as yappy as the smaller schnauzers?

[@FraochFlanagan]

Agree totally. Our 1st family dog was a Bouvier des Flandres, he lived to 11 1/4 years, died of cancer. We then decided on a German Shepherd, believing less work with grooming, oh foolish mortal. I just traded grooming, for constant vacuuming. When he was 5 yrs we added a female German Shepherd, Czech lines. She is almost 12 and winding down with age and ailments. We are returning to another Bouvier. For us, they are more calm and observant, only using enough force or intimidation as the situation calls for. They can be a little stubborn, but not hyper or trigger happy, as some Shepherd lines can be...shoot first, ask questions later.

[@pgm2934]

I had a Bouvier - he was a fantastic dog. Took me 17 years to get another dog after his loss. I have a Giant now, another fantastic dog. He's almost 3, super smart, active, protective and friendly at the same time - I also have a mini-schnauzer as his companion. She also has many of the same qualities. Not a yapper - both are excellent dogs. They force me to stay active and get plenty of exercise in my old age. It's a blessing to have them in my life.

[@MarissaByrne89]

We lost our Giant over 5 years ago. She undeniably ruined us for any breed. We had her for 12 years and she amazing as a companion guardian for our home and family. Her audimatic response to protect was unbeatable.

[@dogotek2]

You covered all of my favorites. I owned a Dogo and he loved the cold of New Jersey. Smart, powerful and productive. Athletic but a little clumsy. If I ever get another dog it will be a Giant.

[@peterschmidt7409]

Nice! I am from Austria, we have many good working line giant schnauzers here. I had one, was easy one of my best dogs ever. Stay on top with the training, they are strong minded, but late bloomers, they are fully adult not before two and a half or three years.

[@moduman2220]

As a former Cane Corso owner, I can say your assessment of the breed was correct but for one, they do very well in cold weather. I like the Giant Schnauzer breed. Wishing you good luck and many wonderful years with your new dog, Tux.

[@davidwindmueller6000]

Interesting to know about them in the cold.

[@powderedtoastfacekillah734]

@@davidwindmueller6000 I can concur…my brother has a Corso here in Brooklyn NY and it does well

[@dhena8112]

Schnauzer's are great dogs for many reasons one of the best things are health and lack of shedding. I've had the pleasure of living with 3. I've also have had 2 GSD's. Our first GSD shedded to a point that I was always amazed that there was still fur on her body. Our current GSD is a working line sable from Germany the breeder told us what to feed him. Long story short he barely sheds its crazy to me. I'm not sure if it's just his genetics or if what we feed him is what stops the massive shedding. All we feed him is royal Canin GSD with raw beef with liquid omegas and joint supplement. Malinois are just too high energy for me as it is I take our GSD to the park daily for high intensity training the obedience training and bite work weekly. Really I just really like the working line shepherd dogs, terriers, and rotties. It's really tough losing a fur child it was especially tough losing our first GSD for whatever reason not sure why she was just a great dog.

[@chatrinekvinge813]

Schnauzer in all sizes are very good dogs.They have good health,very smart and learn easy.If they have good activities and play time,they are absolutely lovely.I will never choose another breed after owning a Schnauzer🌞👋🇧🇻

[@JOHNRueve]

Bouvier de Flanders. Smart, emotional inelligence of an eight year old, velcro, great sense of humor. Working breed. I went to my moms pen in back to retrieve them inside after we eturnd from a shopping trip. Thats why ifound out why the fenced pen was 12 feet high. So happy to see me! Literally am to the gate and mo running start, srprang 11 feet into the air, over and over. No kidding. The bark wassomoly unreal, had to reputty the windows. Loose in the frame from the sonic waves of the bark. She had 2. Very protective, but guaded you like a sheep, didn't get lured away.

[@Tuishimi]

I really thought about a giant when I was searching after our boxer/cattle-dog mix passed, I ended up with a standard schnauzer. I had a pick from two separate litters, had narrowed it down to a female, when I got the kennel, I chose my girl because a) she was a pip-squeak (she still is, about an inch shorter and 10 pounds lighter than the breed standard after a year) and b) she was the most out-going puppy of the bunch. She was the first to trot over to greet us. Anyway, she's my buddy, but I have to admit she is quite the handful. :D I think the giants tend to be a little calmer, still energetic but not quite so (what I call) "crazy." I think maybe enthusiastic is a better word. HAVE FUN with your new dog! I think you made a great choice. One other thing I think you will appreciate is that they know when to bark and when not to bark, at least it seems that way to me.

[@davidwindmueller6000]

Sounds like you got a great dog! Appreciate the well wishes.

[@tamarahollenbeck2988]

I love how loyal Schnauzers are. I had a large mini, Winston, and he was very protective and smart! Schnauzers have a Very loud and unique Bark/ Howl! Strong personalities. I Lost him a year ago ,and miss him everyday. When I'm ready, I am going to get a Standard. It's an ancient breed of the working class elites; land barons, farriers, brewers. You'll Enjoy your Schnauzer. No other Dog will Ever be like Your Schnauzer 💓

[@rockylamotta8154]

First, condolences on losing your Dobie. Never have owned a GS but truly admire the breed! Hoping Tux brings your fam much joy & happiness like Kozzie(Sp?). Continued success with your beautiful GS!

[@davidwindmueller6000]

Thank you!

[@milamilla1977]

OMG, you described BRT! I had one once, perfect guardian dog for cold climate.

[@lonerhino3229]

I have owned two giant schnauzer. Both female. Incredible dogs. If from a knowledgable breeder, the better. Very gentle animals, smart, loving and brave. They are easy to train and can tolerate very low temperatures. The only drawback was grooming.

[@countrygirl432]

Interesting video. I have a active and professionally trained Cane Corso who loves herding in the cattle,running besides the ATV,chills out with the chickens sitting on top of him. When the weather is hot and a CC has webbed feet,he swims in the pool ,loves to go on barn hunting races or chilling out on the sofa. A CC is a very active breed,not a couch potato,lol. He's been the best working breed for our family. We will always have guardian breed in our home. We've had in the past dobbie,blue heeler,American Bulldog, Caucasian Shepard,but our CC has been the easiest to train and socialize. Plus, he's absolutely loves it when the kids are playing soccer or basketball. The only "problem " per say is when he took the jolly ball toy for himself and away from our old donkey.

[@joe136a]

When I was a kid a German carvel owner this 1968 trained them to guard carvel stores it looked like it was sleeping it was never sleeping it watched with one eye and could clear a carvel counter from a sitting position. He was trained with clicking sounds. He flew them in from Germany.

[@davidwindmueller6000]

🫡

[@GroteDierenvriend1]

I have had a Giant Schnauzer bitch for 10 years and lost het to cancer. I incriminate the dog food we bought for her. No matter what the brands tell you, dog feed is basically a Gigo model: garbage in, garbage out and your dog ultimately paid the price. She was a lovely family dog, but her presence was never that of a Doberman. Especially after having run through our wet pasture, we felt we were left with a half size dog as the hair diminished in volume. I subsequently had two Kangals (Turkish shepherds) and now you're talking guard dog and presence. Wishing you lots of happiness with your beautiful Schnauzer.

[@davidwindmueller6000]

Kangals are incredible dogs. Sorry to hear about your GS.

[@p9a9r21]

Thanks for sharing your journey. Condolences to the loss of your family member. I am on similar journey; single semi retired athletic with experience of owning working breeds; Dobetmans, GSD, Boxer. Will soon be relocating to the Piedmont area to a 15 acre farm to follow my long delayed dream of horse breeding. The Giant Schnauzer is in my top three.

[@davidwindmueller6000]

In my opinion, the Giant Schnauzer is more rugged than the Doberman and Boxer. Might be on part with the GSD, but I'm not positive. I don't think you can go wrong with GS on a farm. Best of luck!

[@p9a9r21]

@@davidwindmueller6000 Appreciate the follow-up. The other breeds are Bovier de Flanders and an interesting mix breed Bernese Mountain and English Mastiff If you saw the movie Shooter this was the dog Sam.

[@madvente]

Both D'manns and GS are equally great breeds in my experience. The Black Russian Terrier (part GS - R'weiler - Airedale Terrier) might also have ticked your boxes. Enjoy Tux, I am sure you will!

[@234i9]

the BRT is a bit too large/heavy to be a "sporty" dog tho.

[@dailylife6935]

My cane Corso is built like a running back. He’s as athletic a dog as you could want. He’s on the smaller side at 115# He can jump into the bed of a 4x4 truck with the gate up. He’s by far the best dog I’ve ever had!

[@davidwindmueller6000]

I've been around a couple Cane Corsos, pretty impressive.

[@acykat2069]

I have an 8 month old salt and pepper giant schnauzer, after having a GSD. She's very smart and picks things up quickly when properly motivated, but she also has that stubbornness they're known for. She also loves to roll in the mud but the wire coat is actually pretty easy to get clean. She is really wary of people she doesn't know but gets along with other dogs great.

[@davidwindmueller6000]

Yes, I am also experiencing the stubbornness. 😆

[@r2p941]

I have a Dutch shepherd and I’ll be getting another one when my current guy passes. Such a perfect family companion. Needs to handle cold weather in GA? Lol! My short hair dogs handle the WI cold just fine

[@davidwindmueller6000]

My youngest really wanted a Dutch shepherd as did I. The cold weather issue was due to the fact we were going to move to Colorado.

[@Juanburr]

We have a giant schnauzer that is 7 years old now. She is very much a family protector. She is still very active and enjoys being around our grandchildren.

[@davidwindmueller6000]

That's awesome. I love hearing that.

[@danielbadiang3817]

I always was interested in this dogs . I will keep watching to see how he turns out . Much Aloha’s for the video .🤙🏾

[@eljuanchosf]

I've had GS' for most of my life. My last one, Toro, lived until almost 14 years old. He passed away one year ago, and yesterday I found myself looking for breeders in my area. GS' can be addictive. Smart, curious, protective clowns. Hope you enjoy yours!!!

[@teehorton5083]

Everyone stops when they see a Chihuahua coming! Great Video!

[@davidwindmueller6000]

😂

[@teehorton5083]

It’s so funny! The first question I always get asked is do they bite? And I say yeah they got to eat! I got 3 Chihuahuas/Mexican Pit Bulls! I love dogs!

[@markw999]

You hear 2 things about the health of Giant Schnauzers. Either very good or very bad. Wondering if that's the difference between show and working lines??

[@dylanbrown3840]

I recently lost my working line GSD and have also been looking at a Giant Schnauzer

[@jeanellef9336]

Dog Lover here, Kazi DP is a good looking family dog, sorry for your loss. Your GS is just as Gorgeous. He will do a fabulous job. Enjoy your New Baby!

[@davidwindmueller6000]

Thank you. Kazi was amazing. Tux is a special puppy. I'm looking forward to raising him to an adult.

[@edwardgomez3633]

Great choice. We’ve had 2 Giants. We’ve also had a Doberman and now have a Dogo the last 6 years. All great breeds.

[@davidwindmueller6000]

The Dogo breed is really cool.

[@antownemercer7552]

@edwardgomez3633- True those breeds you've owned are great but which was your all around favorite?

[@edwardgomez3633]

@@antownemercer7552 that’s a great question. I’d have to answer it by saying I owned these dogs between age 22-67 and between being a single person to a married man raising a family and now back to just my Wife and I in the home. Dogs respond differently to their environment. The Dogo we have now is perfect for our situation. The world is a dangerous place and I am happy being under her watchful protection. Our Doberman was the perfect Family dog. My Daughter just lost her GS of 10 years and I’ve never witnessed a deeper connection between a person and a dog. My Rottweiler was my first dog. Over 40 years later I still have fond memories. He was a big teddy.

[@Celt777]

My deepest condolences on your Doberman.😢

[@davidwindmueller6000]

Thank you

[@kathleenredick275]

I love the Boxers. Not cold weather dogs, tho. I just had to put down my beloved dog companion. Have been trying to balance Boxer, Labrador (black have been most protective in my experience) or Giant Schnauzer. I like the Standard Schnauzer, but don't think the deterrent *look* is enough.

[@burtonkephart6239]

I owned a red Doberman and a standard schnauzer years ago . Both great dogs but I realized if I had just gotten a giant schnauzer then I’d of had really almost both in one !! And yes my Doberman didn’t like cold weather unless he was running around !! Now I own a Australian cattle dog ( blue heeler ) but next dog I want a Giant !! I loved my standard and he was very intelligent and great watch dog and personality . I like a dog that has guard dog instinct and can retrieve and also hopefully likes water but especially the first two. I lived in Birmingham Alabama with the schnauzer and dobie and yes dobie liked warm weather and schnauzer liked cooler .

[@davidwindmueller6000]

Very cool.

[@JoEnUtZ23]

I’ve owned German shepherds, huskies and now I have a Doberman. She just turned 14 years old last month. For me…. I wouldn’t get any other breed now. I’m a Doberman guy for life. My only issue is that once’s she goes. I’ll have a hard time getting another one. So if I do chose to. You bet it’ll be another Doberman lol

[@TheSagaGemini]

Had one from 1990-2000 named Brutto.Cropt,european line...magestic..my forewer friend and guardian. Cheers from Croatia ❤️

[@davidwindmueller6000]

Thanks for the comment. 👋

[@aarona.dubzperson8245]

Nice. We're getting a Giant Schnauzer pup in Jan 2024. He's a week old right now, so of course we have to wait a few weeks. Thanks for the vid.

[@the_watcher_abc]

One breed that you may not have come across is the CBR. The Chesapeake Bay Retriever was bread to retrieve and guard. They descend from hunting hounds and the Lessor Newfoundland. They weigh in between 70 and 120 ponds and are famous for very cold wet weather retrieving. They are wonderful with the family and very, very guard-ie. Their nickname is the ‘pit-bull of the marsh’ because they will not tolerate anyone or any dog who isn’t part of your hunting party. They will run them off and don’t hesitate to bite. But be warned they are not Labradors. These are real working dogs that must be worked hard daily. I like that mine is very alert and is an excellent watch dog, but has the mastiff type guard qualities of not backing down, so he’s an asset to our security. AND I can take him hunting all day in cool weather where he’s a beast. Having said all that this may not be a good breed for the first time dog owner. Most new owners think they are getting a fuzzy brown Lab, but what they are actually getting is a super athletic retrieving Rottweiler. The other downside is they tend to overheat when working them in temps over 80f. PS I have always been a fan of the Giant Schnauzer for the reasons you mentioned. Nice vid.

[@davidwindmueller6000]

I used to see those dogs in Maryland when I was in high school. Very rugged.

[@oui2826]

120 pounds? Man wtf you're capping. 80 at best

[@the_watcher_abc]

@@oui2826 most Breeders have been breeding CBRs smaller because the smaller dogs tend to hunt better and live longer, but there are some very large dogs still being bread. I have come across several. Remember that one of the breeds that make up the CBR is the lesser Newfoundland. And although the lessor Newfoundlands were not as big as the Newfoundland we know today, they were still substantial dogs.

[@RV103]

@@oui2826go to conformation show and you’ll see multiple males 90lbs+

[@CharleneJanzen]

I have always owned miniture schnauzers and really like their personalities. We are getting ready in the next few months to move to our family farm and want to get a companion that will be suitable to our new life. Had your giant schnauzer been working out well living on a farm? If so do you have a recommendation of where I could find a reputable breeder? I live in KS.

[@davidwindmueller6000]

Tux has been really good in our farm environment. He likes to herd the chickens a little too much, but otherwise he's great. Here's a link you might find useful: marketplace.akc.org/puppies/giant-schnauzer

[@CharleneJanzen]

@@davidwindmueller6000 thank you!

[@alphatruckhouse8223]

Great Choice , i have never had one ,but based on your criteria ; i think it's a wise choice. I did experience 2 of them that tried to attack my 105 lb Wolf Dog early am on the trail. But she spun and they were both kept at bay with no harm. ( i don't think he's gonna be quit as athletic as ur Dobi ) but conditioning can bring him to a champion level ~peace~

[@jessewinchester2979]

David, this video was spectacular. You have a rare, natural talent for creating content. And of course, it resonated, as my wife and I are somewhere in-between grieving and understanding how necessary it is to the two of us we share our lives with a companion/companions again. You touched on the toughest piece to the process: The reconciliation. Moving past replacing what you've lost, which cannot be done. But understanding there's a beautiful new chapter to start when you turn the page. We'll get there. The Giant Schnauzer is a real consideration for this GSD family in NH. Thank you!

[@davidwindmueller6000]

Thank you for the wonderful words. We still miss our old dog, but are building great memories with our pup.

[@WarrenFoxJr-ii7qz]

Great choice of a dog. You don't see many of them. Giant poodles are nice to. Enjoy that beautiful dog.

[@juromravec2485]

Have you considered beauceron? I know this is older video though. Just curious what do you think.

[@davidwindmueller6000]

I did look at the Beauceron, but like the GSD, Dutch shepherd, and Malinois, the fur shedding was why I chose the Giant Schnauzer over those breeds.

[@theodorleberle]

How much of action/exercise does he need? Is it a dog which needs agility training everyday and such to be calm and happy?

[@velvetjones1856]

I couldn't go 8 months without a dog. It was less than a week the last two times we lost a dog. First and english bulldog, then switched to a smaller french bulldog. and now another frenchie. All had some similar straights but very different personalities, just like kids.

[@davidwindmueller6000]

We were supposed to be moving across the country which is part of why it took so long. I was also grieving a lot and didn't realize it until we got our pup.

[@leionrosegold7510]

The giant schnauzer and Doberman remind me also of each other I spent a lot of time with both the schnauzer and pinscher are both terriers schnauzer in short means long haired pinscher or wire coated pinscher

[@thatPSNguy99]

giant schnauzer is one third doberman

[@craig5010]

Crazy how I been doing research on both breeds and it was these two great breeds I will do the Giant Schnauzer!

[@davidwindmueller6000]

Very nice

[@mikedr1549]

I saw a video today on the Giant Schnauzer that claimed they may have mixed Doberman's with the standard schnauzer to get the Giant breed. Not sure if it's true but it wouldn't surprise me. I've had mini schnauzers most of my life - super smart and entertaining. Would love to have a Giant if we had the room for one! Enjoy your pup - he's beautiful!

[@davidwindmueller6000]

Yeah, a lot of the claimed mixed in breeds for the GS are intriguing. There are definitely some stark differences between the 2 breeds.

[@jonathanpark7658]

The standard schnauzer and German pincher, cousins. They were both bread up as guardians. Definitely some similarities, definitely some differences. Though my experience is limited.

[@mmurmurjohnson2368]

Large Standard Schnauzers were mixed with Bouviers, Great Danes, and I think possibly standard poodles to get the Giant Schnauzers, whereas German Pinschers were mixed with larger dogs, rottweilers, I think Great Danes and some others to get the Doberman Pinscher. Originally the prototypes; the Standard Schnauzer and the German Pincsher where just long and short haired versions of the exact same dog. Modern breeders have even crossed the two types recently and you end up getting both Pinscher-ish or more Schnauzer-ish puppies again in the very same litter, but the pups did manage to lose the trademark black and pepper salt colorations.

[@Mr9Milly]

I was between a giant and an American Akita. Ended up with the akita. Couldn't be happier! But doing research on the two, heard nothing but great things about the giant. I'm sure he'll serve you well.

[@davidwindmueller6000]

Thank you

[@cc66bb44]

I was just about to mention Akita and you did😀

[@carnebrant]

how did you think he worked in cold weather? I own one myself and i have issues with her getting cramp in the paws when its to cold and need to use socks on her. I keep her fur fairly short but even when i dont cut her during the winter she cramps. actually gets worse if i dont cut her fur on the legs and paws since the snow stucks in it. Other than that i will probably never get another type of bread. Shes my best friend and she would defend me with her life and is allso the funniest dog I ever met. she´s a clown most of the time and loves to play and when im at the local club noone could tell that shes 9 years old. In here mind i thinks shes still 2. =) Higly trainable and loves to work both when we practice and when its the real deal, Planing on getting a puppy soon so i have a rolemodel still alive for the pup.

[@davidwindmueller6000]

With Winter almost over, Tux had no problem with the cold here in Georgia. Kazi was always in a coat during our winters. Tux never seemed bothered and would even eat in the rain like it was nothing.

[@tiffsaver]

Thanks for this interesting and informative video!!

[@peterbaumannyourwealth]

Hi David, Does Tux live inside as well? Sleep inside? I hear conflicting opinions on what GS need with this

[@davidwindmueller6000]

Yes, he sleeps inside with my kids.

[@dr.a.995]

I would have recommended the Airedale Terrier. They are impervious to foul weather, intelligent, brave (served in WW I), family-oriented, slow to trigger to violence but quick to inform of strangers. Ours were large (90 lb male). Stripping them by hand was how I marked the start of Spring.

[@davidwindmueller6000]

90 pounds?! Holy 💩

[@gregalcorn-pu5ye]

Yeah they're great dogs man tough as hell people are the people either don't know about them or they underestimate them which is a mistake

[@keithgriffiths9864]

ATs are great ❤

[@timmclemee3790]

We have two female GS, we do NOT breed them. The oldest is 5 and about 85 pounds, she is full guard whereas her niece is our second one and close to 3 yrs old, she is a BEAST, she hits the scales at 110 pounds, solid muscle. The largest of the two is more like a black panther than a dog, she walks like one, behaves like a cat and can flat footed jump over 5' high from a standing position. They are both very very protective and all the grand kids belong to them, they both have made it clear to the grand kids parents there will be no spankings with them around. I will never be without Giants in my home.

[@NihalShedagaruAshoka]

Hey, could you please share the kennel name that provided you with this lovely puppy.

[@davidwindmueller6000]

Elegy

[@robynwhite5662]

I have a miniature schnauzer that thinks he’s a giant. Been so intrigued by the giants since we got him. I have a standard poodle. He’s non-shedding VERY protective. I call him my fluffy Doberman.

[@davidwindmueller6000]

Nice

[@jonathanpark7658]

My limited experience with giants, is that like any breed, they vary. Though most seem to be versatile. They can do scent work, guard work, and just about anything else you want. Though I'd say many dont have the ocd endurance that my German shepherds have had. I tend to prefer the chill aspect as a family pet and guardian. The giants I've worked with also tend to freeze and observe when they get 'confused', see 'danger' or anything odd happens.

[@davidwindmueller6000]

Interesting. Are you a trainer?

[@jonathanpark7658]

@@davidwindmueller6000 nope, just have a little community of giants in my area, I have personally done scent work with my giant along with basic and advanced obedience type stuff. 11 Giants total They all do well in obedience, they seem to be good in scent work. Some of them are trained in protection.

[@jonathanpark7658]

@@davidwindmueller6000 my experience with working dogs, German shepherds, mals and the like comes from working with military working dogs. I was a medic and worked with the dog handler school. Just what I saw, heard and was taught since I had a German shepherd at the time.

[@davidbrown3029]

I have a question for you? You stated that when he gets into stuff he smells. My question is does he stay in the house with the family and if so when he goes outside to the bathroom and walking or playing outside when he come back in does he smell. I say that to say this I had a bernadoddle Rip Onxy. He lived in the house but when you took him outside for whatever reason he would smell like a skunk for about 10-15mins when he came back in the house, it was so weird to me. I also live in Ga and I wanted a giant 2 years ago I was on a list for a Breeder in Atl but I just didn’t trust that process? I recently put a deposit down for a giant. Thank you for your helpful advice

[@davidwindmueller6000]

Tux is essentially an indoor dog, meaning he sleeps and stays inside most of the time. However, I work him daily in the back, and he regularly dives in the pond and goes in the dirt and mud. So when he gets gross, we keep him off the furniture and will bathe him a few times a week.

[@jerrimorris8494]

Never would trade a dobie best dogs ever

[@8BBB88.]

Got a follow from me. Looking forward to seeing him over the years

[@KevinFry-pw2jh]

David- What a great Video. I would to ask two questions: I am researching the GS health, what should be the main questions besides Hip dysplasia. Eye disease, Thyroid ? second question: Are you feeding him Dry/wet, what is recommended at pup stage . I have a RRB now and he is great dog-needs a playmate. The folks on this thread are very nice !!! they may have made the decision for me and my family- Thank you all.

[@davidwindmueller6000]

I am not a GS expert, I would look for a solid breeder with proven pedigrees. As far as the food, we just go "Prey Model Raw". Basically frozen chicken quarters and pork butt. No grains with the exception of table scraps.

[@KevinFry-pw2jh]

@@davidwindmueller6000 Thank you very much. Appreciate the look have a great night.

[@tomhighsmith]

He reminds me of my Bouviers that I used to have, they look very similar. I also think they are both very calm and sensible.

[@arizonaronin1974]

Cane" Corso It's extremely athletic mine up until she was about 5 used to jump my 6 foot fence. At 120 pounds. They are only as lazy as their owner. And one of the most intelligent dogs I have ever seen. My understands for separate languagesAnd has double medical certifications for me. Also Was trained for protection work. You can Continue the training forever only limited by us.

[@thebarkingbooth6385]

Giants are great dogs. Excellent. The Bouvier des Flandres would also do exceedingly well for you.

[@ivanracine431]

Great choice they are dorbermen dna in them live 12 to 15 years old tough as nails extremely strong very smart dog you have to train him well are he will become the leader and could be dangerous had a 125 lbs giant people were scared but he was well trained would not anything only on command cheers they love the cold from 🇨🇦

[@racknat]

Never thought of my GS as a furry Doberman, but whatever floats! I will say they don't need cropped ears for them to have a presence. I'd add that GS tend to slow down a bit more than most in the warm weather cuz double coats all in black make for warm doggos. Stripping really is the way to go although it is time consuming.

[@davidwindmueller6000]

I didn't expect GS owners to have that opinion. On paper it seems like an equivalent, but living with a GS is much different than a Doberman.

[@racknat]

​@@davidwindmueller6000 Ah that makes more sense cuz yeah, the difference, of course, is in the experience. No litters, let alone individual pups prepared me for our fiesty little piranha. Good thing she mellowed out after a few years. Enjoy the whirlwind with Tux!

[@CaneCorsoShow]

I was looking to get a GS or a Cane Corso. The GS is a beautiful dog. And its' great protection. SUPER STRONG. People underestimate the strength of those dogs by far. I've seen multiple people getting drug down the street by their GS in Colombia

[@davidwindmueller6000]

Damn

[@eia14]

Great video David! We've been wanting to get a GS for a while and have been in contact with the breeder for more than a year. We are now pregnant with our first daughter and got the call from the breeder that they are going to have puppies available in like 2 months.... 3 months before our daughter is born. We're now doing research to learn how good are GSs with babies and kids.. Care to shed any info on this please... We've had 2 labs in the past, and I would trust them my baby with my eyes closed, but labs are silly and never aggressive. Whjat are your thought on this?

[@davidwindmueller6000]

My kids are 10 and 8 and have experience with our last Doberman, however they have had some learning to do with Tux as a puppy. While he has not harmed them, there have been combative moments from him that we were able to mitigate. Puppies in general are quite mouthy and are not well behaved. While teething they can break skin while instigating play. I personally wouldn't raise a GS puppy and baby at the same time. It's too much work.

[@vincentbrown9158]

I agree with you 100% and like you I have had both, The Doberman is a great dog for the reasons you stated. BUT THEY DO NOT DO WELL WITH EXTREME TEMPS, COLD OR HOT. My pair of giant schnauzers where the absolute best! The female "Showgirl" was super intelligent; she did some things naturally, I never had to train her on certain things. The male "Kid Dynamite" was definitely "dynamite." But very affectionate and he actually took has lead from the female, "showgirl." However, The Giant Schnauzer is very strong willed and not necessarily for the unexperienced owner. If you want a top of the line dog and understand how to properly train your dog and establish yourself as they "alfa" then you cannot go wrong with this breed.

[@davidwindmueller6000]

@@vincentbrown9158 💯

[@powderedtoastfacekillah734]

I also see them like hairy Dobermans And if you ever see a clean shaven Giant they look like slightly more solid black Dobermans

[@lakedog3616]

Not saying they would be better but, did you consider an Airedale?

[@davidwindmueller6000]

No I didn't.

[@tomelzear]

any consideration of the Beauceron?

[@davidwindmueller6000]

There was a little consideration, but not a lot. Have similar characteristics as a GSD.

[@nycas2192]

Female or male Gaint schnauzer for family with kids?

[@davidwindmueller6000]

I don't have a lot of experience with female dogs, I always choose males. I would say what would be more important is to have your children bought in and heavily involved in the training of whatever dog you choose. I see a lot of people having to give up their Giant Schnauzers because they are not doing well with their children.

[@ronniemaclaine5234]

Well-bred pitbulls are very intelligent. Sometimes they are so stubborn that they seem like they're not but once you get it in their head to listen to you ,you can train them to do just about anything.

[@davidwindmueller6000]

Yes, there are some stellar pits, but the breed as a whole, not so much.

[@ronniemaclaine5234]

@@davidwindmueller6000 I was just saying because I used to breed them. I think the worst things that can ever happen to a breed is it to become popular or a show dog.

[@sjemna]

I miss my Mario giant Schnauzer. Passed away from cancer at 9and a half. Best dog ever. He was oversized for the breed , peaked at 144pounds, all muscle ,no fat Now we have an 8 pounds Pomeranian equally as intelligent and he thinks he's a doberman 😂 I know you will enjoy your Giant, just stay on top with training, they are very strong willed

[@davidwindmueller6000]

Sorry to hear about Mario, he sounds like he was a big dude.

[@sjemna]

@@davidwindmueller6000 My gentle Giant .... Have fun, they are great dogs, easy to train, very smart and loyal

[@Whocaress700]

Dogo argentino handle the cold quite well actually, snow and everything. Also have a Rottweiler that easily jumps a 6 foot brick wall. It lol depends I guess

[@tarynclemons]

Hello, I lost my Shorkie of 16 years last August. A year later, I feel it’s time for another fur baby. I live in Ga, too. Can you tell me the name of kennel/ breeder where you got tux?

[@davidwindmueller6000]

I got him down around Tampa, FL at Elegy Kennels.

[@josealferez6376]

I love my "Ragnar" 140 pound Doggo Argentino but I think when he gets older I will definitely look for a Giant Schnauzer. I live in Germany so I don't think I'll have issues finding a good working line. I need a dog that will be able to hunt with me. The German government has said no to my Doggo.

[@pauloshaanker5456]

A most interesting vid to me because after owning three Dobes in a row I finally switched. I considered SO many breeds, and even branched out to considering longer haired breeds despite my original list of requirements including a short coat. *May I ask if your GS whines much?* The Doberman whining was the number one factor that made me finally switch. Of course, my last two were working line, and they are a different animal and hard to live with. I considered the GS, and agree with you on the intimidating look. I require it too. The cropped ears are a must. I passed on the breed because I wanted something lower energy than a Dobe and less demanding of exercise and stimulation. The GS seemed too close to the Dobe in that regard. The Dobe is extremely trainable and biddable, where the GS is a bit less so. I also was not satisfied with the size of any of the GS I found. I was looking for a larger dog than the Dobe. Congrats on your new GS pup, and I wish you the best of success!

[@davidwindmueller6000]

I don't want to speak of the breeds as a whole, but Tux (GS) seems to be a little more vocal and sensitive than I remember Kazi being at this age. I wouldn't say he whines, but he barks a lot more and groans. Kazi also had a bit more drive early on. Tux isn't afraid of rain and it's significantly more cuddly than Kazi was.

[@pauloshaanker5456]

Thanks, man.@@davidwindmueller6000

[@millzchan9285]

Hello. What is the name of the breeder you went with?

[@davidwindmueller6000]

Elegy

[@AmyKaminski-f1x]

Can you tell me what breeder you got him from ? I’ve always wanted one and am afraid of going through the wrong person

[@davidwindmueller6000]

I got Tux from Elegy, but this link is a good resource. marketplace.akc.org/puppies/giant-schnauzer

[@foyorama]

my giant is my best friend and the best protection for our family