Why Jinnah Became Governor General And Not PM? | Dr Ayesha Jalal

[@Imranyoutubedotcom]

I'm reading the pakistan paradox.. there are countless references of. ayesha jalal's books. This speaks about her stature as an author

[@CheemaAMC1979]

Being a student of history I haven't found any historian in Pakistan particularly the liberal lot that matches the stature of Ayesha Jalal. I love the way solangi got disappointed by Miss Jalal' s answer regarding Jinnah.

[@akhtarumrani6353]

Madam Mr. Jinnah took the position G.G because under the India Act of 1935 G,G had a lot of powers and PM was only empowered on certain subjects. Basically, Jinnah wanted power, therefore, he took the seat of G.G himself.

[@behtereen4187]

Absolutely. He wanted power without accountability which rested with the PM.

[@shibhanlalpandita6975]

What Islamic invasion achieved in 800 years was flushed down the drain by Jinnah. Some defeats are more important than victories. Muslims lost a subcontinent & Hindus gained a country. Jinnah is Father of India.

[@Inner.divinity]

Yes..feel free to worship Jinnah as the 11th Avtar of Lord Vishnu along with Adi Purush Moti ji in your temples .....

[@dourbeen]

Because jinnah wanted presidential system not parliamentary system for Pakistan.This is in written from him.

[@nikhilhembrom8952]

Jinnah is biggest saviour of hindus in medival times when hindu kings defeated mughals they never converted common muslims jinnah took all the trash by himself he himself destroyed 800 years of islamisation process

[@sheikhmairaj92]

75 سال بعد اس طرح کی باتیں نکالنے سے ہمارے قومی رہنماو کے ساتھ زیادتی ہے ،،ان چاروں میں ایسا کون ہے جو پاکستان بننے کے وقت موجود تھا اور باشعور تھا ؟ ان کو اس وقت کے حالات کا کیا اندازہ ہوگا۔۔جو جتنا جیسا بھی ملک مل گیا ہے اس کی خدمت کرو خدا کا شکر ادا کرو

[@dourbeen]

Brother these people have their own agenda.

[@AllamaMashriqi]

#Clip 18 #documentary | UP Governor Sir Harry Graham Haig Signs Agreement on Allama Mashriqi's Terms kzbin.info/www/bejne/bqPQfHihasmkl7c

[@hgkjkj]

Wrong analysis! Jinnah was so big a personality to Pakistani Muslims that he would have retained his authority under any circumstances. It is stupid to think that Pakistan would break if Jinnah didn’t become Prime Minister. It was his mistake, alongside many other mistakes. Such a shallow analysis by Ayesha.

[@AllamaMashriqi]

#Clip 18 #documentary | UP Governor Sir Harry Graham Haig Signs Agreement on Allama Mashriqi's Terms kzbin.info/www/bejne/bqPQfHihasmkl7c

[@sachitalkhiyan3487]

This lady has a totally Wrong approach about losses of the governor ship of Muhammad Ali Jinnah to Pakistan.

[@bagatsingh4258]

Valid analysis by Dr Ayesha Jalal

[@kalidasswaminathan4341]

Arre, no one ever suggested the Mountbatten be made Governor General of Pakistan. This is something that ONLY she cites without any evidence to offer a lame excuse to Jinnah in hindsight. The simple fact was he wanted all powers concentrated in the colonial office without having to answer to parliament. Thus paving way for the political mess that now obtains there.

[@sachitalkhiyan3487]

As well as I understood,This lady proved herself a true British agent and nowadays represents the USA .....

[@dourbeen]

Lol.. Dude 😂

[@behtereen4187]

​​@@dourbeen She certainly does want to be in with the Establishment. 😢

[@dourbeen]

@@behtereen4187 true

[@amitsai]

Don't agree with logics Mam. Also is she trying to say that he was not courageous enough to take bigger role to make Pakistan a success???? Maybe that's why they say that you can reach on top somehow but staying there proves that you are a champion

[@hassansherazi]

Well agar tum ek team k leader hu ur tumhe pata chalta hai k tum kuch time baad marne wale hu tu kiya tum us team ki command full power k sath rakho ge ya ek ek neye player ko tayar karo ge future k liye?

[@yasmeenzaman847]

Jinnah Shb would have appointed someone else as Governor General as suggested by Mr Solangi. I don’t agree with A. Jalal’s logic. Jinnah Shb was not very democratic.

[@Fitness4Freshies]

May Allah grant Quaid e Azam a place in Jannah tul Firdous for giving us a free nation where we can live without fear of what is happening to Kashmiris and Palestinians. Ameen.

[@mominamomin5429]

Ameen 🌸❤

[@behtereen4187]

​@@mominamomin5429 Please don't worry. It can be said with certainty that he's enjoying 72 hoorain right now.

[@muhammadkazimi8854]

Thank you for your insight Dr.Ayesha Jalal

[@AbaseenPodcast]

This is a terrible justification of Jinnah's undemocratic behaviour and brings into quesion his leadership abilities.

[@naeemharry413]

سولنگی اور رومی صاحب یہ کہاں سے آؤٹ ڈیٹ ڈ گوری لے آئے ھیں، اسے تو تاریخ کی سنس ھی نہیں ۔

[@sheshahayat5117]

British people wished they had a leader like Jinnah,,, Visit Jinnah by Christopher Lee,,,,

[@sheshahayat5117]

There would have been no india, let alone Pakistan, if Jinnah wasn’t there and by now British India would’ve been in shackles like none before. So even Indians must thank Jinnah not Gandi,,,

[@PS-ej2xn]

A quick note to you from the office of Ayesha Jalal,, Jinnah created this universe, revealed the Holy Quran to Muhammad, built the cities of Mecca and Medina, and filled Pakistan with the special air you breathe . Don't undersell the man.

[@naeemharry413]

یہ کیا غلط تاریخ بتا رھی ھے۔ یہ گورنر جنرل کو سپورٹ کر رھی ھے۔ اللہ ایسے تاریخ دانوں سے بجائے ۔

[@sadiqhussain157]

قاٸد کو وزیر اعظم بنا دیتے ھندستان تقسیم نہ ھوتا ۔یہ سیاست کی ناکامی ھے

[@rtewari12071963]

Jinnah knew about his health status yet chose to be GG with the intention of 'consolidating' the nation. What about the the intrusion into Kashmir in 1947 itself? Was he for it or against it? Or did he miscalculate his strength or under estimated the Indian Army response?

[@dourbeen]

Jinnah ordered that intrusion.. and it was a success. The whole Gilgit balitstan and Azad Kashmir ( signed off to india by hari singh) was captured by Pakistan

[@arifeenalvi]

Question is about Governor general,s constitutional authority.priminitsrs authority compromized.After Janah ghulam Mohammad established authoritarian rule in pakistan and destroyed the country.In democracy no person above the head of government with higher authority.This is against the sprit of democracy.

[@venkatrammohangovind4092]

Mr JINNAH took idea of governor from British system.which is being practiced by British in which all powers are with GG.Jinnah like to concentrate all the power in him that is why choose to become governor

[@ranamuhammadusama8051]

Nice explaination miss Ayesha jalal

[@abdulhameedkhatti9231]

He talked about Muslim minority. He didn't talk about minority in the sense we now deem

[@mansehra1000]

Once i used to consider Ayesha Jalal an iconic figure but her unnecessarily tilt towards undemocratic steps of Jinnah and her partisan rhetoric manifests little concerns about basics of democracy..most of her talk is based on fears and assumptions " ye b ho jata ye ho jata"... Worshipping Jinnah is not service to Jinnah

[@dourbeen]

Lol what democracy.. u were literally under the king. There was no constitution.. how would u get that in a year maan sadqay jaun pm chahyyay tha....Jinnah planned a presidential system for Pakistan.

[@IjazKhan-g7s]

Dissatisfied answers by Dr Ayesha mam😢

[@tejindersharma8603]

Jalal couldn't gave a convincing reasoning

[@amjadsohail3253]

dr Ayesha Jalal is below what she seems to be when she said that Jinnah wanted to solve the current issues of Muslims ,Jinnah has never been a strong practicing Muslim then how can he have such a strong affection for Muslims

[@quddusquddus136]

The phrase "falling apart" keep popping up. In its' auspicious beginning, Pakistan enjoys the right to be on its critical phase. English language remains an enigma in a colonized world.

[@abuzarrar774]

But M.A Jinnah knew that he was suffering from a fatal illness and his biggest enemy was time....he did not have time to lay strong foundation for a stable political framework of Pakistan....which led to the political chaos till 1958 when the infant Pakistan was suffered with the first Martial Law.... Also it was some kind of devine help that congress leadership of that time became more interested in separating muslims due to the role that Liaqat Ali khan played as Finance Minister in coalation Govt of 1946 M.A jinnah and leadership of then were struggling for freedom for 7 years...and there was no homework done in terms of planning for the resources and manpower required...and even though we already knew that InshaAllah Pakistan would become a reality yet very little was done in terms of any post-independence sop and planning and that resulted in a disabled independent state that has not yet been recovered and was also broken half....

[@syedaamirhussain6111]

Jinnah Sb did what was good for Pakistan and most of the terms used for political bargain with Congress. You were slaves in India read Congress Raj 1937 to 1939. Secondly the killing of Hussain R.A is known by all of us. So Jinnah Sb told catatonically that State has nothing to do with it and you are free to go to any place of worship you want. Please 🙏 don't malign your leadership like Jinnah Sb.....

[@kiranpeter5630]

Life does teach you who are pseudo intellectuals. Finally.

[@rksingh9186]

This lady is living in with as wife with the brother of Sharmila Bose, who is supporting Pakistan army in her books.

[@PS-ej2xn]

This is disgraceful. This is not a historian. It's just pure apologia and propaganda. History will not be kind to Ayesha Jalal.

[@memyself9959]

Aisha Jalal totally biased !!! "Jinnah became Governor Gen. Just to hold the Power of the Country, as Liaquat Ali Khan was the PM but all the Powers were in Hands of Jinnah, he was presiding Meetings instead of this PM should to Chair that Meetings, but Jinnah was going that!"

[@Moe.allama2023]

"There was no uniting factor for Pakistan if Jinnah was not the GG"..... Ok, hmm....jesus, I always thought Islam was the Uniting Factor? LOL

[@zf2000]

What a stupid comment.

[@somenathnit]

Yeahh....islam was that unifying factor

[@dourbeen]

Are pakistani people as a society in whole following islam?

[@maktv4802]

اسٹوپڈ آنسر

[@saeedr7863]

بالکل فضول دلیل ہے عائشہ کی۔ ماونٹ بیٹن کیوں ہوتا؟ آزاد ملک اپنا وزیراعظم خود منتخب کرتا۔

[@syedhanifrasool]

Illogical statement of Ayesha Jalal on Jinnah's occupation as a Governor General

[@Kinge-Boy1261]

Ayesha looks sophisticated Pakistan study book

[@PS-ej2xn]

Are you a Pakistani? If so, I must salute you. It's sometimes hard to see the obvious if we live with it all the time.

[@hassanrajput9576]

Sovereignty State Consolidation

[@TariqKhan-fl7qb]

Waoooo understanding Jinnah in 2022 by their own perception lol...

[@ViewsNewsChannel]

The answers made no sense. It looks like they have no political sense.

[@erbazkhan266]

Not at all convincing. Her argument is based on mere assumptions.

[@muhammadkhan6033]

Bhonga jawab.

[@behtereen4187]

As if it wasn't a "simple disaster" otherwise. Hilarious.

[@zf2000]

... still better than that hell on earth called ....

[@PankajSharma-ir7fb]

Prof istiyak trashes her all claims. Invite him to argue with this lady....

[@Fitness4Freshies]

At least learn to say his name properly before you comment on it. “Istiyak” what the f&rk

[@PankajSharma-ir7fb]

@@Fitness4Freshies you got it... Thats the point.. Why do u even bother to point?

[@Fitness4Freshies]

@@PankajSharma-ir7fb Sharma kuch sharam krlo, how would you like it if I pronounce your name “Sarma” which is a Turko/Greek dish? Respect people’s names and say it right .

[@PankajSharma-ir7fb]

@@Fitness4Freshies I wouldnt mind actually, as long as one is able to figure out and it's not derogatory. Why are you being so touchy here?

[@Fitness4Freshies]

@@PankajSharma-ir7fb not being touchy , just trying to educate you a bit on pronunciation; you know names have meanings and if you “mispronounce” a name it can mean something totally different and derogatory; try to work on that before you say the name; the name you’re trying to say is “Ishtiaq” meaning "longing" or "craving".

[@camenezes1]

AJ: it was not a foregone 'conclusion' - It was pure ego... and non democratic. Don't base your assessments on false assumptions. Address the elephant in the room.

[@AllamaMashriqi]

#Clip 18 #documentary | UP Governor Sir Harry Graham Haig Signs Agreement on Allama Mashriqi's Terms kzbin.info/www/bejne/bqPQfHihasmkl7c