Why Kazakhstan is Insanely Empty

[@Xntsgarcia]

I have always loved Kazakhstan. You have the coolest and most beautiful flag! Love from Brazil 🇧🇷🇰🇿

[@ASGARD85]

Obrigado! 🇰🇿🇧🇷

[@Yayer3k]

Nigga simpin

[@Yayer3k]

@AikoTore базара нет

[@mishkaseverokavkazskiy230]

​@AikoToreтвоя писанина попахивает нацизмом.

[@AdamAdam-ee1rg]

@@mishkaseverokavkazskiy230оно не попахивает, оно им пропитано, это закономерное явление, чем больше народ вытерпел тем более националистическое мышление

[@DRAGON-gz8lt]

I live in Kazakhstan and I can tell you the reason: in the 17th century there was a hundred-year war between the Kazakh Khanate and the Dzungaria, where more than 30% of the country's population died, then the Russian Empire came from the colonization, the Kazakhs rebelled, but nothing happened, then when the Reds came, that is, the Soviet Union of Kazakhs there were 6 million but because of the famine there are 2 million of us left

[@44SWAGNUM-MAGA5]

brutal !

[@rayhans7887]

Goddamn

[@theplayerofus319]

and still you got a great future ahead of you and a good growing economy. got some good stocks from your country.

[@SconnerStudios]

Do you guys fear China or Russia ever coming in to your country today? Culturally, is there anti-Russian or Chinese sentiment? I've never met someone from Kazakhstan before, though I think Borat comes from there (joking).

[@theplayerofus319]

@@SconnerStudios i have read that they are very Western oriantated but maybe the og commenter can say more about this.

[@MrCHAIRMANOFTHEBORED]

My brother used to be the ambassador to Kazakhstan, and he told me that the country is incredibly beautiful, the people are absolutely friendly and welcoming and the food is fantastic, I'm hoping to visit Kazakhstan someday especially the Bayterek Tower in Astana/Nursultan and the Baikonur Cosmodrome,a few weeks ago my brother informed me that he was chosen to be the new ambassador to China,he begins his ambassadorship on October 1st,2024🙏

[@ЗубайдаДуйсебаева]

Thank you!Welcome to Kazakhstan!🎉

[@mnn4793]

WELCOME to us!!!

[@ggg000gg]

Приезжай ко мне домой,Казахская кухня тебя сильно удивит и ни когда вы не ели такое блюдо

[@bigsurbill]

Yes, I saw Borat also. Can I really sell my sister? She is good cook, keep house clean but she has no vagina. Will follow up!

[@АбуталифАкылбеков]

It's Astana now😅

[@arimolyki]

I'm a child of 2 engineers in the uranium industry, whose parents migrated into Kazakhstan (KSSR) in the Soviet times. They never fully assimilated in my opinion, still feeling more aligence to Russia, while I absolutely see myself as a Kazakhstani first. I'm really surprised to see how deeply this video resonated with me, and grateful for highlighting how much our country suffered from colonialism as it's still overlooked by many! Love from KZ

[@estherbosbach377]

Yes colonialism. It is hardly seen that way. Wonder why, while in the West colonialism is all over the talk.

[@redme]

Поиязанность это не наш выбор. Это история где нас хотели уничтожить. Но мы выжили. Но пропаганда всю жизнь промывала мозги наших отцов и детов поэтому остались люди думающий что россия наши спасители

[@ktrimbach5771]

That is normal for most immigrants. The first generation never fully assimilated whereas later generations consider themselves native first, then acknowledge their heritage.

[@ktrimbach5771]

⁠@@estherbosbach377 Globalists are trying to destroy the West by destroying nationalism. Russia is restoring their ethnic minorities, while strengthening Russian nationalism. This is why the West hates Russia so much.

[@eliotness4029]

full scale western lie. explain us how you killed all native americans

[@xelzoid]

Thank you for sharing the history of Kazakhstan with so many people, our country has suffered a lot and only now have started getting back up, love from Kazakhstan 🇰🇿 the most hospitable country in the world

[@SombreroGato]

He didnt cover it here, but are there plans to undo the cotton fields irrigation and canals and let eh syr daya flow naturally into the aral again? i know nothing can be done about Uzbek's southern river, but i figured since cotton isnt necessary anymore because of the oil then why not get rid of all the irrigation?

[@merlinious01]

​@user-cv2lh3wu2q ...you don't eat cotton...iirc it is one of the only major crops with zero edible parts.

[@sneaky4217]

Planning to visit towards the end of this year, is there any must visit areas? Thanks in adcance!

[@lifesgood9908]

​@@sneaky4217 there are a lot of wild natural places and urban places

[@NK-093]

@@sneaky4217 You can visit two of our major cities Astana and Almaty

[@painterforbeginners9613]

As a individual adopted from Kazakhstan I can attest that the Kazakh history is sadly forgotten and not looked into. Thank you so so much for sharing apart of my families history. People just think of us as a Borat joke but we have a deep history that needs to be told!

[@dankadesign7462]

I know its heart but dont forget most people never took book to read about history of Kazastan they rely on Google and western propaganda what they read in newspapers...People who are educated will never think of Borat as representative of ur country.cheers

[@watcherOFsteppe]

As a 22 years old kazah, I am sure that our history only starts, and our country's future depends from us new and young generation, I very hope that majority of us will do all what they can do for good future of our homeland.

[@diftyfaq]

Много чего из истории вы крадёте. У узбеков, кыргызов, уйгуров и других. Думаете типо Сталин уничтожил вашу историю, а теперь такие сказки сочиняете. Я был просто в шоке, что сейчас пишут в интернете.

[@Ben_diez]

@@diftyfaq не пиши ничего

[@Mahapadmadipatu]

@@watcherOFsteppe it russian land northern russia would historically slavs land

[@thefrogprincess266]

Cried several times during video. Similar history, know the pains Love and support to amazing people of Kazakhstan from Ukraine ♥️🇺🇦

[@European-Federation]

Yes, Ukraine and Kazakhstan are a victims of Russian colonialism

[@keteket]

🇰🇿❤️‍🩹🇺🇦🫂🫂🫂

[@philipfry8351]

🇰🇿♥️🇺🇦

[@teon5329]

Our history is not similar, u are slavs as russians

[@watcherOFsteppe]

🇰🇿🇺🇦

[@notaeronesiaa]

Love Kazakhstan from Indonesia 🇮🇩❤️🇰🇿

[@antiliberalismKz]

🇰🇿🤝🇮🇩

[@eliotness4029]

full scale western lie. explain us how you killed all native americans. and who robbed kazakhs? who is owner of kazakh oil now?

[@eliotness4029]

Genocides and ethnocides are ubiquitous policies of many modern powerful nations like Britain, USA, how much native people now in USA. how much native people now in Kazakhstan how much native people now in USA government. how much native people now in Kazakhstan government. you are very lucky. you are live. because you was born in Kazakhstan. and hundreds millions was not born in USA because British killed all of them. and now british pays you money to deny truth. Stupid people claim that Kazakhstan is unlucky because Kazakhstan does not have a sea border. And if Kazakhstan had a sea border, then 300 years ago the British colonizers would have come and completely exterminated the entire local population, as they did in Australia and America. Kazakhs are lucky people because they lived inside the continent and the ships of the British Empire could not come close to the lands of the Kazakhs and could not completely destroy the entire Kazakh population

[@user-xn5bq8uo6o]

Respect and love to our Kazakh brothers from Uzbekistan 🇺🇿🇰🇿

[@IX-fc4po]

to you too bro. we should develop further our trade relationships for mutual profit. also you are welcome to come to our country to work or study, its better for you than going to russia (we only ask to do everything in legal way).

[@nauryzbay_qazaqstan]

Assalam yalekum 👋 бауырым

[@always-alicia]

I thought you all hated each other (at least that’s what Borat said).

[@husanalikuvvatov3371]

@@always-alicia it is propaganda, russia wants a conflict between them and always wants to control them

[@dbuonline1]

@@always-alicia non khazak civillians when an arabic looking english actor makes a movie in a state called Romania (formerly a subject) and calls it kazhakistan my point is because of that accursed(funny guy btw) our nothern bretherns in east africa are called walwdwiya or smt

[@Julianna.Domina]

For anyone curious like i was: That circle in the middle of Kazakhstan is the Baikonour Cosmodrome, where Russia launches its spaceships from. It's not de jure russian land, but it is rented basically indefinitely by Russia

[@t.n.h.ptheneohumanpatterna8334]

Why don’t Russia and Kazakhstan reunite I edit it is not okay to call people out of their names for asking a question

[@mjokkerr4150]

@@t.n.h.ptheneohumanpatterna8334 maybe because kazakhs and russians are culturally different people?

[@aparadisebird]

@@t.n.h.ptheneohumanpatterna8334 thats a stuoid question to ask

[@Julianna.Domina]

@@t.n.h.ptheneohumanpatterna8334 Why are you asking me?

[@t.n.h.ptheneohumanpatterna8334]

@@aparadisebird realax bruh I was just curious I edit theI comment this mf really said that’s a stupid comment but bro can’t even spell stupid

[@samaltemirbekova6988]

As a kazakh girl I’m impressed how detailed and accurate is your video! Thank you for your research and spreading knowledge about our country ♥️

[@Lonely_Phoenix]

Айтпа! Бірінші рет осындай тарихшыны көріп тұрмын кім тура шындығын айтты 😢🇰🇿

[@Ghazalee313]

​@@Lonely_Phoenixбіз білмейтін шындығын білетін тарихшылар көп out there. Бұл жерлердің көбі қазір Қытай астында..бір Алла жар болсын халқымызға

[@pinoyRN67]

i’m american 🇺🇸 of asian descent i want to marry a Kazakhstan young woman

[@alichunrepeatable3459]

​@@pinoyRN67Let's break the backbone, Kazakhs for Kazakhs

[@user-er555jf1xc6p]

​@@Lonely_Phoenixи что из этой информации извлекут страны мира? Огромная территория где население всего 20 млн. Супер! Приходите и берите. Даже армии и той нет. Думайте и зрите в корень. Скоро придут. Ждите. Ничего зря в этом мире не делается

[@justadutchman5169]

Great video. As a Dutchman from the small country called the Netherlands I’m fascinated by the huge country of Kazachstan 🇰🇿 Greetings to all Kazakhs from the Netherlands. 💯🫵🏼👍🏼🫡👊🏼✌🏼🇳🇱

[@eliotness4029]

full scale western lie. explain us how you killed all native americans. and who robbed kazakhs? who is owner of kazakh oil now?

[@timgotta1]

Boo to the Netherlands. This man wants to be your King Leopold

[@Daurenkozha]

Kazakhstan has a big potential. 99.8% literacy. Many students are sent abroad to study. No enemies. Friendly to all countries. Vast natural resources. Time will show if Kazakhs will be able to use these advantages or not.

[@expensivenes2645]

As a Kazakh while I agree that my country has a lot of potential its also has a lot of problems Nearly all of Government is corrupt Profiting from land and people not giving anything back First president was in power for 30 years second one is following in his footsteps We have Russia and China as our neighbors depending on them for our economic stability and with no hope of defending if they attack us

[@prostoname5338]

Where did you get ur stats? It’s false

[@fsul8536]

Your country has a bright and prosperous future as long as there is no corruption and the money is invested properly.

[@jcliu]

@@rebeli-argum Is it really flirting with NATO? Kazakhstan seems to be doing a pretty good job leveraging its useful neutrality at the intersection (physical and cultural) of Russia, China, Turkey/Muslim World, and the West. (Xi Jinping guaranteed its territorial integrity after Putin invaded Ukraine!) Whereas, say, Austrian or Swiss neutrality after the Cold War is just depraved free-riding, Kazakh geography still makes sense for it to play all sides. Call it a giant Qatar.

[@rebeli-argum]

@@jcliu swiss are not really neutral anymore. Macron wants Kazakhstan on the side of the west and to stop them trading with Russia because sanctions and all of that. Kazakhstan tries to be Turkey with two chairs strategy but i'm not sure how are they going to do this. They want to be cool with Russia and also want to be cool with the west

[@dsadafar]

We've met so much injustice and struggle through the centuries. Despite that we keep moving forward! Greetings from Kazakhstan 🖐️

[@MARKCRASTO]

You are a brave people! Love from India 🇮🇳

[@createdforthemoment6740]

My friend, heed the warning of Ukraine, don't let yourself fall victim again to Soviet styled thinking....

[@captaincrunch7]

Love from Türkiye

[@andreaswesterveld]

You seem like a country with a dark past and a bright future!

[@jujirer]

@@createdforthemoment6740 they are smart enough not to fall into your traps,what happened to Irãq?to libyå?Ukrāine was attacked because they betråyed us and put our national security at risk at the cost of them getting the benifits of joining NÄTO.

[@spacet3445]

As a Kazakh resident I should say that this is one of the most accurate video about Kazakhstan I've ever seen. Thanks from Kazakhstan

[@NigerianCrusader]

I LOVE KAZAKHSTAN KAZAKHSTAN IS AWESOME ANYONE WHO SAYS THE WORLD IS OVERPOPULATED IS WRONG ANTARCTICA AND CANADA EXIST

[@Eblonoid14]

@@NigerianCrusader I am from Kazakhstan, and I am live in Kazakhstan. I am half Kazakh, and half German.

[@NigerianCrusader]

@@Eblonoid14 YOU ARE THE 1 PERCENT IN GERMANS OF KAZAKHSTAN I SEEN IT ON THE WIKIPEDIA PAGE

[@RamazanKaisar]

@@Eblonoid14hey man, that’s cool! 😁👍

[@eliotness4029]

full scale western lie. explain us how you killed all native americans

[@jameslaylyn]

Love Kazakhstan 😊 From Sweden 🇸🇪 ❤ 🇰🇿

[@Тимур-к6щ6з]

🤝 Aкtobe Kazakhstan

[@pranklinprak]

mutual! I am one of those who love smart people. That's why I love Alfredo Nobel, the father of dynamite, and I love your country, Sweden, just like that🇰🇿🤝🏻🇸🇪

[@eliotness4029]

full scale western lie. explain us how you killed all native americans. and who robbed kazakhs? who is owner of kazakh oil now? As a Kazakh person from Kazakhstan

[@sjjejdjxnsm6176]

Thank you!

[@MyDante7777]

Жерімізде қанша қиыншылық болса да, біз бәрібір көтеріліп, елімізді жаңа биіктерге көтереміз!✊Алға Қазақстан!

[@sakenzhar1721]

İn Şa Allah

[@Habibulat]

Сначала надо победить коррупцию.

[@dudefromdnipro]

Алга Казахстан 🇰🇿,помогаем друг другу 💪

[@colendwinter2705]

@@Habibulat да, сами себе мешаем.

[@ГалымГалымов-д2г]

Сөзіне май, астына тай.

[@kayleighlehrman9566]

You know its bad when "the most nuked place on Earth" is only the second worst environmental disaster in the country's past fifty years.

[@GrimDoesMineCraft]

Yeah I had heard about the Aral Sea shrinking but I didn’t clock how massive the environmental implications would be until this video

[@carkawalakhatulistiwa]

​@@GrimDoesMineCraft aral sea gone after Soviet collapse

[@AlneCraft]

@@carkawalakhatulistiwa They started it.

[@ItIsYouAreNotYour]

Veh-wee Nyee---ice

[@houdini246]

@@carkawalakhatulistiwa Soviets did irreparable damage to sea, which lead to disaster

[@username_504_gateaway]

During the famine, my great-grandfather was the only one of ten brothers who survived. It was genocide, every Kazakh knows and remembers it

[@terraluna9128]

😢

[@qu4zz4r]

Lol. I'm from Kazan, the city on Volga river, Russia, and we had the same famine here at that years. Moreover, Poland had the same at that time. And there were no communist government there. The genocide of Kazakh people is a spooky story like "Golodomor"® in Ukraine

[@dishka3452]

​@@qu4zz4r Depends on what you mean by 'genocide', I guess. As in, It, probably, wasn't intentional but caused by extreme incompetence of the government, which is hardly any consolation.

[@nazarmUKhametzhan]

​@@qu4zz4rдумаю у вас не было голода такого масштаба. Если учесть потери казахов от двух волн от искусственно созданного голода, то получится что минус 50% местного населения. В начале прошлого века казахов и узбеков было одинаково, сейчас нас 20 млн (в том числе русские и другие нации), а братьев узбеков под 40 млн. У той же Украины потери от голода в районе 30% от общего числа всего населения, у нас у казахов пугающие 50%.

[@alinakenzhegariyeva2760]

@@qu4zz4rу казахов от голода умерло половина населения, если не больше. остальные страны хоть и пострадали от голода, но самый ужасный удар был нанесен именно нам.

[@SonUmut-f8r]

Шетелдіктер Қазақстан қандай ел деген кезде осы видеоны көрсететін боламын. Еліміз турасында толыққанды зерттеп, жүйелі видео жасағыныңыз үшін көп рахмет!

[@eliotness4029]

full scale western lie. explain us how you killed all native americans. and who robbed kazakhs? who is owner of kazakh oil now? As a Kazakh person from Kazakhstan

[@aianchik2873]

@@eliotness4029 сглш мал орк

[@zhcultivator]

It would be great if Kazakhstan becomes as Wealthy as South Korea or Singapore 🇸🇬 🇰🇿 🇰🇷 in the future.

[@oxananovikova7812]

для этого надо искоренить коррупцию

[@Enzesshshshsh]

Thank you for believing in us 🇰🇿 with love from the people of Kazakhstan. We will always be glad to see you.❤️✌🏻

[@aazh9869]

I truly believe this will happen. Europe is in the shitter rn, Middle East and Asia are continuing to rise… we are right in the middle. I pray we will continue to rise, our ancestors went through so much, I hope we can make them proud for surviving decades of fascism and colonialism.

[@NigerianCrusader]

SOUTH KOREA IS POOR DID YOU MEAN NORTH KOREA SOUTH KOREA IS POOR NORTH KOREA RICH SOUTH SUDAN IS ALSO RICH

[@NigerianCrusader]

@@EnzesshshshshKAZAKHSTAN IS ALREADY RICH

[@yaseen8511]

Damn! Kazakhs have been through a lot. (At least they have beeen blessed with one of the greatest singers on earth, Dimash Kudaibergen)

[@theseangle]

Listen to Samaltau by him. Exactly about some of the devastating events..

[@eliotness4029]

full scale western lie. explain us how you killed all native americans. and who robbed kazakhs? who is owner of kazakh oil now?

[@eliotness4029]

Genocides and ethnocides are ubiquitous policies of many modern powerful nations like Britain, USA, how much native people now in USA. how much native people now in Kazakhstan how much native people now in USA government. how much native people now in Kazakhstan government. you are very lucky. you are live. because you was born in Kazakhstan. and hundreds millions was not born in USA because British killed all of them. and now british pays you money to deny truth. Stupid people claim that Kazakhstan is unlucky because Kazakhstan does not have a sea border. And if Kazakhstan had a sea border, then 300 years ago the British colonizers would have come and completely exterminated the entire local population, as they did in Australia and America. Kazakhs are lucky people because they lived inside the continent and the ships of the British Empire could not come close to the lands of the Kazakhs and could not completely destroy the entire Kazakh population

[@jake_timabay]

I’m a Kazakh, I have died and risen thousands of times. Amazing job, thank you for this video. catched every moments!

[@sturmx96]

So you are better than Christ then?

[@dumpq8690]

​@@sturmx96 its a quotation from popular kazakh song "i am a kazakh", and if you have a brain, youd know that they didnt mean it literally,,,,,,, like how,,,,,,,,,

[@almurtkettidomalap]

@@dumpq8690 Негізі ол Жұбан Молдағалиевтің өлеңінен алынған, дереккөз ретінде соны көрсеткен жөн

[@Ataulf108]

​@@sturmx96russich

[@kuanysh.tynybek]

Thank you very much for your video, brother, it's very detailed! I am a Kazakh, studying in Germany. Working hard every day to make my country rise one day 🇰🇿🇰🇿🇰🇿

[@eliotness4029]

full scale western lie. explain us how you killed all native americans. and who robbed kazakhs? who is owner of kazakh oil now? As a Kazakh person from Kazakhstan

[@colincuratolo1645]

I’m happy for Kazakhstan’s recent growth. They have the coolest flag 🇰🇿. Love from 🇺🇸

[@Baby_tea]

Thx bro ❤ USA 🦅🦅🦅

[@plastelina_ytb]

DEF have the coolest flag. I agree 💯

[@IX-fc4po]

@@plastelina_ytb I am always surprised that a lot of people find our flag to be beautiful :D imo it looks very average

[@yeet8336]

that flag is mad ugly imo

[@thegodofbob]

@@IX-fc4poIt has a nice blue to it, looks unique

[@aitore3005]

This is suuuuuuuch a good work brother. I am kazakh and this is the most detailed video about kazakhstan's geography and demography I have ever seen. Yes, some things were forgotten like kazakh-dzhungar wars but for english viewers I believe its more than enough to know.

[@abylai8kerim]

Тағы тіл мәселесін көтергенде ғой

[@stevec7923]

Indeed. A fascinating presentation for us Yankees. I learned a lot!

[@xmurshedz]

And that part left intentionally!

[@Charlie-phlezk]

We see the desert. That's the reason.

[@eyey7070]

selamun aleyküm kardeṣ 👋 greetings from turkey

[@HopefulKingsFan]

I have a good friend of mine at work from Kazakhstan, he’s actually there visiting family right now, and he and his family are some of the kindest people I’ve ever met

[@olddirtybasterd-ex2vb]

very nice

[@smd5020]

yeah because all kazakhs pretend to be kind

[@jalalljumnbhjk]

@@smd5020 Why?

[@dwaynekeenum1916]

@@smd5020you yt

[@Sidneeey-]

@@smd5020noone is pretending

[@ulanakimov6198]

As a kazakh born in independent Kazakhstan, it is sad to see older generation glorifying USSR. They were so brainwashed that majority of our traditions and national identity disappeared.

[@golden_horde]

Вы не чем не лучше. Бросаетесь из краиности в крайность. Почему то все уверены что на западе всё лучше, когда упоминаете ашаршалык не говорите об оралманах в основном баях которые убежали со скотом оставив умирать от голода остальных, мир серый тут нет светлого или черного. Были плохие моменты и были хорошие, вы же только выпячиваете плохое, потому что не видели как до СССР жили люди. Ты сейчас имеешь образование, здравоохранение безопасность на улице благодаря старшему поколению, что тебе ещё нужно?

[@TarlanT]

@@golden_hordeОрысқұл троль.

[@golden_horde]

@@TarlanT Мүмкін қандай да бір дәлелдер келтіресің бе, әлде қорлағаннан басқа ешнәрсе қолыңнан келмейтін мамбетсің бе?

[@helloworld-ti5zs]

Old generation of Kazakhs lived in the USSR. WE CAN COMPARE TWO SYSTEMS: CAPITALISM AND SOCIALISM. That's why they think so. Young

[@ulkiyorasan]

​@@golden_hordeкурыш, не айтып кеттин?! Бугинги кунде казакша сойлеуге озимиздин кинамизгой, себеби сссрда туылгандар уйренгиси келмейди тилин озинин, казаки улт-дастурди билмейди, бари сол сссрдын кинасы, АШАРШЫЛЫК ТИПТИ БОЛМАС ЕДИ, СОЛ СССР БОЛМАГАНДА

[@Ash_tommo]

Yaşasin Qazaqlar Biz bir millatmiz, Özbekistandan salamlar bolsun 🇰🇿❤️🇺🇿🐺 Özbek ve Qazaq bir tuğan

[@ЗубайдаДуйсебаева]

Рахмат сизга!🎉

[@gigrichie3313]

Azərbaycandan Özbəkistan, Qazaxstan və tüm türk qardaşlarımıza salamlar🇦🇿❤️🇰🇿❤🇺🇿

[@jacobsmith8272]

Özbek öz ağam dep beker aytpağan 🇺🇿 ❤ 🇰🇿

[@DP-ey7wp]

Узбәкләр һәрвакыт казахлардан шәпрәк

[@Eblonoid14]

@@DP-ey7wp На что обижен?

[@pgbrown12084]

Simon did an extraordinary documentary about the Aral Sea. I rarely get upset over planetary/ Climate change topics, but Simon's video absolutely devastated me for days after watching it. The arrogance of a few men destroyed not only the lives of millions of people, but also turned a verdant paradise into a dystopian desert hellscape, just for a short-term unsustainable gain. But the effort humans took to save the Aral Sea gave me so much hope for humanity.

[@vidi6745]

In fact, it was written about the Aral Sea as a failed experiment of stupid people in all textbooks of the USSR. I was very worried about this as a child and remember it well. But the scale was not clear. There's some kind of sea there. Is it big or small? Where is it? Somewhere on the edge of the country's map. It probably doesn't have much effect on anything. I thought then. To be honest, Russians have a very strong imperialist mindset, even if they themselves don’t suspect it(

[@888alt]

There is Kazakh saying: Men - qazaqpyn myñ ölıp, myñ tırılgen. I’m a Kazakh, I have died and risen thousands of times. Thanks for such a detailed video 🇰🇿❤

[@JmKrokY]

Cool

[@ildarshamgulov2746]

​@@eyey7070Turkish, Kazakh, Kyrgyz, Tatar, Azerbaijan, Uzbek language very similar

[@ayman3763]

@@eyey7070 don't be such a sore loser, 'hopefully better than turkey" have some pride

[@Apistoleon]

"Ben Kazakım bin ölüp, bin dirildim" in Turkish of Türkiye 😊

[@luamint]

hard af

[@hangman2869]

from 1932 to 1933 the soviet union confiscated all of livestock from kazakhstan. this resulted the nation to suffer from famine, loosing about 4 million people. from 1924 to 1937, kazakhstan’s population went from 6,47 million to about 2.1 million.

[@Zhanna_ts09]

💯

[@eliotness4029]

full scale western lie. explain us how you killed all native americans. and who robbed kazakhs? who is owner of kazakh oil now? As a Kazakh person from Kazakhstan

[@hangman2869]

@@eliotness4029 бот? или шиза? либо выучи английский, либо начни читать до конца чужие слова перед тем как отвечать. Если все же прочитал и понял, начни думать головой, так как я сам казах из казахстана, мои слова не перечат казахскому пониманию развития истории, а ты назвал меня американцем и обвинил в убийстве индейцев. Ебанат?

[@calvin659]

@@eliotness4029 Nah, it’s true. Ask the Soviets.

[@eliotness4029]

@@calvin659 a thief points his finger at another thief

[@aaronjones8905]

Don't forget that the Kazakhs have managed to save the Northern Aral. If Uzbekistan could detach its economy from cotton, there's a chance that the full Aral could be restored.

[@annenelson5656]

I sure hope so. Bringing the fishing industry and agriculture back would put Kazahkian a major world bread basket and will be able to provide food for all Central Asia. Russia has to mind their own business and let Kazakhstan run their own business.

[@handyvickers]

But the snowfall upstream has diminished hugely?

[@Fenixsamarkandian]

Uzbekistan werenʼt problem on that time. Soviets

[@Jae336]

Өзбектер тәуелсіздік алғаннан кейін де Арал теңізін сақтауға тырыспады

[@tyronemaroney335]

​@handyvickers not to late to change it

[@MrQwertypoiuyty]

I was on a recent vacation in Kazakhstan during the Labor day week 2024. (1) Weather experience: When I arrived in Astana, 1st of May at 12 midnight, it was snowing with the weather or temperature at minus 1 Celsius. This was May. And when I asked my tour guide friend the next day, he informed me that temps in Astana can easily drop minus 40 degrees Celsius during winter. (2) Land Area: Driving to Burabay National Park, the tour guide told me that Northern Kazakhstan is similar to Siberia in Russia - a vast land with a lot of birch and pine trees wherein winters are the harshest. We also drove near the steppes, and it was very flat and you cannot see civilization, only grazing horses! Overall, it became one of my favorite countries that I have visited as there are NO crowds in their touristic places 😊

[@samalaimukhametova7290]

Personally, I don’t think now that this is a Russian tree after what I recently heard. On the other hand, we also have birches in Kazakhstan

[@abylai8kerim]

Қош келдің!

[@ljubexns]

You wanted to say Siberia, not Serbia, right?

[@MrQwertypoiuyty]

@@ljubexns Indeed. I corrected it already 😅😅😅 Thank you.

[@jimb9063]

Fantastic. This part of the world in general has always fascinated me, partly because you've usually had to go out of your way to find out about it in years past, at least where I've lived. Where I live possibly adds to the interest too. I think it's said that in the UK you're never further than 70 miles from the coast. Somewhere so different beyond my everyday experience just blows my mind.

[@dr.woozie7500]

You left out an important part of Kazakh history, the Kazakh-Dzungar wars which started in the 1600s. The Dzungars were a western Mongol tribe that controlled a large portion of Xinjiang and southern Siberia and subjugated the Kazakhs, gaining territory as far west as Lake Balkhash. This wiped out a huge portion of the Kazakh population. Then from 1755-1757, the Manchus (Qing dynasty) sent an expedition out west and massacred 90% of the Dzungars with the help of the Turkic Uighurs and Kazakhs. As a result, Xinjiang today is home to mostly Turkic Muslim people rather than Mongol Buddhists and the Kazakhs never expanded past the Tian Shan and Altai mountains. The Russians swept south during their conquest of the steppe with little resistance.

[@mastersafari5349]

You can't blame Russians on that so it's out of the scope of this video 😅

[@terrian8205]

@@mastersafari5349 i gotta say his videos are heavily western propaganda and biased. quite frankly im suspecting he's secretly paid by US government

[@adamthaeer217]

they want to blame Russia so that not helping 🤣

[@churblefurbles]

@@mastersafari5349 Yea seems the CIA found its next target.

[@maxh7637]

Actually, the Kazakhs took part in destruction of Dzungar khanate by Qing empire, not Uyghurs. Uyghurs in fact accepted quite a few Dzungarian refugees.

[@zabi_aka]

Visited Kazakhstan last year for the first time, it was so beautiful! The people were all friendly too! ❤

[@misteryeen]

A chilling reminder of how the lack of care, forethought, and hubris of mankind has devastating consequences on the innocence of life and land. Bless the folks that have endured.

[@AL-lh2ht]

Mostly just Russia being evil.

[@hofahome]

Very well said

[@tengir-too]

Communism

[@hofahome]

@@tengir-too eh, it’s not really confined to any political system. It’s human nature to some degree.

[@josecipriano3048]

​@@tengir-too communism doesn't do anything, the people in power do. And they're the worst in every single system. Or maybe you think that the environment isn't getting destroyed anymore, now that communis doesn't exist.

[@o.kukharchuk]

I hope Kazakhstan will continue to develop and become truly rich and influential. I hope that terrible soviet and russian past will remain only in history. Best wishes from Ukraine! 🇺🇦 Алга Казахстан! 🇰🇿

[@keteket]

Slava Ukraine 🇰🇿❤️‍🩹🇺🇦🫂

[@unnamed_person666]

With our government we ain't getting developed

[@FKS964]

Glory to Ukraine!🇰🇿❤️🇺🇦

[@PlaylistMagic]

🇰🇿❤️🇺🇦

[@pompom6675]

Terrible Soviet past, when ukrainian-born Brezhnev and his gang ruled for 18 years.

[@Yazeedalotaibi]

Love Kazakhstan from Germany

[@posione_6347]

🇰🇿🇩🇪💓

[@zhasulan2009]

Hallo aus Kasachstan nach Deutschland🇰🇿❤️🇩🇪

[@Eblonoid14]

I’m German-Kazakh!!!

[@Rain4lie]

мы воевали ​@@Eblonoid14

[@user-ww2vi5re4u]

Are you Native German

[@memelandiaa]

My father is Russian, my mother is German, I was born and live in Kazakhstan, I am Kazakh at heart and nothing will change that

[@mazardam11]

Жарайсын 🇰🇿❤️

[@Farhan_Ayubi]

You’re a coloniser

[@memelandiaa]

@@Farhan_Ayubi I was born here, how can I be a colonizer

[@Farhan_Ayubi]

@memelandiaa the video clearly mentions why. Not your fault but a colonialist pushed by and for tsarist regime and later for ussr. What good did we achieve collectively. The narrators captured the pain of ethnic Kazakh and immigrants so accurately.

[@memelandiaa]

@@Farhan_Ayubi the past cannot be corrected, we live in the future

[@KurtisC93]

The Kazakh famine from 1930-1933 is something I was aware of, but only as the Soviet Republic hit hardest by the nationwide famine apart from only Ukraine, who experienced the horrors of the Holodomor, today widely considered a genocide. Learning the specifics of the Soviet policy towards Kazakhstan during this period, I am now of the opinion that we aren't using strong enough language to describe what took place. It was not a mere famine, nor was it an anthropogenic catastrophe-it was genocide.

[@standom2390]

For what reason?

[@Boomer-oq3iq]

Чё ты несёшь? Вы шизойды хотя бы можете мне сказать на кой черт СССР решил совершить геноцид целого народа?

[@user-fyoresjsethp]

Colonization​@@standom2390

[@gabaakzhigit5857]

​@@standom2390The communists launched a satanic program called “collectivization,” the essence of this program was this: everything you have belongs to the state! Thus, the communists took all the livestock from the Kazakhs, the only source of food in the harsh steppes of Kazakhstan, and the famine began!

[@ansaraliidrisov5261]

Казахстан пострадал от ссср больше чем Украина.

[@AtAmeKeN100]

I am a Kazakh, I have tasted the bitterness of life from the cradle... I died and was born a thousand times... I laughed, and light appeared from the darkness. I cried - tears flowed from the sun's eyes... I am a Kazakh, I am an immortal heart in which, Like a child in its mother's womb, All, with all the vast, endless space The steppe fits. And becomes me...

[@nurzhamalsmatullaeva6602]

💔💔💔

[@stanktaint15]

Kazakhstan greatest country in the world All the other countries are run by little girls Kazakhstan! Kazakhstan! You very nice place

[@sa_flower23]

👍💯🇰🇿

[@larrynelson5136]

❤that’s gay

[@eliotness4029]

full scale western lie. explain us how you killed all native americans. and who robbed kazakhs? who is owner of kazakh oil now?

[@Jae336]

I'm glad someone finally made a video on this topic! As a history and geography teacher, I know everything that is said in this video - but I want every ordinary Kazakh people to know it . Thank you for the video :3

[@Lørd_von_Maximus]

I have a question, are you from Kazakhstan?

[@Sophie-dd5xr]

My WORLD history teacher in high school told me that he knew where Kazakhstan was and proceeded to google “map of Middle East.” He then pointed to the top right corner where there was a sliver of Kazakhstan and I laughed and said “true, but why not google ‘Central Asia’?” He did and his jaw dropped as he saw the actual size of Kazakhstan! 😅 He then proceeded to add Kazakhstan to one slide out of his entire year’s worth of PowerPoints. “Countries that claimed independence after the fall of the Soviet Union.” That made me smile since otherwise, we never would’ve talked about Kazakhstan at all that year.

[@RamazanKaisar]

I know, I know. Weirdly enough, I just recently noticed just how tragic Kazakh history is, the sheer horror, trials and tribulations of it. Being raised in Kazakhstan, its history was televised and mentioned all of the time. I heard and read about it to the point where I grew accustomed to it, and since then I saw these atrocities as something arbitrary and a part of everyday life. Thank you for your work and the international attention that it brought online. I wish you all the best. ❤.

[@govement9151]

36:12 There is saying in kazakh: we have died 1000 times, and 1000 times more resurrected

[@siratshi455]

Мың өліп мың тірілген елім ай. Қаншама азап шектік, неше апат көрдік. Алла жар болсын, отанымыз көркейсін. Бізді жәбірлеген дұшпандар өзі бәлелерге батар.

[@dbuonline1]

@@siratshi455 "the enemies who have oppressed us will be in trouble" love thy enemy no less

[@altinbey5831]

@@dbuonline1haha, your country clearly doesn’t border russia LOL

[@theseangle]

​​@@dbuonline1 the translation to English is incorrect. They didn't mean that literally

[@sharif7099]

I was born and have always lived in Almaty, the largest city in Qazaqstan. Always knew that my country is 9th by size, but it was a piece of abstract information for me. Only after I decided to drive 1200 km from Almaty to Astana I realised how huge and beautiful my country is. 18 hours on the road. Borderless steppes, arid lone hills, distant mountains, dense northern forests and this lead-coloured heavy sky (as we say in russian). I had to see it to undestand that I truly love this land all that it bears

[@nimblehuman]

I'm American and I've driven across the vast empty stretches of this land under skies lead, cobalt, yellow and every shade of desert pastel. It's true, being by yourself across such an immense and glorious landscape does bring about love for the land.

[@louzo5175]

@@nimblehuman yesterday rode to border of almaty for an animation studio of 16akres of land and what the eiiwfirbf it was so pretty out there n not that far off too mountains seen in detail and awesome sky (summer clouds sure are pretty) tho im sure usa has similiar, bc i thiink theres a place in there w similiar climate n mountains uncrowded places... awesome overall

[@eliotness4029]

full scale western lie. explain us how you killed all native americans. and who robbed kazakhs? who is owner of kazakh oil now? As a Kazakh person from Kazakhstan

[@AK-74K]

Steppes aren't that beautiful))

[@sharif7099]

@AK-74K just plain steppe may be not, but there are many sights to see. Balkhash lakes west coast looks like icy marshes in mid march, snowy hills, red tulip fields. We also have mountains in the city oI live in

[@tiati3750]

Sorry, I'm using a translator. I come from Kazakhstan, and despite ALL the problems of my state, be it corruption, crime, etc. I love my country very much and I hope that in the future everything will be different, better!🇰🇿♥️🌏🌎🌍🌐

[@saiansydyk5796]

Орта жуздер келуи керек

[@DP-ey7wp]

you should start loving lgbt then. the future will be rainbow for you

[@tiati3750]

@@DP-ey7wp thank you, bro. I believe that the future lies in traditional values. behind the economy, successful diplomacy, thanks to good people, behind military strength. LGBT has nothing to do with it, and I don’t see the future of my country THAT way. Of course, to some extent I am tolerant and tolerant of the LGBT community, but sorry, no

[@tsugumorihoney2288]

ну да, то что территория страны это гребаная пустыня, ну совсем не влияет, то-то у меня столько знакомых Казахов родители которых по распределению после универа свалили в сраную кровавую Россию и остались жить там, ибо увы и ах лучше жить в комфортном климате чем в пустыне

[@Eblonoid14]

@@tsugumorihoney2288 Пустыня? Одна пустыня в Тарасе это весь Казахстан? В Казахстане есть горы, степи, такие же современные города, и такие же как у всех деревни и послёлки. В Казахстане также есть много больших, малых, загадочных озёр, скал, холмов. Ну и как же без лесов.

[@plumbum2233]

As a Kazakh person from Kazakhstan its so infuriating listening to all the shit this colonialism has done to us. And the fact that almost noone considers or remember the great djut (hunger) in the 30s as an intentional genocide. Only people who shared our circumstances like Ukrainians Even our mythology and culture suffered as half of our population was killed and we didnt have any time to breath and try to rebuild it. Hopefully we can take our time this century

[@mueezadam8438]

Imperial European powers have a history of using eastern regions as a buffer zone, and every region they used is feeling the effects to this day.

[@Zarina-y4b]

По чьей то вине, погибло столько народа от голода, сколько миллионов погибло,забыли да историю совсем недавнию.

[@fastinradfordable]

We remember.

[@eliotness4029]

full scale western lie. explain us how you killed all native americans. and who robbed kazakhs? who is owner of kazakh oil now?

[@Momusinterra]

​@eliotness4029 Was it you?

[@raphaelgarcia9576]

Before watching this I knew they got a raw deal, but had no idea it was on this scale. There are no words 😢 Thank you for opening our eyes. I hope we can all learn from this to prevent this from ever happening again.

[@ДаирКаракеев-м5е]

As a Kyrgyz born in Kyrgyzstan and now residing in Kazakhstan, I deeply appreciate this insight into Kazakhstan's history. It's a reminder of the resilience and strength of this nation, which I'm proud to call my second home. Thank you for sharing this powerful video. As Kyrgyz and Kazakhs, we are brothers, sharing a bond that transcends borders🇰🇬 🇰🇿

[@SombreroGato]

I mean your both closely ethnically related, basically were same people until 600sAD, and used to reside in the same location close to modern Tuva.

[@keteket]

exactly

[@ЗубайдаДуйсебаева]

Чоң рахмат!

[@Ocean-d1p]

Бауырым, аман бол❤

[@kablan2714]

Аман бол бір туғаным!

[@tkg__]

7:30 They didn't "begun settling". They were forcibly moved. That's why there's a big Polish diaspora in Kazakhstan.

[@stannumowl]

Not exactly big diaspora, more like bigger than should be expected given the location

[@eliotness4029]

full scale western lie. explain us how you killed all native americans. and who robbed kazakhs? who is owner of kazakh oil now? As a Kazakh person from Kazakhstan

[@theccpisaparasite8813]

​@eliotness4029 what part is a lie?

[@eliotness4029]

@@theccpisaparasite8813 explain us how you killed all native americans explain us how much native americans in usa governmet. and compare with Kazakhstan

[@eliotness4029]

@@theccpisaparasite8813 and who robbed kazakhs? who is owner of kazakh oil now?

[@allieSunl]

I never knew anything about Kazakhstan, so I was happy to learn so much from this video!! Much love from the US! 🇰🇿🇺🇸

[@Skyhawk98]

I camped where the Alatau range in Kazakhstan meets the Tian Shan range. We drove 6 hours on dirt roads from Almaty and mostly saw herders, yurts, 1 mosque and 1 shop. The herders are so nice and they gave us Kumis to drink (fermented horse milk). A friend I know there is a descendant from Stalin’s German to Kazakh diaspora, and German is still spoken in his family. It’s true that the demographics are complicated there due to the USSR. But love for the country’s cultural heroes like Abai Qunanbaiuly is strong. The country and her people are beautiful. Ох, как скучаю по тебе, Казахстан 🇰🇿 💛

[@brtnai]

❤

[@Noname-e9k7k]

Were there alot of Germans who came to Kazakhstan after the war? I know there were alot of forcible migrations in the Stalin days, but in school they only talked about migrations internal to the USSR, like the Crimean Tatars.

[@RastiGan]

There were many Germans who where drawn in by the Russian Empire as settlers. They even had their own autonomous region within the USSR right next to Khazakstan around the lower Volga river. Shortly after the start of the war in 1941, Stalin accused them all (baselessly) of collaboration with Nazi-Germany. The Volga German ASSR was dismantled and ethnic Germans were deported to Siberia or Khazakstan. From the latter there are storys, that the German people were basically dumped in the middle of nowhere without any belongings. Not unlike the Crimean Tartars. Wouldn't call that "migration".

[@Noname-e9k7k]

@@RastiGan "Forced migration" doesn't mean anything like what just "migration" means. English doesn't really have a phrase for things like those population transfers, because we don't have a word for "half-deportation, half-genocide".

[@ml8028]

Enjoy the info

[@moved-old]

I did NOT expect my favourite channel about geography make a video about my native country 😭 Бәрібір, видеода үшін рақмет брат!!!

[@jfjjfjdjdjdn78]

Айтпа

[@AbG-jy7gq]

Is it wrong to make a video about Kazakhstan

[@mautida9998]

I loved this video. Very instructive. So sad to see what happened to Kazakhstan but I’m happy to see that it’s recovering. I would love to discover the Kazakh culture and language. Btw what language do people speak in general?

[@IX-fc4po]

@@mautida9998 yeah its not a bad country nowdays, a quite good gdp per capita, human dev. index etc. people speak russian as lingua franca (only 71% are kazakhs) and kazakh. If you plan to visit it, I recomend you Almaty - the most important region historically and economicaly.

[@michaelsurratt1864]

Damn dude sorry to hear. At least by the looks of it, you don’t live there anymore.

[@mansurrussayev9372]

All Kazakhstan wants is to live in peace and enjoy a good relationship with neighbors and other world.

[@illiatsarenko]

russia will not allow that, be ready

[@GeneralWinter9]

Russia isn't the problem you are! 🇰🇿 ❤️ 🇷🇺

[@m_urbanist]

@@GeneralWinter9nobody asked ruzzian😂

[@GeneralWinter9]

@@m_urbanist Go back to front line. Elensky is mobilizing. Do I need to notify the SBU? You've got no reason to be on the internet. Orc

[@tarro78]

How lovely, but russia don't

[@subashchandrabowse2926]

Wonderful documentary.. I learnt a lot about Kazakhstan..

[@littlemaridee]

This was incredibly compelling, albeit demoralizing. I expected the reasons for the title to be more about harsh terrain, and I fully underestimated man's cruelty and apathy. I learned a lot. I wish the Kazakh people peace and prosperity.

[@xanderreyno]

Loving the central asian solidarity in the comments from Uzbeks, Kyrgyz, Kazakhs... Very cool to see!

[@helloworld-ti5zs]

Yessssss. The countries from Central Asia respect each other. I am sure Kyrgyz or Uzbek will help me. Central Asia is famous with its kindness and hospitality in CIS.

[@LalaLa-ze7kv]

They ve gone through some shit together in soviet union :) it means something

[@Kurameno]

We are all brothers and sisters

[@Herxh428]

Respect landlocked country 🇰🇿 from Landlocked country 🇳🇵🇳🇵 . We know how hard it is to survive as a landlocked country.

[@RajeshSoni-k7d]

You know Nepal is Hindu Many Nepalis love india also live in india

[@azharulislam4975]

​@@RajeshSoni-k7d I have a number of Nepalis friends. They are excellent people. But what I realise many of Nepalis students who are living abroad, they prefer Hindi language. I got surprise that how they always speak Hindi with North Indian and Pakistani people than English.

[@samal1115]

hey brother 🇰🇿

[@RajeshSoni-k7d]

@@azharulislam4975 because Nepali is in Devnagari Script You can't find much Difference b/w Hindi and Nepali 😄 Even my Mother tongue is Nepali

[@eliotness4029]

full scale western lie. explain us how you killed all native americans. and who robbed kazakhs? who is owner of kazakh oil now? As a Kazakh person from Kazakhstan

[@Dauren25Oral-nj4fe]

The small population of Kazakhstan is associated with the climate and the famine of 1929-1933, part of the all-Union famine caused by the official policy of “destruction of the kulaks as a class,” collectivization, increased food procurement plans by the central authorities, and, in fact, the confiscation of livestock. If you take away up to 3 million of the population of Kazakhstan, then this is actually half the population of Kazakhs at that time. Since then, World War II has claimed the lives of countless people. But even despite the high birth rate of the Kazakh population. Only in the 70s were the Kazakhs able to reach the population level they had before the famine.

[@nanaki1990blox]

The picture of abandoned ships on a desert that used to be a sea is post-apocalyptic and surreal.

[@sergiygolovin5478]

My own uncle built this railway in 1970 in the Kostanai area. Then he returned home to Kyiv with a lot of money and bought an apartment😎 He told me that it was very difficult there and the climate was bad

[@no-sq2pn]

Wait, wasn't it illegal to buy and own private property in the USSR?

[@emilymschoener9193]

Haventbyou read animal farm? Some ppl were exempt hence the Revolution

[@sergiygolovin5478]

@@thermn8r 👌🤌🤏💸)))

[@user-ConnorKaroThompson]

i think he meant rent

[@maxh7637]

​​@@no-sq2pnThere was such thing as a cooperative apartment you could buy and own.

[@МахамбетМамыров]

Truly great job! Speaking as kazakh who knows my history, you did awesome in summarising 20th century for Kazakhstan. And especially for a westerner.

[@SaturnineXTS]

they don't generally teach us falsified history here in the West, so that shouldn't really come as a surprise

[@gagandeepsingh-sz7px]

After all the genocides that Russia committed on Kazakhs I believe more in God now. How God brought everything back to where it was and allow kazakhs to live with dignity and prosperousity. God bless you, love from a Sikhs❤

[@turinturambar347]

Irony considering the ancestors of the modern Kazakh peoples did the same to the natives 1300 years ago. Most of the modern Kazakh genetic makeup is influenced by the Arabic conquest of the late 7th century AD. There were other groups before and after that tried colonizing the area, but none who were so successful as the muslim conquest of the 7th and 8th centuries. They colonized much of the area and enslaved and genocided many of the natives at the time.

[@jochenkirn9468]

What a powerful and depressing video. Thanks for making it. So, it wasn't a series of catastrophes. Russia was the catastrophe.

[@homo._.sapiens]

Just like any metropolitan country.

[@МусаАлиев-б4с]

In college, I had a privilege to talk with a now-famous startup's CEO, when they went to give a lecture to our students. I vividly remember a very interesting thing he said to us: "If there was like a Civ V game about the modern world, with all the resources, politics, and stuff, the most OP country would be Kazakhstan! Look at all the resources we have: oil, gas, iron, copper, uranium. Look at our geography: 9th biggest country, so many arable lands, crossroads between Europe and Asia. Look at our politics: no enemies, neutral in every aspect, friendship with Russia, China, Europe, US etc. Even if we talk about space exploration: the biggest spaceport and all the best space infrastructure, maybe second only to US, is all in Baikonur!"

[@fletchermunson]

Russia and China are not friends to anyone at all. These are two crazy empires. Thank God, their population is declining and all the technology is in developed countries, so it is physically difficult for them to occupy Kazakhstan.

[@evgeniykh.4152]

Байканур не строили казахи, вообще ни какого отношения к Байкануру не имеют. После развала СССР, Казахстан попилил большую часть пусковых площадок, остались ровно те которые арендует Россия, а после запуска "ангары" со своего космодрома теперь вопрос времени когда РФ перестанет арендовать. И Байканур останется историей. В Казахстане много пахотных земель, но есть дефицит воды. В Казахстане много ресурсов, но нет технологий по переработке, а все самые ценные инженеры уезжают из страны либо в США либо в Европу и создают там новые технологии и патенты. Заработать на наземных торговых путях когда можно было, но появились морские пути которые в сотню раз выгоднее. Я думаю вы цитируете фантазию которая к объективной реальность ни имеет отношение.

[@nurdauletpolatbek2681]

Yeah but nah, being landlocked is a MASSIVE cockblock that invalidates a lot of otherwise great assets Kazakhstan has

[@louzo5175]

spaceport still belongs to russia :(

[@louzo5175]

@@nurdauletpolatbek2681 thats a good way to put it as well as selling all the stuff raw n cheap instead of at least processing it first

[@anthonymelohorstmann1238]

Literally just got into yt to find something to watch while eating, and find out RLL had posted something 32 seconds ago... came looking for copper, found gold

[@miliba]

You found superior potassium

[@rundown132]

Copper is pretty expensive these days, that's a dated expression

[@jab00ty42]

Same these videos are prime eating content

[@stereo-soulsoundsystem5070]

I was thinking the same but this episode is so bleak I might have lost my appetite

[@Bhq870]

This is me now ..

[@Piperdogloveshats]

The destruction of an entire SEA and surrounding area in a matter of decades then the even further reaching cascade of disastrous events is truly incredible. We humans can really be the worst…

[@tomwalsh96]

I never realised how similar the history of Kazakhstan is to the history or Ireland

[@abylai8kerim]

Айтпаңыз, кейін сіздер секілді тілімізді ұмыта жаздадық

[@abylai8kerim]

Bí sábháilte, mo dheartháir cinniúint Éireannach! Beannachtaí ó an Kazakh tír

[@JamesPilkenton-se5cx]

...sooo...does this make Borat the original Florida Man ?

[@TarlanT]

Yup. As Kazakh, I’m always surprised, how many similarities there are. Especially with famine, anti-colonial revolts and loss of native language. However things are much better with the later issue in Kazakhstan.

[@СаматБакторазов]

Actually North Qazaqstan is like North Ireland...

[@aznau]

As a Kyrgyz i remember my grandfather told me how the Russians starved the Kazakhs and they fled to us and we helped our brother nation

[@abylai8kerim]

Иә, Жүсіп Абдрахманұлына мың рақмет

[@seiro8606]

Полное враньё

[@57ar7up]

Typical Russia

[@seiro8606]

@@57ar7up типичный западный зомби.

[@kid876]

Сколько тебе платят за это враньё?

[@SAYLAW88]

Heydar Jemal: Kazakhs today occupy a place determined by their past significance. That is, they are the descendants of those who were the backbone of Batu Khan’s army. The Kazakhs are direct descendants of those who took Kozelsk and Moscow, and their role in the military-political formation of the Horde is obvious. For now, the significance of the Kazakhs is of a historical nature, oriented to the past, and the potential for revealing the Kazakh people is waiting in the wings. This will happen within the framework of greater Turan, where Kazakhstan will be the backbone of Central Asia.

[@aynurchelikenova9517]

You have done a very meticulous research of Kazakh (Kazakhstani) history! You have covered all the tragedies and problems we have faced over the years after being conquered by Russia (USSR). Thank you!

[@TheVitalOne]

On April 1 you need to release a 45 minute video about why the Moon is so empty.

[@membranealpha5961]

lmao yes

[@keithrodrigues7508]

Moon Nazis rule it !

[@strategistaow3520]

May for now people don't live in moon But in future people will

[@KeepItSimpleSailor]

@@strategistaow3520😂

[@campandcook3118]

​@@KeepItSimpleSailor even now, some people behave like they live on the backside of the moon. Like "so far, no one got it right. BUT next time, socialism will work"

[@LoveKA4]

Everything in this video is true. Thank you for your big and hard work. I am from Kazakhstan, I love my country, but yes, most of us don't love our government. I don't think so radical, I think that our government do something wrong and stupid, and do another things right and correct. I don't hate Russia as country, but I hate Russia as government. I don't hate Russian people, but I hate Russians who talk bad about Kazakhs, Kazakistan, Ukraine and another countries and nationalities. I believe that Kazakhstan can became a great country, but I don't know when it's gonna be. Kazakhstan had and have a lot of bad historical moments, but it also had great. Kazakhs are descendants of Great Tukcic Kakhanate, Kypchak Kakhanate, Gengiskhan Empire, Golden Orde etc. We had 2 battles like 300 Spartians (first is Orbulak Battle, second is storie of 28 Panfilov soldiers). Now we are weak, but we have great history, we have heart, we try to be better, we want peace, but we can fight for our past, present and future.

[@Laurence0227]

Just for curiosity, do you think Nazarbaev or Tokaev is worse?

[@LoveKA4]

@@Laurence0227 I think Nazarbayev is worse. But I don't know if Tokayev is good or bad. I think if Nazarbayev is gone earlier, people would think Nazarbayev was good president, because in the begining he made things to improve country. But now Kazakhstan is so corrupted because of him. Tokayev could fix it, but I don't feel it. Sometimes I hear news that Tokayev makes some correct law for my opinion, but after that I hear news I don't like. I don't know if Tokayev is good liar or really good president who just can't fix everything which was broken by Nazarbayev.

[@MTTT1234]

For anybody wondering why some maps here of the country have a weird circle cut out in the center, that would be the Baikonur Cosmodrome, which is leased to Russia, so Kazahk authorities have only limited power there, as far as I know.

[@zacherysaucier6747]

thank you! I was trying to find what that was up with that!

[@carkawalakhatulistiwa]

​@@zacherysaucier6747the principle is similar to US military bases

[@circleancopan7748]

Baikonur was like Subic and Clark Airfields before the volcanic eruption in 1991, local laws don't apply to them.

[@abba-Flammenfresser]

@@carkawalakhatulistiwa I can count on my hand how many host nations are happy with having Russian bases on or around their land. Meanwhile nearly all American ones are by the grace of the host countries. That concept baffles the Russians to this day…and they wonder why their former “allies” couldn’t wait to flee the second the USSR collapsed🤦🏼‍♂️dümbässes

[@meteorknight999]

​@@abba-Flammenfresseredit: why is the dumbarse below talking reuniting on military base topic kazackstan wanted to stay in USSR and voted to keep it running when everyone voted out. You are spreading horrible misinfo they also like and by grace keep russians in

[@ARYS02]

I am Kazakh and i never listened interesting history lesson in my school such as this. I knew all you was talking about, but it was infinitely more interesting than my history classes in school. Rakhmet!

[@leonardowynnwidodo9704]

Actually, Kazakhstan was the last Soviet state before the USSR fully dissolved, so Russia "broke away" from Kazakhstan in a sense.

[@betaincel]

yeah technically we could claim to be the heirs of the USSR, but that would be dumb because at the time of its collapse the USSR had accumulated HUGE debts($100 Billion) that needed to be paid to the US and other Western countries and only Russia was able to repay them

[@yb_Ali]

Thats because if Kazakh government would break away from USSR before Russia, ethnic russians in Kazakhstan wouldve rebelled.

[@yb_Ali]

Thats why kazakh government was waiting for Russia to break away first, so not to cause a rebellion that was stirring in the North.

[@leonardowynnwidodo9704]

@@yb_Ali but what about the other former SSR states, minus maybe Transnistria in Moldova and Belarus (who remains an ally of Russia to this day)? Wouldn’t the ethnic Russians in those states have rebelled too?

[@yb_Ali]

@@leonardowynnwidodo9704IN northern Kazakhstan, russians comprised like 70%-80% of the population. In all other republics russians were a minority, except eastern ukraine, where russians eventually rebelled.

[@lsksod]

i’m from KZ and my grandmas from both sides had 11-12 children in Soviet era. my dad and mom are the youngest in their family. i mean our grandparents did everything to survive and raise the population. i have 4 siblings 👋

[@autumn2182]

МашаАллах! иә , ондай көп балалы отбасылар көп болған бұрыңғы заманда.

[@eliotness4029]

full scale western lie. explain us how you killed all native americans. and who robbed kazakhs? who is owner of kazakh oil now?

[@lsksod]

@@eliotness4029 what 💀

[@eliotness4029]

@@lsksod as a kazakh. tell me who robbed kazakhs? who is owner of kazakh oil now?

[@Fernandodosanjosjeiiw]

Why do people in Kazakhstan have many children?

[@TemuulTK]

I didn't realise how much Kazakhstan went through as a country. Sending love from your Mongolian cousin. Stalin was worse than HItler almost! He probably rotten in hell. And btw China should return Shinjian, Inner Mongolia and all the rest of our land back to Mongolia and Kazakhstan. Kazahs went almost the same atrocities as the Mongols under the oppression of Soviets and China. We're growing and the Central Asian nomads once again started to thrive. And btw Russia also should return Buryats, Tuvans, Baikhal lake and Siberia back to Mongols.

[@BorisSergeevich]

LOL

[@Enzesshshshsh]

classic 🇲🇳🇰🇿

[@umbrellacorp3889]

😂😂😂😂😂

[@louzo5175]

stalin n hitler r almost like twins fr

[@markleeisalegend339]

🇲🇳🇰🇿brother

[@renerudzinski1703]

Loved your video! So informative while easy to digest

[@naurzoom7393]

Such a deep and correct analysis of Kazakhstan. Big respect to you from kazakh!

[@yargolocus4853]

hope it goes well for you guys in there. I doubt the west can manage to muster as much support as it lends to its neighborhood, but you are definitely in the right here. wishing unity and prosperity for you.

[@eliotness4029]

full scale western lie. explain us how you killed all native americans. and who robbed kazakhs? who is owner of kazakh oil now? As a Kazakh person from Kazakhstan

[@evilduck1000]

Imagine escaping a famine in Kazahkstan, to go to China where there would be a brutal invasion and the deadliest famine in history.

[@Barmaley80x]

That's was in history. With good quantity livestock, no fear.

[@peanutbutterpirate314]

@@Barmaley80xyour English sucks 😂

[@grebnedu1219]

Legit when watching this video I almost screamed "STOP! STOP HURTING POOR KAZAKHSTAN!" 😭

[@AidanaTazhen]

🤧🤧🤧

[@SARKA.]

In the Aral Sea on the island, the Russians made biological weapons and sprayed

[@SARKA.]

Poisonous heptyl poisoned Kazakhstan

[@LegendaryObserver]

it’s a hard watch, seeing all those insane number of death and misery

[@RamazanKaisar]

I know, I know. Weirdly enough, I just recently noticed just how tragic Kazakh history is, the sheer horror, trials and tribulations of it. Being raised in Kazakhstan, its history was televised and mentioned all of the time. I heard and read about it to the point where I grew accustomed to it, and since then I saw these atrocities as something arbitrary and a part of everyday life. Thank you for your work and the international attention that it brought online. I wish you all the best. ❤.

[@MattCombs-ge7ki]

Excellent content! Thank you for such high quality presentations

[@guka249]

It’s not because of the harsh weather, it’s a sad history! We were killed a lot

[@БауыржанЕрешов-и2ъ]

Вы откуда

[@Lonely_Phoenix]

💯 😭💔🇰🇿

[@Flow-du6ti]

Кто же, интересно?)

[@Gajubas]

​@@Flow-du6tiниче скоро рашку поделим и сделаем колонии как они делали с нами,око за око месть за месть

[@turinturambar347]

Kazakhstan has been conquered and colonized by Persians, Greeks, Persians again, Arabs, Mongolians, Ottomans, and finally the Russians. The traditional nomadic herding culture has gone on for millennia not changed all that much, though the ethnicity of these herders has likely changed much over time with influxes of Persians, Turks, Slavs, Mongolians, etc. It's a region that is in the middle of many historical regional powers, and thus was grabbed up multiple times by the new power of the day. It's sad, but it's also history. It is what it is. You can't change it. You can only try to overcome and flourish in the future.

[@Quypzhatyr]

Seriously didn't expect such a great video about my country and people by the thumbnail. But wow, this was really awesome. The points are accurate. Just another fact for the ones interested: because of such a diverse population dynamic, different ethnic groups are coexisting in a very friendly manner these days. I had German, Tatar, Uyghur, Armenian, Georgian, Russian, and Ukrainian friends growing up in Almaty. These days you can see a partial polarisation of the Russian ethnic group living in Kazakhstan, as some embrace Kazakh language and identity in protest of the Russia's policy, while some others get influenced by Russia's rhetorhic. I have seen people organising Kazakh language courses for russians and making reels where they try to speak Kazakh, and there was a small attempt of declaring independence for russia in the north (all of the perpetrators of the attempt are already in jail)

[@retro5014]

I looked at the ethnic makeup map and noticed it being all over the place. Aren't there many mixed families these days as well?

[@Quypzhatyr]

@@retro5014 Yes. A lot of us are mixed, especially in the cities. My great granddad literally yoinked a german girl from Germany during WW2. In the old days, christian white group usually intermixed between themselves. However, nowadays the ethnic and cultural lines are becoming more blurry between Kazakhs and other ethnic groups. Kazakhs are more homogenous, but there were frequent instances of intermixture, as shown by my great granddad

[@everus8558]

It wasn't "small attempt of declaring independence for Russia in the north", organization which did it is banned in Russia. Russia and Kazakhstan have history of joint operations against Kazakhstan separatists.

[@Quypzhatyr]

@@everus8558 You mean communists? I think we are speaking about different events here. I am talking about most recent one, with a proletariat thingy

[@erke_-cd7bo]

​I am here!! I'm mostly Kazakh , but also have russian, tatar and French ancestors. Owing to that mix I have green eyes and light hair, but I look like east asian😂 ​@@retro5014

[@thatiowan3581]

Central Asia is a criminally underrated part of the world, so thank you for making yet another video about them 🇰🇿🇰🇬

[@t.n.h.ptheneohumanpatterna8334]

Because y’all are not important

[@oDAKE]

​@@t.n.h.ptheneohumanpatterna8334 uneducated 😉😉

[@twinsplay0795]

Wtf???

[@thatiowan3581]

@t.n.h.ptheneohumanpatterna8334 no one: Absolutely no one: You for some reason: ur worthless Why bro? Why be a terrible person?

[@chisaki703]

​@@t.n.h.ptheneohumanpatterna8334 tell that to the west who are increasingly meddling in with us as to avoid russian and chinese dominance in the region

[@Hostolnit-hosby]

As a kazakh, i can only hope that we could get better.

[@eliotness4029]

full scale western lie. explain us how you killed all native americans. and who robbed kazakhs? who is owner of kazakh oil now? As a Kazakh person from Kazakhstan

[@Hostolnit-hosby]

​@@eliotness4029wtf? What is a lie? That I hope our country will become a better place huh?

[@eliotness4029]

@@Hostolnit-hosby As a Kazakh person from Kazakhstan. who robbed kazakhs? who is owner of kazakh oil now? he will never tell you

[@jonnelacecodog3490]

World Records of Every Central-Asian Country: Kazakhstan: The largest land-locked country in the world Uzbekistan: The cheapest country in the world Kyrgyztstan: The furthest country from any major oceans of the world Tajikistan: Has the highest average elevation in the world Turkmenistan: The weirdest country in the world

[@samankucher5117]

and kurdistan the biggest non state opp in the middle East . the stan is a curse bro 💀

[@plony6142]

@@samankucher5117 oh man, you haven't heard about "Sovietistan", :)

[@aksamhuda7]

Pakistan?

[@ryboi1337]

​@@aksamhuda7does anything need to be said about pakistan? We all have eyes lol

[@Belgiannnn]

You mean Turkmenistan, the country with a leader that has the smallest pipi in the world

[@MrMangistau]

I appreciate that you call our people 'Kazak'. The term was distorted to differentiate Russian Cossacks, although the actual name was initially Turkic and nomadic, meaning 'people without rulers' or 'free people'. The first Kazaks were nomadic people who were left without a ruler due to the disintegration of the Golden Horde. With the establishment of serfdom in Muscovy, serfs began to flee to the nomadic steppes and join the nomadic Kazaks. Gradually, ethnically Kazaks predominantly became Slavic. Later, during the expansion of Muscovy, these Slavic Kazaks started to serve Moscow and became part of Muscovy, playing a significant role in further expanding the Russian Empire into Siberia and Central Asia.

[@eliotness4029]

full scale western lie. explain us how you killed all native americans. and who robbed kazakhs? who is owner of kazakh oil now? As a Kazakh person from Kazakhstan

[@MrMangistau]

​@@eliotness4029 Brother, what are you talking about? Your questions may be legitimate, but they do not align with my comments, right? Why do you think it is "a full-scale Western lie"? Could you please explain what you are trying to prove?

[@eliotness4029]

@@MrMangistau As a Kazakh person from Kazakhstan from Mangistau. tell me who robbed kazakhs? who is owner of kazakh oil now?

[@jotarokujo9164]

I am from Uzbekistan and I can tell you that Central Asia is the unluckiest region on earth. We were subjugated and conquered by the Chinese (during the Tang), and later the Russians. And both of them wanted to depopulate us long ago, hell there were even eradication of Western Turkic population (it was the Tang that a massive Turkic population fled west), and then Russian imperialism. We were so lucky to survive today.

[@AL-lh2ht]

EU: soon

[@МихайлоВербицький-ф9л]

You are a very tough people. Surviving two evil empires altogether demonstrated that.

[@maozedong8370]

So convenient of you to forget the fact that these empires were so hostile because they were ravaged by Central Asians for centuries. The Mongols and the Huns ransacked China more times than you could count and slaughtered people and the Russians were severely impacted by such raids too, so much so that the entire reason Russia exists was because they had to unify the Kievan Rus into a tsardom to increase their level of power to stop being massacred, sold into slavery and having their cities burnt down. I just find it hypocritical that people complain about the "white man" and conveniently forget about WHY they do stuff like this in the first place. The Mongols almost annihilated the Kievan Rus from existence it was so bad, you thought the Russians would let that happen again? Russia is so paranoid about war and invasions that they conquer the world in order to not be conquered because you burnt them so bad. The entire reason Russia took over Central Asia was to stop the barbarians from ransacking their nation.

[@maozedong8370]

@@МихайлоВербицький-ф9л They aren't "evil." You forget China and Russia were annihilated by Genghis Khan as well as other Central Asian nomadic peoples who crippled them so badly that both China and Russia turned the tables as soon as they could and expanded into those lands to prevent it from ever happening again. War is natural for all societies. Stop acting like some moral crusader, there is NO such thing as good or evil, they are all convenient labels humans just make up in their head and throw at whatever, at whenever time they please.

[@miliba]

@@maozedong8370 Now the moskhols have become these barbarians instead, Chairman Mao

[@Dmitrii_Ikonnikov]

What is the difference compared to the results of US policy towards the indigenous peoples of The Great Plains, other than the fact that more kazakhs survived?

[@Aspandala]

Absolutely, no difference.

[@Aspandala]

Consider that evils were white Christians

[@ace.of.skulls]

Love Kazakhstan from USA 🇺🇸❤️🇰🇿

[@matheussanthiago9685]

Great success

[@DCONightingale]

Borat is that you

[@zikotarghi7190]

You keep your dirty american handa away from kazakh oil😊😊😊

[@Spoopy_man]

Very nice

[@yusufsuleyman5666]

My dad did his army service in Semipalatinsk in 1990. He went there with full hair but came home with almost all of his hair falling due to the radiation(his father and his 2 brothers have full hair). I am 27 and almost bold due to the modified genetics, so I guess the Soviets are still f*cking up some of our lives

[@yb_Ali]

Bro my dad served there too, and he s bold 😂. Thankfully ihave hair, but i was definitely born with radiation in my dna 😢

[@yusufsuleyman5666]

@@yb_Ali I have almost the same case, my brother who is 2 years older than me has full hair, but the fate decided to make me hairless😂

[@yami_curr]

sorry to hear that bro

[@shaverdesign]

Its Bald not bold! Bald = no hair. Bold = Brave.

[@yusufsuleyman5666]

@@shaverdesign sorry, i mispelled that

[@rexringtail471]

Kazakhs are the most genuine and nicest people I've met

[@Enzesshshshsh]

Thanks my bro❤

[@louzo5175]

aww

[@OlegToaster]

Yes and no. Some of them are... Braindead nationalists, but mostly yeah, kinda nice people. Like everyone else.

[@thomasgrey9121]

Despite everything we are still standing. Come visit us, friends. Our country is very beautiful. Peace for everyone!

[@sohopedeco]

Friend: "Don't be sad. There's plenty of fish in the sea." Me: "Tell that to the Khazakh fishing industry."

[@FADNaR]

There are a lot of fish there now. The Northern Aral Sea has been restored

[@faratolybai]

SAD

[@geosimp3889]

You mean kazakh?

[@sohopedeco]

@@geosimp3889 it's written Cazaque in my language

[@Soufriere84]

@@FADNaR It has. Unfortunately the dam wasn't built quite tall enough for the water to reach Aralsk like it used to, but it's leagues better than Uzbekistan caring more about its insane cotton industry than toxic dust storms

[@mooney1739]

Our history is gloomy, but our hope is our future won’t be so. Thanks for making amazing video and showing our history! 🇰🇿

[@DiavoloVolpe]

A few mistakes I should point out: Guryev and Vernyi aren't Northern forts, Guryev is the modern-day city of Atyrau located in the West, and Vernyi is the Soviet name for Almaty, located in the South-East Also, it would've made sense to mention the forceful relocation of ethnic Koreans to Central Asia by Stalin during WWII Other than that, a solid video 👌

[@ArmanAubakirov]

Сколько казахстанцев посмотрело видео? Ставьте лайк. There is no Guryev. It's Atyrau. There is no Verny. It's Almaty, and it's not in the north, but in the South-East of Kazakhstan, the biggest city and the former capital. Thank you for making a video about my country.

[@kllermen5554]

23мың дай қазақ қараған шығар

[@kllermen5554]

34мың дай орыс

[@eliotness4029]

full scale western lie. explain us how you killed all native americans. and who robbed kazakhs? who is owner of kazakh oil now? As a Kazakh person from Kazakhstan