Why the most luxury cowboy boots are disappointing - Lucchese

[@RoseAnvil]

Get a high quality wallet, belt or MORE in the Rose Anvil shop here - bit.ly/44jXLNu

[@Floki.Autista.Cinico]

Search for Paraiso Boots. Zero synth. Full oldschool.

[@bodiestevens9845]

I bought my son a pair of Lucchese $1100 for his high school graduation, he has never had a pair of shoes last him more than a year or year and a half. It has been since 2018 and he needs to have them resoled, that is how much he has worn them, and they still look great.

[@smalliver365]

My dad gonna get me some when I graduate from UT this spring, wanted that instead of a “class ring”

[@johnpuga1982]

My opinion, Lucchese is a dress boot brand. However, they do have a few work boots around $300-400 in the Rusty and Raymond product line. I like/own boots in the Carson and Tanner Roper style/product line. I wouldn't wear these styles to do outside work, they're too nice.

[@billgarland4918]

No one is work in Luke’s

[@joedazier6960]

Bullshit. I wear my Luchesses and put them through hell. They've held up great so far. I'll gladly pay400-600 if they're good boots. My luchesses are the most comfortable boots ever

[@stevescoville8465]

I tried to buy a pair of the Rusty model and they’re made in Mexico so therefore are considered import. Because of that they do not custom make you have to buy what they have on the shelf and they only send up to Lucchese in El Paso every couple of months. they put my name on a list back in May 2022 and I still haven’t heard anything from them even after contacting a few times to ask the status.

[@Nicholas-ze5vv]

@@joedazier6960 Are they actually good for work? I feel like I’d wear holes into the leather and stuff. What kind of work do you do?

[@michaelraemisch1605]

precisely

[@taylorvelasquez3725]

I’ve been wearing cowboy boots since I was 9 years old and I’ve always found boots from Mexico to be the absolute best in terms of quality, comfort, and durability.

[@jacobdavenport516]

Not a shot bro but I respect ur opinion

[@jaym280]

@@jacobdavenport516 MEXICO 🇲🇽 has mastered the craftsmanship of cowboy boots. The artistry is unmatched. No argument stands a chance.

[@davidraak1055]

The country of origin makes no difference in quality its the man in the country, tecovas makes better boots than Justin but double h makes better than ariats, country don't matter

[@5.0Lorenzo]

i agree. mexican made boots are the best quality and comfiest boot you can buy for a reasonable price

[@bingbong8775]

no doubt you can also find some of the worst boots in the world in mexico, too.

[@F0XD1E]

They should definitely have better quality lining in there. I would expect calf or something for that price.

[@ausfuhrung]

Yeah but what you're missing is the fact that they are making these boots the exact same way they made them a 100 years ago to now, to change anything would change the heritage, when you get a pair you're wearing the same boot that James dean wore

[@F0XD1E]

Im sure James Dean had a composite narrow square toe structure. Much heritage.

[@Brian-ee1gx]

@@ausfuhrung They weren't using plastic toe stiffeners and foam heel cushions 100 years ago...

[@justsomeguy5470]

@@Brian-ee1gx They didn't even exist yet

[@cs4235]

They don't make lucchese boots like they used to. At this point they still sell boots because of the name, if you want a real pair of boots get some rios of mercedes.

[@BwBumbar]

I have Justin’s from their handmade cowboy boot line that were made in Texas and half the price of luchesse, but other than having a round toe, they have similar features. If they still offer a US made line of boots then they would be worth investigating? I also have some USA made steel toe Justin’s that punch way above their weight class so to speak. Love the videos!!!

[@kepofshangri-la8942]

I have two pairs of Lace-Up Ropers and a pair of their handmade boots. Damn they're good.

[@konacopia]

Justin's top handmade boots still don't match the topline quality of a pair of high-end Lucchese Classics, period. Justin's don't use anywhere near as many lemonwood pegs for example. Granted, $1000 Lucchese are a luxury item. Lucchese has lower-priced handmade boots that are just as luxuriously made as the boot they featured, but they aren't using that type of supple leather for example. There are several handmade cowboy boots in the $300-800 range that are made with similar quality to Lucchese mid & top boot lines, but they just don't have the Lucchese heritage. The only boot company with an older boot heritage is Frye's, which also makes great high-quality boots. Also, someone who can afford to buy high-end Lucchese boots isn't going to cross-shop a Justin boot.

[@PUNISHERMHS_2021]

I believe the only line that Justin still makes in America is the Bent Rail line of boots.

[@James_Edward59]

@@konacopia Justin also owns Tecovas I believe

[@AggiePhil]

@@James_Edward59no

[@rasperryguy1197]

Hi, just want to say I love your videos. Literally the best youtube channel on boots. Really helps buying decisions seeing all the insides especially from boots lacking reviews from people who know what they are talking about. A thing I would love for you to cut in half would be the corcoran original jump boot model number 1500 because most people who own them praise them like they are the best boots ever.

[@jvc3312]

Thanks for the great video. I know it hurts to cut up expensive boots, but what you do is a valuable service. To do a fair comparison, I think you should stick to over-the-counter brands as opposed to custom made brands. I have no doubt almost any of the well-known custom made brands will be better and much more expensive than the Luccheses. Chisos, Black Jack, and Rios are all very good choices for comparison. I would also like to see Heritage Boot Co from Austin, Tx.

[@c.carroll5635]

I have a pair of Lucchese mad dog goat and a pair of full quill ostrich. Both pairs have worn and aged really well. The ostrich is really thin leather but is as tough as any leather I’ve ever seen. The goat is like a calf or lamb skin glove leather in texture but tougher. I didn’t pay full retail for either pair and consider both exceptional value for the money, I got them at the factory store in El Paso which occasionally has red tag sales for even better prices. These are boots you could wear everyday because the more you wear them the more comfortable they get. I also own several pairs of Tony Lama’s, which I like very much, but the Lucchese are higher quality and if you can afford them or find them at a discount are worth the splurge.

[@elliowb2]

I used to live in El Paso, that's a great store. I picked up a pair of Lucchese Classics for a great price and have had them now for going on 10 years. They continue to look great.

[@adama4791]

I have some Lucchese Elgins (basically ostrich versions of what you show) that were $800 in black cherry and I love them to death

[@eddierodriguez9408]

Thinking of buying my first pair are they comfortable

[@adama4791]

@@eddierodriguez9408 the first 5-7 wears (I don’t remember) we’re ok…not good not bad, then as soon as they broke in, my god I love those boots. Very comfortable and so good looking, gotten the most compliments on them and I love wearing them

[@drivinolered5835]

Yes, they are comfortable even without a padded insole. I have the Cliff in black cherry and love them. Unfortunately, I’ve worn them so much in the 2+ years I’ve had them, I wore holes in the bottoms. Definitely a pure dress boot not for working in.

[@adama4791]

@@drivinolered5835 get em resoled and keep going

[@MsHeather383]

My son had a vintage pair, loved them.

[@taylorficke3047]

Olathe boots are made in the US and are way more affordable! Plus you can actually work in them...I've worn a pair almost every day for 5 years and they the best boots I've ever had

[@DanMar5858]

I agree!! I’ve been wearing western/cowboy boots for at least 27 years and I bought a pair of Olathe’s last year. Now I own 6 pair and I don’t even bother wearing any of my others. Plus I wear them to work all day everyday and my feet don’t hurt at days end. I especially love their Tall Tops. 👍🏽

[@JestRLee]

Another honest review... That's why we watch, we trust your experience, knowledge, and opinion... thanks for another great video, Weston...

[@neildickson1151]

I’d love to see some Anderson Bean cowboy boots cut in half, I’ve heard they are real quality and made in the USA

[@looooooooot432]

I've got a pair I wore daily for 7ish years that had been resoled twice. Awesome boots with the only issue being the seam between the heel and toe leather split after 4 or 5 years. Had it stitched up when I got them resoled and it help up fine. Unfortunately last summer I got in extremely late one night and just kicked them off by the door instead of putting them up on the rack.....woke up to find my new puppy had added them to his chew toy collection ha

[@mariopena7793]

They were bought by the Rios Of Mercedes boot company which is in South Texas, they’ve been making handmade quality books since the 1800’s.

[@jonjohnson63]

​@@mariopena7793 Anderson bean wasn't bought by rios of mercedes. it was founded by rios of mercedes in the 80s, to offer an even more affordable version of their boots without causing the same confusion as the different lines often caused for lucchese tony lama and justin

[@konacopia]

@@mariopena7793 I had a pair of Rios of Mercedes boots from the early 90s. They were handmade and gorgeous...but eventually, I grew in foot size and had to gift them to a good friend of mine. Every time he wears them around me, I quietly cry inside with envy because I wish they made that style and design again.

[@straycat62]

I don't own any Anderson Bean yet do have 4 pair of Rios of Mercedes. Used to be a huge Lucchese fan boy. Found Rios and I really lean there first. Consistent high quality. Still love Lucchese but have branched out. Rios is worth checking out.

[@jakob8327]

I would love to see a comparison of classic British brands like Trickers, John Lobb, Crockett & Jones, Edward Green, Church. Maybe even pitting them against US staples like Allen Edmond, Alden, GH Bass. For other videos, I would also love to see famous casual shoes like the Tods Gommino or the Loro Piana Open Walk. Keep up the great work!

[@stepanmikulica]

I would like to see my Loakes on the channel. Probably not the top of tops from shoes, but still handmade GY welted shoe in England.

[@Froggyboy7]

@@stepanmikulica a decent amount of loakes are only partially or not all built in the UK sadly.

[@stepanmikulica]

@@Froggyboy7 I know it depends on the colection - luckily I got the 1880 Colection which should be made in England. But I know they are sort of entry level shoes. It was a bargain as I get them with 50% discount. Sometimes having an odd size have benefits.

[@holdthatblaow]

As someone who only wears cowboy boots, I love this series! haha.

[@ЗакатРассвет-ы2ж]

2022 man. how many years since cowboys are long gone?

[@DanBCooper]

@@ЗакатРассвет-ы2ж They’re still alive and well Russian bot. Where do you think beef comes from ? Bring your ass on over to Central California you can meet some.

[@ЗакатРассвет-ы2ж]

@@DanBCooper first of all, I'm not Russian, but I speak Russian.

[@ЗакатРассвет-ы2ж]

@@DanBCooper and I'm not from Russia. and I despise Russia's actions in Ukraine

[@ЗакатРассвет-ы2ж]

there are hundreds cowboys, not tens of thousands. the most subscribers of the channel aren't cowboys. and there a few real cowboys wearing a 10 gallon hat with a 6 shooter on their belt. but if you mean by cowboy a cattle handler, well... it's a disrespect towards the legend.

[@scottcarroll9201]

It would be hard for Lucchese to make a boot for James Dean in 1960, he died in a car accident in 1955. Maybe you meant to put up a picture of Jimmy Dean the country singer and breakfast sausage magnate? Also Kennedy was assassinated in 1963, not 1961.

[@94aleng]

Would really like to see some Montana boots cut open. They feel nicer than Lucchese that I've looked at, but 1/3 the price. My boots are caiman vamp, goat shaft, and calf lined, but I don't know what's inside that you can't see. Wish they were easier to find!

[@breft3416]

If you lined those boots up not knowing the price and said pick the best one, the Lucchese would win, I think. It's a work of art compared to the others.

[@hughanderson7840]

Yeah, you’ve undersold the style. Cowboys are flashy dressers.

[@RichardWhite86]

Bingo. Everything in this review says they’re better boots than the others, and whether something is overpriced is subjective.

[@Sullenberger]

Love learning about boots and how they are made. I've owned many brands and different types of boots, but the best, BY FAR, have been boots made by Rios of Mercedes. They are hand made in Texas and have far exceeded the value, look and durability of other brands. My first pair were so good, I had to get a second just to rotate. It would be very interesting to see how they stack up to your other tests.

[@Booksandboots]

In excited to see the Chisos one, Chisos has done their own boot cutting video and compared and contrasted but ofc Id love to see this channels review and opinion

[@mikemiller2633]

I think the only knock he might have on The Chisos #2 is the synthetic foam foot bed with the leather lining on top. But with that being said it is removable, replaceable and not part of the boot's construction (as it is not a permanent part of the boot) . I own a pair of #2s and I think they are great. I don't do work in them though, they are my going out boots.

[@notthatproud7453]

I have a couple pairs of Luccheses. They used to have a non-handmade line that was cheaper. I paid about $300 for a pair of ostrich leather boots. My other pair was about $700, all cowhide, and they were a wedding gift from my wife. I really like my boots a lot. The cheaper ones are more than 10 years old and the more expensive are 9 years old. Both are holding up well with normal maintenance. One other thing about Lucchese is you can often select the type of leather you want from normal cowhide to goat all the way up to exotic things like crocodile. I once saw a pair in a store in Santa Fe that purported to be elephant skin. That is insane to me. Anyway, I don’t have the ability to measure the thickness of the leather on mine, but I would guess they’re thicker than 1.5 mm. Maybe the thickness is related to the leather you picked?

[@gabrielespana319]

They still make the 1883 line, and they’re still nice boots for a lower price

[@jeffmiller3150]

Elephant 🐘 hide boots are fairly common, readily available.

[@spreaddeezhazelnutz7511]

​@gabrielespana319 I have a pair of Lucchese Lewis goat leather boots, which are a part of the 1883 line, and so far (a few months in) I'm very happy with them.

[@perrycheung9394]

Thanks for making this video. I’ve had my Luccese for about 25 years and they are still in good condition but i don’t wear them that often. They were almost 3 times the price of my Boulets at $600cad and I agree that they are not worth such a price difference. The Lucceses fit a little better and were much more comfortable right from the first day. Glad I bought them to say I have a pair but won’t be buying them again. Keep making these great videos.

[@juniorr2646]

What's the point of keeping them around 😂

[@majormushu]

Lucchesse and Leddy's boots also come with the concept of a well fit boot. If your foot fits perfectly in an off the shelf boot from boot barn then good for you but most of the time those boots are going to be pretty loose. A good way to know easily when it comes to cowboy boots is if you can easily take them off by hand your boots are far too big. You should need a boot jack to get them off easily. Having a thinner foot leddys and Lucchesse are the only places I've found with boots that fit off the shelf as they have a wider size range going for them. Plus you don't have to go up to $1k, they have several boots for $500-$700 same as Leddy's. But if you're going up to $1k anyway you might as well go up to $1500 and get yourself a full custom pair from Lucchesse. Mine should be coming in next month lol.

[@pumped2run]

Another handmade in texas brand I would love to see is Beck. I spend a lot of time in the rodeo arena and I'm thinking about ordering some working cowboy boots from them

[@panthro213]

The best Cowboy boots are by Texas Traditions (Lee Miller).

[@_bats_]

Came to the comment section to post this. His boots are, as far as I'm aware, the absolute pinnacle of the style.

[@rudygaytan6628]

And very, very expensive.

[@jacksudduth5667]

I suggest looking into Burn’s Cowboy Shop in Park City, Utah. Their boots are custom, made to order in Utah and are of incredible quality and construction. Some of the best boots I’ve ever seen. They outfitted the entire Yellowstone cast for seasons 3-5!

[@badgermacwillstone9696]

There’s a good luchesse boot outlet in El Paso. Up to 75% off. Call them and they will mail to you.

[@agubser07]

Texas Traditions (Lee Miller is the bootmaker) seems to be the best of the best of the best, sir. Check out the series that was done on Kirby Allison's channel for his bespoke boots.

[@ilg2012]

Not a realistic purchase as they’re custom. This channel should only show boots that everyone could buy, off the rack. We can’t be sending 5k on boots that take 6 months to make. Next!

[@krazmokramer]

Those boots Kirby Allison had made were just plain ugly. Those boots and the custom cowboy hat he ordered made him look like an Urban Cowboy from the 1970s! Next he'll want a mechanical bull.

[@shaneflowers418]

I went through several brands in the sub $500 range, including a custom made pair and the $300 luchesse ropers fit better and are by far the most comfortable.

[@johnlyon8403]

My Lucchese ropers are a super comfortable pair of boots.

[@eonarts]

My rompers were goat skin and I love those boots. Had ‘‘em resoled locally and they screwed them up!

[@nathanmassell8176]

I love that you have a Tactile Knife Co Rockwall too. I love Tactile's products

[@57WillysCJ]

I have two or three pairs of Lucchese. They have a nice look to them. The things that made me really irritated is I moved north where there are cold temperatures along with snow and ice. You can't wear a thick sock in them so your feet are either pinched or cold. Then there is the leather sole which after both feet going out from under you and a week of pain in the shoulders, neck and head, tou become unhappy. The thin leather cracks even with weekly treatment. I have one good pair left and use it for summer wear. Bought a cheap set, put insoles for better comfort and you can wear heavier sock. Dropped them off to be resoled in vibram. That was as much as the boot, but great for winter wear.

[@HarborLockRoad]

Exactly, ive got the same issues. But add to that, the lack of a pattern or rubber sole to grip in ice and snow, or even mud. Cowboy boots in new england are only good to wear when its too hot to wear them!

[@jonjohnson63]

@@HarborLockRoad what treatment do you use?

[@elliowb2]

I would never wear my Lucchese's in the winter. Not only is the ice a slip hazard, but all the salt will decimate the leather. I've ruined a decent pair of Allen Edmonds dress shoes, and would hate to see that happen to my Lucchese Caiman leather boots.

[@Lucithron]

As a german I would it love to see a cut in half haix airpower. I love this boots and haix are used a lot in german military, police, firefighting and medical areas. I wore my last pair over 6 years and they stil go strong. Also they are super comfortable.

[@TheChickenx18]

Thank you for covering US brands!!! Could you do a review of another US brand? I am interested in getting some Allen Edmonds and I am not sure about them being shankless and having a cork insole. In particular, I am looking at the weatherproof boots that they have. I have done Danners and Red Wings before, but I am growing up and need a grown-up boot.

[@nnathanaubree]

Would love to see a video on Sendra boots! Seems like they'd be exactly what you were hoping these would be, but made in Spain.

[@michaelsipe9010]

I would love to see an Anderson Bean comparison also

[@dizzy4303]

This. AB are the best fitting and best feeling boot ive owned. They are cheaper than these too and dont sell from a yuppie marketing boutique.

[@adamnsandler1607]

i love how yoour videos just keep evolving, evem tho its garage science it a nice to see how you educate us and show us something that is actually relevant, im buying sneakers and boots by looking at your videos, its not like i can buy a 1000 usd pair of boots but i mean the cheaper but quality ones, keep on the good work and thank you

[@theengineer8290]

I’ve had my elephant skin ( very tough skin) Lucchesse boots for 10 or so years. Got them on sale for like $600. Put some leather conditioner on them and they look straight out the box. Sad to hear I over payed but I love those boots!

[@MikeHaggarKJ]

You really didn't at 600 bucks though

[@pubcle]

600 for elephant skin handmade boots? That's not overpayed at all. That said, I'm going for the 650 handmade, custom-fit boots of the Wilson's.

[@danshakuimo]

@@MikeHaggarKJ Well 10 years ago 600 bucks was worth more. Though with elephant skin it's probably well worth it assuming the rest of the construction is good.

[@henryperez606]

Pretty sure their elephant skin boots are $2000 now. You did great!

[@daviddehass6877]

Hmmm, you didn't over pay.

[@Coca-Cola-cowboy]

Drew’s boots makes a tall top cowboy boot I would love to see! Also Olathe boots would be interesting!

[@75nathen]

I’d second Olathe or Anderson Bean.

[@mphilleo]

To be fair, Lucchese offers boots in a wide price range. The sweet spot for value seems to be around $500, which isn't bad. On a side note, they also offer GYW work boots, which I'd be interested in seeing bisected.

[@mrsukhoverkov6285]

I have a brown sand shark pair of lucceses that I got for $550. They are about the same shape as these but the leather looks beautiful and they are about the same price as a exotic pair of Ariats. For $550 I absolutley love my shark skins and have worn them to honkeytonks and everywhere else for about a year straight now. I think Luccese you are def paying for the name but I am willing to for a kickass pair of cowboy boots.

[@kevinl4271]

Asking again for you to do Double H boots. They’re USA made and union made at that. I just want to see if my purchase was a good choice ha

[@wmk29]

Waiting for Rose Anvil to cut open some Alden's, Hoffman Boots and Some Russell moccossains.

[@nzoomed]

I found that their cheaper lines typically had the thinner leather such as their 1883 series, however I found it made them much lighter to wear and quicker to break into the shape of your foot. As a dress boot, I feel thats OK. Their classics line is much more expensive and my pair of those is quite alot heavier. Another point missed in this video is that this line of Lucchese boots aims to be made as close as possible to the traditional way of doing it. Yes there is a little synthetic material used in places as mentioned, but things such as the pegging on the sole is unique to Lucchese and not found elsewhere AFAIK. You are paying for something that has had alot more hand labour go into its production than any other boot.

[@PLAZALOT58]

@@LoneWolf-qk9pl I ordered and just received a pair of blackjack boots in the same size as my Lucchese Classics boots. They are very well made and fit ok. But I have to say I’m disappointed because they don’t feel as good as the Lucchese. There is just something about the way Lucchese Classics boots fit and the comfort that seems to be unique to them.

[@spreaddeezhazelnutz7511]

​@@PLAZALOT58You can't beat the silhouette of Luccheses either. They just look so good. All of the design proportions are perfect.

[@birdytiger]

I watch this channel because I like nerds nerding over their nerdom of choice. This particular episode has so much in common with my personal nerdom of watches. Where it's made and name on the dial is a big chunk of the consumer tag

[@joeporter4970]

Dang Weston. I love that you are so honest and genuinely disappointed or impressed with the shoes you cut. I love your videos.

[@linotexieralopes]

I have several pairs of lucchese's awesome dress boots awesome fit, I'm Australian and think highly of them, I love cowboy boots because they make narrow sizes .they wear out so much better compared to the D widths... I feel the vintage stuff are higher quality...

[@Elementecho]

Those are a dress boot. Dressier leathers will cost more as less of the hide will be usable. Luchese may be in the same vein as Alden (though apparently handmade), last step before bespoke. Not sure if they are worth the price but they are definitely not work boots.

[@drewby618]

I’m very glad that the one pair of Lucchese’s that I own were lightly used and less than $100 off of eBay

[@donmcarthur2146]

I am going to disagree with your assessment. Without going into a long rant, the boot you assessed compared to the others so far is a dress boot. And as stated by you, not purchased to wear to work. I have all the boot mfgs you have assessed so far and I still think that the Lucchese is the better purchase. I will grant there has been a change in quality these past 10 years probably due to being part of the Boot Barn company. But the boots do wear well, repair well. Pricy? Yup. But not nearly as steep as custom which will run double what you pay for them. You want a good baseline of what a good hand made boot is like find an old (pre 1980's) used custom made boot somewhere and cut that in half. Enjoying the series. Look forward to what's next.

[@PUNISHERMHS_2021]

Hold up, what do you mean part of Boot Barn company?

[@donmcarthur2146]

@@PUNISHERMHS_2021 Apologies.. Arena Brands. Other investment companies own Arena Brands. My error was from an article that incorrectly attributed Lucchese Boots as a subsidiary of Boot Barn.

[@centexrails]

Here's another suggestion for Hondo. You can find videos of them cut apart online but they are presented by the company. Consider doing it an outside 3rd party using a boot off the shelf.

[@troyhood]

Ultimate traditional cowboy boots? Lee Miller at Texas Traditions in Austin. He took over the shop from the GOAT bootmaker Charlie Dunn.

[@orlog3343]

Top 5 best boot makers in the world easily and definitely the best cowboy boots

[@djmuller2349]

Great video. There is a premium on US made fine leather boots. I do think These are expensive, but so are Black Jacks, which in my opinion may be the best off the shelf American made boots. I’d love to see that puncture and cut on some stingrays. That’s a tough leather!

[@csipawpaw7921]

Lucchese boots have the reputation of being the boots of choice for rich or successful white-collar businessmen in the west, such as Bankers or cattle buyers. They have not been the boot of choice for working cattlemen for a long time. Rocketbuster boots are not working man's boots either. They are custom-made and are a step above Lucchese and are considered one of the top custom-made boots in America with extreme custom options and thousands of unbelievable patterns. I would choose them over Lucchese. But they cost even more and I am a retired Lawman with a modest income. So I can only dream.

[@konacopia]

Just picked up a pair of JB Hill boots that were $850 on Macari for $150...they were used once for a photoshoot, so there were barely any scratches on the soles. JB Hills are all hand custom-made with premium material and amazing unique designs. Really, there are a lot of high-end quality handmade cowboy boots by lesser-known brands made in the USA or Mexico that can be had for $500-600...one just has to get familiar with what makes a quality cowboy boot and what they intend to use the boot for (ie. fashion or work boots).

[@straycat62]

@@konacopia good point

[@650tonyd]

@@konacopia I saw those boots. Size 11! I was pissed because I wear a 12

[@konacopia]

@@650tonyd I’m still waiting for delivery. The condition of the leather dye seemed uneven in the pics, so will have to see if I have to send them to JB Hill to restore them...yes, they offer such services & I hear it ain’t cheap, but they do a fantastic job. Crossing my fingers =)

[@benscarpenter]

The best (and I mean best based on time, cost, customization) are those made by Lee Miller in Austin TX. He has a 3-4 year wait list, and his boots start at $3k.

[@brandonzimmermann]

Like many others have said, Boulet boots out of Canada seems to be mostly traditional and of high quality. If you really want something close to the “original” cowboy boots evolving from cavalry/wellington boots I’d want to see the Boulet 4002 cut in half. The Arabia steamboat museum has a lot of preserved examples of boots headed out West in 1856. TLDR cut in half some Boulet 4002 for historical accuracy

[@juniorr2646]

LIKE MANY OTHERS? STAAP LYING BRUH. THE BEST BOOT MAKERS IS FROM LEON GUANAJUATO 🇲🇽

[@jakepotenzo2990]

You have got to cut apart a pair of Anderson Bean boots. I am from Texas and I have heard from some of my friends that they are the best built boots that money can buy. Keep on doing your videos they're awesome!!!!!

[@DanBCooper]

Answer, yes. With that said, I love my Chisos to death, they feel like slippers, best boots I’ve ever owned, and would definitely buy another pair. 100% legit, no corners cut. I also acknowledge they are (subjectively) over priced.

[@liamsbarber]

Cut up some Chisos already man! let the folks see what the future of cowboy boots are! Nothing comes close in comfort, durability and value!

[@High_Desert_Tanner]

I've been looking at Chisos... Which boot do you have? I just wish they had more traditional stitching.

[@DanBCooper]

@@High_Desert_Tanner I’ve got the #2’s in brushed brown ( narrow square toe ) Yea the shaft stitching is definitely unique, I like that though, and that there’s meaning behind it. Different strokes though 😎. They’re still a young company too, not more than like 3 years old I think. If you haven’t watched some of the owner Will Romans videos on KZbin check ‘em out. Cheers 🍻

[@High_Desert_Tanner]

@@DanBCooper I've watched quite a bit about the boots, the company, and Will... Definitely seem like good people to support. Thanks!

[@eonarts]

In the 80’s it was ALL about the pointy shoes. One owned doc martins for the mosh pit and pointy shoes for the rest of the time! I got my tony lamas during that time. They hurt my feet. They always have. In the early 90’s I got a pair of hand made Lucchese rompers in goat with a very pointy toe. OMFG I loved those boots. When I took them in to be resoled they messed up the leather. I got a pair of peanut brittle Nacona’s that I loved as much as my Luccheses. When I went to Austin ( pointy boots cowboy boots are hard to get in my city so when I went to Austin) got a pr of machine made Luccheses and a fancy pr of crocodile boots in some brand. I love pointy cowboy boots!

[@MrJohnnyt1982]

Are they too much? You need to know how much they pay the craftsmen who make them.

[@ianturnbow7011]

I’ve never considered buying or wearing cow people boots. Thanks for the info, Wes!

[@PreludeDude]

Dude that was easily a 9 cut centered score... You're really hard on yourself with that score metric!

[@bigjohnson9561]

Lucchese makes good boots especially the classic edition. If you want the best quality cowboy boot, you have to go to a custom boot maker. There are several here in Texas. Texas Traditions, Littles Cowboy Boots, and Spivey Boots are custom boot makers are just a few.

[@vance3973]

The most traditionally made boot you'll probably find for $300 or less is Hondo boots.

[@michaelriffey2372]

I have two pair of Hondo and absolutely love them.

[@cameron3525]

Or boulets

[@vance3973]

@@cameron3525 Boulets are slightly less traditional from what I can see in their newer boots. The hondos still have a traditional leather insole and a channeled welt. I know modern boulets have a removable insole and I am not sure about the channeled welt.

[@jonjohnson63]

I'm curious to see a pair of bootmakers cut open and how they compare to the classics. lucchese currently has "bootmaker construction" and "classic construction" boots which used to be 1883s and classics respectively. I know how they compare based on what I can see but im curious how they compare on the inside.

[@joe3379]

Weston, go for Chisos boots. I'd say they are the "Nick's Boots" of cowboy boots in terms of quality. Also, what was the most difficult boot for you to cut in half??

[@650tonyd]

Bull! Chisos are nice but they aren't anywhere near the quality of Nick's

[@joe3379]

@@650tonyd okay, what would you say is a closer equivalent?

[@originaltails01]

I'll happily send my vintage Tony Lama El Rey Teju Boots. But maybe Anderson Beans or Rios would be a good 'traditional' boot to cut in half.

[@wc4201]

I have 2 pairs of lucchese classics… the first pair was purchased by my wife as an engagement gift for me over a decade ago and the boots are still super comfortable and fit my feet perfectly. They are dark brown, calf skin with the French toe. I work in IT project management and didn’t need them for true hard work but there was a point when my normal brown work shoes died and I started wearing the luccheses daily. They held up real well for about 2 years when I had an issue with the heal on one of the boots when I was out on a business trip. I had to take it to a cobbler to get the heel redone. They are actually a little more comfortable now but on the downside Lucchese won’t work on them again which is a stupid business policy. Anyway they have held up remarkably well and are a shine away from looking almost like new. The second I got are the same style and leather except in black Cherry. I don’t wear them as often but they too are extremely comfortable. I got those at a store closeoit sale for $350. I was looking for a black pair but they are darn near $900 now!!!! I love them but yea they are ridiculously overpriced now.

[@DirtyDanMunicipalMan]

Best cowboy boots I’ve purchased were Abilene boots. Made in the USA and super comfortable and affordable. By far my favorite everyday brand of boots.

[@Cadv-gw1xt]

4:12 how would James Dean get a pair in 1960 if he died in 1955?

[@AdamManley7]

Seems like he put the wrong picture, the guy he said is singer Jimmy Dean vs the picture which seems to be actor James Dean

[@mikemiller2633]

@@AdamManley7 Maybe it's Jimmy Dean the guy that sells breakfast sausage, or is that the same guy?

[@trevorgwelch7412]

Dan Post boots I really like

[@thevtadventure1062]

I think anyone buying these would strictly by them for the fashion/looks and name.

[@FirstDonkie]

I own a pair of Sendra cowboy boots that's 30 years old. Did nothing to 'm but a resole now and then and a lick of grease to keep 'm in condition. It's a brand from Spain. My boots look very much like the Seta Sprinter Chocolate in their current line up, but I really don't know if they're the same. They're not as expensive as the Luchettes, but tough as nails! Nice vids about the boots, tnx!

[@kirill42069]

I like how you shill a $100 pen after talking about overpriced boots

[@dereksullins4841]

My favorite handmade work boot is Rios of Mercedes. They own Olathe and Anderson Bean brand boots. The way I understand it, the Anderson Bean use the widest last, the Olathe are narrower than Anderson Bean, and Rios of Mercedes are the narrowest in the three brands. I have narrow foot, so Rios are my boot. All that said the price is tiered from Rios to Olathe, to Anderson. The boots I wear to work my ranch everyday are a custom boot designed by a local retailer. I paid $600 for this set. They're are made out of horse hide for the vamp and counter and have an inlaid shaft. The worst boot in the brand are the Anderson Bean Horsepower boots. Owned one pair and they only lasted 6 months while I was living in town going to college...junk. I'm a traditional boot guy all the way. I also own and wear several pairs of Nick's Boots lace ups.

[@konacopia]

Since you were reviewing the justification of the price of these boots, I find it odd that you didn't comment on the other quality features of a high-end cowboy boot like the amount of pegging used, which is a hallmark of premium quality cowboy boots...generally, the more pegs used, the better the build construction. You didn't go over the quality of the stitching & design on the outside of the shaft which is far superior to other mid-line cowboy boots you had assessed. I'm sure if you cut into a pair of exotic-skinned boots, you'll also find that they're also thin. Your comment on how thin the leather is, but you noted it's higher quality leather. You don't think the higher quality leather doesn't contribute to the cost like other exotic premium skins? Surprisingly, as a cobbler, I thought you'd have better insight as to what makes a quality high-end cowboy boot, yet you don't speak adequately to key facts about top-line dress cowboy boots: if they're handmade, the quality & cost of the premium leather, stitch quality & design of the exterior on the shaft, and whether the model is a limited edition or a custom design. My ex used to work in a cowboy boot store back in the early 1990s (which is why I've got over eight pairs of cowboy boots), and I learned a lot about the key differences between budget-priced cowboy boots, mid-line cowboy boots, and the high-end cowboy boots. It really comes down to the materials, build quality, the boot's intended use (fashion/work/daily use type of boot), and it's availability (ie. limited editions). If you're going to compare $1000 boots, compare them to other high-end boots (ie JB Hills, Tony Lama Gold/Black Label etc...), citing the qualities that makes them high-quality boots...not on merely how thick the leather is. You'll find that exotic leathers aren't very thick at all as well.

[@straycat62]

This

[@scout3058]

I'd love to see you do Abeline boots. They're made in my hometown area of Somerset County PA.

[@alexgonzalez695]

You should definitely do a Mexican brand with it being the birthplace of cowboys and cowboy boots

[@jamesismyfriend4403]

@Marc Carran Does Spain make any cowboy boots?

[@75nathen]

Mexican Brand? He already did Tacovas. They’re just Mexican made boots with a big marketing budget. They are fashion boots not really cowboy boots, but they are hand made in Mexico.

[@jjvelvetackbar6430]

@@jamesismyfriend4403 sure! Sendra and Sancho come to mind, but I am sure there are others.

[@PUNISHERMHS_2021]

@@jamesismyfriend4403 I think they're is one company, I just can't recall the name right now. But yes cowboy boots did start in Europe, cowboy boots are modeled after the old riding boots from there.

[@nathanbedfordforrest9546]

@@jamesismyfriend4403 The tradition of leathercraft started in Spain and they brought it over to Mexico.

[@caliwhitestone4520]

Well Luchesse is the most comfortable boot I’ve worn. I’ve worn ariat and then tecovas for work as well. With lots of walking on concrete, they don’t come close to sustaining my feet (and back!) like Luchesse.

[@TylerSnyder305]

Everything I'm seeing in this series just goes along with what my uncle always says. He says typical " cowboy boots " are just for show, and real " cowboy boots " have kilties. I certainly would much rather have the WHITES Packard that my uncle and everybody else on his ranch swears by, I prefer the look of course but I also want the most boot for my money that is the best tool for the job.

[@ЗакатРассвет-ы2ж]

call them smth else. real cowboys are gone

[@TylerSnyder305]

@@ЗакатРассвет-ы2ж We still have some real cowboys, but they use trucks more than horses, carry a 1911 instead of a single action wheel gun, and many have gone to AR's over lever guns. Plenty of 30-30 model 94 and savage lever guns out there as well.

[@TylerSnyder305]

@The Third Heaviest Uncle in Town What gave you that idea ?

[@PUNISHERMHS_2021]

@@ЗакатРассвет-ы2ж cowboys are still a thing

[@TylerSnyder305]

@The Third Heaviest Uncle in Town What stance, the one where they were focusing on handguns for the civilian market right now and just making rifles for military contracts? As far as I know it wasn't a political choice. Theres tons of AR manufacturers, but the snake series wheel guns are all colt.

[@dukenallow2673]

GREAT video. Thank you so much. PLEASE do a pair of Beck boots. I think that could be the really great, made in USA boot you thought you were cutting in half.

[@snowrs1]

Clicking pens in meetings is a huge pet peeve of mine, one of the best parts of zoom is everybody is on mute.

[@soggycracker5934]

Tactile Turn full sized pens use the Pilot G2 ink cartridges, which are available EVERYWHERE.

[@teofiloljubisavljevic7943]

Made in china tony lamas? Why did you take the worst possible tony lama for testing? I have never even seen a chinese tony lama in person. They usually make their boots in mexico.

[@beaurodriguez5640]

I have a pair of Cinch Boots that outside of having rubber on the bottom of the heal stack and a rubber insert in the forefoot to help with slipping are all natural. Wood pegs and everything. I got the for $150 new.

[@jacobbwalters8133]

I don’t find the Lucchese‘s disappointing. They might be trading on their heritage, but they don’t seem to be cutting corners. It would be one thing if they were selling a mostly synthetic boot, but honestly, these irritate me much less than the $500 Ariat boots. The Lucchese’s, despite being relatively similar to the other boots, were still the nicest pair that you cut apart. There are almost always diminishing returns at the top end of the market for any items.

[@JJ-zr6fu]

@@amanasd26 lol

[@konacopia]

The fact that he made no mention of the amount of pegging used in this high-end boot tells me he isn't familiar with what features make a quality handmade boot. The pig skin lining is not a big deal because it's soft and doesn't distort over time, especially when lined under such fine-quality leather. I'd like him to cut into other high-end cowboy boots like Tony Lama or JB Hill boots...he'll find his assessments similar to what he found with these Lucchese with the criteria he went by. He's a cobbler...he should do a better assessment.

[@Sowindiee10]

Try Hondos or Anderson Beans! They are traditionally constructed, and I think at least the Anderson Beans are handmade in Texas. Hondos are small but rapidly growing as far as I am aware.

[@dahak972]

I got a pair of custom Beck boots for $850. They were made from molds of my feet. I can’t see paying a grand for something that wasn’t completely custom.

[@SirenaSpades]

I once had a pair of shoes custom made and it was quite an experience. This was many years ago, I would say late 90's. If I remember right, around $200.

[@gnicewarner225]

great video, as always. I own 8 pair of cowboy boots. I used to buy mostly Justin when I was younger, have a couple pair over 30 yrs old now, also have a pair of Tecovas, and 1 pair of dress Lucchese gators. Mine are def thicker than the ones you just destroyed, maybe due to them being an exotic leather vs. a "cow" or animals of that herbivore nature.

[@EssenceofPureFlavor]

Obviously with companies like Red Wing, we know US production doesn't mean a boot has to cost $1000. Looks like it's all name to me.

[@orlog3343]

You’re paying for the name with Lucchese. All name, low quality. That’s the problem with most cowboy boots nowadays, unless you go bespoke but that’s thousands of dollars. The mid 500s with something like Chisos or Hondo seem to be the best value but they aren’t the prettiest boots out there…

[@thedude5449]

Red wing makes us boots? News to me.

[@orlog3343]

@@thedude5449 ? Red Wing only makes boots in USA

[@littlejackalo5326]

@@orlog3343 not all of them, but their upper range of boots are US made. Most are not US made, but the price is really low. The US made ones are around $250.

[@EssenceofPureFlavor]

@@thedude5449 All their heritage boots and a big chunk of their work boots. And then besides Red Wing, there's also companies like Danner, and even White's, Nicks, Wesco, not all super cheap, but definitely have options well under $1000, that are way better quality boots than Luchesse appears to be.

[@archaon6791]

Do Double H next! They have quite a few American made boots around the $200 price point.

[@jokly1264]

That's too bad how these turned out. I wonder if the quality went down over time like we see with many brands nowadays. Maybe vintage pairs had some outstanding qualities compared to others back in the day.

[@cb86258]

I think a problem is that I can’t think of a “luxury” dress boot competitor. I’m not a boot aficionado, but if you want to dress boot for special occasions, you aren’t putting on an Ariat or Tony Llama.

[@cb86258]

Specifically Cowboy style boots

[@CafeLibrado]

I don't understand why so many comments act like its a terrible boot. Its a much higher quality boot than the others, just maybe not three times as nice. still a great boot

[@PUNISHERMHS_2021]

They are great boots, but those are definitely dress boots.

[@scottcooksey5284]

I have several pair of Lucchese boots,,, I like them all. Some of mine are 20 years older or better. They're holding up well. Exotics as well as plain leathers. I'll probably buy a couple more pair. I also have and have had Ariat, Justin's, Dan Post,, Foley's, original Dingo, Red Wing and Frye. Of all of those the Frye boots were the toughest but the Lucchese are the nicest. Of all those brands the Ariat and Justin's we're the most comfortable straight out of the box.

[@andyhart5669]

I have no skin in the game as far as American made as I am from the UK. I have two pairs of Lucchese boots. The first are ostrich skin that were $1,000 back in 1992. The ostrich skin is very thun, but surprisingly durable. The lining leather is better quality than the outer leather on most boots I have seen. My other pair are Lucchese 2000. The budget range made in Mexico. As the name suggests they are from 2000 and cost about $300. Both boots have had a serious amout of wear and tear in the 30, and 22 years I have owned then, especially the cheaper pair. They are both still going strong. The notable thing beyond the durability of them is the comfort. They are full shaft boots (one cowboy, one roper) that are as comfortable as RM Williams or Grenson Chelsea boots. Are they worth the money? Yes until someone shows me something better and cheaper!

[@user-il9ze9py8c]

I have a pair of Lucchese's and several other brands including Tecovas and Ranch Road, and the Lucchese's are FAR more comfortable than any other boots I have worn. Not saying they don't have their shortcomings, but they are very light and fit perfectly. I have bought Nicks, JK's, Red Wings and nothing else I have worn has come close in terms of comfort. They are not work boots, but if I do need a beater boot I have Jim Greens.

[@robertcaldwell2994]

The picture you have for Jimmy Dean is of James Dean who died in his Porsche in 1955, so no boots needed for him in 1960 (unfortunately, but he probably did have a pair)

[@Brian-ff7tw]

Please do Nocona! Also american made in Nocona Texas... I love mine, but would love to hear your opinion and peak inside.

[@graysonmiller9624]

Can you get your hands on some White’s Plainsman or Drover cowboy boots? I know they’ve been discontinued but I’m sure with your connections you could find some! Olathe would be my next choice after Whites!

[@rickramirez4285]

You should try Rios from Mercedes TX or Anderson Bean also from Mercedes TX. I believe Mercedes is known as the capital of handmade boots. If you drive around that small town, they have these giant 6 to 8ft cowboy boots in every street corner painted to recognize Texas Universities.

[@mattbrown3801]

We would all like to see a boot video on Texas traditions one of the finest quality of cowboy boots made in Texas